Transcript [00:00] Joining me to debate the election [00:01] results so far is political scientist [00:02] and activist Norman Finkelstein, [00:04] Jonathan Conricus, senior fellow [00:06] Foundation for Defense of Democracies, [00:08] the Palestinian-American journalist and [00:10] commentator Omar Baddar, and Peter [00:12] Beinart, who is the author of the [00:13] Beinart Notebook. Well, I I can't think [00:15] of a better panel to try and dissect all [00:18] this. Jonathan Conricus, let me start [00:19] with you. You know, [00:21] you've been one of the guests I've had [00:23] from the pro-Israel side who's never [00:25] been blindly loyal, supportive of [00:27] everything the Netanyahu government [00:30] does. You're obviously a former IDF man [00:32] yourself. Eisenkot is a former IDF man. [00:35] What [00:36] Where's your sentiment lying right now? [00:38] I mean, given the drop in support for [00:41] Netanyahu's government, do you think it [00:44] is the moment now that Israel gets a new [00:47] leader? Or do you think Netanyahu has [00:49] done enough here to survive, and that [00:50] would be a good thing? [00:54] >> Yeah, good evening. Shalom. Um, you [00:56] know, as an Israeli, how I feel today is [00:59] that I'm happy that we have a free and [01:01] democratic elections. Probably the only [01:04] ones conducted in a 2,000 km radius. I'm [01:08] happy at the democratic level to see [01:10] lots of Arabs voting and participating. [01:14] Uh, it's sad that these Arabs, uh, even [01:18] though they are part of the political [01:20] process and have the same rights as [01:21] everybody else, continue to refuse to be [01:25] part of modern Israel and to call [01:27] themselves Israelis and, uh, [01:29] be part of the state of Israel in that [01:31] sense. And, you know, Jonathan made [01:33] interesting remarks, and I think he's a [01:35] thoughtful fellow. The only thing that [01:37] kind of struck me wrong was how he kept [01:39] referring to them as Palestinians. The [01:42] way I see them and the way that actually [01:44] many of them would see themselves would [01:46] be Israeli Arabs. [01:48] Uh, and that whole narrative of of, [01:50] you know, branding them as Palestinians [01:53] is, [01:53] uh, a bit subversive. But, more to the [01:55] point about Netanyahu, I I he's again [01:58] proven himself as a grandmaster of [02:01] Israeli politics. [02:03] His campaign in the last two three [02:06] months was basically focused on him and [02:09] him alone. He hid away all of his [02:13] less qualified and less eloquent [02:16] ministers, some of them with very [02:17] troubling records and [02:20] the way that they have [02:22] have or have not really performed [02:25] under this government. He He really [02:29] put all of those in a cupboard and threw [02:31] away the key and shouldered the the [02:33] entire campaign on himself and [02:36] apparently it has worked just enough to [02:39] prevent the other side from winning. [02:41] And that's the bottom line here. Now, [02:43] where my assessment of Israeli politics [02:46] differ a little bit from what Jonathan [02:47] said, [02:48] I think that Eisenkot has a lot of bad [02:52] options. His results are not good enough [02:54] to actually unseat Netanyahu. And I [02:57] don't think that he will repeat the [02:59] mistake that has been that was done by [03:01] Bennett a few years ago in actually [03:05] working with or relying on the support [03:08] whether tacit or active of Arab parties [03:11] in order to form a minority government. [03:13] His numbers aren't good enough and it [03:15] would be a blatant violation of [03:18] many election promises and most parts of [03:21] his block will probably not agree with [03:23] it. And um [03:25] I think that a unity government while it [03:28] is definitely called for, [03:30] as said before, there are a lot of [03:32] people, Israeli Jewish Zionists who feel [03:35] very strongly against Netanyahu. [03:38] What that brings us to is a stalemate [03:41] and the scenario that a lot of people [03:44] feared is that we will have to do [03:46] elections all over again in three or [03:50] actually five months [03:52] with these inconclusive results. And [03:54] what I look at from a security [03:55] perspective is that this of course [03:58] exposes Israel to additional aggression. [04:01] Our enemies, I'm sure, are happy with [04:03] the fact that we have indecisive [04:07] elections here, and I'm sure that they [04:09] look forward to trying to drive a wedge [04:11] between different parts of Israeli [04:12] society. Hamas, I'm sure will appreciate [04:16] the the fact that there's less pressure [04:18] on them, and I'm sure we will discuss [04:20] the Iranian [04:21] regime and what it means for them. But [04:24] all in all, happy that we have a [04:25] democracy, not happy with the results. [04:29] >> Okay. [04:31] Um Norman Finkelstein, [04:33] do you do you think you really I might [04:35] will bring you in because I saw you [04:36] grimacing at some of the things Jonathan [04:38] was saying, and I I think I know which [04:39] bit in particular. I will come to you. [04:41] But but Norman Finkelstein, [04:43] do you think it really matters [04:45] who ultimately prevails here? Because, [04:49] you know, many people say, "Look, um [04:51] Isaac got He He's not Netanyahu, but [04:54] he's not far off." You know, they they [04:56] differ on a few small issues, but [04:58] broadly speaking, there would be [05:01] unlikely to be a massive