Transcript [00:00] He's black, he's Muslim, he's beded, and [00:02] he's a Zionist. Through social media, [00:05] Tamil Masudin has become an outspoken [00:07] activist against anti-semitism and [00:09] anti-Israel propaganda. His story [00:12] challenges the simplistic labels often [00:14] imposed on Israel. Today on East to [00:16] West, we speak with Tamil about Zionism, [00:18] Bedwin identity discrimination, the [00:20] experience of Israel's black Bedwin [00:22] community, and how anti-Israel [00:24] propaganda exploits racial divisions to [00:27] turn communities against one another. [00:35] Masudin, welcome to East to West. [00:37] >> So, my name is Tamar Masudin. I'm an [00:39] Israeli bedwin Arab Zionist content [00:42] creator. All of the titles included. [00:44] >> You're an MBA Israeli. I heard that and [00:46] I absolutely love that. [00:48] >> Yes. So, [laughter] so uh uh recently [00:50] graduated from Brandise University. Go [00:53] Brandise. um also fullbrite scholar, [00:56] argov scholar, arov graduate as well [00:59] from university uh and you know on the [01:02] side I'm a social media content creator [01:05] and full-time entrepreneur [01:08] >> thank you very much for joining me [01:09] today. [01:09] >> Thank you for having me. Um, you are a [01:13] Muslim Bedwin [01:16] >> Arab Israeli [01:18] who has become a prominent voice in [01:22] against anti-semitism and against [01:24] anti-Israel hatred. My my question to [01:26] you is [01:29] what's your goal? [01:31] >> H what's my goal? That that is a [01:33] question no one asked me before. Um also [01:36] you forgot Zionist to add into the the [01:38] naming of all the things. Yeah. [01:41] >> Um so it all started I think even [01:44] slightly before October 7th uh maybe two [01:47] or three years before October 7th. [01:49] >> Um so I went and graduated from [01:52] university. I got a degree in um [01:54] government diplomacy and strategy. Um [01:57] and what drove me to to go to university [01:59] and study was the Abraham Accords. [02:02] Right. So I saw the signing of the [02:04] Abraham Accords. I saw both Morocco, [02:06] UAE, Bahrain uh signing the agreements [02:09] and I got excited. I got excited because [02:10] for me it was like okay this is an [02:12] opportunity um as an individual living [02:15] in the state of Israel to come forth and [02:17] basically visit and travel to these [02:18] countries and um present who I am, what [02:22] I am, the nationality, everything that [02:24] is complex and beautiful about my [02:26] country, right? M [02:27] >> um simultaneously I was also doing a lot [02:30] of work with different organizations to [02:32] combat anti-semitism and hate speech [02:35] online but that was um mostly off the [02:38] record behind the scenes. I wasn't doing [02:40] anything in front of camera. I wasn't um [02:42] actively promoting anything. I was just [02:44] you know as an analyst basically working [02:46] behind the scenes to do that. Um, and [02:49] throughout both of these two different [02:52] approaches, my goal was, I would say, a [02:55] complex and and not so unique, but it's [02:57] unique to me. Uh, is present an image of [03:00] what my country truly is, what it's uh [03:04] it's like to live in it. Uh, what it's [03:06] like to be a a member who is [03:08] contributing to the society and and and [03:10] to push forward in it. uh while [03:12] simultaneously also defending um the [03:16] indigenous group who live in this [03:18] country which are the Jews uh and their [03:20] right to self-determination uh in their [03:22] own state and I didn't realize how how [03:26] tough of a goal it's going to look like [03:28] it's going to be until October 7th [03:30] happened. [03:30] >> Yeah. Um so as I told you prior to that [03:33] I was doing things behind the scenes [03:35] contributing with meeting with um youth [03:38] organizations and you individuals from [03:40] both UAE from Bahrain and basically [03:42] trying to build uh cooperations and [03:45] programs together. This is what you know [03:47] I was passionate about. I was passionate [03:49] more about building things and less [03:51] about talking in front of the camera. Um [03:53] then one thing led to to the other. All [03:56] of a sudden, I see well this is [03:58] happening um publicly speaking, diplom [04:01] diplomacy wise speaking, we see that I [04:03] see that we're in in a very tough [04:05] position. Uh although October 7th [04:07] happened, a massacre that was caught on [04:09] on all cameras on GoPro cameras, [04:11] everybody was seeing what happened and [04:13] still somehow we came out as the bad [04:16] guys. Um on top of that, there was also [04:19] Arab civilians, Arab casualties who got [04:21] killed on October 7th. [04:22] >> There were bedwins as well. [04:23] >> Right. Right. So to me it felt like, you [04:25] know, at that time, well, if you guys [04:28] are advocating all of these crazy [04:31] anti-Israeli individuals out there, if [04:33] you guys are advocating for Hamas and [04:35] the Palestinian Islamic Jihad and all of [04:37] these terrorist organizations, uh, well, [04:39] you guys also need to know that they're [04:40] not only targeting Jews, because I get [04:42] it. I figured out that you don't care [04:44] about Jews, but they're also targeting [04:45] Arab-Israelis who live in the state of [04:47] Israel, who contribute to the society in [04:49] the state of Israel, uh who see [04:51] themselves as part of the country. Uh [04:54] and you guys don't see that. So I would [04:56] say again to me was the goal of [04:58] protecting my nation, protecting my [05:00] country, uh protecting the people who [05:02] are who live in it uh constantly all the [05:05] time and also trying to present a [05:07] clearer image uh to the outside society. [05:10] You mentioned Zionism previously uh [05:13] which is the the Jewish right to [05:15] self-determination and the Jewish right [05:17] to to return to their ancestral [05:19] homeland, [05:20] >> right? [05:20] >> What do you Tamil Masudin as a Arab [05:23] black Muslim Bedwin have to do with [05:26] Zionism? [05:27] >> Perfect. Well, to put it simply, as you [05:31] stated, as you put it, it's uh the the [05:33] belief that Jews have the right to [05:34] self-determination in their ancestral [05:36] homeland. That's that's pretty much it. [05:37] That is the the basic definition of [05:39] Zionism, right? Uh and to me I feel [05:43] really grateful. Why do I say this? [05:45] Because I look for example at the state [05:47] that the Jews have managed to build uh [05:49] since 1948 and I also look at other [05:52] countries in the region from uh Jordan, [05:54] Egypt, basically any country that is not [05:57] uh in the GCC. uh and I compare in [06:00] between them and I say well look the [06:03] Jews came they returned to their [06:04] ancestor homeland they built a wonderful [06:07] state a wonderful country with [06:10] infrastructure with high-tech [06:13] solutions with solutions that most of [06:14] the world can't really um live without [06:18] uh in the day and age that we live in [06:19] from uh cyber technology phone [06:22] technology network technology medicine [06:24] health all of these things um and to me [06:28] it seems seems very ridiculous the idea [06:31] that well Jews who are indigenous to the [06:35] region who are indigenous to their [06:36] ancestral homeland don't get to have [06:38] their country don't have don't get to [06:40] have their own land don't get to have [06:41] the right to self-determination um but [06:43] everybody else in the region minus the [06:46] Kurds minus the Yazidis you know the [06:48] predominantly uh let's say Arab [06:51] nationalist in in the region get to have [06:53] their countries get to to name them [06:55] Jordan Egypt Iraq all of these places uh [06:58] but the Jews who have been indigenous to [07:00] the land don't get to to build their [07:02] country, don't get to get their home. [07:04] >> And to me, it sounds ridiculous. Also, [07:06] the fact that [07:08] >> although I grew up uh in in the region, [07:10] I grew up here, I was pretty much immune [07:13] to um anti-semitic rhetoric from from a [07:16] young age. Uh mostly because my [07:18] grandfather fought in in in the war of [07:20] independence and I come from a family [07:22] that is uh see itself as involved in in [07:25] the Israeli society. Um, and it never [07:28] really clocked into me the the rational [07:30] behind accusing the Jews of everything [07:32] that is bad in the region or or even the [07:34] world. Uh, accusing them of controlling [07:36] the media, accusing them of controlling [07:38] the economy, accusing them of [07:40] scapegoating them basically to [07:42] everything that is bad. [07:43] >> Every single blood label out there, [07:45] >> every single blood label accusation. And [07:47] to me, as somebody who's always looking [07:50] for the voice of reason and logic and [07:52] things, it's like, you guys can't blame [07:54] every single thing that is going bad in [07:57] the region, in the world, on on a [07:59] population that is what, 7 million [08:01] people in in in the country, 7 million [08:03] Jews in the country, right? Let's say [08:04] eight. Uh, and accusing them of [08:07] everything that is going on is it's not [08:09] rational. It's extremely ridiculous. Um, [08:11] so I was like, "Okay, maybe maybe [08:13] there's something that I can learn from [08:14] from the Jews instead of demonizing them [08:16] or hating them or uh pushing them [08:19] aside." And I learned a lot. Um, and the [08:21] fact that me as an individual coming [08:23] from the place that I'm I come