Transcript [00:02] Rabbi Ari Z. Schwartz, such a privilege [00:04] and pleasure to be sitting with you in [00:05] the heart of Jerusalem around the corner [00:07] from your home in the shul, in the [00:08] synagogue that you pray in. [00:10] You're an incredible author, just came [00:12] out with the Spiritual Revolution of [00:14] Rabbi Cook. You're an amazing teacher [00:17] and you're a dear friend. I got to grow [00:19] up with you in Sydney, Australia and to [00:21] watch you from close and from afar [00:23] inspiring so many means so much. [00:25] So thank you so much for joining us [00:26] today. [00:27] >> Thank you for having me and uh yeah, [00:29] it's exciting to talk to you. We [00:30] probably could have had this [00:31] conversation for many years, but finally [00:33] got to put it on film. [00:34] >> Can't wait to have it. So I guess let's [00:36] start. You know, you're a Jewish mystic [00:38] yourself. What is Jewish mysticism? [00:41] >> Okay, well I think the word Jewish [00:43] mysticism, if you like really use a [00:45] technical term, it's obviously Kabbalah [00:47] and uh [00:48] I think for me my my entrance for [00:50] Kabbalah is through Rav Cook. So Rav [00:53] Cook is somebody who basically has taken [00:56] the most practical parts of Judaism and [00:57] uncovered how they're all connected to [00:59] some higher spiritual purpose. So for [01:01] example, like if you're putting on [01:02] tefillin, so it could just be a [01:04] mechanical thing, but according to [01:06] Kabbalah, it's something which is [01:07] connecting to your soul, to all [01:09] different spiritual worlds and obviously [01:11] having an effect on something bigger [01:13] than just the individual. So I think [01:15] Kabbalah in that sense and mysticism is [01:17] taking something which seems very [01:19] simple, just like a simple law, a simple [01:21] practical thing and realizing it has [01:23] major effects on not just your own [01:26] physical body, but your soul and all the [01:28] people around you. [01:29] >> And how were you introduced to Jewish [01:30] mysticism? [01:32] >> Again, [01:33] keep going back to Rav Cook because I I [01:34] really think any other type of Kabbalist [01:37] or mystic that I was introduced to, it [01:39] didn't really affect me until I got into [01:41] Rav Cook's writings. One of the big [01:42] misconceptions of Rav Cook is that he [01:44] was just like a normal chief rabbi of [01:46] Israel, but the deeper I got into him, [01:48] the more I realized this is [01:50] a person who took Kabbalah as his number [01:52] one identity and you know, anything from [01:56] meditation to prayer to studying [01:58] Kabbalah, um [02:00] even small things like he would [02:02] literally write books and he believed [02:04] that there was such positive spiritual [02:06] energy he wrote in them Rash Million, [02:08] they would literally give it out to [02:09] people and he believed that there was a [02:10] spiritual effect it would have on people [02:12] just by having it in their hands. [02:13] >> So I guess how did you connect to him [02:15] then? [02:16] >> Yes, so again, I think that uh [02:19] even I'd gone through Rabbi Nachman's [02:20] writings before. Um, you know I I the [02:22] Baal Ha Sulam, I looked at his writings, [02:24] but to to I think Rav Kook, when I was [02:27] introduced him um through Rav David [02:28] Aaron, um [02:30] it was the first time that I really [02:32] realized Kabbalah and mysticism wasn't [02:35] just something like cool and trendy, it [02:37] really helped my personality. [02:39] And anything from [02:41] if I focus more on my thoughts, they can [02:44] affect people um just by thinking [02:46] positively. And or something another [02:49] thing like you know if I am always [02:51] having negative thoughts on someone, um [02:53] that will have a negative effect on my [02:55] own relationship to them. And this is [02:56] this is you could obviously say is [02:57] psychology, but I think it's deeper than [02:59] psychology because um Rav Kook and the [03:01] Zohar and [03:03] the Baal Ha Sulam, they really believe [03:04] there's an interconnectivity between all [03:06] existence. So if I really am connected [03:08] to everything, [03:10] um if I think something negative about [03:11] somebody, it's going to have a ripple [03:13] effect on them. And that ripple effect [03:15] will come back to eventually to bite me. [03:16] It's going to come get me as well. So I [03:18] really want to take responsibility for [03:19] my thoughts and my my words and my [03:21] actions. And I think that's really the [03:23] beginning of what mysticism is for me. [03:26] And uh and again through Rav Kook, [03:27] that's how I got into it. [03:28] >> And so in an ideal world, would all Jews [03:30] be mystics? [03:32] >> You know what? [03:33] Rav Kook says in um in Shimon Kvatzen [03:36] that he thinks there are [03:38] mister souls, [03:39] which means there are mystical souls and [03:41] there are more practical souls. So [03:42] mystical souls for Rav Kook is a certain [03:44] type of personality that Hashem put in [03:46] the world, a certain a certain soul. So [03:48] I don't think [03:49] Rav Kook or and I wouldn't believe this [03:51] either that everybody has that type of [03:54] So there are souls who really are much [03:56] more connected to the practical parts of [03:58] life. And for them, it really feels [04:00] unnecessary to talk about [04:02] um something which you can't touch and [04:04] you can't see. But for those souls who [04:06] need that almost like um they need [04:09] nourishment. They need they need that [04:11] food to survive. Um it's a must. [04:13] Mysticism is a must for people who have [04:16] that certain sensitivity in their soul [04:18] who can feel almost in a poetic way that [04:20] there's something more than just meets [04:22] the eye. You know I was always into [04:24] music growing up. Um so I always had [04:26] this feeling like that when I listen to [04:28] music it's doing something to me even [04:30] though I can't see it. I don't know [04:32] where it's coming from. And then I'd [04:33] want to listen to it with other people [04:34] and you know you know what you've heard [04:35] me play clarinet before. [04:38] Um so what exactly am I doing with the [04:39] clarinet when I'm playing it you know [04:41] there's almost like a vibration coming [04:42] out and is it affecting people but I but [04:44] I can't see what's coming out of the [04:45] clarinet. [04:46] And so I think for me people who are [04:49] very musical Rav Cook says are often [04:51] very connected to mysticism. Um people [04:53] who are very artistic are very connected [04:55] to mysticism. So for those people who [04:57] have not been exposed to Kabbalah and [04:59] mysticism but are really musical and [05:00] artistic um I think it actually is an [05:03] obligation for them. Like they should be [05:05] immersed in Zohar and immersed in [05:07] Ramchal, you know Rav Cook, Ba'al [05:10] HaSulam, Ba'al HaTanya. But for other [05:12] souls um who really just are more [05:15] intrigued by the practical parts of life [05:18] and I don't think it's it's necessary [05:20] for us to put it into them. And also Rav [05:22] Cook has this great line in that piece [05:23] in Shemona Kvatzim where he says that [05:26] they've already been nourished enough in [05:28] the kind of spirituality that that's why [05:30] when they learn Kabbalah they feel like [05:32] I don't need this. So it's the opposite [05:34] of what you would think. You would think [05:35] Rav Cook would say oh we're [05:36] undernourished um if we don't like [05:39] Kabbalah and we're overnourished like we [05:41] have enough and you know we need more. [05:44] But it's the opposite. The people who [05:45] aren't turned on by mysticism for Rav [05:47] Cook it's because something inside of [05:48] their soul is happy without it. So we [05:51] shouldn't be judging them and saying oh [05:52] really you're not as deep as me. It's [05:54] the opposite. Something inside of their [05:55] soul is extremely um it feels well [05:58] rounded. It doesn't need that. And on [06:00] the other hand people who are extremely [06:02] um like hungry like myself um for you [06:05] know that which you can't see, that [06:06] which you can't physically touch, but [06:08] know it's real is almost like I'm [06:11] undernourished. I need more of that. And [06:14] just like on a practical level, I'm [06:15] learning mysticism every day. And if [06:18] it's Rav Kook, if it's the [06:21] These are things that almost like food [06:22] I'm putting inside of me every day cuz I [06:24] feel there's something lacking if I [06:25] don't learn it. [06:26] >> So what do you think of you talk about [06:28] something that you feel but you don't [06:29] touch? [06:30] >> Yeah. [06:30] >> What do you think of when I say the word [06:31] God? [06:32] Like what is that construct? What do you [06:35] imagine or what do you connect to? [06:37] >> So I think for for what the word God is [06:39] is I think it's pointing to something [06:41] extremely deep. And just like a menu, [06:44] you know, like you know, when you're [06:45] looking at a menu and and you see like a [06:47] chocolate soufflé with ice cream and and [06:49] you know, melting caramel, [06:51] it would be ridiculous to eat the menu. [06:53] So like the words are trying to point to [06:55] some experience. What is the experience [06:57] of God that the word is pointing to? For [06:59] me, based on what I've learned [07:01] um and definitely in Rav Kook's [07:02] writings, I think the word is pointing [07:04] to a [07:06] consciousness that exists, that is [07:09] pursuing me, that is guiding me, that [07:11] won't leave me alone, that loves me [07:13] unconditionally, and that is asking me [07:16] to do something. [07:17] And um it's not a guy in the sky, but it [07:20] is something beyond me. So in that sense [07:23] when we say these phrases, you know, in [07:25] in normal rabbinical language like our [07:26] Father in heaven and [07:28] I don't think they're so far off. In [07:29] other words, there is something beyond [07:31] us like a king. There is something [07:33] compassionate like a father. So these [07:35] words are not um superficial. They're [07:37] pointing to something very deep. But on [07:39] the other hand, the mystics and and you [07:40] know, like the Ein Sof, they love using [07:42] the word Ein Sof. Rav Kook loves using [07:43] that phrase which means the infinite [07:45] one. It's not just a thing in the sky. [07:47] It's something that permeates