Transcript [00:00] Look, as we can see the conflict between [00:02] the Palestinians and the Israelis, [00:05] you know, I'm outside of it, right? As a [00:08] Kurd, but when I see um [00:11] what do you think about uh do you do you [00:14] believe that the the the Israeli force, [00:16] the Israeli uh regime or or government [00:20] treating Palestinians bad? Do do you [00:22] believe that they have treating them bad [00:25] or do you think that they have been [00:26] treating them justly? [00:27] >> treat them I think they treat them [00:29] better than any other Muslim country has [00:32] ever or would ever treat them. They give [00:34] them more grace and more opportunities [00:36] to save their own lives than any other [00:38] country in the region. [00:39] >> How are you doing, Tal? [00:41] >> Good, habibi. How are you, brother? [00:42] >> Mr. Bob, I hope everything is good with [00:44] you too. [00:45] >> I'm blessed. Yeah, thank you. [00:46] >> Okay, great. I'm Kurdish, actually. I'm [00:48] Kurdish from Iraq. I'm from Kurdistan. [00:51] Um [00:53] as as as probably you know that we Kurds [00:56] together with with Jewish communities, [00:58] we had a very good relationship in our [01:00] home homeland before uh [01:03] uh the Jews were [01:05] kicked out from the land. [01:07] >> Yes. [01:07] >> Uh I have stories from my grandparents, [01:10] you know, they told me that we lived [01:12] side by side and it wasn't it it you [01:14] know um we didn't have any kind of [01:17] issues, you know, they saw themselves as [01:19] Kurds and the Jews [01:21] who lived in Kurdistan have been in [01:24] these lands since back in the time when [01:26] the Assyrians and Babylonians took them. [01:28] You know the story. [01:30] >> Half of my family half of my family is [01:32] that Assyrian Jewish community. So I am [01:35] very familiar. I have a grandfather [01:36] great-grandfather who lived in [01:37] Kurdistan. [01:39] >> Yes, that's and and you know I'm a very [01:41] curious person, you know, I'm I'm I'm [01:43] trying to you know see and listen and [01:45] try to hear from different you know [01:47] mouths and and stories and I have been [01:49] listening to documentaries. As as far as [01:52] I know, the Jews lived in peace side by [01:55] side with the Kurds and we know that the [01:57] Kurds have always been Muslims, [02:00] the majority of them, you know. [02:02] And we didn't have any kind of issues. [02:04] And it doesn't matter if you you you [02:06] have if you were Christians, if you were [02:09] a Christian or a Jew or or or probably [02:12] a non-believer. [02:14] We Kurds have never ever [02:16] had any issues with people [02:18] where they came from. Yes, we had some [02:20] political issues back in the early 1900s [02:23] together with some Christian groups and [02:25] the Britons, they came and they came to [02:27] try to colonize our lands back in the [02:30] the imperialist time from the British [02:32] people when Sheikh Mahmoud Barzinji were [02:34] fighting against them until the '50s [02:37] when he was exiled from his own land, [02:39] for example. We know when the Brits [02:41] came, they tried to change [02:44] our [02:45] kind of living, right? And they even [02:48] created like [02:50] newspapers in Kurdistan called [02:54] And [02:55] means modern new thought. [02:58] Be modern. They they believed that the [03:00] Kurds was backwards, okay? So they came [03:04] us and they divided us and a lot of [03:05] issues created after that. They they [03:08] they they came they they brought a king [03:10] from Saudi Arabia and and and they put [03:12] it and created Iraq after that, you [03:14] know. Since then the Kurdish issue has [03:16] always [03:17] been [03:18] difficult back in that time. But if if [03:21] we go back to to to to to the [03:23] relationship between the Kurds and and [03:25] and the Jews, [03:26] as far as I know, as far as I have been [03:29] listening to our elders, we didn't have [03:31] any kind of issues. So my question to [03:34] you, Mr. Tal, [03:36] do you believe that Kurds should have [03:38] their own state? [03:40] >> Absolutely. [03:42] >> Do you believe that the Kurds are [03:43] indigenous to that land? [03:46] >> Absolutely. [03:47] >> Okay, what