from, uh, [08:26] managed to get all of the opportunities [08:28] that I had in a Jewish state, in a [08:30] Jewish country, uh, democratic state as [08:32] well. I know for a fact that I will not [08:35] get 10% of these opportunities or 10 10% [08:39] of these chances. uh if I lived almost [08:41] anywhere else in the region. [08:43] >> You mentioned um your family's unique [08:46] history within Israel and and I do want [08:48] to get to that afterwards, but just want [08:50] to zoom out for a second for our viewers [08:51] who have no idea what is a Bedwin [08:54] Israeli. Can you give us a little bit of [08:56] context of what that means? [08:58] >> For those who who don't know, Bedwins [09:00] are nomadics um by by culture, by [09:02] tradition. Um, we're talking about [09:05] people who roamed and lived and survived [09:07] in the deserts of Arabia and the Middle [09:09] East for thousands of years. Um, and [09:11] where my family comes into the picture [09:15] basically. So, um, historically [09:17] speaking, if we go up until the seventh [09:20] uh, century when we go slightly back uh, [09:23] from that, people who look like me were [09:25] not really indigenous uh, to the region. [09:27] We are a byproduct of the Arab/Muslim [09:30] slave trade. I mean, it's uh it's a a [09:33] slavery that lasted for what 1,300 [09:36] years, right? Um on top of that, I mean, [09:39] historians debate whether it was 8 [09:41] million, whether it 10 million, or [09:42] whether even it was 18 million. [09:44] >> Um but let let's say let's be moderate [09:47] and conservative and say, okay, 10 [09:49] million 8 million between 8 to 10 [09:50] million people. Yeah. Uh who were [09:52] brought who were sold during uh the Arab [09:54] rule in the Levant uh during the Turkish [09:56] rule in the Levant, the Ottoman. Um, and [10:00] pretty much were used for warfare. We [10:02] were used for agriculture. We're used [10:04] for domestic affairs. Um, I mean, I [10:06] don't know if this will fly on YouTube, [10:08] but the men were castrated. The women [10:10] were used mainly as uh as as sex slaves [10:14] um in households and harams for rich [10:18] Islamist and Arab individuals in in in [10:20] the region. uh and pretty much that is a [10:23] practice that continued and lasted until [10:25] I think what the defeat of the Ottoman [10:27] Empire and then the British came into [10:29] the picture um and basically they were [10:32] the main drive behind you know let's uh [10:34] let's let's stop this let's stop this so [10:37] they started in in regions in which they [10:39] had um uh colonial power and in which [10:42] they had uh rule over and it pretty much [10:45] they managed to eliminate [10:48] um I would say the remnants of of the [10:51] Arab and Muslim slave trade. Uh and this [10:54] is something that will forever will [10:55] always be grateful for the British for [10:57] uh and I think this is something that [10:59] they should be proud of. Um but it still [11:01] exists in in some places in the Middle [11:03] East in the region until today. I mean [11:05] if you look at uh Libya today, there's [11:07] still markets of of people individuals [11:09] who are being sold. Um and also I I read [11:13] an article about the Tunisian [11:15] authorities also being involved in into [11:17] to it into some aspect. So it's like [11:19] it's pretty Yemen for example like you [11:22] know Ethiopian people were living or [11:24] migrated and moved to Yemen been sold to [11:26] slavery also if you remember in the 2015 [11:30] 2015 16s uh during the waves of um [11:34] Sudanese and also Somali migration [11:36] towards uh Israel I think a lot of them [11:39] were moving through Sena through Egypt [11:41] and many of them were sold into slavery [11:43] because of that were kidnapped uh so [11:45] it's something that very much um exist [11:48] to some extent uh in in the world today [11:51] in this region and in nobody want to [11:53] talk about nobody want to discuss it. [11:55] It's like I think I made a video [11:57] recently about Abdman say uh this [12:01] Egyptian from Egyptian ancestry he was [12:04] talking about reparations uh in in the [12:06] state of Michigan like yeah this is [12:08] something that we need to discuss paying [12:09] reparations for slavery um and I made a [12:12] video I was like well you know based on [12:15] your family history I see that you're [12:16] Egyptian you know Egypt was a major [12:18] trading hub for the Arab slave trade [12:20] >> where is my reparations where is my [12:23] where's the acknowledgement for the [12:24] things that your ancestors, people who [12:26] look like you, enslaved people who look [12:28] like me in the region for 1,300 years. [12:31] What when are we going to talk about [12:32] this? Not like I want reparations, but I [12:34] want to let's let's first acknowledge [12:36] the problem that happened so that we can [12:38] move forward. [12:39] >> Uh so my family is uh that is [12:41] practically the history of my family and [12:43] how we we came to the region. Um that [12:45] being said, we also very much like to be [12:48] bedwin. We're very close and associated [12:50] with the with our culture. uh for [12:52] example like the the fact that we are [12:54] very hospitable. We like to bring [12:55] people. We like to welcome people, [12:57] right? We also have our own customs and [13:00] and rules and in within our own society. [13:03] >> Uh which is something that I I I like. [13:05] It's not like something that I uh [13:06] distant myself from like I I tell people [13:08] yes I'm I'm Bedwin. I'm Israeli. Uh and [13:11] there is some complexity in it. And [13:14] >> so that's what I want to ask you is, you [13:16] know, within the Bedwin society, how do [13:18] bedwins fit in within the Israeli social [13:21] fabric? [13:21] >> Right? So here's the thing. Um, if we're [13:24] talking about 1948, 1947, uh, at the [13:27] beginning, this is how my grandfather [13:29] was, you know, uh, fought for for Israel [13:32] in the war of independence. I would say [13:34] that the relations were pretty much [13:36] close because at the time saw um what [13:40] Arab rule in the land of Israel. They [13:42] saw an atom rule in the land of Israel [13:44] and then the British came and now uh we [13:46] have the independence of the state of [13:48] Israel and we pretty much played ball [13:50] with whoever came and whoever basically [13:53] granted us um you know to have uh for [13:56] example rights protected you know to [13:58] have the ability to move to own land to [14:01] have land to to grow and to flourish. [14:03] Yeah. [14:04] >> And this is why many also families in [14:07] especially in the Israeli negative still [14:10] have the tradition of going into the [14:12] military, serving in the military, uh [14:14] serving in the police force, joining, [14:16] you know, being very much active in [14:18] inside the Israeli society. uh with [14:20] slight you know complexities and in [14:22] internal issues um between the the [14:25] Beduin community to an extent to uh the [14:29] Israeli government I would say [14:31] especially regarding um everything that [14:33] is related to unrecognized Bedwin [14:36] villages in in the south that is [14:38] something you know that is a topic that [14:39] is uh pretty much on debate they're [14:41] always talking about it like what can we [14:44] do to basically solve the situation um [14:47] on one end you know the state wants [14:48] everybody body to live uh in [14:51] infrastructure, civil infrastructure [14:53] that is already built and I think what [14:55] we have seven bedwin um recognized [14:57] bedwin villages in the negative and we [14:59] have also roughly many communities who [15:01] still live in what I would consider to [15:03] be the the diaspora of the negative. uh [15:05] and there's like you know ongoing back [15:07] and forth between the state and between [15:08] the different communities on how can we [15:10] basically solve this and how can we uh [15:12] move forward but that is an argument and [15:14] that is a debate between any I would say [15:17] democratic society and you know with [15:20] modern borders [15:20] >> yes with modern borders and and you know [15:23] minorities who live in it so it's not [15:24] really um a gigantic problem or I would [15:28] say as uh the anti-Israeli crowd likes [15:31] to point it as you know an apartheid is [15:33] treating those uh uh poor bidins in a [15:36] very poorly manner. No, many of them see [15:38] themselves as an Israeli members of the [15:41] Israeli society. And again, we we have [15:43] our own issues. [15:44] >> So that leads me to my next question. Um [15:47] what was it like for you growing up here [15:49] in Israel as a bedwin? Um did you face [15:52] discrimination? [15:54] >> Well, it depends from whom uh if you're [15:56] asking. uh I think uh overall when I [16:00] lived uh and and I still live here I [16:02] haven't really faced uh any systematic [16:04] uh discrimination from an institution [16:07] from the government from the police from [16:09] uh anything I was pretty much uh left to [16:12] live my life and flourish as a as an [16:14] individual. Um, and as I told you [16:16] before, I think the moment that I [16:18] started even to pull my weight and I did [16:20] two years of national service, um, in my [16:23] local youth organization, uh, in my [16:25] local community, uh, and I also showed [16:27] that I'm not looking to be, uh, sitting [16:30] on my behind all day and be a victim [16:32] that complains all the time. And I, you [16:34] know, actively went to to work and to, [16:37] uh, improve my living