Transcript [00:05] And I want to start with the the primary [00:07] justification for the war in Iran, which [00:09] was a nuclear Iran, the threat of a [00:12] nuclear one Iran. And I want to ask you [00:14] first, [00:16] should we be worried about this? Because [00:17] there does seem to be a bit of debate [00:19] about is this even a real threat that [00:21] Iran poses in terms of its nuclear [00:23] program. [00:24] >> Sure. Well, it's good to be here with [00:25] all of you. Um, I'm already energized [00:28] and encouraged. um just in the short [00:30] time I've been here. So, it's a real [00:31] privilege to be here. So, I guess I I [00:33] would back up and I think that part part [00:35] of what's going on is um a lot of people [00:37] are under the impression that uh [00:39] President Trump decided to go to war [00:42] against the Iranians sort of out of the [00:44] blue. And that that's a big part I think [00:46] of the mi of the misunderstanding about [00:48] how we got here and what we're doing. [00:51] Um, you can go you could zoom out and go [00:53] really far back or go far go back 47 [00:56] years um to the establishment of the [00:58] Islamic um uh revolution and of what the [01:03] current regime is. And it really is a [01:05] revolutionary Islamist regime. But I I [01:08] actually think for our purposes, what's [01:10] really helpful to just correct in our [01:12] thinking or maybe underscore in our [01:14] thinking is the current war that we're [01:16] in is really the result of or the most [01:20] proximate cause is October 7th. Okay. So [01:24] um when Hamas [01:27] um launched its genocidal attack against [01:29] Israel, [01:32] that was really when Israel, I mean [01:35] remember Hamas is one of Iran's proxy [01:38] forces. So Hamas is trained by the [01:42] nation of Iran. It is armed by the [01:44] Iranians. Um there some people dispute [01:48] how much the Iran regime actually had to [01:51] do with directing the Hamas attacks, but [01:53] if you look at the tactics of Hamas on [01:55] October 7th, um many um analysts, [01:59] including myself, believe that you'd [02:01] really have to be trying to not see an [02:03] Iranian connection to to that um attack. [02:06] And so then what happened was Israel has [02:09] been incredibly restrained for many many [02:11] years um against Hamas in um in in Gaza. [02:15] But it was at that point that they said, [02:17] you know, we we cannot let this ever [02:19] happen again. And so you saw the [02:21] Israelis, you know, counter Hamas in in [02:25] Gaza. That precipitated Iranian strikes [02:29] against Israel. The first time that Iran [02:32] actually launched direct missile strikes [02:34] against Israel. Normally they fight via [02:36] proxy and then you saw the Israelis um [02:39] really go hard against Iran. That's when [02:43] President Trump saw a moment of [02:44] opportunity when the Iranian regime was [02:47] actually this sort of myth that you [02:49] couldn't actually take the Iran regime [02:52] headon was sort of busted. And um and so [02:56] President Trump said this is actually a [02:58] huge moment of opportunity where the [03:01] United States can fly wing-to-wing with [03:03] the Israelis and finally significantly [03:06] degrade if not totally eliminate their [03:08] their nuclear program. Now, why do we [03:10] not want the Iran regime to have a [03:13] nuclear program? Well, when you think [03:15] about what Hamas did on October 7th, and [03:17] then you understand that that the Iran [03:19] regime is simply Hamas but with much [03:22] more power and ability to carry out [03:25] their objectives, you realize how [03:26] intolerable that should be for anybody [03:28] in a Western country. Um and so you know [03:32] countries are motivated by particular [03:34] ideologies and perceptions of national [03:36] self-interest and the Iran regime really [03:38] does have um a view that Israel is a [03:43] great threat um and they want to destroy [03:46] Israel but they want to destroy the [03:47] United States and they see Israel and [03:50] the United States as essentially one and [03:51] the same. So do we want you know should [03:54] we permit um the Iran regime to have a [03:57] nuclear capability? I think of course [03:59] not. Um, and so I think that that that [04:02] was that was the um that's what [04:03] precipitated the the decision on the [04:06] part of President Trump to say we [04:08] actually have a moment of opportunity to [04:09] destroy or degrade the nuclear program [04:11] at really low cost to the American [04:12] people after the Israelis went in there [04:14] and took out their air defenses. So, um, [04:16] I thought it was a courageous decision [04:18] and I think the reason that we're stuck [04:20] now, unfortunately, is because of the [04:23] midterm elections and a concern that [04:25] there could be an uptick in strikes [04:27] against Gulf States if the United States [04:29] resumed military operations. But, um, I [04:32] think we'll probably resume military [04:33] operations after the elections. [04:37] I I do want to note just for for [04:38] timeline purposes because I don't know [04:40] how many in the audience tracked this [04:42] very closely, but to Rebecca's point, [04:45] there were actually multiple rounds of [04:47] fighting between Israel and Iran before [04:49] the US got involved. And you you start, [04:51] I believe it's April 2024, and there's [04:53] another one in the fall of 2024, then [04:56] again in June in 2025. And it was only [04:58] at the end of that third round that [05:01] President Trump made the decision to [05:02] send the, you know, the B2, I believe [05:04] it's the B2 stealth bombers, correct? [05:06] >> Yeah, the the B2 bombers. So, just for [05:07] you, um, the United States, when you [05:11] think about the United States's [05:12] competition with the Chinese, and you [05:13] hear a lot about the US competing with [05:15] China in AI and tech in one of the [05:17] technologies in which the United States [05:19] of America still has a dominant lead, [05:21] it's stealth. And our B2 bombers are [05:23] pretty old and they're going to be [05:25] replaced by the B-21 bombers which are [05:27] even stealthier and even better. And so [05:29] for us to be able to and the Israelis [05:31] are amazing in terms of their military [05:32] capabilities and their ability to do um [05:35] significant damage against a power like [05:37] Iran, but they don't have the bomber [05:40] fleet that we have. And so it really [05:42] required the United States's bomber [05:44] fleet to