Transcript [00:00] So in his typical fashion, Abdul Elsad [00:02] gives a great political answer saying [00:04] that Israel should guarantee equal [00:06] rights and I agree. However, watch what [00:09] he adds. Take a look. [00:10] >> What should Israel be? I believe that [00:13] Israel ought to be a country [00:17] that upholds equal rights for all of its [00:19] citizens. Equal rights for all its [00:21] citizens. Does not identify itself with [00:25] a culture or a faith. [00:27] >> Hold on to that one. and that dignifies [00:30] the rights of those citizens to live [00:32] free under its laws. That's again the [00:35] question of peace, dignity, and [00:37] self-determination. And let's step back [00:38] from here because we always start from [00:40] the premise of what is Israel now and [00:42] what should it be versus the premise of [00:45] what should be the juxtaposition of [00:49] states [00:51] or state [00:52] that upholds equal rights for [00:54] Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. [00:56] Well, the issue is that many quote [00:58] unquote Palestinians are not citizens of [01:01] Israel. So, if you're not a citizen of a [01:04] country, you don't get the same rights [01:05] as the people within the country. People [01:08] in Mexico don't have the same rights [01:10] granted by the country as an American [01:13] because, well, duh, doofus, they're not [01:15] Americans. In the same way, Palestinians [01:18] in the West Bank or in Gaza don't have [01:21] the same rights as Israelis because [01:23] they're not part of the country of [01:25] Israel. And I do think there is a lot of [01:27] work to be done as it pertains to the [01:29] West Bank or Judea and Samaria, [01:31] whichever you'd prefer to call it, I [01:33] don't really care. I don't think it [01:35] makes that big of a difference. This is [01:36] a political answer and Abdul Elsad is a [01:39] great speaker. Whether you love him, [01:40] whether you hate him, it's just the fact [01:42] of the matter. He's very good at it. He [01:44] knows what he's doing. He knows how to [01:45] convey his messaging and to be very [01:47] discreet in certain points that he's [01:49] making. However, you can't just say that [01:51] I believe in equal rights and you put [01:53] that at the beginning of your answer and [01:54] then you expect everybody else to agree [01:56] with whatever comes after that. And [01:57] that's exactly what he's chosen to do [01:59] here. Like, of course, people should [02:01] have equal rights. The question is why [02:03] in your answer that requires Israel to [02:06] stop identifying as Jewish. I want you [02:07] guys to listen to this again. It's not, [02:09] oh, we should just want equal rights for [02:11] everyone. No, it's that Israel as a [02:13] state, as a nation, must stop [02:16] identifying with one particular religion [02:18] or one specific type of culture. Check [02:20] this out again. Pay attention. [02:22] >> I believe that Israel ought to be a [02:25] country [02:26] that upholds equal rights for all of its [02:29] citizens, equal rights for all its [02:31] citizens, does not identify itself with [02:34] a culture or a faith, and that dignifies [02:37] the rights of those citizens to live [02:38] free under its laws. Now before we go [02:41] any further, I think I would point out [02:43] that Arab citizens of Israel that are to [02:46] him he would probably call them [02:47] Palestinians. Many identify as such. [02:49] They are legally I guess classified as [02:51] Israeli Arabs. They already have the [02:53] right to vote and run for parliament. [02:55] There are people who serve in the [02:57] Knesset, basically Israel's uh Congress, [03:00] right? Who are Arab. There have been [03:02] Arabs who have literally had Jewish [03:04] Israeli leaders kicked out and arrested. [03:06] Equality is already recognized by [03:08] Israel's courts. So in this case, we're [03:10] not talking about a country where [03:12] citizenship and political participation [03:14] are only and exclusively reserved for [03:16] Jewish people. That doesn't exist. Now, [03:18] does that mean that everything is equal [03:20] in practice? No. Does it mean that there [03:23] aren't laws worth challenging? No. The [03:25] nation state law explicitly reserves [03:27] national self-determination to the [03:29] Jewish people. And there is a debate [03:31] over what that means for minorities. But [03:33] there is also a reason why Israel [03:35] maintains that it must maintain uh to be [03:38] a Jewish state. To believe that Israel [03:40] hasn't had a historic argument or a good [03:43] reason for wanting to keep and maintain [03:45] its Jewish majority is to be [03:47] historically illiterate. The reason that [03:49] it must maintain that is because if it [03:51] is not a Jewish majority state, it is no [03:53] longer a Jewish state. If Israel must [03:56] sacrifice, must disassociate its culture [03:59] and religion entirely from its country, [04:01] its laws, anything like that, does he [04:04] also believe the same thing about all [04:05] the surrounding Arab and Muslim [04:07] countries? Instead of debating, hey, [04:09] what laws in Israel may be [04:11] discriminatory? What laws may kind of [04:14] impede on the rights of certain people [04:15] while granting better or greater rights [04:17] to other people? So instead of having [04:19] that conversation, he goes considerably [04:21] further saying that the country of [04:22] Israel shouldn't identify with any [04:24] culture, with any faith, a culture. What [04:28] does a country without a culture even [04:30] look like? Abdul, tell us. This is not [04:32] an argument of, oh, we should separate [04:34] religious authority or religion from [04:35] government. Oh, separation