Transcript [00:00] All right. So, welcome everyone to uh [00:03] the inaugural session of ISGAP reads. Uh [00:07] before I introduce our uh esteemed [00:10] panelists and our members here, I want [00:12] to explain a little bit of what who am [00:14] I, what this is about. So, my name is [00:16] Shai Davididai. I recently joined as a [00:18] research fellow at ISCAP, the Institute [00:20] for the Study of Global Anti-semitism [00:22] and Policy. Uh I work on different [00:25] project at ISGAP. But one of the things [00:27] that the moment I joined I said I really [00:29] want to do is I want a journal club. Now [00:32] let me be completely fair and honest I [00:35] just miss having journal clubs. When I [00:38] was in academia, one of the things that [00:40] I loved the most, whether it was in [00:41] Colombia with all its faults and the new [00:43] school in Princeton and Cornell, was [00:45] that once a week or once every two [00:48] weeks, I got to sit down and read [00:51] something that I may have not [00:52] necessarily have read before that maybe [00:56] felt a little bit like I was forced to [00:57] do it, but then really engage with new [00:59] ideas and hear what other people that [01:02] engaged with the same ideas thought [01:03] about this. And as I was preparing to uh [01:09] to put ISGAP reads together, uh the the [01:13] idea became not just of us engaging with [01:16] the with the writings of ISGAP faculty [01:19] and ISGAP affiliated faculty, but also [01:22] to figure out how do we take the [01:24] knowledge that so many of our amazing [01:26] ISSGAP members or the community of [01:29] ISGAP. How do we take that knowledge and [01:31] move it to the bigger world? So many of [01:33] you I see are here are affiliated in one [01:36] way or another with ISGAP. So welcome [01:38] and I would love to have you and your [01:40] writing here as well in the future. Many [01:42] of you are not. You are equally welcome [01:44] and regardless of whether you are with [01:47] ISGAP or not. I hope that by the end of [01:49] this hour you will see yourself as part [01:51] of the ISGAP network and ISGAP community [01:53] and help us move the information outward [01:57] from the ivory tower or the ivory zoom [02:00] to the real world. [02:02] So uh before uh we begin I'd like to [02:05] introduce so uh first and foremost our u [02:10] writer of the of the month our inaugural [02:12] meeting uh Dr. Professor Andrew Pessen [02:16] uh from Connecticut College will be [02:17] talking about uh professor Pess's uh [02:20] work setting the record straight [02:21] refuting the common lies told about [02:23] Israel. Uh with us is Rachel Suggs who [02:28] is um the engine that makes Isgap work [02:32] or at least part of the engine. Uh if [02:36] you take [02:37] >> if you take away the Rachel, I don't [02:39] know if the car would move far or as [02:41] fast as it does. Uh Rachel will be uh [02:45] our co-panelist in the Isap reads and [02:48] hopefully moving forward as well. And uh [02:50] you can also see u Shira Zeller. She is [02:54] the program coordinator and the person [02:56] that takes my crazy ideas and makes them [03:00] into a concrete reality. So, thank you [03:02] Shar for uh being with us. Uh if you [03:06] have not read uh the setting the record [03:09] straight, refuting the common lies told [03:10] about Israel uh by Andrew Pess. Uh the [03:14] link has been sent to everyone who [03:16] registered. I really really highly [03:18] recommend this. You know, and when you [03:19] open up a PDF and it says 135 pages, you [03:23] get that scaring, uh, oh, I'm never [03:26] going to get this. You open it in a tab [03:28] and then you never get to it. But [03:29] really, it goes by like this. I learned [03:32] a lot. And I thought I knew everything [03:35] about the topic. And every time I read [03:37] something like this, I'm reminded by how [03:39] little I know and how much more there is [03:41] to know. So, thank you, Andrew. But [03:43] we're going to start with Rachel. [03:45] Rachel, [03:47] when [03:47] >> Hi. Hello everybody. Oh, sorry, Shai. [03:50] And hello, Shai. I remember you and I [03:53] concocted this idea for the ISGAP reads [03:55] journal club together at an Israeli [03:57] bakery in Manhattan. And now today, it's [04:00] finally a reality. So, it's very [04:02] exciting to be kicking this off. And Dr. [04:04] Pessant, when Shy and I concocted this [04:06] idea, your writing was the first idea [04:08] that came to mind and we said we can't [04:10] start with anybody other than Andrew [04:11] Pess. So, we're very happy to be here. [04:14] >> So, no pressure. [04:15] >> Yeah. So, no pressure. [04:17] Uh [04:18] >> I can think of several others I would [04:19] recommend ahead of me but thank you. [04:22] >> And I should say before we begin maybe [04:23] Rachel just so you know a little bit of [04:25] kinks. Uh we're going to be talking for [04:27] about half an hour. Then we're going to [04:28] break out into breakout rooms for a [04:30] little discussion that's in smaller [04:32] groups that every participants will get [04:33] to meet every participant and come back [04:35] into the room where I'll open it up for [04:37] Q&A that you can ask Andrew questions. [04:39] Uh okay Rachel. [04:41] >> Yes. [04:42] >> Off the top of your head like what was [04:43] your reaction? what did you think [04:45] reading this? [04:47] >> So, I also know quite a lot about the [04:51] subject. Um, this was my academic focus [04:53] and it's also been my professional focus [04:55] uh in my career. And I was surprised at [04:57] how much I learned. Uh, I was also [05:00] surprised at how easy it was to apply [05:04] rational thinking to nebulous [05:06] overarching ideas and thoughts that seem [05:10] uh that they can't be counteracted. I [05:12] was I was very pleasantly surprised at [05:13] how easily Dr. Pessen wielded the pen as [05:16] the sword and and combed a lot of [05:18] nebulous ideas. I thought that it was [05:21] rather as somebody who's read a lot of [05:23] literature on this subject. I thought it [05:25] was one of the most exhaustive, [05:27] definitive, comprehensive, [05:29] all-encompassing. It was quite a [05:31] surgical analysis, if you've read it, [05:33] you know what I mean, of the many [05:35] strains of logic that surmount and [05:38] overwhelm the Jewish and Israeli [05:40] community. and it made it in an uh quite [05:42] in an accessible way. And I found it to [05:45] be a staunch defense of what you Dr. [05:48] Preston call the cognitive apparatus. I [05:50] found it to be a staunch defense of [05:52] intellectual sovereignty about seeing [05:54] the lies for what they are and to be [05:56] able to dislodge you use the word [05:58] lodging in the cognitive apparatus to be [06:00] able to empower people to dislodge the [06:03] lies from the cognitive apparatus. So I [06:05] found it to be a defense of intellectual [06:08] sovereignty. Those are my uh initial [06:10] thoughts. [06:11] >> Was there anything that you read that [06:14] stuck with you either on the lie side or [06:17] on the refuting side? [06:20] >> So, I will say I've heard many times [06:23] people say at the French Shabbat dinner [06:24] tables that, you know, Israel isn't [06:27] guilty of what the our enemies are [06:29] accusing us of and in fact, we're [06:31] victims of what our enemies are accusing [06:33] us of. But to actually read it with all [06:36] of the evidence uh readily available, it [06:41] was quite eyeopening to see, wait a [06:43] minute, here's a concrete example of how [06:45] we actually avoided doing what we were [06:47] accused of, and here's a concrete [06:48] example of how we were actually victims [06:50] of doing what we were accused of. And it [06:52] left a lasting impression on me of [06:55] there's this term in psychology called [06:57] DARVO, D- A RV O. It's an acronym for [07:01] deny, attack, reverse the role as a [07:03] victim and offender. And it drove home [07:06] for me the understanding that what's [07:10] being levied against the Jewish and [07:11] Israeli communities right now really is [07:13] a form of psychological [07:16] uh I wouldn't say warfare, that's a [07:17] little strong, but psychological [07:20] >> say [07:21] >> psychological warfare. and that these [07:23] are documented tactics that the [07:25] psychological community has documented [07:27] in psychological abuse and psychological [07:28] torture and and psych and it's a form of [07:31] psychological warfare against the Jewish [07:33] and Israeli communities and it was [07:35] backed