change in [05:03] philosophy, regardless of which one of [05:05] them prevailed in the end. Is that how [05:07] you see this? [05:09] >> Well, thank you for that important [05:12] question. I'd like to just previous [05:15] uh briefly comment on your previous [05:18] speaker. I hate to throw cold water on [05:21] his parade, but there was no democratic [05:24] election in Israel for a very simple [05:26] basic fact. [05:28] The Palestinians in the West Bank and [05:30] Gaza are part of the state of Israel. [05:34] Israel has annexed those territories. [05:38] In July 2024, [05:41] the Israeli Knesset passed a resolution, [05:44] there will be no Palestinian state west [05:48] of the Jordanian River. [05:50] Mr. Netanyahu, when he spoke at the [05:52] United Nations, was very emphatic. Judea [05:57] and Samaria are part of the state of [06:01] Israel. [06:02] Now, that population represents 30% [06:06] of the potential electorate. So, I ask [06:10] you, Piers, because you're an [06:11] intelligent person, my publisher told me [06:15] that last night, I ask you a very simple [06:18] question, not polemical, not rhetorical. [06:23] If New York State, [06:26] California, [06:27] Texas, and Florida, [06:30] if that electorate, if those voters were [06:35] excluded from participation, [06:38] would you call it a democratic election? [06:42] I believe, but you can speak for [06:44] yourself, that you wouldn't. So, how can [06:47] you classify the Israeli election as [06:51] democratic when 30% of its population, [06:55] according to the Israeli government, [06:59] is excluded from participation? [07:02] Now, to the question that you asked, a [07:05] second problem with calling it a [07:07] democratic election is that essentially [07:11] there is one party in the state of [07:14] Israel. [07:16] It consists of a a right-wing, [07:19] a [07:20] far right-wing, and an ultra right-wing. [07:25] Mr. Eizenkot, [07:27] he got together with Netanyahu [07:30] approximately 100 of the 120 seats in [07:34] the Knesset. [07:35] Now, Mr. [07:38] Netanyahu is, according to many, [07:42] probably a broad consensus of scholars [07:46] and humanitarian and UN institutions, [07:49] he is a genocidal murderer. [07:52] He is a child killer. [07:55] He comes to the UN and holds up a pager [07:59] bragging [08:00] about what even the former head of the [08:04] CIA, Mr. Leon Panetta, called an act of [08:08] terrorism. [08:10] About that, there is no dispute. So, [08:13] let's go to Gadi Eizenkot. [08:16] Eizenkot is best known for having [08:20] authored the Dahiya Doctrine. What is [08:23] the Dahiya Doctrine? Every one of you [08:26] listeners knows the most basic principle [08:29] of the laws of war law. Everyone knows [08:32] it. It's called the principle of [08:34] distinction. What does that mean? [08:37] It's just a highfalutin term for you can [08:41] target combatants [08:43] and you can target military sites, but [08:47] you cannot target civilians and civilian [08:51] sites. [08:52] In 2006, [08:54] Gadi Eizenkot, [08:56] he was the one who authored the Dahiya [08:59] Doctrine, which is that you target [09:03] you target civilian sites, you target [09:09] civilians. [09:10] He is by [09:13] an act of authorship, [09:16] he is a certifiable [09:19] war criminal [09:21] under the most basic principle of [09:24] international law, the principle of [09:27] distinction. [09:30] >> Piers, can I comment here? [09:32] >> Um [09:33] Well, I saw you grimacing there. [09:35] >> I want to bring the other two in first, [09:36] Jonathan. I will come back to Jonathan. [09:37] >> I'll just make it short. [09:38] >> Peter Baynham. [09:39] >> Yeah, yeah. Jonathan, some of us haven't [09:40] >> Well, well, no, I don't I don't I want [09:41] to give the others [09:42] No, no, I don't I will bring you in, but [09:44] the others haven't had a chance to speak [09:45] yet. They They must We We have a panel [09:47] here. So, Peter, welcome welcome back to [09:49] Uncensored to you. Um I want to play a [09:52] clip from Donald Trump reacting to [09:55] the news that Netanyahu had clearly done [09:57] better than people thought. Let's take a [09:58] look. [10:00] >> I'm hearing that he did very proudly. [10:02] You know, [10:03] three votes. [music] [10:04] Very well. [10:06] I think when the endorsement went out, [10:08] it it helped them a lot. [10:09] But I actually heard he did pretty well. [10:11] Might be winning. [10:13] Or a tie. A tie is still considered a [10:14] win in that [10:16] it's a big kiss thing. [10:20] >> I mean, they're kind of wedded, aren't [10:22] they, a bit, uh, Netanyahu and Trump? [10:24] They're joined at the hip over the war [10:26] on Iran. Trump has been very supportive [10:28] of Netanyahu, um, particularly recently [10:30] in the run-up to the election. He called [10:32] him a great warrior prime minister. Uh, [10:35] anyone else Trump wanted to be the wrong [10:36] leader, and so on. How significant, how [10:39] influential is Donald Trump in all this [10:42] as the [10:44] as the negotiations now play out as to [10:47] what kind of government's going to get [10:49] formed? [10:50] >> I I think Trump is much less significant [10:53] than the rules of the game in Israel in [10:55] general, which are, to use a phrase that [10:57] Trump often likes to use, rigged. Which [11:00] is to say, because Israel defines itself [11:03] as a Jewish state, it's 20% of [11:06] Palestinian citizens, right? As Norman [11:08] was saying, most of the Palestinians [11:09] under