all [07:48] existence. And for me, that means that [07:51] not only is God the creator of my life, [07:54] but I can actually experience the divine [07:56] in music, in art, um even in this [07:59] relationship right now in this [08:00] conversation. Martin Buber, who was a [08:02] famous [08:03] uh mystic, he used to say that God is [08:04] the electricity between two people when [08:06] they feel connected. So I think that [08:09] there is divine experiences in all [08:12] depth. And I can pursue that. And more [08:15] than that, it's pursuing me. Even if I [08:17] am not pursuing God and and [08:19] spirituality, it continues to run after [08:22] me even if I ignore it. So if I'll go [08:23] through a day [08:25] where I was too immersed in worrying and [08:27] and and money and you know, and the [08:30] busyness of life and stress, I find [08:33] myself almost being pursued by God. Like [08:35] Hashem [08:37] won't let me just have a day that's [08:39] satisfying by working on material [08:41] things. Like he won't let me just be [08:43] happy in the physical world. There's [08:45] something more to life. And so no matter [08:47] how much I try and ignore it, um that [08:50] spirit is pursuing me. And Rabbi Heschel [08:52] in God in Search of Man, he said more [08:55] than we are um in search of God, God is [08:57] in search of us in the sense of this [08:59] consciousness that is um some we can [09:02] hold on to isn't just like this blind [09:04] force that I can feel sometimes. It is [09:06] literally pursuing me. It's running [09:08] after me. It won't let me have a break. [09:11] And I think there's something very [09:12] almost romantic about the Kabbalistic [09:14] understanding of God. Like Hashem is in [09:16] love with me. Hashem is in love with the [09:18] human beings. And doesn't matter how [09:20] much human beings have ignored God [09:22] throughout history, um God will not give [09:24] up on us. And uh I think there's [09:27] something very beautiful about that that [09:28] there is this love um story between God [09:32] and creation. [09:33] >> It's more almost like our faith in God [09:34] reveals God's faith in us. [09:35] >> Yes, 100%. [09:37] >> Beautiful. And what about the Jewish [09:38] people? What's our purpose? [09:41] >> Oh, the Jewish people. The Jewish [09:43] people, I think, is a tough question. [09:45] You know, there were people um who were [09:46] very bothered by the idea of the Jewish [09:48] people having some unique connection to [09:49] Hashem and you know, that sounds racist [09:51] and [09:52] and you know, you think you're superior [09:53] than the other [09:55] nations. I think a more mature [09:57] understanding of the Jewish people is [09:59] based on a famous Midrash, which is that [10:02] God searched [10:03] for any nation and all nations to [10:05] receive the Torah. And [10:08] you know, the nation that didn't want to [10:09] receive Torah until eventually Amisrael [10:11] along and said, you know, [10:14] we want the Torah. So, in that sense, [10:16] um, Hashem is pursuing humanity, but [10:20] we said yes. We wanted the mission that [10:23] Hashem wanted to give us and wanted to [10:25] give the whole world. And if any non-Jew [10:28] would want to join this amazing mission, [10:30] um, called the Torah, then they can [10:32] join, right? That's called a convert. [10:33] But we're not going to force, um, and [10:36] convert someone against their will [10:38] because it really is, um, [10:40] a mission by choice. So, I think the [10:42] Jewish people in that sense are [10:43] definitely a mission. We have a mission [10:45] in life and it's a spiritual mission and [10:47] it's an ethical mission and it [10:49] materializes itself in many ways like [10:51] having a physical land that we have to [10:53] protect, but it could also be not just [10:55] about the land, it's what the land does [10:57] for the world, right? It can be I heard [10:59] Jordan Peterson say this when he came to [11:01] Israel that that he felt like Israel was [11:03] the land of Israel, um, was was really [11:06] like a light to the world. Like when he [11:07] came, he felt like it was more than just [11:09] a country. Like it represented something [11:11] bigger than itself. So, I think that is [11:13] what Israel is supposed to be. That even [11:15] though it is a country and it's a [11:16] concrete thing, it is both concrete and [11:19] also something much bigger than the [11:20] concrete. And as someone who made you [11:23] know, you've made we both came from [11:24] Australia, I don't feel like living in [11:26] Israel and being a part of the Jewish [11:28] people is the same as living in [11:30] Australia and being part of the [11:31] Australian nation. It seems to be [11:33] something more than just the physical [11:35] going on here. So, the Jewish people in [11:37] that sense we really [11:39] are personifying this higher purpose to [11:41] life and anybody who wants to join it [11:44] and fulfill it is welcome. [11:47] >> Yeah, and they they also you know, even [11:48] if they don't want to fulfill it, they [11:49] have their own ways to relate and [11:51] fulfill different purposes, but you're [11:53] saying there's a unique purpose for [11:54] Jewish people and other peoples equally. [11:57] >> Yeah, in other words, the fact that the [11:58] non-Jewish world doesn't have to convert [12:00] doesn't mean obviously they can't [12:01] connect to God and meaning and purpose. [12:03] There's so much depth and meaning, um, [12:06] in many other ways to connect to God. [12:08] But I do think something unique as you [12:09] said, you know, what is something unique [12:10] about the Jewish people? I think that [12:12] that [12:14] that we have taken upon ourselves as an [12:15] entire people, this responsibility. And [12:18] what's remarkable in Rav Kook's writings [12:20] is he he says even if a Jew [12:22] says, you know, I'm part of the Jewish [12:24] people, but I don't believe in the [12:25] mission, I don't believe in God, I don't [12:26] believe in [12:28] they end up being a part of the mission [12:29] anyway. In other words, just associating [12:31] yourself with the Jewish people causes [12:33] you to be a part of this mission. Um you [12:35] can't run away from it. And that goes [12:37] back to what I said about before that [12:39] it's more than we are in pursuit of [12:40] Hashem, Hashem is in pursuit of us. Like [12:43] a person who wants to assimilate, but [12:45] they're a Jew, they still have that name [12:47] Jew. [12:48] And it pursues them wherever they go. [12:50] You know, they can go to Kansas City, [12:53] um they can go to Australia, but your [12:55] name Jew, you know, [12:57] is going to pursue you. And it's just a [12:59] matter of time hopefully that you come [13:01] back. You know, that's the the story of [13:02] the Zionist, you know, the Herzl, [13:04] Theodor Herzl, that he was trying to [13:06] throw away his connection to the Jewish [13:08] people for so long, but eventually he [13:10] came to the he really deep acceptance [13:12] that to be a Jew is something I can't [13:14] evade, I can't run away from. And [13:16] instead of trying to uh you know, throw [13:18] it away, maybe I'll look into it and go [13:20] deeper into it. And Rav Kook had a lot [13:21] of respect for the early Zionists [13:23] because [13:24] even though they didn't connect to all [13:25] the Torah and the whole spiritual [13:27] mission, they really believed that there [13:29] was something worth fighting for to be a [13:31] Jew. So I don't think it's an all [13:33] nothing. Like there are Jews who feel [13:34] connected to some of the Jewish people [13:36] or the Jewish tradition and Jews who [13:38] feel connected to all the Jewish [13:39] tradition. I think ultimately it's like [13:41] a letter [13:42] you know, letter of observance. And [13:44] every Jew who wants to go deeper into [13:47] what this Jewish tradition is gets more [13:49] and more and is able to give more to the [13:50] world. [13:51] >> And how does prayer work? [13:53] >> Okay, prayer. Um [13:56] I think prayer is one of the greatest [13:58] tools that God has ever given us [14:00] um as human beings to transform [14:02] ourselves and the whole world. [14:04] Um so take for example [14:08] If I'm praying for somebody that I truly [14:11] think needs help. So usually we think if [14:13] someone needs help when they're sick, I [14:14] would send them to the doctor, which is [14:16] something we should do. This is a very [14:17] important thing to realize we're not [14:19] just spiritually caring for them, we [14:21] have to physically care for them, but [14:22] the role of prayer is is [14:25] is very significant. If I'm praying for [14:27] somebody, definitely according to [14:28] Kabbalah and mysticism, my words have a [14:31] ripple effect on them and there's the [14:33] interconnectivity as I spoke to before [14:35] that if I'm praying for somebody, I [14:36] really am using my positive energy and [14:39] sending it out to them and there are [14:41] some, you know, people believe you have [14:42] to say their name exactly [14:45] and if you don't say their name, that it [14:46] won't work. Other people say, okay, it [14:48] generally just I should send positive [14:50] prayers towards that person. [14:52] But either way, there is some incredible [14:54] ability. If I really take my words and [14:57] my thoughts seriously, I can influence [14:58] people who I've never even met [15:01] across the world. So that's one [15:02] understanding of prayer. Another [15:03] understanding of prayer is more like a [15:05] psychological understanding and I don't [15:06] think that's any less important that if [15:09] I'm using words every day almost like a [15:10] mantra [15:12] and I'm saying every day, I want to be a [15:14] wiser person. I want to be a more more [15:16] caring person. [15:17] I really I want to be a person who takes [15:19] healing more seriously, which is what is [15:21] in the Amidah, [15:23] then those values start becoming [15:25] internalized into me. And the question [15:27] of is prayer psychological or is it a [15:30] mystical thing? I think the answer [15:32] usually when it comes to those questions [15:33] is yes. [15:34] It is both psychological and is all [15:36] mystical and we shouldn't feel the need [15:39] to have to pick one over the other [15:40] because things have you know, they have [15:42] many dimensions. So the fact that prayer [15:44] psychologically does change my thoughts [15:46] every time I say the words, no matter [15:48] what, even if I didn't