up and proven uh by your very [07:38] exhaustive impressive research and so [07:40] that was the the lasting impression that [07:41] I had. So, one thing, so for people that [07:44] haven't uh read all the the the essay, [07:47] and you know, I definitely really I will [07:49] keep saying this, you should. Um the way [07:51] it's built is around 12 big lies. We'll [07:55] get to that in a second, what the [07:57] biggest lies are. Um and then um Andrew [08:01] uh Dr. Pess he presents the lie presents [08:05] a long refutation but for many of the [08:07] lies then there's another segment called [08:09] the reversal and how the actual truth is [08:12] you know the lie is actually true if you [08:15] flip the roles and you realize that what [08:17] Israel is being accused of is actually [08:19] what Israel is experiencing. So maybe [08:22] I'll throw this and we weren't planning [08:23] this but Andrew when you were writing [08:26] this was this the structure you were [08:29] imagining or was this a structure of it [08:31] came out as you were writing? How did [08:33] you get to this lie reputation reversal? [08:37] >> Wow, what an opening. Well, first thank [08:39] you to ISCAP. ISAP does tremendous work. [08:42] So those new to ISAP, follow ISKAP, find [08:44] out about what they do. It's a it's an [08:46] honor and a pleasure to be the inaugural [08:48] um speaker in your series. And it's an [08:50] honor and a pleasure to be with Shai and [08:52] Rachel in particular. Um, uh, true [08:55] heroes. Um, some in front of the scenes, [08:57] some more behind the scenes, but both [08:59] heroes. So, it's a pleasure to share the [09:00] screen with you. Um, I could probably, [09:03] you know, they say professors, they pay [09:05] us by the word. So, I I could probably [09:07] respond to just the things you've said [09:09] so far with 45 minutes, which I will not [09:11] do, I think. Um, but let me just say a [09:14] couple of things. Um, first, uh, I do [09:16] want to make sure I mention that I have [09:18] launched the Institute for the Critical [09:19] Study of Anti-Zionism, which is a [09:21] scholarly enterprise to go after this [09:24] ideology, which is the source of a lot [09:26] of the problems we're seeing certainly [09:27] on campus, I would argue. And [09:29] interestingly for me, when I did a quick [09:31] review of this piece as I prepared for [09:34] today, um, I I saw how this piece led me [09:38] to the next step, which was creating [09:39] this institute. So maybe we I hope I [09:42] remember to, to get to that a little bit [09:43] later. Um, so yeah, check us out [09:46] substack.exo.com. [09:48] Uh, sorry, exo.substack.com. [09:50] ICSA.substack.com. [09:52] Find out what we're doing. Please [09:54] participate. Um, so, uh, you know, [09:57] here's what I'll say. This I I wrote [09:58] this piece fairly quickly, um, shortly [10:01] after October 7th. Um, I doing what [10:05] professors do. I don't know. I'm sorry. [10:07] What professors ought to do and maybe [10:09] used to do, at least used to aspire to [10:11] do, which is argument, evidence, facts, [10:14] logic, reason, make a case for [10:16] something. Uh, it would felt very much [10:19] like an emergency at the time that I was [10:20] writing this after October 7th. A lot of [10:23] the material that went into here were I [10:25] took from drafts of earlier pieces [10:26] because I've been doing this stuff for [10:28] for quite a while. very aware that um [10:31] you know I used to call it [10:32] misinformation and now I it's just it's [10:35] a campaign of lies and defamation and [10:37] it's malicious uh in its intent. Um so [10:41] I've been collecting responses to it for [10:42] years and it finally became time after [10:45] October 7th like you know all of jewelry [10:48] was on trial in front of the world [10:50] basically for defending ourselves [10:52] against genocidal maniacs who were [10:54] trying to slaughter us in large numbers. [10:56] uh it felt imperative to bring it all in [10:58] one place, have it as a resource, and [11:00] I'm reminded um uh I won't digress into [11:04] Renee Deart, a philosopher I studied [11:06] extensively, but um you know, the [11:09] exercise of refuting the lies and maybe [11:11] we'll get to that just that's I think [11:13] the big question here. We're not going [11:14] to spend time going through I think any [11:16] of the reputations. We don't have time [11:17] for that. Um but the idea of refuting [11:20] the lies itself uh I know for me it's [11:23] something I needed to do at least once [11:25] in my life career thoroughly because we [11:29] need to know and feel confident that the [11:31] truth is on our side. I I do know that [11:34] the truth is on our side but uh as [11:36] especially as a professor as a scholar I [11:38] need to establish the truth is on our [11:39] side in the way that I do which is the [11:42] what the product here it's a hopefully a [11:44] useful reference source for many people [11:46] but what I also learned um is that most [11:50] of our and and the truth is important [11:55] used to be important should be important [11:57] but the truth is important um as we face [12:00] our collective enemies there are many [12:02] distinction I think we could make within [12:04] the people who are opposed to us. There [12:06] are some hardcore people who we will [12:08] never touch. They're just enemies and [12:10] there's no point in engaging or [12:12] discussing with them. But I do and [12:15] there's a little bit of maybe naivity or [12:17] hopefulness or optimism. I'm mostly a [12:19] pessimistic person. I do think the [12:21] majority of people on campus, the [12:22] majority of students, even the ones [12:24] participating in anti-ionist activities, [12:27] they're not haters in their heart. they [12:29] are just caught up in this movement [12:31] which has all this information flowing [12:33] around. And if you get those little [12:35] threads of information that they get, [12:38] you know, if I if that's all I got, I [12:40] would be with them in the encampment. I [12:41] mean, like if Israel just the other day [12:44] um Providence, Rhode Island, where I [12:45] live, was voting on a BDS um ballot for [12:48] the city council. It's the biggest city [12:49] now to have it and it passed [12:50] overwhelmingly. And I spent three hours [12:53] handing out flyers trying to convince [12:55] people to vote no on the initiative. It [12:57] was not a pleasant experience, let me [12:59] put it that way, especially it passed [13:00] 75%. Um, but there was uh one person in [13:04] particular like I'm voting to divest [13:06] from genocide, you know, and [snorts] [13:08] it's like couldn't even penetrate into [13:10] that. It's cuz by the way, if I thought [13:12] a genocide was going on, it would be [13:14] reasonable to divest from it like, you [13:16] know, to begin undoing that thing that [13:19] Rachel mentioned lodged in her brain, [13:21] you know. And of course, I only had [13:23] about 15 seconds as she was walking past [13:25] me to go in and vote. I'm like thrusting [13:27] a flyer at her. Um hopeless there. But [13:30] um we need to know the truth and we need [13:32] to get it to as Shai was saying earlier, [13:34] right? We need to get it out there [13:35] because I do think many of the people [13:38] can be peeled away from this movement. [13:40] Not necessarily turned into Zionists. [13:42] That's too ambitious and maybe not even [13:44] desirable, but peeled away from the [13:46] anti-sionism to the point where they're [13:48] willing to say, "Well, you know, it's a [13:50] pretty complicated conflict. You know, I [13:51] don't know what I think." Which to me is [13:53] probably the most honest answer that [13:54] most people should have. So it's [13:57] important to do the truth, but much of [14:00] what we're facing isn't interested in [14:02] the truth. So I I wrote it in this [14:04] really emergency state of mind. October [14:07] 7th had just happened. We need to sort [14:09] of put it on the record that we're and [14:12] what we were seeing of course after [14:13] October 7th was this campus positive [14:16] response to this massacre. Uh approval, [14:20] celebration, endorsement, calls for [14:22] more. I mean it was absolutely shocking [14:23] to see and I needed to understand first [14:28] h how is that possible like I could [14:31] understand maybe being pro Palestinian [14:34] but looking at this thing and see it as [14:35] a nightmare that position was almost not [14:38] occupied by anybody right it was all in [14:40] celebration endorsement so I needed to [14:43] understand well what is the case that [14:44] they're making that turns this from a a [14:48] jihadi genocidal terrorist atrocity into [14:51] you know an act of national liberation. [14:53] And so the case is the thing that I'm [14:55] engaging with here, right? They have [14:57] this narrative and this whole set of [14:58] lies that um has taken over and [15:02] believing that helps one look at October [15:06] 7th and say you're, you know, you're in [15:07] favor of the murderers [15:09] >> and and you start the piece. Sorry. [15:11] Sorry. Go ahead, Rachel. [15:13] >> Oh, I don't mean to cut you off. Uh I [15:15] just wanted to say that I picked up on [15:16] on two issues of inversion when you were [15:19] speaking, Andrew. Right. [15:20] >> What was the the woman you were speaking [15:23] with said, "I'm voting to divest from [15:25] genocide." I I'm going to speculate. I I [15:29] know exactly what was going through her [15:30] head. What was going through her head [15:32] was what would I have done in 1940 in [15:36] America or in Germany? I What would I [15:40] have done during the apart regime in [15:43] South Africa? I would have wanted to [15:46] divest from the aparate regime in South [15:47] Africa and I would have wanted to divest [15:49] from Nazi Germany and because that's [15:51] what I want would have wanted to do [15:52] then. This is what I'm doing now. This [15:54] is my time if you there's the quote or [15:57] the graffiti that's on all of the public [15:59] bathroom stalls in every liberal town [16:01] which is if you've ever wondered what [16:02] you would do during the Holocaust or [16:04] apartheid like you're doing it now. [16:05] >> You're doing it now, right? [16:07] >> She's this is what she's thinking in her [16:08] head but it's an inversion. [16:10] >> Inversion. There was an attempted [16:13] holocaust on October 7th, 2023, but it [16:16] was actually against the Jews. The Jews [16:18] weren't the ones holocaust. So [16:19] everything is is inverted, [16:22] >> right? Uh, and I think that that really [16:25] is the defining mechanism of [16:26] anti-semitism as opposed to maybe other [16:29] classical forms of hatred or bigotry is [16:31] that it's a disease of the mind where [16:34] realtored [16:35] and what's up is down and what's down is [16:37] up and what's left is right is what's [16:38] right is left and uh and everything is [16:41] in the wrong place and you're seeing [16:43] reality distorted [16:44] >> and think right and I don't want to cut [16:47] shy off but I I definitely was picking [16:49] that up uh when when you were speaking [16:51] and I think you outline that very very [16:53] well in your book. [16:55] >> And I think that that inversion, you [16:56] know, there's a lot of things that get [16:58] get inverted and lies and they don't [17:01] take hold. And I think the reason that [17:04] these lies take hold so deeply and and [17:08] they like you said, they lodge [17:09] themselves in people's mind is because [17:12] they're not just lies. They are lies [17:13] that come with a story. It's it's a [17:16] whole package that people are sold and [17:20] you just have to accept the story. And [17:22] you call this the false narrative. And I [17:24] want to read this out loud for people. [17:27] Yeah. Right. [17:28] >> You you basically the way this essay is [17:30] structured is you start with the false [17:32] narrative that's going around on [17:34] campuses and in politics and then you [17:37] break it apart to each lie. So here's [17:39] the false narrative and it goes like [17:42] this. [17:44] There once was a country called [17:45] Palestine, existing from time [17:47] immemorial, ruled by the Palestinians [17:49] and home to a few Jews with whom they [17:51] got along nicely. Then the Zionist Jews [17:54] began arriving from Europe in the 20th [17:56] century, starting an ongoing genocide [17:59] against the Palestinians and expelling [18:01] hundreds of thousands in ethnic [18:03] cleansing as part of her project of [18:05] settler colonialism, thus coming to [18:08] occupy Palestinian land in 1948 and to a [18:11] greater extent after 1967 and building [18:15] illegal settlements. Palestinians who [18:17] remained in Israel and their descendants [18:20] are kept subjugated under apartheid, a [18:22] political system that reflects and [18:24] maintains Jewish supremacy. Those who [18:26] are expelled to the West Bank, Judea, [18:28] and Samaria now live under a crippling [18:31] occupation, while those who are expelled [18:33] to Gaza are kept in an open air prison. [18:36] All of the above proves that Zionism is [18:38] racism and that resistance to Zionism by [18:41] any means necessary is entirely [18:44] justified, including the massacre, [18:46] rapes, torture, and kidnappings of [18:48] October 7, 2023. [18:51] >> Right? So, if you believe that, right, [18:54] you'd be on the other side. And what [18:57] Shai wasn't able to reveal is that many [18:59] of the phrases in in that fourth [19:01] narrative are in scare quotes. So [19:03] there's a genocide and an ethnic [19:05] cleansing and settler colonialism [19:06] because those are basically all all the [19:09] major lies woven into a single narrative [19:11] which is very easy to digest. It's very [19:14] emotionally gripping and if it were true [19:16] you know and I've actually used that [19:18] same analogy Rachel myself which is like [19:20] if you know if I believe the Nazis were [19:23] massacring Jews in large numbers I would [19:26] participate in encampment and I would [19:27] break the law and I would get arrested [19:28] there. You know this I would do a lot of [19:30] things. Um, so I understand the mindset, [19:33] but then the scary point, and I do want [19:35] to elaborate a little bit on this now, [19:37] is that they've got sort of the right [19:40] general principle, which is genocide, [19:43] mass atrocities should be contested, but [19:47] they've got everything inverted. Um, and [19:49] I I just wrote a piece. I was very happy [19:51] with the title. Um, you mentioned it was [19:53] something like when up is down, black is [19:55] white, and the axe wielding lunatics run [19:57] the asylum. So, you know, um that's what [20:00] it feels like in academia today to me, [20:03] which is that this narrative, almost [20:07] every little piece of it is not just [20:09] false, but blatantly and demonstrably [20:12] false, obviously false. And yet, how [20:14] does it come to grip the mind? Starting [20:17] with the professors and then trickling [20:19] downwards to the students, right? Um so, [20:22] uh [20:22] >> so in your analysis, where is this [20:25] story? Where is this narrative coming [20:27] from? Is it a story that throughout the [20:29] years kept adding more bricks to it or [20:32] was it a hey world here's a narrative [20:35] please buy into it? [20:37] >> So let's first talk about the the Darvo [20:39] stuff right reverse victim and offender. [20:41] So as you study this, so this was my [20:45] understanding this narrative is crucial [20:47] to understanding how people could come [20:48] to support October 7th on campus and [20:50] then it was absolutely important to me [20:52] personally to make sure I could refute [20:54] it, which is what this piece is. And I [20:56] think everyone should have this in their [20:58] back pocket. You should be able to [20:59] refute these lies. But then as you start [21:03] pushing more deeply and you study how [21:06] each individual eye comes about and [21:08] comes to be added you know into the [21:10] entire narrative and I I will get to [21:12] your point Shai in a couple minutes um [21:15] you you realize that this is this is not [21:17] an accident. This this whole thing is [21:19] actually crafted quite deliberately [21:22] intentionally carefully by a set of [21:25] players. call them the major [21:26] anti-Zionist players, the members of the [21:28] anti-ionist complex to to use a phrase. [21:31] Um, and it is assembled um with [21:35] malicious intent and that intent is [21:38] ultimately the desire to annihilate the [21:40] Jews. And that's a little dramatic, but [21:43] it's true. That's ultimately what's [21:45] driving the manufacturers of this whole [21:47] false knowledge is they wish to destroy [21:50] the Jews. And so what you need to do and [21:52] this is maybe the most foundational [21:54] instance of the darvo of the reversing [21:56] victor offender or projection is another [21:59] word for this where you project what's [22:01] actually