Israeli control can't become [11:11] citizens, so they can't vote in Israeli [11:13] elections. But the 20% of Israel [11:15] citizens who are Palestinians, they can [11:18] vote, but they're not considered fully [11:19] legitimate members because it's a Jewish [11:22] state. It's almost as if, imagine [11:24] America defined itself as a white [11:25] Christian state, and most Americans [11:27] voted against Donald Trump, but then the [11:30] media said, "Well, you know, a [11:31] significant number of those votes [11:33] against Donald Trump were voted were [11:35] were the votes of black people or other [11:37] people who are not Christians, and so [11:39] we're not sure those are really [11:40] legitimate people to enter into a [11:43] government." That explains the situation [11:45] that Israel's in today. In a healthy, [11:48] functioning liberal democracy where all [11:50] citizens were treated equal, Palestinian [11:52] citizens would be the base of the [11:55] anti-Netanyahu coalition, and they would [11:57] be at the heart of a more progressive [11:59] politics, just like black Americans are [12:01] in the United States. [12:05] >> Okay, and I'm about a year you were [12:07] pulling faces Jonathan Conricus's early [12:11] comments. I think it was about what [12:13] Norman touched on of course, which is [12:15] this supposition that Jonathan put out [12:17] that everyone gets treated equally in [12:19] this election. So, what did you want to [12:21] say about that? [12:23] >> Yeah, it's it's completely absurd on its [12:25] face. Israel is an apartheid state as [12:28] essentially, you know, confirmed by [12:30] Amnesty International and Human Rights [12:31] Watch. And it's not difficult looking at [12:33] what how Israel operates in practice. To [12:36] Norman's point, the most critical part [12:37] is that millions of Palestinians who [12:39] live under Israeli control do not get to [12:41] participate in that election. And if you [12:42] want to dispute whether, you know, they [12:44] live under Israel or not, ask any [12:46] Palestinian in the West Bank if they [12:47] want to travel anywhere in the world, [12:49] who do they go through? Do they control [12:50] their own borders? Do they collect their [12:51] own taxes? Their lives are completely [12:53] controlled by Israel. They have to go [12:55] through Israeli border controls before [12:56] they can go anywhere. So, they are [12:58] controlled by the state of Israel. And [13:00] they don't get to participate in that [13:01] election. And when we talk about [13:03] Palestinian citizens of Israel who do [13:05] get And by the way, there's nothing [13:06] insidious about calling them [13:08] Palestinians. That is their identity [13:10] from before Israel was even created. So, [13:12] they are Palestinian citizens of Israel. [13:14] They put forth a bill in the Knesset [13:17] trying to define Israel as a country for [13:19] all its citizens. And the Knesset does [13:21] not even allow that to come to the floor [13:22] for a vote. That is the level of [13:24] contempt that Israel has for Palestinian [13:26] citizens of Israel. They do not see them [13:28] as equals and they do not treat them as [13:29] equals. In addition to the fact that [13:31] their schools are underfunded, the fact [13:33] that they face incredible legal [13:35] discrimination on the books in terms of [13:37] housing, in terms of a whole slate of of [13:40] of issues in which they are told that [13:41] they are not equal. And the most [13:43] remarkable thing about this election [13:45] appears is that you do have a situation [13:46] right now where the pro-Netanyahu bloc [13:48] and the anti-Netanyahu bloc are neck and [13:50] neck and fighting over who's going to [13:51] win. And either of them could solve this [13:53] very easily by simply forming a [13:55] coalition with the Palestinian citizens [13:57] of Israel, the so-called Arab parties in [13:59] in there. But the level of contempt that [14:01] they have for them that they both [14:03] promised that they would never work with [14:04] them. Which reminds you of how much [14:06] these both blocs have more in common [14:08] that they do in opposition to each [14:09] other. They are both committed to not [14:11] forming coalitions with Palestinian [14:12] citizens of Israel. They're both [14:14] committed to keeping Palestinians under [14:16] the boot of military occupation [14:18] indefinitely. No Palestinian state, no [14:20] equality under [14:22] under the law for everyone. And so [14:23] effectively, they are joint in a deeply [14:26] anti-Palestinian posture. That is what [14:27] they collaborate on. And the difference [14:29] is about a level of extremism, about a [14:32] degree of extremism. Where Eisenkot and [14:34] his wing would rather manage the brutal [14:37] occupation in a way that is a little bit [14:38] better from a PR perspective. And people [14:41] like Netanyahu, with Ben-Gvir and the [14:42] rest of the team of lunatics they have, [14:44] they want to be extremely aggressive in [14:46] terms of pushing ethnic cleansing in the [14:47] West Bank in line with what they've done [14:49] in Gaza, and pursuing this insane war [14:51] that they have with Iran more [14:53] aggressively. So it is about a degree of [14:55] badness, but we should be absolutely [14:57] clear-eyed about the fact that [15:00] the central issue, which is the whether [15:02] Palestinians get to have freedom and [15:04] basic human rights, that is not simply [15:06] an