believe in God, [15:49] the prayers literally are affecting my [15:51] mind, we should say, well, that's a real [15:52] thing. On the other hand, if that's only [15:54] prayer, [15:56] Rav Kook says in the one beautiful [15:57] piece, he says if prayer only changes [15:59] you, [16:00] so then, you know, we don't even need [16:01] God anymore, you know. But if prayer is [16:04] like a magic trick where I just like say [16:05] the words and then I hope hocus pocus [16:07] somebody will get better, so then that's [16:09] kind of ruining [16:11] and and taking away from the inner logic [16:13] of prayer. Prayer does have a deep [16:15] spiritual logic to it. And as I said [16:17] before, the psychological can be one way [16:19] to explain it, but the mystical can be [16:21] another logic, which is my words or my [16:24] thoughts have a ripple effect on the [16:25] universe. And the more I take my word [16:28] seriously [16:29] and the more I concentrate on the person [16:31] I'm thinking of, the more it can affect [16:32] them. [16:33] >> So if prayer is our capacity to speak to [16:35] God, [16:36] often people say that Torah study is God [16:38] speaking to us. [16:39] The question is what's the goal of Torah [16:40] study? [16:41] >> Okay, Torah study. So Torah study is [16:44] kind of like [16:46] I would say the partner of prayer. [16:47] You've got, you know, prayer being able [16:50] to affect the universe. And in many ways [16:52] studying Torah is me trying to [16:55] access the wisdom of what I'd want to [16:57] even pray about. Rabbi David Aaron, who [17:00] I know you're going to have on this [17:00] show, um who's one of my teachers, he [17:02] you know, he says that we [17:05] um study Torah to know what God wants [17:08] and we pray to to want to what God wants [17:11] and then we do mitzvot to do what God, [17:13] you know, wants. So I think that's a [17:15] great way to think about um Talmud [17:17] Torah. Torah is me accessing wisdom of [17:20] how [17:22] exactly God wants me to act in this [17:23] world. But I think there's also another [17:25] element and I learned this from Rav [17:26] Shagar, who is another great mystic um [17:28] who died I think he died in 2004 [17:32] um [17:33] or 2006. Rav Shagar said that when a [17:36] person learns Torah, when a Jew learns [17:38] Torah, there's a unique brit. There's a [17:40] deep connection, like a covenant that a [17:42] Jew has when they learn Torah and it's [17:43] not just to access information. And I [17:45] definitely feel like this with my [17:46] talmidim when we're learning in yeshiva [17:48] on a midrashot that it almost feels like [17:50] we're having a deep connection right now [17:52] with the Ein Sof, with the you know, [17:54] with with the infinite, with our souls. [17:56] It's it's like an experiential thing [17:58] happening. So it's not just information [18:00] that later on I'll, you know, use in my [18:02] life when I get home with my wife and [18:03] kids, but the very active studying and [18:06] reading and immersing ourselves in in [18:08] divine wisdom, [18:10] I go through a transformation right here [18:12] right now. And if anybody has never [18:15] studied Torah late at night, you know, [18:17] with in a beit midrash with a few [18:19] friends, that is a mystical [18:21] And I remember had this one rabbi in [18:23] Yeshiva, [18:24] um, at about midnight every every night [18:27] in the Yeshiva, he'd come in late in the [18:28] night [18:30] and um basically the lights would turn [18:32] off in the Yeshiva and and then there'll [18:33] be this little part in the Beit Midrash [18:35] that would stay on. [18:36] And uh the guys would huddle around and [18:38] then he would teach us Zohar. I remember [18:40] he would teach us Zohar. [18:41] And I remember this like excitement, [18:43] like what's going to happen at midnight? [18:45] What ideas are we going to enter into? [18:47] But it wasn't like I'm going to learn [18:49] information and then later on it will be [18:50] helpful in my life. It was helpful in my [18:52] life, but there was actual experience [18:54] that was [18:55] happening in that moment live right now. [18:58] And you have to try it. You know, you [19:00] have to try this experience called [19:01] Talmud Torah. So I think those are the [19:03] two aspects that I often think about. [19:05] Torah for some practical benefit, right? [19:07] Talmud Torah [19:09] said. That's what the Gemara Kedushin [19:10] says. Talmud Torah, learning Torah [19:12] brings action. And then Talmud Torah for [19:15] its own sake. Learning Torah as its own [19:17] spiritual experience. And definitely the [19:19] mystics, you know, Rabbi Shimon bar [19:21] Yochai, he would sit in the cave. Is [19:22] that famous story where he literally [19:23] just sit and study non-stop. There's no [19:26] doubt that when he's in that cave, it's [19:28] not just learn Torah. So when he leaves [19:30] the cave, he'll know what to do. The [19:31] cave itself, being inside of there is an [19:34] experience of God. [19:35] >> Amazing. So you have the privilege to [19:37] teach women and men in Yeshivot and [19:40] Midrashot. [19:41] Um, is there a difference in Jewish [19:43] mystical teachings between women and [19:44] men? [19:45] >> It's a very good question. Um, I think [19:48] there is a fundamental difference. [19:51] Question is is that fundamental [19:53] difference so strong today? [19:56] I think theoretically there's a [19:57] fundamental difference. In other words, [19:58] if you read Kabbalistic books, we should [20:00] be honest, [20:01] there is very strong emphasis on men and [20:03] women women being different and feminine [20:05] aspects and masculine aspects and [20:08] So I do think on a theoretical [20:10] theoretical level, 100% [20:13] it would be a lie to say, no, really [20:14] they're the same. [20:15] But on a practical level, in other [20:17] words, I'm actually I deal with them. [20:18] I'm I'm I'm learning with them every [20:21] every day. Literally today I taught in [20:22] the morning in Yeshiva and then in the [20:24] afternoon in Midrash shot. I do think [20:26] that over time it's becoming less and [20:28] less noticeable the difference. And and [20:31] I've been teaching for almost 15 years [20:32] now in Midrash shot in Yeshiva. I think [20:34] it's becoming less and less noticeable [20:36] as the years go by even in my teaching. [20:38] And I don't know exactly [20:40] why that's happening, but it is [20:41] happening. And um I remember you know [20:44] sometimes in Yeshiva they'll make fun [20:46] and they'll say oh we learn better than [20:48] in Midrash and I always say to them I [20:50] teach in Midrash, they're better than [20:51] you. Like they're learning more serious [20:53] than you. They take more attention to [20:55] everything I say. They ask questions at [20:56] the end of the class. You guys [20:58] immediately after class run away and you [20:59] know want to go eat some food. [21:01] >> So you are saying there's a difference [21:02] just women are better? [21:04] >> I wasn't saying that but I but I but I [21:06] was saying that I often knock back men [21:08] who who immediately say oh we must be um [21:11] greater than them cuz cuz I'm I've [21:13] literally living that experience of of [21:16] of teaching them and then teaching them [21:17] and it's not that they're the same but I [21:19] just don't feel strong differences and [21:22] I'm sure there are differences. I'm just [21:23] not [21:24] uh spiritually attuned to be able to [21:26] pick up on them. And it would be [21:27] arrogant for me to say I know the [21:29] differences um you know on what exactly [21:31] is going on. I also think that there's [21:33] because of the generation we're in and [21:35] definitely because of the liberal and [21:36] and secular values that we are so [21:38] affected by it's becoming more and more [21:40] clear that people are very confused [21:42] about their identities um sexually and [21:45] what masculine energy is and what [21:46] feminine energy is. So I think that [21:48] we're in a very exciting time period [21:50] where literally in like writing a PhD [21:52] about what a man and a woman is. We [21:53] don't know. You know Simone de Beauvoir [21:56] a very famous feminist you know who who [21:58] talked a lot about um you know how women [22:01] are inferior. That's what she wrote [22:02] about. She said but I don't even know [22:03] what a woman is. [22:04] You know she wrote in her famous book [22:05] Second Sex said I don't even know what a [22:07] woman is. We have not even figured out [22:10] what the woman is. We have to figure [22:11] what that looks like. [22:13] Um we know what men are but we don't [22:14] know what women is. [22:15] So I think we're in a time period where [22:17] we're really just getting deeper and [22:19] deeper into that discussion and I'm [22:20] exciting to to see what the generation [22:23] will produce, what what of insights um [22:25] will come out of men women. And I would [22:26] just say the Rav Shagar wrote [22:28] um in one of his essays that he cuz he [22:30] also taught in Yeshivot and Midrashot, [22:32] and he said that he believed that the [22:34] Torah of Geulah is going to come out of [22:35] Midrashot and not Yeshivot. [22:37] >> The redemption [22:38] >> The Torah of redemption. And the reason [22:39] in his opinion, [22:41] and I think there is something to this, [22:42] that in Yeshivot it's often very um [22:45] stale because this is what you need to [22:47] learn and this is how many hours you [22:49] need to learn this and that. [22:51] Whereas in Midrashot it's it's quite [22:53] it's a new thing. It's fresh and there's [22:55] more room for different insights and [22:57] classes and [22:59] and classes on the Zohar and and [23:00] Kabbalah and Rav Kook and Rabbi Nachman. [23:03] Yet in the Yeshiva world, in the men's, [23:05] they're still kind of stuck on no, you [23:07] don't learn that. You only learn this. [23:09] So Rav Shagar was quite excited to see [23:10] what the Midrashot, what the women's, [23:12] you know, spiritual institution would [23:14] produce. And they just being cuz I'm a [23:16] part of it, it it is very exciting. It's [23:18] like wow, these students are so [23:19] incredibly insightful and deep [23:22] as well as the the Yeshivot, but it's [23:24] it's amazing. It's not so clear what is [23:25] the difference. [23:26] >> So what like when you when you work with [23:29] these women, these men of all ages [23:31] really, [23:32] what do you think is the biggest [23:33] obstacle to living a more