Transcript [00:01] Rabbi Manis Friedman, Dean of Bais [00:03] Chana, a shaliach, a true emissary, and [00:06] teacher of millions, tens of millions of [00:08] people across the world. Thank you so [00:10] much for joining us here today. [00:12] >> Thank you. [00:13] >> So, what is Jewish mysticism? [00:15] >> I don't know, it's mystical. [00:17] >> [laughter] [00:19] >> You know, it's like, what are the [00:20] secrets of Torah? Well, I can't tell [00:21] you, they're secrets. [00:24] Uh [00:25] mysticism simply means [00:29] a more personal view [00:31] of [00:33] the Torah, [00:34] the commandments, and the relationship [00:36] between us and God. [00:38] The commandments can be very dry. [00:41] The mystical side is the more personal, [00:44] the more [00:45] uh [00:46] intimate, the more romantic. [00:50] >> So, how were you introduced to this? Is [00:52] there a moment in your life where you [00:53] remember sort of connecting in a deeper [00:55] way and then going on this path of [00:57] becoming such a teacher to so many? [00:59] >> I grew up with it. Being in in the in [01:02] the in the Chabad school, [01:05] that's that's our bread and butter. [01:08] And I'll go a little deeper. What's [01:09] going on? Make it personal. [01:13] Remember, we were like 14 years old, a [01:15] group of us sitting around [01:17] when we should have been studying, and [01:19] we were talking about like, [01:20] "Why are we doing this?" [01:23] We were all observant from observant [01:25] families, [01:26] but we were sitting there saying, "Why [01:27] why do we do this?" [01:30] We had to make it personal, [01:33] which is [01:35] probably necessary. [01:37] If you never asked yourself that [01:38] question, you're you're not [01:40] you're not getting past the surface. [01:43] So, why are we doing? Why are we doing [01:45] it? Why is this important? [01:48] Make it personal. And if it's personal [01:51] on your part and you're serving God, it [01:53] must be personal on his part. [01:55] >> Yeah. [01:55] >> Otherwise, we're not communicating. [01:58] >> Amazing. So, then ideal world, all Jews [02:00] all Jews be mystics? [02:03] >> The whole world. [02:05] We can't remain strangers to God. [02:09] >> So, what do you think of when you say [02:11] God? What what is this concept? [02:15] >> God is the creator who desires a [02:18] relationship with us, [02:21] whose pleasure comes from [02:24] being invited into the physical world by [02:27] the physical world. [02:30] >> So, then what's the [02:31] >> That's romantic. [02:32] >> What? It's that invitation of God. [02:34] >> Yeah. [02:35] >> And what is the purpose of the Jewish [02:36] people? [02:38] >> To bring this knowledge to the world and [02:41] practice it and share it with the rest [02:43] of the world. [02:44] >> And how does prayer work? [02:48] >> The The real Obviously, yeah. [02:51] In a time of need, you should turn to [02:53] God. Who else you going to trust? [02:55] That That's the simple practical, you [02:57] know. [02:59] But the daily prayers, [03:01] which is not necessarily a time of need, [03:04] I hope you're not that needy. [03:06] Three times a day, every day. [03:09] The daily prayer is simply like a [03:12] reality check. [03:14] So, stand in front of God and tell him [03:16] how you're doing. [03:18] And keep a straight face. [03:19] >> [laughter] [03:21] >> Don't Don't Don't hide. Don't Don't [03:25] Don't spin. [03:27] Just stand there and and and tell God [03:31] We tried [03:32] making [03:33] our prayers meaningful. [03:35] And okay, we were kids and we didn't get [03:37] very far. [03:38] So, we One of the kids in the class [03:40] asked our teacher, our mentor, [03:43] "I tried to daven. I tried to pray. I [03:45] tried and [03:46] nothing happened." He said, "Oh, that's [03:48] good." [03:50] I said, "What do you mean that's good?" [03:51] He said, "That's the whole purpose. So [03:53] that you know where you stand." [03:56] You try to talk to God and say something [03:58] and you have nothing to say. Good. [04:00] That's a reality check. [04:02] >> Okay. [04:03] And what about Torah study? What's the [04:04] goal of Torah study? [04:07] >> I