Transcript [00:00] It's time once again for the big picture [00:02] here from the Israel 365 news studios [00:05] here in Bait Sheamesh just outside of [00:07] Jerusalem. Rafi Ice, how are you? [00:09] >> I am great. How are you, Pesak? [00:11] >> I'm doing well. And for those of you who [00:12] have not been following, Rafi has been [00:14] putting out his monologues on culture [00:17] and the intersection between culture and [00:18] politics and spiritual life and the [00:20] world and everything else that's very [00:21] important, covering a lot of very [00:23] important issues. So, make sure that [00:24] you're following all everything that [00:26] Rafi is putting out. It'll really give [00:28] you an even bigger picture of what's [00:29] going on. We have a lot to talk about. [00:31] We were just uh chatting before the show [00:33] that we could probably do three episodes [00:37] uh this week with everything that's [00:38] happening. This probably true every [00:39] week. So, we have to choose what we're [00:41] going to focus on. [00:44] Um and we're going to get into a [00:46] remarkable speech that Secretary of [00:49] State Marco Rubio made a few days ago to [00:52] the Federalist Society. and he he he [00:55] touched on some very important issues [00:57] that are worth drilling down on and [00:58] that'll be the bulk of our conversation. [01:00] But first, we have to talk about what's [01:02] happening in this in this Israeli [01:05] political scene. You know, I I went to I [01:07] went to the synagogue. I went to Shul [01:09] last week and you know, because of what [01:11] I do, you know, everyone always comes [01:12] over to me to talk about politics and [01:15] people were coming over to me and saying [01:16] like, "Hey, what's going on? Can you [01:18] explain what's going on?" And I was [01:19] like, "I have no idea what's going on." [01:22] I mean, just because we live in this [01:25] strange twilight zone right now where in [01:27] the United States, we have Trump between [01:31] getting shellacked in the midterms and [01:34] looking down range at this rapidly [01:37] approaching point at which he's going to [01:40] be dealing with a full-on Democrat [01:44] Congress. He's got that coming [01:49] and they're going to make his life [01:51] miserable from day one and he's got big [01:53] decisions to make right now. And then in [01:54] Israel, we have Netanyahu who's prime [01:56] minister of of a caretaker government, [01:58] which traditionally in Israel, no big [02:00] decisions are made, but traditionally in [02:02] Israel, we didn't have a transition [02:04] between an election and a coalition. [02:06] while there was a massive national [02:09] security, [02:11] you know, acute crisis going on like [02:13] Iran that is on the table that could [02:16] come to a head at any moment. So, we're [02:18] in the we are in [02:20] the most confusing political moment in [02:23] my memory. Uh but at the down to the [02:27] brass tax, horse trading, dirty politics [02:30] level, what's your take on what's going [02:33] on here? We're still in this holding [02:34] pattern. Gotti Eisenkot is officially [02:36] supposed to be putting together a [02:37] coalition. The Arabs are now driving a [02:40] harder and harder bargain, you know, [02:42] putting the screws on him and they're [02:44] doing our work for us by standing up and [02:47] walking out on the national anthem. That [02:48] it was the greatest gift [02:50] >> that they could have given us. I think [02:51] we mentioned that last week. [02:53] >> Meanwhile, Netanyahu every day is [02:55] calling for national unity, which is [02:58] making him look really good to the [03:00] Israeli people, which it makes it great [03:01] politics, but it also corners Eisenhot. [03:04] It makes Eisenhot look like the guy [03:06] who's intrigent and doesn't want unity, [03:08] but it's also great politics for BB [03:10] because he knows that, you know, he's in [03:12] the driver's seat if it ever comes to a [03:14] unity government. So, what's your take [03:16] on where we are? [03:17] >> I think the most important thing of [03:19] what's going on is actually what is not [03:21] going on. Traditionally what happens [03:23] during this time period after a [03:26] after a minister a member of the Knesset [03:29] receives the mandate to form a [03:31] government is they work to form a [03:34] government like that's what they do like [03:36] their party got x number of seats now [03:38] they have to bring along this party and [03:39] this party and this party and they start [03:41] negotiating who gets this ministry and [03:42] who gets that ministry and you know the [03:45] horse trading that happens in in [03:47] politics [03:49] and then after that Then you start to [03:52] discuss Knesset committees and who's [03:55] going to be the speaker of the Knesset [03:57] and which what's the priority of [03:59] legislation, right? And here the whole [04:02] thing's reversed. Gotti Eisenot is [04:04] spending the bulk of his time and time [04:08] is a zero sum game. You don't get extra [04:10] time. Gotti Eisenkot is spending the [04:12] bulk of his time dealing with Knesset [04:16] and legislation. So he got his guy Matan [04:20] Kahana to be the speaker of the house. [04:22] Okay. He and a Victor Lieberman have [04:25] taken over some of the committees within [04:28] the Kesset. Great. Except for one thing. [04:32] Gotti Isot has a total of 28 days. May [04:36] he can ask for a 14-day extension, but [04:38] he really only has a month to a month [04:39] and a half to form a government. And it [04:42] doesn't look like he's done any of that [04:43] work. He's just focusing on other [04:46] things. [04:47] which means that he doesn't think he can [04:50] form a government. So, he's trying to do [04:52] other things to if we go to new [04:54] elections, maybe we'll get some votes. [04:57] So, here's what I think he's doing. [04:57] Here's what I think his plan is. [04:59] >> Okay, cuz I have a take. Oh, let's hear [05:01] yours first. [05:01] >> He He's got 47 seats or something. 480s [05:05] that are easy between his party Yashar [05:08] exclamation point party and um Natali [05:12] Bennett and Laid's party of Byad the [05:15] together party and a Victor Lieberman [05:18] yel betenu Israel our home party they [05:20] have 40ome seats okay [05:24] they there is a huge dispute between [05:27] Gaddyot and Victor Lieberman as to how [05:29] are they going to get 61 [05:32] Gaddy doesn't want to get to 61 GI [05:34] Azenat wants to either he either wants [05:37] to get to 61 with the Arabs or he wants [05:40] to get to 61 as a minority government [05:42] meaning there's only going to be a [05:44] government of 40ome people but the Arabs [05:46] will act as their like offensive linemen [05:49] to like they'll vote them into the [05:50] government and then they'll prevent the [05:51] government from falling and they'll help [05:53] out when needed but they're not really [05:55] going to be part of the government. [05:56] That's Gotti's preferred approach. A [05:58] Victor Lieberman says that's incredibly [06:00] short-sighted. We'll get a few things [06:02] done, but then the backlash on us will [06:05] be so intense that it will be as if we [06:08] were never in government. So, Victor [06:11] Lieberman wants to have the kharedim [06:13] join and he's been willing to compromise [06:16] on uh the uh enlistment issue, the the [06:20] draft issue for the karedim [06:22] >> at great cost to him by the way. [06:24] Correct. Unbelievable cost because it [06:27] has been to call it his signature issue [06:29] is an understatement. It's almost the [06:32] reason why people vote for him. [06:34] >> Correct. Correct. There a lot of [06:36] right-wing people who vote for him only [06:38] because of that issue and therefore [06:42] they have a dispute how they're going to [06:43] get the 61. And by the way, the karum [06:45] don't even seem like they're going to [06:46] they're willing to play bowl. One of the [06:47] kari parties is flirting with a Victor [06:49] Lieberman and this proposal and the [06:51] other one is saying no, we're part of [06:52] the rightwing. We're not even the the [06:54] shasaric party is like not even playing [06:56] bowl with this with this suggestion. And [06:58] so Gadia's like, "Okay, I'm not even [07:00] going to focus on building a coalition. [07:01] He's trying to take control of Kesset [07:04] and try and pass legislation." And [07:05] here's what I think he's trying to do. [07:07] There are a number of legislative moves [07:08] that he wants to make to appease his [07:11] base. Number one, he wants to undo the [07:14] judicial reform. Okay, that's huge for [07:17] many people in his base. [07:19] Um, number two is he wants to pass some [07:23] kind of law that will prevent BB from [07:24] running again. Okay. It could be a term [07:27] limits law. It could be a if you're [07:30] under indictment, you can't be prime [07:32] minister law. It but it's going to be [07:34] some law, maybe two or three laws that [07:36] will all be, you know, very nicely fit [07:39] on BB's current circumstance. Maybe [07:41] it'll be like, oh, there's a retirement [07:43] age or something like that. Maybe if you [07:45] have a certain number of grandchildren [07:47] or great-grandchildren, you can't be [07:49] prime minister. Tailor laws. What [07:51] they've actually said was they want to [07:52] make a law that anyone who's under [07:54] indictment [07:56] can't run, which is I mean under [07:58] indictment, let's be clear, under [07:59] indictment doesn't mean you did anything [08:01] wrong, [08:01] >> right? [08:02] >> Under indictment means that someone is [08:05] claiming you did something wrong. And [08:08] [snorts] [08:10] there's a prosecution there's an open [08:11] prosecution against you. That could [08:14] >> It's absurd, [08:15] >> right? It undermines democracy because [08:17] democracy that the people get to decide. [08:19] He was saying, "No, no, the people only [08:20] have certain choices, right?" [08:22] >> Um, so Gotti Eisenhot is um I think [08:26] that's what he's trying to do. If he [08:26] feeds enough