Transcript [00:00] What a load of codswallop. I mean, it [00:02] seems like Zack Polanski doesn't have a [00:03] clue what his position even is. [00:06] >> Are you saying he's not a noted [00:07] international law expert? Is that what [00:08] you're implying? [00:09] >> According to him, under international [00:11] law, no countries have a right to exist. [00:13] And I assume that even means Great [00:15] Britain doesn't have a right to exist. [00:18] The guy doesn't really seem to know what [00:19] he's doing. He deliberately missed that [00:21] vote. I'm not sure why. [00:23] I think he said he wouldn't have voted [00:25] for it because he felt that this idea [00:27] that there needed to be a single state [00:30] where all the population could could [00:32] vote wasn't what he thought. He felt [00:35] that that Israelis and Palestinians [00:37] should get to decide for themselves. But [00:39] of course there's not much chance [00:42] of the party adopting that idea when [00:43] they seem to think that their finger [00:45] wagging from from the UK about this is [00:48] going to concern either side over over [00:51] in the Middle East. And the point is I [00:52] think the man isn't really a serious [00:54] politician. That's a big surprise. I [00:56] don't think he's got serious positions [00:57] on most things, but certainly on this [00:59] issue he doesn't really have anything [01:01] serious to contribute. His idea, I mean [01:04] even this idea that there could be some [01:06] kind of single state where there is a [01:08] democratic vote for the government [01:10] between all of the so-called refugees [01:13] that classed as Palestinian refugees [01:15] around the world and the Israelis living [01:17] there and that there would somehow be [01:19] a better situation. I mean, what would [01:21] happen there? The reason that doesn't [01:23] work for anybody that isn't up to speed [01:26] on it is that effectively the Jews and [01:28] the Israelis would be outnumbered [01:29] immediately by this influx. [01:31] They would then vote as they tend to for [01:34] some kind of tyrannical or dictatorship [01:37] based system run by Islamist rules just [01:40] like they did in the Gaza Strip when [01:42] they were given that vote there. That [01:44] would then seize power, never let go of [01:46] it. Even in the West Bank where Hamas [01:48] isn't in power, Fatah and and Mahmoud [01:50] Abbas in year 22 or 23 or 24 or [01:53] something of his four-year term. The [01:56] Palestinians tend to have elections once [01:58] uh and then that's it and they often [02:00] vote for well, always vote for something [02:03] horrific, whether it's Fatah or whether [02:04] it's Hamas and that something horrific [02:07] doesn't have a very good or preferable [02:09] or fair or nice view of Jews. Um, so [02:12] obviously the idea is preposterous. It's [02:14] an idea to try and eradicate the state [02:16] of Israel, try and eradicate Jews. I I [02:19] don't think these are serious players, [02:20] but I don't think they're really going [02:21] to have a very big impact on the world [02:23] stage either. [02:24] >> And speaking of the uh Israeli election, [02:26] we will be speaking to Nicole Lampert [02:27] next week uh Tuesday next week. She will [02:29] be there. Uh Jonathan, I'm sure will [02:32] provide us provide us with some expert [02:33] uh um commentary too. I've so many [02:36] things I want to ask you, Jonathan. [02:37] There's so many things I want to talk [02:39] talk to you about. Can I just get a [02:40] quick word on France actually? Because [02:42] we're talking about this later on in the [02:43] program. There is a sort of fiction that [02:45] all these people are, you know, lovely [02:48] uh warm cuddly lefties who are worried [02:50] about schoolbooks and uh the fact that, [02:53] you know, uh that example was the form [02:55] because it was hot. I mean, this is [02:57] looting. This is rioting. And many of [02:59] these people are doing so under a [03:00] Palestinian flag. [03:03] >> Yes, I mean, in all the footage that we [03:05] can see coming out of France, you don't [03:06] see very