Transcript [00:00] Okay. So, welcome uh friends and [00:03] colleagues of ISGAP to a very uh I think [00:06] a very special gathering. Today is the [00:09] book launch of two uh faculty members of [00:12] ISGAP and leading members of ISGAP [00:14] actually and not only leading members of [00:16] ISGAP but some of the finest scholars [00:19] globally dealing with contemporary [00:21] anti-semitism. So I'm very honored to [00:24] introduce two friends and colleagues, [00:26] Professor Carrie Nelson and Professor [00:29] David Patterson. And the you know ISGAP [00:32] is uh growing its publications and we [00:35] have a a book series with academic [00:37] studies press which is part of the [00:39] Groder. These are two very important [00:41] publishing houses and recently uh part [00:44] of the ISGAP book series at Academic [00:47] Studies Press we published professor [00:49] Carrie Nelson's book. The book is [00:52] entitled College Zionists Confront the [00:54] Abyss: The Aftermath of October II and [00:57] Higher Education and Its Consequences [00:59] for Progressive [01:01] uh Politics. So, this is a very a very [01:04] important um book that um I urge you all [01:09] to to read. You can get it from our [01:11] website or from Amazon. And then David. [01:14] So, first we'll have Carrie speak about [01:16] his book and then we'll turn over to [01:18] Professor Patterson and and Professor [01:21] Patterson's new book is entitled [01:23] Redemptive Anti-semitism after 107 which [01:27] is also a very important insight into [01:29] the contemporary politics of of [01:31] anti-semitism and the kind of global [01:34] crisis [01:35] not only of anti-semitism but I think [01:37] the attacks on our our democratic [01:39] principles and higher education that [01:42] Carrie writes about is perhaps the most [01:44] important institution in our democracy. [01:46] This is where young people actually go [01:48] to learn to be citizens and to think [01:50] critically. So Carrie's book is uh [01:53] important at many levels. So Professor [01:55] Nelson, I'm going to turn it over to you [01:57] for your presentation on your important [01:59] new book and your work. So thank you. [02:02] >> Thank you, Charles. Uh it's great to be [02:05] doing this with David. Um these books, [02:08] these two books both deal in different [02:11] ways with the uh impact and sources of [02:16] what happened on 107 and with the [02:18] consequences. And I think what's so [02:21] interesting is that the books really [02:23] complement one another. I think you get [02:26] if you're if you're willing to get both [02:27] of them and read both of them, you'll [02:29] have a fuller picture of what actually [02:32] went into that horror than you would [02:34] just reading either one of them. Not [02:37] that not that either of my books are [02:38] inadequate, but hey, they do they do [02:42] take up different issues. What I I do [02:45] two things broadly in my book. The first [02:48] is to talk about uh the the the two [02:52] years that follow 107 [02:55] and lay out what actually happened. Uh I [02:59] think people are dimly aware that in [03:02] addition to the couple hundred [03:05] encampments that took place in the [03:07] United States that there were [03:10] encampments in Canada and Britain. [03:13] People aren't so much aware that there [03:15] was an encampment in the Jordanian [03:17] University, an encampment at Kuwait [03:20] University, there were nine encampments [03:23] in Japan, all over the world. Brazil had [03:26] two. It was organized worldwide. And it [03:30] was the most rapidly growing [03:34] politicization of campuses, not just in [03:37] our lifetime, but in the history of the [03:39] world. in part because it was largely [03:42] organized on social media and you know [03:46] uh 30 years ago that wouldn't have been [03:49] possible wouldn't have been possible 10 [03:51] years ago. So it was we we've never [03:55] experienced anything like that. The [03:57] encampments began uh late April at [04:01] Columbia University. By miday they were [04:04] literally all over the planet uh Asia, [04:08] South America, North America and so [04:10] forth. Um so the book first of all does [04:14] that to try to give you really a picture [04:17] of this organized anti-Zionist and [04:20] fundamentally anti-semitic [04:23] series of events that consumed campuses [04:26] and communities major cities certainly [04:29] for a large part of that time. Then the [04:32] book asks the second question which is [04:35] what are the leg what's the legacy [04:38] um of those events for the present time [04:42] what's the legacy looking forward and [04:45] what I want to do today is talk about [04:47] the second half that is talk about what [04:50] we can look on what we can look forward [04:53] to over the next few years as the result [04:57] of this incredibly wellorganized [05:00] host [05:02] anti-Zionist movement that consumed the [05:05] planet. And what I'm going to do to make [05:07] this organized is I'm going to identify [05:10] seven key areas of unwelcome [05:14] politicization [05:16] that have now [05:18] the academy has now inherited in an [05:21] enhanced and more aggressive form than [05:24] it had before. There were hints of these [05:27] things before but they've ne after 107 [05:30] they peaked and became definitive [05:33] features of the life that those of us [05:35] who work in universities live. So the [05:38] seven key areas [05:41] all of them disastrous um but worth [05:44] noting their differences. The first of [05:47] the seven I and I think in many ways the [05:51] most intractable and the nastiest is [05:55] politicized academic disciplines. [05:59] That's I think the single most serious [06:01] problem is that unyielding unexamined [06:05] anti-semitism [06:06] has become embedded in a number of the [06:09] belief systems of particular academic [06:12] disciplines. [06:14] These disciplines in s significant ways [06:17] are now lost to the powers of reason. [06:22] And people are possessed by the notion [06:24] that they now have found the truth that [06:27] they know the absolute condition of uh [06:31] collective life on the planet. And [06:34] unfortunately, convincing them otherwise [06:36] may be simply an impossible task because [06:40] why should they abandon explanatory [06:43] models that they think they deeply think [06:46] are true? Once you think that a [06:49] dichomous model of oppressor versus [06:53] depressed peoples explains the world, [06:56] you're going to find plenty of [06:57] confirming evidence and you're not going [07:00] to want to let go. confirmation bias is [07:04] going to shape how you think about the [07:06] world. [07:07] And I should say because I spent 23 [07:11] years of my life in as an elected member [07:15] elected leader of the American [07:16] Association of University Professors. [07:20] All dur during much of that time, the [07:23] AEUP believed that disciplines that go [07:27] off the rails, academic disciplines that [07:30] become consumed by error and hatred [07:33] would eventually correct themselves, [07:36] that there were corrective measures [07:38] built into the academic process that [07:41] would enable these disciplines to heal [07:43] themselves. Well, the AUP may still [07:46] believe that, but I don't. I don't think [07:49] these disciplines will heal themselves [07:52] of anti-Zionist hatred. I think that [07:55] they're unfortunately they're consumed [07:57] by it and that's the future we face. So [08:04] second category, [08:06] politicized national disciplinary [08:09] associations. [08:11] Anti-Zionist activists now control the [08:15] governing bodies of a number of national [08:18] organizations that rent represent [08:21] academic disciplines. National [08:23] organization like the American [08:26] Anthropological Association, the [08:28] National Association of Women's Studies, [08:31] these are consumed, controlled by [08:34] anti-Zionists. [08:36] And unfortunately, one response, one [08:40] understandable response that many Jewish [08:43] members have had is to simply not renew [08:45] their memberships, to decide they don't [08:48] need that kind of hatred in their lives. [08:51] And so they let their memberships go. [08:54] And that of course makes it even less [08:56] likely they'll be reformed because the [08:58] ideological content becomes increasingly [09:02] uniform. But I don't blame them from [09:04] quitting. Third, politicized campuses. [09:08] There are now campuses, especially some [09:12] small liberal arts colleges that are [09:14] pretty much uniformly controlled by [09:17] anti-sionist belief. Large institutions [09:22] tend to have many places that aren't [09:25] occupied by anti-sionism. [09:27] I taught for 35 years at the University [09:29] of Illinois. And if you want to get away [09:32] from anti-sionism, [09:34] you you you get away from the women's [09:37] studies program, you get away from the [09:40] English department, you get away from [09:42] the history department, and you go to [09:44] chemistry or biology, and you can sort [09:47] of you you can escape the Zionist the [09:50] anti-sionist atmosphere that way. But [09:53] small liberal arts colleges, if they [09:55] really become consumed by those those [09:58] forms of hatred, the campuses really [10:02] have no safe spaces. No no space where [10:05] you can go that faculty think [10:08] differently. No space where students [10:10] will feel intellectually and emotionally [10:14] safe. So politicized campuses are it's a [10:18] relatively small number where I think [10:20] the campus is totally lost but there are [10:23] some campuses in the US that I where I [10:26] think are totally gone. Okay. Fourth [10:29] problem politicized faculty hiring and [10:33] evaluation. There are many departments [10:35] in the humanities in the interpretive [10:37] social sciences that really consider [10:41] anti-sionism, fierce anti-sionism to be [10:45] a prerequisite to hire a faculty member. [10:48] They don't declare that in their ads. [10:50] Instead, what they'll say is, "We're [10:53] looking for someone who studies [10:55] indigenity [10:56] or we're looking for someone who studies [10:59] postc colonial studies." And those the [11:02] these days those are code words for [11:04] anti-semitic beliefs. And you can't [11:09] directly ask a candidate his or her [11:12] political beliefs. Some of them have [11:14] revealed them in any case by [11:16] organizations that they belong to [11:18] openly, by social media presentations [11:21] that they give that are that exhibit [11:24] those kinds of convictions or by signing [11:27] on to job searches for bodies of theory [11:32] that have become primarily anti-sionist. [11:35] Postcolonialism didn't start that way. I [11:38] helped hire postcolonialist scholars for [11:40] my English department. something to my [11:43] regret because as postc colonialism [11:46] shifted more and more toward anti-ionism [11:49] those fountain members became not my [11:52] friends any longer. So the fifth problem [11:57] and one that um of course is I find [12:01] particularly horrific is that not only [12:04] individual academic disciplines have [12:06] shifted toward anti-Zionism but the one [12:10] inter multidisciplinary group that's [12:12] supposed to represent all faculty in a [12:15] neutral manner is the AUP. I was in the [12:19] elected leadership literally for 23 [12:21] years. pretty big piece of my life and I [12:25] really [12:26] it was it was a nonpolitical [12:29] organization for all that time indeed [12:32] for almost a hundred years and it was an [12:36] absolute unacceptable thing for an AUP [12:40] leader to endorse a political candidate. [12:42] If I had endorsed a political candidate [12:44] as president, I would have been asked to [12:47] resign or I would have been impeached. [12:49] It just was a red line you did not [12:51] cross. This year, for the first time, [12:53] the AEUP endorsed 10 candidates for [12:56] office and you can't they all happen to [13:00] be Democrats and that means that [13:03] Republicans who belong to the AUP no [13:06] longer feel intellectually welcome here. [13:08] Uh and some of the Democrats of course [13:10] took anti-Zionist positions. So that [13:13] meant that Zionist members felt [13:15] unwelcome. [13:17] That process at the AE has been slowly [13:20] going on for several years, but it's now [13:23] complete. The AEUP is an anti-Zionist [13:28] organization and uh all of its [13:31] leadership are once again I don't see [13:36] any way to liberate that group. I think [13:40] what you what we should do is continue [13:43] to use the excellent principles and [13:46] policy statements that the AEUP issued [13:49] for 99 years and realized that the [13:52] organization is no longer capable of [13:54] doing that. But we shouldn't give up [13:57] those policies that accumulated for [14:00] nearly a century. they should still [14:02] guide us even though the AEUP as a whole [14:05] can produce uh neutral policy statements [14:08] any longer. Six uh next to the last [14:13] politicized graduate employee and [14:15] faculty unions. The AUP is now largely a [14:19] union. It's over about 90% in collective [14:23] bargaining. Um [14:26] on campuses along with groups like [14:29] students and faculty for justice in [14:32] Palestine, [14:33] graduate employee unions are the most [14:36] fiercely anti-Zionist groups on campus. [14:39] Didn't wasn't always that way. [14:42] A lot a lot of my professional life is [14:45] the product of unforeseen developments, [14:48] unanticipated developments. So I helped [14:51] organize graduate employee unions for 25 [14:54] years. I traveled around the country [14:57] helping to do that. And in that period [14:59] of time there were no anti Zionist [15:02] graduate employee unions. Now they [15:05] almost all are. And they're younger than [15:08] faculty members. they're more even more [15:10] vocal and outspoken and they are [15:14] extremely hostile in their in their [15:17] anti-Zionism [15:19] and there are some faculty unions that [15:21] have made that shift as well uh at at [15:24] CUNI for example uh NYU faculty unions [15:29] are among the unions in the country that [15:31] have also formally adopted anti-ionism [15:35] so those politicized unions are I [15:39] the sixth major problem we're facing. [15:42] And finally, the last one of the seven, [15:45] politicized campus governance. [15:49] Faculty members, especially within the [15:51] last year or so, anti-Zionist faculty [15:55] members have realized that they can take [15:58] over the governing mechanisms of a [16:00] campus. that a limited number of zealots [16:04] who campaign for office can take control [16:07] of the faculty senate. They can take [16:10] control of faculty review boards. They [16:14] can take control of hiring generally. [16:16] And so one of the changes that we've [16:18] inherited as a result of 107 is much [16:22] more organized efforts by anti-ionist [16:25] faculty to control the mechanisms of [16:28] faculty governance. And the only way to [16:31] combat that is to combat it for people [16:34] who believe in political neutrality or [16:37] Zionism to run for those offices and [16:41] compete for them and try to take them [16:42] over. And that's really not happening. I [16:45] mean, that's a hypothetical at best. [16:48] What all of the organized campus efforts [16:51] seem to be coming from the other side. [16:54] Um, so I think that's [16:58] that's not a very cheerful legacy that [17:01] I've identified. Uh, and um, I don't [17:05] have a lot of good news to offer. What's [17:07] happening? What's happening on the [17:09] positive side? Well, first of all, there [17:12] are faculty [17:13] >> and also just letting you know you have [17:14] five minutes left. [17:16] >> Thanks. Um there are faculty cohorts [17:20] of Zionist faculty being organized [17:25] throughout the world. [17:27] Isgap of course has been doing that for [17:29] years and has a wonderful [snorts] [17:32] summer program that gives faculty the [17:35] knowledge they need to be effective [17:37] activists. [17:39] Um and there are other groups or [17:42] organizing both in England and in North [17:45] America. [17:47] I think what so far at least what most [17:49] those groups mostly do is increase our [17:52] knowledge base and therefore they [17:55] empower faculty to be effective because [17:58] the faculty are well informed. You can't [18:01] combat anti-zionism [18:03] if you're if you're ignorant of its [18:05] history and its current formation. So [18:08] that and people feel I think um loyalty [18:13] to these groups and they all s also feel [18:16] reinforced by them. It gives you some [18:19] sense of social reinforcement. However, [18:23] social reinforcement across the globe [18:25] doesn't necessarily make you feel at [18:27] home on your own campus. So we we retain [18:31] a problem of intense faculty alienation [18:35] for Zionist faculty on campuses that are [18:38] largely been lost there. I think all of [18:41] those groups that are organizing [18:43] research on behalf of faculty members [18:46] and supporting Zionist faculty research [18:50] they have to provide faculty members [18:52] with ways of shifting also toward [18:54] activism. having an activist component [18:57] in their life but keeping us separate [18:59] from their scholarship. Um that's I [19:03] think something we need to see much more [19:05] strongly but at least we're getting a [19:07] great knowledge base from which to work. [19:11] Um [19:13] okay [19:15] a couple minutes short and that's [19:17] probably best. It's uncharacteristic. [19:20] I apologize for that, but you know, I [19:24] think that's probably enough for me. [19:26] >> Okay, Carrie, thank you very much. And [19:27] we'll have a conversation. So, we'll [19:29] people will be able to ask you some [19:31] questions. We'll have more more of your [19:32] insights. So, thank you very much for [19:35] your really important and uh perhaps [19:37] unfortunately timely assessment of of [19:40] these issues. So, thank you. So now I'm [19:43] honored to uh move the conversation to [19:46] to David Patterson for about 15 to 20 [19:49] minutes, then we'll have Q&A. So as I [19:52] said earlier, David's new book, and he's [19:54] a prolific writer. His new book is [19:56] Redemptive Anti-semitism After 107. [19:59] Professor Patterson, the floor is yours, [20:01] and thank you for being here. [20:05] >> Thank you so much. Uh thank you, Carrie. [20:08] I I found myself wanting to chime in [20:11] several times as as you were speaking. [20:14] Uh you made, [20:17] you know, one important point after [20:19] another. Uh one important point you made [20:22] is that they the anti-sionists, the [20:25] academics, the intellectually elite [20:29] believe they have not only the truth but [20:34] the good justice. [20:37] So that in many academic circles [20:41] uh in order to be counted among the [20:43] righteous you have to be anti-sionist. [20:48] Uh you can't be considered a person uh [20:52] with moral integrity if you support the [20:54] existence of the Jewish state. [20:58] Um I think you also your your point [21:01] about knowing the history of anti-ionism [21:03] and kamas and the the and being able to [21:07] name the evil is also very important. [21:10] You know the anti-ionist uh [21:14] premise here anti-ionist anti-semitic [21:17] premise is not that all Jews are evil [21:19] but all evil is Jewish. That's why Jew [21:24] hatred takes on a redemptive [21:28] aspect and certainly Hamas [21:31] regards all evil as Jewish. If you read [21:34] their ideologues say beginning with you [21:36] know and going back to the brotherhood [21:38] ideologues say for example Ahmed Yasin [21:43] the founder of Hamas [21:45] uh they understand themselves to be in a [21:48] meta kind of metaphysical war for the [21:50] salvation of humanity. [21:53] So how does this manifest itself? In my [21:57] book, I I discuss uh how how this came [22:01] about in the academy, how it influences [22:04] social movements in the academy uh from [22:07] the academy, you know, to the street. [22:09] But really fundamental are points that [22:12] Carrie made and I'll elaborate on uh the [22:16] the self-righteousness with which the [22:20] anti-Zionists uh espouse and incite [22:23] their Jew hatred [22:26] and the [clears throat] the the nature [22:29] of kamas the evil when when you see [22:32] students in the encampments wearing [22:33] t-shirts that say we are kamas what do [22:36] we are what who are you identifying with [22:38] what does it mean [22:41] now October 7th, 2023 [22:45] was uh Simka Torah [22:49] which was also on a Shabbat which was [22:52] also on the the holy day of Shimat. [22:55] Simka Torah is rejoicing in the Torah. [22:58] Shimyatser is the the eighth day of [23:02] gathering together after the feast of [23:04] tabernacles, you know, Sukkot. [23:07] It's uh it's it's a the day when Shabbat [23:12] simra shamanat converge is is a day of [23:17] holiness on the Hebrew calendar. A point [23:20] not wasted on kamas. Yaki senoir bragged [23:24] about how much he had learned about [23:25] Judaism during the 22 years he spent in [23:28] an issraeli prison. [23:31] Um, similar to the Nazis, I think they [23:34] were they planned this for for a Jewish [23:36] holy day. It had originally been planned [23:39] for Passover of 2023, which would be the [23:43] anniversary of the Park Hotel Passover [23:48] massacre in Natana, although that [23:50] massacre was not on the scale of this. [23:54] Um, the also reminiscent of the Nazis. [23:58] If you if you look at the the photos of [24:01] what took place of the scene of the [24:03] aftermath, if you if you can stand to [24:06] watch the videos that Senoir ordered to [24:09] be taken by Hamas, [24:12] uh you'll see that children were first [24:16] targets and were not just killed. The [24:21] Jews on that day were not just murdered. [24:23] murders. The word murder seems to be [24:26] inadequate when you see [24:29] what happened. [24:31] Um Charles and I and and a couple of his [24:34] gap folks were at Kar Aza in January of [24:38] 25. [24:40] And while we were there, the the the [24:43] person guiding us around the kibuts [24:46] mentioned that, you know, there's a man [24:48] who who still rummages through the [24:50] rubble looking for his son's head. [24:54] That's what we're dealing with. [24:57] Uh part of the shock was not just the [25:02] the brutality, the butchery, the rape. [25:05] Uh again, these words fall short when [25:08] describing what happened that day. Uh [25:12] when 6,000 individuals came from Gaza [25:16] into Israel, almost half of whom were [25:20] so-called civilians. [25:23] uh the words the language falls short [25:28] but the um the the horror of what [25:31] happened part of the horror of what [25:33] happened was the reaction to what [25:34] happened or the lack of one. [25:37] Some of us are still in our naive t [25:39] thought well now the world will wake up [25:44] to this evil [25:47] this this extermination this Jew hatred [25:50] that it's espoued by Hamas they now the [25:54] world won't be so careful to endorse it [25:56] and exactly the opposite happened [26:00] the celebrations in Gaza were matched [26:03] only by the celebrations on college [26:05] campuses worldwide. [26:09] As Carrie points out, as if that weren't [26:12] enough, uh when three of the leaders of [26:16] the top universities in the world had an [26:18] opportunity to say something, they [26:22] basically remain silent. Liz McIll of [26:24] Penn, Sally Cornbluth of MIT, Claudine [26:27] Gay of Harvard, uh Dr. McIll and Dr. gay [26:33] have since resigned, but [26:35] nevertheless, [26:38] um, so in in again to Car's point about [26:42] knowing what you're dealing with, who [26:44] are these people, where do they come [26:46] from, [26:47] what what are their aims? You know, many [26:50] people, [26:52] I think, are perhaps familiar with names [26:54] like Hitler, Himmler, and Gerbles, and [26:57] Guring. [26:59] Uh but fewer people are familiar with [27:02] Ahmed Yasin, Abidazi Alantisi, Khaled [27:05] Mashal, Isma Khan, Khan Senoir, and now [27:08] Hala. If we don't know these names as [27:12] well as we know the Nazi names, we don't [27:14] know who we're dealing with. We don't [27:17] know who we're dealing with. [27:20] Uh Kamas is Muslim Brotherhood. The [27:23] Muslim Brotherhood leader Ysef [27:25] Alcaradawi, [27:26] the late Alcaradawi [27:28] once said that the aim of the [27:30] brotherhood is to complete what Hitler [27:33] started. That's what you're dealing [27:36] with. Open open [clears throat] and [27:38] unabashed. [27:39] Uh Hitler declared in the early 1920s [27:42] declared to his friend Herman Rashning [27:45] that his mission in life was to destroy [27:48] the tyrannical god of the Jews and his [27:51] life denying ten commandments. Uh I [27:55] think that [27:58] planning this massacre for Simka Torah [28:01] uh we see what the anti-Zionists are [28:04] anti. Simka Torah is rejoicing in the [28:07] Torah that goes forth from Zion as it's [28:09] written. Uh the Torah goes forth from [28:12] Zion, the word of God from Jerusalem. Uh [28:15] I think similar to the Nazis but with [28:18] the with their own difference. Uh what [28:21] Hamas and the Muslim Brotherhood are [28:24] doing is basically [28:26] obliterating [28:28] the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. [28:32] Uh and there are of course connections [28:35] between the brotherhood and the Nazis. [28:37] The brotherhood and kamas which [28:39] identifies itself as brotherhood. Uh one [28:42] of the key connections is as I explain [28:45] in the book is Hajamin Al- Husseini. [28:49] Uh [28:51] Al Husseini preached that murdering Jews [28:54] pleases Allah. In fact, the blood of a [28:56] Jew guarantees us a place in paradise. [29:00] If you if you note what is happening as [29:03] the the Hamas [29:06] murderers are, you know, butchering, [29:08] beheading, burning, maming the Israelis, [29:12] they pray Allahu Akbar. They praise God. [29:17] This is not a night and fog operation, [29:20] right? As the as the Nazis sometimes [29:23] referred to what they were doing. uh [29:25] Ahmed Yasim the founder of Kamas said [29:29] the killing Jews is an act of devotion. [29:33] How do you show your righteousness your [29:35] your redemption your salvation [29:38] [clears throat] [29:40] and you know before Allah [29:43] you spill the blood of the Jews you [29:45] raise your hands stained red with the [29:48] blood of Jews. Uh, how do you virtue [29:53] signal your righteousness in the [29:55] academy? You vocally [30:00] support Hamas. You encourage your [30:02] students to go out onto the encampment [30:04] and and shout death to the Zionists from [30:07] the river to the sea. We are Hamas. [30:12] uh [30:13] the [30:16] those who would be as God which is which [30:19] among whom are the elite intellectuals, [30:21] those who have the truth as Carrie said, [30:24] those who have the good uh those who [30:28] would be as as God have to not only what [30:33] legislate from the divine throne, but [30:36] they have to dam from the divine throne. [30:40] And the first ones damned [30:43] here are the Jews. All evil is Jewish. [30:49] Uh so the the SA massacre, [30:54] it's the SK Torah massacre, the massacre [30:56] of October 7th [31:00] was about butchering, not about [31:02] butchering human beings. It was about [31:04] waging war against Satan. [31:07] [clears throat] [31:08] Uh the demonization of the Jews is a key [31:12] to the incitement of hatred of the Jews. [31:16] Uh demonization [31:18] leads to dehumanization. [31:21] Demons aren't human. Uh which in turn [31:25] leads to devictimization. The humans [31:29] only humans can be victims. Once they're [31:32] dehumanized, they can't be victims. [31:35] Part of part of 107 denial lies in dev [31:40] victimizing [31:41] the victims as well. They brought it on [31:43] themselves. Well, it's exaggerated. [31:46] There's the uh the women's studies [31:48] scholar at University of Minnesota who [31:50] who said well there's really not much [31:52] evidence of rape and if you accuse kamas [31:56] of rape it's racist. It's the old uh [31:59] people of color prey on white women. [32:04] Uh [32:06] once [32:08] all Jews are evil and not and that is [32:11] all evil is Jewish rather the Jews are [32:14] rendered as invisible as Satan. This the [32:17] the Satanizing of the Jews, the [32:19] demonizing of the Jews [32:21] is an abstraction of the Jews. [32:25] It's much easier to hate an abstraction [32:28] than a flesh and blood person. Although [32:31] it finds its expression there. I mean, [32:33] every time M Donnie uh accuses Israel of [32:36] genocide in Gaza, [32:39] Jews on the street of New York get [32:40] attacked. [32:42] Uh it legitimizes the assault on the [32:45] Jews. This demonization legitimizes [32:49] assault on the Jews. And the the moral [32:53] inversion that we see coming out of the [32:55] campuses is is is [32:58] mindblowing. You have people like uh [33:00] Russell