issue in this election at all and has [15:08] not been discussed in this discourse, [15:09] and will simply not change no matter who [15:11] wins this essentially sham of an [15:13] election. [15:15] >> Here's [15:15] >> Okay, well, Jonathan, congratulations on [15:17] showing a very rare very rare patience. [15:20] I have to take my hat off to you. Very [15:22] unlike you not to [15:24] try and jump in and interrupt. So the [15:26] floor is yours. [15:28] >> Yeah, thanks for the snark in the [15:30] comment. And it is really testing [15:32] because you bring three people [15:35] buddying up with the same infantile and [15:38] ignorant opinions about Israel. [15:41] And at least I should have the same [15:43] amount of time. [15:44] And I'd like to confront the ignorant [15:46] really you [15:47] tremendous levels of of just [15:51] I I don't know if it's willful ignorance [15:53] or if it's stupidity or malice, but [15:55] someone who's a professor should know [15:57] better than to claim that Israel has [16:00] annexed or applied Israeli law over [16:02] Judea and Samaria. It has not. There [16:04] have been statements by Israeli [16:06] politicians, but under Israeli law, [16:09] Israel has done no such thing. There are [16:11] many people who want to, but the state [16:13] of the matter is that the legal [16:15] situation that governs the situation in [16:17] Judea and Samaria are the Oslo Accords [16:20] whereby the Palestinian Authority exists [16:22] and they are the ones who govern the [16:24] Palestinian population there and Israel [16:27] is responsible for the Jewish population [16:29] there. Now, if we all want to talk about [16:31] elections, free elections, by all means [16:34] let's do that. And since you seem so [16:37] caring and [16:38] interested in how Arabs vote and where [16:41] they vote, do you know where they vote? [16:43] Arabs [16:44] between the river and the sea, the only [16:46] that they can vote freely is in Israel. [16:49] The only place where they are prevented [16:50] from voting is in their autonomy as [16:53] provided to them by the Oslo Accords and [16:55] that is in the Palestinian Authority. [16:57] >> Jonathan, can you address can you [16:59] address specifically the fact that [17:00] Palestinians in the West Bank cannot [17:02] live under Israeli control? [17:03] I'm asking you to address. I'm not [17:05] interrupting you. I'm asking you a [17:05] question. [17:06] >> have any interruptions. I'm not going to [17:08] have any interruptions. I stayed quiet [17:09] in spite of the vitriol and nonsense [17:12] that you speak about. [17:13] >> asking you to address the point. You're [17:15] just not answering it. [17:15] >> I'm not even going to not even going to [17:17] address it. The The only people who are [17:20] not allowed to vote and who do not have [17:24] any democratic representation are Arabs [17:27] living under the Palestinian Authority [17:29] who currently are governed by Mahmoud [17:31] Abbas and his thugs in the PA who are he [17:34] is in his 22nd or 23rd year of a [17:38] four-year term. Many countries, [17:40] including your country, Piers, and many [17:43] others recognize the Palestinian [17:45] Authority and some of them said it would [17:47] be on condition of reform and elections [17:50] in the Palestinian Authority. Those [17:52] elections were supposed to be held late [17:54] this year or by the latest by the [17:57] beginning of next year and guess what [17:59] happened? They've been canceled by [18:01] Mahmoud Abbas for whatever reasons. [18:04] He's given a few [18:06] window-dressing reasons, but the bottom [18:08] line is that if any of you hypocrites [18:10] had any concern for freedom of for [18:13] democracy, for freedom of political [18:15] freedom for Arabs between the river and [18:18] the sea, your first talking point [18:20] shouldn't be to slander democratic [18:23] Israel where 2 million Arabs have voting [18:26] rights and participate in the political [18:27] process, it should be [18:29] >> There is I need to I need to respond to [18:30] this if possible. [18:31] >> which is the Palestinian Authority. And [18:34] the second point that I want to respond [18:35] to is the defamation about the Dahiya [18:39] Accords. First and foremost, I suggest [18:41] that you at least know learn how to [18:44] pronounce it correctly. It's the [18:45] southern neighborhood of Beirut and if [18:47] you're referencing something, at least [18:49] make the effort of making it sound [18:51] correctly, Professor. And the second [18:53] point, which is totally inaccurate and I [18:56] believe me, I've studied the doctrine [18:58] much better than you have, is that it is [19:00] a issue of targeting terrorists and [19:03] hitting the terrorist despite the fact [19:06] that it is understood that they're [19:08] hiding behind innocent civilians and [19:11] using them as their human shields, which [19:14] in fact is Hezbollah's [19:17] modus operandi. The same modus operandi [19:19] that Hamas uses, using humans as human [19:23] shields and putting their own people in [19:25] harm's way and doing it knowingly. And [19:28] the Dahiya doctrine simply says, we [19:31] recognize the fact that the terrorists [19:33] are hiding behind people and we're going [19:35] to warn ahead of time, cause people to [19:38] leave, but we're also going to signal to [19:41] the terrorists that it's not going to [19:43] help you that you're hiding between [19:45] them. And in closing, I want to say one [19:47] last thing with regards to the situation [19:50] in Israel. [19:52] I [19:53] definitely didn't vote for either [19:55] Smotrich or Ben-Gvir and I have said on [19:57] this program and many others that I [19:59] think Ben-Gvir has done tremendous [20:01] damage to Israel. I have also said that [20:03] Israel needs to do better in terms of [20:06] policing and upholding law and order in [20:09] Judea and Samaria and not to allow [20:12] Israelis to operate as they have. But I [20:15] think that so many people [20:17] >> very quickly? [20:18] >> So many people are simply either racist, [20:22] antisemites, filled with hatred, or [20:25] ignorant, and they're willing to even on [20:28] a day when Arabs in Israel participate [20:31] and make a landslide achievement, go on [20:34] and pontificate about democracy in [20:36] Israel, which is the only democracy in [20:39] the region in many thousand kilometer [20:41] radius where Arab people, [20:43] >> Okay. [20:44] >> women and men can vote, and they can do [20:46] so freely without repression, without [20:49] violence. [20:50] >> So, suggest that before you bring the [20:52] others [20:52] >> apartheid regime in the region [20:53] committing genocide, actually. [20:55] >> So, do you want to bring the others in, [20:56] Jonathan? Well, I gave you I gave [20:58] You've had nearly 5 minutes, Jonathan. [21:00] So, let me let me I I'll go [21:02] Hang on a sec. Hang on a sec. Hang on a [21:03] sec. Hang on a Hang on a sec. Hang on. [21:05] Norman, hang on. Norman, hang on because [21:08] well, for one reason, Peter has to leave [21:09] us. So, Peter Peter [21:11] Peter, before you go, just your your [21:13] reaction to what Jonathan said, then [21:14] I'll bring the other two in. [21:16] >> Yeah, it's interesting Jonathan talked [21:18] about the Palestinian Authority not [21:19] holding elections. I think he's exactly [21:21] right. I actually wrote a column in the [21:22] New York Times just a few weeks ago [21:24] arguing that the United States should [21:25] push for elections in both the West Bank [21:28] and Gaza and East Jerusalem. But for [21:30] those elect The reason those elections [21:32] don't take place is not only because [21:34] Mahmoud Abbas is a corrupt [21:35] authoritarian, it's because Israel [21:38] doesn't want to allow Palestinians to [21:40] hold free elections. In fact, neither [21:41] does the United States because they fear [21:43] that Palestinians might choose leaders [21:45] who Israel and the United States can't [21:47] control. So, if we want Palestinians in [21:50] the West Bank and Gaza and East [21:51] Jerusalem to have the right to vote, [21:53] that means allowing them the right to [21:55] vote and them to choose their leaders, [21:57] right? And in fact, Israel's and [21:58] America's policies have been exactly the [22:00] opposite. [22:01] >> Peter, thank you very much indeed for [22:03] joining us. I know you have to leave. [22:04] You said that before we started. Thank [22:05] you very much. I appreciate it. Um and I [22:07] want to bring the others in uh first, [22:09] Jonathan, cuz you had you had a good 5 [22:10] minute wipe there. So, Norman, would you [22:13] like to say back to what Jonathan was [22:15] saying? [22:18] >> Well, first of all, there will be a [22:19] point of agreement here. I do agree with [22:23] Jonathan that my Arabic pronunciation is [22:26] appalling and even though I've written [22:29] several books on Gaza, I've never been [22:31] able to pronounce Gaza correctly. I try, [22:34] but I just don't have an ear for [22:36] language. I'm a reader. I'm not great at [22:39] verbal skills. [22:40] >> And for what it's worth, Jonathan can't [22:42] say Dahiya either in Arabic. [22:44] >> I can say I can say I can say Hamas and [22:47] I can say Hezbollah and I can say [22:49] mujahideen. I'm sorry. [22:51] >> Yeah, this is this is meaningless. This [22:53] is I mean [22:53] >> I can say and I can say the word I can [22:55] say the I can say the word pedantic. So, [22:58] should we get back to the big picture, [23:00] please, gentlemen? [23:01] >> Yeah, and I can say bigots and haters of [23:03] Israel. I can say a lot of things. That [23:05] doesn't make any any difference. [23:07] >> Is this a filibuster? [23:10] Okay, thank you. [23:12] So, [23:13] uh Jonathan says I misstate the Dahiya [23:16] doctrine. People can look it up in the [23:19] Wikipedia or in any other [23:22] um [23:22] place and find out who's speaking [23:25] correctly about whether the Dahiya [23:26] doctrine was specifically the targeting [23:29] of civilian neighborhoods in Beirut, [23:32] which was extended to civilian [23:34] neighborhoods in general. [23:36] So, Mr. uh Karnazes, John Jonathan, [23:41] uh he says Israel only targets people [23:43] when they're being [23:45] uh [23:45] targets civilians when they're being [23:47] used as human shields. So, as a point of [23:50] information for you listeners, let's [23:52] look at the new UN report on Gaza. [23:56] The New York New UN report states that [23:58] Israel, allow me to quote it, that [24:01] Israel continues to commit genocide in [24:06] Gaza. [24:07] Now, Mr. Karnazes, without, you know, [24:10] with his fluency in many languages, [24:13] surely knows that the essence of a [24:15] genocide is you're not targeting [24:18] combatants. You're not targeting [24:22] military sites. The essence of a [24:24] genocide is you're targeting civilians. [24:29] Now, [24:30] the report goes on to say that, quote, [24:34] Palestinian