Transcript [00:00] This episode is going to be a bit [00:03] depressing. And what I mean by that is [00:05] we talk about the breakdown of the [00:07] family, but it turns out that there are [00:10] reverberations of what we would call [00:11] breakdown of the family 2.0. And what I [00:15] mean by this [00:17] is if we There was a recent article [00:20] in the Free Press by Arthur Brooks. [00:23] Arthur Brooks used to be the president [00:25] of the American Enterprise Institute. [00:27] He's a college professor now, and he [00:30] wrote an article called Why Won't [00:32] Boomers Grandparent? [00:35] And [00:36] what he describes is that there are many [00:39] grandparents within the baby boomer [00:41] generation [00:44] who don't want to be grandparents. I [00:45] mean, they had kids and they raised [00:46] their kids, and their kids had kids, but [00:50] they don't want to visit their kids. [00:52] They don't want to help their kids out [00:54] with various childcare matters. [00:56] And I've seen numerous reports [01:01] from friends, [01:02] people on X about how they invite their [01:05] parents to come for the holidays or to [01:07] come visit the kids and the grandkids, [01:09] and the parents, the grandparents simply [01:12] aren't interested. [01:16] And so the article was describing how [01:19] the grandparents who worked hard in [01:21] their lives, [01:23] they are enjoying their relaxing time in [01:27] Florida. They are enjoying their [01:28] vacation homes, their retirement homes, [01:31] and they don't want to be bothered with [01:33] like, you know, raising kids or, you [01:36] know, changing diapers again or even [01:38] like [01:39] sleeping in a guest bedroom. So [01:44] we should understand number one, where [01:46] this is coming from and where it's [01:49] going. And I called this [01:51] the breakdown of the family 2.0. And the [01:54] reason why I called this the breakdown [01:56] of the family 2.0 is because we have to [01:58] understand what was the original [02:00] breakdown of the family. The original [02:01] breakdown of the family [02:04] was the idea that [02:07] at the most basic level [02:10] having children [02:12] was not connected [02:14] to starting a family. [02:16] People could have children out of [02:18] wedlock. That wasn't considered [02:19] embarrassing anymore, right? We [02:22] destigmatized it. [02:26] This was also so people started having [02:28] relations before they got married. [02:32] And that led to a whole host of children [02:35] being born out of wedlock, not knowing [02:37] who their fathers are. [02:39] Their mothers were ill-equipped to to [02:41] raise them. [02:43] But that was only part one of the [02:45] breakdown of the family. [02:47] Part two of the breakdown of the family [02:49] was the [02:50] people who did get married and did have [02:53] children [02:54] but [02:55] then [02:59] like marriage is hard [03:01] and raising a family is hard and [03:03] sometimes you just want your freedom. [03:05] You just want your independence. And so [03:07] what people did is they said, look, I [03:09] consented to marrying this person, but [03:12] marriage isn't forever. It was good [03:14] while it lasted and we're going to [03:16] separate amicably. [03:19] And that led to skyrocketing divorce [03:22] rates. [03:24] So now only about one in two marriages [03:28] actually lasts. [03:29] The rest end up the other half end up in [03:32] divorce. [03:34] And what this led to, this idea, we can [03:37] call it a liberal idea, [03:39] what this liberal idea led to [03:43] or where it stemmed from actually, where [03:44] this liberal idea stemmed from [03:48] people thinking that they were due or [03:51] they were owed a larger amount of [03:54] freedom [03:55] than is actually [03:58] part of human existence. [04:01] What I mean by that is people think, [04:03] I'm born free. I'm born an individual. I [04:07] can do what I want. I only am obliged to [04:10] do things that I choose to do, that I [04:13] consent to. [04:15] And this is an enlightenment idea. [04:18] That I'm free and my obligations are [04:20] only the things that I consent to. That [04:22] is [04:23] a liberal idea. [04:25] Straight out of the enlightenment. [04:28] And so people therefore thought, okay, [04:30] just because I consent it at one point [04:32] in time doesn't mean that I continually [04:35] consent. [04:37] And so marriage kind of got viewed and [04:39] instead of being a covenant, it was [04:41] viewed as a contract. [04:43] And a contract with like, you know, uh [04:47] like an