Transcript [00:00] All right, we are here at the National [00:01] Conservatism Conference in Jerusalem and [00:04] it is my pleasure to have Professor [00:06] Mosha Capel uh one of the speakers here [00:08] at the conference uh on the Israel 365 [00:11] podcast and where I'd first like to [00:14] start is you've been involved in the [00:16] world of politics. you are a professor [00:18] of computer science. Uh but you also [00:21] with your cohello policy forum got [00:23] involved in the world of politics and [00:25] before we do a deep dive I'd love to get [00:28] your take on the state of Israel's [00:31] elections which are coming up in just a [00:33] few weeks. [00:34] >> Okay. Thanks for having me Rafie. [00:36] Delighted to be here with you. Um the [00:38] first thing I want to say is that I [00:40] don't do politics. I do policy. Okay. I [00:43] I am apolitical in case the tax [00:46] authorities are listening to this [00:47] interview. I want on the record I'm [00:50] apolitical. I just do policy. So um [00:54] yeah, if you want to understand uh where [00:56] these elections are going, you you need [00:58] to understand where Israel is going as a [00:59] country, right? Um now the country was [01:03] founded uh mostly by by secular [01:07] socialists. the old uh Labor Party and [01:09] the Labor movement. They ran the country [01:11] until 1977 officially unofficially there [01:16] been not the Labor Party but its its [01:18] ideological descendants have been [01:20] running it ever since. So even though [01:22] began won the election in 77 and and it [01:24] seems like the liquid has been in power [01:26] forever but the fact of the matter is [01:28] that the unelected institutions of the [01:29] country whether it's you know the courts [01:31] of the prosecutors or you know the army [01:33] and and uh other security branches and [01:36] and the media and the universities etc [01:38] etc all of them have been dominated [01:42] >> by the ideological descendants of the [01:44] old labor party. Uh, of course the [01:46] ideology is is somewhat dynamic as [01:48] circumstances change and Israel becomes [01:50] a wealthier country and the demographics [01:52] change and so forth. But that's that's [01:54] roughly the idea and that is about to [01:56] come to an end. Uh, it's coming to an [01:58] end simply for uh political reasons. Uh, [02:02] October 7th changed you know the way [02:04] people see our our neighbors. [02:07] uh because [02:11] demographically there are just many many [02:13] more people who are uh who are religious [02:16] or religious adjacent and uh and uh [02:19] generally have conservative values. [02:23] So uh all this all this plays into [02:26] what's going to happen in the elections. [02:28] Okay. Two things happened over the past [02:31] four years that have worked across [02:33] purposes. One of them is that people [02:36] moved more right as I mentioned partly [02:38] because October 7th was a wakeup call [02:41] for people who still had leftist [02:43] fantasies. Uh but the other thing [02:45] working against that is that there's a [02:49] general dissatisfaction with with this [02:52] government and the way it handled things [02:54] October 7th obviously it being a big [02:56] failure not due solely to the government [02:58] but at least partly um and also because [03:02] some people uh did not like the way they [03:05] handled the interaction with the khedim [03:07] who were part of the coalition but there [03:09] are many other reasons. Uh so the the [03:12] first thing moving to the right is is an [03:14] advantage for the current government and [03:16] the elections but the second one is a [03:18] great disadvantage and the question is [03:19] how do these things play out right I [03:21] mean these are two big big forces that [03:23] are that are working against each other [03:25] right so uh expect rain right it's it's [03:29] like uh the now what's likely to happen [03:34] even though the polls aren't showing [03:35] this at the moment is there is now only [03:38] one party that's a a right-wing option [03:40] that is not tainted so to speak by [03:43] having been part of this government [03:44] which is Winter's party. So Winter's [03:45] party is much more important in this [03:47] election than than people understand. [03:49] It's actually a very very important [03:51] player whether you're for them or [03:53] against them but they're an important [03:54] player because they they are the ones [03:56] who can potentially soak up all of those [03:59] right-wing voters who just don't like [04:01] this government for one reason or [04:02] another. So that that that I think is [04:04] one of the things that needs to be taken [04:06] into account. Um [04:09] in all likelihood [04:11] the the next government will be a [04:15] coalition that includes elements of the [04:17] left and the right. Okay. Uh [04:20] even if the right you know what we're [04:22] calling the right. Okay. We're including [04:24] the karedum in the right. Uh which you [04:26] know was an arguable point. But but um [04:31] even if the current coalition the [04:32] parties in the current coalition plus [04:34] say Winter or anybody else who who who [04:36] is a you know an ally of theirs gets you [04:39] know 