meat to his rabbid base, [08:30] then when we then go to elections again, [08:34] he'll now have passion behind him and [08:37] that's what he's hoping for. Now, we [08:39] should point out that Natali Bennett, [08:42] who you know, there are some people who [08:44] play chess and some of them play [08:45] checkers and some people aren't playing [08:47] any games. Like, they're just not good [08:49] at any games. So, BB is like always [08:51] playing chess. He's like really smart. [08:53] Bennett thinks he's playing chess, but [08:55] he's actually playing checkers. Now, [08:57] checkers, [08:58] >> explain what you mean by that. [08:59] >> Sure. [laughter] In chess, [09:01] >> I like the analogy already, even though [09:03] I'm not exactly sure what you mean. In [09:05] chess, you have like multiple pieces [09:07] that can make multiple moves and you're [09:09] constantly asking yourself what the [09:11] various ramifications are and [09:13] >> and what's the other guy going to do? [09:14] >> What's the other guy going to do? But [09:15] it's not just what the other guy is [09:16] going to do because you have to think on [09:18] multiple levels. Not 3D chess. No, no. [09:20] You have to think, you know, the knight [09:22] moves in one way and the rook moves in [09:23] one way and the bishop moves in another [09:24] way and the king, you know, like all [09:26] these pieces move in different ways. [09:28] Therefore, you have to think at a much [09:31] more sophisticated level. When you're [09:32] playing checkers, all the pieces move in [09:35] one way. Okay, [09:37] you're going this way across the board [09:40] and you can jump people, but you still [09:42] have to think three, four steps ahead. [09:45] If I go here, they go here, then I go [09:47] here. Okay, you have to think multiple [09:49] steps ahead. So, if Bennett is good at [09:51] thinking them multiple steps ahead, he's [09:54] just not good in thinking about, you [09:56] know, what all the various p how the [09:58] various pieces can react differently. [10:00] It's always about one move, jumping [10:02] ahead. Okay, he's a jump ahead guy, [10:04] which is why he was successfully able [10:05] to, and we have to admire his ability to [10:08] do this. He became prime minister with [10:11] only seven seats. Like, that is a skill. [10:15] It's a talent. Unbelievable. [10:16] >> It's unbelievable. Never been done [10:18] before. Okay. So, he's moving to push [10:22] himself ahead. He views Gotti Eisenot as [10:26] a um an upstart who hasn't done anything [10:30] to earn this. He just happens to be the [10:32] guy who was behind Benny Gans. That's [10:35] what makes Gaddy Eisenhot worthy of this [10:37] position. But Ni Bennett wants that [10:39] position, right? Y laid wants that [10:42] position. So they're happy for Gotti to [10:46] go to elections and Gotti Eisenot to [10:47] kind of like flop on his face and and [10:49] and lose and they'll just gobble up his [10:51] seats or something like that. That's [10:53] what I think Neil Bennett is. But he's [10:55] also playing the angles. I don't think [10:57] he's like as antiBB as other people. I [10:59] think it's good enough rhetoric, but [11:01] Bennett is for one thing, pushing [11:02] himself ahead. And [11:05] >> that's what he's trying to It's an [11:06] interesting point on Bennett [11:09] before I tell you what I think Eisenut's [11:11] doing because I agree with you. I I [11:14] agree with you, but I think there's [11:15] something else that he's doing. So, it's [11:17] not to negate what you said. So, first [11:18] of all, on Bennett, but before we do [11:20] that, just a word from one of our [11:21] sponsors. Whether it's planting 700,000 [11:25] fruit trees across Israel, renovating [11:27] the strategic Mitzpe Yosef outlook that [11:31] overlooks Shahim and keeps a Jewish [11:34] presence in a very sensitive area, or [11:36] building a trauma center in Emanuel in [11:38] the Samaria, supporting Jewish farming [11:41] communities throughout Judea and [11:42] Samaria. These are all good things. If [11:44] you're watching this channel, you [11:45] probably agree. And that's just the [11:47] beginning. From Israel's life-saving dog [11:50] unit to supporting struggling soldiers, [11:53] their the widows of many of the fallen [11:55] orphans and at risk youth, the AM is El [11:58] Khai Fund is making an incredible [12:00] difference across Israel. And now for [12:02] the ninth year in a row of their dream [12:05] raffle, they are giving you the chance [12:07] to support all of these amazing [12:09] initiatives while entering to win, get [12:11] this, a brand new $1.3 million luxury [12:16] apartment in Jerusalem. Can you imagine? [12:17] It's a raffle. It's a really cool thing. [12:19] It's a raffle where you can win an [12:21] apartment in Jerusalem. [12:23] >> I mean, I love my apartment in [12:24] Ashkalone, but you know, I I don't know. [12:26] Do I want another apartment in Should I [12:28] buy a ticket? [12:28] >> I'd Yeah, [12:29] >> buy a ticket. Every raffle entry makes a [12:31] difference. Let me just