Transcript [00:00] Robert Spencer is one of the foremost [00:01] critics of Islam, of our age. And in [00:05] this clip, he explains why he believes [00:08] Islamic cultures and societies to have [00:12] had a lot of stagnation and and, you [00:14] know, frankly, oppression in ways that [00:16] we just haven't seen across the [00:18] Judeo-Christian world. Why is that? Uh, [00:21] he gives a pretty uh firm analysis, [00:25] shall we say. Uh, this is on the Glasov [00:28] Gang channel. I'll put the link to the [00:29] full interview in the video description, [00:31] but have a watch of this clip because [00:32] it's really interesting, his analysis. [00:35] >> Well, the latest one is The Tragedy of [00:36] Islam: Failure and Excuses. It's one [00:39] I've wanted to write for years. Glad [00:40] that I finally was able to get a chance [00:42] to do so. And it shows uh very simply [00:45] that Islam is bad for you. Uh it's [00:49] doesn't work. You know, the call to [00:52] prayer, the aan uh it says come to [00:55] prayer, come to success. And yet it [00:58] doesn't give you success. The Quran [01:02] tells you that the if you are righteous, [01:05] if you serve Allah, you will be blessed [01:08] by Allah in this world as well as the [01:10] next. And the unbelievers will suffer in [01:13] this world as well as the next. And yet [01:16] you look out in the world and other than [01:18] the countries that have struck oil, [01:20] Muslim countries are fairly poor. Islam [01:23] doesn't bring success. It does not give [01:25] you success as the aan promises. Now, [01:28] why is that? I show why in the tragedy [01:31] of Islam that Islam actually [01:35] doesn't teach [01:37] something that is a core Christian [01:39] principle and that is the value of work. [01:43] That the uh idea that if you work, God [01:47] will bless the work of your hands. [01:49] That's a Christian idea, Jewish idea. [01:53] In Islam, it's faint. It's it it's not [01:55] that people don't work, but it's faintly [01:57] shameful. [01:58] >> It's better if you have non-Muslims to [02:02] do the work. That's the whole idea of [02:04] the Jizian, that the non-Muslims pay you [02:07] a tax, they do the work, they pay you [02:11] the tax, and you live off that. The [02:14] caiff Umar reminds Muslims in a hadith [02:17] always to collect the Jiza because it's [02:19] the source of your of the livelihood for [02:22] you and your descendants. And so [02:25] the ideal Islamic society is based on [02:28] the Jiza, the payments from the [02:31] non-Muslims. when the non-Muslims can no [02:34] longer sustain the Muslims at the same [02:36] rate because they are discriminated [02:39] against in the Islamic society and they [02:41] can't make as much money as maybe they [02:43] used to. the Islamic societies go into [02:46] decline and I show this in the book with [02:48] relation to the Ottoman Empire and the [02:50] Mughal Empire in India and show that [02:55] once the Jiza once the it's like a [02:57] parasite [03:00] parasitical culture and it finds a host [03:03] that's the non-Muslims who pay the Jiza [03:05] but once but then they discriminates [03:08] against the host keeps them from getting [03:10] good jobs keeps them from making money [03:13] once the host can no longer pay the same [03:16] rate in the tax. The parasite goes into [03:21] decline. When the Jiza was the chief [03:25] source of income for the Ottomans, they [03:27] were on top. They were besieging Vienna. [03:30] They were the church of the world. But [03:32] when the non-Muslims couldn't pay as [03:34] much anymore and the Jizia was no longer [03:36] the chief source of income for the [03:38] Ottomans, that's when the empire went [03:40] into decline. All of that is in the book [03:43] along with infidels making excuses for [03:46] the failure of Islam uh as we always do [03:50] and covering for it by making up the [03:52] myths of the Islamic Golden Age and so [03:54] on. Myths of fake converts. [03:58] Then I show how Islam is bad for [04:00] individuals and show in profiles a [04:03] series of profiles of real converts. how [04:05] Islam actually will destroy your life if [04:08] you take it too seriously and you carry [04:11] out its teachings. You end up being a [04:13] jihadi dead or in prison. [04:15] >> You know, it's very interesting. Uh I I [04:18] think part of the hostility to Israel in [04:21] the Muslim Arab world, the pain is that [04:24] Israel is this tiny people who return to [04:28] their land. A nation of refugees and [04:31] immigrants who many of the people that [04:34] returned