standards. I saw [16:39] like the the harder that I worked, the [16:40] more that I put uh the more effort that [16:42] I that I showed, the the better my life [16:45] and my life conditions were. Um that [16:47] being said, I did face uh discrimination [16:50] growing up. Minor discrimination to an [16:52] extent. Um but it didn't come again from [16:55] institutions. It didn't come from uh the [16:58] Israeli, Jewish, Ashkanazi, Mizrai side [17:02] of of the state. Um it came from my own [17:05] society, my own my own community. to [17:08] >> within the Bedwin community. [17:09] >> Yeah. Yeah. Within the Bedwin community. [17:10] Yeah. [17:11] >> Because you were black. [17:12] >> Because I was black. And I'm still [17:13] black. Nothing changed. But yeah. [17:14] [laughter] Um but because of this [17:17] because one thing that also people fail [17:20] to to understand about bedwin community [17:22] in Arab society overall. Um and I'm not [17:26] painting this as something bad or good [17:28] or negative, but it's just the way it is [17:30] that it's a a very hierarchal society, a [17:33] very tribal society. Yeah. [17:36] um and and based on on honor, based on [17:38] justice, based on its own internal uh [17:40] reasoning and arguments inside of it. Um [17:43] and when you come from specific [17:45] families, big families, uh you're [17:48] treated in a certain way. When you come [17:49] from a smaller families, you are treated [17:51] in a in a different manner. Uh that [17:54] being said, you know, it's also like [17:55] maybe because of the tradition of of of [17:58] the desert, the strong survive and etc. [18:02] Um so we did growing up me and my [18:04] siblings we did face um discrimination [18:06] because of our skin color because of who [18:08] we looked. Uh we also been called [18:10] slaves. [18:13] >> You actually have a very interesting uh [18:15] story related to that. I think it was [18:17] your mother or your grandmother. [18:18] >> No no no it's my mom. See uh my mom's uh [18:22] maiden name uh I think before marriage [18:24] was [18:26] right. Uh, and it wasn't a name that was [18:29] um I mean no one wakes up in the morning [18:31] and think to themselves, wait, you know [18:32] what? I'm gonna call myself slaves [18:34] today. You know, this is this is gonna [18:35] be [18:35] >> right. Alabid means slaves. [18:36] >> The slaves in Arabic, right? Um fun, not [18:39] so fun story. There's an entire [18:41] neighborhood in Gaza also called [18:43] neighborhood tied to the historical [18:45] enslavement of Africans and uh in the [18:47] Levant. And yeah, that was uh that was [18:50] the name that also uh was registered uh [18:54] in to her. Uh and again not because [18:57] anybody in in in in the state of Israel [18:59] thought like yeah I know I'm going to [19:00] call you slaves in Arabic but this is [19:02] the name that was given in the society [19:04] that we lived in and we basically you [19:06] know I was like okay this is this is the [19:07] name that we have uh and yeah I changed [19:09] it when um when when I could I was like [19:12] okay no one is going to call me by T the [19:15] slave or from the slaves or something of [19:17] that sort and it wasn't dignifying uh in [19:20] in my opinion so I obviously changed it [19:23] when I could [19:25] But yeah, and that is also tied to to [19:27] the fact that again, and when I say [19:29] this, people will think that I'm talking [19:31] about all the Bedwin society. I'm like, [19:32] no, I'm not talking about all the Bedwin [19:34] society because um it goes back to the [19:37] fact that I love being bedwin. I love [19:39] being Arab. I love the fact that I come [19:41] from uh the society that I come from. [19:44] But again, we have internal issues. We [19:45] have anti-black sentiment inside our own [19:49] communities. It does exist. It's still [19:51] there. I mean, if we don't talk about [19:52] it, if we don't address it, then nothing [19:55] really going to happen and nothing [19:56] really going to change. Mind you, that [19:58] we we never really had the the civil [19:59] rights movement in the region, [20:01] >> right? There's something unique about [20:03] you, Tamil, where you you're not afraid [20:07] to tackle the taboo, but you do it in a [20:10] way that's proactive. You're like, I [20:12] can't change the past, right? [20:14] >> But I'm going to change my present and [20:16] my future. Whether that's changing your [20:18] mom's maiden name to get rid of that [20:20] word, that degrading word of the slaves [20:22] to wanting to be part of Israeli [20:24] society. Not only wanting to be part of [20:26] Israeli society, but actually fighting [20:29] for the Israeli society abroad. Um, and [20:34] really taking that on your shoulders. I [20:35] mean, this entire interview you keep [20:37] saying, "My country, my country." It [20:39] It's really remarkable. [20:41] >> I mean, I don't see it in in any other [20:43] way. Um, I'm a nationalist. I'm a [20:45] Zionist. I mean I don't shy away from [20:47] it. I don't hide behind it. I do love my [20:50] country. I think um and this is [20:52] something that I really appreciate about [20:55] again as I said about Judaism and about [20:58] Jews. The fact that you know uh [21:01] surviving World War II, surviving, you [21:04] know, the Holocaust coming after all the [21:05] atrocities that happened and also the um [21:08] the riots and the persecution of Mizrai [21:12] Jews in in in the Middle East. Iraq and [21:16] everywhere, you know, everything that [21:17] happened. I mean, [21:20] on paper, uh, and and I and I say this [21:23] again as a as a tremendous thing that I [21:25] believe that the Jewish people are [21:27] capable of, against all odds, you [21:29] managed to to find a way to rise up time [21:32] and time again against any any other [21:34] adversary who tried to to remove you, to [21:36] try who tried to ethnically cleanse you, [21:38] whether it's the Romans, whether it's [21:40] the Nazis, whether it it's whomever, you [21:43] know, who tried to to repeat, you know, [21:45] the uh the war against the Jews and [21:48] remove them and to rise from these [21:51] incidents, to rise from these issues, to [21:53] rise from from from everything that [21:55] happened to you time and time again [21:57] stronger, more capable, more um I would [22:01] say equipped to to deal and and live in [22:04] the future. Not only that, but also to [22:06] bring solutions to the table time and [22:07] time and time again. It's something that [22:09] is I I believe is very admirable. again [22:12] like people sometimes people like maybe [22:14] uh uh older individuals will look at the [22:16] state of Israel and think it's a miracle [22:18] and I'm like you know I I res I not [22:20] resent sorry I resonate with this [22:23] sentiment because it's like again like a [22:26] phoenix coming from rising from the [22:28] ashes on paper it shouldn't happen but [22:30] it did and it did uh and I take pride in [22:32] that and and I take pride in the fact [22:34] that this is my country this is my [22:36] symbols uh these are my symbols these [22:38] are the the men and women who go to the [22:40] military and and don't even think twice [22:42] about what is the religion, what is the [22:44] ethnicity, what is um the skin color of [22:47] the people and the families that they [22:49] protect. This is their duty. This is [22:50] what they do. This is what they have to [22:52] do. Uh and the least I can do is come [22:55] forth and speak and and advocate for my [22:57] country. That is like the least that I [22:59] can do for it. [23:00] you um you mentioned the Holocaust [23:03] earlier and I know that that was kind of [23:05] a big turning point for you growing up [23:07] where you decided on your own that [23:09] you're going to go to Poland to visit [23:11] the uh um concentration camps, [23:13] >> right? [23:14] >> What made you want to do that and what [23:17] was that trip like for you? [23:18] >> Mhm. So that was when uh I still I was [23:22] still in my national service. [23:24] >> Um [23:25] >> and I got an opportunity. I was um in in [23:28] my youth organization, the working and [23:30] learning youth. At some point I was a [23:32] socialist. Not anymore, but that was [23:34] that was [23:34] >> we all have that phase. [23:35] >> We all have that phase. [laughter] Um so [23:37] um we basically I was approached to get [23:40] not only me, it wasn't only me. was also [23:42] um a big group of Arab and and Jewish um [23:48] students who were in the program who [23:50] were in the youth organization. [23:52] >> Um and they asked me if I wanted to go [23:53] and I was I said, "You know what? I [23:56] think I never been to to Poland. I I [23:59] studied about the Holocaust and read [24:01] about the Holocaust in World War II [24:02] mostly from uh school and history book [24:05] and I think this is something that I [24:06] need to see." um not not as a as an [24:10] Arab, not a as as a as an Israeli, not [24:12] as a Zionist, not as any of these [24:15] things. Uh but more like as a person, [24:17] this is something that yeah, this is [24:19] something that affected and and reshaped [24:23] society as a whole. [24:24] >> Uh and for me was something that I [24:26] wanted to learn and from right um so [24:29] throughout the entire u it wasn't just a [24:32] trip that we went um a delegation sorry [24:34] that we went and we came back. uh it was [24:36] u an entire couple of months of [24:38] preparation. So uh meaning that we sat [24:41] down in groups and we discussed it. We [24:43] talked about it. We talked about all the [24:44] history. We also um talked