Transcript [00:09] Good evening. [00:11] It's a real privilege to be here. I want [00:13] to thank our gracious hosts, Rabbi and [00:15] Avital Goldschmidt, for opening up your [00:18] shul to us this evening. I also want to [00:20] thank Carolyn Rowan for your very kind [00:22] introduction [00:24] and for being the driving force behind [00:26] this event. [00:27] Um Carolyn is also one of the biggest [00:29] champions of Ruth Weiss that I know, and [00:31] in my circles there are many. [00:33] So that really says a lot. [00:36] This happens to be one of the fastest [00:37] growing shuls in New York City. I think [00:40] anyone who's come here on a Shabbat [00:42] morning and who's tried to find a seat [00:44] knows exactly what I what I'm talking [00:46] about. And I think that energy points to [00:49] something deeper. This is a shul that [00:52] stands for Jewish strength and Jewish [00:54] confidence. [00:55] And I think that's exactly what's so [00:56] exciting to New Yorkers, Jewish New [00:58] Yorkers today. [01:00] And it also makes it the perfect venue [01:02] for tonight's discussion. [01:05] As you all know, it's a defining moment [01:07] for the state of Israel. [01:09] Yesterday, Israelis voted for the first [01:11] time since October 7th, 2023, [01:14] and the outcome is going to shape the [01:16] next chapter of the nation's history. [01:19] But tonight, our focus is here at home. [01:22] As American Jews, how should we [01:24] understand this moment? [01:26] And how can we help America regain [01:29] its purpose and its confidence? [01:32] We're so fortunate to hear from Dr. Ruth [01:34] Weiss, who brings a deep understanding [01:36] of Jewish history [01:38] and the Jewish psyche, and whose [01:40] insights over the course of her life [01:42] have really so often proven prophetic. [01:45] Ruth, on behalf of all of us, thank you [01:47] for being here. [01:48] >> Thank you. This is [01:51] Thank you so much. [01:52] >> [applause] [01:55] >> I want to begin with the moment we find [01:58] ourselves in today and the Jewish [02:00] response in America to this moment. [02:03] It's a distressing one. We have our eyes [02:05] on our mayor. [02:07] We have our eyes on Michigan. I don't [02:08] need to elaborate. [02:10] But what's so interesting is that in [02:12] difficult moments like these there there [02:14] tends to be a Jewish tendency to look [02:17] inward, [02:18] to say things like if only we did a [02:19] better job telling our story, if only we [02:23] had a better social media strategy, if [02:25] only we got more politicians in America [02:27] to Israel, things would be better. [02:30] In your seminal book Choose Power, which [02:32] we're distributing this evening and I I [02:34] hope you all take a copy, you argue that [02:37] [clears throat] this instinct to look [02:38] inwards to be overly self-accountable is [02:41] actually an ancient instinct. [02:44] What is this impulse rooted in and is it [02:46] the right one? [02:48] >> Yeah, well, [02:50] I don't have to say that um [02:52] I think that almost everybody here if [02:55] you had been asked to come up here and [02:57] speak would have a lot to talk about [02:59] this evening and um [03:01] basically what I'm here is to [03:04] share my anxieties as it were with you, [03:07] but to try to clarify them and to bring [03:10] some clarity. That's the one thing that [03:12] we have to do [03:13] is um that's [clears throat] the one [03:15] thing that I'd like to emphasize more [03:17] than anything is the importance of [03:19] defining [03:21] this for ourselves. Everybody tries to [03:23] define us, including people like me, [03:27] including all the pan pundits and [03:29] pundits, [03:30] but it's very important to control [03:33] uh to know [03:35] everything that is happening from our [03:37] perspective. So firstly, look [03:40] um inward, do we turn inward and do we [03:44] turn inward positively or do we turn [03:46] inward critically or do we turn outward? [03:49] And this is basically [03:52] one of the questions and what Tikva has [03:55] done and what this show does is that it [03:58] knows that these two things are one and [04:00] the same. And this is really uh [04:03] our [04:04] this is our [04:06] mantra [04:07] that [04:08] we have to be for ourselves in order to [04:11] be able to be anything for the American [04:13] public or for anybody else. [04:15] So let me just say where I would start [04:19] here in this shul and with Tikvah. [04:22] This synagogue was not what it was four [04:24] or five years ago. This is a brand new [04:28] response to this moment and look what it [04:31] can do. [snorts] And individuals do [04:34] that. [04:35] This is not committee oriented. This is [04:37] Jews who do this for themselves and for [04:40] everyone else around them. So there's [04:42] this synagogue, Rabbi Goldschmidt and [04:45] I mean it's an amazing new creation. And [04:49] really to the people who were [04:52] involved with this building before, with [04:54] this institution before, who had the [04:57] foresight to be able to go on and really [04:59] create this synagogue, that is [05:00] marvelous. Tikvah itself, you see, is a [05:04] lifeline to me because I was at Harvard [05:08] and Harvard was of course a wonderful [05:10] place to be and a wonderful place to [05:12] teach. [05:13] But when Tikvah was created, it is a [05:15] different form of teaching. It's a [05:17] teaching the same works. You don't say [05:19] anything differently. You don't [05:21] interpret anything differently. But [05:23] here's the main difference. [05:25] At Harvard, I would tell the students in [05:27] classes in which the class was in [05:29] Yiddish, [05:30] I would say to them, the only legitimate [05:33] use of the first person plural pronoun [05:37] we [05:38] is [05:44] We only use the word we to define [05:47] ourselves as people who are reading the [05:49] texts. [05:50] But when I came to Tikvah, we would read [05:53] the same texts and we could say we are [05:57] reading this as Jews. [05:59] We are reading Jewish works as Jews. [06:02] Now if you think about it, [06:04] what are differences? The differences [06:06] that you feel yourself part of a [06:08] community. [06:10] And [06:11] one of the things that I didn't even [06:13] think I would get to, but think about [06:15] it. [06:16] Everybody here in