mean, that's that's the way you get [04:09] closer to uh [04:11] the knowledge of God brings closeness. [04:14] To know him is to love him. [04:17] >> And through Torah study, we get to know [04:19] him. [04:19] >> Yes. [04:20] >> Because it's his mind, it's his thought, [04:21] it's his [04:22] >> It's him revealing himself. [04:25] Telling himself in his own words. [04:28] >> Wow. So, does Judaism [04:30] and specifically Jewish mysticism [04:32] view women and men as the same? [04:34] >> No. [04:37] >> [laughter] [04:38] >> Why would we be the same? [04:40] Same is not a virtue. [04:44] There are [04:45] you know, special talents that women [04:48] have men can only be envious of. [04:51] And there are certain obligations, [04:53] mitzvahs, that men have that women are [04:55] envious of. [04:56] Not the same. [04:58] >> So, what's the biggest obstacle to [04:59] living a more spiritual life? [05:03] >> The assumption that life is meant for [05:05] me. [05:07] My life [05:09] meant for me. [05:11] No. [05:12] That is the beginning of narcissism. [05:16] We were created to be of service. [05:20] Not to tend to ourselves. [05:22] Doesn't make any sense. [05:24] I'm going to create you with problems. [05:26] See how See how well you do. What kind [05:28] of What kind of plan is that? [05:31] I'll give you needs and and and [05:33] obstacles and uh we'll see how you [05:35] handle it. What What is this? [05:37] >> So, why did God create the world? [05:38] >> For his purpose. [05:40] We serve his purpose. [05:44] And that's the way any relationship [05:46] should really be. You're never in a [05:48] relationship for yourself. [05:51] That's horrible. [05:54] So, seeing ourselves in the context of a [05:56] relationship, everything makes sense. [05:59] Otherwise, life itself doesn't make any [06:01] sense. [06:03] >> And then [06:03] >> And then I don't need this. [06:05] I don't need this. [06:06] >> [laughter] [06:07] >> So then where do we sit in that [06:08] relationship in terms of free will? Does [06:10] it exist? [06:11] >> Yes. [06:13] Otherwise, it's not a relationship [06:14] again. [06:16] And you just you just talking to [06:17] himself. [06:19] Only with free will can there be a [06:21] relationship. [06:23] >> And [06:24] it's all leading towards somewhere. We [06:26] talk about Messiah. What is Messiah? [06:30] >> Well, the ultimate purpose of all of [06:32] creation is to achieve a complete and [06:34] total oneness. [06:38] A unified existence. [06:42] Unholiness means [06:45] fractured, [06:48] uh separated, [06:51] which always leads to conflict. [06:53] So, the ultimate goal is the oneness. [06:57] Hashem Echad doesn't mean there's one [06:59] God. [07:01] It means God is all about oneness. [07:04] And as long as there isn't a total [07:06] oneness, [07:08] it's it's not comfortable, it's not [07:10] godly, it's not holy. [07:13] Like, what happens after 60 years of [07:15] marriage? [07:17] You're still trying to get each other's [07:18] attention? [07:21] Or are you just there? You've arrived. [07:24] You've merged. [07:28] Now you're too old to enjoy it. [07:29] >> [laughter] [07:33] >> Is is is the state of Israel on the path [07:35] towards Messiah? Is this part of the [07:37] final redemption? [07:38] >> We're all on that path. [07:41] It's a strange path, isn't it? [07:44] How this leads to good stuff, I don't [07:47] know, but it definitely is leading to a [07:49] grand conclusion [07:52] that will make up for all the pain. [07:54] >> So, many of your students are Jewish and [07:57] not Jewish. On a level of humanity, you [07:59] hear from so many people around the [08:00] world. What do you feel is the greatest [08:02] challenge facing the world today? [08:06] >> Ignorance. [08:09] Ignorance [08:10] Ignorance of the most basic fundamental [08:15] realities. Like we don't know what a [08:17] woman is. [08:18] How did How did we get so far from truth [08:22] and reality? [08:24] Like we fought our way out of [08:29] normality. [08:31] It's It's horrible. [08:33] What do we know? I mean, we [08:35] Why are we here? I don't know. [08:37] How did the world get to be here? Well, [08:38] we don't know. [08:40] What