about the Assyrians? [03:50] >> I believe they're also indigenous to the [03:51] land. [03:52] >> But Assyrians think that these lands we [03:55] Kurds live in [03:57] belongs to them, for example. [03:59] >> Well, so so do the so do the Iraqis, so [04:02] do the Persians, so do the Armenians, so [04:04] do the Azerbaijanis, so do the Turkish. [04:08] The the Kurdistan or what will be [04:11] proposed as Kurdistan in the future [04:13] encompasses I mean I've looked at a map [04:15] of greater Kurdistan in the same way [04:17] that I looked at a map of greater Iran, [04:18] greater Armenia, greater Azerbaijan, [04:21] greater Turkey. [04:22] All of these countries have a claim [04:24] that's way bigger than the actual [04:25] borders today. So [04:29] you know there's a conflict of interest [04:30] there, but I believe that [04:32] self-determination [04:34] for all the non-Muslim groups in the [04:36] Middle East plus the Kurds because you [04:39] guys are the only Muslim group in the [04:41] Middle East I believe that really needs [04:43] a state right now. [04:44] But [04:45] the all the non-Muslim groups plus the [04:48] Kurds is imperative. It is super [04:52] important to knock down the borders or [04:55] to minimize or reduce the [04:57] terrestrial control that many of these [04:59] Islamist groups and nations have to [05:02] humble them in my opinion. [05:06] The more land that Kurdistan, Assyrians, [05:09] Chaldeans, [05:13] Amazigh, Yazidis, [05:16] Maronites in Lebanon, [05:20] the Druze, the Alawi, the more lands [05:23] that each one of these groups attains as [05:25] their own independent state in my [05:26] opinion is actually better for the [05:28] entire region. [05:29] >> I got you. So you believe in like like [05:33] divine Iraq and Syria for example or [05:36] Turkey [05:37] to give the ethnic groups who lived in [05:39] these lands give them a part of their [05:42] lands [05:42] >> alert from Gaza. [05:45] Sorry there was just a rocket fired I [05:46] guess from Gaza. [05:48] Um yes. I do I do believe in an element [05:51] I know this is probably not going to go [05:52] down well with many Iraqis, but I I [05:54] think [05:56] I don't know with the solution with [05:57] Kurdistan I really don't know what is [05:59] the right idea because I've spoken to [06:02] Kurdish people in Iran who both are pro [06:04] and against the Kurdish state, and I've [06:06] spoken to Kurdish people in Iraq that [06:08] are both pro a Kurdish state in both [06:10] places. So I don't I don't are like both [06:12] pro and against. I don't know what the [06:14] exact land needs to be. don't know if it [06:16] needs to be a larger portion of Iran or [06:18] a larger portion of Iraq or a smaller [06:20] portion of both. I don't know what it [06:22] needs to be, but I know for a fact the [06:24] idea of a Kurdish state is something I [06:26] support. Like 100% the idea of it in the [06:29] land that they believe is theirs, in the [06:31] land where they populate most the [06:33] majority. To me probably what we look at [06:35] is the the Iraqi Kurdistan, the Erbil [06:38] and [06:39] and Mosul and all the areas in the north [06:42] makes more sense, [06:43] right? Because it's already like [06:45] culturally and economically functioning [06:48] as a state. [06:49] But I don't really I don't know the [06:51] solution for it to be honest with you. [06:52] >> I got you. I got you. You know the [06:54] Kurdish cause [06:56] I'm sorry Tom. [snorts] The Kurdish [06:58] cause [06:59] it's [07:00] if if you see the issue of the Kurdish [07:02] issue, [07:03] it's beyond 200 years old. [07:06] Beyond. It's back in the Ottoman [07:08] Empires, back in these times, you know, [07:10] you know, 18 1880, for example, you [07:13] know, we have we have struggled against [07:16] um [07:18] uh forces who have unjustly, you know, [07:21] uh treated the Kurds, you know, [07:23] especially especially where we come [07:25] from. But when you say that I don't know [07:27] if the the bigger part is in Iran or [07:29] Iraq, actually we Kurds we are [07:33] we are in four countries. We are in [07:35] Syria. [07:36] We the the the majority is in Turkey, [07:39] for example. Uh [07:41] so