Rickford of Cornell who [33:02] glorified [33:04] the rape and the slaughter and the [33:06] butchery perpetrated by Hamas saying it [33:09] was it was exhilarating. It was [33:11] energizing. He says [33:14] and those who weren't exhilarated are [33:16] not quite human. [33:19] There's it's a mark of humanity, mark of [33:22] righteousness, the mark of of uh moral [33:25] integrity [33:27] to find what happened on 107 [33:31] exhilarating. [33:33] Uh see what this is again the the kind [33:38] of perversion that you get when all evil [33:41] is Jewish. So whatever the going evil of [33:45] the day [33:47] might be, whether it's colonialism, [33:50] apartheid, racism, genocide, [33:54] uh what have you, Israel, Israel gets [33:56] tagged with it. [33:58] Uh racism continues to be a fundamental [34:02] evil. I mean that many of us would [34:05] rather be deemed a pedophile than a [34:08] racist. [34:09] uh the Soviet uhbacked resolution 3379 [34:14] from 1975, Zionism is racism still [34:18] abides, still has a huge impact. You [34:21] you'll see signs on these at these [34:23] encampments saying Zionism is racism. [34:27] uh they would think if [clears throat] [34:29] Israel, you know, Palestine will be free [34:32] from the river to the sea, they might [34:34] think that it will be free of racism. If [34:38] it's free of the Jews, then it's free of [34:39] racism because racism is an evil that [34:44] comes from the Jews. Uh [34:49] ultimately however [34:51] the the redemptive nature of of this [34:54] anti-semitism [34:56] uh is really not about some historical [34:59] contingency like colonialism or [35:03] apartheid or racism or genocide even the [35:07] Jews the Jewish state is not hated for [35:10] any of its actions or even its policies. [35:14] The Jewish state is hated for its [35:16] existence. [35:19] And indeed, uh, a Salafus shake named [35:23] Muhammad Hussein Yakub of Egypt, uh, [35:27] >> Professor Patterson, just letting you [35:28] know, you have five minutes left. [35:29] >> Okay, that's all I need. [35:32] She uh Muhammad Hussein Yahoo once [35:35] declared once said not so long ago, if [35:38] the Jews left Palestine to us, would we [35:41] start loving them? [35:43] The Jews are infidels [35:46] i.e. evil not because I say so be but [35:50] because Allah [35:52] says so. Uh they are enemies not because [35:55] they occupied Palestine. They would have [35:58] been enemies if they did not occupy a [36:00] thing. Our fighting with the Jew is [36:03] eternal until not a single Jew remains [36:05] on the face of the earth. And I can [36:08] imagine this this clip being played at a [36:13] faculty meeting and nobody saying [36:15] anything. [36:17] Um so what are the anti-ionist of today [36:22] saying when they celebrate when they [36:25] then when they cry out we are Hamas [36:28] death to the Zionist from the river to [36:30] the to the sea. [36:33] uh they're saying that the Jews have to [36:36] be exterminated for the sake of humanity [36:40] and in the name of God. If you're a utoo [36:43] utopian progressive for the sake of [36:45] humanity. If you're a jihadist [36:49] uh fanatic, it's in the name of God. And [36:53] it's non-negotiable. [36:56] This is nonnegotiable. [36:59] uh these this this anti-ionism has the [37:03] trappings of a kind of religion. Uh some [37:06] call it Palestinianism. [37:09] This is a term that's has has issued in [37:11] the last couple of years because it's [37:13] come about. [37:15] Uh so how what can we do about it? What [37:18] should I mean when when Jews ask me that [37:20] I tell them be Jews unapologetically. [37:23] Rejoice in your Judaism. [37:26] uh don't don't water it down. I mean, [37:29] however you understand it and uh if [37:34] you're not Jewish, [37:36] stand you should stand for the truth. [37:40] Uh ask your ask yourself when when what [37:43] am I identifying with when I identify if [37:46] I identify with Hamas? if I identify [37:49] with the Palestinians and after 107 [37:53] Palestinian means basically Hamas. [37:57] Um, so that's all I have. Thank you all [37:59] and I look forward to questions. [38:17] Thank you. [38:20] >> Thank you guys so much. That was really, [38:22] really insightful and incredible. Um, [38:25] Dr. Small, are you ready to begin the [38:27] Q&A and moderate that? [38:40] >> Have we lost Charles? [38:44] Not 100% sure, but what I could do in [38:47] the meantime, there are a couple of [38:48] questions in the Q&A box. So, I can go [38:51] ahead in the meantime start asking you [38:53] guys those because I know a couple of [38:54] those. [38:55] >> Sounds good. [38:56] >> Okay, let's go ahead and do that. Oh, I [38:57] see four. Okay, let's go ahead and do [38:59] this. Okay, so the first question is [39:03] from Louise for Professor Nelson. You [39:06] mentioned that the encampments, mares [39:09] and protests were well organized and you [39:12] expand on who were the organizers. Is [39:14] there any research on that aspect? [39:19] >> Well, the first thing to say is that um [39:22] it didn't have to be organized in a [39:25] standard topdown declaratory fashion. It [39:29] didn't have to have leaders and that's [39:31] really because of social media. So, you [39:34] know, if you were if you were in the US [39:36] and you were interested in running an [39:39] encampment, you would find that you had [39:42] pamphlets [39:43] in your mailbox, your email box, telling [39:47] you what to do, diagrams about how to [39:50] resist police, diagrams about how to or [39:53] occupy a building. So social media [39:57] widely distributed the guidelines for [40:00] running the encampments and for the [40:02] anti-Zionism [40:04] and its ideology that pervaded these [40:07] groups. So ordinarily you think or well [40:10] organized means particular leaders are [40:14] identified. In this case you don't need [40:16] leaders, you just need messages. [40:19] Anonymous messages are quite sufficient [40:21] and operated that way. That was one of [40:24] the ways that this was unique. Uh the [40:27] other thing that we we're just starting [40:30] to find out because it's very difficult [40:33] is where all the funding came from. I [40:36] mean ISGAP has done wonderful research [40:39] in tracking cutter cutteries money into [40:42] universities. But we know that there's [40:44] still more than that. And we know that [40:47] there's cutteries money and other money [40:49] perhaps Saudi Arabian money that uh [40:52] we're not yet tracking. Obviously, if [40:56] you know, if a campus group gets a bag [40:58] of $100 bills at 2 am in the morning, [41:02] it's not going to register as a [41:04] transaction that can be traced. But [41:06] we're we're beginning to learn that. But [41:09] that's an element of it where I think [41:10] there's a tremendous amount of [41:12] additional work to be done. Um so I [41:16] think that's when I when I say that well [41:19] organized you have to really understand [41:21] that could be done was done very much [41:24] differently than would have been done in [41:26] the past. You think of the some of the [41:28] student movements in the 60s that I was [41:31] part of. They always had particular [41:33] charismatic figures who were running the [41:36] show. [41:38] There were no charismatic figures here. [41:41] There were some outspoken and rather [41:43] loathome faculty members, but they [41:45] weren't they weren't internationally or [41:47] even nationally charismatic. [41:54] >> All righty, let's move on to the next [41:55] question because I'm seeing a lot more [41:57] come in. Okay, the next one is, "Thank [42:00] you, Professor Nelson, for your [42:02] courageous and important work. You have [42:04] used the word anti-semitism at times in [42:07] your talk, although predominantly [42:08] anti-ionist hatred. Do you see [42:11] anti-ionism as anti-semitism? Some [42:14] claim, I'm not against Israel existing, [42:16] classic definition of Zionism. I just am [42:19] opposed to the oppressor, colonialist, [42:21] etc. Is anti-ionism therefore the [42:24] correct term and serving as a guise for [42:26] anti-semitism? [42:28] >> Yeah, that's a really important [42:30] question. I'm glad you a that whoever [42:32] asked it asked it. Um the simplest way [42:35] of saying this, the clearest way I think [42:38] of saying it is that anti-zionism [42:42] is the contemporary form of [42:45] anti-semitism. [42:47] It's the form that anti-semitism [42:49] takes now and of course started to take [42:52] in 1948 when Israel was founded. Prior [42:56] to 1948, you could be a Jewish [42:59] anti-Zionist and you were just engaged [43:01] in a philosophical political [43:03] conversation. What's the best route for [43:06] the Jewish people going forward? So, [43:08] should they assimilate into existing [43:10] countries or do they need their own [43:12] homeland? Well, in the wake of the [43:15] Shawah, the Holocaust, it became pretty [43:18] clear that Europe wasn't much of a [43:20] homeland for Jews. that they needed [43:22] their own place and they needed their [43:25] own state. Well, anti-Zionism [43:28] in 1948 [43:30] became opposition to a particular [43:34] national entity to a to a to the country [43:37] of the Jews and therefore it acquired a [43:41] religious component. Anti-Zionism on [43:44] that day in May 1948 [43:47] became partly a religious movement. I [43:50] think the the one lesson you must take [43:52] from what you heard from David is that [43:56] 107 was a religious event. [44:01] Hamas was driven by religious passion. [44:04] That's the single [snorts] [44:06] hardest lesson for Americans to take. [44:09] >> Yeah. [44:10] >> We just we like to people like to think [44:12] of Hamas as a political movement. Well, [44:14] it