do you know? [08:42] I mean, these are such fundamental [08:43] questions. If you don't know this, [08:45] what's the difference what else you [08:46] know? You know how to get to the moon? [08:49] >> [laughter] [08:49] >> Great. [08:51] You don't know why you're on Earth, but [08:52] you know how to get to the moon. [08:54] >> [laughter] [08:56] >> So, what do you tell these people? How [08:57] do we deal with this issue? [08:59] >> That That's what the Torah is all about. [09:02] The whole point of Torah is God gathered [09:04] us at Mount Sinai and said, "I'm I'm [09:07] sure you're wondering [09:09] >> Why we here? [09:10] >> Why I created you and why you're going [09:13] through all of this? Well, let me tell [09:14] you. [09:15] This is my plan. This is what I need. I [09:18] need you to help me. I need you to [09:19] partner with me [09:21] and turn the world into [09:23] a godly unified place." [09:27] >> And [09:28] how is modernity changed Jewish [09:30] mysticism? Is it different today? [09:34] >> On the one hand, it made it much worse [09:36] because the splintering and the and the [09:39] the conflicts and the frictions between [09:42] people and nations and it's just [09:44] horrible. Probably because we don't even [09:46] know where we're going, so we're [09:47] stepping on each other. [09:49] On the other hand, [09:51] it provided communication [09:54] abilities. You can talk to the world. [09:59] When I started, [10:00] when you know, as a shliach of the Rebbe [10:02] to Minnesota, if I got 12 students, I [10:05] thought I was so successful. [10:10] Cuz I started off with two. [10:12] I reached 12, I thought, "Wow!" [10:15] Now, I'm talking to 80 million people [10:19] and [10:20] it's nothing. [10:22] Drop in the bucket. [10:25] >> You don't even connect with them all. [10:28] >> 8 billion. [10:30] >> Well. [10:31] How does Jewish mysticism differentiate [10:34] from other forms of mysticism? What [10:35] makes it unique? [10:38] >> Well, first of all, it's God's [10:40] mysticism, [10:41] not human mysticism. [10:45] It's not anyone's theory. [10:48] It is a part of the Torah. [10:50] At Mount Sinai, God revealed Torah in [10:52] four dimensions. [10:55] One of them is the mystical. [10:58] But that was kept private, [11:00] taught only to select [11:02] among the the scholars. [11:05] They had [11:07] very select individuals who were taught [11:09] one-on-one, never in a class, [11:13] until it was written down as the Zohar. [11:16] And then the Ari, 400 years ago, made it [11:19] public. [11:20] And then Hasidus made it understandable. [11:24] >> So, why why was it allowed to be [11:25] changed? Why can this generation be [11:28] studying to this level, whereas at the [11:30] beginning it was more kept, as its name [11:32] is implied, sort more secretive? [11:35] >> The more private and the more personal [11:37] something is, [11:39] the [11:43] the more selective you are who you want [11:45] to share it with. [11:47] But after [11:48] 3,000 years of serving God under [11:52] impossible circumstances, [11:55] we're ready. [11:57] We're ready to move on to something a [11:58] little more personal. [12:00] And when people hear it, [12:02] I I can't describe the the power. [12:07] Like people use expressions like [12:09] "Wow! [12:11] Now I can breathe. [12:13] It's like oxygen. [12:16] When you realize there's a relationship [12:18] going on, [12:20] everything falls into place. [12:23] So that's why I'm here. That's why God [12:25] created the world. That's why he gave us [12:26] the Torah. That's why we have all these [12:28] commandments. [12:30] That's why the world needs [12:32] Yeah, now everything makes sense. [12:34] >> That's why it's called revelation. [12:36] Reveals everything. [12:37] >> It's amazing. [12:39] >> So does one need to be religious to [12:40] study it? [12:42] >> Not at all. [12:43] Religion is part of the problem. [12:46] >> What do you mean? [12:48] >> Religion just [12:51] probably didn't mean to do it, but [12:53] in the end religion makes you [12:55] self-conscious. [12:57] And that's exactly what we need to get [12:59] away from. [13:01] Am I good? [13:02] Am I