we are about 35 to 40 million people [07:44] and we have always been living these [07:46] lands. And I'm you know, unfortunately [07:49] we have some forces uh [07:52] like speaking about that Kurds should [07:54] have been, you know, in these lands for [07:56] about 500 years ago. They have been [07:59] came from Iran and occupying these lands [08:01] and that's not true because we Kurds [08:05] when we study uh [08:07] you know, our ancestry back in the time [08:09] we we we we get connected all the way to [08:11] the Median Empire and Median Empire [08:14] everybody knows especially you you Jews [08:17] you have it in in your scriptures when [08:19] the Medians together with the Persians [08:21] and the Assyrians [08:22] >> While I appreciate I appreciate your [08:24] your your perspective so much I the [08:27] reason why I I'm not so knowledgeable on [08:30] Kurdistan and it's honestly not like my [08:32] forte it's part of the reason why I [08:34] don't [08:35] you know I I'm just trying to have a [08:36] show about specifically when it comes to [08:38] Zionism [08:38] >> But can I can I ask you another question [08:40] let us speak about something you know [08:42] about okay [08:43] >> And then let's do Joe next but go ahead [08:44] go ahead we'll do Joe next [08:45] >> sorry if you don't have enough time I [08:47] can come another time [08:48] >> We can do it we can do it quickly let's [08:49] do it quickly [08:50] >> All right all right look as we can see [08:53] the conflict between the Palestinians [08:54] and the and the Israelis [08:57] you know I'm outside of it right as a [08:59] Kurd but when I see [09:03] what do you think about do you do you [09:05] believe that the the the Israeli force [09:07] the Israeli [09:09] regime or or government treating [09:12] Palestinians bad do do you believe that [09:14] they have treating them bad or do you [09:16] think that they have been treating them [09:18] justly [09:19] >> they treat them I think they treat them [09:20] better than any other Muslim country has [09:23] ever or whatever treat them [09:25] They give them more grace and more [09:26] opportunities to save their own lives [09:28] than any other country in the region [09:31] >> But when you say other countries why [09:33] should other countries intervene when [09:36] >> the Jews [09:39] What a surprise a Pakistani came on and [09:41] said [ __ ] the Jews we're shocked [09:47] >> Why should other [09:48] countries yes they are probably same [09:51] people right they are Arabs all of them [09:53] probably you you as a Jew will believe [09:55] that why don't you help them but the [09:57] thing is the thing [09:59] >> They're not Arabs [10:00] Palestinians [10:02] Palestinians are Jews [10:04] Most Palestinians [10:05] >> that they are Jews from the beginning [10:07] >> Yes most most of them are factually [10:09] Most Palestinians come from Judea and [10:11] Samaria. Most of them were Christian a [10:13] couple generations ago and before that [10:15] they were Jewish. [10:17] >> A lot of Nabataeans were in that area [10:19] around the Levant and Jordan and Arabia, [10:21] so. [10:22] >> But but when you check the DNA of most [10:24] Palestinians living in the West Bank, [10:26] most of them are actually ethnically [10:28] Jewish. There are a few Kurdish groups, [10:30] there's a few Bosnian groups, there's a [10:31] few Baghdadi groups. There's a few the [10:33] ones from Gaza are almost completely [10:36] unconnected to the land. Most of them [10:38] are Egyptian or North African. The ones [10:40] in the Galilee and the Golan most of [10:42] them are connected to the land. They're [10:44] Levantine, Canaanite, Samaritan, Semitic [10:46] DNA, almost all of them. So I recognize [10:48] them as local to the land. I just don't [10:50] believe in Palestine as an identity. [10:54] >> I got you. But for example, today as we [10:56] see [10:58] those who live in Gaza, for example, [11:00] what kind of solution do you have as a [11:02] Jew for them? [11:04] >> I don't have a good solution for them [11:05] other than subjugation at this point. [11:07] I think the only thing that can help [11:09] them in their situation is for like [11:11] literally wave the white flag and accept [11:13] being ruled over by Israel. That's it. [11:15] Other than that, if they keep fighting [11:16] us forever, we're going to keep winning. [11:18] Like and I'm I'm afraid for them in the [11:20] future that at some point there might [11:22] actually be like right now everyone's [11:23] screaming genocide, genocide, genocide, [11:26] but their population [11:28] literally increased by almost 100,000 [11:30] people during said genocide. [11:32] I'm actually afraid for them that in the [11:33] future if they keep doing this, if they [11:35] keep up this disgusting behavior for 30 [11:37] more years, maybe there will be a Prime [11:39] Minister in 30 years that had to endure [11:42] the October 7th genocide the actual [11:44] genocide on October 7th that had to [11:46] endure the attacks and see everything. [11:48] In 30 years, 40 years there's going to [11:50] be a Prime Minister that's super PTSD [11:52] that remembers everything like it was [11:54] yesterday and is just going to go on a [11:56] rampage. So I don't I think they need to [11:59] just give up. They need to surrender. [12:02] >> In in how? In what way? [12:05] >> Wave the white flag, disarm completely [12:08] and accept living under Israel. [12:11] >> But what about the people That those who [12:13] who who isn't [12:15] um [12:16] how do you say? Those who doesn't carry [12:18] weapon. [12:20] I know which group you mean, right? But [12:22] what about the civilians? Do you believe [12:24] that there are civilians who are living [12:26] in that land? [12:27] >> Yes, of course. [12:28] >> Okay, do you want them to wave the white [12:30] flag too? [12:31] >> Yes. [12:33] >> But what have they done? [12:35] >> They're they're civil they're civilians [12:37] inside of a that's what happens when you [12:39] it's not just the army that waves the [12:41] white flag. The the entire strip needs [12:44] to be uh subjugated completely to [12:47] Israel. [12:51] >> Okay, I understand you Tal uh but you [12:54] know [12:55] as I can see here they have [12:57] they have nothing left to do actually. [13:00] I'm speaking about the civilian. I'm not [13:01] talking about the the the those who are [13:03] carrying weapon. I don't I don't want to [13:04] you know speak about uh them. I speak [13:07] about what I see in television. Probably [13:09] [clears throat] [13:09] you will say hey you you are watching AI [13:11] stuff and you are this guy that [13:14] >> I I I'm just trying to understand your [13:15] point. [13:16] >> But the point is what I'm trying to say [13:20] my brother is that [13:21] you have a lot of people who live in [13:24] Gaza [13:25] uh who try who probably been forced by [13:30] uh [13:31] these groups who have [13:33] who live in the same land as them for [13:35] example. They are fighting you guys and [13:38] when you strike them back you strike the [13:40] civilians. For example [13:42] what would happen if um [13:46] let us say [13:48] an an embassy in Europe, let us say an [13:51] American embassy will will will [13:54] will get how do you say uh [13:57] some group will [13:58] came come in and with weapon or some [14:00] something like that. Do you believe that [14:03] the the the country from that land will [14:05] strike a bomb on embassy or do you [14:07] believe that they will send some SWAT [14:08] group to to to to rescue the civilians [14:11] and to take uh [14:13] the terrorists? What what what what what [14:15] what would you think? Do you think that [14:16] they will, you know, [14:18] totally demolish the [14:19] >> an argument. [14:20] You're making an argument that Israel [14:23] didn't send in the SWAT teams to Gaza. [14:31] Every every single one of my friends was [14:33] in Gaza. Every one of my friends. [14:35] Every one of my I could send you pages [14:36] of influencers right now who are on the [14:38] ground in Gaza. I have a friend who was [14:40] in Gaza for nine months straight. He got [14:43] out every week or he got out every two [14:45] every two months for like two weeks. He [14:47] lived in Gaza for the last two years. [14:49] Lived in Gaza. He's a good guy. He's a [14:51] great guy. He's one of my closest [14:53] friends. [14:54] >> Was he a civilian or a soldier? [14:57] >> No, he's