there just experienced the [04:35] worst crime in human history. And many [04:38] from the Arab world were kicked out in [04:40] the same year of its reestablishment, [04:42] also facing awful oppression and [04:44] persecution. And from this barren land [04:47] have no natural resources. They've [04:48] created this thriving country [04:51] that's now growing at an incredible rate [04:53] by the way [04:56] and as a really you know as a first [04:57] world country now. And they look at that [04:59] and they have their narrative about how, [05:02] you know, Islam's going to dominate the [05:04] world and Islam's going to overtake and [05:07] uh, you know, they look at things and [05:10] they think to themselves, well, how do [05:13] we square that with the Jewish people [05:15] returns their land in the heart of what [05:17] was supposedly meant to be the Islamic [05:20] heart? um and also that it's thriving in [05:23] a way and you know many Islamic [05:26] countries just aren't in that same way [05:28] and are quite oppressive. How do they [05:29] square that? [05:32] At the same time, by the way, it is [05:33] worth noting that some of the ideas of [05:36] monotheism and the narratives in the [05:38] Torah Islam did bring to the world. It's [05:40] not entirely black and white story and [05:42] Judaism, our Jewish philosophy makes [05:44] makes space for that. And I'm actually [05:46] uh going to be we've been working on one [05:48] of our next documentaries which is going [05:49] to go out on JTV Plus. Um we're working [05:53] on one at the moment about Muhammad and [05:55] the Jews about the the truth about the [05:58] Islamic world's relationship with the [06:00] Jews because a lot of the a lot of this [06:01] is whitewashed including the story of uh [06:04] you know Muhammad and the Jews. So this [06:06] is going to be pretty uh um important [06:10] one but that that's uh in the works [06:12] coming soon. Um, but you can access all [06:15] our premium documentaries uh right there [06:17] now at j--tv.plus. [06:19] Um, but I think there's another [06:22] interesting point which is that I was [06:24] speaking in a in a previous video about [06:26] um the dangers of religious extremism [06:30] and that even little uh aspects of it [06:34] can can emerge in in even fringes of uh [06:37] the Jewish world. [06:39] uh for example extreme measures to avoid [06:43] any contact whatsoever between the [06:44] sexes. Sometimes what can end up [06:47] happening is you actually end up [06:52] just disrespecting people's basic human [06:54] dignity and [06:57] over sexualizing everything. And the [06:59] mistake people make is thinking that if [07:01] we're extreme on one religious [07:02] principle, that won't be another [07:03] religious principle like respecting a [07:05] fellow human being that isn't [07:06] potentially uh going to be downgraded. [07:09] So the Jewish message was always about [07:12] holding these these um various concerns [07:15] between man and God and man and man in [07:17] tension and in uh you know in balance. [07:20] Um, and one of the things people said to [07:23] me is, Ollie, you know, that this idea [07:24] of not ever seeing a woman's face, even [07:28] having zero contact whatsoever, [07:31] it's quite Islamic, [07:33] someone said. And, you know, it got me [07:36] thinking [07:38] that [07:39] the Jewish experience has primarily been [07:41] in the Islamic world and the Christian [07:44] and then secular West. [07:47] And I think we sort of have two [07:49] interesting kind of models there that [07:52] are kind of both offshoots of Judaism. [07:54] One of which said [07:57] it deemphasized the law and put more [07:59] emphasis on just grace and and [08:01] forgiveness. [08:03] Very well-intentioned. Um and I think [08:07] evolved into now just what you have as [08:09] the you the secular west which says you [08:11] know let's now just uh potentially [08:14] remove God from the equation and just [08:16] maintain these values forgetting where [08:18] they where the values of uh human [08:20] dignity and and and justice actually and [08:23] equality and actually came from. And [08:25] then you have the Islamic law which said [08:27] the problem with the law is it's not [08:29] strong enough. It's uh it needs to be [08:32] tighter. needs to be strong, more [08:34] extreme. And uh the Jewish people, [08:37] Judaism, the Torah, always held that [08:40] kindness and justice, compassion and [08:42] justice must be held in in balance with [08:44] one another. And so it's no surprise to [08:48] us [08:50] that countries and societies that lean [08:52] most into the biblical values and the [08:54] biblical vision of how you balance these [08:55] two things [08:58] do well and ones that don't [09:02] end up not. There's got to be a balance [09:06] between trusting God but also doing your [09:08] part. Not just saying, "Oh, no. Not [09:10] going to do any work. I'm not going to [09:12] not going to partner with God in any [09:13] way. everything's pre-ordained anyway [09:15] and I just have to believe and that that [09:17] even that thinking can sometimes creep [09:19] into as I say you know Jewish circles to [09:21] a much lesser extent but it can be there [09:24] and and uh actually if we look carefully [09:28] at what the Jewish vision was the [09:30] original Torah biblical vision I think [09:32] we'll be able to find a lot of wisdom [09:34] there for the world the world that I [09:36] think desperately needs it and I think [09:38] understanding that actually this [09:41] actually get cuts to the heart of what [09:43] lies at the root [09:44] of hostility towards Israel will help [09:47] you understand so much. We made a film [09:50] about this showing how the roots of [09:52] anti-semitism and anti-Israel hostility [09:56] are primarily from this religious [09:58] paradigm. It goes all the way back to [10:01] actually the beginnings of the Jewish [10:04] versus Islamic worldview uh [10:09] battle [10:11] as well as the Jewish people and and the [10:14] Wests. And don't get me wrong, there's [10:16] also been a lot of synergy and [10:18] partnership particularly in the West. [10:20] And so this film explains this in detail [10:23] and I want to show you um a trailer for [10:26] it. It's called Chosen. And to watch the [10:28] film in full, just click on the link [10:29] below in the video description. [10:31] Something remarkable is happening. For [10:33] decades, the world told us the problem [10:35] was Zionism, occupation, international [10:38] law. But lately, the mask is slipping. [10:40] Muhammad Hijab, millions of followers [10:43] said in his own words, [10:44] >> "It's not just Zionism, it's Judaism [10:46] [music] as well. They believe they are [10:49] superior to you." [10:50] >> Taka Carlson from the other direction [10:52] keeps insisting, "Sorry, but the Jews [10:54] are not the chosen people." that there [10:56] is no chosen people. The chosen people [10:58] are people who choose Jesus. [11:01] Notice what both of these people coming [11:03] from completely opposite worlds have in [11:05] common. They're not talking about 1948. [11:08] They're not talking about land. They're [11:10] not even talking about Israel. They're [11:12] talking about Jewish choseness. [11:16] And here's what blows my mind. This is [11:18] not a modern argument. This argument is [11:21] as old as the first two brothers who [11:23] ever lived, Cain and Abel. [11:26] God chooses one offering, not the other. [11:29] And instead of learning from his [11:30] brother, Cain kills him. The blueprint [11:33] is right there at the very start. And it [11:36] plays out again with Ishmael and Isaac, [11:40] the roots of the Islamic world's [11:41] relationship with the Jewish people, and [11:44] with Esau and Jacob, the roots of the [11:46] Christian Wests, [11:48] the two great fault lines of Jewish [11:50] history. [11:52] And both of them begin not on a [11:54] battlefield, [11:57] but in a nursery. [12:01] And here's what's extraordinary. The [12:03] rabbis of the Talmud thousands of years [12:05] ago summarized this whole phenomenon in [12:08] just one sentence. Hatred. Sena comes [12:11] from Sinai. Sena is Hebrew for hatred. [12:14] From the moment the Jewish people [12:15] formalized their covenant with God at [12:17] Mount Si, the world's resentment was [12:20] ignited. In this JTV documentary, we're [12:24] going all the way back. Back to the very [12:27] first fracture in human history. [12:30] back to the first act of violence ever [12:32] recorded. Because when you understand [12:35] that moment, you understand [12:37] anti-semitism completely, where it truly [12:40] comes from, why facts and arguments [12:41] alone will never be enough to defeat it, [12:44] but most importantly, what the Torah has [12:46] always known about how to finally heal [12:48] it. Because for the first time, we're [12:51] not just diagnosing the world's oldest [12:53] disease, we're finding the cure. To [12:56] watch this JTV Plus documentary and [12:58] access much more premium content, click [13:00] on the link in the video description. [13:07] [music]