expiration date or a contract [04:49] where like, you know, I could uh [04:51] exit at certain points in time or when [04:53] it was just not working for me, we could [04:55] consent that we wanted to end the [04:57] marriage. [04:59] Cuz I no longer want to be part of the [05:01] marriage. And that was what happened to [05:03] marriage in the United States. [05:07] And the consequence of that now is is [05:10] that as the generation [05:12] that dramatically increased the number [05:14] of divorces gets older, [05:17] even the ones who are still married, [05:20] even the 50% [05:22] who are still married, [05:24] they still have in their mind that they [05:26] are owed [05:29] an outsized [05:31] portion of leisure leisure and [05:34] relaxation. [05:36] And so they think that their job as [05:37] grandparents [05:38] is to live in their retirement [05:39] communities and to play golf and to hang [05:43] out with their friends and to go on [05:45] cruises and to travel the world and to [05:48] just enjoy life. [05:50] And when their kids say say hey, would [05:52] you like to come visit, they're like, [05:54] nah, [05:56] we're not going to do that. We'll do it [05:57] another time. [05:59] It's not terribly convenient for us [06:01] right now. [06:03] And they don't feel any kind of [06:03] obligation to do that. So, [06:05] let's try and understand why this [06:07] liberal principle is wrong, [06:12] and then get to [06:14] where it leads to and what the dark side [06:16] of this all is. Let me tell you [06:19] about an exciting opportunity [06:22] that we at Israel 365 have for you. [06:26] Planting 700,000 fruit trees across [06:28] Israel, renovating the strategic [06:32] overlooking [06:35] and keeping a Jewish presence there, [06:37] building a trauma center in [06:39] Immanuel, supporting Jewish farming [06:42] communities throughout Judea and [06:43] Samaria, and that's just the beginning. [06:47] From Israel's life-saving dog units to [06:49] supporting struggling soldiers, widows, [06:51] orphans, and at-risk youth, the [06:55] is making an incredible difference [06:56] across Israel. And now, for the ninth [06:59] year in a row, [07:01] is their dream raffle. They are giving [07:03] you the chance to support these amazing [07:05] causes while entering to win a brand new [07:09] 1.3 million dollar luxury apartment in [07:12] Jerusalem. [07:13] Every raffle entry makes a difference. [07:16] Support Israel, enter to win, make [07:19] Jerusalem part of your family's future. [07:21] Visit the dream raffle.com. That's t h e [07:27] d r e a m r a f l e . com/news today. [07:35] So, visit the dream raffle.com/news [07:39] today [07:40] or [07:42] click the link below in the video [07:44] description. [07:46] So, [07:48] this little principle is wrong [07:50] for the most basic reason that we are [07:51] not born as free-floating atoms. We do [07:56] not choose [07:58] who our parents are. We do not choose [08:01] when we are born or even that we are [08:03] born. We have no choice in the matter. [08:07] And that's not a flaw, [08:10] that's not a defect. That's by design. [08:13] Human beings are born as part of [08:16] networks and they must live [08:20] as part of networks. [08:21] And if they don't live as part of [08:23] networks, then they are not [08:25] understanding what it means to be human. [08:30] Okay, we've pointed out before, but we [08:32] should say it again. [08:35] The flip side of independence is [08:37] loneliness. The same generation that [08:40] wanted more independence than any of its [08:43] predecessors is the same generation [08:47] that experienced the loneliness [08:48] epidemics. [08:50] And they experienced the loneliness [08:51] epidemic because they weren't willing to [08:54] attach themselves to other people. So [08:57] yes, we are born [09:00] to our parents. [09:02] When we are born, we are attached to [09:03] them because we are dependent. And as we [09:07] grow [09:08] in our independence, that independence [09:12] doesn't become the goal. [09:14] Rather, it becomes the way station when [09:17] we then say we now want to attach [09:21] ourselves to somebody else and we are [09:23] going to do the hard work to make sure [09:26] that we attach ourselves to somebody [09:27] else. Because why aren't people [09:29] attaching themselves to somebody else? [09:32] Because it's hard. [09:34] They [09:35] crimp your style. [09:37] You have a certain way of living, you [09:39] have a certain way you want the bedroom [09:40] to look, you have a certain way you want [09:41] the living room to