spiritual [23:35] life? [23:36] >> Okay, well I think we should delineate [23:38] like just make a distinction between [23:39] religious and spiritual here. I think um [23:42] we can say what is the obstacle for them [23:43] becoming more religious in terms of [23:44] following laws within the Torah [23:47] um if you're a Jew. And then also what [23:49] makes what's the obstacles for making [23:51] them more spiritual, which would be, you [23:52] know, connecting to some higher purpose [23:54] and feeling of what we were talking [23:56] about before, that that almost [23:58] intangible, something you can't see but [24:00] you can feel and sense. So I think in [24:03] terms of religion, [24:04] at least my students who are [24:07] you know, gone through the system of a [24:10] lot of Western [24:11] wisdom and then they've studied Torah [24:13] also and that combination [24:16] um often is amazing but often confuses [24:18] them. I think what what is making an [24:19] obstacle for them is they feel like [24:22] religion is irrelevant to their life. [24:24] Um they don't struggle so much today [24:26] I've seen with is the Torah from God or [24:28] That's not one of their struggles. Um, [24:30] their question is is the Torah relevant? [24:33] Does it actually have anything to do [24:34] with me as a human being struggling with [24:36] love and happiness and depression and [24:39] all that [24:41] jazz, you know, all that stuff that's [24:42] really difficult for them. And once you [24:44] show them, even with Rav Kook, you know, [24:45] I spend so much time teaching Rav Kook, [24:47] I I can see why it opens them up because [24:49] they see here's a rabbi who really [24:51] speaks their language and is actually [24:53] helping them deal with like sadness and [24:55] jealousy and anger and arrogance [24:57] and loneliness. [24:59] And all of a sudden, once they start [25:01] respecting rabbis in general, then they [25:04] can go onto other parts of Torah. So [25:06] that's in terms of [25:07] an obstacle towards religion. They [25:08] really need to be shown how um the Torah [25:11] and this ancient tradition is relevant [25:13] to them. Not just that it's divine, but [25:15] that it's actually um relevant to their [25:17] life, that it will help them. [25:20] And then in terms of spirituality, I [25:21] think one of the obstacles unfortunately [25:22] is uh [25:24] we've become more and more materialistic [25:25] as the generation goes on and become [25:27] more and more addicted to anything from [25:30] our bodies to our food, um to alcohol, [25:34] to sex, to it's just we're so immersed [25:36] in materialism, to sport. And it's very [25:38] hard to um [25:40] pull yourself out of that material [25:42] world. And definitely for me, leaving [25:44] Australia and coming to Israel, enabled [25:46] me to do that because I felt [25:48] that I was so immersed in very [25:50] meaningful materialism in Australia. It [25:52] was beautiful. Um like very heavy sport [25:54] culture. Um and then coming to Israel, I [25:57] felt like the conversations were [25:58] different and the values we talked about [26:00] were different. And so I think that's [26:02] one of the main obstacles that you when [26:04] you're in a very [26:05] material culture, everything is about [26:08] sport, you know, careers, money, [26:11] um fashion, it is hard to pull yourself [26:13] out of it. Now coming to Israel, um and [26:16] I do really believe this um [26:18] opens people up to spirituality. I think [26:20] moving to Israel or even visiting Israel [26:23] does things to people's personalities [26:25] and souls that it doesn't matter if [26:26] you're 100 years in Australia, 100 years [26:28] in America, it wouldn't do. [26:30] Okay? Something about Israel, [26:33] is it the people? Is it something in the [26:35] air? Like the Gamara says, right? That [26:37] there's something in the air that makes [26:38] you wise. I think all of those things. [26:41] It's it's really a majestic place to be [26:43] in. It doesn't matter if you're a Jew or [26:44] a non-Jew. People feel it. [26:46] Okay? [26:46] >> So on a religious level you say it's [26:47] relevance and on a spiritual level you [26:50] say it's materialism. [26:51] >> Yeah. [26:51] >> And those are two journeys we all need [26:53] to really work through. [26:54] >> Yeah, and I and I when I say materialism [26:56] I mean like something which I think is [26:57] almost [26:58] impossible to work on unless you're [27:00] around a setting or people or an [27:01] environment that has made the center the [27:03] spirit and not just the body. [27:05] And um and I myself I would I really [27:08] admit my own flaws here. If I would go [27:09] back and live outside of Israel in [27:11] Australia I don't know how much I'd be [27:13] interested in mysticism. I don't know if [27:15] I'd be able to really pull myself out of [27:17] that intense culture of materialism and [27:19] that's not because it's bad there. It's [27:21] amazing, but it it has a different [27:23] focus. You know, you can kind of think [27:25] about Rabbi Heschel he used to say like [27:27] you go to an art gallery [27:29] and you experience art. [27:31] You know, you go to a to like a you know [27:33] like a concert you know go to see [27:35] Coldplay you know go to a concert and [27:37] you experience music. It opens you up to [27:39] music. So you you want to experience [27:40] spirituality you come to Israel. Israel [27:42] is the [27:43] the museum of spirituality. And once you [27:45] walk inside of Israel you feel something [27:47] different. It does something to you. The [27:49] conversations are different. And in that [27:51] sense I really think we need help. I [27:53] don't think we can do it alone in our [27:54] room. [27:55] Um and when we're humble and admit that [27:58] we can't do it alone and we come to Rav [27:59] Benji Levy and ask for help um or any [28:03] any great rabbi we have you have so many [28:04] great rabbis on this program and [28:06] teachers um I think it's not as hard as [28:10] it is when it's when we're on our on our [28:12] own. [28:12] >> So why did God create the world like in [28:14] the first place? Why put us through all [28:16] these things? [28:17] Why would he do it? [28:19] >> You're asking what's the purpose of the [28:20] universe? That's the frame you have that [28:22] question? [28:23] >> potentially, but also why why did God an [28:26] infinite being decide to create this [28:27] finite existence? [28:29] >> Okay. Well, I think the why versus the [28:31] what purpose is important to make a [28:33] distinction. The why we don't know, [28:35] okay? We have to be God to know why. [28:37] Um Rav David Aaron used to always say [28:38] that, you know, I just want to say just [28:40] cuz there's a there's a whole uh you [28:42] know series on mysticism, it's important [28:43] to realize Rav David Aaron is one of the [28:46] people opened up so many people to [28:48] mysticism in the English-speaking world. [28:50] It's not a small thing he did and there [28:52] are a lot of people who are in love with [28:53] Kabbalah and mysticism and God and [28:55] themselves and human beings because of [28:56] that rabbi. [28:57] So I remember I sat for a whole year [28:59] with him. It wasn't me by myself, there [29:00] was a group of us and I I just you know [29:03] every question I could think of. So I [29:05] remember that question came up Rav Benji [29:07] about [29:08] somebody said, you know, why did God [29:09] create the world? And I remember this [29:11] was the answer and this is what I I [29:12] believe to this day. [29:14] We can't know why God created the world. [29:16] That would be impossible. We would be [29:17] arrogant to say we know why. [29:19] But we can in true humility um say God [29:22] has revealed to us for what purpose he [29:25] has created the world and according to [29:27] at least Rav Cook, his understanding of [29:28] Kabbalah, he has created this universe [29:31] for us to grow [29:32] and for us to transform ourselves and [29:34] for us to overcome struggles and that [29:37] changing and transforming the universe [29:41] um and ourselves is the purpose of the [29:43] universe. So whenever there's suffering [29:45] and pain and struggles in my life, I [29:47] always say back to myself, [29:49] remember that the purpose of this [29:50] universe is for growth and this struggle [29:53] is a possible growth opportunity. Do I [29:55] want to turn it into a moment where I [29:57] play the victim [29:58] and get upset at the world cuz it's so [30:00] hard or do I want to turn it around and [30:01] say this is an opportunity for growth [30:03] and the bigger the struggle, the bigger [30:04] the growth. So [30:06] I think that's a very empowering way to [30:08] think about for what purpose God created [30:10] the universe. But why? [30:12] I think we should all be humble and say [30:16] to quote David Ha Melech, to you um you [30:19] know silence is praise. We should be [30:20] silent. [30:21] >> So does that imply that we have free [30:23] will and like that free will exists and [30:25] what is free will then? [30:27] >> It does imply we have free will and not [30:28] only do we have free will, we have too [30:30] much of it. It seems to be we could [30:31] destroy the whole world without free [30:33] will. It's a risk God took [30:35] and uh clearly the whole purpose is for [30:38] us to grow, so free will was the tool to [30:41] give us that. [30:41] >> But how's there free will if he knows [30:42] what we're going to do? [30:44] >> Okay. So the question and the paradox of [30:46] is there free will [30:48] versus [30:50] does God control everything? In all [30:52] paradoxical questions, the answer that [30:55] I've learned from my teachers and my [30:56] Kabbalistic teachers, you know, and Rav [30:58] David Aaron is definitely one of them, [31:00] the answer is yes, [31:01] which is it's not [31:03] we have free will or God controls the [31:05] world. It's we have free will and God [31:06] controls the world. How can that be? You [31:09] have to be humble and say they both [31:11] exist, yet we can't explain it. And and [31:13] to use Rabbi Blinds language, [31:19] in the place of God's knowledge, when I [31:22] when I say to myself God runs the world, [31:24] I shouldn't be in that moment trying to [31:26] say I have free will. And in the moment [31:28] where I say I have free will, I [31:29] shouldn't be trying to say also God runs [31:31] the world. A paradox doesn't have to be [31:34] I think of both paradoxical ideas always [31:36] at the same