was a political movement, but it was [44:17] also a religious passion. a religious [44:19] crusade and that it's it's that [44:22] religious element that enabled people to [44:26] behave in such monstrous barbaric ways [44:29] just as the crusades did uh thousands of [44:32] years ago. Yeah. The religious passion [44:36] when it's allied with a political [44:38] mission becomes incredibly pernitious [44:42] and that's what we had oh 10 on 107. So [44:46] I think understanding that that [44:49] anti-Zionism is now anti-semitism's [44:52] current form lets you realize that they [44:54] have in large measure fused. They've [44:57] become one and the same. Now the [45:00] compliment complimentary movement to [45:03] their becoming one and the same are the [45:06] anti-sionists saying oh no we're totally [45:10] different. So anti-Zionists have become [45:14] much more passionate in declaring that [45:16] they are not anti-semites since 107 and [45:20] especially in the course of 2024. [45:24] That's become an obsession. Of course [45:26] we're not anti-semites. And the reason [45:29] they say of course we're not [45:30] anti-semites is because they are. [45:33] >> Yes. [45:35] Yes. If I could just underscore two [45:38] brief points. It's an excellent question [45:40] because [45:42] words have meaning. [45:45] The word Zion has a history of meaning [45:47] and a history of usage. Anti-Zionism as [45:50] Carrie points out has its as a term has [45:52] its own history. Uh which [45:56] so knowing some that history is [46:00] important to understanding what's [46:02] happening now. And uh as Carrie says, [46:04] the more fervently now one denies being [46:07] an an anti-semite, the more you can be [46:09] sure he or she is [46:13] especially in the academy. [46:21] Okay, let's move on to the next [46:22] question. [46:24] So this isn't posed to either one of [46:27] you, so whoever wants to jump in can go [46:28] ahead and answer. Um, instead of pinning [46:30] the blame for October 7th on Hamas, aka [46:33] the Islamic Resistance Movement, [46:36] wouldn't it be more accurate to use the [46:38] term Islam Nazism or chronically [46:41] mandated jihad? As you said, half of the [46:44] Jew killers were civilians and groups [46:46] like Palestinian Islam, Jihad, like the [46:49] Alcasam Brigades, etc. Isn't the issue [46:52] Islam and the Quran? [46:57] Well, David, that should be yours. [46:59] >> Here too, there is a history uh of the [47:03] the use of the word jihad. Uh what is [47:07] from Quran and what might be is Islam [47:10] Nazi. [47:11] Uh the Muslim Brotherhood which was [47:14] founded in 1928 [47:17] drew very close to the Nazis in the [47:19] 1930s. They sent delegations to Nermberg [47:22] rallies and this shidak this connection [47:24] was made by Hajjamin Al Husseini. [47:28] Uh so this is who is building on uh the [47:33] a modern turn in the history of jihad [47:37] which is the marriage of jihad with [47:39] politics. [47:41] uh this is something that is uh was [47:45] initiated I don't know about initiated [47:47] but formulated by uh Abdul Alam Madudi [47:52] in the early 20th century. So uh yes it [47:56] it's it's not by accident that this [48:00] current form of kamas style uh jihad is [48:06] Islamic. It's no accident that in their [48:09] charter they invoke the Quran to justify [48:13] their their act their actions and their [48:16] beliefs. They invoke the Hadith. And the [48:19] third proof text they invoked in the [48:22] covenant is protocols of the elders of [48:25] Zion. [48:27] So when you marry the protocols to the [48:29] Quran, this is what you get. [48:32] Uh so yeah, you have you you can't [48:35] ignore the fact that this is Islamic. Uh [48:39] not all certainly not all Muslims are [48:42] jihadist of this of this kind but all [48:46] jihadists of this kind all kamas [48:48] jihadist identify as Muslim. [48:52] Uh Islam is a lot of different things [48:55] like Christianity is a lot of different [48:56] things. Even Judaism is a few different [49:00] things at least. [49:02] So, uh yeah, all the more reason to be [49:06] informed to study history to to read the [49:10] text and the the the manifestos [49:14] of these guys, you know, like Sedum and [49:17] Hassan Albana, if you can stand it, [49:20] uh it'll tell you a lot. So, yeah, this [49:23] it's excellent question. Um we can't [49:26] ignore the fact that this is what [49:29] Harakat amukawama al-Islami right the [49:32] Islamic resistance mo movement [49:36] >> yeah we need to I think people in the [49:38] west need to understand the Islamist [49:41] history much more than they do now yes [49:44] >> and I think the exact term and I the [49:47] exact term that you give priority is [49:50] probably less important than than your [49:52] ability to ask the question I I mean the [49:55] questioner obviously knows something [49:57] about that history and that's what's [49:59] important is to possess that knowledge. [50:01] >> Yeah. [50:05] >> All righty. The next question I see is [50:08] if entire disciplines are doomed are you [50:11] in support of shutting them down? [50:14] >> Ah well you ask the question that keeps [50:18] me awake at night. Um what I've dis what [50:21] I think is absolutely clear is that the [50:24] disciplines won't fix themselves. [50:27] And I think that two things need to [50:29] happen. One is that when corrupted [50:32] disciplines are are given the right to [50:36] hire a new faculty member, the control [50:39] of that hiring process has to be outside [50:42] the department. uh that is people people [50:44] who don't share the biases and [50:47] prejudices of that that corrupt [50:49] discipline need to do any hiring that's [50:52] going to be done and some departments I [50:55] think are so corrupted that they need to [50:58] be literally put into receiverhip and [51:01] simply allowed to dwindle in influence [51:05] and power over a period of time. uh some [51:09] departments need to be denied the grow [51:12] growth potential because there's no way [51:15] to do it in an honorable way. A friend [51:17] of mine a few years ago said, "Well, [51:20] what we need to be sure of is that any [51:22] department of any politicized department [51:25] gets one Zionist faculty member in it." [51:29] Well, let me tell you that ain't going [51:31] to be a happy camper. Uh I mean to be to [51:34] be Ruth amidst the alien corn to be in a [51:37] program that really hates you and feels [51:40] you have no moral witness capacity [51:43] that's not a civilized way for a faculty [51:46] member to operate to be shunned. So [51:49] simply depositing a Zionist faculty [51:52] member into an anti-Zionist program on a [51:56] campus I think is just not a survivable [52:00] way to proceed. The other thing that I [52:02] think needs to happen and we're a long [52:04] way from this but it needs to happen is [52:07] that there need to be programs in [52:10] anti-Zionism in Zionist studying [52:14] anti-sionism and studying anti-semitism [52:18] established on campus formal [52:21] departmental or programmatic mechanisms [52:24] to study those corruptions [52:27] defined in a way that they will be [52:30] ideologically coherent that they can [52:33] offer some balance to departments that [52:36] have drifted into anti-sionism [52:38] and I think you know there are programs [52:40] around the world is gap is one of them [52:43] that's helping to train faculty to teach [52:46] courses in anti-ionism and anti-semitism [52:50] well the next step is to have organized [52:53] programs for those kinds of courses that [52:56] assure coherence support for research [52:59] and assure continuity continuity on [53:02] campus. But you know in answer to your [53:05] question I've reached the conclusion [53:08] that some departments uh need to be [53:10] basically mothballled. [53:13] >> It's yeah it's it's the problem is [53:16] bigger than a problem of of certain [53:19] disciplines [53:21] uh or the humanities. The humanities [53:24] is about everything except the sanctity [53:27] of humanity. the human being. Uh [53:32] the larger problem is we've lost the [53:34] capacity to say I think what exactly is [53:39] higher and higher learning [53:43] what makes it higher? [53:45] What where's the what is the dimension [53:47] of height? [53:49] So uh that's that's a problem that [53:52] concerns the institution institutions [53:54] when you have presidents who can't say [53:56] anti-semitism is wrong. Right? So uh [54:00] yeah there are disciplines as has been [54:04] pointed out here that are notoriously [54:06] anti-ionist [54:08] but I I think it's it's a the problem is [54:10] bigger than a problem of that peculiar [54:14] to this discipline or that. there's a [54:16] bigger problem it seems to me. [54:22] >> All righty, let's move on to the next [54:23] question. This person asked three or one [54:26] comment I should say and then two [54:27] questions. So, I'm just going to put [54:28] them all in one just to knock that out [54:30] of the way. So, firstly, thank you Dr. [54:32] Nelson and Dr. Patterson. Do we know how [54:35] long ago the campus encampments were [54:37] organized? By who are the faculty still [54:40] teaching? A difficult question for me is [54:43] about Jewish students involved in the [54:44] encampments and ongoing anti-ionist [54:47] movements. Can you say something about [54:48] this? [54:52] >> Well, yeah, but I mean if you look [54:55] around the west, you will not find [54:58] faculty organizers of these encampments [55:01] who are no longer teaching. I mean, [55:04] their jobs were not threatened. They [55:06] weren't sanctioned or punished. What you [55:09] will find if you look around the world [55:11] is a number of Jewish