your own desires and ambitions [22:03] onto the other person. [snorts] Um in [22:06] order to destroy the Jews you need to [22:07] tell a story that justifies your [22:09] destroying of the Jews. Not too many [22:12] people are comfortable saying I'm really [22:14] evil. I want to you know genocide an [22:16] entire people. What they have to say [22:18] instead, they have to convince [22:19] themselves, and this is a issue for the [22:20] psychologists [22:22] to to grapple with. They have to say, [22:25] um, they're the bad guys. I'm just [22:28] defending myself from them. And so, if [22:31] you can, for example, project onto the [22:33] Jews the desire to perpetrate genocide [22:35] against you, well, then by all means, [22:38] you are justified in genocying the Jews. [22:40] That is actually and I can argue for [22:42] this at some length the foundational [22:44] Darvo moment or the dar the foundational [22:47] inversion which traces back at least to [22:49] the protocols of the elders of Zion at [22:51] the beginning of the 20th century. The [22:53] desire to harm the Jews is ultimately [22:57] justified by weaving a narrative in [23:00] which the Jews are the aggressors, the [23:01] Jews are evil. So it goes back to the [23:04] protocols and again as you as you track [23:08] the the genealogy of these lies there [23:11] where they develop and you can really [23:13] draw a straight line from the protocols [23:15] to probably almost every one of the lies [23:17] in that narrative that we just went [23:18] through here. You can sort of see where [23:20] it comes from how it de develops and [23:22] evolves. Um that's when you realize that [23:24] this is a carefully orchestrated [23:26] campaign whose goal was to annihilate [23:27] the Jews. And you see it, you know, the [23:29] journey it takes is from the protocols [23:31] in Imperial Russia through the Nazis and [23:35] then back into Soviet Russia and then it [23:37] joins forces with the Islamists and then [23:40] it evolves into the Western [23:41] progressives. So you can sort of trace [23:43] that whole line and you realize that [23:45] that's what it is in the end. It is part [23:47] of a campaign to justify destroying the [23:49] Jews and the best way to do that is to [23:51] ascribe to the Jews a desire to destroy [23:53] you. So the Nazi Nazi propaganda is [23:57] filled with the Jews are trying to [23:59] destroy Germany. This is their their [24:00] main mission in life is to destroy us. [24:02] So we have to destroy them. Soviet [24:04] propaganda absolutely filled with the [24:06] idea that little tiny sliver of Israel [24:08] is seeking genocide of Soviets and to [24:11] destroy all of socialism. Um the [24:13] Islamists since the seventh century of [24:15] the common year are saying exactly the [24:16] same thing. So it's a repeating pattern [24:19] that the people who hate the Jews and [24:21] want to destroy the Jews weave a [24:23] narrative on which the Jews are the [24:24] aggressor and our genocidal aggressors [24:26] against them which justifies conquering [24:29] them. And so that's what we're seeing on [24:31] campuses today unfortunately. [24:34] >> So so let me ask you you know in your [24:36] opening remarks here today you I agree [24:39] with you and I'm asking a friendly [24:40] followup. In your in your opening [24:42] remarks here today, you you [24:43] differentiated between the people who [24:45] who are dogooders and have and have good [24:49] >> mean well and who genuinely think [24:51] something horrible is going on and want [24:53] to fight against it. And then you [24:54] describe right the the people who [24:57] engineer the lies for nefarious reasons [24:59] who want to be get away with genocide [25:02] the Jews without the outcry of the free [25:03] world. So they write these lies and then [25:05] the mass no better believe them. Right. [25:08] And um is it your do you think that the [25:12] reason why these lies right because you [25:14] write about the fact that these lies are [25:16] demonstrabably disproven and you say [25:18] over and over again that these facts if [25:20] we shove these facts down their throat [25:22] it's still not going to dislodge the big [25:24] lie from the cognitive apparatus. Do you [25:28] think that the reason why these facts [25:30] aren't falling on receptive ears is [25:32] because there's this unconscious bias or [25:35] subconscious bias that the Jews are the [25:37] source of all evil in wider society? And [25:40] then when they're given proof to that [25:42] effect and then they they don't believe [25:45] the counter evidence to proof to that [25:47] effect because their initial bias that [25:50] Jews are the root of all evil and [25:51] they're just looking for something to [25:52] confirm that. [25:55] we're entering such dark territory right [25:57] now. Um uh and you know and it gets at [26:00] the foundation of like the failure of [26:03] our educational enterprise to penetrate. [26:06] So again a large part of the answer is a [26:08] psych as the psychologists have to talk [26:09] about how belief systems form what makes [26:12] them recalcitrant and most importantly [26:15] what we pority call poratively call [26:18] conspiracy theories. a person in the [26:20] grips of a conspiracy theory is you [26:23] can't get in there, right? Anything you [26:24] offer as a fact, they'll find a way to [26:26] weave it back into the conspiracy. And [26:28] so what you see when you study the [26:29] history of this, and I'm now writing a [26:31] book on the history of anti-Zionism, [26:32] which is the next step after writing [26:35] this essay here, um what you see is it's [26:37] a massive conspiracy theory. And a [26:40] question I've had as I'm writing this [26:41] book, it's taking a historical approach [26:43] doing this genealogy I was just [26:45] sketching. Um, and I'm looking at it in [26:47] the Nazis and in the Soviets and in the [26:48] Islamists and in the Western [26:50] progressives, etc. Um, do they really [26:53] believe the people who are writing this [26:55] stuff and levying these allegations, [26:56] these liels, these lies, do they really [26:59] believe it or are they just sort of paid [27:01] to produce it? And it's all, by the way, [27:03] most of it's scholars, professors [27:05] working at academic institutes who are [27:07] creating uh this vast conspiracy theory [27:10] and and as I like to describe it, [27:12] dressing it up in science. They they [27:13] dress it up in theory. uh and it it's [27:15] hard to know. It's impossible to know [27:17] for any one individual, but um I've [27:20] become convinced unfortunately of the [27:22] darker conclusion which is I think [27:25] they're both true that many of the [27:27] people, for example, the Soviet [27:28] Zionologists, these academics who are [27:30] producing book after book after book [27:32] accusing Zionism and Israel and Jews of [27:35] every sin under the sun. Um I think they [27:38] both know that it's false and yet [27:40] believe it anyway. Like that sounds [27:41] contradictory, but I think that's the [27:43] case. convince themselves. They became [27:47] victims of their own big lies. [27:50] >> Yes. You know, it's a it's a [27:51] psychological question, but these people [27:53] are literally paid to produce this [27:55] scholarship that casts the worst [27:57] possible light on the Jews that advances [27:59] this protocol's conspiracy theory about [28:00] the Jews. So knowing that you're paid to [28:02] write it, you know, you sort of know [28:04] that you're I don't know, inventing it, [28:06] making it up, and you when you get into [28:08] the weeds, you know, like the ridiculous [28:10] things they end up saying. It's unbel, [28:12] you know, rape dogs is just like a [28:14] that's a tip of an iceberg of such a [28:15] such a thing that the Kristoff liel a [28:17] few months back. Um, but I think, yeah, [28:21] I think they know that it's false, but [28:22] then precisely because they're gripped [28:25] by this overall narrative of Jewish [28:27] evil, then everything becomes [28:29] believable. your normal epistemic [28:31] standards are decreased. Like if you [28:33] already know the Jews are evil and [28:34] someone says, "By the way, they're [28:36] training dogs to rape Palestinian uh [28:37] prisoners," it's very easy to believe [28:39] that because you already have this [28:40] entire theory that makes it plausible [28:43] that the Jews would do such a thing. You [28:45] don't really need evidence. If you were [28:47] coming completely neutral with