Transcript [00:00] We are back in studio with the big [00:01] picture. I'm Rabbi Peswiki. I realized I [00:03] never introduced myself. I'm Rabbi Pesaf [00:05] Wiki and with me as always is Rabbi Rafi [00:07] Ice. How you doing? [00:08] >> I'm great. Great to see you. [00:09] >> I'm back from Canada. Now before we get [00:12] into the big headlines, I have to tell [00:13] you Canada was very interesting. Tell [00:16] you why. I I grew up in Canada. I don't [00:20] know how many of you know that I grew up [00:21] in Canada and I spent my high school and [00:26] college years in Toronto and that's [00:27] where I spent uh this past week. I was [00:30] there for almost a week. I arrived there [00:32] on Wednesday morning. I left Tuesday. [00:35] Longest visit I've made to Toronto since [00:37] I left there over 30 years ago. [00:42] And I I'd been back there many times for [00:45] a day, two days, never for such a long [00:48] time. On the one hand, I saw a lot of [00:49] old friends. Uh, and that was it was [00:52] wonderful. On the other hand, the [00:55] anti-Jewish [00:56] sentiment in the street, in public in [01:00] Toronto has gotten so bad that it was a [01:04] little shocking to me because this is a [01:05] city I know very well. And every [01:06] synagogue has a police car parked in [01:10] front of it. And security's ramped up. [01:14] The conversations I was having with [01:15] people non-stop were about the [01:19] realization that so many Canadian Jews [01:21] are coming to that there's no future for [01:23] their children in that country and what [01:26] the plan is going forward and that's the [01:28] conversation and it was just very it was [01:32] very chilling [01:34] uh because there's no there's nothing [01:37] over the horizon that points to a [01:38] reversal of the trend right [01:40] >> and uh so on the one hand it was a very [01:43] nice homecoming to see old friends. On [01:44] the other hand, it was a very in some [01:47] ways a dark experience. [01:49] >> Um I mean my my brother um moved to [01:52] Israel this past summer. He met Aliyah [01:54] this past summer because he saw that [01:57] Toronto he [01:59] >> Oh, he lived in Toronto. [02:00] >> He he lived in Thornhill. Uh his wife [02:02] grew up there. Um and he just saw that [02:06] it was turning basically into Palestine [02:09] and didn't see a future. If I ask my [02:11] brother, you know, if I would go back [02:13] five years, my brother did not speak [02:15] about making aliyah moving to Israel or [02:18] anything rel related to that. I mean, he [02:20] he felt close to Israel and supportive [02:22] of Israel would describe himself as a [02:24] Zionist, but that actual jump uh but the [02:28] over the last two years, the realization [02:31] that as you said, there's no reversal. [02:34] This is what the future of Toronto is. [02:37] um kind of like propelled them forward. [02:41] >> Yeah. And one last comment on my trip [02:42] before we get into the big headline, of [02:45] course we have to talk about the [02:46] midterms, we have to talk about some [02:47] developments in the Israeli election, [02:49] but one last comment on Canada, [02:52] uh that we had at the same time as there [02:56] was that cloud hanging over the trip, I [02:58] actually had a very inspiring [02:59] experience. We did a a Shabbat dinner at [03:03] the Bay at the largest synagogue. It's [03:05] really the largest synagogue in Canada. [03:07] Uh the largest synagogue in Toronto in [03:09] the the main synagogue in Thorn Hill [03:10] there. We did a Shabbat dinner. There [03:12] were about 160 people there. About 30 of [03:14] them were pastors [03:16] who came to Shabbat dinner at the [03:18] synagogue [03:20] >> with with members of the synagogue and [03:21] they were dispersed among the tables. So [03:23] every table had Christians and Jews at [03:24] it. And then we had a panel discussion [03:27] with with two of the Christian leaders [03:29] and myself and Rabbi Mark Fisherman from [03:31] Israel 365 who went with me and uh it [03:36] was a and it was very open dialogue [03:39] talking about the elephants in the room [03:41] and what we're really doing there is [03:42] we're building we're starting to build a [03:45] sense of community of Jewish Christian [03:46] relations uh at the leadership level at [03:49] the communal level in Toronto and I [03:51] think it's something that that the [03:52] Jewish community needs to know that they [03:53] do have friends in the area, but the [03:55] Christian community is also under siege, [03:57] >> right? [03:57] >> Uh, you know, by the, you know, by the [03:59] left [04:00] >> by the woke left progressive government [04:02] of Canada. Uh, so there was a lot of [04:04] positive that came out of the trip. All [04:06] right. The big headline, of course, is [04:08] the midterm elections and the absolute [04:11] bath that uh that Trump took. It was [04:16] beyond what anyone uh what anyone was [04:18] expecting. [04:20] Uh, but what I want to focus on is what [04:22] everyone's talking about this morning, [04:24] which is a lengthy post on X that Vice [04:28] President JD Vance put out talking about [04:30] why this happened. Uh and of course most [04:33] of the pro-Israel community is up in [04:35] arms over this uh over this tweet, this [04:37] post because [04:40] when you get down to the punchline of [04:42] it, uh JD Vance uh [04:45] blames well or blames or he puts he puts [04:48] a heavy amount of the blame on the war [04:50] with Iran and specifically the Israel [04:53] relationship. U I'm going to read you [04:55] one passage in the it's a very long [04:56] post. I'm not going to read the whole [04:57] thing. He says, "Another pollster, one [04:59] of the smartest people I know in [05:00] politics, told me yesterday we'd lose [05:02] the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt [05:04] negative going into Tuesday, but even I [05:07] was shocked by this. In his polling, he [05:08] saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were [05:11] angry and planning to vote for [05:13] Democrats." He asked those voters who [05:15] had abandoned us what could what would [05:17] cause them to come back on our team. [05:20] the top four answers accounting for [05:22] nearly all of the responses [05:25] which means there weren't even five or [05:27] six answers [05:29] u in any in any real numbers were number [05:33] one end the war number two focus on cost [05:36] of living/inflation [05:38] number three put America first and [05:40] number four change our relationship to [05:43] Israel [05:46] and then he writes [05:48] and this is and this relevant to my [05:50] comment on this. So, I'm gonna I'm gonna [05:52] talk a little bit, Rafie. Sorry. Go for [05:54] it. [05:54] >> And then, you know, so before you rob [05:55] the train, let me just [laughter] [05:58] >> our voters showed up. This is what Vance [06:00] writes. And above and the above four [06:03] reasons are why many of them voted for [06:04] Democrats. This is according to a [06:06] pollster who nailed the results. While [06:09] many spent Monday attacking Rachel [06:11] Campos Duffy for calling for a [06:13] diplomatic resolution to the conflict, [06:15] it turns out her political advice was [06:18] sound. [06:19] she's also a great person. Okay, that's [06:21] what he writes. [06:25] So, here's my take on this. It is [06:28] absolutely okay. First of all, this this [06:30] post by Vance is very very smart [06:32] politics. If