Transcript [00:00] Hello and welcome back to another [00:02] episode of culture matters. Today we are [00:05] going to discuss how Gotti Eisenot is [00:07] trying to push himself into power [00:09] despite not having a majority or in [00:12] other words Gotti Eisenhot is acting [00:15] like a tyrant. Let me explain what [00:18] Culture Matters is. Culture Matters is a [00:21] podcast discussing how we are [00:24] continuously influenced by the various [00:27] noises, sounds, the the the messages [00:30] around us. We don't even realize [00:32] sometimes what we're being told or why [00:34] we're why we're being told it. But what [00:37] those messages are doing, they're trying [00:38] to shape the way that we understand [00:41] reality and what is supposed to come [00:43] next. And so c if we say that politics [00:46] is downshifting from culture then in [00:48] fact culture matters. So let's get into [00:51] Gotti Isakat because we've talked about [00:53] Gotti Isakott before on this podcast and [00:56] we need to understand that Gottiott has [00:58] a major major problem on his hands. His [01:02] problem is that he does not have 61 [01:06] seats to appoint him as prime minister. [01:08] Now in Israeli elections, we should know [01:11] that the legislature and the executive [01:15] are separate but also combined, right? [01:18] The prime minister is a minister in the [01:21] government. He votes. [01:24] But what actually happens is that there [01:28] are two separate branches of the [01:29] government. The prime minister is [01:32] elected by 61 members of the Knesset. [01:36] And so what normally happens [01:39] after an election [01:41] is that [01:43] the person who the president thinks has [01:48] the easiest chance of the best chance, [01:52] not the easiest, but the best chance of [01:54] forming a government. He's given a [01:56] mandate to then negotiate with all the [01:58] parties and they agree on who's going to [02:00] be the defense minister and the foreign [02:02] minister and the the finance minister [02:04] and you know there are a whole bunch the [02:06] education minister there a whole bunch [02:08] and then sometimes they create [02:09] additional ministries just so other [02:11] parties and other members of the [02:13] Knessets can have this feeling of like [02:15] oh I'm a minister and now I'm important [02:18] and [02:20] that's like the regular horse training [02:21] that goes on here in Israel and [02:22] sometimes it's like gotten into the [02:24] mid20s in terms of the number of [02:25] ministers, whatever. That's not the [02:28] discussion for today. But generally [02:30] right after the candidate from the party [02:33] that receives the mandate to form a [02:35] government, what he does is he spends [02:38] all of his time [02:41] actually negotiating with his partners [02:44] and the people who are not yet inclined [02:46] to join him and trying to entice them to [02:49] join his coalition so that he can then [02:52] have 61 members of the Knesset vote him [02:55] in to become the prime minister, meaning [02:58] become the executive. [03:01] But Gotti Eisenhot is not doing that. If [03:04] you're paying attention to what Gotti [03:05] Isn't doing, Gotti Eisenhot is trying to [03:07] take control of the Kasset. What I mean [03:11] by that, he's trying to take control of [03:12] the legislature by having a new uh [03:16] speaker appointed by taking control of [03:19] certain committees, right? They they [03:20] just had some people appointed to the [03:22] arrangements committee, which actually [03:24] deci decides kind of like the law and [03:25] order within the Knesset. So it sounds [03:27] really boring, but it's actually like [03:29] the one that determines the agenda. And [03:31] if you determine the agenda, then you [03:33] determine what happens next, right? So [03:36] Gotti is is doing that, but he's not [03:40] spending his time trying to build a [03:43] coalition with his partners. To tell you [03:45] how unusual this is, we should notice [03:48] that literally up until this election, [03:53] the primary role for the person who was [03:56] given the mandate was to try and form a [04:01] majority coalition. That's what they [04:03] spent their time doing. [04:06] they worried less about who was the [04:08] speaker and who was in charge of the [04:09] committees because once they had the [04:12] coalition [04:13] all those issues were resolved so they [04:16] may have lost a few weeks let's say [04:18] right Gotti Eisenh is given uh 45 days [04:21] to form this coalition he can ask for an [04:23] a short twoe extension but after that if [04:24] he doesn't do it then it's given to [04:26] somebody else