no [28:49] background and someone said the Israelis [28:51] train dogs to rape Palestinian [28:52] principles, you would demand presumably [28:54] a very high level of evidence before you [28:56] believe it. But if you've already got [28:57] this package in place, it's believable [28:59] before they it even gets off the ground. [29:01] So, um I think I think many many people [29:05] and I don't know how to distinguish now [29:07] the you know the hardcore you call them [29:09] dogooders that feels too positive for [29:11] them, but they're they're not hardcore [29:13] at least, right? They're not hardcore [29:14] haters. They think they're doing the [29:16] right thing in a very sort of sincere [29:18] way. Um, [29:20] >> you know, I think the hardcore people [29:22] are gripped by the conspiracy and then I [29:25] hope that the nonh hardcore softcore, is [29:28] that the right word? The softcore people [29:30] are um uh like all of us, [29:33] >> the followers, the followers. [29:35] >> Followers, they're even more than that [29:37] though. So, it's hard to find the right [29:38] word. I'm going to go with soft soft [29:39] core. Um, I think we're all prone to [29:42] conspiracy thinking. Um, there's [29:44] something satisfying about conspiracy [29:45] thinking and when there's social [29:48] pressure around you, it just becomes [29:50] believable and you rarely stop to ask, [29:52] but what's the truth? And here's the [29:54] last thing I'll say and I know you want [29:56] to go to breakout rooms, but um, uh, [30:00] they've done something very, very [30:01] clever. By they, I mean, you know, the [30:03] the enemy at large on the academy. This [30:06] comes out of progressivism. [30:08] um what they've established is that [30:11] maybe there's no such thing as objective [30:13] truth. There's just different narratives [30:15] that are expressing or advancing power. [30:18] And for a long time, you know, the the [30:21] the white male Jews, Israel is the [30:25] powerful party and the people of color, [30:27] Palestinians, oppressed, they are the [30:28] marginalized party. And so what we need [30:30] to do is advance and amplify the [30:34] narrative of the oppressed. And when the [30:37] other side naming us and I'm coming as a [30:40] white Jewish old man, right, like coming [30:43] to this, it doesn't matter what I say, [30:46] I'm actually dismissed in advance [30:48] because anything I'm saying right now, [30:49] the porative term haz, right? But like [30:52] anything I'm saying when I insist on [30:54] facts and I hold up this 130 page thing, [30:57] you know, I'm going through the [30:58] evidence, the facts, etc. I'm really [31:00] just trying to um advance the genocide. [31:03] That's all I'm doing. you don't. So, [31:05] they've set up this defensive shield [31:08] that does not allow truth or facts or [31:11] logic or reason to get in because the [31:13] insistence on those things is part of [31:15] the power structure that supports the [31:17] genocide. So, that's the moment when you [31:20] realize the academy is dead and the ax [31:22] wielding lunatics are running the asylum [31:24] because whatever the norms of the [31:26] academy once aspired to be or should be, [31:28] it's not that. It's not that. You're [31:30] dismissed in advance no matter what you [31:32] say. And it doesn't matter how many [31:33] footnotes I have and the sources I cite [31:35] and the the tightness of my logic. I'm [31:37] just an old white Jewish guy who is [31:39] trying to defend the genocide of the [31:41] Palestinians. So, [31:43] >> it's a a dark moment. [31:45] >> I want to do the thing that the the [31:48] people on the other side that were [31:49] accusing them, they never do, which is [31:51] give him grace and give him a benefit of [31:53] a doubt for a second before everyone [31:55] gets mad at me. Let's think of someone [31:57] like Rashid Khaledi who is a historian [32:03] I esteemed by others or think about [32:07] Nadia Abu Khaj who is an archaeologist [32:09] at Barnard in Colombia. Think about [32:11] these people, [32:12] >> right? [32:13] >> They would look at your false narrative [32:15] and what would their reaction be? I [32:18] mean, would they say, "Yes, this is it's [32:23] you're absolutely right. This is the [32:24] narrative and it's not false." Or would [32:26] they say, "You've taken the most extreme [32:29] story, [32:30] >> but you're missing a lot of aspects that [32:33] make it like you've they would blame you [32:36] of [32:37] >> narrowing down the complexity." That's [32:40] right. [32:40] >> Right. Or they could blame you of doing [32:43] the thing that you mentioned which is [32:44] the the anti-semitism of detraction. [32:48] Right. Like it's not about like what I [32:50] say, it's what I don't say. [32:52] >> So if we take their perspective for a [32:55] second, how would they defend the false [32:59] narrative? So I think the perfect [33:01] example is Khaledi because his book 100 [33:04] years on pal 100 years war on Palestine [33:06] is the perfect example of that where he [33:08] is more or less defending I would say [33:10] most at least offh hand like most [33:11] aspects of this narrative explicitly and [33:14] here's uh and and I think this is very [33:16] important I I believe still and I'm just [33:18] an old Jewish white guy so you can [33:20] dismiss it but you know I believe as a [33:22] professor in the classroom I really [33:23] believe in pedagog pedagogical [33:25] neutrality [33:27] that doesn't mean you can't express your [33:29] opinion but I try I work hard to do two [33:31] things. I work hard to represent the [33:33] other side as fairly and as well as I [33:35] can recognizing my own limitations and [33:37] biases etc. and also to distinguish as [33:40] well as I can when I'm sharing something [33:42] I consider to be a fact and when I'm [33:44] sharing my opinion. So I whenever I'm [33:46] teaching any of issues that are related [33:48] to this I probably say 20 times per [33:50] class session, well this is just my [33:52] opinion, right? Like recognizing that [33:55] these things are nuance. So I I'm very [33:57] committed to that and uh and the way I [33:59] distinguish I actually have a a little [34:01] spiel I do on the beginning of every any [34:03] cl any course that the testes on these [34:05] materials and distinguish between having [34:07] an opinion and being biased. Having an [34:10] opinion is a good thing. That's what [34:11] we're supposed to do to teach you to [34:13] think for yourself is to form an opinion [34:14] but being biased is a bad thing. So we [34:17] have to distinguish what is the [34:18] difference between having an opinion and [34:19] being biased. And at least part of that [34:22] distinction is having an opinion um well [34:26] a bias is one-sided that tends to ignore [34:28] complexity and context on the other [34:30] side. Whereas if you've looked at all [34:32] the factors and all the arguments and [34:34] you finally reach a conclusion, well [34:35] that's what you're supposed to do, [34:37] right? But the crucial part of that is [34:39] make sure you're looking at the entire [34:42] set of complexities that are involved. [34:44] So I know personally, you know, within [34:46] the limits of the 24 hours of the day, [34:49] right? I work hard. I read a lot of [34:51] anti-ionist literature. I read I read [34:53] most of Khaled's books, for example. I [34:55] need to know what they're saying. I need [34:57] to make sure I can refute it because [34:58] otherwise I should believe I accept [35:00] them, right? Um and here's what you [35:02] notice. Here's what I notice [35:04] consistently when I read anti-ionist [35:06] scholars including Khaled. I got like [35:08] his book 100 years war in Palestine. I [35:10] have pencil marks like every page, [35:12] right? Omission, omission, omission, [35:14] omission. They tell a story and they [35:17] completely omit all the surrounding [35:19] context, the relevant context, etc., [35:21] etc. So, what they do, and he's a [35:24] scholar, so I can only assume that he's [35:28] doing this deliberately because he knows [35:30] how to do re some of his scholarly work. [35:31] You know, he goes into the archives and [35:33] he creates a historical story based on [35:35] primary literature. That's very, very [35:36] impressive. I don't have that skill, but [35:38] what I can see by the way he tells the [35:41] story is how much he omits and [35:42] misrepresents and distorts. And I know [35:45] that because I happen to know the other [35:46] side of that