we go all the way back to [06:35] the beginning of the war, we will [06:36] remember that from the from the day one [06:40] of the war, [06:41] even the weeks leading up to the war, [06:44] but certainly from day one of the war [06:46] through until the ceasefire on April [06:49] 8th, [06:51] JD Vance was nowhere to be seen. He was [06:54] staying out of it. He was clearly [06:56] distancing himself from the decision to [06:58] go to war. [07:00] Um, and I said at the time, many people [07:03] said at the time that he was doing this [07:05] so that he would not be identified with [07:08] it. If it goes badly, everyone will know [07:11] that it wasn't his war. And then when it [07:15] came uh to the negotiations for theou [07:17] the ceasefire negotiations which I'll [07:20] remind you at the beginning when the war [07:21] was stopped on April 8th it [snorts] was [07:24] stated at the time that this was for two [07:26] weeks because the Pakistanis said that [07:28] they could have a deal within two weeks [07:30] to get the straits of Hormuz opened and [07:31] resolve this thing. Of course that [07:33] didn't happen. And they ended up with [07:34] this memorandum of understanding which [07:36] was one of the one of the worst pieces [07:41] of diplomatic like one of the worst [07:42] diplomatic agreements I've ever seen. [07:44] And I read a lot of these things. It was [07:46] horrible. Everyone knew it was horrible. [07:48] It was criticized roundly by anyone who [07:51] knows anything about the Middle East. Of [07:52] course, it fell apart in about 10 [07:54] minutes. And u but that was Vance's that [07:58] was where Vance re-entered the picture. [08:01] and [08:03] and then we've had what we've had this [08:05] this prolonged [08:08] uh you know situation. [08:10] Now, [08:12] it's absolutely true that this war [08:16] caused [08:18] is one of the prime drivers, maybe the [08:19] main driver because of what it caused [08:21] with inflation and everything else, but [08:22] that the war I mean everything that [08:24] Vance says in his assessment. I don't [08:26] think that this is incorrect. And I [08:30] think that the that those in the [08:31] pro-Israel community who are slamming JD [08:34] Vance for blaming the Jews and jumping [08:36] all over it and saying there's other [08:38] reasons are missing the point here. I [08:41] think he's absolutely right that this [08:43] war uh led to this bloodbath. [08:47] However, [08:49] and this is why I read that next [08:51] paragraph when he says here, "While many [08:54] spent Monday attacking Rachel Campo's [08:57] Duffy for calling for a diplomatic [08:59] resolution to the conflict, it turns out [09:01] her political advice was sound. [09:04] This is [09:07] dead wrong." [09:09] You see, [09:12] if you want to blame Israel, you want to [09:15] blame Prime Minister Netanyahu for [09:17] convincing President Trump to go to war [09:18] in Iran, I'm not going to quibble with [09:20] you. Never mind the fact. I mean, we [09:23] could quibble the fact that President [09:24] Trump since the 1980s [09:27] has been more focused on dealing with [09:30] the with the Iranian threat than any [09:32] other person in American public life. [09:36] people who think that the only reason [09:38] he's anti-Iran or wants to get rid of [09:39] Iran's nuclear program is because of [09:40] Netanyahu have not been paying attention [09:42] to his entire life and public his entire [09:44] public life when he the day he announced [09:47] he was running for president that was [09:48] what he talked about. I mean he's [09:50] obviously had Iran on his mind for a [09:52] long time. So that [09:55] but even if you want to say that this [09:57] was Israel's war [09:59] and that Israel pressured Trump into it. [10:04] This war was not fought the way Israel [10:06] wanted it fought [10:10] in the the five weeks or so the five [10:13] plus weeks of fighting from February [10:15] 28th until the war was stopped. It was 5 [10:17] and a half weeks of fighting of bombing. [10:23] About 2 weeks into that, the Iranians [10:25] closest to Hormuz, the Americans shifted [10:27] their attention to there. The Americans [10:29] and Israelis were both hitting initially [10:32] all the ballistic missile launch sites [10:34] and other military military targets that [10:38] would neutralize taking out the navy. [10:41] The Americans focused a lot on that. [10:44] Israel almost immediately was focused on [10:46] decapitation of leadership. They were [10:48] assassinating leaders. It was going on [10:50] for weeks. It wasn't just day one. We [10:51] all have in our memory that they took [10:53] out Kamayi on day one. But we remember [10:55] that it kept going for weeks. Larijani [10:58] who was who was the top guy until he was [11:00] dead was killed I think three weeks into [11:02] the war. Okay. The Israelis were taking [11:04] out their leadership and the Israelis in [11:06] the final two weeks [11:09] started hitting IRGC targets. They were [11:12] hitting besieged checkpoints. That's the [11:14] stormtroopers who terrorized the people. [11:16] They were hitting their checkpoints. [11:17] They were with drones. They were causing [11:20] defections in the IRGC. They were going [11:23] after the actual people who suppress the [11:26] population. [11:28] I'll also remind us all that as much as [11:33] a few weeks into it, everyone in the US [11:36] administration suddenly were saying that [11:38] they're not interested in changing the [11:39] regime and especially Trump started [11:41] negotiating with them and talking about [11:43] getting a deal with the regime which is [11:45] still in power. On day one of the war, [11:48] when Trump stood in front of the mics [11:50] and announced this war and gave an [11:53] eight-minute speech, the last two [11:55] minutes of that speech are devoted to [11:57] regime change. [11:59] I think this is an exact quote where he [12:01] said to the Iranian people, I say the [12:03] hour of your freedom is at hand. We're [12:06] going to create the conditions for you [12:07] to take back your country and it's going [12:09] to happen sooner than you think. [12:12] He said that in that speech. Now, he [12:13] didn't state it as a military objective. [12:16] He stated four military objectives. That [12:17] wasn't one of them. But after he stated [12:19] those objectives, he then talked about [12:20] regime change. [12:24] And for good measure, just to finish [12:26] framing my point before I really get to [12:28] the punchline, [12:32] the Iranians have been threatening [12:33] everybody recently. Just in the last [12:37] week, they've been threatening the [12:38] Europeans. They've been threatening all [12:41] of the Gulf states that house American [12:42] bases. They've been threatening the [12:43] Americans directly. They still have not [12:45] issued a a threat to the Israelis. [12:49] They haven't threatened the Israelis. [12:50] Think about that. They're issuing all [12:52] kinds of trashtalking threats to [12:53] everybody. They have not threatened the [12:55] Israelis. They threatened AI companies [12:57] that work with Israel. They put out a a [13:00] piece the other day. I made a video [13:01] about it. It was a very strange article. [13:02] It was like basically a press release [13:04] from the IRGC warning AI companies that [13:06] are collaborating with Israel that [13:08] they're going to get retaliated against. [13:11] They warned Elon Musk for Starlink. They [13:13] they put out an article the other day. [13:15] They put out a statement warning him. [13:19] They're not issuing any warnings to [13:21] Israel. They're terrified of the [13:22] Israelis. Since April 8th, they've [13:24] bombed everybody. They haven't bombed [13:26] they sent one missile to the Israelis [13:28] and they regretted it immediately and [13:29] they stopped. [13:32] They're terrified of the Israelis. Why? [13:35] Because the Israelis actually have a [13:37] plan to bring down the regime and were [13:39] implementing it. [13:41] when this war stopped. [13:46] What we have said since the very [13:48] beginning, what I have sensed since the [13:50] very beginning, and if you watch my [13:51] channel, Pesiki on YouTube, shameless [13:54] plug, make sure you're following that [13:55] channel as well. [13:58] I've been saying this since the [13:59] beginning, [14:01] and it's not wararmongering. The only [14:03] way to deal with the Iranian threat is [14:05] to bring down the regime. It's the only [14:07] way to deal with it. the Trump laid out [14:09] four mil four four objectives. Get rid [14:11] of the ballistic missile program. Get [14:12] rid of the nuclear program. Um destroy [14:16] their navy and destroy their ability to [14:18] fund their proxies. Hormuz was added [14:21] afterwards when when that was closed. [14:24] Okay. But on day one of the war, he laid [14:25] out those four objectives. And I think I [14:27] said on day one of the war, the only way [14:29] to achieve those four objectives is to [14:30] bring down the regime. [14:33] So even if your goal isn't bringing down [14:34] the regime, if your goal is to [14:35] accomplish those four things, the only [14:37] way to do it is to bring down the [14:38] regime. [14:39] And Trump himself, as I said, was [14:41] talking about regime change on day one. [14:44] At some point, he bought what the [14:46] Pakistanis and the Qataris were selling [14:47] him [14:50] and decided to go to diplomacy and start [14:53] negotiating with the people in power [14:54] there. And I said this, I said this [14:58] before the war started. I remember [14:59] saying it on TV. I think I said it on [15:02] Fox News [15:04] that the goal of the Iranians is to drag [15:07] things out. That is always their goal. [15:08] Kick the can down the road. Kick the can [15:10] down the road. Kick the can down the [15:11] road. That is always their goal. They're [15:13] great at it. And that if they can do [15:16] that and they can keep the price of oil [15:18] high and they can kick the can down the [15:19] road and get closer and closer to the [15:21] midterms, they know they're going to [15:22] win. [15:25] So it's Israel's fault that against [15:28] Israel's wishes [15:31] Donald Trump decided to capitulate to [15:34] people like JD Vance around him and the [15:38] Pakistanis and the Qataris [15:41] and halt the war and stop short of his [15:43] objectives [15:45] so that it would drag on and keep oil [15:47] prices up which was the objective of the [15:49] Iranians. This outcome is exactly what [15:52] they were gunning for. It's exactly [15:53] their playbook worked perfectly. They [15:56] knew from the outset. [15:59] You know what? I'm going to do this. [16:02] I'm going to pull up something that I [16:04] wrote [16:06] 10 days before the war the war was [16:08] launched. 10 days before the war was [16:10] launched. Here [16:13] I wrote a column in the Jerusalem Post [16:16] 10 days before it was launched that said [16:18] Iran isn't trying to win the war with [16:20] the US. It's trying to survive Trump. [16:23] That was the article I wrote because at [16:24] the time the Americans had this massive [16:26] military buildup. Remember in the weeks [16:28] leading up to the war it was LIKE WOW [16:29] MORE BUILDUP than decades for you know [16:32] look at all these. And Steve Witco said [16:36] in an interview on Fox News around that [16:38] time that President Trump was confused [16:41] how come the Iranians aren't [16:42] capitulating with but but by seeing this [16:44] military buildup. So I wrote an op-ed [16:46] about this and I said the following [16:50] because it looked like foolish of them. [16:52] Are they are they in they know that they [16:55] cannot defeat the Americans militarily. [16:57] They knew that from the beginning. Here [16:59] we are. [17:05] >> Trump has shown he's willing to use [17:06] force quickly and decisively. The [17:08] strikes on the Iranian nuclear [17:10] facilities and the 12-day war and the [17:11] campaign against the Houthis [17:13] demonstrated that clearly. But he has [17:14] also shown that he has no appetite for a [17:16] prolonged war and certainly not for [17:18] American casualties. And that's why [17:20] Tehran is threatening exactly those [17:22] outcomes. Iran's calculation is brutally [17:24] simple. If it can prolong a conflict, [17:28] widen it regionally, [17:31] political pressure inside the United [17:32] States will spike. [17:38] >> They wanted they this is exactly the [17:40] outcome that they were gunning for. And [17:42] they did it. They won. They Trump did [17:46] not listen to the Israelis who wanted to [17:49] continue. [17:51] So while JD Vance is absolutely correct [17:54] that the war caused this and it could [17:57] very well be that Israel was of course [18:00] Israel was lobbying for this war. That's [18:02] also correct. Let's not let's not back [18:04] away from that at all. Of course, this [18:06] Israel is in best in the of course this [18:08] war was in Israel's best interests, [18:12] but to blame Israel for the way it's [18:16] gone. This isn't the playbook Israel [18:18] wanted. This was against Israel's will. [18:22] So, I I hear what JD Vance is doing. [18:24] Very smart politics, by the way, in [18:26] terms of where things are going. In [18:28] fact, now that it's after the midterms, [18:29] he can even distance himself from Trump, [18:32] which he kind of does with this tweet. [18:35] He doesn't call out the president, but [18:37] of course the president's the [18:38] commander-in-chief. He's made these [18:39] decisions. And Don Jr. retweeted this [18:43] post by uh JD Vance approvingly said [18:45] 100% correct. [18:48] So this very smart politics by JD Vance, [18:50] very smart tweet, not entirely incorrect [18:53] that the war caused this, but at the [18:56] same time, let's bear in mind if this [18:59] war had been fought the way the Israelis [19:01] wanted it to, we wouldn't be in this [19:03] situation. your thoughts [19:06] >> and and thank you for listening to me. [19:08] [laughter] [19:08] >> I think first of all I think the most [19:10] important part of the tweet is what's [19:12] not there. The tariffs are not [19:15] mentioned. When does President Trump's [19:18] approval rating start going down? It's [19:21] the imposition of tariffs and [19:25] at the beginning of the Iran war, his [19:27] approval rating goes up because you know [19:29] it's patriotic to support your nation at [19:31] war. But then as the gas prices start to [19:34] rise, then his frivoling continues to [19:37] slip. But the cost of living issues are [19:39] a combination of the tariffs and the and [19:44] gas prices going up because of the war. [19:46] Now I I I want to just drill down into [19:50] gas prices slightly. when you have [19:52] tariffs on specific items, so those [19:55] items go up. But when gas goes up [19:59] because everything goes up because [20:01] everything