be able to do what was [05:45] necessary. And so, so that was like the [05:47] famous B2 flights that flew from the [05:50] United States to to um Iran overnight um [05:54] and refueled in the air and flew for [05:56] something like 32 hours. But huge [05:58] display, I think, of American military [06:00] competency and power. It was pretty [06:02] impressive. [06:03] >> Yeah, it really it really was. I I want [06:06] to back up for a moment though just [06:07] because something I'm seeing online and [06:10] I don't know how many other people are [06:11] are hearing this or saying this but [06:13] there's this argument floating out there [06:15] and really this is from the the more [06:17] let's call it restrained wing maybe is [06:19] isolationist wing of American foreign [06:21] policy arguing that in the cold war you [06:24] know people got nuclear weapons and we [06:26] didn't think it was good necessarily but [06:28] it also didn't create you know an end of [06:31] history style conflict. The apocalypse [06:33] never happened because there was the [06:35] doctrine known as mutually assured [06:36] destruction. It created the sense in [06:38] which rational actors could coexist with [06:40] nuclear weapons. And I want to maybe put [06:43] you on the spot and just ask you very [06:44] very pointedly, [06:47] does that apply in this context or is it [06:50] your assessment that that doctrine no [06:52] longer works in a world in which a [06:54] regime like Iran might also acquire [06:56] nuclear weapons? [06:56] >> It's it's a great great question. So the [06:59] answer is we we actually don't know. So [07:01] we actually don't know if you have a [07:03] regime. So So first of all, there's a a [07:05] long nuanced answer is the United States [07:07] doesn't really live under mutually [07:08] assured destruction anymore. Really [07:10] since the cold war, we've developed a [07:11] nuclear strategy and doctrine where we [07:13] do um we have a flexible um nuclear [07:17] posture so that we would um and we have [07:20] missile defenses now. We we so we don't [07:22] we do not intentionally remain incred [07:24] you know vulnerable nor do we um [07:26] threaten to target cities with the [07:28] potentiality that the Russians for [07:29] instance might might target cities. But [07:31] but to your point, we do have an [07:33] understanding of deterrence where we [07:35] understand something about rational [07:37] actors and what may incentivize or [07:39] disincentivize a country to attack or [07:42] not attack, to be restrained or not. And [07:43] does that apply for a country that has [07:45] such a committed ideology to essentially [07:48] suicide? If you h how do you do how can [07:51] you do um how can you credibly deter a [07:54] country that doesn't care about its own [07:58] survival? I mean, this is what I keep [08:00] trying to explain. I do a lot of Fox [08:01] News and, you know, I keep trying to say [08:03] on, you know, it's over and over again. [08:04] It's like, how do we negotiate with the [08:06] IRGC when the IRGC welcomes martyrdom? I [08:10] mean, right now we're we're we're having [08:12] um diplom diplomatic um open openings. [08:16] You know, every once in a while you hear [08:17] the vice president come out and say, [08:18] "Look, the Iran regime has decided to go [08:20] a different path and they want a good [08:21] relationship with the United States." [08:22] I'm like, "Well, if you're talking to [08:23] somebody who's saying that, those people [08:25] have no power in Iran. The people who [08:27] have power in Iran are the IRGC. The [08:30] IRGC welcome martyrdom. The guy who's in [08:32] charge of the IRC trained Solommani who [08:35] the United States under President Bush [08:37] or President Trump took out in the first [08:39] Trump administration. Um and um remember [08:42] I mean Kasum Salammani was was [08:44] essentially trained by um the Sammy [08:46] what's his name? Um not Vahiti. Yeah, [08:50] Bahiti. [08:51] >> Um Vahiti is now the She's shaking her [08:53] head. Yes. On the way back. um she loves [08:54] it when I call on her for factchecking [08:56] and she she does not but um but but he [08:59] but he but he is who is in charge of the [09:00] IRGC right now. You're not going to [09:02] negotiate him with him. He's not going [09:04] to abide by anou. And so um so no so and [09:08] you know so for a for the United States [09:10] to say look we might be able to deter [09:13] Iran if it has a nuclear weapon, but why [09:15] would we even try if we have a moment of [09:18] opportunity to set back their program or [09:20] to get rid of it? I mean, right now [09:21] we're living under the the threat of the [09:23] North Koreans that have nuclear weapons [09:25] when we had a moment of opportunity in [09:26] the '9s to take out their program and [09:28] didn't do it. So, I think the fear, the [09:30] concern, the credible concern among [09:31] Syria's people um um was that why let's [09:35] let's take this off the table so that [09:37] we're not trying to to contain or to [09:39] deter a a country with nuclear weapons [09:41] that has genocidal intentions against [09:43] our allies, but also against Americans. [09:46] >> Sure. for for an audience that maybe is [09:50] not as familiar with the the theory of [09:53] just war. I wonder if maybe you could [09:55] help us connect the dots a little bit. [09:56] You're you're describing the sense in [09:58] which it's intolerable there there's [10:00] therefore some inobligation to prevent [10:02] nuclear weapons being acquired by the [10:04] Iranian regime. How would you frame that [10:07] or connect the dots between that idea [10:10] and just war theory which for a long [10:12] time is how Christians have justified [10:14] the use of force or war. Yeah. So um I [10:19] actually became uh very very interested [10:23] in studying that people ask me like how [10:25] did how in the world did I start this [10:27] professional path where I became you [10:30] know um a specialist in nuclear strategy [10:32] and it's really because um I I I was a [10:36] freshman in college on 911 and uh the [10:39] short version is you know lots of people [10:41] my age at that time is very very [10:43] formative went into national security [10:45] policy but they looked at they were [10:47] doing low-intensity conflict and the [10:48] global war on terrorism. And I kind of [10:50] had this realization that the United [10:54] States is really focused on this and [10:56] we've like taken our eye off the ball on [10:58] what major power war could look like [11:00] with nuclear weapons and nuclear weapons [11:02] are our most powerful kind of weapon and [11:04] we better be thinking about these [11:07] weapons correctly. And during the Cold [11:10] War, what happened was when the United [11:12] States had to do a significant nuclear [11:14] buildup to deter the Soviets, you know, [11:16] the the people who pushed back the most [11:18] on that were very very well-intentioned, [11:21] sincere Christians. The the anti-uclear [11:24] movement really came from very sincere [11:27] Christians. Um and and and so and my [11:32] view is that um they had a Go ahead. [11:36] >> I'm sorry. Just just to clarify, you're [11:38] referring to Americans who were anti the [11:41] nuclearization of the American [11:43] >> military. The build up of our own [11:44] buildup, the own so they the anti-uclear [11:47] sort of movement. Um you would often [11:49] see, you know, Catholic nuns protesting [11:52] outside um some of our nuclear labs, [11:55] etc. or you would see um you know other [11:57] Christians just just trying to urge the [12:00] various American presidents from doing [12:02] this nuclear buildup for fear that the [12:04] United States would become party to [12:06] something that would be morally [12:07] indefensible um this nuclear So what I [12:10] was concerned about is if the United [12:12] States does have to return to doing [12:15] nuclear recapitalization or deterring um [12:18] nuclear power again, I want Christians [12:21] to be armed with thinking about this [12:23] correctly and having have very very [12:26] clear moral clarity about this and our [12:29] nuclear weapons um and the way we think [12:32] about them in strategy and doctrine [12:34] actually does come from the just war and [12:36] remember the just war doctrine was [12:38] developed by serious Augustine serious [12:43] Christians who wanted to be able to [12:45] equip Christian military members of the [12:48] military who were feeling guilty for [12:50] going to war and they said no let's [12:52] think about this rightly how can a [12:53] Christian in good conscience go to war, [12:55] put on the uniform of their country and [12:57] go do this. And so the just war doctrine [13:00] is fundamentally a realist doctrine for [13:04] people who seek to honor Christ in what [13:06] they're doing. And so it has some some [13:09] principles. Discrimination, meaning you [13:12] don't intentionally kill civilians. [13:14] Proportionality, meaning we're we don't [13:16] use our military forces for vengeance. [13:18] we use our military forces with only as [13:21] much force as necessary to carry out our [13:23] political and military aims, etc. And [13:25] that's what our just war doctrine [13:27] essentially has informed the laws of [13:29] armed conflict. And um and so I I think [13:34] that, you know, I think where Christians [13:36] can get tripped up is is is failing to [13:38] differentiate between what we as private [13:40] Christians may do versus what the the [13:42] the government can and should do. And in [13:45] my view, scripture tells us that the [13:47] government does have a duty to protect [13:49] the innocent and avenge the wicked. [13:51] That's what the government does. The [13:53] government bears the sword for justice [13:56] and not for nothing. And um and so you [13:59] as a private Christian should always [14:00] abide by your conscience. And if you [14:02] conclude that you yourself are pacifist, [14:04] that's one thing. But to require the [14:05] government to be pacifistic and [14:07] especially pacifistic with the most [14:08] powerful weapons, I think would be um a [14:11] derelict of the government's moral [14:13] responsibility to protect its people. [14:15] And so my my my doctoral thesis was it's [14:17] called duty to deter and it's about um [14:21] our the American nuclear deterrent [14:23] strategy based on the just war doctrine. [14:28] >> There's a lot there. I wish we could [14:30] unpack that and if there's time maybe [14:31] we'll come back to that in a moment. But [14:33] I do want to ask you some other other [14:35] questions about what this war means in [14:37] terms of American foreign policy [14:39] generally, not just in the context of [14:41] this, you know, nuclear weapons race [14:43] that Iran may or may not be engaged in. [14:46] How how do you think America needs to [14:48] think about this from a big picture [14:50] standpoint? Because something we also [14:51] see a lot right now, especially in more [14:54] of the right-wing of foreign policy, US [14:56] foreign policy, you've got this question [14:57] of, okay, should we be focused on the [15:00] Middle East, or should we focus on [15:03] Europe, or should we be really sort of [15:04] turning our backs on those and really [15:06] focusing our energies more so in the Far [15:09] East, especially as it relates to China? [15:12] And I guess the question I would have [15:15] for you is, what is this war revealing [15:17] in terms of America's standing in the [15:19] world? Do you think this really is [15:21] primarily a conflict in the Middle East, [15:24] relegated to the Middle East, or is this [15:26] part of a broader conflict that's [15:29] playing out between the US and some of [15:31] its other, you know, global power rivals [15:34] like Russia and China? [15:36] >> So, um, so this is what I tell people, [15:38] and this is kind of gets back to your [15:40] restrainer. I do think that the [15:41] restrainers are actually isolationists. [15:43] They call themselves restrainers because [15:44] it seems much more intellectually [15:46] serious. Um, and I think isolationism [15:48] has a lot of negative connotation. That [15:50] does not mean that I think that the [15:53] United States exercising restraint is [15:55] bad or foolish. [15:58] The and the reason I bring this up is [16:00] because people say, well, look, you you [16:01] know, you might you if you're against [16:02] sort of like the restrainer view, does [16:04] that mean you think the United States [16:05] should be interravening everywhere? No. [16:07] But it does mean that I I believe that [16:09] the United States should posture itself [16:11] so that the that the president of the [16:13] United States and his and his adviserss [16:15] have maximum options that we don't [16:18] shrink back from the world so that we [16:20] force ourselves to be restrained. Does [16:22] that make sense? So, so I want the [16:26] United States to have as many options [16:29] possible so that we can we and our [16:31] government can move in the world on [16:33] terms that benefit the security, [16:35] freedom, and prosperity of the American [16:36] people. Why? Because it is our [16:38] government's responsibility to protect [16:40] the American people and the American way [16:42] of life. And that's biblical. I mean, [16:45] for for a government that's seeking to [16:46] be just a just government, that's what [16:48] we should do. So to then to to tie this [16:50] into your second question or your next [16:51] question here is you know the United [16:53] States is is is in a is in a competition [16:56] with China. I mean who is going to be [16:59] the preeminent power? The country that [17:01] has the strongest economy and military [17:03] is the country that will influence [17:05] global events towards what they believe [17:07] is right. So the world essentially has [17:10] two choices. And I know the other [17:11] countries hate it when you put it this [17:12] way but it's just the way it is. It's [17:14] essentially a a vision in which the [17:16] Chinese Communist Party um is the is the [17:20] political force that is determining [17:22] global events and setting our policy on [17:24] AI and technology and trade and medicine [17:27] and etc. We've lived through COVID [17:29] probably don't want the Chinese to be [17:31] the ones in charge of that. um or it's [17:34] the United States of America as [17:36] imperfect as we are and our alliances [17:40] that um that we collaborate with in a [17:43] variety of ways. China is increasingly [17:46] working with the Russians, the Iranians, [17:49] the North Koreans, and these [17:50] naroterrorist states in our hemisphere. [17:54] And in ways that strategists [17:57] were insisting couldn't happen even just [17:59] three to five years ago. And so, you [18:01] know, I tell people like, you know, this [18:02] is I mean, I think that the United [18:04] States is obviously hands down [18:06] completely crushing the Iran regime. [18:08] It's not a stalemate. The United States [18:10] is completely dominated. We've we're [18:12] completely choking out the regime, but [18:14] we still have to, I think, um, come to a [18:17] final military political conclusion. So, [18:18] the United States isn't doing this for a [18:20] while. But the Iranians are only [18:24] surviving to the extent that they are is [18:26] because of China. [18:28] China has reportedly provided overhead [18:30] surveillance and satellite imagery to [18:32] the Iranians that to directly target [18:34] American troops and they they're of [18:37] course the the primary buyer of Iranian [18:40] oil including elicit um trying to evade [18:42] sanctions. So I do think it's something [18:44] like a a proxy war against the Chinese. [18:48] >> Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. There [18:49] were most recent case I think was the [18:52] the missile strike in Jordan, right? [18:55] There were US I don't believe any US [18:56] service members were killed in that case [18:58] but certainly wounded and there's been a [19:00] lot of research about the impact of [19:02] long-term impact of injuries sustained [19:05] in these missile strikes even when a [19:06] service member doesn't die of course the [19:08] concussive effects and whatnot. It's a [19:10] it's a really serious issue and China [19:12] certainly has some [19:14] maybe it's a little too graphic or [19:16] explicit to say this but it's some blood [19:17] on their hands in terms of the support [19:18] that they provided the Iranian regime [19:20] over the course of you know the last [19:22] several months. [19:22] >> I I I certainly think so. the Russians [19:24] as well. The Russians have sent [19:26] component parts, their military [19:27] capabilities, I think, to the Iranians. [19:29] Um, but the but the Russians also have [19:31] their hands full with the war of [19:32] aggression that that Putin caused in in [19:34] Ukraine. Um, so they can't help to the [19:37] extent that they might like to, but they [19:38] certainly are rooting for the Iranians [19:40] to prevail over the United States. Um [19:42] but the but ch but this is also an [19:44] interesting thing an interesting factor [19:46] is you know the Chinese are insistent [19:48] that the United States does not sell or [19:50] deliver or deliver the weapons that the [19:52] Taiwanese have already purchased from [19:54] the United States and the credible [19:56] reporting coming out of these [19:57] discussions between President Trump and [19:59] Xiinping is essentially our weapons [20:01] might be being we might be restraining [20:03] our delivery of those weapons in the [20:05] hopes that that convinces China not to [20:07] become more involved on the side of Iran [20:09] in this conflict. [20:12] Yeah, obviously a very tangled web in [20:14] that case. Hard to sort of separate [20:15] these conflicts from each other. I I [20:18] want to ask you maybe now if we if we [20:21] pivot back to Israel for a moment to [20:23] really zero in on where the debate seems [20:26] to be focused in the last couple of [20:28] months. There's this question of okay, [20:30] not just do we pivot from the Middle [20:32] East to Asia or try to put them in their [20:34] own separate silos and think of them [20:36] separately. There's a much more specific [20:38] question that's being debated right now. [20:40] Should the US, [20:42] not just Israel, Ukraine as well, but [20:44] especially Israel, should it basically [20:47] take away some of its support for Israel [20:49] and then reposition it in Asia? And I [20:53] want to ask you how how do you think [20:55] about the balance? I mean, obviously we [20:57] have finite resources and that's the [20:58] argument made by a lot of the we can [21:00] call them the restrainers or the [21:02] isolationists, whichever term you [21:04] prefer. One of the arguments they make [21:06] is we have only so much money, only so [21:08] many weapons, only so much capacity for [21:10] production. We have to balance this [21:11] somehow. So, how do you think about [21:13] finding that that balance? [21:15] >> Sure. I really I think it's um so [21:17] interesting that the people who make the [21:19] argument that the United States has only [21:21] finite resources and so we can't support [21:22] Israel and we can't support Ukraine. And [21:24] those are the same people who have [21:25] argued against defense increases, won't [21:27] support supplementals, won't support um [21:30] you know things that that this our [21:32] government's trying to do right now in [21:34] order to um like replenish our stocks [21:37] that we've expended. So it's a little [21:39] bit of a you know, if you look at the [21:41] people who have for years been arguing [21:43] that the United States has to rebuild [21:45] our defense industrial base. I mean, [21:46] since the Cold War, the United States [21:49] has allowed our defense industrial base [21:51] to atrophy. So, for those of you who [21:52] have not ever heard somebody say, "What [21:54] is the defense industrial base?" That's [21:55] the workforce we need, the the the um [21:59] the components that we need in order to [22:01] manufacture the weapons at the rate [22:04] necessary and in the numbers necessary [22:06] to fight a war to defend the United [22:08] States. That's our defense industrial [22:10] base. So, it's not just stockpiles. [22:12] Stockpiles just sit there. You build [22:13] weapons, they sit there. That's one [22:15] component of American military [22:16] readiness, but it's only one. [22:19] But you want you want to be able to in [22:21] order to credibly deter they're not a [22:23] museum piece and they're not a bluff. So [22:26] sometimes we have to use them and when [22:27] you use them you can rebuild your [22:30] defense industrial base and reiterate [22:32] and actually have greater capabilities. [22:34] So our support for Ukraine has actually [22:36] yes it's depleted some kinds of [22:39] munitions. We also make way more 155mm [22:42] rounds now than we did before we started [22:44] supporting Ukraine. Um, we've adapted [22:47] all kinds of weapon systems now that are [22:48] way better to take on the Russians [22:50] should we ever have to get there because [22:51] of our support for Ukraine. So, it's a [22:53] little bit it's a little bit harder and [22:54] messier. Um, we also the kinds of [22:57] munitions that we've depleted against [22:59] the Iranians are this is a little bit in [23:02] the weeds, but for those who are wonky [23:03] and interested in this stuff, we've only [23:05] depleted certain kinds of weapons that [23:07] we needed in the beginning of the war. [23:09] They're called these exquisite longer [23:11] range strike weapons like tomahawk. We [23:14] don't need those anymore because we've [23:15] completely stripped along with the [23:17] Israelis the the Iranians um air [23:19] defenses and so now we have gravity [23:20] bombs and we have plentiful of those. So [23:22] if we do have to go back into military [23:24] operations, we have plenty of the [23:25] weapons that we do need. But to your [23:27] question, do we have but we still have [23:28] limited resources? Yes, definitely. [23:31] Which is why we need allies. So for all [23:33] of these people who then are restrainers [23:34] and say the United States has to draw [23:36] back, well they should they would really [23:37] really help us out if they would stop [23:39] antagonizing the people we need to to [23:41] help us. Who are our greatest allies? [23:44] One is Israel. It's one of our greatest [23:47] allies. [23:49] The Ukrainians have actually turned [23:51] themselves into incredible allies of of [23:53] the West and of the United States. Um, [23:56] and then you can look and you can see [23:58] there's actually European allies that we [24:00] need to repair our relationships because [24:02] all of our um our military strikes that [24:05] we conducted, not all of them, but many [24:07] of them once we started doing midnight [24:09] um or Epic Fury, Operation Epic Fury, [24:12] they all came out of Europe. All our [24:14] tanker bridge that refueled our planes [24:15] all were b out of European basing. So we [24:18] were running through eight different [24:19] European countries airspaces. We need [24:21] allies. We need allies to invest in [24:23] their defense industrial bases. Um, we [24:25] need to do that. But how do we [24:27] prioritize? I would say we need to be co [24:29] getting a coalitions together to [24:31] [snorts] be able to deter in their [24:33] particular regions. We don't need [24:34] everybody to do everything. We do not [24:36] need Israel to give their missile [24:38] defenses to Ukraine. There's lots of [24:39] people who are beating up on Israel for [24:40] not giving their missile defenses to [24:41] Ukraine. I'm like, I mean, Israel's job [24:43] is to stay really safe. That's Israel's [24:45] job. Um, and we don't need the [24:48] Ukrainians to do everything, and we [24:49] don't need the Brits to do everything. [24:50] But we do need everybody to do what they [24:52] can do, and the United States can do [24:53] what only it can do. So, I I think the [24:56] answer is the United States can't do it [24:57] all by ourselves, nor should we. We need [24:59] to figure out what our priorities are. [25:01] But all of these areas are connected. [25:04] And if Europe if if strategic deterrence [25:06] fails in Europe and the war in Russia's [25:08] war against Ukraine escalates into a [25:12] another NATO country, the United States [25:14] is going to have a terrible time [25:16] deterring China in the Pacific. And so [25:19] even if you think China, as I do, China [25:21] poses the greatest capability to pose [25:22] the greatest harm to the American people [25:24] and the American way of life, you still [25:25] have to make sure the Middle East and [25:27] Europe are secure. [25:31] How would you describe what's going on [25:34] in our politics then? Because this all [25:36] sounds very rational and makes a lot of [25:39] sense, but at the same time, if I go [25:42] online, uh they're on Twitter or on the [25:44] news or whatever, it seems like [25:48] everyone's just very everyone's speaking [25:50] with more anger than they are rational [25:52] thought right now about our foreign [25:54] policy. And like you said, we're [25:56] approaching midterms and so it's an [25:57] election year, which means things are [25:58] going to be even crazier than normal. [26:01] How would you describe what's going on [26:03] right now in terms of the role that [26:05] foreign policy is playing in our [26:08] national politics? Because in this [26:10] election year, it feels like something [26:13] is happening that's a little new and [26:16] frankly uniquely concerning. [26:18] >> Yeah. So I think what's going on is I [26:20] try to remind people you you have to try [26:23] to understand what um what the American [26:26] people are saying and where their [26:27] frustrations are coming from. A lot of [26:29] the a lot of people who have become [26:31] anti-Israel or anti so let me put it [26:33] this way first. I think that there's [26:35] reasonable reasonable people