story. So it's true that [35:49] maybe the false narrative if I put here, [35:51] if you only see this paragraph, you [35:52] might say that's not fair, um, a fair [35:54] representation of the other side. But [35:56] I've actually studied the other side [35:58] pretty well. And I think this pretty [35:59] much captures their narrative and I [36:01] understand how they produce that [36:02] narrative by omitting, distorting, [36:04] misrepresenting, and a whole bunch of [36:05] other violations of academic norms. So I [36:09] can only see that as and this comes back [36:11] to our original question [36:13] um are they doing it knowingly and [36:14] maliciously or are they caught up in [36:18] their narrative? And here's what happens [36:20] when you have a narrative and we're all [36:21] subject to this problem like and I right [36:23] we have to correct for this problem. [36:25] Once you believe a narrative then things [36:28] that confirm the narrative you're just [36:29] far more likely to believe and you're [36:31] going to be more likely to dismiss [36:32] things that don't confirm that [36:33] narrative. Right? we have that those [36:35] kinds of biases, confirmation bias [36:37] amongst amongst others. Um so you know [36:40] once you're in the narrative you can [36:42] easily you know history is complicated. [36:44] I like to say um you know in the 120 [36:47] years of the modern [36:50] I call it the Israeli Palestinian Jewish [36:51] Arab Muslim Iran conflict and even [36:53] that's not complicated enough to capture [36:55] the complexities of it. Right? A billion [36:58] times a billion times a billion separate [37:00] incidents have occurred. Some favor your [37:03] narrative, some don't favor your [37:04] narrative. Some are neutral, right? You [37:05] can always find a whole bunch. If you [37:07] want to say that Zionism is settler [37:09] colonialism, you can find a hundred [37:11] different facts and incidents, etc. [37:13] which support that narrative. But is [37:15] that a fair rendition? Well, no, because [37:17] you also have to look at the hundreds or [37:19] thousands of facts which don't fit that [37:20] narrative. They are masters at selecting [37:24] the facts. how either they do that [37:26] knowingly and maliciously leaving out [37:28] the facts that don't fit the narrative [37:29] or like many human beings inclined [37:33] towards a narrative those are the facts [37:34] that stick out to you those are the [37:36] facts that you think matter the most the [37:38] ones that support the narrative so um I [37:40] do think this is a fair summary of the [37:43] false narrative as it's held certainly [37:45] by many of the students the softcore [37:47] people even the hardcore people and even [37:51] the scholars I think I'm also thinking [37:53] of Pepe case work, right? Like this is [37:55] the this is their narrative and I feel [37:58] having attempted to refute it for myself [38:02] that I have a sense of how they [38:03] construct that narrative by violating a [38:05] whole bunch of academic norms. [38:07] >> So, [38:08] >> and the result is that there's an sorry [38:11] Shai that there's a another inversion [38:12] which is you said at the very beginning, [38:14] one of the first things you said is [38:15] we're now Israel and the Jews are now on [38:17] trial having to defend [38:19] >> our right to defend ourselves. We're [38:21] having to defend ourselves for defending [38:23] ourselves, right? And that's another [38:24] >> the other side isn't having to defend [38:26] themselves for attacking us. We're [38:28] having [38:29] >> um just so I want to apologize for [38:31] people. We're having an issue with the [38:32] breakout room. So we will stay in this [38:34] room. But I do want to ask you please uh [38:37] or encourage you to ask questions in the [38:39] Q&A. And I do want to ask question. I [38:42] was I had a version of this um but I [38:45] think Jod Newman is saying it better [38:47] than I will. Um given that the same [38:51] geophobic conspiracy theories, [38:53] scapegoating, everything that you've [38:54] mentioned, the Islamist, the Soviets, [38:56] the the Nazi, the progressive, all of [38:59] that are have been with us for [39:00] millennia. [39:03] Uh why do you think that in you know [39:07] that we can debunk conspiracies with the [39:09] truth, right? like your [39:13] >> and I have noticed and I have noticed [39:15] your your essay is called setting the [39:17] record straight. Now, typically you set [39:19] the record straight just so it stays [39:22] there for posterity, not necessarily to [39:25] change things. I want to believe that [39:28] we're doing more than just marking [39:31] history books so they will know that not [39:33] everyone was crazy and we're actually [39:35] trying to fight and change things. So do [39:38] you believe that refuting the lies will [39:40] be able to change something? [39:44] >> Um that it's a great initial question [39:46] and then your development of it was is [39:48] also a great question. Um I am uh you [39:52] know I am not an optimistic person by [39:54] nature. My wife likes to say that my [39:56] glass is two-thirds empty and leaking [39:58] and I like to say if only my glass were [40:00] only half empty. That's so that's that's [40:03] where I come from. I I [40:05] uh am not optimistic we're going to win [40:07] this battle, whatever that means. Um uh [40:10] so setting the record straight, I I do [40:12] feel almost like we're creating a time [40:14] capsule so future historians will look [40:16] back on this time. [40:19] Today, many decent people at least look [40:21] back on the Nazi period and they say, [40:23] you know, the German people were caught [40:25] up in this collective delusion, this [40:27] this almost psychotic mass psychosis [40:30] that lasted a number of years for the [40:32] Nazi regime and eventually it was [40:34] defeated and had to be denazified and [40:36] that bubble burst and they came back to [40:38] their senses. Right? That's how we look [40:40] at the Nazi period. And I can only hope [40:44] that future historians will look back at [40:46] the period that we're in right now and [40:47] see something similar. Adam Louie Klein [40:49] likes to say something like this. People [40:50] are going to look back at this period [40:52] and one day look at anti-Zionism as the [40:54] shameful thing that it is. Right. And I [40:57] I think that's right. How will we get [40:59] from here to there? That's where the [41:01] pessimism comes in. I don't know. I I [41:04] don't know. I am the sort um I believe [41:07] uh for example it is time for Jews to [41:09] start arming themselves in America. I [41:11] really believe that. um doesn't mean the [41:13] pugrums are going to happen tomorrow, [41:15] but I can see the path that takes us to [41:17] the puggrams that's coming around around [41:19] the bend. And again, maybe that's my [41:20] pessimism. So, uh what I know is I have [41:23] I have a quote on my wall that keeps me [41:26] going, um when I'm feeling despair, [41:28] which is most of the time, and it says, [41:31] "I speak out not because I expect or [41:34] hope to change others, but because if I [41:36] don't speak, I'll have changed myself." [41:38] Something like that, right? which is I [41:41] I'm speaking to set the record straight. [41:43] I'm speaking to assert my moral and [41:47] intellectual clarity. What looks to me [41:48] at least like moral and intellectual [41:50] clarity. I can't control other people's [41:54] responses to it. Um, you know, so will [41:58] we change [42:01] people's minds? I I don't know. I think [42:02] we're in the middle of a mass psycho [42:04] psychotic episode. And when that's [42:07] happening, arguments and this pamphlet [42:09] are not relevant or useful. What is [42:12] relevant and useful is packing a weapon [42:14] because you need to defend yourself in [42:15] the end. Like, you know, you're not [42:16] going to when the Nazis is coming for [42:17] you, you don't hold up your record and [42:19] say, "Here's why your your narrative is [42:21] false, right? That's that's not what you [42:22] say to the Nazi whose goal is to kill [42:24] you, you defend yourself." And I think [42:26] that's where we are. However, just to go [42:28] back to was it Jod's um point or [42:30] question, um you know, there is no hope. [42:34] And this is more than just a pessimist [42:35] to me. There's no hope of eradicating [42:38] this um really mass conspiracy theory [42:43] against the Jews because as you pointed [42:44] out, it's been going