is being shipped using gas, [20:04] therefore the price of everything goes [20:06] up. Okay. Now, [20:08] the fact that JD doesn't mention that [20:11] highlights that this is more propaganda [20:14] than truth. And what I mean by that is [20:18] as follows. [20:20] America has very serious issues that it [20:25] needs to deal with. Its industrial base [20:30] does not exist. The factories are [20:33] closed. They were shipped overseas to [20:36] slave laborers in China and Vietnam. [20:39] It has an insane level of national debt. [20:44] And the problem is, and here's the [20:46] fundamental problem. The fundamental [20:49] problem is that in a democracy, [20:52] especially when there are major [20:53] elections every two years, you win by, [20:57] we'll call it bread and circus by [21:00] appeasing the people, [21:02] >> band-aids, short-term solutions. [21:04] >> So, the solution to national debt is not [21:09] solving the problem of national debt. [21:10] The solution to a lack of industrial [21:12] base is not to do anything about it. [21:16] Because in order to rebuild the [21:17] industrial base, you have to make it so [21:20] that the slave laborers in China [21:25] are not able to sell in the United [21:27] States. Or if they are able to sell in [21:28] the United States, it's only at a level [21:30] that's competitive with the American [21:32] factories because of course American [21:35] factories are going to cost more. Their [21:38] products are going to cost more than the [21:39] Chinese slave factories because Chinese [21:41] slave factories don't pay anything. [21:44] America has all these rules. safety [21:46] rules, minimum wage rules, right? How [21:49] much time you can work during the day. [21:50] China doesn't have any of that. A [21:52] Chinese factory can go 24 hours a day, [21:55] seven days a week, pay them pennies, [21:57] develop thousand products, ship them to [22:00] United States, and you and I or people [22:04] living in New York, New Jersey or Ohio [22:06] or California get cheap goods. Do you [22:08] know that Walmart on its own is I think [22:13] China's fifth largest trading partner. [22:15] Meaning if Walmart was a country. [22:17] >> Wow. [22:18] >> It's in the top 10 for sure. It's it's [22:21] way up there. It's like in the top five. [22:23] >> So if Right. I mean but that's a [22:25] problem. [22:26] >> Yeah. Americans ex expect cheap goods [22:29] and the only way to rebuild the [22:32] industrial base is to rebuild factories [22:35] and begin to accept that goods will be [22:38] more expensive. And the consequence and [22:40] and it's so important to not get caught [22:43] up in the short-term thinking because [22:45] here's what happens. [22:49] There's what's called flyover country [22:51] between the coasts where people are [22:54] really suffering. The only way to [22:56] rebuild factories is to figure out a way [22:59] to make sure that the Chinese products [23:02] can't compete. National debt. But let me [23:04] say it a little differently. If I had a [23:07] diet of ice cream and potato chips, I [23:10] would really, really enjoy myself. Every [23:13] meal I ate would be delicious, [23:15] fantastic. The problem is that if I did [23:17] that over the course of years or [23:19] decades, I would be morbidly obese and [23:23] I'd have like my arteries would be [23:25] clogged and my doctor would say, "Okay, [23:27] look, you're either going to die young [23:30] or you need to go on a serious diet." [23:32] And that is the place where America is [23:34] right now. [23:36] America needs to solve its national debt [23:39] problem. It needs to solve its [23:41] industrial base problem. It needs to [23:43] figure out a way to rebuild [23:47] its national attachment and that [23:49] requires sacrifice for the future. And [23:53] if Americans aren't willing to sacrifice [23:56] for the future, then what they're saying [23:58] is yes, I know I'm 500 lb, but like [24:02] yolo, so why should I why should I [24:06] suffer? And that's a choice that America [24:07] has to make. [24:09] I'm not even talking about Iran. [24:12] Like that's a choice America has to make [24:13] on a whole host of issues. And the fact [24:16] that JD doesn't address that is I think [24:19] the biggest problem. Now let's talk [24:21] about Iran for a second because I I I I [24:24] heard uh one of these political [24:26] commentators say that if you had the [24:28] choice between a nuclear Iran and [24:30] communism, [24:31] he would choose a nuclear Iran. Well, [24:34] the answer is is that by choosing a [24:37] nuclear Iran, you get both because of [24:39] the red green alliance. Hold on. So [24:41] wait, wait a second. Whenever people set [24:43] up binaries like that for the for [24:45] rhetorical points, you have to often ask [24:47] yourself, is the binary itself valid? [24:51] >> It's not valid. That's not the choice. [24:53] >> Correct. [24:53] >> We don't have to choose between [24:54] communism and a nuclear Iran. [24:56] >> So when someone says something like [24:58] that, it's, you know, it's that itself [25:01] is propaganda [25:02] >> for for sure. But a nuclear Iran [25:05] threatens everybody. And if Americans [25:08] think that they're going to be exempt [25:10] from nuclear Iran, that somehow Iran is [25:12] not going to threaten them, then they [25:14] don't know what is actually going on, [25:16] they're just simply putting their head [25:18] in the sand and calling it MAGA. That's [25:21] not how the world works. You can't be [25:24] isolationist, right? There is a reason [25:27] why the Secretary of State, the position [25:29] of the Secretary of State is in the [25:32] American Constitution because America [25:34] was never meant to be an isolationist [25:37] country. [25:38] >> Well, well, let's go even further. Even [25:39] if you want to go back to, you know, you [25:42] have Americans today who have a shallow [25:47] Monroe Doctrine viewpoint. when I say [25:49] shallow Monroe doctrine viewpoint [25:52] because they think that well forget it [25:56] we don't need to be anywhere let's close [25:57] up we don't what are we sending people [25:59] overseas what are we sending money [26:00] overseas for let's just protect our [26:02] borders and make you know what and [26:04] you're going to surrender the you're [26:06] going to surrender the entire globe to [26:07] the Russians and the Chinese that's [26:09] going to I mean that the world is so [26:11] much more interconnected today I'm [26:13] saying even even if right [26:16] >> even even going back to the constitution [26:17] when Monroe said what he said it was a [26:19] different world. The world is so [26:21] interconnected today that I'm sorry you [26:24] you have to be you have to be a presence [26:27] in the world, [26:28] >> right? That doesn't mean you need to be [26:29] a globalist and doesn't mean you need [26:31] army bases like throughout the entire [26:33] world, right? There is something very [26:36] important to bringing your troops home [26:38] but relying more on your allies. And if [26:41] you read um [26:42] >> the national security strategy, [26:44] >> the national security strategy, but [26:45] Bridge KBY, who I believe is one of the [26:48] authors of National Security Strategy, [26:49] Bridge Colby before he was in the [26:52] administration, right after October 7th, [26:54] wrote an op-ed in the Times of Israel, [26:57] like a blog in the Times of Israel, [26:59] right? He was uh I forget