holy now? [13:04] Am I a saint? Not a saint? Almost a [13:06] saint? [13:08] Total distraction in a relationship [13:10] that's poison. [13:13] So am I a good husband? I'm a good [13:14] husband, right? I'm a good husband? [13:16] Yeah, yeah, yeah, a lousy husband. [13:19] Why aren't you thinking about your wife? [13:21] Then you would be a good husband. [13:24] So if you're thinking, am I holy? Am I [13:25] religious? Am I super religious? Am I [13:27] the best? Am I the [13:29] You're missing the whole point. [13:32] And religion does that. It makes you [13:33] very self-conscious. [13:37] It's not supposed to. [13:40] >> So how do we liberate ourselves from the [13:42] constructs of the negativity that you're [13:44] saying some religion can bring? [13:46] >> Well, I think in from the negative we [13:48] can get to the positive. [13:50] We've descended into such a horrible [13:53] narcissism [13:55] that we're horrified [13:57] by our own lowness. [14:00] Narcissist? [14:02] That's really sick. [14:04] And now we we want to run the other way. [14:06] Just get me out of this narcissism. [14:09] So well, I'll help you become a better [14:10] person. No, don't do that. [14:13] I don't want to be a better person. [14:15] I want to get past myself. [14:18] Tell me something more important than [14:20] me. [14:21] Cuz if you start with me, [14:24] I'll be a narcissist. [14:27] >> So, can it can it ever be dangerous [14:29] Kabbalah Hasidut Jewish mysticism? [14:33] >> I don't think it can be dangerous, but [14:35] it can be very [14:37] misunderstood, [14:39] can easily be corrupted. [14:44] You can use that to become [14:45] self-conscious. [14:47] Am I mystical now? [14:49] That's not the point. [14:50] >> So, what does one do to protect [14:51] themselves from that or [14:53] >> Focus on the other. [14:56] Focus on the other. It's not how well [14:59] you serve, it's who you're serving. [15:03] >> And how does this in your personal life [15:06] apply in your in relationships? [15:08] You're teaching out there to so many [15:10] people. Do you feel like it's also [15:11] influenced the inner [15:13] in with your children, with your spouse, [15:15] with your students, with colleagues? Are [15:18] there any particular relationships where [15:20] you see this expressed? [15:23] >> It has kept me out of trouble. [15:26] I don't have time to focus on myself, [15:28] otherwise I probably would. [15:31] So, it's a blessing. [15:32] >> So, is there an example of it like with [15:35] a child or with a friend [15:37] or with a student that you can [15:40] give an example of how this has really [15:42] imbued your relationship or made it more [15:44] meaningful? [15:44] >> Well, you look at a child [15:46] and you say, [15:48] "What is wrong with these people? [15:52] Why do they make a big deal out of [15:53] nothing? [15:54] Why can't they grow up?" [15:56] And then you realize you haven't grown [15:58] up either. You're just more articulate [16:03] because you do the same thing. I want, I [16:05] don't want, I like, I don't like, but [16:08] the kid is up front about it. [16:11] And you're trying to be sophisticated, [16:13] but you're doing the same thing. [16:16] So, what do you want for the child? You [16:18] want the child to stop thinking only [16:20] about itself. [16:22] Himself or herself. [16:24] Think about someone else. You're not the [16:26] only one in the room. [16:27] Don't scream and cry because you're in a [16:29] bad mood. There are people here. You're [16:31] disturbing them. [16:32] You don't have to think about that. [16:34] That's a child. [16:37] So, moving from self-aware, which you [16:39] were born self-aware, [16:42] moving from that to aware of others, [16:47] that's maturity. That's sanity. That's [16:49] That's service. [16:51] It's everything. [16:53] So, it it keeps reminding you. [16:56] Stop thinking about yourself. [16:58] And in many, many instances, [17:01] the one conversation I dread, [17:04] the ones I'm just not in the mood. Not [17:06] now. I don't They turn out to be the [17:08] best. [17:11] Just to remind you. [17:13] >> So, what advice would you give? Like, [17:15] what do you think is