about [24:47] everything that is related uh to World [24:50] War II and in the propaganda that [24:52] happened uh under the Nazi regime up [24:54] until the point that the Holocaust [24:56] happened in during the Holocaust itself [24:58] and how people reacted to it. Um and it [25:02] was [25:03] very um [25:06] it was very uh uh empowering to an [25:08] extent because the moment that I was [25:10] there, the moment that I started walking [25:12] and crossing in the concentration camps [25:14] and I wrote wrote a journal about it uh [25:17] with my friends, the Jewish friends and [25:19] the Arab friends who were discussing and [25:21] talking about this all the time. Um, [25:25] seeing this made me um, appreciate the [25:29] state of Israel even even more, if that [25:31] was even possible at the time. Um, again [25:34] because it goes back to the fact that [25:36] after everything that happened and I saw [25:37] it with my own eyes, the remnants, the [25:40] the concentration camps, you know, what [25:42] happened there, you know, the the gas [25:43] chambers, everything that I, you know, [25:45] read about in in in the books, in the [25:47] history books, uh, and and seeing it [25:49] live in and in and walking in these [25:52] places that, you know, the people who [25:53] were before me walked and I was like, [25:55] okay, I I cannot I can't not appreciate [25:59] the state of Israel and what it became [26:01] after this. And [26:03] It it made me truly um want to become [26:07] the person that also uh defend it and [26:10] also take the stance of you know um [26:12] never again is not just a slogan it's a [26:14] it's a life mission. [26:16] >> Yeah. You mentioned um uh you mentioned [26:19] the propaganda, the Nazi propaganda, [26:22] right? [26:22] >> Um and something that's maybe less [26:25] reported on is the Nazi propaganda [26:28] targeting the Arab world, [26:29] >> right? [26:30] >> Um could you dive into that for me a [26:32] little bit for our viewers? [26:34] >> Sure. Uh, interestingly enough, it was [26:36] my uh my my Arab counselor who uh we [26:39] were sitting and we were talking and and [26:40] then he brought up the story of Al [26:43] Husseini and his ties to the Nazi regime [26:46] and uh you know after we went dived into [26:48] his history, how he became connected to [26:50] to Nazi Germany, the time that he met [26:52] with with Adolf Hitler and and and and [26:55] they discussed how to you know expand [26:57] that they were pretty much aligned. Both [26:59] of them hated Jews. Both of them wanted [27:01] Jews to be gone. Uh [27:02] >> let's be friends. Yeah, let's be [27:04] friends. You know, it's like, you know, [27:05] we we hate Jews club. It's like [27:07] everybody, you know, get together and [27:09] talk about how to, you know, to get rid [27:10] of the Jews. Um, and I remember I asked [27:13] him like, you know, why how come like we [27:16] we we never talked about this and we [27:18] never discussed this person, this [27:19] individual and the movement that was [27:21] behind him, especially since he was a [27:23] predominant leader in in Palestinian [27:26] society at the time, religious leader as [27:29] well. Um and he told me something very [27:31] interesting that I I still I haven't [27:32] forgot until this day. Uh he said that [27:35] we Arabs we have we have a tendency to [27:37] talk about how we we are the victims of [27:40] of western imperialism, western [27:42] colonialism. Uh about the powers that [27:45] came here and divided and did this and [27:47] did and all of the things but we rarely [27:50] discuss the times in which we were the [27:51] perpetrators, we were the the [27:53] aggressors, we did the bad things to to [27:55] other groups and other people. Uh and [27:57] that that thing you know stayed with me [28:00] until until this day. Um and they did [28:04] let's say they they did a lot of work um [28:06] both Hajim Husseini and Hitler and in [28:09] terms of facilitating and making sure [28:11] that uh people within the region Arabs [28:13] within the region would really hate the [28:15] Jews. As a byproduct of that we saw the [28:18] the Farhood in Iraq that happened that [28:19] was pretty much all of it was inspired [28:22] by by Nazi propaganda. uh and also the [28:26] translation of the the protocols of [28:27] elders in of Zion in Arabic and mass [28:30] printing them in in different locations [28:32] in different places in um in in the [28:35] Middle East. Also, the Soviets took that [28:37] uh to another [28:38] >> red green alliance, [28:39] >> right? The Soviets took that even one [28:41] step further and continue to distribute [28:43] it. The fact that you know this [28:45] conspiracy the Jews somehow the Zionist [28:47] control everything around you. Um, and [28:51] it took like a fire [snorts] in a [28:52] haystack. Uh, I believe in in in the in [28:56] the Arab world, especially since you [28:58] have an Islamist, very radical Islamist [29:00] sentiment that is very anti-Jewish, uh, [29:03] from, you know, organizations such as [29:05] the Muslim Brotherhood, uh, which later [29:08] Hamas emerged from as a terrorist [29:09] organization. Uh, so like there was [29:12] already to an extent a very strong [29:14] anti-Jewish sentiment and to add to that [29:16] the Nazi propaganda. And it's like, you [29:18] know, [29:18] >> I guess then it's not surprising that we [29:20] we found um copies of of mine uh within [29:25] the Hamas uh uh you know, tunnels uh [29:30] throughout this war. [29:31] >> Right. Right. And interestingly about [29:33] all of this is the the the fact that I [29:36] mean, correct me if I'm wrong, but from [29:38] what I read and I understood that um [29:41] Hitler didn't really like Hussein. [29:45] didn't really have any sort of [29:46] appreciation for Arabs and Muslims and [29:49] in fact he viewed them and viewed us as [29:52] uh something lesser than the Aryan race [29:54] that he was so so much obsessed about. [29:56] But for him, he was like here another [29:58] tool that we canact weaponize and use [30:00] against you know um western countries [30:02] and western powers in in the region. uh [30:05] you know a cheap manpower that we can [30:07] utilize to fight and and and give them [30:10] uh an opium, you know, keeping hate the [30:13] Jews, keep continue to hate the Jews and [30:14] and fight the the British and and and [30:16] everybody who was um trying to find the [30:20] Nazi uh uh regime and they really, you [30:23] know, lent on and and heavily on this [30:25] point. Um, and to an as you stated, I [30:28] mean, the the the books that we found in [30:30] in Gaza within Hamas's region, the [30:32] Palestinian Islamic Jihad, uh, the fact [30:34] that Mine Comp is still being produced [30:37] and sold in Arabic in in different [30:39] places in in the Middle East. I mean [30:41] it's still it's still there and it's a [30:43] legacy that will probably will not get [30:45] rid of like Nazi legacy that will [30:47] probably never get rid of until the [30:49] moment that we decide and even you know [30:52] Arab leaders in the region decide to say [30:54] you know what maybe maybe we can stop [30:56] with hating the Jews at this point. [30:58] Maybe we can you know stop with with [31:00] producing and reading this propaganda [31:01] and this propaganda material because [31:03] it's it's never been doing us any good. [31:05] So, I want to talk about um what October [31:08] 7th was like for you and and your [31:11] community, the Bedwin community. Take me [31:13] back to that day um and the the you [31:18] mentioned earlier that sort of [31:20] dissonance um between what was happening [31:23] here in Israel. The Bedwin community [31:25] very much targeted. There were several [31:27] Bedwin hostages that were taken captive. [31:29] Unfortunately, some were killed in [31:31] captivity. I actually met with their [31:33] families [31:34] >> um who were very hospitable when I met [31:35] with them. [31:36] >> There's just a refusal to even [31:40] >> acknowledge what happened on October [31:41] 7th. [31:42] >> Um but this uh misrepresentation of who [31:45] was actually targeted because it wasn't [31:47] just Jews and Israelis. We're talking [31:49] about a vast uh uh targeted of people [31:54] that were from all different races and [31:55] religions. [31:56] >> Right. Right. In in October 6 and the [31:58] same person who was in October 7th. [32:00] >> 100%. Right. So, I remember waking up in [32:03] the middle of uh in the morning. I think [32:05] was around 6:37, something like that. [32:08] >> Uh and I I think I slept through the [32:11] first round of sirens because I didn't [32:13] hear anything. [laughter] [32:14] >> And and then I woke up and I was like [32:16] looking outside of the window and I [32:17] hearing the sirens. It didn't even clock [32:19] me to to go to the shelter at the [32:21] beginning. Uh because I was like living [32:22] in Ramat Sha, we don't have sirens in [32:24] Ramat Shaon. It's very um it's one of [32:27] it's the reality I guess of living in in [32:30] the center of of the country that uh you [32:33] don't face the same kind of threats [32:35] necessarily that the people who live in [32:37] near the Gaza envelope face. Um and I [32:40] was extremely confused. I was like what [32:43] is going on? What is happening? Um, and [32:45] then I open my phone and I go into [32:47] Twitter and uh, you know, all of a [32:49] sudden I'm seeing the images, the videos [32:51] of the paragliders and and the comments [32:53] and and you know, slowly I begin to [32:55] understand what's what's going on. Uh, [32:57] and slowly I also begin to understand [32:59] how