so Gotti Eisenot [04:30] is not spending his time trying to form [04:33] the coalition right and when you have [04:34] the coalition You decide all these [04:35] things, you lose a few weeks as to the [04:37] speaker, but nothing happens during that [04:39] time anyway. And you move on with your [04:40] lives. No one actually cares. It's a low [04:42] stakes decision. [04:44] But because Gaddy knows that he can't [04:47] form a coalition, [04:49] he's trying to get some legislation [04:52] passed anyway without ever becoming the [04:54] executive. Let's explain this. [04:58] So right now Gotti Eisenhot has mid 40 [05:03] number of seats of people who like truly [05:06] support him. He has his own party. He [05:09] has the bey party the together party [05:13] of Napali Bennett and your Iliped and he [05:16] has the Israeli Israel Betenu party of [05:20] Avdar Lieberman. But that gets him to [05:23] the mid-4s. He needs to get to 61. [05:28] And there's a major dispute within his [05:30] camp as to how he's going to get to 61. [05:36] On the one hand, Gaddy's preferred [05:38] approach is to get the Arab parties not [05:42] to join the coalition because they [05:44] won't, but to get the Arab parties to [05:49] vote him in as prime minister to remove [05:51] BB Netanyahu. They want to remove BB [05:53] Netanyahu, but then not really be part [05:55] of the coalition. not receive any kind [05:57] of ministries and plus it won't look [06:00] good for him amongst the Zionist voters [06:02] that he's relying so heavily on these [06:04] Arab parties. [06:06] So he that that's his preferred method [06:08] that will get him over 61. [06:11] But a Victor Lieberman does not want to [06:14] go down that path because that path was [06:16] tried already before under Napali [06:18] Bennett about four plus years ago and [06:23] Natali Bennett's government he was prime [06:25] minister but he lasted a total of one [06:26] year and the immediate aftermath of that [06:29] was that the right meaning BB Netanyahu [06:32] and Batalmotric and um Benvir [06:38] they won the most seats than they have [06:40] ever one and this has been this past [06:42] government has been the most right-wing [06:44] government that Israel has ever had. So [06:48] Victor Lieberman like you know we have a [06:50] saying in the Talmud who is someone who [06:52] is wise he who anticipates the future. [06:55] So a Victor Lieberman knows that relying [06:59] on the Arabs will [07:02] um might bring short-term benefit but [07:05] will be long term very detrimental in [07:08] the long term. So instead what Verd [07:09] Leman wants to do is he wants to create [07:12] a coalition with the ultraorththodox [07:14] parties. There are two ultraorththodox [07:16] parties. There's the Eastern European [07:19] ultraorththodox party called United [07:20] Torah Judaism and for them their main [07:23] issue is exemptions from the army. But [07:26] there's a second what's called an [07:28] ultraorththodox party but it's not [07:29] really an ultraorththodox party. That's [07:31] the party of Shas. Shashas represents [07:33] the Jews [07:36] who immigrated to Israel or descend from [07:40] people from North African and other [07:42] Middle Eastern countries. And so [07:47] shas they have some of their supporters [07:50] some of their voters are now [07:52] ultraorththodox [07:54] but many of the voters are regular [07:57] workingass or middle class or even upper [07:59] middle class people who just want the [08:04] sphartic the middle eastern and the the [08:08] north African heritage of Judaism to be [08:11] a strong presence within the state of [08:13] Israel. And so [08:16] the United Judaism party has expressed [08:19] uh a certain openness or willingness, [08:22] let's say, to follow along with the [08:23] Victor Lieberman's plan. But Shas has [08:26] thus far rejected. They said, "No, no, [08:28] we are part of the right-wing [08:29] government." Because if they join simply [08:32] because of army exemptions, they're not [08:36] going to be able to uh get future votes [08:40] because they're more uh yeshiva oriented [08:44] uh or ultraorththodox oriented voters [08:47] will vote for them, but they're regular [08:49] people who want a strong right-wing [08:51] government are no longer going to vote [08:52] for them. And Shas understands that and [08:54] they're going to lose votes in the next [08:56] election. [08:58] The other problem is that one of the [09:00] major issues on the left during this [09:02] election was getting rid of these [09:04] exemptions. Lieberman ran on this and [09:07] Gotti Eisenhot ran on this and Bennett [09:09] and Laid ran on this. They all ran on [09:12] this. And