on a long time, [42:46] etc. My goal was way more modest. I just [42:50] want there to be a little less Jew [42:52] hatred than there currently is. Like if [42:54] I, you know, as Shai point, if I could [42:56] change one mind, just just peel off one [42:58] person, two people, that's a that's a [43:00] victory. Um, and even that looks hard [43:02] right now because again when the, you [43:04] know, we were talking right before this [43:06] started, it feels like there's an [43:08] absolute tsunami coming our way and [43:10] we're just trying to like plug a hole or [43:11] two in the in the dyke, you know, to [43:14] back it. Um, better to plug one hole [43:16] even if a million need plugging than [43:18] zero, I suppose. But if the tsunami is [43:21] coming your way, you know, get a boat [43:23] that like there's a different strategy. [43:25] So there's no hope of removing it. It's [43:27] the it is the oldest hatred and it is [43:30] fascinating psychologically how it [43:32] really grips people and it is a [43:33] conspiracy theory ultimately. Um but [43:36] yeah so it's important to speak you know [43:39] as long as I'm still a professor at a [43:40] college I'm the only Zionist on my [43:42] campus and I get abused mercilessly by [43:44] students in particular, [43:47] you know, God put me there to be the one [43:49] who's the genocide denier. That's what [43:52] you know that's what they call me. I'm [43:53] the ethnic cleansing baby killing [43:54] genocide denier. And you know what? God [43:56] put me on that campus. So, there's one [43:57] person who's going to deny that that's a [43:59] genocide. And as Rachel was stressing [44:01] earlier, right, like point out the only [44:03] genocide that happened is the one on [44:04] October 7th. It's not been a genocide [44:07] since. Um, and if I don't do that, then [44:10] who am I? Um, but am I optimistic I'm [44:13] changing anyone's opinion? [44:15] >> I want to I want to ask another [44:16] question, and this is um a rendition of [44:19] question by Karen Klene. She's asking [44:21] about the basically the impact of the [44:24] false narrative and all these lies on [44:27] Jews. She talks about Jewish [44:28] institutional leadership. I, you know, [44:30] but in general, we we see Jews caught up [44:33] in this false narrative. And correct me [44:35] if I'm wrong, but it doesn't seem like [44:38] there are many Jews who read the [44:40] protocols of the elders of Z and believe [44:43] it. There weren't many Jews that saw [44:45] Hitler's depictions of Jews and believe [44:48] them. There aren't any Jews to my mind [44:50] that see Islamism and say, "Oh, their [44:52] perception of the Jew is the right." [44:56] >> And yet, [44:58] what m what is it about these 12 lies, [45:01] this false narrative that captures the [45:04] Jewish mind? Again, the vast majority of [45:06] Jews don't fall for it. And but we can't [45:10] we can't turn a blind eye to those that [45:11] do. What is it? That is [45:14] >> I just want to t tack on to Shai's [45:16] question to give you more to stew on is [45:17] I also saw that there's a lot of [45:19] questions of people here saying what can [45:21] we do differently when you opened your [45:23] when you had your opening remarks you [45:25] said if I had not been inoculated from [45:27] the beginning not to believe these false [45:29] narratives I would have been in the [45:30] encampments [45:31] >> right [45:32] >> what do you think contributed to you [45:34] being inoculated and me and shy from the [45:36] beginning to know what we were seeing [45:39] wasn't real what do you think [45:40] contributed to that inoculation how can [45:42] we spread it throughout [45:44] and continue. [45:45] >> Yeah, you you know you're not paying me [45:47] enough to deal with these incredible [45:48] questions. [45:49] >> We're not paying you anything. So, [45:51] >> exactly. Exactly. No, these are [45:53] fantastic and deep and rich questions. [45:55] So, I mentioned I'm writing a book on [45:57] the on the history of anti-ionism now. [45:59] And I had to make the decision as this [46:01] book got longer and longer and longer [46:02] because the deeper you go, the deeper it [46:04] goes. Um I I am not even having a [46:07] chapter on contemporary Jewish [46:09] anti-Zionism in this book even though I [46:11] want it to be pretty exhaustive because [46:13] that subject itself needs at least a [46:15] whole book. It it's actually enormous [46:17] and complex and rich. So I I can't [46:19] possibly do my initial thoughts on it [46:21] even initial thoughts on it any justice. [46:23] But um uh you know let me say a couple [46:26] of couple of things. Um, you know, even [46:29] most of the people today on campuses, [46:31] most of the students in question are [46:33] progressives. You know, far-left [46:35] progressives. And if they've even heard [46:38] of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, [46:40] they probably haven't, and they [46:41] certainly haven't read it. Almost no [46:42] one's read it, including people who [46:43] believe in it. Um, but they probably [46:46] haven't heard of it. They certainly [46:47] haven't read it. Um, but that of course [46:49] doesn't mean that the tropes and liels [46:51] that come out of this book, which by the [46:54] way set off modern anti-semitism and [46:57] also modern anti-sionism, they're both [46:59] grounded in the protocols with the basic [47:01] premise that the Jews are fundamentally [47:03] aggressors. The Jews have a plan to [47:05] conquer the world. So, anything the Jews [47:07] do is advancing that plan. And by [47:09] definition, Jews are aggressors, which [47:12] is amongst the reasons why we cannot be [47:15] seen as victims ever. even October 7th, [47:19] if you have it built into your head this [47:20] idea that Jews by their very existence [47:22] or nature are aggressors, then Jews must [47:25] be the aggressor and therefore you know [47:27] Hamas is just defending Palestine from [47:30] Jewish aggression. And by the way, side [47:32] of point like you know that phenomenon [47:34] of tearing down hostage posters which is [47:36] just disgusting, repulsive and horrible [47:38] and fascinating, right? Like why do you [47:40] need to tear down those hostage posters? [47:42] One of my little theories about that, [47:44] it's complex, but one of the theories is [47:46] it doesn't compute in the mind of these [47:48] people because Jews can't be victims and [47:50] a hostage, you know, there were pictures [47:51] of like three three-year-old girls who [47:53] initially like taken hostage. How do you [47:55] tear that hostage poster down? Answer, [47:58] because since Jews are always aggressors [48:00] and can't be victims, that person can't [48:02] be a victim. Therefore, either it's not [48:04] true what I'm seeing or it's some part [48:07] of, you know, hazar propaganda that [48:09] advances the genocide. Right? So in any [48:11] case, people who've never read heard of [48:14] or read the protocols still absorb its [48:18] tropes and liels. They're sort of in the [48:20] atmosphere. And that's true of Jews, [48:22] too. And here's where I think it it gets [48:24] really interesting. Um I mean, all of [48:27] it's really interesting. It's [48:28] interesting from the beginning, but um [48:30] you know, Jews are the fundamental trope [48:34] of the Protocols, by the way, is Jewish [48:36] supremacy. Jews have this supremacist [48:38] plot because they think they're chosen. [48:40] and they're better than everyone else. [48:41] So, they can control the world and [48:42] enslave or genocide. The genocide liable [48:44] goes back to the protocols. The Jews are [48:46] think they're entitled to genocide the [48:48] because of their uh choseness and [48:50] their their supremacy. Um, and the [48:53] fascinating thing about that liel is you [48:56] you couldn't find a less supremacist [48:58] people, I would argue, than the Jewish [49:00] people who are the I I I don't know [49:02] every other people's traditions, but we [49:04] are so unbelievably self-critical. Our [49:06] Torah, our religious text is filled with [49:09] all of our failings and sins and flaws [49:11] and, you know, everything horrible about [49:13] us to the point where anti-semites have [49:16] traditionally gone to the Bible and say, [49:18] "Look how evil the Jews are." The Bi, [49:19] it's in the Bible, right? Because we're [49:20] we there's a lot of bad behavior in that [49:22] Bible, right? We are. But of course, [49:24] what we know is that Jews, we're [49:27] self-critical