can [26:37] disagree on what the United to the [26:38] extent the United States should help [26:40] this or this this or that country. So [26:41] that that to me is is sort of nobody has [26:44] a monopoly on wisdom. Okay. But the [26:46] trends that I'm seeing are that because [26:49] people are so frustrated with challenges [26:51] here at home that they believe that the [26:54] United States is wasting our resources [26:57] on foreign crises or foreign problems [26:59] that don't have anything to do with us. [27:01] And we've seen this play before. This is [27:04] what happened in the 1930s. Um and and [27:06] if you don't and if you're frustrated [27:08] here at home and you believe that your [27:11] political leaders are busy doing things [27:13] abroad that you don't understand, things [27:15] feel complex, things feel out of [27:17] control, it doesn't feel like you're the [27:19] one determining global events or things [27:21] that are happening to you. What do you [27:22] do? What's the human instinct? Blame [27:24] somebody else. You scapegoat problems. [27:27] You take complex problems you don't [27:29] understand and you look for a simple [27:30] solution. What is the oldest scapegoat? [27:33] The Jews. [27:35] What does anti-semitism correlate with [27:37] in the history of the United States? [27:39] Isolationism. [27:41] It's the Jews that are pulling the [27:42] United States into wars. They're the [27:44] ones that are deceiving our leaders. [27:45] They're the ones that are doing all [27:47] these things I don't understand. They're [27:48] the ones that are creating problems. [27:49] They're the reason I can't afford this [27:51] or that. They're the reason I can't get [27:52] a job. And so, it's it's human sort of [27:55] sinful instinct, I think, to look for [27:57] something else to blame other than [27:59] yourself or the failure of our leaders [28:01] in this or that way. But it's complex. [28:04] But you look for a simple answer. And so [28:06] I I we were just chatting over dinner. I [28:08] said I was worried about this pull for [28:10] anti, you know, for this for [28:11] isolationism, but I wasn't going to be [28:13] really really alarmed about it until I [28:15] saw an uptick in anti-Israel [28:18] um sentiment and anti-semitism. And [28:21] that's when the huge flare up, I think, [28:22] happened about two years ago. And sure [28:25] enough, that's whenever you you started [28:27] to see um a pretty strong desire for [28:29] people to say, "Forget it. Pull up the [28:31] drawbridge. Let's come home." Of course, [28:33] in an era of drone um warfare and [28:38] hypersonic missiles and anti-satellite [28:40] missiles, there's no drawbridge to pull [28:42] up. [28:43] And so, it's incredibly dangerous at [28:45] this point to think that the United [28:47] States can sort of like turn inward and [28:49] have nothing to do with foreign affairs [28:50] because our adversaries can reach out [28:52] and um and touch targets on the American [28:56] homeland actually quite easily. [28:58] Can you elaborate on what is it about [29:02] anti-Israel sentiment or anti-semitism [29:05] that is such a red flag? I mean, why is [29:08] that the moment where you realize some [29:10] something's not just wrong, but really [29:12] wrong? [29:14] >> How much time do we have? Um, okay, [29:16] good. So, [29:17] >> you're good. [clears throat] [29:20] Um so a lot of it is um [29:24] from my perspective the United States [29:26] Americans you look at Americans so every [29:28] country has its own strategic culture [29:30] and when I say strategic culture I mean [29:32] it's its willingness to the reasons why [29:34] it will it's willing to go to war sort [29:37] of it's it's a very very diverse and [29:39] intellectually diverse country and yet [29:41] there's still some things about [29:42] Americans that are just common about us [29:44] and where there's a you know there's [29:47] just so many of us who think this [29:48] particular ular way that it sort of [29:49] defines a characteristic that that that [29:52] makes America who we are and um our [29:56] Judeo-Christian roots and if this is [29:59] kind of manifested in various ways since [30:01] our since the American founding but [30:04] certainly post World War II um the [30:07] United States's kind of strategic [30:09] culture has been very defensive of Jews [30:13] Jews here at home. I mean, I have a [30:15] Jewish friend who told me, Rebecca, he [30:17] said, "There's only two places in the [30:19] world where Jews can feel safe." That's [30:22] Israel and the United States of America. [30:26] Um, and so I believe that it is um it's [30:30] it's part of our strategic culture to [30:34] have this um have this I don't want to [30:37] really really call it ideologically, but [30:39] a a strong attachment to um Jews, [30:43] American Jews, um but also the nation of [30:47] Israel and the home of the Jewish [30:48] people. And not only that, but if you [30:52] just sort of look at what Israel does [30:53] for the United States in practical ways, [30:56] um you know, it's our incredible I mean [30:58] inc you do not want to be on the other [30:59] side of the IDF or the MSAD. It's a bad [31:02] idea. um um incredibly hyper competent [31:06] in terms of the ingenuity and the [31:07] capabilities um of of of Israel, [31:11] [snorts] its willingness to understand [31:13] that Islamism and to call it out as [31:17] antithetical to Western values. Um [31:21] Hamas, I mean, I use Hamas because all [31:23] of us know what Hamas did on October [31:25] 7th. It's a culture of death and and [31:29] Israel um the Israeli government is is a [31:32] culture of life defends life which is [31:34] why it makes it so difficult when Hamas [31:36] captures a single Israeli because the [31:39] country will do anything it can to to to [31:41] defend that one. Well, what other [31:42] country does that? Ours. [31:45] Ours. And um and so to to me, you know, [31:50] I say I kind of joke and I say look like [31:52] Americans love to beat up on ourselves. [31:54] We love to beat up on the Europeans. [31:56] That's kind of an American pastime. But [31:58] if you start to see a rise in [32:00] anti-semitism and anti-Israel against [32:03] all American self-interest, Israel [32:06] didn't drag us into the war against [32:08] Iran. Israel was taking care of [32:09] business. The United States of America [32:12] has no econ we're so we're so much [32:14] stronger um than than than our allies [32:18] and and our adversaries. Obviously, [32:21] China is a pretty close competitor, but [32:23] the United States could decide on its [32:25] own terms when to act. And so, and and [32:29] so this it's foolishness to believe that [32:31] that a small state, you know, nation [32:33] state the size of New Jersey is [32:35] dictating what the United States should [32:36] and shouldn't do. So, I became very [32:39] concerned when I started seeing this [32:40] rise in anti-semitism that we were going [32:42] to see a rise in in isolationism, which [32:45] is exact they correlate and that is [32:47] exactly what's happened. We've seen it. [32:49] I totally, you know, if you if you read [32:50] the book Those Angry Days about Charles [32:53] Lindberg and you listen to Tucker [32:55] Carlson, they're the same arguments [32:58] and and so I think that that's for me [33:01] that's what it was. I mean, Israel has [33:02] such a unique tie to the United States [33:05] both in what it provides in terms of [33:07] hard power and technology, um its [33:10] willingness to fight alongside us, our [33:12] shared adversaries, the people who hate [33:14] Israel, hate the United States for for [33:16] reasons that should be clear. We we [33:19] believe in the dignity of the human [33:20] person in Mago Day. So do the Jewish [33:23] people. And um and that's why we built [33:25] an entire system designed where the [33:27] people rule and the people are sovereign [33:29] and the government works for us because [33:30] we get our rights from God, not from [33:32] government. [33:34] And it's the it's the countries that and [33:36] the ideologies that hate that um that [33:38] are our shared enemies with the [33:40] Israelis. And so when I when I started [33:43] to see an uptick in the in the [33:44] anti-semitism and then you know again [33:46] the restrainer wing but just tends to [33:48] always also be pretty defensive of of uh [33:51] the anti-semites. Um that's when I [33:54] became really concerned that we were [33:55] living through something that we've that [33:57] this country has seen before. [34:00] So it sounds like the concern is is [34:02] really twofold. One just an inability to [34:05] recognize what's in our own best [34:06] interest. to a sense of, you know, moral [34:10] moral confusion, for lack of a better [34:12] term, that where there is no moral [34:14] clarity, countries will shrink from the [34:16] fight, so to speak, when they they need [34:18] to be in it. [34:19] >> Yeah. And here's the thing, too. You [34:20] know, there's another sort of belief [34:22] that has taken um taken hold where [34:25] you're either a realist or you're an [34:28] idealist who cares about morality. But [34:30] we started our conversation talking [34:31] about the just war doctrine which was [34:34] really meant to equip Christians in a [34:37] fallen world this side of eternity to be [34:40] able to deal with the real evils that [34:41] actually exists. What is our duty to our [34:44] country and how should we act and so you [34:47] can be both moral and realistic. I would [34:50] argue that the most realistic people [34:53] understand their Bibles. [34:57] So you should so our principles our [34:59] principles should align with our [35:01] interests and vice versa and I believe [35:03] that they are reinforcing and so when we [35:05] do have this moral confusion we can't [35:07] understand who the threats are and who [35:09] our allies are I mean that's a major [35:11] major problem and it creates all kinds [35:14] of um I think challenges in our strategy [35:16] then [35:18] >> I want to ask you just just one last [35:21] question maybe maybe question and a half [35:24] for those in the audience who are either [35:27] curious to learn more about this or who [35:30] are thinking seriously about trying to [35:33] work on some of these issues. [35:36] What advice would you give to them in [35:38] terms of [35:40] where where do you start learning and [35:42] preparing yourself to think seriously [35:45] and to actually work on some of these [35:48] these really important issues? [35:50] >> Well, I guess so these are college [35:52] students, right? Are these [35:54] >> mostly [35:54] >> mostly um so I mean a couple of things I [35:58] mean a lot of this is I mean study study [36:00] lot some of this just be requires [36:01] studying certain areas I mean you want [36:03] to study the American founding I mean [36:05] the founders actually grappled with a [36:07] lot of this stuff like you know you have [36:08] people popping up who think that they've [36:09] just now discovered that Adams was wrong [36:12] and Hamilton was wrong and you know and [36:15] and George Washington I mean what a what [36:18] a loser that guy was you know and um you [36:20] know we actually note now that the [36:22] enlightened was was just a a a trick to [36:25] persecute Christians in 2026 or [36:28] whatever. I mean it's it's just not [36:30] true. So study the founders actually the [36:32] founders actually grappled with the with [36:33] questions about Judaism and Christianity [36:36] and how do we build a country that um [36:40] where human beings can flourish and that [36:42] where we don't have a series of [36:44] sectarian religious wars. That's the the [36:46] people who came here were were fleeing [36:48] from religious persecution. my own [36:50] ancestors were were were French [36:51] hugenauts. Um, and so I would go back [36:55] and just really understand the early [36:56] debates. That is so important. Um, and [36:59] then then really I mean you're doing [37:02] you're already doing it. So I should [37:03] already like pat yourself in the back [37:04] because you're here. You're already [37:05] taking the steps I think to learn this [37:07] and to kind of learn why it's important. [37:09] But um but really try to understand um [37:13] the the why we say Judeo-Christian and [37:15] and the Jewish influence on the American [37:17] founding and why as Christians we should [37:20] be the most defensive of our Jewish [37:22] fellow citizens the most. I mean and so [37:26] I I think that sort of exercising that [37:28] sort of making sure your conscience is [37:30] tuned the right way to be prepared for [37:32] that. And then you look there's all [37:34] kinds of great jobs working on Capitol [37:36] Hill. Um you know working in various [37:38] think tanks where you can continue to do [37:40] this good work. But I think the [37:41] important part is is studying studying [37:44] the founding. Um I'm trying to think [37:46] some of these great there's I can I've [37:48] got a list of books I can give you if [37:49] you want to shoot