look. You have a [09:42] certain type of food that you like and [09:44] then somebody else comes and you're [09:46] living with them and they have their own [09:48] way and their own style. [09:51] And you don't always like their style. [09:53] You don't like the way that, I don't [09:55] know, [clears throat] [09:56] they spread or the way that they cook [09:59] or, you know, how often they generally [10:01] shower. There are all sorts of and [10:03] again, I'm not talking about my wife [10:04] here. [10:07] But these are all common questions that [10:09] people experienced with any roommates. [10:13] Think about your college roommates. [10:15] There was the guy who spread his stuff [10:17] everywhere and didn't notice or never [10:19] did his laundry or whatever else. [10:22] That is what it means [10:24] to live with roommates. [10:26] But your spouse isn't merely your [10:28] roommate. They are the person that [10:29] you're spending the rest of your life [10:30] with. [10:32] That's what a marriage is. It is it is a [10:34] commitment. It is a covenant [10:38] to spend the rest of your life with that [10:41] person. [10:43] And so what happens is [10:45] is you have different parenting styles [10:47] and as money gets tight as it always [10:49] does, [10:51] you have disagreements as to what is [10:53] worthwhile to buy and what is not [10:55] worthwhile to buy. [10:56] What should you spend your money on and [10:58] you know when is are you being a little [11:00] too miserly when you're trying to save? [11:02] These are all questions that come up in [11:05] every marriage and couples fight about [11:08] them or they argue about them or they [11:10] strongly disagree about them. That's all [11:13] normal. The question is how do you react [11:16] when these arguments come up? [11:19] Do you say, oh well this highlights that [11:20] this is no longer working for me and I'm [11:22] out of here cuz I want my freedom and [11:24] independence [11:26] or do you say we're going to do the hard [11:27] work and work through it. We're going to [11:28] learn to communicate better. We're going [11:30] to learn the areas where we can [11:32] compromise, the areas where we can't [11:35] compromise, the areas where we can [11:36] actually have even a win-win. [11:39] The areas where I'll just say, look it's [11:40] not worth the fight. I'm just going to [11:42] let them do their thing. [11:44] Those are all different mechanisms by [11:46] which spouses resolve their conflicts, [11:49] whether it's how to raise children or [11:53] how to spend money or how much time, you [11:55] know, you're going to how you're going [11:57] to balance, you know, your profession [12:00] and your family obligations. Those are [12:02] all normal disagreements that come up in [12:06] the family context. [12:12] But the boomer generation, [12:15] they decided that they were owed more [12:19] freedom than the past. And because they [12:20] were owed more freedom than the past, [12:23] the first thing that they did was they [12:24] cut themselves off from their parents. [12:27] They mocked their parents. Their parents [12:29] were old fuddy-duddies. [12:31] They were stiff and stale and boring and [12:36] black and white. They were the '50s [12:39] people. But the boomers, they were in [12:42] Technicolor. [12:43] They were full of color. They were the [12:45] '60s people who really enjoyed life. [12:49] But it turns out [12:51] that it was more like [12:53] getting drunk and now suffering the [12:55] hangover. [12:57] So [12:58] the boomers enjoyed the '60s, [13:01] but then [13:03] they struggled to get married. And when [13:05] they got married, they struggled to stay [13:06] married. [13:08] And they struggled to raise their [13:09] children. [13:11] And they overspent. And many of the [13:13] problems that we see today can be traced [13:16] to [13:17] the aftermath of the sexual revolution. [13:20] And so [13:22] that revolution continues to this day. [13:26] And that revolution continues to this [13:28] day because now the ones who [13:32] successfully raised their children so [13:34] that their children have children [13:36] are now saying, we don't need to be [13:38] grandparents. We did the parenting stage [13:40] in life. Now we're going on cruises. Now [13:43] we're going to the pool. Now we're going [13:44] to the beach. Now we are enjoying life. [13:49] And those people [13:51] continue to believe [13:54] that [13:55] they are entitled titled to a level of [13:58] freedom that goes against the entire [14:02] history of humanity. [14:07] And