time. They can be different [31:39] parts of my mind that I access at [31:40] different time periods. So for example, [31:43] before I come to this, you know, this [31:45] interview, I say I have absolute free [31:47] will and I need to prepare for it and I [31:49] can think of what do I want to say and [31:51] how do I want to talk or what type of, [31:53] you know, persona I want to bring to it [31:55] and what type of clothes out. That's [31:56] free will. Do not use God as an alibi [31:58] and an escape going oh whatever happens [32:00] happens. So I should be in the dimension [32:02] of I have free will, completely, 100%. [32:05] And then after we're finished, [32:08] if I feel any feelings of regret or [32:09] guilt or why did I do that or why I [32:11] should have said that, [32:13] let go. [32:14] God runs the world. It was meant to be. [32:16] You put in your [32:18] your responsibility, your hard work. Now [32:21] you need to accept that there's a [32:22] dimension of existence that you have no [32:24] control over anymore [32:26] and to enter into that what the mystics [32:27] call [32:28] you know, being able to surrender. So I [32:30] think that's a really great way of [32:33] utilizing the paradox of free will [32:35] versus determinism [32:37] to our benefit. Now Rav Arush who who [32:39] wrote a great book on emunah, garden of [32:41] emunah, he says that the negative way to [32:44] use that paradox, in other words, the [32:46] the unhelpful way, the the way that [32:48] would hurt your life would be before you [32:49] do something, you say everything's from [32:51] God, I don't have to work hard. [32:53] And then after you do it and you failed [32:55] in it because you didn't work very hard, [32:56] you say, oh, it was my fault, I [32:58] shouldn't have done that and you beat [32:59] yourself up. [33:00] But if you flip it around, that is [33:02] really a very empowering way to think [33:04] about that paradox, which is before I do [33:06] things, I take 100% responsibility on [33:09] how I prepare and I'm a hard worker and [33:12] I don't make excuses. And then after the [33:14] action happened, [33:16] after the event happened, I need to let [33:17] go. I need to accept that God runs the [33:19] world and that will give you immense [33:21] responsibility to your personality and [33:23] also give you immense humility. [33:25] >> So God's running this world to a certain [33:27] end, so to speak, the end of history, [33:29] which is the times of Moshiach. [33:30] >> Yeah. [33:31] >> What do you think of when I say the word [33:32] Moshiach? What is Moshiach? What is this [33:34] time period? What is it going to be? [33:36] >> So Rav Cook says there are two types of [33:38] Moshiach. This is based on the Gemara. [33:39] There's Moshiach ben Yosef and there's [33:41] Moshiach ben David, right? The Messiah [33:44] of Joseph and the Messiah of David. And [33:47] according to Rav Cook, they're not just [33:49] two different people, they represent two [33:51] time periods. So Moshiach ben Yosef is [33:53] the time period according to Rav Cook [33:56] that all of humanity [33:58] and definitely the Jewish people [34:00] um let's stay with the Jewish people [34:01] first of all. All the Jewish people are [34:03] coming back to Israel and we're we're [34:05] rebuilding this country and rebuilding [34:07] our identity on a national level and [34:10] that could be anything from the army to [34:12] the economy to the yeshiva to the [34:14] midrashot to our identity. That's [34:16] Moshiach ben Yosef, okay? Coming back to [34:19] our land. [34:20] Moshiach ben David is spreading our [34:22] light to the world. [34:23] Okay? The second phase of the Messiah, [34:25] of the Messiah, where we actually are in [34:27] Or HaGoyim and we actually add [34:29] and give and don't just come back to [34:32] ourselves. A good way to think about it, [34:34] Rav Cook says, is you need hitbodedut [34:37] and then [34:38] you can give yourself to the world. [34:39] Hitbodedut it spending time alone. And [34:42] then once you have recharged yourself, [34:44] then you can give yourself, and you [34:46] should give yourself to the community. [34:47] So I think that's a great way to think [34:48] about the the time period of the [34:50] Messiah. The Messiah [34:51] is a person, but it's also a time [34:54] period. And if you want to say, yeah, [34:55] but it's a person, so, you know, where's [34:56] the person? I think Martin Luther King [34:58] Jr. is kind of a good way to think about [34:59] it, that he is a person [35:02] that represented more than himself. In [35:04] other words, during the civil rights [35:06] movement, he was an actual real person [35:07] you could have met him, but the time [35:09] period of the civil rights movement in [35:10] America [35:12] is much bigger than an individual, and [35:13] it actually matters what happened and [35:15] not just what he did in his life. So I [35:17] think that's a good way to think about [35:18] the Messiah that Messiah [35:21] David will be individual people that [35:23] will um be a catalyst um for some bigger [35:27] time period in history, but [35:29] ultimately it's not about the [35:30] individual. It's about the consciousness [35:32] and changes that happened during that [35:33] time period. [35:34] >> So where does the state of Israel fit [35:35] into this? Is it a part of the [35:38] sort of final redemption? [35:39] >> So the answer is yes. Like I said [35:41] before, Messiah [35:42] Joseph, the first stage of the Messiah [35:44] and the first Messiah is coming back to [35:46] Israel. And And for Rav Kook, I mean, [35:48] it's a very controversial idea of his, [35:50] but when Theodor Herzl um when he died, [35:53] they asked Rav Kook to get up and give a [35:55] eulogy. And he said, uh, I don't know if [35:57] I should do it or not. All the religious [35:59] people in his time period, the Haredim [36:01] were very against, don't get up and do a [36:03] eulogy for Herzl. He was a secular [36:05] Zionist. [36:06] And then all the secular Zionists said [36:07] to Rav Kook, you should get up. He's the [36:10] most important Zionist in, you know. [36:12] And so what did Rav Kook do? He got up [36:13] and he gave a eulogy about how the [36:16] Messiah Joseph had just died. [36:18] >> Wow. [36:19] >> And he never said Herzl's name even once [36:21] in the eulogy, but everybody knew what [36:23] he was talking about. And he really [36:24] believed, and I think this is a powerful [36:25] way to think of [36:27] your question, which is the first phase [36:29] of the Messiah we are inside of right [36:31] now. Um Theodor Herzl was the catalyst. [36:34] It's not about him. It's about where we [36:35] are right now. And he [36:37] really began this new time period in [36:39] history. And Hashem, you know, [36:41] used him to bring us back to Israel. And [36:44] we're in a remarkable time period. I [36:45] love living in Israel. The army, um, the [36:49] economy, the language, he he revival of [36:51] Hebrew, the amazing [36:53] that we are around it, the fact that I [36:55] can speak to Jews of all types, that is [36:58] the beginning of Messiah and that really [36:59] is connected to [37:01] on the other hand to say this is what we [37:04] were praying for for thousands of years [37:05] and that's it. [37:06] No, there's more. And so that's what the [37:08] second stage of the Messiah is and [37:10] that's a more universal. So you could [37:11] almost say the first stage is national, [37:13] the Jewish people reviving their nation [37:15] and then the second phase of the Messiah [37:17] and the Messiah [37:19] is reviving and redeeming and healing [37:21] the whole world [37:23] So you're going to the whole world here [37:25] and we see our role within that. What is [37:28] the greatest challenge facing the world [37:29] today? [37:31] >> The greatest challenge that the whole [37:32] world is facing, I think there's a [37:34] number. [37:36] Um, [37:37] I think materialism actually is a very [37:39] big problem. Um, to go back to our [37:40] discussion before, I think the world is [37:42] saturating materialism and it's [37:44] exhausting for people and it feels so [37:46] empty to believe that your career is the [37:48] only thing that matters [37:49] and making money [37:51] and the way your body looks and the way [37:53] people look at your body and putting [37:55] yourself online. So that materialistic [37:58] um, [37:59] almost sickness that people are affected [38:01] by and infected by, I think that is [38:04] destroying people. Okay? People are [38:06] mentally unstable. It's leading to so [38:09] much chaos emotionally to people. So I [38:11] think that's number one. The world is [38:13] saturating materialism and we are so [38:15] affluent. We have so much materialism [38:16] today as you know, Rabbi Twerski used to [38:18] say that we have so much not to complain [38:21] about. We have the most, you know, [38:22] affluent society, you know, in all [38:24] history we have so much food. We have [38:26] more food than most kings would ever [38:27] have. We have more clothes than any, you [38:29] know, royal people would ever have and [38:30] our houses are bigger and [38:32] and yet we're so sad and depressed and [38:34] and [38:35] and that just shows you that people are [38:36] so misguided and they're so stuck on [38:39] things that don't matter that it's [38:40] causing them to do disgusting things to [38:42] literally their own children. [38:44] And so I think [38:46] to really get us back to purpose and [38:48] meaning and spirituality, what Victor [38:50] Frankl said in Man's Search for Meaning, [38:51] I think that's the number one. If we [38:53] could really get people back to purpose [38:55] and meaning, [38:57] wow, that would be big. Now, number two [38:58] I would say is [39:00] um on a national level, cuz that's on an [39:02] individual level. I think the national [39:04] level, antisemitism, the world is [39:06] falling apart with antisemitism and the [39:09] Jewish people end up always being in the [39:11] center of the attention in every [39:12] generation and it seems like we're here [39:14] again. [39:14] And I think the world is is got to has [39:17] got to heal themselves of this [39:18] antisemitism and it's a disaster and [39:20] it's affecting everybody and anybody who [39:23] has got this sickness inside themselves [39:24] that they hate the Jews or they have [39:25] some negativity towards the Jewish [39:27] people and and we have a real [39:30] responsibility to um you know Israel [39:33] advocacy to actually speak