faculty who have [55:13] been in corrupted disciplines and are [55:16] eligible for retirement. They retire. I [55:20] mean they give up at some point and I [55:22] don't blame them because I have friends [55:24] who've done that and they've just [55:26] they've decided they don't need that [55:28] hatred in their life anymore. They don't [55:31] need to be in those hostile [55:32] environments. they'd rather just [55:34] continue to do their work without facing [55:37] daily hostility. So, we are we're losing [55:40] Zionist faculty, but where we are not [55:43] losing anti-Zionist faculty. They're [55:46] still happily enscconced and they're [55:48] hiring more people. So, it's a good it's [55:51] a good challenge. Um I will say that [55:55] um there's no reason why faculties [55:58] should feel they need to hire [56:00] anti-Zionists. [56:02] That's a perfectly good reason not to [56:05] hire someone. Um especially if they have [56:08] if they have a passionate social media [56:11] presence. It's rational to decide you [56:14] don't need that influence on your [56:16] campus. Uh and you and boards of [56:19] trustees can block hiring like that. [56:22] There needs to be you know that kind of [56:24] oversight. Now ah yes about the about [56:28] the Jewish students and faculty there [56:32] are certainly significant numbers of [56:34] Jewish faculty who have actually become [56:39] more passionately anti-Zionist post 107 [56:43] Jewish faculty who are dedicated and [56:46] Jewish students dedicated to [56:47] anti-sionism have become more outspoken [56:51] more committed and so forth and I think [56:54] part of it part of it. It's I mean I [56:58] reject the notion of a comprehensive [57:01] form of self-hatred amongst Jews, but [57:04] what what you can learn as a Jewish [57:07] anti-sionist is to hate a portion of [57:10] yourself to to to dislike that portion [57:14] of yourself that perhaps grew up in a in [57:18] a positive relationship to Judaism, grew [57:21] up in a positive relationship to the [57:23] Jewish state. you can learn to dislike [57:26] that part of yourself. So partial [57:29] hatred, partial self-hatred, I think is [57:31] a feature of that passion. And obviously [57:35] all of the anti-Zionist movements love [57:38] to put a Jewish member front and the [57:40] center. I mean, you know, get a Jewish [57:42] Voice for Peace member who actually is [57:45] Jewish, which not all of them are. Um, [57:48] and put that person on stage with you, [57:50] standing with you at an anti-Zionist [57:53] event. So Jews get used that way. I will [57:57] say this to someone who thinks they can [57:59] survive that. You will be asked to [58:03] testify to your anti-Zionism, [58:06] to prove your anti-Zionism [58:08] over and over and over again. One [58:12] admission is not going to be enough. [58:15] You're going to have to stand up and [58:17] disavow the Jewish people over and over [58:20] again. And it's really not worth it. [58:23] It's not a good [58:26] identity for yourself that it but some [58:28] Jewish students and faculty have been [58:31] trapped in it. It's absolutely true and [58:33] it's one of the more painful things we [58:35] face on campus. [58:37] >> Yes, if I Yes, that's the that's how [58:42] evil works. And I don't hesitate to use [58:45] the word evil. Uh, [58:49] as far as Jewish faculty go, they're [58:51] they're not immune to virtue signaling [58:54] any more than anybody else. They want to [58:56] be counted among the righteous and the [58:58] redeemed like most people. They want to [59:02] be regarded as good Jews, which as you [59:07] point out, Carrie, sometimes means [59:11] selling your soul, basically being being [59:14] called out repeatedly to confess, [59:18] confess, confess. being uh having to use [59:21] the language of crimes against humanity [59:24] and apartheid state as terms that were [59:28] used in a document signed by 400 [59:31] so-called scholars in Judeaic studies. [59:34] As for the students, the students are [59:38] are young and and by definition a [59:40] student is uneducated, [59:43] uninformed. They're too young. But what [59:46] is what makes me nuts here and and what [59:49] exposes the evil is how it exploits [59:53] their desire to be good, [59:56] their desire to be part of a just cause. [59:59] I mean, some of us can still remember [60:01] that time when we were 20 and you wanted [60:04] to you wanted to stand up, be counted [60:07] for something worthwhile. [60:10] Uh, and of course, you know, they they [60:13] don't they can't they don't know the [60:15] what the river or the sea might be that [60:18] Palestine will be free, but they want to [60:20] be part of justice in Palestine without [60:23] even knowing what that means or what it [60:25] looks like. And they get exploited [60:29] by [60:31] the others who do know exactly what [60:33] they're doing. [60:35] So uh I blame the professor as much as I [60:39] do you know the this the students for [60:43] the for what happens in these [60:44] encampments and for for engaging in this [60:47] incitement to hatred. [60:51] >> Yeah. For students who make a commitment [60:52] to anti-ionism there's tremendous social [60:55] reinforcement. [60:57] >> Yeah. [60:57] >> They get invited to parties where people [60:59] feel the same way. They may go on trips [61:02] where people feel the same way. So the [61:05] social reinforcement for the commitment [61:07] to anti-Zionism is very strong. And if [61:11] you're an isolated Jewish student or [61:13] faculty member, there's there's an [61:15] absence of social reinforcement for you. [61:18] >> Yeah. You're alienated. Um and so we are [61:22] we are competing to some degree with uh [61:26] with strong social reinforcement on one [61:29] side of the fence and precious little on [61:32] the other side of the fence. Obviously a [61:35] student can belong can be active in hell [61:38] in a kabad in groups where they can get [61:40] that kind of social reinforcement. [61:42] Faculty members tend not to have it [61:44] available on their campuses. Um and that [61:48] the rein the social reinforcement for [61:50] anti-Zionist students is very very [61:53] strong. [61:54] >> Yes. [61:56] Yes. Don't underestimate that. [62:00] As you say, it's very strong. [62:04] >> All righty. Let's move on to the next [62:06] question. Should there be an Israeli [62:08] government that includes Arab MKs? [62:15] Well, I mean, my answer to that is [62:17] simple. [62:20] Arab citizens of Israel are 20 to 22% of [62:24] the country and I think that they need [62:29] to be part of the government. I think it [62:31] was it's a serious mistake um for uh the [62:36] opposition movement in Israel feeling [62:38] that they had to disavow the possibility [62:41] of having Arab MPs part of their [62:43] coalition. I understand it because in [62:46] the wake of 107 there's a stronger [62:49] feeling that that there's a fifth [62:52] columnist representation amongst the [62:54] Arab citizens. But I think by and large [62:57] Arab citizens of Israel do not want to [63:00] be in a country ruled by Hamas. They [63:03] don't want to be in a country ruled by [63:05] the Palestinian Authority. Um things are [63:09] better for them in Israel than they [63:11] would be in any of the existing Arab [63:13] countries. They actually like freedom of [63:15] speech and a few other things about [63:18] Israel that are characteristic of it. So [63:20] I think that um and I understand why [63:24] it's taken that turn since 107 but yes I [63:28] think uh Arab MPs Arab members of MKS [63:33] members of Kesset is a virtue and I [63:37] think a coalition should include them. [63:42] >> Yes. Certainly you don't want ethnic [63:44] origin to be a qualification [63:47] for holding a seat or a position or [63:50] being part of you know the government in [63:52] a democrat democratic society [63:56] that I mean that's a that's a pretty [63:58] important principle I think [64:00] >> yeah but you don't you don't want to ex [64:02] you don't want it to be a basis of [64:03] exclusion either that's that's the thing [64:06] you not like to percentage but you don't [64:09] also don't you don't want to rule out [64:12] active active participation in a [64:13] coalition from Arab members. I mean, you [64:16] know, obviously when when Bennett was [64:19] running the country, he was a very [64:21] conservative figure, but he did have uh [64:24] Arab MK MKs [snorts] [64:26] as part of his coalition. Uh and it [64:28] worked. Okay. [64:30] >> I So I think that's that's that's that [64:33] that's that needs to be recovered. [64:36] Israel needs to recognize that it has [64:38] loyal Arab citizens who are just as [64:41] loyal as anyone else and should be part [64:44] of the governing process [64:45] >> and can be help and can be helpful. [64:49] >> Right. [64:51] >> Absolutely. [64:56] >> All right. The next question. I am told [64:59] some students imposed students only seek [65:01] justice for poor Palestinians and are [65:03] anti-Israel not anti-Semitic. Also, [65:05] increasing number of Jews don't like or [65:08] agree Israel should exist as a Jewish [65:09] state. How to respond, please? [65:16] >> Well, Israel is a Jewish state. Uh, [65:19] that's what it is, and I think that's [65:21] that's what it always should be. But [65:23] there needs to be complete freedom of [65:26] religion. Um and people with all [65:28] religious faiths who are citizens need [65:31] to be able to participate equally in [65:33] political and social life and need to [65:36] have equal opportunities just as they [65:38] should have equal opportunities here. Uh [65:41] I think that that needs to be an [65:43] essential part of Israeli democracy. I [65:46] think it