America these days is [06:20] nervous, is apologetic [06:23] about being part of a community. [06:27] It's as if the idea of anti-Americanism [06:30] has become so strong and the idea of um [06:34] you know just who do you think you are [06:37] has become so strong that people [06:39] apologize. For example, you know schools [06:42] don't want to bring in legacy. [06:46] They don't want to give any points to a [06:48] legacy student who is applying to a [06:51] school. [06:53] Understand? It's gone that far. You [06:55] understand? What? [06:57] Just because your grandfather and your [07:01] father went to Harvard, you think you [07:04] have a [07:05] a point even in your favor so that you [07:08] should be able to go to this [07:09] institution? [07:11] Well, but look, we are a community that [07:12] lives on a completely different basis. [07:15] We say with pride, you were just saying [07:19] my parents you [laughter] know were in [07:21] the [07:22] were married in the [07:24] in in Prague, right? And of course, [07:29] where would one want to have one's [07:30] children married? In the where we were [07:33] married. And isn't that what you want to [07:35] perpetuate? Don't we want to perpetuate [07:37] community? So one of the things I think [07:40] that we have to stand for here is we [07:42] have to understand we stand for the joys [07:46] of a community. [07:47] That family is the kernel. The family [07:50] grows into the community. The community [07:53] grows into the larger community and that [07:55] is how you get to [07:58] America. That's how you understand the [08:00] American community. You don't understand [08:03] it because you don't want any two people [08:05] to fit together in the same paradigm. [08:08] No, you you know that it has to grow [08:10] organically, and it's never exclusive of [08:13] others. It's inclusive. So I think that [08:16] that dichotomy is something that I would [08:19] first like to, you know, sort of [08:21] address, that we have no shame of [08:24] calling ourselves Jews, and we have an [08:27] investment [clears throat] in the Jewish [08:29] community. And not only is that not [08:32] against Americanism, it is the paradigm [08:35] for Americanism. And if there's anything [08:37] wrong with America today more than [08:39] anything else, it's that Americans don't [08:42] have this sense of civic community. They [08:45] have no sense of it. You can get it [08:47] sometimes locally on a small basis. But [08:51] one has lost that. One doesn't even say [08:53] the Pledge of Allegiance with great [08:56] pride. You see, maybe hockey teams, [08:59] sports is the one arena where people are [09:01] able to express this in terms of their [09:04] team, their But you see how much people [09:06] need that. You can see how needy they [09:09] are by the way in which one reacts to [09:11] sports events. So that's just a general [09:14] I wasn't even thinking of going to here, [09:16] but [09:17] when you said the elections which we [09:19] will maybe get to in some way, [09:22] I'm always worried that we lose the big [09:24] picture. [09:25] So if you see people of my age, of my [09:28] age, invited usually to speak to people, [09:32] right? [09:33] Um the main especially to students, what [09:36] are they invited to talk about? [09:39] They're invited to talk about their [09:40] experiences in the Holocaust. [09:43] How did you survive the Holocaust? [09:45] What did Now that very important and [09:48] that generation is of course our [09:50] generation's completely, you know, [09:53] almost gone. [09:55] But I find it so perplexing. [09:58] See, I would like to go [10:00] and I bear witness to something which is [10:04] the most amazing thing to me in the [10:06] history of Jewish civilization and in [10:08] the history of world civilization. [10:11] And I think I'm not exaggerating. [10:14] Um, [10:15] I was alive [10:17] at the creation of the state of Israel, [10:21] the resurrection of the state of Israel, [10:23] which had been under foreign domination [10:26] for 2,000 years. [10:29] Now, [10:30] we live in this time. [10:33] I mean, we [10:34] we are [10:36] we live to attest to something which is [10:38] miraculous. Do we know how many [10:40] generations of Jews would have done [10:43] anything to live at a time when you had [10:46] a Jewish state alive, a living Jewish [10:49] state? So, this is something that we [10:52] should carry with us as a You know, we [10:54] don't go around saying, gee, you know, I [10:57] live in miraculous times. Of course not. [10:59] But it is a consciousness that one [11:01] should have and transmit to one's [11:04] children, never to take this for [11:06] granted. This is really extraordinary. [11:09] And um, you know, I said this before [11:13] uh, [11:13] it struck me very much. We live among [11:16] Christians. We take Christianity very, [11:19] very seriously. And Christians believe [11:23] that Jesus was resurrected on the third [11:26] day. And you know how much art and music [11:29] and passion is consecrated to the fact [11:32] of that resurrection. [11:34] Well, I would like to [11:36] remind ourselves [11:39] that in 1945, [11:42] Second World War came to an end. [11:45] And um, [11:47] Dwight Eisenhower [11:50] and other Americans [11:52] came and what they saw was [11:55] what was left of European Jewish [11:57] civilization. [11:59] The ashes at Mauthausen, [12:02] corpses at Bergen-Belsen and at and at [12:06] Dachau. [12:08] [laughter] [12:08] It was it was horrifying, right? [12:12] Um, [12:13] three years later, three years, [12:17] the Jewish state was resurrected, [12:20] was reborn. [12:22] Now, [12:23] this is the people we're talking about. [12:25] This This is who This is our people. We [12:28] have a share in that, [12:30] you know, and and that is so precious. [12:33] So whatever we you know, and it and [12:36] everybody in a sense it is because it is [12:39] so central and because it is so precious [12:42] that it becomes also the target for all [12:44] the animus against it. [12:47] And so we have like two [12:49] jobs in one. [12:51] Uh, [12:52] of course they're so closely [12:54] interrelated. The first is to know that, [12:57] to carry that positive knowledge with us [12:59] and to build on it, [13:01] really. And to repeat it to ourselves. [13:04] You know, [13:07] says the prayer, right? That