there will be consequences. Let me [14:09] tell you the first consequence. The [14:12] first consequence is I want to read you [14:14] this post that I saw on social media on [14:17] X. K, it doesn't matter who it was from, [14:19] but it was it's gotten a lot of [14:22] engagement. Over 420,000 views, over [14:26] 1,000 retweets, over 2,000 likes, close [14:29] to 400 bookmarks, over 3 and 1/2 [14:33] thousand comments. And here it goes. [14:36] I told my mom today that it's not my [14:38] responsibility to take care of her, and [14:40] she went all emotional. [14:42] As much as we don't want to hurt our [14:44] parents, sometimes they deserve to hear [14:46] the bitter truth. Every parent needs to [14:48] understand that raising a child and [14:50] giving them a good education does not [14:51] automatically mean that child, I think [14:54] means the child owes you the same thing [14:57] when you grow old. No child asks to be [15:00] born. It was your responsibility to take [15:02] care of them, not a trade by barter [15:04] deal. [15:05] Save for your old old age. Don't become [15:07] a burden to your child. Whatever they [15:09] choose to do for you should come [15:12] willingly, not from entitlement. To be [15:15] honest, no child owes you anything. The [15:18] more we understand this, the better for [15:20] everyone. Yeah, so if your ideal is [15:22] freedom, then parents are in fact a [15:23] burden. [15:25] That is 100% true. If your goal is to [15:28] maximize your leisure, your relaxation, [15:31] and your freedom in life, then you will [15:34] view your parents as a burden. [15:40] Howard, this is all wrong. [15:43] The goal is not [15:46] to maximize your freedom in life. [15:50] The goal is to make sure that you are [15:54] perpetuating the values, God's values, [15:58] the ones that you hold dear to your [16:01] children and your grandchildren. [16:04] And this requires [16:06] parents who are deeply engaged parents [16:09] and parents who are also willing to be [16:13] deeply engaged and even sacrificial [16:15] grandparents [16:17] because raising children is hard. And [16:20] because raising children is hard, a very [16:22] easy easy thing for parents to do, for [16:25] grandparents to do, is to help their [16:27] kids out just a little bit. [16:29] Once a week, once every two weeks, [16:33] maybe just take the kids for a night [16:35] so that your [16:36] child and and and either son son and [16:39] daughter-in-law [16:41] can [16:42] go out on a date and have a quiet night. [16:44] You remember what it was like being a [16:47] young parent. [16:48] So why not help your child out? [16:50] Why not give them a little bit of a leg [16:52] up and a little bit of an easier time? [16:55] Trust me, they're not going to be [16:56] relying on you. They're not moving in. [16:58] They're not asking you for a handout. [17:01] What you are doing [17:03] is you are making sure that they become [17:06] successful parents. [17:09] That's at the most basic level. [17:12] But now let's go a little bit deeper. [17:14] And we need to go a little bit deeper [17:15] because this entire construct [17:18] of people born independent of [17:22] their ancestry and having children that [17:25] then become independent from them [17:28] is misguided. [17:31] We are born, let me be super clear. [17:35] We are born as part of networks, and [17:38] those networks create obligations. [17:42] Let me give you a simpler example. If a [17:44] person has a sibling with physical or [17:48] mental disabilities, [17:51] primary responsibility for taking care [17:53] of that [17:56] sibling [17:57] is with the siblings. [17:59] Yes, the parents will do their part [18:01] until they can no longer do that. [18:03] But as that sibling gets older into the [18:05] 30s, 40s, 50s, and the parents are [18:08] either no longer alive or no longer can [18:10] help, [18:12] you become obligated to care for your [18:14] sibling simply because [18:17] they are your sibling. [18:20] That's what it means to be born into [18:22] obligation. You don't choose your [18:24] obligations. You're born into [18:26] obligation. And the same thing is true [18:28] with religion. We are all born into our [18:31] obligation with God. We do not choose [18:35] it. [18:37] Yes, I know this is like a longer debate [18:39] amongst Christians and different [18:41] denominations there, [18:42] but we are born in a certain religion [18:46] and we have obligations simply because [18:48] we were born into it. If you want if [18:51] you're supposed to take on later [18:52] consensual