is possible to be both Jewish [65:48] and democratic. It has challenges [65:51] obviously, you know, it's not without [65:53] its tensions, but I think that's been [65:55] the model for Israel and I think it's [65:58] still the model that it needs to adhere [66:00] to. [66:03] Yeah. Uh look, when I we hear this [66:07] language all the time, I'm I'm just uh [66:09] trying to champion the cause of justice [66:13] uh for the oppressed people of [66:15] Palestine. Who's who's oppressing them? [66:19] Uh, it was the Hamas has murdered more [66:25] citizens so-called of Gaza, more [66:27] Palestinians [66:29] since they came to power than they than [66:31] Israelis. [66:33] Who's the oppressor? Who's the enemy of [66:35] the Palestinian people? I think in many [66:38] instances it's their leadership. [66:41] Uh, so [snorts] what what is I'm not [66:44] sure what justice looks like exactly. [66:48] Uh I'm not sure what the what the source [66:50] of the unjust oppression is exactly. Uh [66:56] there needs to be clarity on that point [66:59] before one makes the accusation about [67:02] you know unjust oppression. Where is it [67:05] coming from? What what are the examples? [67:08] What's driving it? [67:10] Uh [67:12] so yeah it's this this is sloganism. [67:18] sloganism. [67:19] >> One of the one of the remarkable things [67:21] that we saw on 107 and in the months [67:24] that followed [67:26] prior to that for decades prior to that [67:29] there were lively debates and [67:33] conversations about how to bring about a [67:35] two-state solution. [67:37] >> Yeah. It was it was as if some sort of [67:40] chemical process had occurred on 107 [67:43] because all the conversations about how [67:46] a two-state solution could be realized [67:50] disappeared. I mean it was like they [67:53] evaporated before our eyes. People were [67:55] no longer talking about possib different [67:58] ways of organizing two states, one for [68:01] one for Palestinians and one for [68:04] Israelis. Um [68:07] and the the date the the triggering date [68:11] for anti-sionism [68:13] changed [68:14] the for decades. [68:17] The triggering date was 1967 [68:20] and the 67 war when Israel first took [68:24] over Gaza and took over the West Bank. [68:28] That was the date, the critical date [68:30] that was argued about politically. After [68:34] 107, it ceased to be the date. The date [68:38] became 1948 when Israel was founded. [68:42] That became the pivot piv pivot point, [68:45] the key date that was disputed. And [68:48] that's a fundamentally anti-semitic [68:50] complaint. If you believe you're [68:53] fighting for justice for Palestinians [68:56] and you think justice means erasing the [68:59] state of Israel, which the movements on [69:01] campus now universally feel, that's [69:05] anti-semitic movement. [69:07] >> Yes. You c you cannot demand the [69:11] dissolution of the Jewish state and be [69:14] >> plainly [69:16] anti-sionist. [69:18] that demand. If you if you believe that [69:20] Israel is irredeemable, that it's a [69:23] fundamentally unethical entity and needs [69:26] to be eliminated, then you are taking an [69:29] anti-semitic position. And of course, [69:32] historically, we have believed that [69:35] states that are committing genocide [69:37] can't be fixed. They can't be corrected, [69:40] >> right? [69:41] >> Believe they need to be eliminated. And [69:43] the claim that Israel was committing [69:46] genocide in Gaza has consumed the [69:50] anti-Zionist movement. And it's an [69:53] anti-semitic conclusion and one that [69:56] demands Israel be eliminated. That's an [69:59] anti-semitic position. And that's part I [70:02] think the question help us helps us [70:04] realize how the two terms have coalesed [70:07] and become basically identical. [70:10] >> Yeah. Good. Well said. Yeah. What is [70:13] morally required when faced with a [70:16] genocidal state, [70:19] right? [70:22] >> All righty. I do want to be mindful of [70:23] time. I know we're a little bit over [70:25] time, but there are several questions [70:26] coming just as a heads up. Um, we'll try [70:29] to get through most of them. So, thank [70:30] you everybody for all of your very [70:32] important questions. Um, the next one [70:34] that we have is, "What legitimate and [70:36] effective role do you see for the [70:38] federal government to help deal with [70:41] this crisis on campus given the often [70:43] false counterargument about academic [70:45] freedom?" [70:49] >> Yeah. Well, that's um when I said that [70:51] the previous question was keeping me [70:53] awake at night, I should add that this [70:55] one was keep it keeps me awake also. uh [70:58] I have become convinced that campuses [71:02] cannot heal themselves at this point. I [71:05] think administrators [71:07] have realized that if they do nothing to [71:10] combat anti-semitism, [71:12] they will face less trouble and less [71:15] conflict than they will face if they [71:18] actually try to act against [71:20] anti-semitism on campus. They've figured [71:23] out that their personal survival has the [71:26] odds are better for them if they just [71:28] keep their heads in the sand and do [71:30] nothing to combat anti-semitism. [71:33] And that's one of the reasons why the c [71:35] most campuses have made no real progress [71:38] in it. And so you come to the conclusion [71:41] there needs to be more powerful outside [71:43] forces that are helping to push campuses [71:46] in the right direction. I think that um [71:50] Hel International, the Brandeise Center [71:53] um you know are amongst the forces that [71:56] I think the the the outside forces uh [72:00] that can help that can help get a sort [72:03] of national conversation going and can [72:06] help encourage reform on campus. I think [72:10] the federal government should be an [72:12] effective power and uh if you if you [72:17] look at the campus agreements that were [72:20] signed prior to the last election and [72:24] sometimes shortly after the last [72:26] presidential election, those agreements [72:29] with the federal government are pretty [72:31] good. Um they're co I think they're [72:33] coherent. They make pretty sound [72:36] demands. Uh if you look at the agreement [72:39] with uh George Washington University, I [72:42] think it's a pretty good document. [72:45] Unfortunately, those agreements had no [72:47] real enforcement power. That is, they [72:50] were signed as statements of principle [72:53] and they did not prove terribly [72:55] effective in actually generating the [72:58] results asked for. There was such an [73:00] agreement with my own campus, the [73:02] University of Illinois. What has the [73:05] University of Illinois done to to bring [73:08] the agreement into reality? What act [73:11] what actions has it take taken to [73:13] actually inaugurate the steps required? [73:16] Well, it's very simple. Absolutely none. [73:20] The first the first thing in the [73:22] agreement was that the agreement would [73:24] just be distributed to the faculty. That [73:26] was over two years ago and even that [73:29] hasn't happened yet. We were supposed to [73:32] have good uh anti-semitism [73:35] awareness training on campus. We don't [73:38] yet have that. We have we have a [73:40] problematic first draft uh that it's [73:43] quite confused and quite problematic. [73:46] Um so I've watched campuses um avoiding [73:52] actually fulfilling those agreements for [73:54] a long time. So you have to say there [73:58] needs to be some teeth in them. I would [74:00] also say that the agreements the Trump [74:03] administration has signed with campuses [74:06] are have not been enforced. They've been [74:09] very threatening, but they haven't [74:11] actually produced much results. So, uh, [74:15] do I think there needs to be federal [74:17] involvement? Yes. Has the federal [74:19] involvement so far been anything one can [74:22] feel confident in, one can admire? Can [74:26] one even feel confident in its [74:28] motivations? No. Um, so it's a it's a [74:32] pretty dark picture where you need [74:35] federal involvement, but the federal [74:38] involvement has often been destructive. [74:43] Yeah. What's the federal involvement can [74:46] take basically two forms. One is [74:49] [clears throat] money [74:51] and the other is lawsuits. [74:55] Um and as you say unless there's a price [74:58] to be paid [75:00] for violation of the statement of [75:03] principles even [75:06] uh nothing will nothing will happen if [75:09] there's no price to be paid if there's [75:11] no consequences [75:15] that's you know that's how I see it. [75:18] Yeah. [75:19] >> Yeah. I agree. [75:23] All right, Dr. Patterson, if people [75:25] regard their anti-semitism as a moral [75:28] obligation, does exposing their [75:30] prejudice have any effect? What might [75:32] lead them to reconsider beliefs they [75:34] regard as morally justified? [75:38] >> Uh, in some cases, nothing will lead [75:41] them to change beliefs or reconsider [75:44] beliefs. [75:46] uh as we've mentioned this in many cases [75:49] this has the power of religious creed [75:53] religious doctrine [75:56] uh especially when it gets attached to [76:00] one's redemption [76:03] uh [76:05] having said that there are in my [76:08] experience there are cases more often [76:11] with students than with faculty where [76:14] you can when you You you can ask why do [76:17] you think that? [76:20] What makes you think that uh the is [76:24] Israel is an aparthide state exactly? [76:28] Or or is racist exactly? What does that [76:31] mean? Or [76:33] you can ask what is what would justice [76:36] in Palestine look like? [76:39] Uh I'm fighting for justice. What what [76:41] does that look like? So