really important to [17:16] tell a parent in parenting their child? [17:19] Is there sort of a Obviously, there's a [17:21] lot to say, but is there a key message [17:22] that one should keep in mind? [17:24] >> a lot of wisdom involved in weaning a [17:27] child away from [17:29] himself [17:32] without hurting, [17:34] without crushing, without damaging. [17:38] But, the point is [17:41] it's not about you. [17:43] How do you convey that to a child? [17:45] We actually do this unconsciously. You [17:47] say, "Time to go to bed." The kid says, [17:50] "I don't want to." [17:52] You say, [17:53] "But, it's time." [17:55] See, the butt [17:57] is like weaning. Yes, you don't want to, [18:01] but [18:03] What does that mean? [18:04] It means there's something else to [18:05] consider. [18:07] The fact that you don't want to is not [18:09] the end of the story. [18:11] But, [18:13] if a father tells you to do something, [18:15] you're supposed to do it. But, it is [18:18] your bedtime. This is when you go to [18:20] sleep every night. But, right? [18:23] So, without hurting the child, you're [18:25] actually saying "Yeah, but." [18:29] You're in the mood, you're not in the [18:30] mood, but there's something more [18:32] important than that. [18:34] >> If If we flip flip the relationship, [18:38] um you've given beautiful advice for [18:40] what a parent needs to do with a child, [18:42] what advice would you give a child [18:43] towards a parent to be a better son [18:45] daughter at any range of ages? [18:49] >> Be patient. Your parents will grow up. [18:53] >> [laughter] [18:55] >> The same thing. [18:58] The same thing you say to parents. [19:00] The child will grow up, be patient. [19:03] We all We all grow. [19:06] >> Even the parents. [19:08] What about spouses, a husband, a wife? [19:11] What advice do you give in that [19:12] relationship? [19:13] >> Definitely grow. [19:15] The idea that once you're married, [19:16] you're done. [19:18] Not you're done, you're starting. [19:20] Like, "Oh, we're married now. We don't [19:22] have to be nice." [19:24] Kind of ridiculous attitude is that? [19:28] Marriage is a challenge. [19:31] How [19:34] noble can you be? [19:37] How much patience can you have? [19:39] How much tolerance can you have? [19:42] How much flexibility are you capable of? [19:46] Every virtue in the world, you're going [19:48] to need it. [19:50] Use it. [19:54] >> And um you know, we talked about [19:56] practical advice with these [19:57] relationships and theological questions, [20:00] free will, God, why God created the [20:01] world, [20:02] and how that's informed by the beautiful [20:04] teachings of Jewish mysticism. I'd love [20:06] to end this conversation with you just [20:08] sharing a Jewish mystical teaching. [20:10] What's something that inspires you or [20:13] you know, just might be top of mind at [20:14] the moment to share with us. [20:17] >> Just the idea that in a relationship, [20:21] your behavior is more important than [20:24] your intentions. [20:27] Good intentions don't make good [20:29] relationships. [20:32] I mean you you hear couples getting [20:34] divorced and they're sobbing, they're [20:36] crying on it. I know you meant well, but [20:38] I just can't live with you because the [20:40] way you behave. [20:43] I know you didn't mean to hurt me, but [20:44] you kept hurting me. [20:47] So, good intentions [20:51] in our relationship with God, the [20:53] commandments [20:55] are [20:57] primary. [20:59] If God says this pleases me [21:02] and you ignore that, [21:04] no matter what your intention or reason [21:06] is, you blew it. [21:10] So, the notion that we can do without [21:12] the commandments, [21:14] that's like you can be married without [21:16] hearing your wife. [21:18] No, you can't. [21:21] God reveals himself and he's very open. [21:24] You know, if we could be as open with [21:27] each other as God is with us, [21:29] we wouldn't need therapy. [21:32] He even tells us that he can't stand the [21:34] thought of eating bugs. [21:37] Makes him [21:38] nauseous. [21:41] What a confession for a God. Like, [21:43] really? [21:45] You're the creator of the whole world [21:47] >> [laughter] [21:48] >> and you're not ashamed to say that the [21:50] thought of eating a bug makes you [21:53] it's abominable to you. [21:55] Wow. [21:57] So, we need to be open. The mitzvahs are [22:00] God are [22:02] God's way of telling himself. [22:05] This pleases me, this doesn't please me. [22:08] This pleases me very much and this [22:10] pleases me very little and this gets me [22:13] very angry. [22:15] And I can get angry and I can get [22:17] angrier. [22:18] He's so open. [22:21] And then in the end he says, no matter [22:23] how angry, no matter how loving, [22:26] we are going to be together. [22:30] That is not negotiable. [22:33] >> [sighs and gasps] [22:34] >> So, in the relationship with God, the [22:38] action is more important than the [22:40] intention. [22:41] Cuz the intention is just a [22:44] degree of your [22:48] maturity, of your wisdom. [22:51] It doesn't connect you to him. [22:54] Smart people don't always make good [22:56] spouses [22:57] cuz they're too busy with their own [22:58] thoughts, with their own [23:03] Like this couple who are having trouble [23:04] and the husband says to me one day, [23:07] "You know, I think things are going to [23:07] get a lot better because I I I figured [23:10] her out." I said, "Oh, no. [23:13] Now [laughter] she's in trouble." [23:16] You figured her out. [23:19] Mhm. [23:22] This is so romantic. [23:24] >> [laughter] [23:25] >> But, if you're so in tune that you know [23:28] what she's going to want in 5 minutes [23:30] from now, [23:32] now you're talking. [23:34] That's connection. That's [23:36] a relationship. [23:38] But, you figured her out. [23:43] So, when people say, "I can't figure God [23:45] out." [23:48] You can't figure yourself out. What did [23:49] you think you're going to figure out? [23:53] But, you know exactly what pleases him. [23:56] Do it. [23:58] And what am I going to get for that? [24:00] Nothing. [24:02] You're doing it for him. [24:04] The question reveals that your thinking [24:06] is all wrong. [24:08] So, will I go to heaven? [24:10] No, you're not going to heaven. [24:14] Uh, you want to do what he created you [24:16] for or not? [24:18] Stop making deals with him. [24:20] If I do this, you do that, we'll work it [24:22] out. [24:26] That is narcissism. [24:32] So, a world united means everything and [24:36] everyone is serving the purpose for [24:39] which it was designed. [24:41] Jews are being Jewish, human beings are [24:44] being human, animals are being animals, [24:47] minerals are minerals, everything is [24:50] doing exactly what God intended for it [24:53] to do. [24:57] That is a universe. [25:03] That isn't tearing itself apart. [25:07] >> Wow. [25:09] It starts with the awareness of what our [25:10] purpose is and then it's just about [25:12] fulfilling it. [25:13] >> And that's so universal. Everything has [25:15] a purpose. [25:17] And you don't make it up. [25:19] You're created to that purpose. [25:22] So, it should be the easiest thing in [25:24] the world. [25:25] It's what you're designed for. [25:27] How can that not feel [25:29] comfortable? How can that not resonate? [25:34] >> Wow. [25:36] Well, Rabbi, [25:37] um this is such an incredible [25:39] conversation. [25:40] Um on two levels. Number one, to be able [25:42] to package such deep wisdom, which I [25:45] know you can speak hours about each of [25:47] these questions, [25:48] in such a concise way and yet for it to [25:51] be so profound. [25:53] And second of all, because [25:56] I feel like you are one that does what [25:59] you're meant to do. [26:00] And you're in tune with that sense of [26:02] what my purpose is here and you're [26:03] giving that over. And I think that is [26:05] the message that you're really saying, [26:08] whether it applies to our children, to [26:11] our spouses, to our friends, to our [26:12] congregates, and ultimately to ourselves [26:15] and of course to God. So, we give you [26:17] our blessing that you can continue to [26:18] inspire so many others and to keep [26:21] achieving your purpose to help us find [26:22] our own. [26:24] >> Amen to that. [26:25] >> Thank you so much. [26:41] >> Mhm.