this is the [13:10] the beginning, the kernel of our [13:13] redemption. [13:14] Nobody says that Israel, the creation of [13:17] Israel was the redemption. In fact, Jews [13:19] have a great suspicion. As much as they [13:21] really ask for the [13:23] you know that the Talmud is as worried [13:26] about the [13:27] coming as it is about forgetting to pray [13:30] for the coming of the [13:32] So we live in a [13:33] very strange but we know that the state [13:37] of Israel really is the beginning [13:39] because of what I'm saying. [13:41] You see, [13:43] um, [13:46] what had happened in in Europe was [13:48] basically uh, not a Jewish story at all. [13:52] I mean for us it's a Jewish story. It's [13:54] a story of our [13:55] greatest [13:58] you know, one of one of the greatest [14:01] And you know in Yiddish [14:04] the word [14:04] is the word that you use for the [14:06] destruction of the first temple and the [14:08] second temple. And of course it's the [14:10] same word that you use for the [14:11] Holocaust. It's the [14:13] And so that connection is very [14:15] straightforward. It's a great, great, [14:18] great catastrophe, [14:20] right? [14:21] And then, you know, we have [14:25] the fact that [14:27] the state [14:29] comes into being [14:31] very soon afterwards, not as a [14:33] substitute of any kind, but to say that [14:36] the death does not define it. [14:39] The problem is [14:40] that it really had nothing to do with [14:43] the Jews. [14:45] This was done to us, but it is the story [14:48] of Germany. [14:50] And then we come to the second part. [14:52] Jews [14:53] are marvelous, [14:55] but when we stood at Sinai, [14:58] we stood alone. [15:00] I was at Sinai, and I climbed Mount [15:02] Sinai. This was unbelievable. [15:05] And when you are there [15:07] in that nothingness, you can really feel [15:11] the reality of how a people can actually [15:14] be there, how Moses can go up on the [15:16] mountain, how he can bring down the [15:17] commandments, and how a people can be [15:19] shaped by this. It is amazing. But over [15:23] the years, what has occurred to me [15:26] more than anything is that [15:29] something goes along with that that we [15:30] were not prepared for, [15:32] that you have to carry the Torah, [15:35] but you have to carry it among the [15:36] nations. [15:38] It would be wonderful if we were the [15:41] only people who lived, [15:43] or better still, if everyone else were [15:45] like us, [15:47] or even better than us. [15:49] Wouldn't that be wonderful if all the [15:51] nations of the world were not only not [15:52] Noahide laws, but better than we are? [15:56] We would dream of such a day, [15:58] right? [15:59] But in the meantime, we carry the Torah [16:03] and the civilization of the Torah among [16:05] the nations. [16:07] And one of the nations was Germany. [16:10] And I think one of the things I would [16:11] like to repeat about the second part, [16:13] which now it becomes dangerous about [16:15] America too, [16:17] what happened to Germany? Germany was [16:20] the model. It was not only the center of [16:22] Europe, but it was civilization itself. [16:26] Bach, [16:28] Beethoven, Brahms, [16:30] Kant, Hegel, [16:32] I mean the art, [16:34] the music, the philosophy, the thought, [16:38] Goethe, Schiller, [16:41] I mean the Ninth Symphony, you know, and [16:44] the Ode to Joy. [16:46] Well, the way in which I see it is what [16:48] antisemitism came to Germany in 1870. [16:52] Antisemitism was formed, and what it [16:55] said was the Jews. [16:57] And it really came to power. [17:00] It was the most dynamic ideology in [17:05] modern political history. [17:07] Formed in 1870, the Antisemitic League, [17:11] which called itself that, [17:13] elected its first mayor by the end of [17:15] the century, brought Hitler to power. In [17:18] the 19th 1933, he was already chancellor [17:22] of Germany, and then of course the Nazi [17:24] party was ready to be the [17:27] Third Reich and conquer Europe. [17:30] So you see what antisemitism did to [17:32] Germany? [17:34] It took that [17:36] amazing country [17:38] and it brought it to absolute ruin. And [17:41] the way I see it is it went from [17:44] Schiller to Schicklgruber, [17:47] which is Hitler's name, [17:49] from the uh Ode to Joy to the [17:52] Horst Wessel song. [17:55] That is that is the story of the [17:57] Holocaust. [17:59] So I would just say that uh and that is [18:02] going to be the story of America if [18:05] antisemitism takes root. [18:08] You see? [18:09] So it is the other side of the coin [18:12] to be that great nation [18:15] and to stand for civilization in our own [18:17] quiet, personal way. But we live among [18:21] the nations. So you have to be able to [18:23] accept the principle of coexistence with [18:26] us. That's the only principle you have [18:28] to accept. [18:29] Cuz we'll adjust. We'll learn your [18:31] language. We'll adjust to your thing. [18:34] But what you have to do is you have to [18:36] accept the principle of coexistence. [18:38] And the society that uses instead, uses [18:42] the Jew as the person there destroys [18:45] itself. We can talk about why that [18:48] happened. It's not a miracle. I mean, [18:51] antisemitism is very destructive. [18:54] Its purpose is destructive, to destroy. [18:57] It organizes around the principle of [18:59] destruction. It thinks it's destroying [19:02] the Jews, but it destroys what the Jews [19:04] stand for, etc., etc. [19:06] So when we stand for ourselves, we have [19:09] to know why we do, but we also have to [19:12] have the courage to stand against. [19:15] Do we ever have to stand against? [19:19] And uh here let me just you know I [19:22] can't remember everything, but I wrote [19:24] down this uh [19:26] and sometimes you write down things [19:28] which you admire very much. But uh the [19:31] Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, [19:33] who is herself Jewish, and I'm sure that [19:36] you're all nodding because you [19:37] understand and you've all heard this and [19:39] read this and sha- shaken your heads. So [19:42] she tells the Michigan Democratic Jewish [19:44] Caucus the Jews have, and I quote, a [19:47] moral imperative to place the needs of [19:50] the world above even our own [19:53] self-interest and yes, even above our [19:56] own survival. [19:59] See? [20:00] Now