the name of [27:01] his the company he was he was running [27:03] then. Um but he talked exactly about [27:07] this that America is not going to [27:11] support militarily Israel as much and [27:14] the opportunity for Israel is that [27:16] Israel has more independence because [27:18] America needs to focus on China. What [27:20] bridge Colby is not saying is that [27:22] America needs to become isolationist. [27:24] What he's saying is America's primary [27:27] enemy is China and America needs to [27:31] focus on China. He's written a book [27:32] about this. He He's a person who has [27:34] like a clear sense of world. [27:36] >> Yeah. Here's the post. July 4th, 2023. [27:39] The threat of a USChina war requires a [27:41] USIsrael reset, [27:43] >> right? [27:43] >> Yeah. [27:44] >> And and it's it's it's it's a brilliant [27:47] read. And so what what needs to happen [27:49] is Americans need to grow up and they [27:52] need to say something along the lines of [27:56] I am going to sacrifice [27:59] part of my present for my children's [28:02] better future right you know like [28:05] >> so what does that look like in your mind [28:07] like [28:08] >> sure um does America need to be involved [28:11] in the war war in Iran I don't think so [28:14] but it does need to allow Israel to do [28:16] whatever Israel is going needs to do, [28:18] but Americans should accept higher [28:21] prices because [28:24] rebuilding their industrial base, [28:26] meaning so that people in Akran, Ohio [28:29] can have factories to work in or [28:31] anything to work in, right? It requires [28:34] that they're not competing with slave [28:37] laborers from China. It is impossible to [28:39] economically compete with slave laborers [28:41] from China. And you know, you go back to [28:45] the the early part of the the American [28:48] uh to the American founding and tariffs [28:51] are like an important part of America's [28:54] trade strategy. Not because they were [28:57] like merkantale or protectionist, but [28:59] because they understood that having a [29:02] productive industrial base is the engine [29:05] that runs the country. And what's [29:07] happened is over the last, I don't know, [29:08] 60 or 70 years, we've diluted ourselves [29:12] into thinking, but it really started [29:14] with with NAFTA under Clinton. We've [29:16] diluted ourselves into thinking that all [29:19] you need to do is like buy stuff. We [29:22] became a consumerist economy. A [29:24] consumerist economy is a short-term [29:28] gain, long-term losing economy because [29:31] the people just become fat and decadent. [29:35] What is really needed is a productive e [29:38] economy. And in order to have a [29:39] productive economy, you have to be able [29:41] to say NAFTA was a mistake. Outsourcing [29:45] industry to China was a mistake. And [29:48] even if Trump had never entered this [29:51] war, the tariffs would have led to the [29:54] same bloodbath. [29:56] The war was a cherry on top. It it was [29:59] an enhancing factor. Maybe you want to [30:01] call it the steroids. But the real issue [30:04] is that America has some serious [30:06] problems and maybe it was a mistake for [30:08] Trump to try and tackle both at the same [30:10] time. [30:12] But there's also a certain urgency. [30:15] Yeah, I hear you. You know, so [30:19] this is this is a fantastic point and I [30:21] wasn't you know there are certainly [30:23] other reasons why Americans are unhappy [30:26] right now and that's what a lot of the [30:27] comments on JD Vance's post are bringing [30:29] up. [30:32] My point is that even if I concede his [30:35] point that it's the war in Iran, [30:39] the problem with the war in Iran [30:44] is not the war. When he says [30:48] in the same breath [30:51] >> that moving to a diplomatic solution [30:53] would have been the right move. [30:55] >> It's idiotic. That's that what my argu [30:57] what I'm saying is moving to a [31:00] diplomatic solution is the original sin [31:03] correct [31:03] >> in the handling of this war. That's [31:05] where things went off the rails and [31:08] that's where you ended up with the [31:09] outcome that we have today because you [31:11] tried a diplomatic solution. Diplomacy [31:14] does not work with evil regimes. It [31:15] didn't work under, you know, with [31:16] Chamberlain and Hitler and it doesn't [31:18] work now. It's never worked. It does not [31:21] work. That's my point. So, Israel is now [31:24] taking a beating, a serious beating. [31:28] This this post by JD Vance is not a [31:30] small thing. [31:32] It's a very strong narrative framing [31:36] that is being put on this midterm right [31:38] now because of how much it's being [31:41] talked about because of where it came [31:42] from. Trump is not pushing back on it. [31:44] >> That is not true. [31:45] >> He did. So, what did he say? [31:46] >> Someone asked him about JD's post and he [31:48] said the war in Iran was the right thing [31:50] to do. you cannot have a nuclear Iran. [31:52] Okay? And he made it sound like he's [31:54] going to continue the war. It it I Trump [31:57] is full throttle pro this war. Listen, I [32:01] I hope that's true because my [32:03] inclination today [32:06] is a very strong fear that he's going to [32:08] look for an off-ramp. [32:10] >> Why? [32:10] >> I don't know. [32:11] >> For what reason? [32:13] >> I guess bec because of how unpopular it [32:15] is. But I guess he has nothing to lose [32:16] at this point. What does he have to lose [32:17] if he doesn't if if JD decides that that [32:19] he's going to betray Trump even with Don [32:22] Jr. like supporting Vance, right? Trump [32:26] has not one other option but two other [32:29] options, right? Everyone's was like, [32:31] "Oh, maybe Rubio's going to run." But [32:33] Rubio has been quiet this entire time. [32:35] >> Oh, there's other people. There's other [32:36] people. [32:37] >> You know who like really stepped up? [32:39] >> Ronda Santis. All of a sudden, Ronda [32:41] Santis, who's going to be out of a job [32:42] pretty soon because of term limits in [32:44] Florida, [32:46] he starts publicly commenting and he's [32:50] positioning himself to run. He is going [32:53] to run. And if people when people betray [32:56] Trump, Trump doesn't feel any loyalty to [32:59] them. And at some point, Trump's going [33:01] to decide either whether it's worth [33:03] endorsing somebody depending on his own [33:04] popularity and who he's going to [33:06] endorse. So Trump knows that he has [33:08] options. He knows how to bite his time. [33:11] Anybody who's read his book knows that [33:13] he gives off this impression of being [33:15] crazy and impetuous. But in the book, [33:18] the importance of discipline, [33:20] >> right? [33:21] >> He's disciplined. [33:22] >> The man doesn't drink alcohol, right? [33:25] Okay. So, we we should we should [33:27] understand that he has options and [33:29] things are going to change over the [33:31] course of the next two years. [33:33] All right. Let's shift our attention to [33:36] the Israeli election. So, I left on [33:38] election day. I left to Canada on [33:40] election day before the votes were even [33:42] counted [33:44] and so I've been away and I just got [33:46] back yesterday. [33:48] Um, [33:50] and it's been kind of a lot of turmoil [33:53] going on around this election. So, could [33:54] you first of all, I've been at a [33:56] distance. I've been watching the news a [33:57] little bit. I was