up and say [39:36] who the Jewish people are, what it [39:38] actually means to live in Israel, invite [39:40] people to come to Israel. And I do [39:42] believe almost like like since it's [39:43] about mysticism, there will be a real [39:45] effect on the universe, a ripple effect [39:46] that if the world [39:48] understands and respects the Jewish [39:51] people, [39:52] it will eventually um it will have a [39:54] ripple effect back on them and it will [39:56] bring positivity to their life. And now [39:58] obviously you could say this is such a [39:59] strange argument. It's one tiny nation. [40:01] What how does this have to do with the [40:02] whole world is falling apart? [40:04] But again and again in history the [40:06] Jewish people end up not even us wanting [40:08] to be. We just end up being the center [40:11] of attention and you know the World War [40:12] II, [40:13] you know the the Nazis and the [40:14] Holocaust, why are we being pursued and [40:17] afflicted? [40:19] Picking on other people. [40:21] But it ends up being the Jewish people [40:22] and and when the world respects the [40:24] Jewish people then then the Nazis go [40:26] away. [40:27] >> The how is modernity [40:29] sort of after that time period coming [40:31] into today? How has modernity affected [40:33] Jewish mysticism? [40:35] >> I think modernity has made Jewish [40:37] mysticism harder on the one hand and [40:39] easier on the other hand. On on the one [40:41] hand it's harder because you know the [40:43] beginning of the Renaissance period and [40:45] modernity is all about reason. [40:47] Um [40:49] so many famous philosophers talked about [40:51] the importance of reason, you know, but [40:52] Immanuel Kant was probably one of the [40:54] most famous. [40:55] And reason is something which mysticism [40:59] challenges. [41:01] So the more you take reason and logic as [41:04] the center of the way you think, the [41:06] harder it is for you to accept that [41:08] there's something that you can't see, [41:10] um, that you can't touch, [41:12] but is real. And it's so real that you [41:14] would willing to sacrifice your life [41:15] for. You know, the Jewish people have [41:16] sacrificed their life for this [41:17] tradition, [41:19] which is in many ways very mystical. [41:21] Um, [41:22] now that's how it makes it difficult [41:24] modernity because it's so focused on [41:25] reason and isn't able to let go. [41:28] Um, on the other hand, postmodernism, [41:31] which is actually a part of modernism, [41:33] right? I think they're very [41:34] interconnected. Postmodernism is almost [41:36] like modernism getting to its logical [41:39] end and then coming back and criticizing [41:41] itself. In the name of reason, [41:44] which is a modern idea, in the name of [41:46] reason we can critique reason. [41:48] And mystics are very, very rational at [41:51] the end of the day. I've studied Rav [41:53] Kook was such a rational person. He [41:55] loved philosophy. He studied so much um, [41:58] Maimonides, Rambam, but he also was [42:00] deeply affected by the Zohar. So how can [42:02] someone who's so deeply affected by [42:03] logic um, appreciate something which is [42:05] beyond the logic? Because the logic can [42:07] critique logic, okay? Rav Kook has this [42:09] one piece um, where he talks about [42:13] that everybody needs to do a [42:14] Now [42:15] is when you like deny your body to eat [42:17] something. So he says sometimes you need [42:19] to deny your mind. Your mind wants to [42:22] say but give me your explanation and you [42:24] need to say to it, [42:25] there are some things that are true even [42:27] though they can't be explained. And um, [42:29] so I think modernism and definitely [42:31] leading into postmodernism, this is a [42:32] Rav Shagar idea, [42:34] um, actually will enable us to get back [42:36] into mysticism more than in any time [42:38] period because now we can use our own [42:40] reason to critique the limits of reason. [42:43] You know, for example, love. [42:45] There is no way based on logic. Just use [42:47] your mind to really explain the [42:48] phenomena of love. That would be a [42:51] ridiculous belief that if I could [42:52] actually, you know, analyze love, it's a [42:54] perfect analysis, and now I know how to [42:56] love somebody perfectly because I've [42:57] analyzed it,I've read a book, now all [42:59] love will make sense and I'll be able to [43:01] be amazing in every relationship. We [43:03] know that love is mysterious. Every poet [43:05] wrote about it, every musician wrote [43:06] about it, and it doesn't matter how much [43:08] you analyze it, it continues to baffle [43:10] people how mysterious it is. So love [43:13] is something which has circular [43:14] reasoning, which is I love you because I [43:16] love you. [43:17] And it is what it is. I can't explain [43:19] where it comes from, but I know it it's [43:21] there. And whatever analysis you give, [43:24] it's always weak in comparison to the [43:26] actual phenomena. [43:27] So I I think that modernism actually, [43:29] and this is the great potential of [43:31] postmodernism, um if we use all the [43:35] tools of modernism, we can actually put [43:38] reason where it's supposed to be, which [43:39] is reason can done can do some things, [43:41] it can explain some things, and also we [43:43] should be able to have the logic to be [43:45] able to say and reason also is faulty [43:47] when it comes to trying to explain love [43:49] and music and art and prayer and [43:51] meditation um and unity and all these [43:54] incredible things that animate us, um we [43:56] can't actually use reason to get there. [43:59] But we can use our mind to critique the [44:01] reason. And in that way, I think that we [44:03] don't have to be um threatened by [44:05] modernism or postmodernism. We can see [44:07] it actually finally we have language um [44:10] that can actually uh legitimize [44:12] mysticism. And even Immanuel Kant, [44:14] who was such a famous um advocate for [44:16] reason, said um that there is something [44:19] beyond reason. Um [44:22] we may not be able to explain it, but it [44:24] does exist. And everything that we are [44:27] experiencing is from the subjective [44:29] point of view, but there is something [44:30] beyond the subjective. And we know it's [44:32] there even if we can't comprehend it, we [44:34] can experience it. And I can feel a [44:36] connection to you right now even if I [44:37] can't put my finger on where it's coming [44:39] from. And I think that that's very [44:41] exciting. And also I think that as [44:43] myself, someone who grew up in, you [44:44] know, Western education as well as [44:46] religious education, I don't want to [44:48] have to say everything I learned in the [44:50] Western world was wrong and everything I [44:52] learned in mysticism is right. I think [44:53] that feels very piecemeal in its truth. [44:56] I am there's some things are right, some [44:57] things are wrong. [44:58] I always very attracted to rabbis and [45:00] thinkers who are able to show a holistic [45:02] point of view. And I think mysticism is [45:05] holistic. [45:06] >> Well, that was also Rav Kook integrated [45:08] everything holistic approach. [45:11] In terms of um you know the universe and [45:13] the particular in this holistic way [45:15] there's sometimes a particular voice. [45:17] You know we speak in different ways. Is [45:19] that true of Jewish mysticism as opposed [45:21] to other mystical traditions? Is there [45:24] something unique about Jewish mysticism? [45:26] >> 100% there's something unique. Now I'm [45:28] not a historian of Jewish mysticism, so [45:30] I don't want to try and say these are [45:31] the differences between you know [45:32] Christian, Muslim, Jewish mysticism. I [45:34] have studied other mysticisms. I've [45:36] studied [45:37] from Christianity and Rumi from Islam. [45:40] Um so I have I have read and seen that [45:42] there are universal values. All the [45:44] mystics talk about love [45:46] prayer [45:47] unity. So in that sense there really is [45:49] a universal language of the mystics and [45:51] they are often [45:53] uh saying very similar things. On the [45:55] other hand, there's no doubt about it [45:57] that the Jewish mystics um [45:59] choose a different lifestyle. [46:02] They get married. They have kids. [46:04] Um they eat a lot of food. [46:06] Okay the Kabbalists um took food very [46:09] seriously. They took clothes very [46:10] seriously. You know the Ari Zal [46:13] talks about how important clothes are on [46:14] Shabbat. And he even has this one [46:16] amazing [46:17] um description where he says every [46:19] single thing that you wear on Shabbat [46:21] should be different to the week. Every [46:22] piece of clothing, your shoes, your [46:23] socks, your pants, your shirt. [46:24] How materialistic of you Ari Zal. Why [46:26] don't you give me some meditation to do? [46:28] He will give you a meditation, but right [46:30] now he's talking about clothes. [46:31] So I think that Jewish mysticism takes [46:33] the material world very seriously and [46:35] this is in line with Judaism [46:37] that [46:38] the Jewish tradition is inherently a [46:41] physical and spiritual religion. [46:44] Um so the mysticism that comes out of [46:46] Judaism is also very connected to the [46:49] physical. And you know there's all these [46:50] phrases in Kabbalah like [46:54] which is raising up the sparks of the [46:56] physical serving God through the [46:58] physical. [46:59] Ultimately, if you actually are around [47:01] Kabbalists, which I have spent a good [47:02] amount of time, [47:04] um they are very physical people, and [47:06] they take the physical world and the [47:07] food they eat and the clothes they wear [47:09] and the family [47:11] um that they have very seriously, and [47:13] they're not often the pixies. So I think [47:15] that there's something incredibly [47:16] grounding about Jewish mysticism, which [47:18] for me is as a family man is very [47:21] attractive. That I don't want a [47:23] spiritual system that will tell me to [47:25] neglect my family and neglect my body. [47:29] And for many years I do think that I was [47:31] going in that direction of doesn't [47:32] matter what my body looks like, it [47:34] doesn't matter [47:35] if I if I have a job, if I have money. [47:37] The main thing is my connection to some [47:39] you know spiritual power. And over the [47:41] years I've I've moved away from that and [47:43] I've realized that's actually not the [47:44] Jewish tradition. That