65 seats okay which is possible. Um [04:44] that's not the government that the Lord [04:47] or BB wants. Okay first of all BB never [04:51] wants to be the most moderate or the [04:55] most right-wing element of his [04:57] government. He loves having people on [04:58] his left and on his right so that he can [05:02] if he doesn't want to do something he [05:04] always has somebody to blame. Okay, so [05:07] that's that's the first thing. But the [05:08] second thing is that the used to be [05:12] cheap partners in a coalition. Okay, [05:14] everybody knew the terms of the deal, [05:16] right? you you gave them, you know, what [05:18] they wanted and you gave them their [05:19] budgets for their yeshivas and their [05:20] institutions and you kind of kept the uh [05:24] we won't draft you thing going and and [05:26] and they were what are you know what we [05:29] call honest politicians. They stayed [05:31] bought, right? And and the problem is [05:34] that the uh became too expensive as [05:38] coalition partners in the last four [05:39] years to be perfectly blunt about it. uh [05:42] they were indispensable to the coalition [05:44] and they exploited that fact to the [05:46] hilt. Uh they killed all kinds of [05:49] reforms because they weren't getting [05:50] what they wanted on on other issues. So [05:53] they they killed the milk reform. They [05:55] killed, you know, there's a whole long [05:56] list of reforms that they killed. [05:58] They've become too expensive and they're [05:59] also politically costly because people [06:01] there are people who would have voted [06:03] for the leood and the only reason [06:04] they're not voting for the leood is [06:05] because they they they were in bed with [06:07] the right. So, so they have become [06:10] expensive and um it therefore becomes [06:14] unlikely that BB will even want the [06:17] current coalition if he could possibly [06:18] reproduce it. Uh so now the left has no [06:22] hope of putting together a government. [06:24] You know, they have fantasies of, you [06:25] know, the Arabs are going to abstain, [06:27] but only the moderate Arabs. They're not [06:29] going to be anywhere near enough vote. [06:31] They were the the left, not counting the [06:33] Arabs, is not even going to get 50 [06:35] seats. more likely somewhere in the [06:37] mid-4s. Okay. Uh so even even with the [06:40] Arabs, they're not going to they're not [06:42] going to have six. Maybe they'll scratch [06:43] out 60 tops 61 and you know to have 61 [06:48] based on you know Ahmed Tibbe is you [06:51] know that just that is not a winning [06:52] strategy right so so odds are then that [06:57] it becomes it comes down to Likud and [07:00] Eisenot making some kind of a deal each [07:02] one bringing along its satellite [07:04] partners. The only uh question is uh is [07:10] anybody willing to you know kind of [07:12] subordinate themselves to the other guy [07:14] and it BB is surely not going to play [07:16] second fiddle to Eisenkott. That's not [07:18] going to happen. And uh it's pretty [07:20] unlikely that Eisenhot will play second [07:22] fiddle to BB. The only way out would be [07:25] would be a rotation. I hate rotations. [07:28] They're not a good thing. Uh but it it [07:31] it's a possibility and you know for BB [07:34] to get two years and then give Eisenhot [07:37] two years or Lieberman two years or even [07:39] Bennett two years um it doesn't cost him [07:42] much because two years from now Trump is [07:45] gone. BB will have done what he's going [07:48] to do you know or realize that it's not [07:52] going to get done. It's not going to get [07:53] done under President Nuome or AOC or JD [07:57] Vance. Right. So so If you ask me, will [08:00] BB take two years and then say to [08:02] Eisenhott, you get the next two years? [08:05] >> Yeah, he do it in a heartbeat. [08:06] >> Every day we're confronted with lies, [08:08] misinformation, and distorted narratives [08:11] about Israel. And here's the problem. [08:13] Even when we know something isn't true, [08:15] we don't always have the facts at our [08:17] fingertips to respond. If this sounds [08:20] like you, then I highly recommend a book [08:22] we just launched called the Pro-Israel [08:24] Handbook. This book gives you the [08:26] history, the facts, and the arguments [08:29] you need to confidentally stand up for [08:31] Israel and challenge the most common [08:33] false narratives being spread about the [08:35] Jewish state. Don't just support Israel, [08:38] know how to defend it. Get 15% off your [08:41] copy of the ProIsrael handbook today by [08:43] clicking the link below and using the [08:45] code handbook 15. Now, back to the [08:47] video. Okay. And and you don't see a to [08:50] drill down into this a little bit, you [08:52] don't see a coalition where let's say [08:56] Lieberman and BB start begin to work [08:58] together. [08:59] >> Possible. Yeah. Just as just as I as BB [09:01] and Eisenkot might work together, maybe [09:04] the Liberman will work together. Yeah, [09:05] for sure. But but but I I I think it's [09:08] pretty certain that both the Liood and [09:11] uh at least at least one if not more of [09:14] of Eisenhot Lieberman and Bennett will [09:17] will be in the coalition. Okay. [09:19] >> Year