because they all ran on this, [09:14] to suddenly give that up and allow these [09:17] exemptions, this front coming from a [09:19] left-wing government means that not only [09:21] is it not going to happen in this [09:23] government, it's likely not going to [09:25] happen for any time in the near future. [09:29] Because whatever law is passed now can't [09:31] simply be challenged in the Supreme [09:33] Court because it's not a right-wing or [09:35] what the Supreme Court likes to do is [09:36] say it's a abnormal crazy right-wing [09:39] government doing this. It's going to be [09:41] a leftwing government doing it. And when [09:42] it's a leftwing government doing it, [09:44] then it's legit. So Gotti Isot [09:48] is in a real pickle. So he has a way of [09:51] getting out of that pickle. And the way [09:53] he wants to get out of that pickle is to [09:55] say that this is an emergency. [09:59] And this is a phrase that he has used [10:02] multiple times. Okay? Simply over the [10:06] last three days, he's used it at least [10:08] three times. And he used it before that [10:10] as well, probably at least [10:14] seven or eight times, if not more. [10:18] And the reason he's calling this an [10:20] emergency, because he said explicitly [10:22] that what he's trying to do is [10:24] unconventional and creative political [10:26] moves. Okay? Now, if you're someone who [10:30] pays attention to political language, [10:32] when a politician tells you they want to [10:34] do unconventional and and creative [10:36] political moves, you should be very very [10:39] scared [10:41] because what that means is that they are [10:43] not going to follow the regular rules [10:45] and procedures [10:47] of the way the country is supposed to [10:49] function. So, what Gotti Isot is hoping [10:51] he's trying to do two things. Number [10:53] one, [10:54] he's taking over the Knesset and he's [10:57] trying to at least pass legislation [11:00] so that he can rile up his base and say, [11:04] "Look, we got this legislation passed. [11:06] If you vote, if you don't vote, then the [11:08] the other the other side's going to [11:09] repeal it." [11:12] His other move is he's trying to [11:15] actually get himself appointed as the [11:17] executive, but he doesn't have the 61 [11:18] votes. [11:20] So, what he's going to try and do is [11:22] trying to [11:23] get himself appointed as the executive [11:26] even without the 61 votes. And he's [11:30] trying to take control of the executive. [11:32] And so, he issues these warnings. He [11:34] tells the military they're not allowed [11:36] to do anything because BB is not really [11:38] the prime minister. BB is really the [11:40] prime minister. He's what's called a [11:42] caretaker prime minister. It is [11:43] discussed in the laws. There are certain [11:46] role things he's allowed to do, certain [11:47] things he's not allowed to do. But if [11:49] Gaddy isott wanted to be prime minister, [11:52] he could actually just form a coalition [11:55] and do that. [11:58] That's what he is supposed to do. And so [12:02] we should understand that Gotti Eisenhot [12:05] is actually [12:07] channeling [12:08] a political theorist named Carl Schmidt. [12:12] Okay. Now, people who have heard of Carl [12:15] Schmidt immediately associate him with [12:17] the Nazis, [12:19] and there's lot to be said about that, [12:20] but I I'm this is not me calling Gotti [12:23] Eisenott a Nazi. Okay? I'm not going to [12:25] whatever that internet rule is, like how [12:27] many steps it takes, turns it takes an [12:31] argument for someone to be called a [12:32] Nazi. That's not this. I'm not calling [12:34] him a Nazi. Koshmmet was a serious [12:38] political theorist who wrote about some [12:41] of the inherent contradictions within [12:44] liberalism in terms of how it governs [12:47] and human nature. And he wrote this in [12:50] the 1920s way before there was a vibrant [12:53] or even uh a political force known as [12:56] the Nazi party. [12:59] But he has a a book called political [13:02] theology [13:04] and the first chapter [13:08] is called definition of sovereignty. [13:12] What makes somebody the ruler? And [13:15] listen to this first line. The first [13:17] line of the book written in the 1920s, [13:22] not 1930s, [13:24] early 1920s. This is what Carl Schmidt [13:27] wrote. Sovereignty is he who decides on [13:32] the exception. [13:34] That's the key line [13:37] because we have a regular rule and [13:39] order. [13:42] The way politics normally works, it's [13:43] predictable. You understand what's going [13:45] on and why it's happening. And the [13:47] problem is that people who are given [13:50] political power