busy in Canada. Fill [33:59] us in on what we know about these [34:02] election results and where things stand. [34:03] >> Okay. [34:05] the the main thing to know about the [34:07] election is that there wasn't that much [34:10] change between the sides. Now, you'll [34:12] say, "Yeah, but if you look at the the [34:14] numbers, there was significant change in [34:15] the numbers." So, then you need to kind [34:17] of like drill down into some of the [34:19] details. In the previous election, there [34:22] were two left-wing parties that did not [34:24] make it into the Knesset, meaning they [34:26] took left-wing votes and were just below [34:28] the threshold. the Balad Muslim party [34:32] and the merits very left-wing communist [34:35] party. Both of those parties merged with [34:39] other parties. So Labor and Merits [34:41] merged to become the Democrats under [34:43] Golan and the Balad party rejoined the [34:47] joint Arab list and therefore all those [34:49] votes were now counted [34:51] um for the for the for the left. that [34:55] gets enhanced by the fact that the left [35:00] that that the Arabs had incredibly high [35:03] turnout for the Arabs. It was on par [35:05] with the rest of Israel, but they had [35:08] 80% turnout, but the rest of Israel also [35:10] had 80% turnout. Okay? But they there [35:14] since everything's based on percentages, [35:15] they got a higher number of seats based [35:17] on the percentage. And on the right hand [35:20] side [35:22] you had two parties. one right-wing [35:24] party by Ofair Winter Venter um and also [35:29] the uh reser party [35:31] >> which was basically a right-wing party [35:33] >> which is basically right a center-right [35:35] party uh former liquid officials but [35:37] some others that took and that was about [35:40] a total of combining those parties that [35:42] was a total of five seats about and [35:45] [clears throat] excuse me those since [35:47] those those two parties didn't pass the [35:49] threshold [35:52] [clears throat] [35:52] Sorry. Since those two parties didn't [35:55] pass the thresholds, those votes were [35:58] lost. Okay? So, had they been added [36:00] doesn't mean the rate would have gotten [36:01] five more seats, but it would have [36:02] gotten three more seats, four more [36:04] seats, something along those lines. [36:05] Okay? Because everything gets rejusted [36:08] based on percentages and who's, you [36:09] know, and and each seat gets worth a [36:11] certain number of people. So, the the [36:14] switch between the sides um did didn't [36:16] change that much. The second thing to [36:19] know about the election is that this was [36:23] the left's best effort. And the left's [36:28] be best effort still came short of the [36:33] rights, you know, kind of best effort, [36:36] but not even still fell short of the [36:38] right. And that is incredibly [36:40] demoralizing for them. [36:42] There were over 60,000 people who flew [36:44] in to vote in the election. Mostly [36:46] people who are leftwing like Galadot, [36:49] you know, um took a video, took a selfie [36:52] of herself voting in the uh in in in the [36:55] election and saying she was voting [36:57] voting for the change block. Okay. The [36:58] Arabs are not part of the change block. [37:00] They are a kind of a separate entity, [37:03] but the change block did not reach 50 [37:06] seats, whereas BB and the right-wing [37:08] block did reach 50 seats. And let me [37:10] also add in uh just to underscore your [37:14] point. The LI could had 32 [37:17] seats in the previous Knessa. They have [37:19] 27 now. They actually got more votes in [37:22] this election. [37:23] >> Right. Exactly. [37:24] >> The Lud got more votes in this election [37:27] than last time and they have less seats. [37:28] Just to underscore your point. [37:30] >> Correct. [37:30] >> By the way, before we go on, I I always [37:32] forget to do this. Let me do this right [37:33] now. Um something very important. Across [37:36] Israel, Jewish families are working [37:38] every day to build their lives, raise [37:39] their children, and strengthen their [37:41] communities in their ancestral homeland. [37:43] But they can't do it alone. There are [37:45] those out in the cold on alert day and [37:48] night patrolling the area to keep them [37:51] safe. That's why Israel 365 charity is [37:53] raising funds to support the warm corner [37:57] or pinama in Hebrew, a vital community [38:00] initiative providing comfort, essential [38:03] supplies, and a place of support for [38:06] those uh those security officials, those [38:09] who are helping keep Jewish families [38:11] safe. They don't serve in the army. [38:12] They're serving in these security units [38:13] that are protecting Jewish communities. [38:16] and we're setting up these areas where [38:17] they can stop in, get a cup of coffee, [38:20] uh, keep themselves supplied and and [38:23] well rested. Click the link in the [38:25] description to donate to [38:26] israel365.com/wararmth [38:29] uh, and help us ensure that the Jewish [38:32] families in Israel can continue to live [38:34] safely and proudly in their homeland. [38:37] >> Okay. [38:37] >> All right. The third thing to know about [38:39] the Sorry, one last thing to add to that [38:41] point. The religious Zionist parties [38:42] meaning the religious Zionist party plus [38:44] Hudit under Benvir basically got the [38:46] same number of seats. I think it was [38:48] minus one. The right did very well as [38:52] well. Now the third thing to know about [38:53] this election [38:55] is that [38:58] there was definitely there were [38:59] definitely some shenanigans [39:01] amongst the Arabs voting. What do I mean [39:04] by that? And and I want to be um precise [39:08] in what I say. There is significant [39:11] evidence that Arabs were incentivized to [39:15] show up to vote by receiving [39:20] um gasoline gift cards to various [39:23] gasoline stations here in Israel. Okay. [39:27] That there is evidence for. How much did [39:30] it incentivize people to get off their [39:32] couches? [39:32] >> Doesn't matter. It's illegal. It's [39:34] illegal. [39:34] >> It's not a matter of that. Yes, it's [39:37] illegal. The question is, can this be [39:39] called an illegitimate vote? So, and [39:42] that's part of the discussion that's [39:43] going on now. Um, and here's where I [39:45] want to be precise. There are two open [39:48] questions that still need to need an [39:51] investigation and need to be resolved, [39:52] and I'll get to that investigation [39:53] momentarily. [39:55] The first is that it's not clear how [39:58] much this incentivization actually got [40:00] people off their couches versus like, [40:02] oh, people were planning on showing up [40:04] anyway and therefore just got a gift [40:06] card. That's number one. The second [40:09] question also not resolved is was this [40:13] funding from the outside either the [40:15] Palestinian Authority or Qatar or was it [40:18] an internal [40:21] um way of getting out the votes right [40:23] there? You know, for instance, Chicago [40:25] is uh long known for incentivizing [40:28] people to vote. Oh, you need a new [40:29] garbage can. Great. We'll get you new [40:31] garbage can. You need this. Those kind [40:33] of shenanigans happen all over the [40:36] place. And we don't call [snorts] them [40:38] fraudulent elections. We don't say that [40:40] it's a stolen, we don't say it's a [40:42] stolen