Golan will not be in the coalition. [09:20] He's a nut. [laughter] [09:22] >> Yeah. [09:22] >> And and what about Okay, so let's let's [09:26] pivot a little bit. Yeah. [09:27] >> So let's say that is the coalition. Some [09:30] kind of very centrist coalition. Maybe [09:33] some more leftwing partners, some [09:34] right-wing partners. um in the uh [09:37] exiting coalition, you were one of the [09:41] uh theorists and then proponent [09:43] proponents of the idea of judicial [09:46] reform. And this worked at a number of [09:48] different levels um in terms of the [09:51] types of laws that the Supreme Court is [09:53] allowed to review, what the extent of [09:56] that review is, the process for that [09:58] review, how judges are selected. I don't [10:01] want to get involved in too many of [10:03] those those weeds. Um but and and I [10:06] think before the practical part of [10:09] judicial reform, you did a fantastic job [10:12] really trying to build a coalition [10:14] around this, right? You had someone like [10:17] Yah Laid come and speak at the Kahala [10:19] policy forum and he gave a speech about [10:22] why he thinks his version of judicial [10:25] reform is needed. Um, so there's I I [10:30] think some kind of broad agreement that [10:33] there or at least there used to be some [10:35] kind of broad agreement about judicial [10:37] reform. Where do you see where do you [10:39] see the future of judicial reform? [10:41] >> Okay. So you need to see judicial reform [10:43] in the context of what I was talking [10:45] about earlier in the unelected [10:47] institutions of this country have been [10:49] held by the ideological descendants of [10:51] the Labor Party and they like that and [10:53] they want to keep it that way. Okay. [10:55] Now, how do you keep losing power? [10:57] >> Yeah, exactly. So, how do you keep your [11:00] power if you actually haven't, you know, [11:02] been elected in in almost half a [11:05] century, right? So, how do [laughter] [11:07] how do you manage to do that, right? So, [11:10] the the answer is well, you use the [11:12] power that you have because you hold [11:15] these institutions in order to maintain [11:16] it. So, for example, if if the judges [11:19] are all, you know, uh lefty activists, [11:23] to put it inelegantly, [11:25] um uh what what they can do is that they [11:29] they can use their power in order to [11:31] make sure that other appointments, [11:34] right, to other unelected institutions, [11:36] whether it's the the head of the army or [11:38] the head of the police or the head of [11:39] the Shabbach or the head of the Mossad [11:41] or or uh you know, you you name it, [11:44] right? uh make sure that all of those [11:48] people are people that you like. So that [11:50] if the government proposes somebody that [11:52] you don't like, you say, "Well, that's [11:53] an unreasonable appointment." Now, I [11:55] just to be sure, unreasonable doesn't [11:58] mean um illegal. No, if it were illegal, [12:00] they would say it's illegal, right? No, [12:02] it's not. It's perfectly legal. Uh it's [12:05] just it's unreasonable, right? So, they [12:07] they find, you know, like the attorney [12:09] general, who's always one of their [12:11] friends, is is investigating the person. [12:14] Okay. Well, you know, the attorney [12:15] general can investigate anybody. You [12:16] know, there's there's really, you know, [12:18] no threshold for investigating. And then [12:20] there's, well, if they're investigating, [12:21] we think it's unreasonable for you to [12:22] take a person under investigation and [12:24] make them, you know, give them, you [12:25] know, put them in this position. So, [12:27] that's that's how the game is played. [12:29] Almost all the tricks they use, almost [12:32] all [12:33] the bad decisions they make uh are to [12:37] keep their friends in power. Okay? you [12:40] know, when we say that they, you know, [12:41] they strike down uh government decisions [12:44] as being unreasonable, I'm not talking [12:47] about, you know, whether they, you know, [12:48] a particular, you know, the the length [12:50] of the awnings on on cafes in Tel a Viv [12:54] is unreason, you know, unreasonably [12:56] regulated, right? That is not what we're [12:58] talking about. What we're talking about [12:59] what they they use this basically to [13:02] say, uh, we are not going to let you [13:04] appoint people we don't like. That's the [13:07] way they use. Now, that's that's [13:09] reasonable. The the the one of the other [13:11] big fights is how are [13:14] Supreme Court justices or other judges [13:17] uh appointed? And and the answer [13:19] [clears throat] is that they have a veto [13:20] block on the committee that actually [13:22] chooses the judges. Right? So there [13:24] there in a committee of nine in which [13:26] you need seven to pass to become the [13:28] Supreme Court justice. There are three [13:30] sitting Supreme Court justices. Okay? So [13:33] they've got a veto block. Okay? So this [13:35] is this is what it's all about. Now um [13:39] if you ask me do I think passing [13:42] judicial reform had we passed it or if [13:44] we pass it in you know in the next [13:46] government uh is that sufficient the [13:48] answer is no because the ones