out to the to them [37:51] after this too. That could be really [37:52] good. Um, but then, you know, resist the [37:56] temptation to go along with political [37:59] tribes that try to simplify these [38:01] complex issues. You you don't have to do [38:04] it. You you don't you don't have to go [38:06] with this tribe or that tribe. And [38:08] especially when your conscience is kind [38:09] of going haywire, like this doesn't seem [38:11] right to me. Um, it probably isn't. And [38:14] so I think that the the the challenge [38:16] for all of us right now is to understand [38:18] how important um our alliances are, what [38:21] our adver who our adversaries really [38:23] are, and then also just in our personal [38:26] lives as Christians, you know, what is [38:28] your moral responsibility now daytoday [38:31] and I've just we were talking about how [38:33] across college campuses there's [38:35] flare-ups of anti-semitism. That's [38:37] terrible. And I would just say get in [38:39] your mind right now that you want to be [38:40] the Christian who's intolerant of it. [38:43] be be the safe place for your your [38:45] Jewish um peers. Um because you know [38:49] anti-semitism is a sickness and it'll [38:53] it'll it'll it'll it'll ruin this this [38:55] American experiment in self-government. [38:58] So my last half question for you, I call [39:01] it that because I think this is a bit of [39:02] a softball, but [39:04] what are two or three scripture passages [39:08] that have most shaped the way that you [39:10] think about all these things or the [39:12] reasons why you care about these issues? [39:15] >> I really did not know he was going to [39:17] ask that, but I do have something I want [39:18] to read to you. [clears throat] [39:22] Okay. [39:24] So, so I mean obviously I mean it's that [39:28] so simple simp simple answer is just [39:29] like all of the verses that talk about [39:31] what is the role of government obviously [39:33] but then also just the verses where it's [39:34] like you know people think that being a [39:36] Christian sometimes they sort of o [39:38] overcompartmentalize it like I'm a [39:40] Christian in my personal life but I'm [39:41] not a Christian it's like you're not [39:42] you're actually a Christian you're a [39:43] Christian journalist you're a Christian [39:45] student you're a Christian so so I think [39:47] I'm internalizing just that concept but [39:49] this is this is something for me um this [39:53] is from when uh Jesus Jesus realizes [39:55] that Lazarus has died. [39:57] And this is from Tim Keller's book. Tim [40:00] [clears throat] Keller. So Jesus learns [40:02] of the death of Lazarus and goes to the [40:04] tomb. [40:05] This is from Tim Keller's book on [40:07] suffering. When he Jesus approaches the [40:09] tomb, most translations say he was once [40:12] more deeply moved or he groaned in [40:14] himself. But these translations are too [40:17] weak. The Greek word used by the gospel [40:20] writer John means quote to bellow with [40:23] anger. [40:25] It is a startling term. Theologian BB [40:27] Warfield writes, quote, "What John tells [40:29] us in point of fact is that Jesus [40:32] approached the grave of Lazarus in a [40:34] state not of uncontrollable grief, but [40:37] of irreressible anger." End quote. Why [40:40] did the sight of Lazarus's tomb and his [40:43] family's grief enrage Jesus? In some [40:45] ways, his anger and tears seem [40:47] inappropriate. [40:49] He knows full well that he is about to [40:50] turn all the grieving and mourning into [40:52] shouts of wonder and joy. He is about to [40:54] raise Lazarus from the dead. So why is [40:57] he quite literally furious and what is [41:00] he furious at? Warfield, relying on John [41:03] Calvin's commentary on the same passage [41:05] gives a remarkable answer. [41:07] The spectacle of the distress of Mary [41:10] and her companions enraged Jesus because [41:13] it brought poignantly home to his [41:14] consciousness the evil of death, its [41:17] unnaturalenness, its violent tyranny, as [41:20] Calvin phrases it. In Mary's grief, he [41:23] contemplates the general misery of the [41:25] whole human race and burns with rage [41:28] against the oppressor of men. [41:30] Inextinguishable fury seizes upon him. [41:32] His whole being is discomposed and [41:34] perturbed. It is death that is the [41:36] object of his wrath and behind death him [41:40] who has the power of death and who he [41:42] has come into the world to destroy. What [41:45] John does for us in this particular [41:47] statement is to uncover to us the heart [41:49] of Jesus as he wins for us our [41:51] salvation. Not in cold unconcern but in [41:54] flaming wrath against the foe Jesus [41:56] smites on our behalf. He has not only [41:59] saved us from the evils which oppress [42:01] us. He has felt for and with us in our [42:03] oppression and under the impulse of [42:05] these feelings he has wrought out our [42:07] redemption. I know that's long but to me [42:11] um I think that you know we we the [42:14] United States are so incredibly blessed [42:17] to be founded on the on these principles [42:20] of life and the dignity of the human [42:22] person. That's what western values are. [42:25] And so I think for Christians, we should [42:27] feel this sense of duty to steward this [42:30] great gift of citizenship that we have. [42:33] And um who is the other nation? We've [42:35] got Western nations that feel similarly, [42:37] but the other nation that h that that [42:40] really has that same sense of God as [42:42] creator and who's created the human [42:44] person in his own image and with dignity [42:47] um is Israel. And and so um I think as [42:52] people who love life and the creator of [42:54] life and the one who came to um give us [42:57] eternal life, we should be great [42:58] defenders of it. And um so for me uh [43:02] that is what motivates me and inspires [43:05] me to to do this good and important [43:07] work. [43:09] >> I just want to say go ahead. [applause] [43:17] I'm going to ask him to do that again in [43:18] a second. But first, I just want to say [43:21] I really appreciate your example of [43:23] someone who thinks really seriously and [43:26] has attained a tremendous amount of [43:27] expertise, but is also very sincere in [43:31] the way that your faith informs the way [43:32] that you think about these issues. [43:34] Tremendous example to all of us here. [43:36] Thank you very much for sharing it this [43:38] evening. And again, please give her a [43:40] round of applause. [applause]