don't always have all [13:53] the support, all the political support [13:55] that they need [13:57] to actually get something done. So they [13:59] start to create exceptions. Okay, let's [14:02] just give some simple examples from the [14:03] United States, right? In the United [14:05] States, you're supposed to pass laws. [14:07] But let's say a president doesn't have [14:09] one of the houses of Congress, [14:12] you know, being controlled by his party. [14:14] So, presidents have opted to start [14:17] making [14:19] um you know uh regulations or executive [14:23] orders or something along those lines. [14:25] They write something up and because [14:27] there's a large bureaucracy, the [14:28] bureaucracy is able to implement parts [14:30] of that [14:32] desired law into their own regulations. [14:36] Similarly, in order for the United [14:37] States to declare war on another [14:39] country, you need an act of Congress. [14:42] Which is why numerous presidents, not [14:45] just Donald Trump and Iran, but other [14:47] presidents going back decades have [14:51] started to call, you know, these the use [14:54] of the military and foreign nations, [14:56] they're not wars. They're military [14:58] interventions. we're stopping terrorists [15:00] or something along those lines, but [15:01] they're not going to call it a war so [15:03] that they don't get into any kind of [15:04] legal dispute about whether they were [15:06] allowed to use [15:08] the military to uh act in a foreign [15:12] country. So they create an exception. [15:17] That is the key to understanding. So [15:19] let's continue with Carl Schmidt for a [15:22] little bit. [15:24] So what Carl Schmidt says is although [15:27] tendencies of modern constitutional [15:30] development point toward eliminating the [15:32] sovereign in this sense right we used to [15:35] have kings says Carl Schmidt they had [15:39] absolute power and the purpose of [15:41] representative government and [15:43] democracies etc is to eliminate all that [15:46] to remove that power and therefore how [15:48] does one [15:51] get their [15:53] sovereign back [15:55] says Carl Schmidt. [15:57] He decides whether there is an extreme [16:00] emergency as well as what must be done [16:02] to eliminate it. [16:05] That is fundamentally the issue that [16:07] Carl Schmidt is addressing in this [16:10] chapter and that is what Gdaddy Isakot [16:12] is trying to do. Gotti Isakot knows that [16:15] he does not have a majority supporting [16:19] him. He may not ever become the prime [16:21] minister but he is hoping. And the way [16:23] he's hoping to become a prime minister [16:24] is to decide that there is an emergency. [16:29] And because there is an emergency, he [16:30] can tell you what exceptions to the [16:32] normal [16:34] order of things [16:37] can be implemented, right? Maybe we're [16:39] just going to be under martial law. [16:41] Maybe certain habius corpuses are going [16:43] to be suspended. Right? There are all [16:44] these actions that can be done in [16:46] emergency situations. They have [16:48] legitimacy when they're under emergency [16:50] situations. And Gotti Isaac is trying to [16:52] create an atmosphere of legit of of [16:55] legitimacy for an emergency. But there [16:59] is no emergency. [17:02] It doesn't exist. [17:05] How do I know it doesn't exist? Because [17:08] nothing's going to happen tomorrow or [17:11] the day after or the day after. There's [17:14] no urgent situation that needs [17:15] resolving. [17:18] Rather, Gotti Eisenhot simply does not [17:22] like the fact that he didn't get enough [17:24] votes. So for him, that's an emergency. [17:29] That's it. So [17:32] this is where the culture [17:35] is very delicately trying to shape the [17:38] way that you think. Gottien is it's like [17:41] that phrase, do you still beat your [17:42] wife? Right? The question assumes a [17:45] certain reality that you do beat your [17:46] wife. That's what Gaddy Isaac's doing [17:49] right here. He's going past the sale, [17:51] right? He's not knocking on the door and [17:53] saying, you know, do you want to buy [17:54] knives? His question is, how many knives [17:56] do you want? [17:58] Similarly, he's not asking you whether [18:00] there's an emergency. He's telling you [18:01] that there is an emergency and he he is [18:03] here to stop that. He is here to solve [18:05] that emergency. That is what he is [18:08] doing. And it's really just a plain old [18:11] power grab. That is it. It is nothing [18:14] more, nothing less. It is a plain old [18:17] paragraph because he does not have the [18:19] democracy behind him. And by democracy I [18:21] mean the majority of the