this sounds like [20:02] Tikkun Olam. [20:04] Right? This is really uh right? [20:08] But you know what it's really saying? [20:11] We have a moral purpose to bring Hitler [20:14] to power. [20:15] We have a moral purpose to destroy [20:18] America. That's what it really means. [20:21] If If stand for ourselves, who are we [20:23] standing for? We are standing for the [20:25] people who are against us. [20:27] And that's no joke. [20:29] We're not standing for something better, [20:31] higher. We're standing for something [20:34] incredibly more dangerous and more [20:37] destructive of our society. You see? So [20:41] so these two things really are so so [20:45] closely [20:47] combined. And [20:49] and the first is so important [20:52] because it's the only way that you have [20:54] the strength to fight off the second and [20:57] all the lying and inversions [21:00] and [21:02] you see the wickedness [21:04] that goes with being against the Jews. [21:08] >> So back to Jews in power, another [21:09] question you explore is whether or not [21:12] democracy is good for the Jews. [21:14] We are all pro-democracy and we [21:16] understand that democracy has brought [21:18] tremendous opportunity and flourishing, [21:20] but you point to a darker side that [21:23] poses unique challenges to Jewish [21:25] existence, one we don't think about as [21:27] often. [21:28] What is that darker side? [21:31] >> Well, look, I mean, I I think that we [21:33] see it very clearly. [21:36] We don't want anything but democracy. I [21:38] mean, obviously. And Jews have democracy [21:42] built into us, you know. Many of the [21:43] principles of a democratic society are [21:46] Jewish principles, right? The kind of [21:49] individuality [21:51] that our way of life calls for, [21:54] individual accountability, [21:56] the rule of law, which is certainly [21:59] something which is fundamental to the [22:00] Jews. Much of the United States of [22:02] America [22:03] is drawn from actually Jewish Hebraic [22:06] sources. And this is a great [22:08] contribution that Tikva is making, by [22:10] the way, talking about the Hebraic [22:14] sources of American civilization. We [22:16] should know that as well. [22:19] So [22:20] of course [22:21] democ- but you see that because [22:23] democracy depends on [22:26] the rule of the people, the governance [22:28] of the people, [22:30] by the people, for the people, [22:33] of the people. [22:35] Um, populism is built into it. [22:38] And by populism, you know, it is [22:42] anything that can sell to a large [22:46] public. [22:47] So it's very interesting in Yiddish. [22:49] I've been [clears throat] teaching my [22:51] grandchildren some of my mother's [22:54] sayings, and the Yiddish sayings are so [22:56] many, but here's a very interesting [22:58] thing about this saying. Yiddish has two [23:00] sayings. The same saying, you can say it [23:03] in the positive and you can say it in [23:04] the negative. And not one is not more [23:07] important than the other one. So you say [23:12] That is the public is a [23:15] dummy, right? The public are fools, you [23:18] can say it. [23:19] And then you say [23:24] The public is no fool. [23:26] [laughter] [23:27] So which is it? [23:29] And that's the choice that democracy [23:31] gives us, to be fools or to be no fools, [23:35] you know, not to be fools. [23:37] So [23:38] you know, that is kind of [23:42] wouldn't say of course that's always the [23:44] side that's going to be exploited, and [23:46] we know how much now social media [23:49] contributes to that possibility of [23:52] somebody coming and [23:54] really [23:56] selling lies, [23:57] really changing the language. We see [24:00] this happening to us all the time. [24:04] So we have to fight very hard [24:07] for democracy, but the main thing in [24:10] democracy [24:12] is the [24:16] reinforcement [24:18] of [24:19] what it is, the teaching of it. [24:22] You have to be very careful in a [24:24] democracy. You see, when you have an [24:27] authoritarian ruler, let's take some of [24:30] the Arab countries. [24:32] Very dangerous some of them, but look at [24:34] that. You look at Saudi Arabia and you [24:37] think, gee, if only MBS is really good, [24:42] you know, he can change it overnight. [24:45] You know, if only China gets another [24:47] ruler, [24:49] hey, there's hope. [24:52] It's so amazing that countries that are [24:54] run by [24:57] despots and countries that are run by [25:00] authoritarian rulers, you can see that [25:02] sometimes it feels so I know they're [25:05] called communist countries, but they're [25:06] run by despotic rulers, you know. So [25:10] you know, you [25:11] you [25:12] you see how simple it is, presumably, [25:16] how how much easier it is to keep order, [25:18] how much easier it is to get things [25:20] done. [25:21] So a democracy is difficult, and we know [25:24] this from our experience. [25:26] You teach you teach the children. Do you [25:29] know that in Khader that much despised [25:32] Khader because it was much wrong with [25:34] the Khadorum of Eastern Europe. There [25:36] was so much critical literature about [25:38] the Khadorum of Eastern Europe. But you [25:40] know what book they began with in grade [25:43] with children in grade [25:44] who came at the age of three. [25:48] What did they begin with? [25:50] Leviticus. [25:52] Not Genesis. They began to teach [25:55] Leviticus because you want the law. And [25:58] I wonder here, you know, we don't teach [26:00] our children law. We kids go to law [26:02] school. Why shouldn't kids in grade one [26:05] and two study laws of [26:11] how to cross cross the street, [26:13] transportation laws, laws that relate to [26:15] them in some ways, right? Family law. [26:18] There's no concept here of really [26:21] inculcating the democratic teachings, [26:24] how the state is formed. These I and [26:27] America is absolutely miraculous. [26:31] It took so much time for a democracy [26:33] like America to be created. This is very [26:36] very precious. [26:38] You know, it's only been here 250 years. [26:42] But I can just tell you from having been [26:44] in the academy, [26:46] if the academy does not take this [26:48] seriously, [26:50] you see, and it did not, [26:52] does not take this seriously. It does [26:55] not teach American history seriously as [26:57] if this is our country, therefore we [26:59] have to know everything about the way in [27:01] which it was created. The best teachers [27:03] have to be out there teaching the [27:05] American democracy and the way of life. [27:07] The Constitution has to be taught to [27:10] everybody, especially students from [27:12] foreign countries who come here to [27:14] learn. There You see, there's there's [27:16] there's no sense of um So democracy is [27:20] great, but the idea of how much it takes [27:24] you have to understand that if you have [27:26] a democratic system, you have to be that [27:29] much more invested in things like [27:31] teaching from the ground up and in all [27:34] the institutional parts that make it [27:36] work. [27:37] >> I want to shift now to what Jews can [27:39] teach Americans. [27:42] You've pointed out that the central [27:43] message of the Passover Seder is that, [27:46] and I'm going to quote you, the price of [27:47] freedom is gratitude. [27:49] We are in the freest country [27:52] in history and we're seeing more [27:54] grievance [27:55] and less gratitude than almost anywhere [27:57] in the West. [27:59] Why is that and how can we inspire our [28:01] neighbors to feel gratitude over [28:03] grievance? [28:05] >> Well, that is um [28:08] I don't know how you change things [28:10] except by example again. [28:14] Um [28:15] You know um [28:18] Let me just I think that this is really [28:21] one of the most crucial things about the [28:23] the question of democracy as well, and [28:25] that is gratitude. [28:28] This is one of the most important things [28:29] that the Jews have, [28:31] and that is um the blessings. [28:35] Now [28:37] I This is a an orthodox synagogue. [28:40] And I don't know what the levels of [28:41] observance are among all people here. [28:44] Probably as different as as many of you [28:46] as there are, that's how many different [28:48] levels of observance there are. That's [28:50] what That's what That's what it is to be [28:52] a Jew, even an orthodox Jew. Um we used [28:55] to call ourselves [28:57] non-practicing orthodox Jews. [29:00] Just not to be funny either, but [29:04] it caught up with us and we became more [29:06] and more and more observant as time went [29:08] on. The most important part of that is [29:11] you wake up in the morning and you say [29:15] I stand here and you bless. [29:17] And the men who put on tefillin, [29:20] the blessings that they say, and we [29:22] bless the food that we eat. [29:26] And we bless [29:29] We have blessings for everything. We [29:31] kiss the mezuzah and we bless. [29:34] What does that create? [29:36] You know, you just say it It's funny. [29:37] People say it's only paying lip service. [29:42] You know, I take that phrase now it [29:44] occurs to me [29:45] it's a very serious thing, pay lip [29:47] service. [29:49] By all means. [29:50] Yes, children in the morning should have [29:55] an assembly in school [29:57] that takes some form of blessing. [30:00] Bless the country that you live in. In a [30:03] Jewish day school it would be Jewish [30:04] blessings. Definitely to inculcate pay [30:07] it lip service. [30:10] And um [30:11] and one is so grateful for that. You [30:14] know, [30:15] in my I did not grow up in an orthodox [30:17] family, a very Jewish family, but it [30:20] wasn't an observant family in any way. [30:22] And I went to a summer camp at some [30:25] point which was a Hebrew summer camp. [30:27] And there you said the blessing [30:30] after the meals and you said the [30:32] blessings on Shabbat and so on. So I [30:34] learned how to say the blessings after [30:36] the meals. I would not have known them [30:37] otherwise. [30:39] Do you know what it is really? We don't [30:41] do it all the time, but when there is a [30:43] when there are people around, when it is [30:45] Shabbat for sure, and when there are [30:47] people [30:48] after a meal, [30:49] people together bless. Now, [30:53] some people say it so quickly you think, [30:55] oh, nobody means this, nobody means [30:57] this. And when you're young, you're so [30:59] worried about authenticity. [31:01] Oh, this is hypocritical. This is [31:03] authenticity. Well, [31:05] I have to say I've stopped worrying [31:07] about that. [31:08] Doesn't matter. [31:10] You say it, and then it becomes real. [31:13] If you say the words, and if you do it [31:15] often enough, that's how the gratitude [31:17] grows. [31:18] And if there and and and this is so, you [31:21] know, really crucial. [31:23] Um I I even, you know, [31:26] um digress a little bit, you know, [31:28] students [31:30] would come to me sometimes at at [31:32] Harvard, which was very gratifying, but [31:34] they sometimes wanted to ask you more [31:37] than just about [31:38] and they thought that you were some kind [31:39] of an expert in life because you taught [31:42] them literature. And I would try to say, [31:44] look, I'm not that, I'm not that, but [31:46] still you think oh. So people would ask [31:50] me about observance, [31:52] about observance. [31:54] And [31:55] so I [31:56] would sometimes level with them and say, [31:58] well, about this question of gratitude, [32:02] uh for me um it was before our second [32:06] child was born. [32:08] Uh we had our we had moved into our [32:10] first home. [32:12] And um [32:14] I was about, you know, couple of months [32:16] before giving birth to him. [32:19] And my husband and I decided that we [32:21] would like to make Shabbat. [32:23] We'd never made Shabbat. We'd have to [32:25] make Shabbat. So he would learn the [32:27] blessings. He would make kiddush. [32:30] And um [32:32] and I would bless the candles, which of [32:35] course my mother had occasionally done [32:36] whenever the spirit spirit moved her. [32:39] But but I would do it regularly. [32:43] So I had to light the candles. Okay, [32:45] this is me [32:47] in my [32:49] at the age of 30 or 31. [32:51] How can I do this? [32:54] I don't know I don't know God. [32:56] I have no idea of God. [32:58] This goes back. [33:01] How do you say [33:05] Blessed art thou, oh God, [33:07] when you have no [33:09] feel no [33:10] don't know what God is. [33:13] It's a real [33:14] you know, everybody should have such [33:15] problems, right? This should be the [33:18] biggest problem of your life. But [33:19] anyway, I took it very