much of a catastrophe it is. Um, [33:03] then first thing first I did was talking [33:05] to my parents because uh, my brother at [33:07] the time was staying in in uh, he was [33:10] recovering from a surgery and he was you [33:12] know with with my auntie. He wanted to [33:14] be in a quiet place. This is something [33:17] that he said he wanted to be somewhere [33:18] quiet. Um and my first instinct was you [33:23] know to call him to see how is he doing? [33:25] Is everything is okay with him. uh then [33:27] seeing like you know the news coming [33:28] from the the things that are happened in [33:31] in the police station and and and then I [33:34] see the reports coming from [33:37] Twitter pages and and and um feeds and [33:41] also people who live in SE shalom and [33:43] and other bedin communities talking [33:45] about what what happened who was [33:46] kidnapped who was killed um then I see [33:49] you know faces uh of people that I um [33:52] recognize for example we had police [33:55] officers from the of insealam who who [33:59] got killed and I looked at this and I [34:01] was like this is this is insane this is [34:03] like [34:05] what is going on what is happening right [34:07] um and then I also saw the feeds coming [34:10] out from the anti-Israeli side from the [34:12] pro Palestinian movement celebrating [34:14] joyous oh my god it's a liberation day [34:17] for all of us um and two thoughts popped [34:20] into my head the first is like one you [34:22] guys really don't understand what has [34:24] just happened and what kind of gates of [34:26] hell you opened by by celebrating this [34:28] by doing this. Um and two is the media [34:33] sentiment also you know social media [34:35] sentiment and the people who are [34:37] commenting a lot of it was like already [34:39] seems like it's a grass not a grassroots [34:41] sorry already established anti-Israeli [34:44] anti-ionist anti-Jewish propaganda [34:47] >> it was very prepared [34:49] >> very prepared very very prepared I think [34:51] in New York and in London was like you [34:53] know demonstrations and and protests [34:55] started like on on October 8th almost [34:58] and like maybe on October for 10 like [35:00] maybe 2 3 days already like with you [35:02] know hundreds of people walking and [35:04] doing all of the things like holding [35:05] Palestinian flags, Kofia, Hamas merch, [35:07] you name it. So it was you know pretty [35:09] much prepared. [35:10] >> There were already accusations of [35:12] genocide I think that first week. I mean [35:15] before there were even any Israeli in [35:18] Yes. I was like what are we even doing? [35:21] Um and I noticed that you know there was [35:23] also bedwin uh hostages who were [35:26] kidnapped and in and who were killed. [35:29] Some of them I saw uh on the video feeds [35:31] since I started working on October 8th [35:33] and I started working with this [35:34] organization. One of the things that, [35:36] you know, continued to pop into my feed [35:37] is videos, ongoing videos and from uh [35:40] October 7th and everything that happened [35:42] on that day still continued to to show [35:44] on my feed for like months and months [35:46] and months. Um, from videos of of Arab [35:49] individuals who were being in um [35:52] confronted with ArabIsraelis who are [35:54] being confronted by Hamas thugs and like [35:57] you know asking them on camera, are you [35:59] Arab, are you Muslim? No, we don't [36:01] believe you you know and and then like [36:02] you know shooting the people [36:04] >> and uh to me it was like okay like no [36:06] one is talking about this to to that [36:08] extent no one is presenting this uh and [36:11] also as you said it was very much [36:13] prepared so like something I need to do [36:16] something about it this is where I [36:17] started making my first videos and [36:18] started making them uh at the beginning [36:20] it was in Arabic um I pretty much said [36:23] that Hamas is uh uh is not so much [36:27] different than ISIS uh in their [36:29] propaganda and their mission [36:30] and it doesn't represent me as an Arab, [36:33] as a as an Israeli, as a Muslim. It [36:35] doesn't represent me at all. And pretty [36:37] much denounce the violence that they're [36:38] committing and the terrorism, the [36:40] horrific terrorism that they committed [36:41] against civilians um against Israeli [36:44] civilians, against Jewish civilians, [36:46] against um tourists, against people who [36:49] are not even civilians, but workers who [36:51] came to work in the Israeli uh south in [36:54] the negative. And the funny it's not [36:56] funny but almost [36:58] a year before that it was me and and and [37:01] a group from university we were u in [37:04] communities we were at the Gaza um I [37:06] think one of the crossing we were [37:08] sitting in there we were a year before [37:10] that talking about you know maybe there [37:12] was a kibbutz nearby that wanted to uh [37:15] open a factory build a factory in the [37:18] region to to help Gazans who uh you know [37:21] people want live in Gaza to come and [37:23] work provide for their families and come [37:25] back to the Gaza Strip and basically [37:26] have a financial incentive uh not to go [37:28] into terrorism and not to be recruited [37:31] by Hamas and all of these radical [37:33] organizations, right? [37:34] >> Um so the sentiment before October 7th [37:38] was okay maybe maybe there's something [37:39] that you know we can do something that [37:41] we can work on and after October 7th I [37:44] was like no it it was never about [37:46] Palestine. It was never about [37:47] liberation. It was never about uh [37:50] independence. It was never about none of [37:52] that. It's [37:52] >> so what is it about in your opinion? [37:54] >> In my opinion to simply put it, it's [37:56] about ethnically cleansing Jews from the [37:58] land of Israel and removing all of them [38:01] and destroying the state of Israel. Uh [38:03] one thing that let's say organizations [38:06] such as Hamas and the Palestinian [38:08] Islamic Jihad has been very consistent [38:10] upon is we are not interested in living [38:13] side by side with the with the Jews. [38:14] We're not interested in living side by [38:16] side by the state of Israel. [38:17] >> There's definitely no two-state [38:18] solution. [38:19] >> Definitely no two two-state solution. [38:21] I'm sorry. Uh what we're interested in [38:23] is completely wiping out Israel from the [38:25] map. This is something that they've been [38:27] consistent upon since the the very first [38:30] time they they had their charter in 87 [38:33] or 88. Uh famous article 7 that they had [38:36] that the day of judgment will not come [38:37] until the Jews and and the Muslims fight [38:39] each other and they start fighting. [38:41] >> Is that what from the river to the sea [38:43] means in your opinion? [38:44] >> In my opinion 100%. 100%. Because what [38:47] what are you saying when you say from [38:48] the river to the sea Palestine will be [38:50] free? Like what are you saying? I mean [38:51] you have a democratic country, a Jewish [38:54] democratic country in which Arab [38:56] civilians and Arab citizens are equal in [38:58] with all the rights that they have to an [39:00] an Israeli and Jewish citizen. We can [39:02] live, we can work, we can get married, [39:04] we can get elected to the Israeli canet. [39:06] I mean we can I mean hypothetically [39:09] speaking like you have a if you have a a [39:12] dominant Israeli Arab politician like [39:16] nothing stopping him or her from [39:17] becoming a prime minister like no laws [39:19] against it. Nothing is stopping anyone [39:22] from doing that. We judges, police [39:24] officers, doctors pretty much. Um, so [39:27] when you come and say like, you know, [39:28] free, what what is what is your ideal of [39:30] of of freedom? It's not like, hey, let's [39:33] replace a democratic society in which [39:36] everybody has rights, equal rights, with [39:38] another democratic society in which [39:40] everybody has equal rights. No, [39:41] basically what you're calling for is [39:42] like, let's wipe everything out of this. [39:45] Let's like, we don't want any Jewish [39:46] self-determination in the land of [39:47] Israel. We want to remove all of this [39:49] and we want to establish I don't know [39:52] maybe another independ fail fa failed [39:55] independent Arab state you know governed [39:58] by Sharia laws or religious laws which [40:00] is basically what Hamas and the [40:01] Palestinian Islamic jihad are calling [40:03] for [40:03] >> which was also an experiment that was [40:06] tried in 2005 with the the the Israeli [40:09] pull out of Gaza and look where that got [40:11] us. [40:11] >> Right. Right. So we pulled out of Gaza [40:13] in 2005 and what did we get? We get [40:15] Hamas as as the governing body like in [40:18] the same year or the year after uh they [40:21] went to into a small civil war between [40:23] them and in and fat and killed each [40:27] other, thrown each other from the roofs, [40:28] dragged each other off, did awful things [40:30] to to each other and Hamas stayed in [40:34] power since then in in the Gaza Strip. [40:36] And interestingly enough, they don't [40:38] they don't hide their their intentions. [40:40] They don't hide the things that they're [40:42] doing. So they filmed themselves digging [40:44] water pipes from underneath the ground [40:45] to build and make rockets out of them. [40:47] So they bu filmed themselves digging [40:49] tunnels underneath the ground to prepare [40:50] for uh for a ground invasion. They [40:53] filmed themselves um