children, children, [24:38] are deliberately targeted on [24:41] discriminatory grounds. That is to say, [24:45] they are targeting the children [24:48] deliberately [24:50] because they're children. Now, what does [24:53] that mean as a practical matter? [24:56] Since the ceasefire went into effect in [24:59] October 2025, [25:02] 1,400 Palestinians have been killed in [25:05] Gaza. [25:06] Now, Piers, that's more Palestinians [25:11] killed in Gaza since the ceasefire [25:16] than were Israelis killed on October [25:19] 7th. [25:21] So, if that's a ceasefire, [25:24] then what happened on October 7th was a [25:29] super ceasefire. [25:32] Of those 400 [25:34] Gazans killed, [25:36] 300 [25:39] 300 [25:41] 300 [25:43] were children. [25:45] 36 Israeli children were killed [25:49] on October 7th. Nearly 10 times more [25:56] Palestinian children have been killed [25:59] during the ceasefire. [26:02] But, Mr. Konrikus [26:04] is very adamant, very insistent [26:08] that Israel would never target civilians [26:12] only when Hamas is using them as human [26:15] shields. [26:17] >> Yeah, I'd like to response to that, [26:19] Piers. Respond to it. [26:20] >> Well, you can you can respond given you [26:22] a reference by name many times. And [26:24] then, Omar, you can respond to Jonathan. [26:26] Cuz it is two it's two v one at the [26:27] moment. Accept that. And uh I don't want [26:29] you bleating afterwards that you were [26:31] outgunned. I think you can handle two [26:33] people, Jonathan. [26:34] >> [snorts] [26:35] >> I can [clears throat] handle more, and [26:36] Israelis handle more every day, Piers, [26:38] so it's totally fine. But, I appreciate [26:40] the gentlemanly approach here. Um [26:43] so, if we're serious here for a second, [26:44] and these are serious matters, [26:47] um allow me not to be impressed by yet [26:49] another UN report written by corrupt, [26:53] biased, um sham sham liars against [26:58] Israel. Allow me not to be impressed by [27:02] Hamas statistics of who is a child and [27:05] who isn't. Allow me to remind you that [27:07] Hamas regularly uses 14, 15, 16, [27:11] 17-year-old boys as combatants. And [27:14] allow me to remind you that yes, Israel [27:17] has indeed violated the ceasefire [27:19] numerous times, but it is in order to [27:22] take out, eliminate, or assassinate [27:25] Hamas terrorists who participated in [27:27] October 7. And while I agree, I take the [27:30] point that it is indeed a violation of [27:31] the ceasefire, those said terrorists who [27:34] participated in the worst massacre of [27:37] Jews since the Holocaust on October 7, [27:40] when they went in purposely killing [27:42] civilians, burning, murdering, raping, [27:47] and humiliating Israelis at the scale [27:49] never before seen, regretfully. What [27:52] they did on that day has prompted Israel [27:54] to say, "Well, we are going to hunt them [27:56] down, and we're going to hunt every last [27:59] one of them down. And every time that [28:01] Israel is able to take one of them out, [28:03] we will [28:04] >> [clears throat] [28:04] >> issue a statement saying, 'This is who [28:06] we attacked. This is what this terrorist [28:08] did on October 7, and this is why he [28:10] also was a threat for the future, [28:13] because he was busy building Hamas [28:15] capabilities, Hamas or Islamic Jihad [28:17] capabilities [28:18] for the future, and that is the reason [28:20] that Israel fights.' So, if you want to [28:22] make that grotesque comparison between [28:25] the genocidal intent of Hamas on October [28:28] 7 against Israeli civilians and [28:31] soldiers, what they did, and if you want [28:33] to make a comparison between that and [28:35] hunting down terrorists and per- perhaps [28:38] inadvertently also killing [28:39] non-combatants, but totally leaving out [28:42] the context, I think it tells very much [28:44] more about your intellectual integrity [28:47] and how deep down the rabbit hole of [28:50] Israel hatred you are, Professor, and I [28:52] think it erodes your very basic [28:54] legitimacy to have any point of [28:56] reference on what's going on, and it [28:58] just exposes how perverted your [29:00] perspective is. [29:03] >> Okay, I want to just read uh [29:06] We I'm uh you will be responding now. I [29:08] just want to bring in the fact that [29:09] Polymarket has been asking in the [29:11] prediction markets who'll be the next [29:12] Prime Minister of Israel. A lot of [29:14] movement, as you'd expect, in the past [29:16] 24 hours. Netanyahu has jumped into the [29:18] lead, 47%. Yesterday, only 27%. Eisenkot [29:22] now on 33%. Yesterday, peaking at 56%. [29:27] Another one, center-regular, Naftali [29:29] Bennett, currently on 4%. He's dropped [29:31] about 10 points in the last few days. [29:33] And there's $75 million in that in that [29:34] market. So, you know, the prediction [29:36] markets are often on the money, [29:40] uh I would argue, Omar, and they're [29:41] definitely pointing, it seems, that the [29:44] the predictive money is going towards [29:47] Netanyahu staying in power. And I, you [29:49] know, we can go back over the history of [29:51] various things, but actually, right now, [29:53] there is an ongoing live election in [29:56] play, which is going to have enormous [29:58] consequences. And I don't think we [30:00] should move too far away from that. Um [30:02] would you If I gave you a set of [30:05] circumstances [30:06] that notwithstanding your general view [30:09] of all of them, [30:11] uh [30:11] that if you ended up without Smotrich [30:14] and Ben-Gvir and their parties being [30:16] part of a government, would you consider [30:19] that to be a better scenario than the [30:21] one that we currently have? [30:25] >> I would answer your question, Piers, by [30:26] pointing the fact that the only [30:27] difference there is between people like [30:29] Smotrich and Ben-Gvir and then somebody [30:31] like Netanyahu is the fact that they are [30:33] explicit about the goals, where he would [30:35] rather keep it hidden and under the [30:36] carpet. That is the primary difference. [30:38] Netanyahu's policy is one of ethnic [30:41] cleansing, of genocide, of depopulating [30:43] Gaza, of wanting to pursue a more [30:45] aggressive posture in the West Bank to [30:47] do something similar. But, he wants to [30:49] put the cover of security on top of it, [30:51] whereas Smotrich and Ben-Gvir speak [30:52] openly about it as being an ethnic [30:54] cleansing project to get rid of the [30:55] Palestinian population there. That's a [30:57] cosmetic difference, so I don't think [30:59] that it would be particularly [31:00] consequential, apart from maybe better [31:02] PR for Israel in their campaign of [31:04] ethnic cleansing and genocide if those [31:06] were not there. But, just to respond [31:08] really, I think it's very, very [31:09] important to address what what Jonathan [31:10] had just said about the killing of [31:12] children, and he's inserting doubt into [31:14] that, you know, how many of these [31:15] children are Hamas fighters and who [31:17] counts and whatever. There have been [31:19] dozens of Western doctors, including [31:21] American Jewish doctors, who have gone [31:23] to Gaza, and they have said that there [31:25] is a pattern of targeting of Palestinian [31:28] toddlers, two and three and [31:29] four-year-olds, with sniper bullets. [31:31] Now, Jonathan is so committed to this [31:33] narrative that Israel only targets [31:35] terrorists, that it would effectively, [31:36] at this point, have you believe that [31:38] one- and two-year-olds who've been shot [31:39] in the head by Israeli snipers must be [31:41] Hamas members or something. It is [31:42] completely ridiculous. There's just [31:43] simply no [31:45] doubting the fact that anybody who looks [31:46] at the evidence, overwhelming evidence [31:48] in terms of video footage, in terms of [31:50] testimony, in terms of reports and [31:52] everything else, that Israel is waging a [31:54] war on the civilian population. And then [31:57] he talks about how concerned he is about [31:59] Palestinians voting and Palestinian [32:00] democracy. Well, the last time [32:02] Palestinians in the occupied territories [32:03] voted, the wrong party won, and Israel [32:06] responded by putting the Palestinian [32:07] population under a suffocating siege, [32:10] where they were punished collectively [32:12] having basic food items not allowed into [32:14] Gaza because they voted the wrong way. [32:16] And you have Chuck Schumer, the leader [32:18] of the Democrats here in the United [32:20] States, coming out and explicitly saying [32:22] that the goal of that siege is to teach [32:24] Palestinians a lesson, to make their [32:25] lives difficult, so that they would [32:27] learn to vote the correct way next time. [32:29] That is the view about Palestinians and [32:31] democracy, and you would never apply [32:32] that standard to Israelis when they vote [32:35] lunatics into power like Netanyahu and [32:36] Smotrich and the rest of them. Nobody [32:38] says it's time to starve Israelis and [32:40] and punish them and stop letting food in [32:41] so that they would vote the right way [32:43] the next time. We respect the principle [32:44] of democracy in a way that we've never [32:46] respected it with Palestinians. And [32:47] Mahmoud Abbas at the end of the day is a [32:49] janitor who basically manages that [32:51] occupation in the West Bank. He is not [32:53] in control of anything. [32:55] Palestinians in that West Bank, again to [32:57] the point that Jonathan just completely [32:59] glossed over [33:00] when he's talking about the annexation [33:02] never happened. Yes, on paper it never [33:04] happened, but de facto it is a reality [33:06] on the ground. Israel is in charge of [33:08] the West Bank. Palestinians moving from [33:10] one place to another inside the West [33:12] Bank have to go through Israeli [33:13] checkpoints. Palestinians trying to [33:14] leave or enter the West Bank have to go [33:16] through Israeli border controls. Israel [33:18] is in control of that territory. And any [33:21] pretense that that Palestinians are not [33:23] living under Israeli control is complete [33:24] and total fiction designed to [33:26] manufacture again, just utter [33:30] PR for an apartheid government and [33:32] pretend that it's more democratic than [33:33] it actually is. [33:34] >> Yeah, just to clarify for the [33:36] >> Jonathan, we need [33:37] >> Jonathan, before you before you apply, [33:40] Jonathan. Hang on hang on, Jonathan. [33:41] Hang on, Jonathan. Let me just tee you [33:43] up. You're going to get a chance to [33:44] speak. You know, it's interesting [33:46] because [33:47] people might tune in at this stage and [33:49] they'll say, "Well, you've got two guys [33:50] obviously very anti-Netanyahu [33:53] and one in the middle who, you know, is [33:56] from right wing F and supportive of the [33:57] Israeli government