Transcript [00:00] Denmark is waking up or has been waking [00:03] up for quite a while now. Let's take a [00:05] look. [00:05] >> Until just a few years ago, nobody would [00:07] have imagined that this woman would lead [00:09] Europe's anti-immigration agenda. She's [00:12] met Frederickson, the prime minister of [00:14] Denmark. From the Social Democratic [00:17] Party, seen by many as a model for [00:19] center-left parties across the [00:20] continent. [music] And in a speech as [00:22] head of the presidency of the Council of [00:24] the European Union, she said things like [00:26] this. [00:28] We need of course to be in control of [00:30] our own borders. Who can enter and stay [00:34] in our countries? That needs to be a [00:37] democratic decision. [00:40] And I will be very frank. People come [00:43] from coming outside [music] who commit [00:46] serious crimes and do not respect our [00:48] value and way of life. I don't think [00:51] they have a place in Europe. Denmark is [00:54] known as one of the happiest, safest, [00:56] most equal, and most progressive [00:57] countries on the planet. For decades, it [01:00] was held up as an example of openness, [01:02] solidarity, and a strong [music] welfare [01:04] state. But we know something changed [01:06] when the leader of the party that built [01:08] that model started pushing for zero [01:10] refugees, mass deportations, and strict [01:12] border control. How did such a [01:14] progressive country governed by a [01:16] center-left coalition end up [01:17] implementing one of the toughest [01:19] migration policies in Europe? This is [01:21] the story of a country that decided to [01:23] protect its social cohesion, even if it [01:25] meant breaking one of the most sacred [01:27] values of its own identity. And to [01:29] understand why Denmark now defends its [01:31] welfare by closing its borders, we first [01:33] need to understand how the idea of [01:35] protecting it at all costs was born. [01:39] During the Second World War, Denmark was [01:41] occupied by the Nazis. And when the [01:43] Nazis decided to deport the Jews to [01:45] concentration camps, the Danish [01:47] population stopped it. In a matter of [01:49] days, fishermen, priests, doctors, and [01:52] families organized an underground [01:53] operation to move the Jews out of the [01:55] country in small boats to Sweden, [01:57] [music] which was a neutral country. [01:59] More than 7,000 people were rescued by [02:02] their own neighbors. It wasn't a [02:04] religious or political cause. It was [02:06] something much deeper. The Jews were [02:08] above all Danes and they were protected [02:11] as part of the community. This episode [02:13] explains part of the country's identity. [02:16] In Denmark, people know that the [02:18] survival of a small country depends on [02:19] the strength of its community. And for [02:21] them, social cohesion isn't an abstract [02:24] idea. It's a historical practice. When [02:27] the war ended, there was a broad [02:28] political commitment to build a solid [02:30] welfare states able to guarantee [02:32] stability and security for all citizens. [02:35] Free and universal education, an [02:37] accessible and efficient health care [02:38] system, public housing policies, and a [02:40] safety net for the unemployed. In the [02:43] following decades, the country went [02:44] through a period of economic growth [02:46] driven by a light industrialization, the [02:48] modernization of agriculture, and the [02:50] expansion of the public sector. The [02:52] so-called Danish model of collective [02:54] bargaining made it possible to set wages [02:56] and working conditions through [02:57] consensus, which raised productivity and [03:00] reduced social conflict. By the mid1 [03:02] [music] 1960s, Denmark had become a [03:04] model of prosperity built on social [03:06] cohesion and mutual trust. It was a [03:09] homogeneous society where almost the [03:11] entire population shared the same [03:12] language, religion, [music] customs, and [03:14] a social contract in which every [03:16] individual had a clear place. At first [03:19] glance, it looked like an indestructible [03:21] fortress. But economic growth was [03:24] creating an unexpected [music] pressure. [03:26] Denmark needed more workers than its own [03:28] population could provide. That's why in [03:30] 1967, the government signed its first [03:33] recruitment agreements for foreign [03:34] workers with Turkey, Pakistan, and [03:36] Yugoslavia. [03:38] These workers were called hoster biter, [03:40] guest workers. The idea was that they [03:43] would temporarily fill the less [03:44] attractive jobs in factories, ports, [03:46] construction sites, and services and [03:48] then go back to their home countries. At [03:51] first, the numbers were small, but they [03:53] grew steadily. By 1973, shortly before [03:57] the oil crisis put an end to these [03:58] recruitment programs, it's estimated [04:00] that there were between 30,000 and [04:02] 40,000 hoster in the country. At the [04:05] time, there weren't major tensions. The [04:08] economy was growing, unemployment was [04:09] low, and the scale of the phenomenon was [04:11] manageable. But what started as a [04:14] temporary solution would become the [04:15] starting point for a demographic shift [04:17] that would shape the coming decades. [04:19] Because in the 1980s, immigration [04:21] changed when new arrivals no longer came [04:24] for work, but were fleeing wars and [04:26] persecution. The country started [04:28] receiving refugees from Iraq and Iran, [04:30] displaced by the Islamic Revolution of [04:32] 1979. In the war that went on through [04:35] the 1980s, [04:36] Somalis also arrived, escaping the civil [04:39] war that broke out in 1988, along with [04:41] Palestinians and Lebanese affected by [04:43] the conflicts in the Middle East. [04:45] [music] In the 1990s, the break up of [04:47] Yugoslavia and the war in Bosnia forced [04:50] hundreds of thousands of people to flee, [04:52] and Denmark took in tens of thousands of [04:54] them. Immigration stopped being [04:57] marginal. In working-class neighborhoods [04:59] in big cities, foreign origin [05:01] communities began to form, concentrated [05:03] almost entirely in large public housing [05:05] complexes. These neighborhoods had been [05:08] designed to promote equality, but [05:10] concentration ended up producing the [05:11] opposite effect. Areas where Danish [05:14] stopped being the main language and [05:15] where local customs lost visibility. The [05:18] labor market was the main breaking [05:20] point. Employment rates among immigrants [05:22] stayed persistently below those of [05:24] Danes. language barriers, the difficulty [05:27] of getting foreign qualifications [05:28] recognized, and [music] the lack of [05:30] social networks slowed their entry into [05:32] formal work. Many ended up depending on [05:35] state benefits for long periods, which [05:37] strained the core of the Danish welfare [05:38] model. Schools became the second alarm [05:41] bell. In some neighborhoods, most [05:43] children didn't speak Danish, and in [05:45] some schools, more than 80% of students [05:47] had an immigrant background. Teachers [05:50] reported difficulties in transmitting [05:52] basic norms of Danish civic culture like [05:54] punctuality, gender equality, or respect [05:57] for the teachers authority. What had [05:59] initially been seen as multiculturalism [06:01] started to look like the creation of [06:03] parallel communities marked by [06:04] marginalization. [06:06] Security finally solidified these [06:08] worries. In several neighborhoods, the [06:10] police reported a growing presence of [06:12] informal groups exercising social [06:14] control. Mhm. [06:15] >> It wasn't just crime, it was territorial [06:18] control. [06:19] >> Entire areas where the police needed [06:20] reinforcements just to enter. [06:23] >> The scale of the change was clear. In [06:25] 1985, only about 3.3% of the population [06:28] was made up of immigrants or children of [06:30] two immigrant parents. By the late [06:33] 1990s, they already made up more than [06:35] 8%. For a small, highly homogeneous [06:38] country, the impact was fast and [06:41] geographically concentrated. [music] [06:43] Soon, what had begun as a problem of [06:45] integration in specific neighborhoods [06:47] turned into a broader debate about [06:49] national cohesion. [06:52] In this [music] context, the 2001 [06:54] elections brought to power a [06:55] center-right coalition led by the [06:57] Liberal Party, Ventre, which would [06:59] govern until 2011. For the first time in [07:02] 80 years, the Social Democrats were no [07:04] longer the biggest party, and [07:06] immigration became the central issue in [07:08] the political debate. Denmark hardened [07:10] its laws on asylum and family [07:12] reunification, reduced financial [07:14] benefits for newcomers, tightened [07:16] residency requirements, and introduced [07:18] criteria aimed at limiting immigration [07:20] from outside Europe. This shift was [07:23] built on the idea that social cohesion [07:24] was a limited resource and that the [07:27] welfare state to keep functioning needed [07:30] newcomers to adapt fully. But soon the [07:33] argument stopped being exclusive to the [07:35] radical right as other political forces [07:37] even on the left started to admit that [07:39] the open door model was at risk and that [07:42] limits had to be set. Denmark was no [07:44] longer debating whether it should [07:46] restrict immigration but to what extent [07:48] and under what conditions it should do [07:50] so. Then in 2010 the country went a step [07:53] further when the government officially [07:55] introduced the so-called ghetto list. It [07:58] wasn't just a rhetorical label, but a [08:00] legal tool with specific criteria. A [08:03] neighborhood would be considered a [08:04] ghetto if more than 50% of its residents [08:06] were of non-western origin, if its [08:08] unemployment rate was higher than the [08:10] national average, if education levels [08:12] were low, and if crime rates were above [08:14] the national