vote. We should recognize that [40:44] the Arabs in Israel voted at the same [40:47] rate as the Israelis, as the Jews in [40:50] Israel did. Um but now there's an [40:53] investigation going on and here there [40:54] seems to be a significant fight between [40:57] Zeni who is the head of um the Shabbach [41:01] between uh you know kind of like the [41:03] Israel Israel's FBI the internal [41:05] services and the attorney general um as [41:09] to how much of an invest like a a [41:13] radical leftwinger and viewed herself [41:14] and throughout BB's tenure was doing [41:17] everything she could to thwart his [41:19] ability to do anything basically. [41:21] And so, [41:23] um, there's like a significant fight [41:26] going on between them as to what this [41:28] investigation looks like. Um, so that's [41:31] part of what's going on. [41:32] >> There's I also heard that there's there [41:34] were a few other issues as well, like at [41:36] some of the polling stations, obser, you [41:38] know, in Israel, every party, every [41:41] regist every party in the election can [41:43] have observers in any polling station, [41:45] >> right? [41:45] >> Okay. I've been an observer in a polling [41:47] station. [41:48] >> Uh, I've been a vote counter. I've done [41:49] a lot of different roles in the [41:51] electoral system here. Uh, and there [41:56] there are there are numerous testimonies [41:59] of Jewish pole workers who were poll [42:02] observers at Arab polling stations who [42:05] were basically chased out of there. [42:08] Some of them violently who were [42:10] thwarted. There were there were armed [42:14] guys in the polling stations making sure [42:17] people voted a right you know the right [42:19] way. There was a and I heard also there [42:21] was a lot of there was double voting. [42:23] There were people who voting who didn't [42:24] actually show up but votes were cast for [42:26] them which can happen if no one's [42:27] observing. Just the way the system [42:29] works. Uh if no one's observing people [42:31] can vote on other people's behalf and [42:33] cross them off the list and say that [42:34] they voted. So there's uh there's a lot [42:37] there's a lot of issues here. I I I want [42:39] to cut to the chase of where we are [42:40] right now. Okay. In terms of [42:42] >> in terms of like where do things stand. [42:44] >> Okay. So here [42:45] >> in terms of coalition building where are [42:48] we [42:48] >> here's what I find most concerning. [42:51] >> Um Gdiot cannot make a coalition. Um the [42:56] Arabs will support him for prime [42:58] minister but they won't actually form a [43:01] coalition with him. He's not going to [43:04] give them ministerial seats. uh and they [43:07] won't really vote for him. What he's [43:09] trying to do is become prime minister as [43:12] a minority government, which does not [43:16] exist under Israeli law. Right? There [43:19] have been minority governments, but they [43:20] started off as majority government. [43:23] >> It's not true. You can have a minority [43:24] government. If [43:26] you can have a minority government, if [43:28] the Knesset votes to seat the government [43:30] and it passes, then the government is [43:32] seated. You need 61 to vote for a [43:35] coalition. You don't need 61 in the [43:37] coalition. [43:38] >> Okay. [43:38] >> Okay. You can seat a minority government [43:40] and that's what he's trying to do and [43:41] the Arab parties may support it. [43:43] >> Right. The Arab parties may support it. [43:45] But the other thing he's doing is he's [43:47] come up with this new phrase called an [43:49] emergency national government by which [43:52] which also does not exist in law. and he [43:56] is trying to uh use that to get himself [44:00] into power to then basically just revoke [44:03] a whole bunch of laws that were passed [44:05] under the previous administration under [44:07] BB and then you like just like when [44:10] Bennett was prime minister um you know [44:13] it collapsed within a year the same [44:15] thing is going to is going to happen [44:17] here um and some of his coalition [44:20] partners especially Vdman but even some [44:22] of the people within the Yashar [44:24] exclamation point party um believe that [44:28] this is very short-term thinking because [44:30] once they create this government with [44:33] the Arabs then um the next election [44:37] which will be pretty soon we'll see a [44:39] major right-wing um [44:42] >> you know uh voting effort and voting [44:45] effort and that will lead to a real [44:47] right-wing government which they don't [44:48] want. Also, even if if they if they do, [44:50] like I was just talking technically, you [44:52] can have a minority government if the [44:54] Arabs vote for it. But [44:56] >> which they've never done. They didn't [44:57] even do that for Bennett. [44:57] >> No, it's never happened. It's never [44:58] happened. It's it's and that's why when [45:00] people say you need a coalition of 61, [45:02] it's [45:04] >> Thank you for the correction. [45:04] >> It's actually not it's not exactly [45:06] technically true. You need it it ends up [45:09] always being true because why would [45:11] anyone vote for a coalition they're not [45:12] in? So, you need a coalition of 61, but [45:14] you actually don't. You need a vote in [45:16] Knessa to seat the government. to seat [45:18] the coalition. So, you end up needing 61 [45:21] because you need everyone to vote for it [45:23] and no one outside the coalition is [45:24] going to vote for it. But if they do, it [45:27] can still pass, right? [45:28] >> Okay. You can have a you can have a [45:30] party that leaves the coalition. For [45:31] example, in this last government for the [45:34] last I don't know I don't remember how [45:36] many months of it, the two [45:38] ultraorththodox parties, the two Karedi [45:40] parties actually left the coalition. [45:41] They gave up their ministerial uh spots. [45:44] They gave up their ministries, but they [45:45] still voted with the government. [45:47] to keep the coalition going, meaning so [45:50] that the government wouldn't fall. [45:51] >> Right. No, that's happened in the past. [45:53] >> So things like that happen. [45:54] >> Their coalition has started with with [45:55] >> Yeah. But but you can actually start it. [45:57] You can seat a government without it. [45:58] Here here's what here here's what really [46:00] really really [46:01] >> but let me just say if that happened if [46:04] they seated a government with a vote to [46:07] seat the government that included the [46:08] Arab parties even if the Arab parties [46:10] not part of the coalition to the Israeli [46:12] voters it's functionally the same thing [46:14] as the Arabs being in the coalition [46:16] >> right [46:17] >> because they're relying on them and I'll [46:20] say something that I think I said last [46:21] week when we talked about this people [46:23] have to realize and and when you're [46:24] having conversations with people about [46:26] this because Israel is gonna Israelis [46:28] are being accused of racism when as the [46:31] news gets out that it's a controversial [46:33] issue in Israel to sit in a coalition [46:35] with Arabs. It has nothing to do with [46:37] sitting with Arabs. There have been Arab [46:38] members of Kesset from Likood from Labor [46:41] over the years who've held positions in [46:42] the government. It's not about them the [46:45] fact that they are Arabs. It's that they [46:48] are anti-Israel parties. [46:49] >> Right. [46:50] >> Okay. And the idea, imagine it, it it [46:54] it's an absurdity, but imagine if you [46:56] had a party running in the United States [46:58] whose party platform stated that they [47:01] fundamentally disagree with the whole [47:03] concept of the Constitution. [47:05] >> The Democrats, [47:07] [laughter] it doesn't officially say [47:08] that, but I mean that's or but the [47:10] Democratic Socialists of America. Yeah, [47:12] they do. [47:13] >> Unlimited immigration, [47:14] >> you know, the but we actually have these [47:16] Arab parties are literally anti-ionist, [47:18] anti-Israel. They don't believe in the [47:20] Jewish state being a being a Jewish [47:22] state and that's why it's that's why [47:24] it's it's a it's a taboo to have them [47:27] sit in your coalition. [47:28] >> Let me let me now get into what really [47:31] concerns me. [47:32] >> Okay. Okay. [47:34] And let me go back a little bit to [47:35] remind our viewers what happened after [47:37] the 2020 election. 