seriously. [33:22] And then suddenly it occurred to me I [33:24] had to do it. So even if it was not [33:27] going to be meaningful, I was going to [33:28] do it. But I didn't want it not to be [33:30] meaningful. And to me that idea of being [33:32] a hypocrite or not meaning it [33:35] it was too important. It ceased By the [33:37] way, let me tell you, at this point it [33:39] has ceased to have any importance for me [33:41] whatsoever. I am just so happy to say [33:44] whatever prayers or whatever things are [33:46] and and the spirit comes through them. [33:49] But it bothered me then and it occurred [33:51] to me [33:52] that I knew [33:54] the God of my forefathers [33:57] because I, you know, used Yiddish texts [34:00] too and I had Yiddish prayer books. [34:02] Somehow I knew what my grandmothers and [34:06] grandfathers whom I I didn't know any of [34:08] my grandparents ever, [34:10] but I had a sense of who their God was. [34:13] A very, very, very real sense of who [34:17] that [34:18] was. And I thought, I can pray to that [34:23] I can. [34:25] You know, I know that God. [34:27] And [clears throat] so [34:29] you know, that is how important it was [34:32] to me [34:33] to [34:35] have a context for gratitude. [34:39] You see, this is so odd. Some people [34:41] think of prayers [34:43] as asking for. [34:46] And I can understand that. If you are a [34:48] deprived in some way, [34:51] then what you want is to pray in the [34:53] sense of oh, please God. And now we know [34:56] that we pray for the health of so many [34:58] people. And we pray for the welfare of [35:00] people. And we pray there's so many [35:02] things to ask for, to pray for, to pray [35:04] for. But for me, it was the opposite. [35:07] I needed a context to express gratitude [35:11] for what was given that I did not earn. [35:15] You see? [35:16] I mean, I worked hard and I earn things. [35:19] But a child [35:21] coming into the world and having a [35:23] child, there are certain things that [35:25] that that are not earned. [35:28] And and if you have those blessings, you [35:30] have to bless for them. You have to give [35:33] thanks. [35:35] Um [35:36] and that enriches you. [35:39] And um and if you and now we see the [35:42] again, everything has its opposite. If [35:44] you don't have that, what you get is a [35:47] culture of grievance. So you we have to [35:50] turn that teach that to America. They [35:53] have Thanksgiving. And there are people [35:55] who have said, you know, we should do at [35:58] Thanksgiving what Jews do at Passover. [36:00] We should have a Thanksgiving Haggadah. [36:03] Something that we read. And there are [36:04] people who've done that, who've made [36:06] these Thanksgiving Haggadot. [36:09] I don't think it's a bad idea for us as [36:10] Americans either, [36:12] perhaps, [36:13] to turn our Thanksgiving into something [36:17] I don't know. Some families probably do [36:19] that already. [36:20] But um [36:22] and by the way, this is not strictly [36:24] Jewish. I mean, [36:25] one of the programs that I uh [36:28] um [36:29] am jealous of, let me say, is Blue [36:32] Bloods. [36:35] Does anybody here watch Blue Bloods or [36:36] know it? [36:38] Okay. Catholic family of uh [36:43] a a dynasty of [36:45] right? You understand why I'm jealous of [36:48] it? [36:49] Because that family, almost every single [36:52] episode, that family is around a table [36:55] and somebody is [36:58] starting the meal with a blessing. [37:00] That's what they do. [37:02] They say grace, [37:04] right? So this is not [37:06] we have something to draw on in that, [37:08] but this is something huge that we could [37:11] bring if we if we speak about it, if we [37:14] know this is one of our strengths, and [37:16] if one enforces it. [37:18] >> So you touched on this earlier, but I [37:20] want to revisit it because it's so [37:22] important [37:24] and will really help us understand our [37:26] role in the American story and where we [37:28] need to go from here. [37:30] So you've made a brilliant and quite [37:32] countercultural observation that Israel [37:35] built one Yad Vashem and constructed [37:38] conscripted thousands of young people to [37:40] fight for their country. [37:42] And in America we did the opposite. We [37:43] built 100 Yad Vashems and we did not [37:46] train our children to fight for the war [37:48] at home, which is the war of ideas. [37:52] Why did we make this error and how can [37:54] we correct this? [37:56] >> Oh, [37:58] well, we know why we made this error. [38:03] I mean, there are many reasons, and [38:04] they're all good reasons. Look, I knew [38:07] Elie Wiesel [38:09] personally, not very well, but I admired [38:12] him greatly, and he was a great man and [38:17] from the age of nine, personally, I went [38:20] to memorials. My parents as soon as [38:23] there was a memorial for [38:26] the dead of Vilna, [38:28] my parents would take me. In Montreal at [38:31] the time you had memorials for the [38:32] individual cities, regions, and you [38:35] certainly had a community-wide [38:37] organizational memorial every year. [38:41] I mean, those were the most [38:44] [sighs] [38:47] well, I guess [38:48] from an emotional point of view, the [38:50] most overwhelming experiences, because [38:52] there were always like over they were [38:54] always in the springtime, like in April, [38:56] like the because they did it usually in [38:59] coordination with the uprising in the [39:01] Warsaw ghetto became the occasion for [39:03] many of these official memorials. And [39:05] they were overheated rooms and [39:08] overheated people. [39:10] And and they were [39:12] extraordinary. And and we memorialize. [39:16] Listen, [39:17] we [laughter] we you know, the summer [39:18] months are spent, you know, [39:20] Mendel Moher Sforim, one of my favorite [39:22] Yiddish writers, [39:25] [laughter] has all these funny episodes [39:27] where [39:28] the somebody is riding in the through [39:31] the countryside, a Jewish wagoner is [39:33] riding through the countryside, and what [39:34] does he see? Berries everywhere. And [39:39] peasants carrying wonderful things, and [39:41] the sun is shining, and all the rest of [39:43] it. And of course, he is fasting because [39:45] it is [39:46] [laughter] it is the days before [39:48] Tisha B'Av, a long period before Tisha [39:51] B'Av. So