obligation afterwards, that's [18:55] another story. [18:58] And so what's happening here [19:01] is that people still think that they are [19:03] born free of obligation. I can choose to [19:05] do whatever I want. But now let's look [19:06] at the Bible [19:07] because the Bible tells us two ideas [19:10] that on the face of it seem to be [19:12] contradictory, but they are not. [19:14] At the very beginning of the Bible, we [19:15] are told that a man should leave his [19:18] mother and his father and cleave to his [19:19] wife. [19:23] That is the independence idea. [19:26] But then we are told [19:29] in the Ten Commandments, honor your [19:31] father and mother. [19:33] Well, which is it? [19:35] Are you supposed to leave and become [19:38] independent [19:39] or are you supposed to be attached and [19:41] honor them? [19:43] That question and how you resolve these [19:46] verses [19:47] is the most important question. [19:51] And so what we have to understand is [19:53] that the Bible is not contradicting [19:55] itself. [19:56] What the Bible is actually saying is [19:58] that successful marriage begin with [20:01] independence. Successful marriages [20:04] cannot have two 10-year-olds marrying [20:06] each other and being emotionally [20:08] immature. Rather, successful marriages [20:11] stem from two independent people [20:15] choosing to spend the rest of their [20:18] lives together. [20:21] That is what makes a successful [20:23] marriage. And so if you want to have a [20:25] successful marriage, first make yourself [20:27] independent. [20:32] That's at the most basic level. [20:37] But in that process of doing it, you [20:39] cannot [20:41] disregard your parents. You came from [20:44] somewhere. [20:45] You have duties, you have obligations. [20:49] You have to honor your parents always. [20:52] You never get to say my parents are a [20:54] burden. [20:57] And so you always need to [20:59] figure out a way that you are attaching [21:01] yourself. As an adult, as an independent [21:05] person, you are now attaching yourself [21:09] to the earlier generation. [21:12] And we should therefore [21:14] think about the end of Joseph's life. [21:20] Because the end of Joseph's life is a [21:22] master lesson in how to do all this. [21:27] Let's look at the end of Joseph's life. [21:29] The end of Joseph's life, we have on the [21:31] one hand his father calls him and says I [21:33] want you to swear to me that you're [21:34] going to bury me in the land of Israel [21:35] and Joseph of course does that. [21:38] But how does the book of Genesis end? [21:40] The book of Genesis ends with us going [21:43] back to Joseph's life. But how [21:45] do we go back to Joseph's life? It's the [21:47] very end of his life. And what's the [21:48] image before us? We see that Joseph has [21:50] great grandchildren. [21:52] And some of those great grandchildren [21:54] are bouncing on his knee. [21:57] That is our parting image of Joseph. So [22:00] Joseph who rose to the highest ranks of [22:04] Egyptian culture, [22:06] the end of his life is one of him being [22:11] a great grandparent. [22:14] And he's a great grandparent because [22:18] he's focused on perpetuation. [22:22] That is what the Torah's message is. [22:25] Yes, become independent. [22:31] Therefore, a person should leave his [22:33] mother and father and cleave to his [22:34] wife. [22:35] Absolutely. Become independent. That's [22:38] number one. [22:40] But number two, honor your father and [22:42] mother. [22:43] When you honor your father and mother [22:45] mother as Joseph did, your children see [22:47] that. They see your dedication to your [22:50] parents. They will then be dedicated to [22:52] you. [22:54] There's a cycle. There's a chain. [22:57] And if you don't like the way that the [22:58] cycle in your family is going, then you [23:01] have to be the ones to break it. And you [23:03] can only break it by staying married, by [23:07] working hard, by them doing the [23:09] difficult work and making sure [23:14] that [23:15] you're not a family is not only forming, [23:17] but that you are attached and you [23:18] continue to stay attached. [23:21] That is the [23:23] essence [23:24] of [23:26] this message here. That is the essence [23:28] of why things are go things are going [23:30] haywire in America. Things are going [23:32] haywire in America because families [23:34] never formed [23:35] in the first place. [23:37] When they did form, they were not [23:39] properly glued together. And now they [23:41] haven't been properly glued [23:45] the