average. The decision was [08:17] controversial. While in other countries, [08:19] governments avoided directly linking [08:21] immigration and crime, Denmark made that [08:23] link explicit. Behind these increasingly [08:26] tough policies, there was an economic [08:28] calculation. The sustainability of the [08:30] welfare state depends on most of the [08:32] population contributing more than they [08:34] receive. That balance started to crack [08:37] when the numbers showed a clear [08:38] difference between natives and [08:39] immigrants. According to official [08:41] figures from the Ministry of Finance, [08:43] Danes of native origin contributed a [08:45] positive net fiscal amount of around 41 [08:47] [music] billion Danish croner per year. [08:50] Meanwhile, groups of non-western origin [08:52] showed a negative net contribution of [08:54] about 24 billion. [08:56] >> That's crazy. [08:56] >> The migration debate stopped being [08:58] abstract and [music] became central to [09:00] the viability of the Danish model. In [09:03] 2011, the Social Democrats returned to [09:05] power after a decade of liberal [09:07] governments. And many people expected a [09:09] change of direction. They thought the [09:11] new government would relax migration [09:13] restrictions, eliminate the toughest [09:14] requirements, [music] or make it easier [09:16] to obtain residence permits. But the [09:19] exact opposite happened. The Social [09:21] Democrats didn't roll back any of the [09:23] measures introduced by [music] the right [09:24] between 2001 and 2011. They kept them in [09:27] place and in some cases they even [09:30] strengthened them, tightening access to [09:32] citizenship [music] and more closely [09:34] linking social benefits to active job [09:36] seeeking. For the first time, the Danish [09:38] left openly embraced an idea that until [09:41] then had belonged to the right. Without [09:43] social cohesion in labor market [09:45] integration, the welfare state [music] [09:47] isn't sustainable. In this context, in [09:50] 2015, at the height of the European [09:52] migration crisis, [music] Denmark [09:54] received more than 21,000 asylum [09:56] applications in a single year. It was a [09:58] huge pressure for a country of just 6 [10:00] million inhabitants with a system [10:02] designed for stability, not for massive [10:04] inflows. While other European countries [10:07] improvised solutions, Denmark responded [10:09] by tightening its laws even more with [10:11] the center right back in power, but now [10:14] with a very broad political consensus. [10:16] Social benefits for asylum seekers were [10:18] reduced, border controls were [10:20] reinforced, and above all, the message [10:22] was sent that national cohesion came [10:24] first. In 2016, the so-called jewelry [10:28] law was passed, a controversial rule [10:30] that allowed authorities to confiscate [10:32] cash or valuables from people requesting [10:34] [music] asylum. The official goal was to [10:36] make refugees help pay for their own [10:38] stay, while also sending a clear message [10:40] that [music] Denmark wouldn't be a [10:41] comfortable destination for those hoping [10:43] to settle in Europe. The government even [10:46] published ads in Lebanese newspapers [10:48] explicitly warning about the new [10:49] restrictions [music] in a deliberate [10:51] attempt to discourage potential [10:52] applicants before they began their [10:54] journey. Faced with the biggest [10:56] migration crisis in decades, Denmark [10:58] defended the idea that solidarity has [11:00] limits and that the social contract had [11:02] to be protected even at the cost of [11:04] controversial measures like the ban on [11:06] the burka and nikab in public spaces [11:08] passed by parliament in 2018. A decision [11:12] that made it clear that cultural [11:13] adaptation as part of integration wasn't [11:16] optional. By 2018, [music] [11:18] the ghetto list included 29 [11:20] neighborhoods spread across major [11:21] cities. names like Volmos, Geller, or [11:24] Tingier became synonyms for exclusion, [11:27] unemployment, and violence. These were [11:30] urban enclaves where common rules and [11:31] values had stopped applying. And the [11:33] [music] state's response to this [11:34] situation was drastic. Plans were [11:37] approved to demolish public housing [11:38] blocks and relocate the families living [11:40] in them with the goal of mixing the [11:42] demographic makeup. Crimes committed in [11:45] these areas begin to carry tougher [11:46] penalties than in the rest [music] of [11:48] the country. And the state made it [11:50] mandatory for children from these [11:51] neighborhoods to attend public daycare [11:53] from the age of 1 for at least 25 hours [11:55] a week to learn Danish and basic social [11:58] values. Families who didn't comply could [12:00] see their benefits reduced. The plan was [12:03] clear. Eliminate foreign enclaves inside [12:05] the country and set a goal that by 2030, [12:07] [music] [12:08] no neighborhood should have more than [12:09] 30% non-western residents. [12:13] In 