for him, it you know, it was [39:53] all the opposite. We still mourn. We [39:56] mourn the dead of the [39:59] who were killed in Jerusalem. [40:01] So [40:02] so we are people that we mourn. We mourn [40:06] our dead. And mourning our dead was the [40:08] way in which we knew that we would [40:10] reclaim the land that they died for, [40:12] right? So [40:14] so [40:15] part of it was because of mourning. But [40:17] the big mistake that was made is [40:20] that the memorials should have been [40:23] private, [40:25] internal. [40:27] No matter how many we did, it would [40:29] maybe not be enough for all the people [40:31] who needed it. [40:33] And we needed that. [40:35] And but the people, [40:37] you know, they wanted to tell their [40:39] story somehow. [40:41] And let me just say that one of the [40:43] reasons that that story sold so well is [40:46] because it is a Christian story. [40:51] Jews, I'm sorry, Christianity believes [40:54] in some way [40:56] that to see [40:59] uh the resurrection, to see Jesus on the [41:02] cross [41:04] is redemptive. [41:07] I mean, Christianity is built in some [41:09] way around the idea [41:12] that [41:13] that is a redemptive story. [41:16] That the death and resurrection of Jesus [41:18] is a redemptive story. [41:21] And so, [41:23] by analogy, [41:24] the killing and [41:26] of the Jews, like a million, 6 million [41:30] Jesuses on the cross. [41:32] Wow. [41:34] That is really [41:36] That makes us into really uh [41:38] That is a redemptive story. [41:41] But it's not a Jewish story. [41:44] The Jewish story is not We never [41:47] believed the death was redemptive. [41:51] Our Passover story, you tell the story [41:54] of the suffering [41:56] for the very first part of the Seder. [42:00] Tell it as I say, you take it very [42:02] seriously. You tell it seriously, but [42:05] it's there for the sake of the second [42:07] part. It's there for the sake of passing [42:10] over, to tell the story of how you you [42:13] came out of Egypt. [42:16] You know, the point of it is to get out, [42:18] to get out into the light, to say the [42:20] opposite. So, one of two stories we [42:22] could have told through the Holocaust is [42:25] very important. One is to tell the story [42:27] of [42:28] the the evil of anti-Semitism, which the [42:31] Holocaust Museum doesn't did not permit [42:34] to be told. [42:36] Do you know that it not did not allow [42:38] books on anti-Semitism to be sold in the [42:42] in in the [42:44] in in in the bookstore [42:46] because it was not to be political? [42:48] As if the killing of the Jews in Europe [42:51] was anything but political. It was a [42:53] political story, not a theological [42:56] story. [42:57] And if it's theological, it's not my [42:59] theology, and it's not our theology, you [43:02] [clears throat] see. [43:03] But it [43:04] it fit into something larger. [43:07] And uh [43:09] and it's very painful because of course [43:11] now it's being turned against us. [43:13] Everything of it is being turned again. [43:15] No, now you're the Nazis. Now you're the [43:18] genocidal. Everything is being turned [43:21] against us like you know just as if it [43:23] was ready-made to be turned in the other [43:25] direction. [43:26] So we have to fight, you know, that that [43:29] reverse order. [43:31] But why we understand why and I I don't [43:35] retroactively, please believe me, [43:37] retroactively I would never find fault [43:40] with [43:41] any of the people who did this with the [43:43] best of intentions [43:45] and who were, you know, [43:48] who wanted to, [43:49] you know, [43:52] you know, [43:53] who wanted to just get it the story out [43:55] there. But the story has to be we have [43:57] to tell the right thing about it. You [44:00] have to tell about the evil of what [44:02] destroyed Germany. [44:04] And and if we're going to tell the [44:06] Jewish story, you tell the story not the [44:08] story only of what happened in Europe, [44:11] but you tell the story of the [44:12] infrastructure that was there. [44:14] Those people who were not killed and [44:17] those people who had already created the [44:20] movement [44:21] of return and reclamation of the land of [44:23] Israel. That's our story. [44:26] Our story really is that [44:28] So you know maybe we maybe we change it. [44:30] We say the story of uh [44:33] the Holocaust and rebirth. [44:35] Or you know just have to add it. [44:38] Say we want to change the museum to call [44:40] it the museum of the Holocaust and [44:42] Resurrection. And this is for America's [44:44] sake. [44:46] But you have to we have to somehow make [44:49] sure that [44:50] [clears throat] we move the needle as it [44:52] were. [44:53] >> Yes, we model them after We model, yes, [44:55] exactly. [44:56] >> So I I think it's only appropriate to [44:58] end with literature, which has been your [45:00] greatest teacher. [45:02] >> So [45:02] >> pointed out to me that a novel might [45:04] occupy only a few inches on a shelf, but [45:07] it can be a touchstone for how we live [45:09] our lives and the greatest vehicle for [45:11] telling the truth. [45:13] So I can't end this conversation without [45:15] asking you, if you could put a novel on [45:17] the bookshelf of every Jewish family in [45:20] America, what would it be and why? [45:23] >> Well, Mira, who is here, a teacher, has [45:25] brought a copy of a modern Jewish canon [45:28] to remind me that I once wrote a book uh [45:31] based on causes that I had given [45:33] [laughter] [45:34] about the great books that one would [45:36] read. So it's a very it's a very thank [45:39] you. So show and tell. That's a very um [45:43] well, because John Silver of uh [45:46] our colleague at Tikvah reminded me that [45:49] it is the 150th anniversary of [45:53] to my mind one of the all time greatest [45:58] novels ever written and ever written for [46:01] the Jews, and that is Daniel Deronda by [46:05] George Eliot. It is quite huge and um I [46:09] have to say that um [46:12] I think that my children have finally [46:14] made their way through it somehow. [46:17] >> It's in the Emet curriculum, so Carl is [46:20] going to read it in a little [laughter] [46:21] >> All right, so she's going to read it. [46:22] It's it's not an easy book, but it is a [46:25] marvelous book, and it's such a [46:26] strangely amazing