ProIsrael

Can ChatGPT Become a Rabbi?

18Forty
18Forty1.2K views • 16 likes • 2 comments3 days ago • 1 hour and 6 min

Chapters & Summary

Host David Bashkin introduces the 1840 podcast and its focus on exploring modern sensibilities alongside traditional Jewish ideas. The episode will examine the intersection between artificial intelligence and halaka (Jewish law), investigating how modernity shapes religious life.

Bashkin explains his long-standing fascination with consciousness and what makes us human, which led him to explore AI early on. He discusses how technological innovation paradoxically raises questions about our fundamental humanity through inverse comparison with computer capabilities.

Introduction of Ben Nywood and Sam Weiss, two computer scientists who developed Halaka Bench to evaluate AI competence in rabbinical law. Their research went viral after being shared on social media, attracting significant attention from major AI industry players.

Transcript

Description (by owner on YouTube)

In this episode of the 18Forty Podcast, we speak with engineers and HalachaBench creators Ben Nyblade and Sam Weiss about how AI performs on rabbinic ordination exams—and what that reveals about halacha, rabbinic authority, and the future of Jewish life. In this episode we discuss: —How do you test whether AI can pass a semicha exam, and who grades the AI? —Why are so many AI researchers fascinated by the Talmud? —Can AI ever replace the relationship between a rabbi and the person asking a halachic question? Tune in to hear a conversation about how “the process is as important as the question in lived Judaism.” Interview begins at 4:16.  Ben Nyblade is a mechanical engineer who builds robots, and Sam Weiss is a software engineer with a background in machine learning. Together with Ilan Weitzman and Jesse Bernstein, they created HalachaBench, a benchmark that tests how today’s leading AI models perform on Israeli Rabbanut semicha exams. Their results, first shared on X, drew attention from across the AI world. References: Talmud Mishnah Tanakh Shulchan Arukh by Rabbi Yosef Karo “A Mathematical Theory of Communication” by Claude Shannon Consider Phlebas by Iain M. Banks  HalachaBench results on GitHub HalachaBench on X The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt A Letter in the Scroll by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks 18Forty Podcast:“Will AI Replace Rabbis?” For more 18Forty: NEWSLETTER: 18forty.org/join CALL: (212) 582-1840 EMAIL: info@18forty.org WEBSITE: 18forty.org IG: @18forty X: @18_forty WhatsApp: join here

Subscribe to the newsletter

A regular email of new videos and articles from across the site. To hear about this channel on its own, use Follow above.

Get the pro-Israel voices the algorithms bury, right in your inbox.

Your email stays private.