who you [13:50] know the the changes we're making are [13:53] are parchment barriers. Okay they're [13:55] just written on paper. Uh writing stuff [13:57] on paper doesn't change the reality and [14:00] the people who are reading this you know [14:01] these laws and applying them are the [14:05] judges. Okay. So it's not sufficient to [14:08] just do that. Uh now what you really [14:10] need to do of course is for this younger [14:12] generation to come into power and just [14:14] sweep out sweep out you know all all you [14:18] know that entire old guard that's been [14:19] there forever. Now once that happens [14:24] then the reform is hardly necessary. [14:27] Okay. So it's it isn't sufficient that's [14:29] for sure. But the point is if what is [14:32] sufficient happens then it isn't even [14:34] necessary. Right? Well, once once you've [14:37] seized power, you know, you seize [14:38] control of the unelected institutions, [14:41] then then, you know, I I don't really [14:43] care so much about whether we we change, [14:45] you know, uh uh paragraph 3A, you know, [14:48] it does it doesn't really matter that [14:50] much. [14:52] >> The the [14:55] if I if I would think about what that [14:57] looks like for a second, right? And I [14:59] certainly see the spirit of the Israeli [15:02] people changing, right? Um I I once [15:05] described um many Israelis as um [15:12] religious but not observant, right? They [15:14] have this sense of belief in God, [15:16] >> traditional. I I just call them [15:17] traditional. [15:18] >> Yeah. [15:19] >> And that is radically different from the [15:21] socialists who started the country who [15:23] were anti-religious. [15:25] >> Right. Um, but when I see this rising [15:29] generation, but it's not as if the [15:33] original leftists have completely [15:34] disappeared. They still are a [15:36] significant number. Not the way they [15:38] once were, but enough to occupy um, [15:42] professorships, fellowships, [15:45] um, admissions to certain uh, schools of [15:48] law and obviously to become judges, [15:51] right? So even if there's still 10,000 [15:54] of them, that's enough people to control [15:58] these various bodies. [snorts] [16:02] >> Do you think that it's just going to be [16:03] this natural process or as and you know, [16:05] Dr. Kevin Roberts described in his [16:07] speech how he sees he's he sees he's not [16:10] scared, he's hopeful, but he sees the [16:12] next 10 years being even more intense [16:15] than the previous 10 years. How do you [16:17] see this process happening? [16:19] >> All right. First of all, uh what's going [16:21] on in the United States is what's going [16:22] on in Israel is not the same thing. And [16:24] the two things should shouldn't be [16:25] compared. Okay? In the United States, um [16:28] I am much less confident about the [16:30] rising generation than I am about the [16:31] sitting one. In Israel, the opposite is [16:33] the case. Okay? But in in any event, [16:35] yes, I think I think you you know uh [16:37] you're making a valid point in this [16:39] sense. In the United States, [16:42] um the way the left keeps control is is [16:48] wholesale. It's not retail. Okay. The [16:51] way they do it is they've got all these [16:52] universities and and liberal arts [16:54] colleges that are um [16:59] uh engage in the overp production of [17:02] what we'll call elites. Okay? By which I [17:04] mean people who are essentially [17:07] unemployable except as DEI bureaucrats. [17:10] Okay? So, so that's so, so, so the left [17:13] has this this humongous humongous [17:15] machine, right, that just produces these [17:17] completely useless people. Um, that's [17:20] not the way it works in Israel, okay? [17:22] Uh, the way the way it works in Israel [17:24] is retail, okay? The it's the old [17:28] establishment sees some some promising [17:31] politician, right? somebody somebody, [17:33] you know, working their way up the ranks [17:35] in the army or in the Shabbach or or or [17:38] um in the legal system, right? And they [17:42] co-opt them, right? It's really a system [17:44] of co-opting because since they have the [17:45] power now, you understand that if you [17:47] want to get ahead, you better play by [17:49] their rules. Uh there are many examples [17:52] of people who came up have the typical [17:54] you know religious right-wing background [17:57] and as soon as they get a taste of power [17:59] and they understand that you know if you [18:02] want to rise to the top you better play [18:04] along right I I mean we can name names [18:07] here but it's pretty obvious who they [18:09] are so it's unnecessary right um so so [18:13] the system in Israel is is retail okay [18:16] um and and therefore I I I think it's [18:20] it's winnable because as all you need is [18:22] a slight shift for young rising people [18:25] to realize that they're not going to win [18:29] anymore by playing that old game, right? [18:32] That that if if you want to get ahead, [18:36] you actually have to look rightward, not [18:38] only leftward. And it's that's a subtle [18:40] shift and it's already happening. [18:43] >> Okay. [18:44] >> Thank you. This is great having you on [18:46] the Isel 365 podcast. [18:48] >> Pleasure. Happy to be here. Okay.