people. [18:24] Democracy like like demonstration [18:26] democracy it mean demos means the people [18:29] right. The democracy is the people are [18:31] deciding and the people can only decide [18:35] if they have the majority. Right? And [18:38] aristocracy is where the elite or the [18:41] wealthy people decide. An oligarchy is [18:44] when the wealthy people decide but for [18:46] the benefit of themselves, right? You [18:49] can have a benevolent monarch and you [18:52] can also have a you can have a [18:55] benevolent monarch and you can also have [18:57] a tyrant. It's not the difference in [18:59] power structure. The difference is in [19:01] terms of how are they using their power [19:05] and to whose benefit? That's really the [19:08] distinction. [19:09] And so Gotti Eisenot is trying to [19:13] accumulate power [19:16] simply by invoking Carl Schmidtz to [19:19] saying there is an emergency. [19:22] This is an exception and this gives me [19:24] emergency powers. [19:29] That's Israel. [19:31] That's what's going on in Israel today. [19:33] But now let's pay attention to what's [19:35] going on in America. [19:37] Because in America there's a huge fight [19:40] over what the college campus looks like. [19:43] Now we need to understand why there's a [19:45] huge fight over what the college campus [19:46] looks like. It's really for two reasons. [19:50] Number one is [19:52] the college campus is the first time [19:55] that young impressionable Americans are [20:00] living out of their h homes. They're [20:03] living away from their parents. And so [20:06] even if a public school teacher in [20:08] eighth grade or 11th grade tries to [20:10] indoctrinate their students with [20:12] progressive ideas, [20:14] the student still goes home and talks to [20:16] their parents and gets like a you know [20:18] more normal let's say uh education and [20:22] the ideas receive push back. But in [20:23] college it's months in between visits to [20:26] home. So what happens is [20:30] the students are living in this new [20:32] environment. They're hearing these new [20:34] ideas and they don't receive the regular [20:36] push back that they would hear if they [20:39] were living at home. That's reason [20:41] number one there's a huge fight as to [20:43] what's going on in college campus. [20:46] Reason number two is that over the last [20:49] 40 years, liberals and progressives have [20:53] taken over the faculty positions and the [20:57] administrative administrative positions [20:59] on these college campuses. [21:02] And right there have been numerous [21:04] studies done as to how many professors [21:06] donate to Republican campaigns or would [21:08] view themselves as conservative. And you [21:10] know it's like in the single digits at [21:13] this point and so [21:16] but the Trump administration hasn't [21:17] trying to push back on it. Other people [21:19] have been trying to push back on it. One [21:20] of the ways that it gets pushed back on [21:23] is um you know how are admissions [21:26] decided? Do you have race-based [21:28] admissions? Do you not have race-based [21:29] admissions? right there. There there [21:31] there was the policy in the United [21:32] States called affirmative action that [21:34] gave precedence to certain minorities, [21:37] especially African-Americans [21:39] uh in getting into [21:42] uh college programs and and post and and [21:44] graduate degrees, [21:46] right? That affirmative action morphed [21:47] into DEI that we need equal [21:49] representation. That is against the idea [21:52] of a meritocracy. [21:55] Why is that against the idea of a [21:56] meritocracy? Well, there are certain [22:02] races. Not it's really not really about [22:04] race though. It's more about culture. [22:07] There are certain cultures [22:09] that are performing above their [22:12] percentages and there are certain [22:14] cultures that are performing below their [22:16] national percentages. [22:18] Okay, let me give you an example. [22:22] Asians [22:23] perform above their percentages. [22:27] African-Americans, on the other hand, [22:28] perform below their percentages. Why is [22:31] this true? Well, the main reason is that [22:34] because Asians generally have stable [22:38] families. [22:40] And in African-American communities, [22:42] unfortunately, [22:44] there is an epidemic of single mothers [22:48] and uh fathers who abandon their [22:50] children. And it's really terrible in [22:54] terms of the creation of a high trust [22:58] functional society. [23:00] Why does this matter? It matters simply [23:03] because [23:05] learning for children is hard. Anybody [23:09] who's a parent knows this. Anyone who's [23:10] was recently a student knows this. Think [23:13] about the last time that you had to, I [23:15] don't know, read a Charles Dickens book [23:18] for school or your child had to read a [23:20] Charles Dickens book for school. And I'm [23:21] not saying a really hard book. Charles [23:23] Dickens is not that hard. But let's say [23:25] Charles Dickens or or Shakespeare uh or [23:29] math. If you're not if if you're not a [23:31] math person, you have to learn uh I [23:34] don't know um rules of geometry related [23:37] to circles or you have to learn u the [23:40] difference between s and cosine and [23:43] tangent in in in math and how you use [23:45] each one. All sorts of concepts that are [23:47] not so easy in math. And so [23:53] the the question is how do you get [23:55] children to learn these concepts? [23:59] And the main answer is [24:01] parents. [24:03] The main factor determining whether a [24:06] child is successful in school or is not [24:08] successful in school is do they come [24:11] from a stable two parent family. Why? [24:15] Well, it's quite simple. [24:18] Because parenting children is hard. When [24:21] you have two parents who are at home, [24:23] they can each take a break at night [24:26] after a long day's work. [24:28] One gets a break while the other is [24:30] doing homework, the other takes a break [24:34] and you know they switch off. But when [24:36] you only have one parent at home, then [24:40] working in the morning and then working [24:44] in the morning and then trying to parent [24:46] becomes this incredibly difficult task [24:51] because you're simply out of energy. And [24:54] when you're out of energy, the what [24:57] happens is that [25:01] when your child is fighting with you [25:03] about homework, you don't want to fight [25:06] with them anymore and so they don't do [25:08] their homework. And one time is fine and [25:10] five times is fine. But when this [25:14] happens over and over and over again [25:18] over multiple years and multiple grades [25:21] then what ends up happening is one child [25:25] is learning in first 2nd 3rd 8th 10th [25:28] 12th grade and the other child is not. [25:33] And when we talk about the battle of [25:35] what's going on on the college campus [25:37] what is there are actually two different [25:39] battles of what's going on. Number one [25:41] is who is being educated? Who is getting [25:45] this elite education? Who's being [25:47] allowed to uh receive these degrees? And [25:52] the second question is what are they [25:54] being educated in? And in order to [25:57] highlight [25:58] um kind of this dispute, we're going to [26:00] look at a video that really we shouldn't [26:04] be looking at because it's basically an [26:06] irrelevant story. But the fact that it [26:08] has become [26:10] a story throughout the United States on [26:13] CBS, NBC, PBS, throughout the United [26:17] States, uh highlights both of these [26:20] factors. Here we go. Okay, here's a [26:24] really a a silly video from uh [26:29] University of Mississippi. Here goes. [26:35] [laughter] [26:44] >> Hey, as you can see, um what was this? [26:48] What was this video? Uh, this video was [26:51] simply [26:53] three college students, two of whom made [26:56] uh monkey or ape noises at a a Ring, you [27:01] know, camera, doorbell camera, something [27:02] like that, right? [27:05] This is non- news. It's simply college [27:09] students acting like idiotic college [27:12] students like we all did when we were [27:15] 18. But it turns out that the [27:21] resident of that apartment was uh is [27:26] African-American, is black, and they [27:29] then promoted or they their their mother [27:31] or parents or something then promoted [27:33] this video on TikTok highlighting [27:37] that uh this is evidence of systemic [27:40] racism in the United States. That's the [27:43] video. That that's what they wanted to [27:44] do. Now, the real story is actually that [27:49] the white female students making these [27:52] eight noises had no idea who was living [27:54] in the in the dorm or the apartment. [27:57] Every time they saw a ring camera as [27:59] they were walking from wherever they [28:00] were walking to wherever they were [28:02] walking, it doesn't even matter. They [28:04] made those same noises. [28:06] It just so happens that in this one [28:09] instance, [28:12] the resident was African-American and [28:15] took offense and decided that therefore [28:17] they were going to share that with the [28:19] rest of the world. Now, let's [28:22] let's let's even grant the most obscene [28:29] type of scenario. Let's say those three [28:32] college students [28:34] um were racist and