a soldier. [14:58] >> Okay. [14:59] >> We we have sent in an endless amount of [15:01] soldiers into Gaza on the ground. [15:03] Endless amount. [15:05] >> To rescue those who have been kidnapped, [15:08] right? [15:09] >> And and to fight Hamas. [15:11] >> I got you, but [15:13] I I totally [15:14] of course [15:16] I I I stand behind this kind of acts, of [15:19] course. [15:20] You know, if somebody gets kidnapped, [15:22] you have to go and rescue them and try [15:24] to minimize the damage as far as you [15:26] can, for example. But [15:28] >> don't even we don't even really need to [15:29] do that. We do that because we're a [15:31] moral army. But anyone in our [15:33] neighborhood would not do the same thing [15:34] as you know has occurred cuz they never [15:37] give you guys that kind of decency. So [15:39] we are doing something that is not and I [15:41] actually think in a lot of ways it's the [15:42] wrong thing to do because Arabs like you [15:45] know has occurred don't respect that. [15:47] They don't respect when you preserve [15:48] their life. They actually disrespect you [15:50] because they think that you're weak. [15:52] If we were to behave more like Arabs in [15:54] this fight, I actually think and [15:56] unfortunately that would mean that a lot [15:57] more Gazan civilians would be dead, a [15:59] lot more. But the reality is we don't [16:02] know how many Gazan civilians are dead. [16:04] We have no idea. We know how many have [16:06] reproduced. We do not know how many [16:08] Gazan civilians have been dead. In my [16:10] own independent research into the topic [16:11] and I could literally call myself an [16:13] expert at this point. It's all I've been [16:15] working on for three years. I've gotten [16:17] to the conclusion that maybe on a good [16:19] day, maybe 20,000 civilians have been [16:22] killed. That means like innocent men, [16:24] women, and children, maybe. Maybe on a [16:26] good day. Maybe. [16:29] But the the the the the the official IDF [16:33] accounts state that 50,000 [16:36] 50,000 Hamas militants have been killed. [16:39] And it's corroborated by a [ __ ] ton of [16:41] data. And you can look you can find it [16:43] all on the IDF. They have backed it up. [16:45] And I can I can quote you every single [16:47] they they quote so many different [16:49] commanders, platoons, and they know the [16:51] structure of Hamas so well [16:53] that they really say about 50,000 have [16:55] been killed. Hamas itself or the Gaza [16:57] Health Ministry corroborates 70 I think [16:59] it's 77,000. Bob, maybe you know. [17:01] Correct me if I'm wrong. It's 72 or [17:03] 77,000? [17:04] >> about 73 74,000. [17:06] >> 73 74,000 making zero differentiation [17:09] between woman, child, [17:11] on the children's list that were killed [17:13] Oh, sorry, on the women's list that were [17:15] killed. So [17:17] we we talk endlessly about this conflict [17:20] that [17:21] bro, 2 million people have died in [17:23] Sudan. [17:24] 500,000 of them are kids. No one bats an [17:27] eye. Not a Kurd, not an Israeli, not a [17:30] Muslim, not a Palestinian. No one gives [17:32] a [ __ ] [17:33] Know how many people were killed in [17:34] Tigray in Ethiopia? You know how many [17:36] people were killed there? [17:38] You know what kind of a genocide [17:39] unfolded recently? [17:42] Not even a fraction of what happened in [17:44] Israel Palestine even meets one week [17:46] there. [17:47] We don't talk about it. [17:48] >> Yeah, I know. Yeah, we I know. I I have [17:50] seen a lot of stuff. [17:52] >> Yemen 380,000 that situation's unfolding [17:54] today. [17:55] Sudan that situation is ongoing today. [17:58] We don't talk about it. We don't care. [18:00] >> Another interesting fact is the Gaza [18:02] Ministry of Health has also refused to [18:04] release a document which they did every [18:06] single year of how many people died from [18:07] natural causes. And so there's about 10 [18:10] to 15,000 natural deaths that are [18:11] unaccounted for [18:13] that are supposed to happen every year. [18:14] >> about that. I believe the the perfect [18:16] number that people landed on was 11,000. [18:18] So if you actually look at the if you [18:20] actually