many French flags being flown. [03:08] Uh and certainly I think it's an [03:10] alarming sight when you see historic and [03:13] and municipal buildings being burnt [03:14] down, uh shops being smashed up and [03:17] looted, uh citizens being abused by [03:19] these crowds. Uh it is terrifying and [03:22] the riots are are [03:24] very very large. The protests aren't all [03:27] violent. The French do like to protest. [03:29] That that is certainly part of their [03:30] culture historically, but but regardless [03:32] of that, this is alarming and it's [03:34] spreading. We're now seeing some some of [03:36] it spreading even to Italy. Uh I think [03:39] there's been some in Milan. Uh there [03:40] have been some indications that there [03:42] are people trying to whip up similar [03:44] riots and protests here in the UK. It's [03:46] possible. [03:47] >> there's a day of action that's meant to [03:48] happen on Friday. It's been sent to me [03:51] by a couple of viewers and listeners [03:52] actually. So, we'll we'll keep an eye on [03:54] that. One thing we'll also keep an eye [03:56] on is the BBC's reporting of all of [03:58] this, especially when it comes to not [04:00] just France, but the Middle East as [04:01] well. Jeremy Bowen, the Middle East [04:04] editor for the BBC, has said this in [04:06] recent days at the talk in Glasgow. [04:13] >> Do you Do you accept any responsibility [04:15] for your failure to call out the BBC? [04:18] >> You made your point. Now, let me answer [04:19] you. [04:22] I would I've been asked various [04:23] questions here about the the genocide [04:26] issues, what you're referring to. [04:28] And what I would say is this, it is an [04:31] absolute myth [04:33] to say that we don't mention that I [04:35] don't mention genocide on air. [04:37] And for me, it's clear what's happening. [04:39] It's genocide. I have reported all of [04:41] these things. What I haven't done is get [04:44] on my soapbox and say, "I know it's a [04:46] genocide." [04:50] >> Jonathan, no huge shock there. Uh the [04:52] mask has slipped to some degree, not [04:54] that it was particularly well affixed in [04:56] the first place in Jeremy Bowen's uh [04:57] case. [05:00] >> But, you know, that's against the BBC's [05:01] editorial guidelines, which say that [05:03] presenters, reporters, and [05:04] correspondents, and on-air editors are [05:06] the public face and the voice of the [05:07] BBC. [05:08] >> You'll be expecting expecting a huge [05:09] sanction, I'm sure, on Jeremy Bowen. [05:12] >> absolutely not. But, they he definitely [05:13] shouldn't be uh giving these sorts of uh [05:16] comments. They they may provide [05:18] professional judgments rooted in [05:20] evidence, but they're not meant to uh [05:22] express personal views on such matters [05:24] publicly, even if it's not on the BBC [05:26] itself. So, I think that it's very [05:27] important uh that the BBC might act in [05:30] relation to that. Of course, they're not [05:31] going to. Uh and I mean, the BBC has got [05:33] plenty of other problems going on, as [05:35] well. I mean, there's news that uh [05:37] a man who was jailed for immigration [05:39] deception after a judge condemned his [05:41] deliberate extended manipulation of the [05:43] system is now the BBC's principal data [05:45] scientist for responsible AI. Yes. And [05:47] he helped shape how the corporation uses [05:50] AI and how news is represented through [05:52] it. I mean, this is a guy that's been [05:53] pictured with Moazzam Beg, the [05:55] ex-Guantanamo guy. So, I mean, the BBC [05:58] just day after day, there are so many [06:00] stories about things going on in there [06:02] that are rotten. [06:03] You know, once might be an accident, [06:05] twice or unfortunate, three, four, five, [06:08] 20, 50, 100 times, that's a habit. And [06:11] it seems to be a very rotten [06:12] institution, especially when it comes to [06:14] things to do with Israel and the Middle [06:16] East. [06:17] >> Uh let's talk about the Palestine poppy. [06:19] This is the Oxford-educated pediatrician [06:21] who's written books for Muslim teenagers [06:23] justifying stoning, warning [06:25] homosexuality is, as he puts it, a test [06:27] from Allah. [06:29] Abdul Kader Ismail, who was one of the [06:31] people behind the Zionism is racism [06:34] motion that the Green Party now has as [06:36] official party policy, has been accused [06:38] of trying to hijack Remembrance Day [06:40] after he began selling an enamel pin [06:42] shaped like a poppy in the colors of the [06:44] Palestinian flag flag for 1.78 on eBay. [06:48] Apparently, it's not for profit with the [06:49] money being donated to Gaza charities. [06:51] That in itself is something I would put [06:53] a question mark over. [06:55] Uh as I say, he's an active member of [06:56] Greens for Palestine. In his book, he [06:59] discusses religious punishments [07:00] including stoning, whipping, [07:02] crucifixion, amputation, describing them [07:04] as deterrents and writing that if [07:06] applied, there may be a blessing because [07:08] a person pays for their sins in this [07:10] life and avoid avoids punishment in the [07:12] afterlife. He describes same-sex [07:14] attraction as a test from Allah and says [07:16] homosexual relationships are wrong. He [07:18] writes, "Even if we have homosexual [07:20] feelings, we would not be able to act [07:21] upon them without displeasing Allah." He [07:24] also says transgender children should [07:26] pray for help and stop themselves from [07:28] acting on those feelings. I imagine the [07:32] likelihood of Jonathan Sacher Doty [07:34] buying one of these pins is sort of [07:36] about as negative as you can get. [07:38] But, should they be sold in the first [07:40] place in your opinion, Jonathan? [07:42] >> It looks more like one of those Pokémon [07:45] things to me. [07:45] >> I I will not be I will not be catching [07:47] them all. [07:48] >> No. Um, it doesn't look much like a [07:49] poppy, but listen, the idea that this [07:52] cause through any individual, especially [07:55] that sort, would try to hijack even [07:57] Poppy Day, [07:58] um, is just a preposterous one. And, but [08:01] I think it's just doing the job of [08:03] alienating most of the decent British [08:05] public who who don't want Palestine and [08:08] this cause, this Palestinianism, [08:10] intruding on literally everything in [08:12] their lives. Nothing uh [08:14] to to people who do stuff like this [08:15] seems to be sacred within British life. [08:17] I think it's as much uh a a the two [08:20] fingers up to uh what that represents [08:23] and and the gratitude that we share uh [08:27] in November for veterans in the UK. I [08:30] It's two fingers up to that, two fingers [08:32] up to the British forces, to the British [08:34] way of life, to what was protected and [08:36] saved by those veterans over the years. [08:39] Uh as it is anything to do with what [08:40] they think about Palestinians. Uh and I [08:43] think it does their cause an enormous [08:45] disservice to try and do things like [08:46] this which are designed to make as much [08:48] noise as possible, to be as offensive as [08:51] possible to ordinary decent British [08:53] people. Uh and and it really does no [08:54] good for people in in the area either in [08:57] the region. I mean, what on earth good [08:59] can this possibly do Mhm. uh to [09:01] Palestinians in in Gaza and in [09:04] elsewhere? It can do absolutely none. I [09:06] mean, that money will get, you know, [09:08] sucked up and lost somewhere in in cycle [09:11] of corruption that is the upper ends of [09:13] of representation in Palestinian society [09:16] and the NGOs there. And as for the PR [09:18] message, what a disaster. These people [09:21] are really I think they're really [09:22] testing the patience and the spirit of [09:25] ordinary decent British people who just [09:28] don't want any of this intruding into [09:29] absolutely every part of our lives. It's [09:32] enough. I think it's time that Britain [09:34] was freed from Palestine. [09:37] >> Thank you very much indeed, Jonathan [09:38] Sacerdoti there. I really appreciate you [09:41] joining us this evening, the writer and [09:42] broadcaster.