using the kites as [40:56] uh as as weapons as tools and and and [40:59] showing how they can use them to to burn [41:00] Israeli fields and uh and to hurt and [41:03] kill people. So they filmed themselves [41:05] constantly firing rockets from from [41:07] tents and humanitarian zones and mortars [41:10] from humanitarian zones and using [41:11] schools uh to for their terrorist [41:14] infrastructure. They film themselves [41:16] constantly doing all of these things and [41:18] committing all of these crimes one time [41:21] after the other. Um, in the video, [41:22] >> how do you I mean, how do you explain [41:24] though that the fact that they're [41:25] filming themselves, they're taking these [41:27] videos, they're putting it out [41:29] themselves on the internet for the world [41:31] to see, and yet the world doesn't [41:34] believe it. It It's crazy. [41:36] >> It is insane. It is absolutely insane. I [41:38] mean, I had talks with people who I [41:39] showed them these videos and the first [41:41] thing that came into from their mouth [41:42] is, "What? Do you think that they're [41:44] stupid enough to film themselves doing [41:46] all of these kind of things?" No. This [41:48] has to be AI. this has to be like [41:50] >> Israeli propaganda [41:51] >> Israeli propaganda like no read the the [41:54] caption it says look at their videos [41:56] like it's posted in in Hamas Telegram [41:58] groups in in like official channels like [42:01] they are posting these things and that's [42:03] like they're hiding and I think it's um [42:06] it's pretty much a refusal to see [42:09] reality as it is pretty much uh complete [42:11] and utter denial uh to see reality and [42:14] to see the truth how it is and how it is [42:16] presented uh because it's feels much [42:19] better to hate on Israel and hate on the [42:21] Jews because it gives uh in my opinion [42:23] the people who are um you know who who [42:26] don't want to believe this this [42:27] propaganda don't want to believe the uh [42:29] the videos or sorry call it propaganda [42:31] they gives them they give it it gives [42:33] them an escape good somebody to blame [42:35] all the problems upon all the issues on [42:37] and we seeing this right now and every [42:39] um you know if you every once in a while [42:42] somebody pops in my social media feed [42:44] and oh look at how many billions were [42:46] sent to Israel and we don't have [42:47] healthcare here or in in the UK. Look, [42:50] you can't even criticize Israel without [42:52] even being thrown into jail. Or what [42:54] happened in uh in the border between [42:56] Morocco and and Spain. Uh look, Israel [42:59] is punishing the Europe by sending waves [43:02] and waves and waves of Muslim migrants [43:04] into the you know uh Europe and all of [43:07] these kind of things. It gives them [43:09] someone something to blame. Uh and it's [43:11] very sad to see. So, as somebody who [43:14] fights anti-semitism online, um [43:17] >> I'm curious to hear from you. A, what [43:20] has been your experience and what has [43:21] been some of the the the most wild [43:24] comments you you've seen out there? [43:26] >> It felt like opening the gates of hell [43:28] uh to to an extent really. I mean, [43:32] >> uh I [snorts] I was expecting receiving [43:34] some sort of a backlash, you know, some [43:36] bad comments here and there. I was even [43:38] debating at some point whether I should [43:39] turn off the comment section or [43:41] whatever. But uh what I wasn't expecting [43:44] is the massive waves and waves and like [43:46] I had uh uh people and I say like you [43:50] know you see the name Ahmed something [43:52] and you see like you know the [43:53] Palestinian flag whatever uh calling me [43:56] the most heinous racial slurs that are [43:59] possibly can be uh Uncle Tom, you know, [44:02] slave some stuff like that. [44:04] >> Wow. [44:05] >> Non-stop. Um, but because I I think I [44:08] told you because at some point like you [44:09] know growing up I got used to some of [44:11] that sort of rhetoric and became very [44:13] much uh uh very much immune to it. So [44:17] like it okay doesn't really affect me [44:20] call me something new something original [44:21] that I haven't been heard before right [44:24] um and and I wish it stopped at there [44:26] then you know the death threats came uh [44:29] for example I remember I was in the [44:31] states and all of a sudden I get this uh [44:34] this email that you know someone is [44:36] trying to look for me and and kill me [44:39] inside the the country itself and like [44:41] >> wow you you pe you people are nuts you [44:44] people are crazy and like all I do is [44:46] sit in front of the camera, hold my [44:48] phone and talk about and I don't even [44:50] say things that are um I would say irr [44:54] or extremist or or [44:56] >> No, you act as sort of I have this joke [44:59] that every morning I wake up and I have [45:01] a date with you like a coffee date [45:03] >> and I love your style of co like you [45:04] know you wake up in the morning you have [45:06] your cup of coffee and you're like [45:08] >> that's it. And you're just dropping [45:10] truth. You're just calling people out [45:12] for their pardon with their [45:14] >> BS. Right. And and you know, I'm not I'm [45:17] not mocking anyone. I'm not doing [45:19] anything like you know that is unless [45:21] we're talking about a a public figure [45:23] for example. You know, someone has [45:26] has like massive followings or like [45:29] Hassan for example. Um so I'm like [45:32] this is absolutely nuts. Nuts. like, you [45:36] know, just just because I mean I'm I'm [45:37] talking about things that you don't like [45:38] or you don't uh you don't necessarily [45:41] agree with doesn't necessarily mean that [45:43] you can send me like, you know, waves [45:45] and waves and waves of like death [45:46] threats to to my uh social media [45:49] platforms in my DMs calling me like the [45:52] most heinous things there is. For [45:53] example, um uh there was um I think it [45:58] was media group um there was I think [46:02] they made a post about something that is [46:03] related to uh illegal migration and I [46:07] commented I think and I said you know [46:09] good work guys or something like that. [46:11] Um and the first couple of comments that [46:13] I get was like you know people who are [46:15] like you know responding to what I said. [46:17] Uh, and there was this uh uh lady from [46:21] she was Tunisian uh because she had the [46:23] Tunisian flag on her profile and she was [46:25] living in Paris apparently um surgeon of [46:28] some sort. Uh and she wrote saying uh [46:31] something you Zionist monkey whatever. I [46:34] was like okay. So I didn't respond and [46:36] another guy was like you know why are [46:38] you calling him like monkey in a slave? [46:40] What are you talking about? And then the [46:42] another comment she was like I wish we [46:45] were living in the times of before. So, [46:47] so that we can own people like we owned [46:49] people like you, like slaves. So, [46:51] basically what she's saying is she [46:52] wishing that slavery is back so that she [46:56] can enslave me so I don't talk like the [46:58] way that I'm talking right now. And I [47:00] like and my reaction and and again, I [47:02] don't get pissed that easily. And my my [47:04] first reaction is like, you know, I was [47:06] I screenshotted this. I posted it on my [47:09] Instagram. Like, guys, this is what I've [47:10] been talking about. This is what I've [47:12] been saying for the past three years. [47:15] This is the anti-black sentiment that [47:17] I've been facing non-stop constantly. [47:19] Like I don't I don't really need to do [47:21] much. I don't really need to go all the [47:23] way in in my content creation and make [47:25] videos and talk like it's enough for to [47:27] talk about one thing that these people [47:29] don't necessarily like and don't don't [47:31] agree with and all of a sudden it's like [47:33] a flood of hate and slurs and uh calling [47:37] for enslavement like we wish we we could [47:38] enslave you, wish we could do this and [47:40] this and this to you. Um, and and I'm [47:42] like, you know, you guys are are really [47:45] making a a bad case for how tolerant and [47:48] peaceful and and respectful you are [47:50] because you're giving me everything that [47:52] I can to take and use and to present and [47:55] like this is this is what happened on [47:57] with with your own admission, with your [47:59] own like, you know, uh, action. So, I [48:01] don't really need to do um much because [48:04] you're doing the the job for me. Um that [48:07] being said, I'm also fortunate because I [48:09] have a lot of good people who tell me [48:11] words of encouragement to talk to me, [48:13] friends, um and that I met throughout [48:16] the journey and communities that uh I [48:18] forged really good bonds with, very [48:20] strong bonds with uh throughout the last [48:23] uh 3 to four years. Um which was very [48:27] very important to me, very good also the [48:29] friends that I met throughout the way. [48:31] So it's like [48:33] the I think the good out outplay the bad [48:36] in a way. Uh because it's enough for me [48:39] to to say that you know even if it's 10 [48:41] people who see my videos and like yeah [48:43] this is very informative. Thank you for [48:45] speaking out. Thank you for saying this [48:47] uh is is worth a lot for me. [48:50] >> So as somebody who combats anti-semitism [48:52] online, right? [48:53] >> I want to get your take on these people [48:56] that are saying, "Well, I'm not an [48:57] anti-semite, right? [48:58] >> I'm just an anti-ionist, [49:00] >> right? [49:01] Well, I think that is a lot of BS. Uh if [49:04] if I may. Uh mainly because [49:08] genuinely speaking, I don't know exactly [49:10] how you can separate Zionism from [49:11] Judaism. I mean, what was Moses doing [49:14] >> going to the promised land? like what [49:15] what he was doing like going to you know [49:17] it's like wandering in the desert for so [49:20] many decades like you know you can't [49:22] really separate in in my opinion at [49:24] least from understanding and learning [49:25] about Judaism and uh understanding about [49:28] Zionism like maybe you can say that [49:32] Zionism Zionism is the political uh on [49:35] the ground interpretation of of of [49:38] um the [49:41] call or you know the the sentiment to [49:43] build uh a Jewish self-determination [49:47] have Jewish self-determination in the [49:48] ancestral homeland. Um, and Zionism is [49:51] basically the manifestation of that on [49:53] the ground. Maybe maybe you can argue [49:54] that, right? So, to me, when I hear [49:56] people say like, you know, I'm not an [49:58] anti-semit. I'm an anti-ionist. Well, [50:01] >> what does it mean to be an anti-ionist? [50:03] All it means that I don't think that the [50:05] Israel has a right to exist and and the [50:07] Jews have right to self-determination in [50:09] their ancestral homeland. Well, that is [50:11] anti-semitic. So, it's like what what [50:13] are we talking [50:14] What what are we what are we talking [50:15] about? You know, what are we talking [50:17] about? You can't, in my opinion, at [50:18] least, you can't separate between the [50:20] two. Uh if you're anti-ionist, you're [50:22] anti-semitic. If you're anti-semitic, [50:24] you're anti-ionist. In my opinion, [50:26] >> I think there's something so um telling [50:28] about the fact that some of the [50:30] strongest advocates for Israel are part [50:33] of its minorities. Whether it's you [50:36] Masudin, whether it's Yusf, whether it's [50:38] Mariamunes, whether it's so many people [50:40] from the Drews community also. Um I [50:44] think that that says so much about you [50:46] know the complexity of this country [50:48] >> right [50:49] >> um it is one very big uh in Hebrew we [50:53] say a tik like a a case to take on one [50:57] small strip of land that is filled with [51:00] so many different minorities so many [51:02] different uh communities that conflict [51:07] um but can actually live together we see [51:09] it it's not perfect [51:11] >> right [51:11] >> but it works in a It works in a way that [51:14] is true. Uh because I think uh that deep [51:17] in between us we have a in a way a [51:20] social con contract between us. So um [51:24] you have your community, you have your [51:26] culture, you have a way your way of [51:28] life. Uh but as long as we can [51:30] communicate, we can integrate in between [51:32] us, we can work together, I feel like we [51:34] can achieve a lot more. Uh for example [51:36] uh in the first I remember in the first [51:38] month of of October 7th it was like a [51:40] bedin tent in Rahhat that a local sheh [51:43] built for the hostages and he said like [51:45] we're not I'm not demolishing it until [51:48] all of the hostages all of them are you [51:50] know back home safe right um and for the [51:54] average I would say anti-ionist [51:56] anti-semitic individual western pro [51:59] whatever activist mumble jumble they [52:00] name it today um in in the UK in in in [52:06] Australia and Canada like I think they [52:08] don't really grasp or understand what it [52:11] means right because again for like for [52:14] example one of the bedin hostages who [52:16] who carried for kadi if I'm not mistaken [52:19] that's his name uh when he came out and [52:21] was filmed he was like you know asked [52:22] like what what they what did what was [52:25] Hamas asking you like what do they want [52:27] from you and he said they wanted me to [52:29] give the Jews and I said no I'm not [52:31] going to give you the Jews I'm not going [52:32] to do that my my father never gave up [52:34] the Jews My grandfather never gave up [52:36] the Jews. I'm not going to be the person [52:37] who gave up the Jews. So you can, you [52:39] know, do whatever you want for me. I'm [52:41] not going to give you that. So like [52:44] >> to an extent I think [52:46] >> all the people in Israel share and [52:48] understand that we share a common [52:49] destiny. you know that the enemies from [52:52] the outside whether it's the Iranian [52:53] regime whether it's Hamas whether it's [52:56] the Palestinian Islamic Jihad whether uh [52:58] it's the Houthies in in Yemen all of [53:00] these um [53:02] in in Lebanon all of these entities uh [53:04] we understand that when they fire their [53:06] rockets when they send their drones and [53:08] when they fire their missiles they're [53:10] targeting everybody uh you know a [53:13] missile that they send won't like you [53:14] know in the middle of the year think [53:15] about like hey is that a Jewish [53:16] settlement is that an Arab settlement is [53:18] that you know like you decide whether [53:20] which one it wants to attack. It's like [53:22] all of us are under the fire. All of us [53:25] share a common destiny. All of us share [53:28] a common state, a common country. [53:30] Whether you know we agree with each [53:32] other, whether we don't, whether we have [53:34] our own internal issues like this, this [53:36] is it. This is it. Um and in a way, you [53:39] can see that also with um let's say [53:42] leftist organizations here in in Israel. [53:45] Uh I think one of them is Standing [53:46] Together, for example. uh very [53:48] left-leaning um organization, pro [53:52] Palestinian organization, if I'm not [53:54] mistaken, this is how they like to [53:55] consider themselves. Uh and even them [53:58] when like organizations such as the BDS [54:00] look at them, they want to boycott them. [54:02] Why? Because regardless of how much you [54:04] you you say that you're opposing uh the [54:07] Israeli government and the farright [54:08] government and all that nonsense that [54:10] they say, it's not enough for us because [54:12] you're an Israeli. It's not enough for [54:14] us. You exist, you know. I think was [54:16] what is what was it? I think yesterday [54:18] or today a congress or like a politician [54:21] uh from and I saw it briefly. I can't I [54:24] can't remember his name was confronting [54:26] um anti-Israeli pro Palestinian crowd. [54:29] I'm going to skim over to see you know [54:31] what he's been saying. It's like you [54:33] know calling Israel calling the war in [54:35] Gaza a genocide you know you know using [54:37] all the blood label accusations etc. Um, [54:41] and still it's not enough. Still it's [54:43] not enough for the anti-Israeli, pro [54:45] Palestinian, whatever crowd because the [54:47] dominant power that is moving all of it [54:50] is the fact that we don't want you to [54:52] exist here. Regardless of what keeper [54:54] you wear, regardless of what name you [54:57] call yourself, regardless of whatever [54:58] you want to associate yourself with, we [55:00] don't want you to exist here. And this [55:02] is something that I think all of us or [55:04] most of us, you know, understand to an [55:06] extent. Maybe some some individuals or [55:08] some groups here still don't figure that [55:10] out, but ever since October 7th, I think [55:12] all of us got got the memo. [55:16] >> My final question to you is as someone [55:18] who, [55:20] like I mentioned before, you're very [55:22] much proud of your heritage and who you [55:24] are. You don't separate yourself as you [55:26] mentioned, [55:26] >> right? um a and you're proud of also the [55:29] country where you live in and you take [55:31] that pride and you've transformed it [55:33] into becoming this pro-Israel advocate [55:36] online and you're very much one of those [55:38] people that's looking for a practical [55:39] solution. Like when I look at you [55:41] speaking I'm like wow this guy is so [55:43] levelheaded and logical like you said it [55:46] yourself you don't get pissed off [55:47] easily. [55:48] >> No [55:49] >> my question to you is [55:51] what is what is the solution in all of [55:53] this? How do we move forward? Here's the [55:55] thing. I've been I I was generally [55:56] thinking about this prior to the to the [55:58] elections. Uh not necessarily on how to [56:01] solve the Israel Palestinian conflict. I [56:02] think there is uh people who are smarter [56:04] than me, more capable than me and and [56:06] who read more books than me and have [56:08] been, you know, far more experience, who [56:11] uh who have their own um solutions on [56:14] how things would look like. So [56:15] practically I'm not looking for a way to [56:19] um to solve this from from our end [56:22] mainly because I think again [56:24] historically speaking if we're talking [56:26] about the the the Palestinian society [56:28] you had numerous times numerous [56:29] opportunities time and time and time [56:31] again um to you know form your own state [56:34] form your own country have you know [56:37] sovereign state next to the Jewish state [56:38] and we call it a day and and everybody [56:40] happy um and they refused time and time [56:43] and time again Uh to me I understood [56:46] that the dominant again um motive behind [56:49] the the Palestinian movement as it is [56:52] today is we're not going to accept [56:54] anything and even if we accept anything [56:56] it's like you know just for now but our [56:57] end goal is to completely