was something [47:45] strange that I was doing to the Jewish [47:47] tradition. That is not actually it. [47:49] And it doesn't matter if you're um [47:51] whatever stream you're in in Judaism, if [47:52] it's modern Orthodox, Haredi, Hasidish, [47:55] ultimately they're all coming back to [47:57] spirituality within the physical. [47:59] And it's a very exciting thing to [48:01] realize that that is a big contribution [48:03] Jewish mysticism has to play in the [48:04] world, a certain grounding, the body, [48:07] the physical, the family, um drinking [48:10] wine on Friday night. You know what what [48:12] does that have to do with mysticism? [48:13] Shouldn't we be a monks staying away [48:14] from wine? [48:16] I was just learning this this morning [48:17] with my students in Yeshiva, how the [48:19] Gemara talks about the dangers of wine. [48:21] And then immediately on the same page it [48:23] talks about how powerful wine is and how [48:25] helpful it is and how you can use it in [48:27] a holy way. This is something unique to [48:28] the Jewish tradition. [48:30] >> So [48:31] do you have to be religious to learn [48:32] Jewish mysticism? [48:34] >> Uh it's a very good question. I I think [48:36] that's a question in general about [48:38] Judaism, but we can apply it to [48:39] mysticism. I I don't think it's all [48:41] nothing. [48:42] I don't think that the Torah and Jewish [48:45] mysticism ever says [48:47] unless you do all of it you can't do [48:48] some of it. It's a ladder of observance. [48:50] You can think of it rungs in a ladder. I [48:52] do think that the more you do the more [48:55] you experience what each detail is [48:57] actually about. So if you're you know, [48:59] just meditating based on some Ariza, [49:02] kabbalistic mantra, but you don't keep [49:04] Shabbat, I don't think you'll really [49:06] understand what that meditation is all [49:08] about and you won't really be able to do [49:09] it. And you know, if I say, you know [49:11] what, I'm not going to put on tefillin, [49:13] but I'll meditate about the ideas of [49:14] tefillin, well, you won't really be able [49:16] to understand what the ideas of tefillin [49:18] are about. So I think that the answer is [49:21] you should say to yourself not yet. This [49:22] is a phrase Franz Rosenzweig used to say [49:24] a lot. He was a famous Jewish German [49:26] philosopher and he would say he was [49:28] doing chuva, he was becoming more [49:29] religious. [49:31] And people would say to him, oh, so [49:32] you're about chuva, you must be doing [49:34] all the mitzvot. Why aren't you putting [49:36] on tefillin? He wasn't putting on [49:37] tefillin yet. And he said not yet. [49:41] I am going to put on tefillin. I'm just [49:42] not ready yet. I think that's a really [49:44] empowering way and an honest way that [49:46] you should say to yourself if you're [49:47] someone who is studying mysticism and [49:49] you're not ready to do all the halachot [49:51] and all the mitzvot, but there are parts [49:54] of Kabbalah that you're very excited [49:55] about, you should teach your mouth [49:57] to never say I won't do the rest of the [49:59] Torah. [50:01] I don't care about organized religion. I [50:02] only care about mysticism. You should [50:03] say not yet. [50:05] Right now, this part of mysticism is [50:07] really exciting to me, but you never [50:09] know in the future those other parts [50:12] of Torah and mitzvot [50:14] may actually come into my life and I'm [50:17] going to wait for them and they'll be [50:19] there in the right time and God [50:21] surprises us. [50:22] And even we who thinks we know ourselves [50:25] in five years are completely different [50:26] people. [50:28] So that's I think a more honest answer [50:29] you should say. And in that way I would [50:31] say we should never ever criticize and [50:34] insult people who are learning just a [50:36] little bit of Kabbalah and say, oh, you [50:38] know, you're not doing all the mitzvot, [50:39] therefore what you're doing is a waste [50:40] of time. I think that is [50:42] a very superficial way to look at [50:44] spirituality. [50:45] >> Is it is it dangerous, Jewish mysticism? [50:49] >> Is it dangerous? I think that every idea [50:51] is dangerous when it's taken the wrong [50:52] way. That what Rav Cook says. He says in [50:54] the [50:55] that every idea when it's taken in the [50:57] wrong way is dangerous. The Torah in in [51:00] Gemara Kiddushin even says that the [51:01] Torah can either be a [51:03] or a [51:04] It can be a [51:05] you know, a [51:06] is is a medicine for you that helps you [51:09] or it can be a poison that can ruin you. [51:11] So I think the Kabbalah can ruin you and [51:13] it can mess with your life. It can make [51:14] you go crazy, but it can also save you [51:17] and heal you and turn you into the most [51:19] selfless giving person. So I think that [51:22] in that sense, every idea can be taken [51:24] in the right way and the wrong way, but [51:25] I do think there is something uniquely [51:27] dangerous about Kabbalah from being [51:28] really honest. And I think the reason [51:30] why it's uniquely more dangerous than [51:32] other things is because it talks [51:34] about unity a lot. [51:35] And things that talk about unity and [51:37] oneness, you often get rid of [51:38] boundaries. And boundaries are very [51:40] important. [51:41] Okay? Boundaries like your body and my [51:42] body. Okay? I'm not allowed to touch [51:44] your body unless you want me to touch [51:45] it. I'm not allowed to go near yours. [51:47] That's yours. This is mine. That's your [51:49] money. This is my money. Boundaries is [51:51] in many ways the materialistic world. So [51:53] when you start entering into the more [51:54] mystical and Kabbalistic, everything is [51:56] one, there's divine in everything, we're [51:58] really interconnected, there's a unique [52:00] danger of people saying, ah, that [52:03] boundary isn't a real boundary in that [52:04] person's body, you know, I'm allowed to [52:06] touch. So I do think if you look at the [52:07] history of Kabbalah, there were people [52:09] who um made this mistake. [52:12] And I don't think it's um [52:14] responsible for me to say, oh, you know, [52:16] there's no dangers in it or it's just [52:17] the same as other dangers. Yeah, there [52:18] is a unique danger in it, but as Rav [52:20] Cook said, [52:22] every single thing has dangers and if [52:24] you go about it in a mature way, for the [52:26] sake of [52:28] great growth that you want to connect to [52:30] a greater purpose, I think um you and [52:33] you're around the right people with the [52:34] right teachers, [52:35] I think um you'll get to the right [52:36] place. And also uh like Rav Cook thinks [52:39] that not everybody needs to learn [52:40] Kabbalah. [52:41] So people who aren't drawn to it and [52:43] attracted to it, [52:45] you don't have to learn it. You don't [52:47] have to study it. And the people who are [52:49] deeply in need of it, [52:50] um those people should go towards it, [52:53] but they should be humble when they go [52:54] towards it. They should say, you know [52:55] what? I'm going to go with a teacher. [52:57] I'm going to be studying it with a [52:58] mentor and little by little I'm going to [53:01] do it in a mature way and then it will [53:03] enhance my life. [53:04] >> So [53:04] >> how is it enhanced your life? Let's [53:06] think specifically about relationships. [53:09] Is there any like very practical [53:11] personal ways that you can say with my [53:12] children or with my spouse or with my [53:14] friends with my students with my parents [53:16] that that it's influenced your [53:18] relationships? [53:19] >> Okay, so I really do think that Kabbalah [53:22] is immensely practical. I mentioned it [53:24] just before that we started the [53:25] interview that Rav Cook was this [53:27] incredible mystic. [53:30] And he really he says many times in his [53:32] writings [53:33] Kabbalah and this is him is my main [53:35] identity in life. [53:36] Now if anybody looks it up on Wikipedia, [53:38] you'll see that he was the chief rabbi [53:39] of Israel, that he was part of the [53:41] Balfour Declaration helping to to to [53:43] create it. He was immensely political [53:45] figure. [53:46] And so how are you a mystic? So this is [53:48] a good example of people who apply [53:51] mysticism in such a practical way. It [53:53] affects the decision making um the way [53:55] they talk to people, the way they act. [53:58] So in terms of Rav Cook, [54:00] I could analyze it forever and ever how [54:01] it impacted the way he treated people [54:03] and there was unity and he didn't insult [54:05] people even if he disagreed with them. [54:06] So I would also say in my own life [54:08] the more I study Kabbalah and and and [54:10] Ba'al HaSulam um Rav Ashlag who who is [54:13] so much about giving and not taking, I [54:15] think that has helped me a lot. [54:17] And let's take the example of my kids. [54:21] So many times I'm talking to them [54:23] and [54:24] and I think to myself, you know, here's [54:26] an opportunity to give to them. [54:28] I could take from them. I could say, you [54:30] know, why aren't you doing it like I [54:31] want it? This is the way I want [54:34] my house to be. This is the way I think [54:36] you should be educated and there's a lot [54:37] of I. And the Kabbalah keeps making me [54:39] return to at least the Ba'al HaSulam [54:41] that [54:42] how can I be a giver in this situation? [54:44] How can I actually not put myself in the [54:47] middle but, you know, how can I give to [54:49] my kids? What do they need that I could [54:51] actually give them that I have the [54:52] unique ability in this situation to give [54:54] to them? If it could be in school um how [54:57] can I help you with school work? I want [54:59] to be a giver. I don't want to be a [55:00] taker in the relationship. Definitely [55:01] throughout history, parents were takers. [55:03] You know, we don't have to go so far [55:05] about um to get to child rights. You [55:07] know, children were abused by their [55:08] parents throughout history. That's why [55:10] they make child rights. So the Kabbalah [55:11] is always reminding me, [55:13] why don't you be a giver in this [55:14] relationship? Don't expect from them. Be [55:16] a giver. And I know your father as well, [55:18] you know, you come home [55:20] they just jump on you and they want [55:21] every single thing. Give me this, give [55:23] me this, give me this. And you're [55:24] exhausted. [55:25] You