Well, George Eliot was [46:29] a brilliant, brilliant novelist. This [46:31] was her last novel. [46:33] And this is a novel about England. [46:36] And um it's basically her worry was, [46:39] what is liberalism [46:42] doing to England? She was a liberal of [46:44] England, but she wanted she saw all the [46:46] problems that you see today. [46:49] And she just saw that she was worried [46:52] that the idea of becoming more and more [46:54] and more liberal [46:57] could go in a wrong direction, you see, [47:00] like democracy. So the book begins, I [47:02] won't tell you about the whole book, but [47:04] anyway, we did a series of talks about [47:06] it, but um the book begins [47:10] uh [47:11] with a magnificent [clears throat] [47:12] first paragraph. So if you read nothing [47:14] else, you can read the first paragraph. [47:16] And there's uh [47:18] it's a young man [47:20] um is uh he's a Brit [47:24] and he is overseas. He's in Europe and [47:27] he's at a gambling casino at a hotel [47:29] which has a gambling casino. [47:31] And he sees a woman at the gambling [47:33] table who's in the process of winning at [47:35] the moment. [47:36] And he sees her [47:38] and he is attracted to her. [47:41] And it says she's so beautiful. [47:44] But wait a minute. [47:45] Beauty, why is it that this is beauty [47:50] um [47:50] that the that it is compelling [47:54] but the whole heart is not filled with [47:57] longing [47:58] for something good. [48:01] Why is it that in that beauty that he's [48:03] attracted to [48:05] that it seems to be compulsion that is [48:07] drawing him rather than something that [48:09] which I can't quote, I'm sorry. I should [48:11] have brought the quotation about who who [48:13] knew uh [48:14] that it's the whole heart in which the [48:16] whole heart consents and longs. [48:20] That's the opening. [48:22] So that's the story and the book is [48:24] called Daniel Deronda because it is [48:26] about the young man. [48:28] But [48:30] this book got people so excited that F. [48:33] R. Leavis, who is one of the great uh [48:36] critics who taught at Cambridge [48:38] University and who wrote about the novel [48:41] and the 19th century novel, he said that [48:44] the book had no right to be called [48:46] Daniel Deronda. It should have been [48:48] called Gwendolen Harleth because he felt [48:51] that [48:52] Daniel Deronda part of the book was [48:55] garbage [48:56] and that the main part of the book was [48:58] about the heroine. [48:59] So you see, it's about this man and the [49:01] woman, and you would think that this is [49:04] constructed so that what has to happen? [49:07] Obviously. They could go through a [49:09] thousand things, but they have to get [49:11] together at the end. No? Isn't that what [49:13] it is? [49:15] Or a tragedy, one of them dies. Is it [49:17] this? [49:18] No. No. I'll tell you what happens. [49:22] Daniel Deronda discovers that he's a [49:24] Jew. [49:27] And he discovers what it is to be a Jew. [49:30] And at the end [49:32] yeah, in [49:33] 1876 [49:35] he goes to Israel, to the land of [49:37] Israel. [49:39] But after having built I mean that this [49:41] is not the supply. Why? How? What this [49:45] means? And what this means for Gwendolen [49:48] Harleth? Because the most amazing thing [49:50] is not just the story of Daniel Deronda [49:53] and how he discovers his Jewishness. The [49:55] great thing for George Eliot was that [49:58] England understands that the Jew has to [50:02] have a land of his own. [50:05] See? This is what she comes to see. She [50:08] wants him for herself. [50:10] The British in that book are very [50:13] accommodating. [50:14] It's not that they hate the Jews, they [50:16] want to expel the Jews. No. They want [50:18] the Jews to become like them. But why [50:20] can't you convert and be like us? We [50:22] would love you to become part of our [50:24] family. We want you to become part of [50:27] our family. George Eliot understood that [50:30] that was not the liberalism that she [50:32] needed, that she wanted. The test of [50:34] liberalism for her is if you could [50:37] accept the Jews as Jews. [50:41] And [clears throat] that is really the [50:43] gist of this novel. Amazing. Just [50:47] amazing. It just [50:49] So you can imagine that [50:52] in [laughter] the the Jewish parts of it [50:54] is such a strange book because the [50:56] Jewish parts of it were translated into [50:58] Hebrew immediately. [51:00] But they never translated the other [51:01] parts. [51:02] [laughter] [51:03] Today it was only the Daniel Deronda [51:05] story. And there is the Christian [51:07] saying, no, no, it's only the Grendel [51:09] and Harlot story. Well, we'll put it [51:10] both together and have it as a book. [51:13] >> It's It's an amazing book and I must say [51:15] not only must you read it, I'm sure it's [51:17] a very well educated crowd, but if you [51:19] haven't, you must. And you must do it [51:21] along with Ruth's eight-part lecture [51:23] series. I say reading it without [51:25] listening to Ruth is like reading the [51:27] Torah without Rashi. [51:28] >> not true. [51:30] [laughter] [51:31] Yes. [51:34] Okay. [51:36] Thanks, kiddo. [51:37] >> Yes, and I'm I'm very proud [51:38] [clears throat] that I've inspired two [51:39] people to read Daniel Deronda so far. [51:41] And one is in the room. [laughter] [51:43] Um and my brother who's not here, but [51:45] he's really enjoying it. Um I can't [51:47] think of a more powerful note to end on. [51:50] There are so many important takeaways [51:51] from this discussion, but one of the [51:54] main ones is that we each have a [51:55] responsibility to enlist in the war [51:57] you've been fighting for many decades in [52:00] this country, which is the war of ideas. [52:03] And I hope that events like this play [52:05] even a small role in that effort. [52:07] >> Oh, thank you. [52:09] >> In the IDF, there's only one active [52:11] officer who holds the highest rank, the [52:13] Ramat Cal, the Chief of Staff. [52:16] Um in the war of ideas in America, you [52:18] are my Ramat Cal. [laughter] [52:21] And I think the Ramat Cal to many in the [52:23] room. [52:24] Tonight you've given us clarity. You've [52:26] given us our orders and now it's on us [52:29] to carry them out in our homes and [52:31] communities. So thank you. [52:33] >> [applause]