families have not been properly [23:46] glued glued together. Even when there [23:48] are new opportunities for attachment, [23:52] they're not attaching. [23:53] They're having a lot of difficulty [23:54] attaching. [23:57] But now let's understand the second [23:59] topic. [24:00] And the second topic and this is not [24:01] related to families and attachment but [24:04] but [24:05] related to [24:07] Joe Biden's autobiography. In Joe [24:09] Biden's autobiography, [24:11] he of course does not like Bibi [24:13] Netanyahu and he writes about Bibi [24:15] Netanyahu. And he writes as follows, I [24:17] was frustrated by his, meaning Bibi's, [24:20] failure to think like a statesman and [24:22] safeguard Israel's long-term interest, [24:25] not just his own short-term political [24:27] needs. [24:28] That's the Biden quote. [24:32] This quote is obviously, of course, [24:36] what was the word that he used? [24:37] Malarkey. [24:40] Okay? [24:40] This quote's just made up. It's a [24:43] made-up reality. [24:45] And why is it a made-up reality? It is a [24:48] made-up reality [24:50] because Biden has a certain vision as to [24:54] what proper statesmen look like and do. [24:58] And Bibi wasn't doing that because Bibi [25:00] actually has a different philosophical [25:01] view. [25:03] For Biden, [25:06] statesmanship means aiming towards [25:10] post-national utopia. [25:12] Kind of like the vision of the United [25:14] Nations. [25:16] Right? [25:17] The vision of the United Nations is, you [25:20] know, all nations, [25:22] all peoples subject themselves to [25:25] whatever the dictates of the United [25:27] Nations is. And when everyone subjects [25:29] themselves to the dictates of the United [25:30] Nations, then eventually there will be [25:32] peace. [25:34] Netanyahu is a nationalist. [25:36] He does not believe that world peace [25:38] means that all the nations are going to [25:41] have a Kumbaya moment. [25:44] Rather, Netanyahu believes that he has [25:46] to make sure that his nation's interests [25:51] are being met. That is it. [25:55] He's looking out for the best of Israel. [25:57] He's not going to give the Palestinians [26:00] or the Arabs some more land as a [26:03] trust-building measure or something [26:05] along those lines. [26:07] Rather, [26:10] he is going to make sure that Israel is [26:13] safe and secure. [26:15] And despite the pressure from the Biden [26:17] administration, he was not going to give [26:19] in because he understood that future [26:22] Israeli lives were at stake. [26:27] So Biden's whole notion of [26:30] be a statesman [26:31] is really just [26:33] be a utopian. [26:35] Believe in this internationalism where [26:39] we all just kind of get along and have a [26:40] Kumbaya moment. [26:43] No. [26:44] Says Netanyahu, that is not what I am. [26:47] And I will not agree. I am a [26:48] nationalist. And by being a nationalist, [26:52] what I am going to do [26:54] is I'm to simply ask myself, is this [26:57] decision in the best interest of my [26:59] country? Yes or no? [27:01] He's not being parochial, he's not small [27:04] thinking. Rather, [27:07] he's being strategic about what is [27:09] actually good for his nation. [27:14] And part of why this is important is [27:17] because there is this kind of like [27:21] moral arrogance that people have [27:25] where they think that nationalism is [27:26] like, you know, that's for the primates. [27:29] That's beneath us. [27:32] But no. Nationalism is actually how you [27:35] build out a much larger message and a [27:39] much larger story. [27:41] This [27:43] is why culture matters. [27:47] If politics is downstream from culture, [27:49] then we need to understand how the [27:51] culture is trying to [27:53] change our mind. What do we think about [27:55] nationalism? If all you hear about [27:57] nationalism is this idea that, oh, well, [27:59] the Nazis were nationalist, [28:02] those the only people who were [28:03] nationalist? Is that as deep as the [28:04] conversation is going to go? [28:08] How do you think about your obligations [28:09] towards your siblings, towards your [28:11] parents, [28:13] towards your children? Is it a chore or [28:15] is it or is it the greatest fulfillment [28:17] of life? [28:19] That [28:22] those are the questions [28:24] of culture matters. [28:28] So please [28:30] tune into this podcast, sign up, [28:32] subscribe to this channel, and [28:36] tune into the next episode of Culture [28:39] Matters because if politics is [28:40] downstream from culture, [28:42] then culture matters. Thank you.