are. You're absolutely exhausted. [55:26] You just came home from work. And to [55:28] enter into that giving mindset, which [55:30] is, you know, the [55:31] main ideology, which is how can I be a [55:33] giver and not a taker, [55:34] which is to emulate God, who is the [55:36] greatest giver, [55:37] I should set my intentions before I walk [55:39] into the room. [55:40] And before I walk into the house, then I [55:41] should say to myself, how can I be a [55:43] giver right now to my kids? [55:45] Okay, they're going to want things from [55:46] me. Instead of feeling upset because I [55:49] want time for myself, you know what? [55:50] I'll get time for myself later tonight [55:51] when they go to sleep. [55:53] Hopefully I go to sleep. [55:56] Um [55:57] how can I be a giver? What can I I'm [55:58] here to serve you. You know what Cook [55:59] used to end off his letters [56:03] I am a [56:04] servant of a holy people and a holy [56:06] land. How can I be a giver? So I think [56:08] in that way mysticism can turn me, and [56:10] it does turn me into a giver. Also with [56:12] my students, [56:13] I think to myself often I walk into the [56:15] room, [56:16] I'm not the center. [56:18] Stop making yourself the center. It [56:19] doesn't matter what you've done in your [56:20] life up until now. How can you be in [56:22] service of these people in front of me? [56:24] And I think that's a really practical [56:26] way for Kabbalah to affect the dynamics [56:27] of my relationships. And then in terms [56:29] of prayer, because I think really [56:31] mysticism affects my prayers so much. [56:34] Wow, when I'm praying, I need to let go [56:36] more. [56:37] Because mysticism spends a lot of time [56:38] working on that you are a [56:41] you know, this tiny speck within this [56:43] universe, within this [56:45] infinite energy. And sometimes when I [56:46] pray, I have to remind myself, okay, I [56:49] want things, I want things, I want [56:50] things, but maybe I can change the [56:51] prayer around a little bit. Hashem, help [56:53] me accept that you run the world, that I [56:55] don't always run the world. Let go. [56:58] There are things happening to me right [56:59] now that have nothing to do with me. [57:01] Or at least they they I'm not in control [57:03] of them. So I have to stop playing the [57:05] victim like, oh, why did that happen? [57:07] Why did that happen? Some things are not [57:08] in my control. Hashem knows why they're [57:10] happening. In that sense, mysticism it [57:12] can be very therapeutic because I can [57:13] really accept my life just as it is. Rav [57:16] Shagar used to always say [57:19] Self-acceptance [57:21] is therapeutic. When you can accept [57:22] yourself and say this is the way Hashem, [57:24] God, the Ein Sof made me, [57:27] you have you don't have to you know try [57:29] and be something you're not. And this is [57:30] the body I was given. [57:32] This is the name I was given. That's the [57:34] country I was born in. I don't have to [57:35] try and be someone I'm not. [57:37] Um and there's something very [57:38] therapeutic about saying Hashem is the [57:40] source of creation. [57:42] He has made me exactly the way he wanted [57:44] me to be. This is the person I'm [57:46] supposed to be. This is the [57:48] relationships I'm supposed to have in my [57:49] life. And to really accept with a deep [57:52] trust that it's going to be okay. [57:55] >> So we've had incredible 18 questions, [57:58] but [57:58] I feel like we've talked about Jewish [58:00] mysticism and you've integrated so many [58:02] sources. But I think for the last one, I [58:05] just want to ask you to share a [58:06] teaching. [58:07] What is one Jewish mystical teaching [58:09] that you take with you that inspires [58:11] you, that animates you, or that's just [58:13] on your mind right now? [58:15] >> Okay. [58:16] So this is um [58:18] again, I keep bringing up Rav Kook [58:19] because I think it's important to quote [58:21] your teachers and not act as if you made [58:22] up these ideas, you know. Kabbalah is [58:24] literally from the word to receive. So [58:26] Rav Kook teaches um he has a lot of [58:28] chapters um and writings about love. [58:32] And um [58:33] and he has this one piece in [58:36] where he says, when you see somebody [58:39] who really hurts you and it really [58:41] really has done something extremely [58:43] painful to you, [58:44] you need to say to yourself, [58:46] their action [58:49] is not the same as their essence. Their [58:51] essence is their soul [58:53] and their pure light of God. [58:55] But their action is what I'm angry at. I [58:57] need to separate their essence from [58:58] their action. [58:59] And the more I do that, it doesn't mean [59:02] I have to forgive every single second, [59:04] but it means I can stop pursuing the [59:07] person and focus a little bit on the [59:09] messenger. Hashem has sent this action [59:12] to me. Why is this action in my life? [59:14] Why did he put this in my life? There [59:15] must be a reason why I'm going for this [59:17] right now. [59:18] And to actually see maybe this negative [59:20] thing is coming to teach me something, [59:21] coming to give me something. So that [59:23] will enable me number one to take the [59:24] message and not just focus on the [59:25] person. That person is such a bad [59:27] person, they're an evil person. How dare [59:28] them? [59:29] And two, when I am trying to heal my [59:30] relationship with them, I can say, you [59:32] know what? Maybe that action I'm angry, [59:35] but I'd have to be angry at their [59:36] essence. And Rav Kook goes again and [59:39] again to this theme because he thinks [59:40] that we often confuse this. We often [59:42] think that someone's action, their bad [59:43] action is their essence. So let's say, [59:45] you know, somebody gets angry, doesn't [59:48] mean they're an angry person in their [59:49] essence. Someone [59:51] acted lazy and came late. Doesn't mean [59:54] they're a lazy person in their essence. [59:55] And again, we don't have to forgive the [59:57] floor, but we have to separate the floor [59:59] from their essence and say they made a [60:01] mistake. I'm going to give them the [60:02] opportunity to improve their action, but [60:04] their essence I want to continue giving [60:06] them opportunities to change. And really [60:08] when you believe that somebody has a [60:09] good essence inherently, it means that [60:12] you're giving them second chances. [60:13] You're giving them opportunities to [60:14] surprise you because they're going to [60:15] surprise themselves. Now I want to now [60:17] flip it around just to make it really [60:18] balanced. Rav Kook has another piece [60:20] where he says that there's a danger to [60:21] this idea. [60:23] What's the danger to just looking at [60:24] somebody whose essence is good and just [60:27] their action was bad? He says the danger [60:29] is is you forgive them too much. [60:32] And to use like a very, you know, [60:34] practical example, if I say Hamas, [60:37] your essence is good, it's just their [60:39] actions are bad, well I may I might be [60:41] too lenient with them and therefore I [60:44] won't actually deal with them the way I [60:45] need to deal with them in order to stop [60:46] the evil actions they're doing. So Rav [60:48] Kook has this amazing piece that's also [60:50] in the [60:51] where he says at the beginning when [60:53] somebody does something bad to, it could [60:54] be incredibly cruel like Hamas or it [60:56] could be just something [60:58] small like somebody who's, you know, [60:59] who's rude to you. [61:01] At the beginning you need to actually [61:02] say that person [61:05] is a dangerous person, is a negative [61:07] person, is an actual person. You say it [61:08] out loud to yourself or it could be in [61:10] your mind. That person is dangerous. [61:12] Hamas are dangerous, not their actions, [61:13] them. [61:15] Later on, after you've protected [61:17] yourself from that dangerous person, [61:20] then you can now analyze. And you can [61:23] make a distinction between their actions [61:24] versus their essence. But at the [61:26] beginning Rav Cook says you need [61:28] like in the name of mysticism, you need [61:30] to actually defend yourself. [61:33] There is a person out there who's trying [61:34] to hurt you. [61:35] And you need to be realistic in the way [61:37] you use mysticism because if you use [61:38] mysticism in an irresponsible way, it [61:40] could lead to you forgiving [61:42] um and being, you know, irresponsible in [61:44] the way you protect yourself from very [61:46] dangerous people. And I And I come back [61:48] to that idea that I said before, the one [61:50] of the unique dangers of mysticism, [61:52] even though I love it, is that people [61:54] often um because they're so passionate [61:56] about unity and the oneness and the [61:58] goodness, that they won't have healthy [61:59] boundaries. [62:01] And when there is a really dangerous [62:02] person in front of you, [62:03] even if it's true their essence isn't [62:05] dangerous, right now they're acting out [62:06] in danger. [62:07] And you need to be realistic and say [62:09] right now that's a dangerous person. [62:11] Protect yourself from them. [62:13] Do whatever you need to do. And then [62:14] later on, when you're really trying to [62:16] heal or um think of them in a more [62:18] positive way, then you can make a [62:19] distinction between their essence and [62:21] their actions. [62:22] >> Well, I'm going to flip it one last time [62:23] to conclude and say [62:25] I've known you for a number of decades [62:27] now from all around the world. We've got [62:30] to educate together. We've been on stage [62:31] together, performed together, and we've [62:33] had these opportunities in Australia, [62:35] Israel. And your actions and your [62:37] essence are both holy and that's why we [62:39] call you the holy Rav. [62:40] So thank you for shedding light in such [62:42] a beautiful way, being such a conduit of [62:45] Rav Cook in this world through your [62:46] writings, through your teachings. Um [62:48] there are few experts in the world on [62:50] your level. And it's incredible that [62:51] you've been able to expose him to such a [62:53] broader audience. And we just um hope [62:56] and pray that you continue to make [62:58] mysticism practical in the way that you [63:00] do your day-to-day life in every single [63:02] action. And we thank you so much for the [63:04] amazing work. [63:04] >> Thank you for having me. [63:05] >> Thank you.