because we aspire to be [49:30] better. We aspire maybe not to be [49:32] perfect, but to be slightly better than [49:34] we are. And the way you do that is by [49:36] having open-minded self-critique in [49:39] order to improve yourself. So our [49:41] religious texts is all about [49:42] self-criticism and documenting our [49:44] flaws. But believing in supremacy [49:48] um you know I I think is actually the [49:50] foundational liel that draws all this [49:52] anti-ionism. So um to come back to the [49:55] the Jews, we have this tradition of [49:57] self-critique which of course is a great [50:00] tradition. It's part of what makes us [50:01] great. We dissent, right? The Talmud ask [50:04] two Jews, you get three opinions and the [50:06] Talmud ask two Jews, you get 30 [50:07] opinions. And we we respect the [50:09] dissenting opinion because we realize [50:11] even errors can be valuable in our quest [50:14] for truth and moral improvement. So we [50:17] have this wonderful tradition, Jewish [50:19] self-critique. Now we are surrounded by [50:23] I'm going to say the whole world [50:24] practically. We have some allies, but [50:26] but it's practically the whole world [50:28] that is flinging horrific liels against [50:32] the Jewish people. And here's I think [50:34] the mistake that we're making, and this [50:35] is why I I am now doing the Institute [50:38] for the Critical Study of Anti-Zionism [50:39] to try to take a different strategy. We [50:42] have to stop in to our enemies answering [50:46] the liels even though I wrote this whole [50:47] thing, right? Um because what that does [50:50] is it is accepting the legitimacy of [50:53] your being on trial in the first place. [50:55] It is accepting the idea that you have [50:58] something that you need to answer for [51:00] and not recognizing that these liels are [51:03] not in good faith. These are liable that [51:05] are aimed to weaken and delegitimize and [51:08] ultimately facilitate your genocide. [51:10] Right? With the Nazis, you don't allow [51:13] the Nazi to cross-examine you on the [51:15] stand. You say, "No, you're a Nazi. [51:16] you're trying to kill me. Right? We But [51:19] we have this tradition of [51:21] self-criticism. And so we hear all these [51:23] liels. And how could Jews not? First of [51:26] all, we have to take them seriously for [51:29] at least until we realize how bad faith [51:31] they are, right? We take them seriously. [51:33] We investigate them. We have to answer [51:35] them. They start to sink in. And by the [51:37] way, what is Israel perfect? Of course, [51:39] Israel is not perfect. And so you could [51:41] easily spend a lot of time criticizing [51:42] Israel. And many Jews feel the pressure [51:44] to do that, hoping that, you know, the [51:46] Nazis around us won't come for us if we [51:49] agree that we're critical of Israel or [51:51] something like that. That is, of course, [51:54] missing the whole point of what the [51:56] anti-ionist is doing, which is they are [51:58] trying to get in your head. They are [51:59] trying to get you to become [52:01] self-critical. They're trying to get you [52:02] to surrender is what they're trying to [52:04] do. So I think this incredible virtue of [52:08] ours, self-reflection, self-critique, [52:11] willing to acknowledge our errors and [52:13] criticize each other, right, is [52:15] weaponized by our enemies with this [52:18] endless liables. And of course, many [52:20] Jews are going to be susceptible to it. [52:22] How could you not be? You're surrounded [52:24] by people who believe horrible things [52:25] about you. After a while, you start to [52:27] say, "Well, maybe, you know, maybe some [52:29] of that's true, right? Maybe some of [52:31] that's true. Um, why are we inoculated? [52:34] I don't know. I, you know, I don't know. [52:36] Um, I I would like to think that [52:40] those raised with a pretty strong Jewish [52:42] education and Jewish identity have some [52:44] inoculation. I think that's probably [52:46] true statistically, but there's [52:47] certainly plenty of cases of the kids [52:49] who had that and turned to the other [52:50] side. So, it's not like it's foolproof. [52:53] Um I think we um [52:58] yeah I think [sighs] [53:00] part of this is this is not just a [53:02] Jewish issue where I know running low on [53:04] time here but um you know I actually [53:06] think the west is under assault. just [53:08] this is part of a larger more complex [53:10] thing and um it those folks who really [53:13] are committed to objectivity and liberal [53:17] norms I think um have a kind of [53:20] inoculation to this because what you see [53:23] in these movements [53:25] uh is it's a hate movement that seeks [53:27] the annihilation of the Jews and if you [53:29] believe in objective truth and liberal [53:31] norms that doesn't work and therefore if [53:34] that doesn't work you have you start [53:35] pushing back against the things that are [53:37] are moving that movement. Um so you know [53:40] that that's a a deeper harder question [53:42] and and certainly for the psychologists [53:44] why are some people immune to it. Um but [53:47] thank God for those few because you know [53:49] when I hang out at an event like this um [53:53] I don't appreciate just how tense I am [53:56] in public all the time now because I'm [53:58] surrounded by hatred in every direction [54:00] and it is [54:01] >> to be to be fair I think many many are [54:03] inoculated. Um we have 65 people that [54:08] joined us today and stayed for the [54:10] entire hour. Um and they're just [54:12] reflective of the many many many more [54:14] that are out there. Um we are [54:17] >> we have to find each other. Yeah, we [54:18] have to find each other and connect. [54:20] >> And that's exactly what I was going to [54:22] end with which is um while we are [54:27] made many times even depressed about the [54:29] fact that the truth doesn't matter [54:30] anymore, we have to remind myself that [54:32] the truth always matters. It doesn't we [54:35] should it doesn't matter if it people [54:37] don't think it matters. The truth [54:38] matters objectively you know and it's [54:41] our goal to fight for the truth and [54:43] that's exactly what we're doing at this [54:44] gap. We are about being self-critical [54:48] about examining with scholarship and and [54:52] um and putting everything in the [54:54] foundation is facts and logic and [54:56] evidence but also not being so [54:59] self-critical that we don't do anything [55:01] about it. Right? So we are the institute [55:04] for the study of global anti-semitism [55:05] and policy. And the end of the day our [55:08] goal is to take this kind of scholarship [55:11] and change the world. So um I'm going to [55:15] thank you first of all Andrew for [55:17] joining us. Thank you Rachel um for [55:21] being my uh co- [55:23] >> something uh in this is gap read Shira [55:26] thank you for helping us and everyone [55:29] who showed up. And I want to leave you [55:30] with just one thing. um to consider. So, [55:36] now that you've heard Dr. Pessin talk [55:38] about this, now that you've read his [55:40] reputations of all the different lies, I [55:43] want you to ask yourself and make a [55:46] concrete plan of how are you going to [55:49] take any of this information that you've [55:52] heard and make the world just a tiny bit [55:55] better tomorrow? Right? And if that's [55:58] only making one person just slightly [56:01] less Jew hateful, is it taking Jews and [56:04] inoculating them? Find your way of [56:07] taking this [56:07] >> writing one letter to one place that [56:10] needs to hear from you, right? [56:11] >> Uh and of course Andrew mentioned it a [56:14] couple of times already. Subscribe to [56:16] the Substack of uh the insta [56:21] >> ICSA.substack.com. [56:24] Please check us out. stopstack.com. Um, [56:27] there was a question about psychological [56:29] ways to fight this. So, um, I'm sorry I [56:32] I who I miss who wrote that question. [56:35] Uh, Rose Shorenstein, I'm actually [56:39] working on a book right now. I'm a [56:40] social psychologist by training on how [56:42] to fight this on the psychological [56:45] fantastic way. Uh, you can subscribe to [56:47] my new Substack, How to Fight an [56:49] ideological war. And I hope that we'll [56:53] have many many more ISCAP reads like [56:54] this one. Starting next month, we'll [56:56] have another one. Uh soon you'll receive [56:59] an email with what paper we'll be [57:01] discussing. Thank you everyone and keep [57:05] fighting.