they knew who the [28:39] residents of that apartment building of [28:41] that of that dormatory or apartment were [28:43] and they intentionally made those [28:44] noises. Let's let's even grant that this [28:48] is still not news. [28:50] It doesn't matter. It's three college [28:54] students in Mississippi. [28:56] The fact that every major news channel [29:00] is talking about it not just once but [29:02] for days on end is highlighting that [29:07] they are using this incident for a [29:09] larger cultural purpose. And that larger [29:12] cultural purpose is that they want [29:14] everyone in the United States to think [29:16] that there is systemic racism wherever [29:19] you go and whites like they just want to [29:22] discriminate against blacks. They just [29:23] want to harm blacks. But let's look at [29:28] the real facts. The real facts are that [29:31] it is whites and Asians [29:34] who are the ones who are being [29:35] discriminated against. Okay. How do I [29:38] know that the white that whites and [29:39] Asians are being discriminated against? [29:41] Because there have been a number of [29:43] court cases over the last few decades [29:46] trying to end what's known as [29:47] affirmative action. Affirmative action. [29:49] Well, you could kind of describe it as [29:51] like the [29:53] [sighs] [29:54] the the younger version of DEI. It [29:57] basically said that uh it was initially [29:59] that African-Americans were [30:00] disadvantaged and they weren't [30:02] disadvantaged both due to slavery and [30:03] the Jim Crow laws and therefore they [30:06] needed a little extra boost in order to [30:09] uh reach the same social status and [30:12] wealth status as the more dominant [30:14] whites in America. That was the initial [30:17] um motivation for it. But it kind of [30:21] grew and grew and grew into like anybody [30:24] who is not white is deserving of a leg [30:26] up. Okay. So let's actually look at and [30:29] then there were lawsuits that went all [30:31] the way to the Supreme Court. numerous [30:33] colleges, you numerous universities, [30:35] they all lost at the Supreme Court [30:38] basically saying, "Stop using race as a [30:42] factor for determining who gets into [30:45] college and who does not get into [30:46] college. Just have objective non-partial [30:51] criteria." That what the Supreme Court [30:53] like kept on saying it. And every time [30:55] they said it, colleges, well, we're [30:58] gonna use zip code. Well, we're going to [31:00] use socioeconomics. They tried to make [31:02] all these um representatives of, [31:08] you know, of of what would constitute a [31:11] minority in order to give them a leg up [31:15] as well. But it turns out that John's [31:17] Hopkins has finally decided that they [31:20] are going to simply [31:24] follow the law and have nonpartisan and [31:27] nondiscriminatory [31:29] uh admissions to college. Okay. So [31:32] someone did a chart as to okay what does [31:35] John's Hopkins um [31:38] uh um what did John's Hopkins um uh um [31:43] admissions policies what's the reality [31:45] of Johns Hopkins admissions um from [31:49] you know 2023 to 2026. So, here goes. [31:54] Here is the chart of what it looks like. [31:57] And what you will notice is that oh, [32:02] the major people being discriminated [32:04] against were Asian-Americans. [32:06] Asian-Americans represented 25% [32:11] of the incoming class at Johns Hopkins [32:13] University. And by 2026, they were 44%. [32:17] Why were they 44%? Because they earned [32:21] it. What do I mean that they earned it? [32:24] I mean that [clears throat] [32:26] they go to school, they do the reading, [32:29] they study hard, they get less [32:33] entertainment and enjoyment in life [32:35] while they are in high school because [32:37] they're focusing on their academic [32:38] studies. [32:41] Where similarly [32:43] um the white population also went up [32:45] from 19% to close to 26%. Not as big of [32:50] a jump, but it's clear that they were [32:51] being discriminated against. And who was [32:53] being favored? Well, you have [32:56] [clears throat] [32:57] blacks went from 10% to 3% of the [33:01] incoming class. Latinos, Hispanics, [33:03] Latinos went from 21% [33:05] [clears throat] [33:06] to 7%. And international students [33:11] went from [33:13] 16% to 10%. There were some minor [33:16] changes with other minorities as well. [33:19] And so here again, [33:21] we see that John's Hopkins, like all [33:24] universities, intentionally wanted a [33:27] certain racial dynamic that more [33:29] reflected the population of the United [33:31] States. [33:33] But once they had nonbiased, [33:36] non-discriminatory