look at the data of what [18:21] happens and I studied it, I really [18:23] because of what I do for work, I can't [18:24] go around bullshitting people. I [18:26] actually had to study these topics and I [18:27] sat down having endless I mean I had an [18:29] hour long conversations with LLMs with [18:32] every single different LLM. I programmed [18:34] to do the deep deep thinking research on [18:36] the highest paid plan of Claude going [18:39] through all the data individually, every [18:40] single one and I know it's an LLM but [18:42] you know I I also I also researched this [18:44] in outside sources as well. You cannot [18:47] find a case for a genocide. You can't [18:49] even find a case for a [18:51] for a a disproportionate [18:54] response from Israel in Gaza. If you [18:57] look at the region as a whole, nothing [18:59] of even if you look at what Western [19:00] armies have done in the Middle East. [19:03] Talk about Italy, talk about the UK, [19:05] talk about America and Iraq. You can't [19:08] even find a claim to say it was [19:09] disproportionate. [19:10] It was totally proportional considering [19:13] the size of Gaza, their preparedness, [19:16] their population, [19:17] the fact that there was not a single [19:19] bomb shelter in Gaza on October 6th. [19:21] >> But Mr. Tal, Mr. [19:23] another question Mr. I got you. I [19:25] understand what you say. But do you for [19:27] example support that rescue groups like [19:31] sending them, you know [19:34] food and water and and and you know [19:36] clothes and this kind of do you support [19:39] that you know [19:41] groups outside of for example [19:44] from Europe or from other countries [19:46] send these kind of [19:48] stuff to to the civilians? Do you [19:51] support it or [19:53] do you believe that it's not a good idea [19:55] to help these kind of civilians who have [19:57] been living in Gaza for example? Do you [19:59] support that [20:01] like the Red Cross or or the Half Moon [20:04] and and these kind of organizations help [20:06] them [20:06] >> I support I support I support any [20:08] attempt to try to help civilian life. [20:11] The issue in Gaza has always been that [20:12] you can't actually help the civilians [20:14] without helping the terrorist group. So [20:16] if these Arabs, if these Arabs like [20:19] Egyptians for example weren't a a of [20:21] [ __ ] and actually stepped up to the [20:22] plate, open the border between Gaza and [20:25] Egypt, create a humanitarian zone inside [20:28] of Egypt, [20:29] and help save the civilians if they [20:32] actually cared. In Jordan. [20:34] >> can't interrupt if the Egyptians open [20:37] the border. [20:38] >> Of course, but they never do. [20:40] They charge them 10 they charge [20:42] Egyptians charge Israel 10th charge the [20:45] Palestinians $10,000 ahead to enter [20:48] Egypt, their brother. [20:49] >> what is their cause? Why don't they open [20:51] the the border? [20:53] >> Who? [20:54] >> Egyptians. [20:55] >> Cuz they hate them. You don't [20:57] understand, bro. Everyone hates the [20:58] Palestinian. Sorry, bro. Have you ever [21:00] met a Palestinian? [21:02] >> Yes, I do. I have. Yes. [21:04] >> You like the Palestinians? [21:05] >> As a person, yes, I do. I haven't any [21:07] kind of issue with them. [21:08] >> you're in the minority. Then you're in [21:10] the minority. And by the way, I'm in the [21:12] minority too. I love Palestinians. [21:15] But [21:15] >> Well, I have nothing against you you [21:18] too, my brother. [21:19] >> you talk to an Iraqi, if you talk to a [21:21] Egyptian, if you talk to a Jordanian, a [21:23] Lebanese, they hate the Palestinians. [21:26] They cannot stand the Palestinians. They [21:28] want them as far away as possible from [21:31] their countries. Why? [21:33] Because because they cause issues in [21:35] every single land they come into. [21:37] >> Is there something in their [21:38] personalities? [21:40] >> I think it's because they're Jews and [21:42] they're they have a massive identity [21:43] crisis and they don't know who they are. [21:45] That's my that's my personal opinion. [21:49] >> All right, Mr. Tal. [21:51] >> God bless you, [21:52] Nice to meet you. [21:53] >> you very much.