2020 election was [47:39] very controversial. There were the votes [47:42] stopped and then all of a sudden jumped. [47:44] And [47:44] >> you mean the American election? The [47:45] American election. [47:46] >> The American election. And then and you [47:47] know and there was like some bickering [47:50] and Trump like was trying to figure out [47:51] what exactly happened and he seems to be [47:53] caught on his back foot. But Biden was [47:55] not caught on his back foot. Biden [47:58] didn't say anything during the campaign. [48:00] But as soon as the election happened, he [48:03] was ready with a stage and a backdrop [48:06] and speeches. He was called [48:08] president-elect by all the media. There [48:10] was a public relations campaign to [48:14] propel him past all the questions, [48:18] right? [48:19] >> The same thing is happening with Gotti [48:20] Eisenhot. Gotti Isn't said nothing [48:23] during the election. Nothing [48:25] >> during the campaign. [48:26] >> During the campaign, he he was [crying] [48:29] >> because he has no personality. He has [48:31] nothing to say. [48:31] >> Now all of a sudden he has these clear [48:33] tweets about how BB is a threat to [48:35] democracy over and over and over again. [48:37] how they are going to make Israel a [48:39] proper country again. Like [laughter] I [48:42] I've never heard the guy be this strong. [48:44] The same thing is happening. There's a [48:46] public relations campaign to propel him [48:48] into office, right? And there's actually [48:51] very little that BB can do to stop him. [48:53] The only people who can stop him are the [48:55] members of his own party who don't want [48:57] to sit with the anti-ionist Arabs and [49:00] Victor Lieberman. Natali Bennett will do [49:02] like do anything. The guy's he has no [49:04] principles. Yeah. Yeah. And Lieberman's [49:06] already said that he's not g I mean he's [49:08] just not going to go along with this. [49:10] >> So [49:11] >> it's it hasn't been as clear to me as it [49:13] is to you. I think he's still [49:14] >> although although uh one of the [49:16] ultraorththodox parties, the UTJ [49:20] uh did refuse to endorse Netanyahu for [49:23] prime minister with the president. And [49:25] >> you never know. They they could cut a [49:27] deal with Eisen, but they wouldn't do it [49:28] if they were if they were uh relying on [49:31] the Arabs. All right. So we're still in [49:32] a stalemate in Israel. That's where [49:34] things stand. America is um is in bad [49:39] shape. Uh I think we'll you know we'll [49:41] just end this conversation with a big [49:44] picture statement which is [49:48] and we talked about this once before. [49:51] Blaming the Jews [49:54] never works out well for people who do [49:55] it. [49:57] Okay? It just doesn't it it doesn't [50:00] work. It feels good short term for them, [50:03] but it's not going to work. Um, you [50:06] know, we opened the conversation today [50:07] talking about Canada. Canada is a [50:10] country that has turned hard against [50:11] Israel after being one of the most [50:13] pro-Israel countries in the world under [50:14] Steven Harper, previous prime minister [50:16] before Trudeau. I mean, two prime [50:18] ministers ago, he was the most [50:21] pro-Israel head of state in the world. [50:24] And Canada was doing great. And the [50:26] Canadian dollar was on par with the US [50:28] dollar. Today it's like twothirds of the [50:29] US dollar [50:32] and they've turned on Israel. And I'm [50:34] not saying it's divine judgment, [50:36] although that could also be a part of [50:37] it. I think it has to do with something [50:41] more deeply psychological. I think back [50:44] to George Gilder's great book, The [50:45] Israel Test. If you haven't read it, you [50:48] got to read it. Fantastic book. But you [50:50] know George Gilder the you know who's [50:51] one of the great u you know writers uh [50:55] of the last 50 years wrote wealth and [50:57] poverty [50:59] uh and his book the Israel test he talks [51:01] about uh Israel as a test for the [51:06] non-Jewish world that how you view the [51:09] Jews right do you bless them or do you [51:11] curse them like do you how do you see [51:13] them ends up reflecting back on their [51:15] own values and I think that's really [51:17] what we're seeing here And if America [51:20] goes down this road where you know JD [51:23] Vance JD Vance just you know threw a [51:25] stick of dynamite into things here and [51:27] he he has set the narrative now and he's [51:30] getting a lot of here here and a lot of [51:33] agreement from people and he's setting [51:36] the narrative that that it it will that [51:38] people will look back on this blood bath [51:40] of a midterm and Israel is in large part [51:45] to blame and it's just not going to end [51:47] well because for the reasons that you [51:49] said when you do that blaming the reason [51:51] blaming the Jews doesn't work well is [51:54] because it's never actually true. Jews [51:57] do not destroy their societies anywhere [51:59] they've ever been. [52:01] But when people blame the Jews, it [52:03] always means that they're ignoring the [52:05] real problems that they want to deal [52:06] that they need to deal with. That's what [52:08] you were bringing up about the national [52:09] debt and all that. So, we're in a dark [52:13] place right now and uh you know, all [52:16] eyes are on Trump. Trump, as you say, [52:18] you think that he's determined to go [52:19] forward. I hope he is. I can't imagine [52:21] he's going to allow he's going to allow [52:23] his presidency to end without resolving [52:25] this Iran situation. He does not want to [52:26] go down in history as a failure. [sighs] [52:29] But like I said, just going back to my [52:30] point, the the original sin in this war [52:35] was stopping the war on April 8th. If [52:37] they had followed Israel's program, then [52:41] this wouldn't be an issue. [52:43] >> Very true. [52:44] >> All right, we'll leave it there for this [52:45] week. Thanks for watching and uh and [52:48] again make sure to go back uh into the [52:50] link in the description of the video as [52:52] I mentioned to support the pinakama the [52:56] warm corners that Israel 365 charity is [52:59] funding in order to keep those security [53:02] uh volunteers and personnel safe and [53:05] warm and taken care of. You can be a [53:07] part of that. God bless.