erase the [56:59] state of Israel and have and and remove [57:01] it and make sure that Jews don't don't [57:02] get to live here. Um, and in my head and [57:06] I'm like, okay, if my adversary is not [57:09] willing um to compromise, is not willing [57:12] to to to nudge, is not willing to accept [57:15] the fact that I exist and I have, you [57:17] know, uh, my history and I have my back [57:19] and I have my right to to be here and [57:21] all they're interested in is is, you [57:23] know, wiping me off the map. It's like [57:24] there's there's no [57:26] what are we what can we talk about like, [57:28] you know what I mean? Yeah. Um, so even [57:31] before the moment that we come to a a [57:34] table and present a solution, I think [57:36] that the Palestinian society need to be [57:38] reformed. Uh, they need to also have a [57:40] deep discussion within themselves like, [57:42] okay, we've been doing this for 80 [57:44] something years now. Uh, how long can we [57:46] continue to do this and and get to the [57:48] same uh outcome outcome, sorry, time and [57:51] time again. Do we continue do we want to [57:53] continue to do this or we don't? because [57:55] we Israelis and Jews and and Arab [57:57] Israelis alike, we don't really have [57:59] anywhere else to go. This is our [58:00] country. This is our place. This is our [58:02] society. We don't have really anywhere [58:03] else to go. Um, and if I have to pick [58:06] between my country, my state, and [58:09] anything else, I'm picking Israel 10 [58:11] times a day and even twice on the [58:13] weekends without even thinking about it, [58:14] right? Um, so in my opinion, it's less [58:18] of what can we try to do to make the the [58:22] Palestinian society and the Palestinian [58:24] leaders uh come to the negotiation table [58:26] and and try to have a um uh you know [58:29] reasonable solution and reasonable thing [58:31] for both of us. In my opinion, it's like [58:33] what can we do to strengthen our [58:36] country, to strengthen our means and [58:38] make sure that the same thing that [58:40] happened on October 7th never happened [58:42] again. So I'm talking about investing in [58:44] our educational system that I think we [58:47] we should I'm talking about heavily [58:49] investing in our culture not our culture [58:52] sorry agriculture I'm talking about [58:54] investing in our tech I'm talking about [58:56] also in incentivizing [58:58] companies such as Tesla such as Nvidia [59:00] other companies to come to Israel and [59:02] also uh be integral part of the Israeli [59:05] tech sector and also everything that is [59:07] between because [59:09] >> for example like that the [59:12] >> when I moved lived here in in in Tel [59:13] Aviv. I barely spent like 24 hours in in [59:17] my new apartment. I met two lovely guys [59:19] who were sitting downstairs talking [59:20] about something. Uh and I joined them [59:22] and they were telling me about this [59:23] crazy startup that they're building in [59:25] defense tech and and I was like [59:27] >> I I just moved like I just came here, [59:30] right? And then you see like another guy [59:31] that is building another thing. I'm [59:33] building a startup myself and [59:34] everybody's pretty much you know [59:35] thinking about what are the solutions [59:37] that we can present to solve the pain [59:39] points for the world, right? Um, and I [59:41] think that is our c core competency as [59:44] the Israeli society and as uh as Jews as [59:47] well and as non-Jews living in this [59:49] country. Uh, our core competency is that [59:52] we can fix and we can solve things and [59:54] we can um [59:56] >> making the impossible possible. [59:57] >> Made the impossible possible. Right. Um, [59:59] and it's something that uh maybe the [60:02] conspiracy theorists right now will jump [60:04] up on it and say, [60:05] >> "Yeah, they're loving it there." [60:06] [snorts] [60:06] >> You're right. And I think it's something [60:08] that the the world can't really um uh [60:12] live without, you know, because um every [60:16] time we innovate, every time we come up [60:18] and present another solution to a [60:19] problem that the world is suffering [60:20] from, another solution for cancer, [60:23] another solution for uh uh you know, [60:26] Wi-Fi connection in remote locations or [60:28] or whatever, 3D printing organs for [60:31] donors, something that I saw in Tel Aviv [60:33] University not a while ago. uh every [60:35] time you come up and we bring a solution [60:38] uh to the table and you know [60:40] specifically the private sector they [60:42] can't really go without it because they [60:44] understand that we innovate we we have [60:46] problems we have issues but we look for [60:48] the solutions within it um so to me [60:52] >> I think and and again I'm going to go to [60:53] back to my original point uh I think we [60:56] should do everything possible to [60:58] strengthen our position to strengthen [61:00] our country um to incentivize [61:02] individuals within the state of Israel [61:04] which means you know, mandatory military [61:06] service for everybody if we can, if not [61:08] mandatory national service for [61:10] everybody, right? Everybody needs to be [61:13] a player in this country, everybody [61:14] needs to have a stake in the game. Uh, [61:16] and also people need to contribute and [61:18] build and innovate because the moment [61:21] that we give that up and we decided to [61:24] give that up, I mean, we practically [61:26] useless. In my opinion, October 7th was [61:29] never um the end. It was the beginning [61:32] of what we're seeing right now unfolding [61:34] uh from the red green alliance and from [61:37] you know the Islamist motivated the [61:39] Muslim Brotherhood motivated uh [61:42] propaganda that we are seeing in in [61:45] Europe right now and we're seeing the [61:46] aftermath of it in Europe right now in [61:48] the UK we briefly mention it the fact [61:50] that now in in some places in the UK [61:52] they're thinking about banning the the [61:54] the national flag from being presented [61:56] because [snorts] it might hurt some [61:57] other people's feelings or whatever. Um [62:00] and we're seeing like no go zones in in [62:02] places like Europe and places like [62:04] Germany and places like the Netherlands [62:06] places in which not not even local [62:08] authorities or emergency you know [62:10] services thinking about going there and [62:13] we're also seeing you know the massive [62:15] rise of socialist or neocialist whatever [62:17] they want to call them from uh guys like [62:19] Hassan who make millions while [62:21] sitting in a in in a penthouse or [62:23] whatever like in luxury house and uh [62:27] telling everybody that yeah you know we [62:28] should use all means of production. Mao [62:30] Zaong was a great leader. All of these [62:32] things that we seeing, I think that in [62:35] the face of all of it, I've seen also [62:36] people who are uh suddenly went and [62:40] became lenient on their position because [62:42] they're afraid that if they speak their [62:44] mind and if they say uh the thing that [62:46] is right, they're going to be [62:47] persecuted. They're going to be [62:48] attacked. [62:48] >> They're going to be cancelled [62:50] >> and cancelled. And I think that is [62:51] already happening. I think if you bury [62:53] your head in the sand, uh it doesn't [62:55] mean that the storm will skip you. it [62:57] just means that maybe it will take a [62:58] little bit longer to reach you. Uh no [63:01] society uh that I know of throughout [63:03] history survives by burying their head [63:05] in the sands and waiting for the storm [63:07] to be over. Uh and I really encourage [63:09] people not to be, you know, to to stay [63:12] strong on their values, to stay strong [63:13] on their principles, not to be bent, not [63:16] to be broken because the moment that we [63:18] do that, the bad guys win. [63:20] >> You mentioned earlier the fact that [63:22] you're an entrepreneur, you're building [63:23] your startup. I want our viewers to [63:25] understand that all this pro-Israel [63:28] anti, you know, anti-anti-semitism [63:30] activism that you do, [63:32] >> that's a side project. [63:33] >> Yeah, that is a side hustle. Yeah, [63:35] >> that is a side hustle. Yeah, exactly. I [63:37] mean, you're setting the the the bar [63:40] very high for the rest of us that are [63:41] just scrolling through Instagram on the [63:43] weekends. [63:44] >> Um, T, it's been a huge honor for me to [63:46] meet you. I've been following you for [63:48] years, and I'm so happy that we got the [63:49] opportunity to to sit down [63:51] >> and and to hear you speak. you're an [63:54] incredible human being. Um, and I and I [63:56] can't wait to see where you go from [63:58] here. [63:58] >> Thank you. Thank you so much. It's been [64:00] a lovely opportunity also to sit and [64:02] talk and have this. I wanted to do this [64:04] for a long time. So, I'm happy that we [64:06] managed to find the time to do and and [64:08] talk about this. And yeah, thank you for [64:09] having me. [64:10] >> And that was east to west. Conversations [64:12] like this remind us that Israel and the [64:14] wider Middle East cannot be understood [64:16] through labels or slogans. It's a region [64:19] of layered identities, complex [64:22] histories, and voices too often left out [64:24] of the conversation. If this episode [64:26] challenged your assumptions, share it [64:28] and follow us here on East to West for [64:30] more voices that take you beyond the [64:32] headlines and closer to the realities [64:34] shaping the region.