racial um policies, [33:40] it turns out that the people who work [33:44] hard [33:46] achieve more. It's a meritocracy. [33:48] Asian-Americans, and there are numerous [33:50] books on this, have a culture of doing [33:54] well, of working hard, and achieving, [33:59] right? Whether it's Japan or China or [34:02] South Korea, these are places that work. [34:06] And African-Americans, who are about 13% [34:09] of the American population, well, they [34:12] are grappling with broken families. And [34:14] in broken families, it is so difficult. [34:18] The lift is so hard to [34:22] do well in school, to achieve, to study, [34:24] and so they go down significantly simply [34:29] because they don't have both parents [34:32] living at home. So Asian-Americans have [34:35] strong nuclear families. And because [34:38] they have strong nuclear families, what [34:40] happens is is that they get their kids [34:42] to work hard and do well. And [34:44] African-American families are are broken [34:47] statistically. And because of that, it [34:50] is so difficult for them to get their [34:53] kids. Again, I'm not saying there's a [34:55] fundamental difference between the [34:56] races, but there is a fundamental [34:58] difference in the cultures. But the good [35:00] thing is that cultures are not dependent [35:02] on genetics. These things can change if [35:07] people are willing to do the hard work [35:09] of change. And by hard work, I mean that [35:13] the it requires an immense amount of [35:15] shortterm sacrifice to build long-term [35:19] gains. And if the African-American [35:21] community is willing to do that, they [35:23] will see incredible results within the [35:26] next 20 years. Now, they might say, "Oh, [35:27] 20 years is too long." But that's the [35:29] type of generational change that is [35:32] needed in order to change those [35:35] statistics. But let's go to another [35:37] video because it's not just about who is [35:38] receiving an education. It's also about [35:40] what is the education that they are [35:43] receiving. And [35:45] here we have um a video of a a social [35:49] work professor from um Michigan, [35:52] University of Michigan. Here goes. [35:54] >> This is what my professor does for my [35:55] class, University of Michigan. even [35:58] [singing] romanticize [36:00] the past [36:02] because it was back [singing] when [36:06] in many ways [36:09] though it's even [singing] more [36:12] now. [36:15] I thought I was here to help [singing] [36:18] folks. [36:21] Okay. So, here we have [36:25] a professor at the University of [36:27] Michigan teaching social work. This guy [36:29] is getting a social work degree and [36:33] this professor is singing about how [36:36] terrible the United States was and has [36:39] only gotten worse. First of all, she's [36:41] singing. This is not even serious. [36:44] So, what she's doing is she's demeaning [36:46] the intellectual exercise as if that's [36:49] not really that important. as if she's [36:51] like a performer. That's number one. [36:54] Number two, she there's no substance. [36:58] It's just a rant. [37:01] So students are being miseducated into [37:03] believing that the United States is a [37:06] terrible place. [37:08] And the evidence that it is a terrible [37:11] place is obviously the [37:13] miss video of these three white [37:17] 18-year-olds [37:19] making [37:21] monkey noises by a ring camera. So, it [37:24] all goes together. This one video of the [37:26] ring camera, which should never have [37:29] been used because it's like silly [37:33] 18-year-olds doing silly 18-year-old [37:36] stuff. [37:38] They're that's now being used to a [37:40] promote the fact that whites don't [37:43] belong in college, right? and one at [37:47] least one of these students has taken a [37:48] leave of absence or maybe was forced to [37:50] take a leave of absence. And number two, [37:53] it's evidence that the United States is [37:56] a terrible place. There's systemic [37:58] racism wherever you go. [38:00] So [38:02] when the when the New York Times has [38:04] this line, all the news that's fit to [38:06] print, it's not just the New York Times, [38:08] it's every single media outlet. They are [38:13] using certain stories in certain ways to [38:16] try to get you to think about reality in [38:20] a certain way. If you think America [38:23] systemically racist, then you're like, [38:24] well, we got to fix that. So, you're [38:27] this is a way that they are trying to [38:30] manipulate you. That brings us to the [38:32] end of this episode of Culture Matters. [38:36] Please remember that if politics is [38:38] downstream from culture, then culture [38:41] matters.