of church and [04:37] state like we have here in America. I [04:39] understand that argument. However, [04:41] countries have languages and traditions. [04:43] They have holidays and histories that [04:45] shape their public life. Okay? They have [04:47] all of these things. To act as if they [04:49] don't is just to be oblivious and they [04:51] don't become neutral in these aspects, [04:53] in these ways just because you remove [04:56] the identity that you don't like. [04:57] Somebody is still going to decide what [04:59] replaces that identity. And again, I [05:01] would love to hear him take this [05:02] argument to Muslim majority countries [05:04] and tell them just as directly that [05:06] their country shouldn't identify with [05:08] their religion or their culture. Do you [05:10] think he would do that? The fact that he [05:12] doesn't do that shows you that he's not [05:13] defending a consistent principle. He's [05:15] just treating Jewish national identity [05:17] as this uniquely unacceptable thing that [05:19] must be uh fixed. It must be resolved. [05:23] It's an issue. But here's the main [05:24] thing, okay? And I think this is the [05:25] biggest problem when it comes to [05:27] Westerners who see the world through [05:29] this lens, who make these types of [05:30] arguments. There is an assumption [05:32] underneath this answer and many of the [05:34] things that you'll hear that bothers me. [05:36] And that is that people in another part [05:38] of the world ought to understand their [05:40] country the way that a progressive [05:42] American thinks they should. Not [05:44] everyone in the world is an American. [05:46] Not everyone in the world thinks like [05:48] you. I don't know why this is so hard [05:50] for people to wrap their head around. [05:52] They don't all have American history or [05:54] our American understanding of what holds [05:56] a country together. And even Americans [05:58] disagree about that. To believe that [06:00] certain rights should apply everywhere [06:01] is one thing. However, that doesn't mean [06:03] that every society has to become [06:05] culturally interchangeable before those [06:07] rights are possible. And with Israel, [06:10] you're talking about people whose [06:11] attachment to a Jewish national home [06:13] comes from a very particular history, a [06:16] a real thing that has happened to them. [06:18] Because for generations, the safety of [06:20] the Jewish people depended wholly on [06:23] whether the government they lived under [06:25] would protect them, whether it would [06:27] tolerate them, whether it would expel [06:29] them or turn against them. They have a [06:32] real concrete solidified reason [06:35] objectively for wanting to maintain and [06:37] preserve a Jewish majority and for being [06:40] a Jewish state. So having a country [06:43] where Jewish people can exercise [06:45] self-government means something that you [06:47] can't just say is this outdated [06:50] preference. No, it is a real thing. They [06:52] have a real reason for wanting this. And [06:54] when you tell them to give that up, [06:55] they're going to ask you what replaces [06:57] it. As I said, because every vacuum that [07:00] opens up in the Middle East, as we've [07:02] seen, gets filled with something. So, in [07:04] this case, who is going to protect who [07:06] if Israel doesn't maintain its Jewish [07:09] majority? Who is going to control the [07:11] institutions of the Jewish state or what [07:13] would no longer be the Jewish state [07:15] where the Jewish people live? What is [07:17] going to happen if the people making [07:19] promises to the Jewish people lose [07:21] power? Those are all actual real [07:24] pragmatic questions that have to be [07:28] answered. Yet, he won't do it because [07:29] this is cheap political talk. Now, this [07:32] all brings me to the end of his answer [07:34] where he says, "States or state." I want [07:37] you guys to take a look at this because [07:38] this to me reveals something that again [07:41] you probably don't pick up just by [07:43] listening to what he had to say. Take a [07:44] look [07:44] >> because we always start from the premise [07:46] of what is Israel now and what should it [07:47] be versus the premise of what should be [07:52] the juxiposition of states [07:56] or state that upholds equal rights for [07:59] Palestinians and Jewish Israelis alike. [08:01] >> So which one do you think he's [08:03] proposing? because we've spent this [08:05] whole answer talking about peace and [08:07] dignity and we still don't know whether [08:09] this guy wants one country as Israel [08:12] that has all of these equal rights or if [08:14] he means two countries. He has said [08:16] historically that he really supports [08:18] whatever the people want. And what we've [08:20] been able to see historically and [08:22] currently through polling continuously [08:24] is that neither the Jewish population of [08:26] Israel wants a two-state solution, [08:28] neither do the Arabs, neither do the [08:31] Palestinians. They also do not want a [08:33] two-state solution. So, if he's going to [08:35] propose two states, then he has to [08:36] explain why one can't be a Palestinian [08:39] national home and the other can't be a [08:40] Jewish national home with both obligated [08:43] to protect their minorities, right? [08:45] Would a Palestinian state have to stop [08:47] identifying as Palestinian? Would they [08:49] have to abandon their own national [08:51] religion of Islam like Pakistan and [08:53] Saudi Arabia, all of these other [08:54] countries? Does he call on them to do [08:56] that? Of course, he doesn't. But back to [08:58] the uh the makeup of this potential [09:00] two-state solution