2019, the Social Democrats returned [12:15] to power after an election campaign [12:17] built on promises to keep the migration [12:19] restrictions introduced by the rights [12:20] and even strengthen them. And that [12:23] promise had a name, Met Frederickson. [12:26] Frederickson understood the cultural [12:27] shift the country was going through [12:29] earlier than anyone else. Direct, [12:32] pragmatic, and unafraid to challenge [12:33] ideological dogmas, she presented [12:36] herself to voters with a clear message. [12:38] Protecting the Danish social model meant [12:40] controlling who could enter. Defending [12:42] the welfare system was no longer about [12:44] opening the doors to everyone, but about [12:46] preserving internal cohesion. With her [12:49] in power, Denmark pushed a political [12:51] goal of reducing asylum applications to [12:53] zero. It wasn't just about tightening [12:55] requirements or speeding up [12:57] deportations. It was about completely [12:59] changing the logic of the system. From [13:02] that [music] point on, immigration [13:03] through asylum was no longer a path to a [13:05] new life in Denmark, but a temporary [13:07] protection with the explicit expectation [13:09] of going back to the country of origin [13:11] as soon as possible. Those who obtained [13:14] protection no longer received stable [13:16] status, but temporary permits of one or [13:18] two years, subject to regular reviews. [13:21] Each case was reassessed, and if the [13:23] situation in the country of origin [13:25] improved, protection was revoked. [13:27] >> And then they need to go. In 2021, [13:28] Denmark revoked the residence permits of [13:30] 453 Syrian refugees. The official [13:34] justification was that areas like [13:35] Damascus and its surroundings were no [13:37] longer considered dangerous enough to [13:39] keep offering international protection. [13:41] According to the government, if the war [13:43] had receded in those areas, then the [13:45] humanitarian obligation had been [13:47] fulfilled. They were moved to departure [13:49] centers, facilities with limited rights, [13:51] where they had to wait until they could [13:53] be deported or agreed to leave [13:54] voluntarily. The change wasn't only [13:57] legal, it was doctrinal, and official [13:59] language stopped talking about [14:01] integration and replaced it with [14:03] self-sufficiency and return. The goal [14:06] was no longer to turn newcomers into [14:07] future Danish citizens, but to make sure [14:10] they could support themselves while they [14:11] stayed and were ready to go back as soon [14:13] as possible. As part of this new [14:15] doctrine, the state started offering [14:17] money to leave. Any immigrant or refugee [14:20] with a residence permit could [music] [14:22] request financial compensation to return [14:24] voluntarily to their country of origin. [14:27] The state covered travel costs and paid [14:28] up to 225,000 Danish croner, about [14:31] €30,000, to help with reintegration. If [14:35] a person didn't have a long-term future [14:37] in Denmark, it was better from the [14:39] state's point of view to pay for their [14:40] return than to support them indefinitely [14:43] through the welfare system. This wasn't [14:45] just a tweak. It was a new way of [14:47] thinking about immigration, much more [14:49] demanding and selective, built on three [14:51] main pillars. The first is integration. [14:55] Since 2023, refugees have had to accept [14:57] a job within 3 months. The goal is no [15:00] longer to study first in training [15:02] programs or learn Danish before doing [15:04] anything else. The idea is to work first [15:07] and learn while working. Integration [15:10] isn't a voluntary gesture. It's a [15:12] condition for accessing the welfare [15:13] system. Those who don't comply see their [15:16] benefits reduced or even cut off. The [15:19] second pillar is citizenship is a [15:21] hard-to-reach goal. Becoming a Danish [15:23] citizen isn't an automatic right. It's a [15:26] long and demanding process that usually [15:28] requires between 9 and 12 years of legal [15:31] residence. On top of that, applicants [15:33] must pass an advanced language test, [15:35] [music] [15:35] another test on Danish history and [15:37] culture, and prove economic [15:39] independence. Their criminal record is [15:41] also checked. The third pillar is strict [15:44] limits on family reunification, meaning [15:46] that bringing relatives is heavily [15:48] restricted. To apply, a person must be [15:51] at least 24 years old, have their own [15:53] income and housing, and deposit 59,000 [15:56] Danish croner, about €7,700 [15:59] as a guarantee. On top of that, there [16:02] are long waiting times that in practice [16:04] mean many reunifications never happen. [16:08] In the years that followed, Denmark [16:09] pushed this logic even further. In 2022, [16:12] Parliament passed a law allowing the [16:14] full outsourcing of the asylum process. [16:17] Under this law, someone who applies for [16:19] asylum in Denmark can be sent to a safe [16:21] third country like Rwanda, with which [16:23] the government signed an agreement so [16:25] that their claim is processed there, not [16:27] on [music] Danish soil. The message was [16:30] explicit. Asylum no longer meant [16:32] automatic access to the country. Even if [16:34] the claim was approved, Denmark didn't [16:36] have to grant residence and protection [16:38] could be provided in the country hosting [16:40] the processing center. For the [16:42] government, the goal was to cut off the [16:44] incentive to physically reach Denmark as [16:46] a gateway into the welfare state. [16:49] All these measures led to concrete [16:51] results. In 2024, Denmark recorded a [16:54] historically low number of asylum [16:56] approvals, just 864 people, one of the [16:59] lowest rates in the entire European [17:01] Union. But these results are just as [17:04] striking as the political shift behind [17:05] them. In recent years, in most of [17:08] Europe, public frustration over [17:10] immigration has translated into the rise [17:11] of right-wing parties that use the issue [17:14] as their main campaign banner. But not [17:16] in Denmark. There, the strict migration [17:19] agenda didn't stay in the hands of the [17:20] right. It was absorbed by the Social [17:22] Democrats. It was an unexpected turn. A [17:26] party traditionally associated with open [17:28] and humanitarian policies decided to [17:30] toughen its stance on immigration and [17:32] take over ideas that had previously [17:34] belonged to the nationalist Danish [17:36] People's [music] Party. By pulling the [17:38] anti-immigration consensus toward the [17:40] center left, the Social Democrats [17:42] managed to neutralize the right, which [17:43] lost its main issue. The Danish People's [17:46] Party, which in 2015 had become the [17:48] country's second largest political [17:50] force, [music] went into a steep decline [17:52] and in the 2024 European elections [17:54] barely managed to keep minimal [17:56] representation. [17:57] What strengthened the right in other [17:59] countries [music] ended up consolidating [18:00] the left in Denmark. And that political [18:03] paradox is a key part of the model. [18:05] Harsh migration policies weren't [18:07] presented as a victory for the right, [18:08] but as a state policy adopted by the [18:11] country's most stable political force, [18:13] >> something that you do. In 2025, when [18:15] Denmark took over the rotating [18:16] presidency of the Council of the [18:18] European Union, [music] met Fredricken [18:20] brought her migration agenda to the [18:22] continental stage. From the podium of [18:24] the European Parliament in Strawburg, [18:27] the Danish Prime Minister argued that [18:28] Europe had to reduce migration flows and [18:30] regain control of its external borders. [18:33] It wasn't a fringe position, but the [18:35] road map Denmark wanted to bring into [18:37] negotiations with the 27 member states. [18:40] Yeah, [18:40] >> at a time when migration policy was [18:42] dividing the union, the Danish social [18:44] democrat was calling for a shift that [18:46] had previously been pushed only by [18:47] nationalist parties. [18:50] >> And once this nationalist party [18:52] perspective became part of the broader [18:54] agenda, [18:56] this is what shows you that there's a [18:57] huge change happening in Europe. Danish [18:59] prime minister says she opposes [19:01] multiculturalism and Denmark is a [19:03] Christian country with freedom of [19:04] religion. Take a look at this. [19:08] Um, [19:13] for example, [19:32] for example. [20:00] Denmark. [20:05] Okay. [20:06] >> So, this is the thing. It it annoys me [20:09] when liberals often bring up talking [20:11] points like the Nordic countries as like [20:14] an example for societies that work under [20:17] socialism or communism or the welfare [20:19] state. They work because they're [20:21] ethnically homogeneous societies. And [20:24] that's how they've always worked. People [20:26] who are living there as minority groups [20:28] for the most part are benefiting off the [20:29] welfare state, not equally adding their [20:32] piece to the pie at all. That's that's [20:35] usually the case. There's exceptions to [20:36] that, but that's usually the case. So, I [20:40] hate when people bring up, especially [20:41] when liberals try to talk to me about [20:43] like look at Sweden. Look at Norway. [20:45] Look at look at Denmark. It's like they [20:47] work because they're ethnically [20:49] homogeneous societies because they [20:52] accept that they have high trust because [20:53] everyone's white and Christian. They [20:55] know they don't have to guess if you're [20:56] from Pakistan and if you're going to [20:58] start a rape gang in your mosque. They [21:00] know where that person is for the most [21:02] part. They know where they are. They [21:03] know what their goals are in life [21:04] because they generally act the same and [21:06] they see a future of a cohesive society. [21:08] Folks, that's the truth. And if you [21:10] don't want to believe it, I'm sorry.