if you can get [76:46] uh your your interlocutors, whoever [76:49] you're talking with, to to think it [76:51] through a little bit more, [76:54] then there's, you know, and I've seen [76:57] reconsideration take place. uh but this [77:00] has to be with with someone for whom [77:03] this uh this redemptive nature of the [77:07] anti-ionism is not so so so [77:11] deeply and religiously ingrained in [77:13] their psyche [77:16] um to for for others who are for whom it [77:19] is ingrained to reconsider would be to [77:23] lose their redeemed status their virtue [77:27] status of being virtuous of of their a [77:30] good person. [77:32] Uh, and because it's so fundamental [77:37] to their worldview, to say it has the [77:39] the trappings of a religion is to say it [77:42] is fundamental to identity, [77:45] understanding of reality, [77:48] uh, the firm ground under your feet. All [77:50] of that would come apart for many [77:53] individuals if they should reconsider [77:56] their their anti-sionisms. One way that [77:59] I I have seen them protect themselves [78:02] from from you know anti-sionism is to [78:07] absolutely express shock that [78:10] anti-ionism now could be considered [78:12] anti-semitic. [78:15] the the many people who are now in this [78:18] context fervently anti-ionist [78:22] absolutely and be bamantly deny being [78:24] anti-semitic. [78:27] >> One of the worst things that's happened [78:29] to campuses since 107 is that for some [78:32] anti-ionists, [78:34] it's become a moral principle, a form of [78:37] moral righteousness not to talk to [78:40] Zionists. I mean, universities are [78:43] supposed to be places where there's [78:45] debate, there's conversation, you test [78:48] ideas against those of your opponents, [78:50] and you listen to one another. But [78:52] anti-Zionists now often say, as a point [78:56] of honor, I don't waste my time [78:58] talkings. [79:00] Once you lose the ability to have a [79:02] conversation, I think you've lost any [79:04] potential for change. And David is right [79:07] there. I mean there are plenty of [79:08] students for whom these are not deeply [79:12] embedded beliefs. [79:13] >> Yeah. [79:14] >> They've made a casual commitment if that [79:16] can be believed to anti-Zionism [79:19] and they can be exposed to alternative [79:22] viewpoints if you have the organized way [79:25] to do that on campus. but thoroughly [79:28] indoctrinated people who've made [79:30] anti-Zionism [79:32] really central to to their identity, [79:35] they often just can't be reached. That's [79:37] I think a conclusion that you know is [79:40] worth recognizing. [79:46] >> Yeah. [79:48] >> Okay, I'm going to ask the last few [79:50] questions. I want to do a hard stop at [79:52] 1:30 just because I know we've already [79:54] gone over time, but there are still a [79:56] few more questions. Um, is anti-Zionism [79:59] disavowing the Jewish people? [80:08] >> Yes. Yes. Next question. [80:11] >> Yeah, that's I think that's [laughter] [80:12] where I'm going to go. That's where I [80:14] would go with that as well because [80:15] anti-ionism, you know, denies the right [80:18] of self-determination. [80:20] the right the the right the Jewish [80:22] people have to have chosen a state of [80:25] their own and that's fundamentally [80:27] anti-semitic. [80:29] >> Yes. [80:31] >> Okay. So, I'm seeing the last two [80:33] questions are more about the Knesset and [80:36] um Israeli politics. So, I'll kind of [80:37] combine it into one. Um at the moment, [80:40] the Arabs hold 19 seats in the Knesset. [80:43] Is it possible that in a few years it [80:45] will increase in numbers and keep on [80:47] increasing until a majority of seats is [80:49] achieved? Regarding active participation [80:52] of Israeli Arabs in Israeli politics, [80:54] should openly anti-Zionist Israeli Arab [80:57] politicians be included in a coalition [80:59] government? [81:03] >> Well, anything's possible. Is it [81:05] possible that it will continue to [81:07] increase? Yes, that's possible. If [81:10] you're forming a coalition, [81:13] you want to have a coalition with people [81:15] who will support your policies, right? [81:19] So there are certain litmus tests and [81:22] not just anti-ionist litmus tests, but [81:25] other policy litmus tests, aren't there, [81:28] that you would that would come to bear [81:30] when you're trying to form a coalition? [81:32] [clears throat] [81:33] Uh what can what can be what can you [81:36] agree on? What can you compromise on? [81:39] And uh [81:42] if if if I were forming a government, it [81:45] wouldn't be so much you can't have uh [81:48] anti-ionist Arabs in the coalition. [81:51] They're anti-ionist Jews also. Even in [81:54] Israel, they exist. [81:57] They exist. [81:58] >> Well, they [laughter] the principle that [82:00] that Eisenhot basically stated for Arab [82:04] participation in a government, it's a [82:06] pretty reasonable one. What he said is [82:09] that uh the Arab the Arab for an Arab [82:12] party to join his coalition, it would [82:16] have to state clearly that they consider [82:18] Hamas to be a terrorist group and I [82:21] think the designation of Hamas as a [82:23] terrorist group is rather accurate [82:27] and many Western governments have shared [82:30] that declaration. Yeah, that's that's a [82:33] reasonable principle to expect uh Arabs [82:36] who join a coalition to be willing to [82:38] sign on to. I don't think one should one [82:41] should ask a Jewish coalition to accept [82:45] thoroughly anti-Zionist [82:47] Arab members into it. So, you know, that [82:50] that declaration seemed to me quite fair [82:53] and accurate. [82:55] >> Yes. and not controversial, [83:00] right? Hamas is [83:02] >> you ought to be able to say Hamas is a [83:04] terrorist group after 107, right? If you [83:06] can't say that, something's wrong. [83:09] >> Yeah. [83:12] >> Okay. And our final question of the [83:14] session today, can you say a bit more [83:16] about the recent congressional report [83:18] investigating the American Psychological [83:21] Association as well as the [83:22] recommendations in process to suspend [83:25] accreditation granting ability for one [83:27] year? [83:30] >> Um well that's been a subject of [83:32] personal research for me uh for some [83:35] time. Uh uh the book the book um College [83:41] Zionists Confront the Abyss has actually [83:44] a long chapter about the single most [83:48] prominent uh anti-Zionist member of the [83:51] American Psychological Association who [83:54] actually headed division 39 uh for over [83:58] two years. Um [84:02] the simplest conclusion well there there [84:04] are two things to say about that report. [84:07] One thing is the simple fact of the for [84:10] of the report being written. The simple [84:12] fact of making the anti-Zionist [84:15] character of the American Psychological [84:18] Association a matter of public record. I [84:21] think that's a huge accomplishment that [84:24] that's really important and it it really [84:28] matters. However, removing their [84:32] accreditation authority for one year is [84:35] chump change. That is not a satisfactory [84:40] penalty for what has happened to the [84:42] American Psychological Association. So [84:45] the report is great. It really makes a [84:48] different to have difference to have a [84:50] public conversation to have a public [84:52] admission that it's a problem a serious [84:56] problem. Um but [85:00] the American Psychological Association [85:03] may be unreformable. [85:06] I'm not sure that it can be fixed. I've [85:09] been working with those people, members [85:11] of the APA uh well for four years and uh [85:16] they brought me on board to have a [85:18] conversation and uh they're a minority [85:22] of the APA [85:24] and that's all that they are. A majority [85:28] of the leadership of the APA is [85:30] committed to anti-sionism. [85:33] So I think reforming that organization [85:35] is going to be very difficult. But it [85:38] needs to be sanctioned in a much more [85:41] serious way than having its [85:43] accreditation eliminated for a year. It [85:46] ain't going to be no better after that [85:48] year. It's not going to heal itself in [85:51] that period of time. So I think that [85:54] part of the agreement as a is really [85:57] just completely inadequate. [86:00] I'm glad that the report is there. It's [86:02] a huge step in the right direction, but [86:05] it's not going to be enough to actually [86:07] change matters. [86:09] >> Yeah, agreed. [86:14] >> All righty. So, with that said, thank [86:16] you all so, so much, Professor [86:18] Patterson, Professor Nelson. This was [86:20] such an incredible book launch event for [86:22] both of your books. This is such an [86:24] exciting time for ISGAP. For everyone [86:26] that joined us today, on behalf of [86:27] ISGAP, we'd like to thank you all and we [86:30] hope to see you at future events. you [86:32] can go ahead and purchase Patterson and [86:34] Nelson's um book either on Amazon or on [86:37] our website. Um and we hope you took [86:39] something very insightful away from [86:40] today's session. Have an amazing rest of [86:42] your day or night wherever you're tuning [86:44] from. Thank you again everybody. [86:47] >> Thank you Sheriff for doing a good job [86:49] and also thank the people who [86:51] articulated those questions. I mean all [86:54] the questions were good. Every single [86:56] question showed knowledge and really [86:58] were interesting. So, it's a great to [87:00] have a conversation. The questions [87:03] really hit the mark. So, thanks to all [87:05] of you [87:06] >> indeed. Yes. Thank you all and thank you [87:08] Sher. Thank you, Carrie.