or one state in this [09:03] case, would the government of these [09:05] states have to detach themselves from [09:07] literally every religious or cultural [09:08] tradition? Or would he say reasonably, [09:10] right, that having a national identity [09:13] doesn't excuse denying anybody equal [09:15] treatment? That's in the case of the [09:16] two-state solution. However, if he's [09:18] going to propose a one-state solution, [09:20] well, that requires even a bigger [09:22] explanation than just, well, everyone's [09:24] going to have equal rights. The [09:26] questions that we have to answer are [09:27] who's going to control the military and [09:29] the armed forces? Okay. How are the [09:31] armed groups there disarmed? What is [09:34] going to stop a government from [09:35] stripping away protections after it wins [09:37] an election? What happens when people [09:39] don't trust the courts or believe that [09:41] the police belong to the other side? [09:43] Now, of course, he doesn't have to [09:44] answer every detail in this short [09:46] interview. I mean, these are again very [09:47] complex questions. They are real [09:49] questions that must be answered because, [09:51] oh, there just has to be two states [09:53] isn't an actual solution. Okay, if it [09:55] were that simple, it would have occurred [09:56] by now. Okay, but these also at the same [09:59] time are not minor details that we can [10:01] work out after everybody agrees on a [10:03] two-state solution. This is precisely [10:05] why people don't agree. So, what we have [10:07] to be asking ourselves is what right [10:10] specifically can only be protected only [10:13] be protected if Israel stops being a [10:16] Jewish country, a Jewish national home. [10:18] Otherwise, why can't it be protected [10:20] through changing the laws or changing or [10:22] strengthening institutions in some way [10:24] or by potentially reaching some type of [10:26] political settlement? That is what we [10:28] should be asking. And if he had an [10:30] answer to that, he would give it. But he [10:32] doesn't. But I'm going to leave it at [10:33] that. So, let me know your guys's [10:34] thoughts, opinions, and arguments down [10:36] in the comments section below. And if [10:37] you enjoyed the video, please do me a [10:39] favor. Go ahead and smash the like [10:40] button. And if you're new here and you [10:42] enjoy the video, please consider [10:43] subscribing to the channel. 70 to 80% of [10:45] you who watch are not subscribed to the [10:47] channel. and I post videos every single [10:49] day, so subscribing would greatly help [10:51] me out. Don't leave the video without [10:52] giving me your thoughts down in the [10:54] comment section below. And if you made [10:56] it this far, I appreciate you for [10:57] watching. And as always, take care of [10:58] yourselves, stay safe, and I'll see you [11:00] in the next one. [11:04] [music]
Abdul El-Sayed opens with a line everyone can agree with: Israel should uphold equal rights for all its citizens. But listen to what he actually adds: that Israel must not identify itself with a culture or a faith. That is not an argument for equal rights. That is an argument that Israel cannot exist as a Jewish state. I break down what he is actually saying, why the framing is deliberate, and why the argument collapses the moment you apply it consistently.
Arab citizens of Israel already have the right to vote, run for parliament, and serve in the Knesset. Equality is already recognized by Israel’s courts. That does not mean everything is equal in practice or that no laws are worth challenging. But El-Sayed goes considerably further than that. He is not arguing for reforms to specific laws. He is arguing that Israel must detach its national identity from Jewish culture and religion entirely. I want to know if he would walk into Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, or Iran and make the exact same argument. He wouldn’t. And that tells you this is not a consistent principle, it is Jewish national identity specifically that he finds unacceptable.
The Jewish people’s attachment to a Jewish national home is not an outdated preference. It comes from real history: generations of Jewish people whose survival depended entirely on whether the government they lived under would protect them, tolerate them, or expel and kill them. That is a concrete and documented reason for wanting a state where Jewish people exercise self-government. At the end of his answer, El-Sayed says “states or state” and never clarifies. If he wants two states, why can’t one be a Jewish national home? If he wants one state, who controls the military? What stops a government from stripping protections after it wins an election? He does not answer these questions because this is not a serious policy argument. It is cheap political talk dressed up in the language of human rights.
Let’s Connect:
Instagram https://instagram.com/themoderatecase
TikTok https://tiktok.com/@themoderatecase
Twitter/X https://x.com/themoderatecase
Newsletter https://substack.com/@themoderatecase
Support Me:
https://buymeacoffee.com/themoderatecase
https://venmo.com/u/ModerateCase
Subscribe for weekly commentary on politics, geopolitics, and media narratives. This channel is dedicated to careful analysis, documented context, and clear explanations of complex public issues.
#Israel #AbdulElSayed #TheModerateCase
Breakdown:
0:00 Intro
0:56 What El-Sayed Is Actually Saying
2:40 Arab Citizens Already Vote and Serve in the Knesset
4:00 What a Country Without a Culture Looks Like
5:30 Would He Say This to Muslim Countries?
6:30 The History Behind Why a Jewish State Exists
7:44 ‘States or State’, Won’t Commit
8:30 The Questions He Refuses to Answer
10:00 My Take