and so on." And it [33:59] was really interesting, Jonathan, this [34:00] time. One of the reasons for that that [34:03] it isn't a slightly more balanced lineup [34:05] in the way that I would have preferred [34:07] is that we tried so many people [34:09] to come on to be [34:12] loud and proud in their support of [34:13] Netanyahu. People didn't want to do it. [34:16] And I found that really interesting. A [34:17] lot of the usual people that we thought [34:20] would want to come on or want to talk up [34:22] Netanyahu did not want to do that. And I [34:25] I just, you know, I do question [34:28] whether Netanyahu's run his course. That [34:31] actually a lot of Israelis, even if [34:33] they've been supportive of him [34:34] historically, they just think the in the [34:37] the [34:38] opprobrium that is being poured on [34:40] Israel globally. [34:41] They blame him and Smotrich and [34:44] Ben-Gvir, these right-wing headbangers [34:46] he did the deal with to get back into [34:48] power. [34:49] They just think it is causing enormous [34:51] damage to Israel and to his reputation. [34:53] And I I agree with that. So, it was I [34:56] just I just wanted to say that. Well, [34:57] let Jonathan respond first and then I'll [34:59] I'll come to you in a moment, but [35:00] >> I must express one point of dissent. [35:02] >> Yeah, so so I want to respond to that, [35:05] Piers, since you since you offered [35:07] >> Well, let Jonathan respond, Norman, then [35:09] I'll give you the final word. [35:11] >> Yeah, I mean [35:12] >> Thank you so much, Piers. [35:13] >> I don't know what the schedule of other [35:15] Israelis are and what motivates them to [35:18] come on or not. Maybe they saw who else [35:21] was lined up on the show and they say, [35:23] "Why share a panel with a bunch of [35:25] Israel bashers?" I didn't know enough [35:27] ahead of time about all of them, so I [35:29] said, "Yes, why not? By all means, let's [35:31] come on after Israeli elections, [35:33] elections that I'm not very enthusiastic [35:35] about, but let's come on and uh [35:38] and uh and speak about them [35:40] nevertheless. Uh to the point that Omar [35:42] made here, it's an important point that [35:44] you kind of glossed over here, speaking [35:46] about wrong results in elections. So, [35:49] let's clarify for people who may be uh [35:52] less aware. When you say wrong elections [35:54] or wrong result, I'm pretty sure you're [35:56] meaning that uh Israel withdrew from [35:59] Gaza in 2005, handed it over on a [36:03] dirty silver platter to the Palestinian [36:05] Authority. They had elections and then [36:07] the population in Gaza elected an [36:10] internationally recognized terror [36:11] organization affiliated with the Muslim [36:13] Brother- Brotherhood, otherwise referred [36:16] to as Hamas. [36:18] They uh have since then governed [36:21] the Gaza Strip and they have brought [36:22] nothing but death, destruction, ruin, [36:25] and poverty on that area. But in this [36:28] panel, like in so many others, you will [36:30] continue to spew your nonsense and [36:33] ignorance about Israeli responsibility, [36:36] but not a single word [36:37] >> What are you talking about? [36:38] >> responsibility [36:39] >> The Israeli government is an infinitely [36:40] bigger terrorist organization and killed [36:42] infinitely more civilians and is [36:43] responsible for the situation in Gaza. [36:45] >> I did not interrupt you, Omar. I didn't [36:47] interrupt you. I waited my turn, and I [36:48] suggest you grow the patience to do the [36:50] same. [36:52] When you said all of these nonsensical [36:53] things about Israel, I suggest that you, [36:55] as an Arab, at least have the basic [36:58] dignity to demand of your own people [37:02] agency and responsibility. You elect the [37:05] terror organizations. [37:06] >> No. [37:07] >> Oh, thank you. [37:07] >> I'm not going to demand more of my [37:08] people when they are being occupied by a [37:10] foreign government. [clears throat] [37:12] >> Quality. This really shows who you are. [37:15] >> What you refer to. [37:16] >> That is the number one priority of [37:17] Palestinians is to resist that [37:18] occupation. [37:20] >> Of course. And and electing your terror [37:22] organizations is what you refer to. This [37:24] is victim blaming and [37:25] This is exactly [37:26] >> We we all know we all we have run out of [37:28] Okay. [37:29] >> You represent a genocidal government, [37:30] and you want me to hold my people [37:31] responsible for living under that [37:33] genocide that is imposed by your [37:34] government. [37:35] >> Guys, when you all talk, nobody can hear [37:37] you. [37:38] I want to make one point. We have run [37:40] out of time. Jonathan, wrap up your [37:42] point. Nobody gets the final word. [37:44] Jonathan, very quickly. [37:45] >> So, I'd like to [37:46] wrap up and say that exactly what [37:48] happened is [37:49] >> wrap up your point, Jonathan, quickly. [37:50] >> Yeah, the point being that demand [37:52] equally. Demand of Arabs what you demand [37:55] of Jews, and measure everybody by the [37:57] same yardstick, and that will be the [38:00] beginning of a solution to problems in [38:02] the Middle East because I assure you [38:04] that Arabs won't continue to get away [38:06] with what they've been up to for the [38:08] last 75 years, where Jews are held to [38:11] one standard, and Arabs, otherwise [38:13] referred to as Palestinians, are held to [38:15] a different one.