finish this ad [12:32] read. Every raffle makes a Every raffle [12:35] entry makes a difference. Support [12:36] Israel. Enter to win. Make Jerusalem [12:37] part of your family's future. Visit the [12:40] dreamraffle.com/newstoday [12:42] or click on the link below, the link in [12:45] the description of this video. I think [12:46] that there's a very good chance [12:50] that Bennett wants to go into a [12:52] coalition government with Netanyahu [12:56] for a couple of reasons. The problem is [12:58] that Bennett does not control the entire [13:00] list that he was the top of. The party [13:03] that Bennett was was was on top of the [13:06] Bennett Laid list called Bey has 12 [13:09] seats, but seven of them are Bennett's [13:12] people and the other five are Leped's [13:15] people. And it's not necessarily the [13:17] case that if Bennett were to join Leud [13:21] with his seven seats that any more would [13:23] go. And because it's exactly seven and [13:27] Netanyahu's block has 53 seats. And that [13:30] would mean that if if Bennett joined BB, [13:34] there'd be 60. He has to get somebody [13:36] else. [13:38] That means you have to poach someone. [13:39] And one of the quirks of the Israeli [13:42] electoral system, and it's a very [13:44] strange quirk, and it's led to some very [13:46] serious issues in Israel's history, is [13:48] that although everyone people don't run [13:50] as individuals, you vote for a party [13:52] list, so if I'm number eight or number [13:55] 20 on a list that gets eight or 20 seats [13:58] and I get in, once we're sworn in, I'm a [14:02] total free agent and I can leave my [14:04] party, [14:04] >> right? [14:05] >> It's a it's bizarre and I actually think [14:07] it's anti-democratic. It's a very [14:09] strange law. [14:12] You get elected as part of a list, but [14:13] once you're in, it's your seat to do [14:15] with whatever you want. And we've had [14:16] this before where people have changed [14:17] parties after getting elected to Kesset. [14:20] And the the party on whose list they got [14:22] in on can do nothing about it. [14:23] >> Right? [14:24] >> In fact, that's how we got Oslo. People [14:26] don't remember this, but there were two [14:28] Knesset members who were part of Raful [14:30] Etan's party, which doesn't exist [14:31] anymore. The Sumat party, which is a [14:33] very right-wing party, who were [14:35] basically bribed. [14:38] I mean, [snorts] it was kind of obvious [14:39] they were bribed with with cars and with [14:41] and with ministry positions just to get [14:44] them to cross over and vote for Oslo. [14:49] Okay, these two guys. Um, [14:53] so Bennett, I believe that Bennett does [14:55] want to go with BB. I agree with I agree [14:57] with your assessment of him. He's purely [14:58] Machavevelian. He has no there's no [15:01] values here. But I think one of the big [15:03] drivers for Bennett, to go back to BB, [15:05] is that Bennett is much much better than [15:08] most Israeli politicians at thinking uh [15:11] about his political career long term. He [15:14] he is playing a long game [15:17] and he knows that the biggest stain on [15:20] his legacy and on his ability to draw [15:23] from all populations is the fact that he [15:26] was the person who broke the president [15:28] and formed a coalition with the Arab [15:30] parties. and he gets reminded of it [15:32] every single day. And the right-wing, [15:35] and this is a guy who used to be the [15:36] head of the Yesesha Council, used to be [15:38] the head of the council of communities [15:40] of Judea and Samaria. He was the darling [15:42] of the right. He was the super he was [15:44] the rising superstar on the right. [15:46] People viewed him as the the potential [15:48] first religious Zionist prime minister. [15:52] But he ended up becoming prime minister, [15:53] but not representing the religious [15:54] Zionist community. And he he threw a lot [15:58] of that goodwill away. most and that's [15:59] an understatement most of that goodwill [16:01] away when he when he made a coalition [16:03] with the Arabs and everything else and [16:04] everything he's done since then and now [16:05] this unity with Leed [16:08] I think he's looking at at what's going [16:10] on now BB's calling for unity's [16:13] looking worse by the day I think that [16:15] Bennett would love to be the savior who [16:19] also says that in the name of unity he's [16:21] willing to go in with BB and then he can [16:25] he will rebuild a lot of the political [16:27] capital in his mind and it it's to a [16:30] certain extent true he he'll rebuild [16:32] political capital on the right by doing [16:35] that by being the savior who comes in [16:37] and allows BB to form a coalition. Okay. [16:39] And this could also happen after a [16:41] second round of elections. That's on [16:42] Bennett. [16:44] Now on Eisenhot, [16:47] why is BB the prime minister now? He's [16:49] the prime minister because the way the [16:51] rules are written, the sitting prime [16:53] minister remains prime minister during a [16:56] transition, right? [16:59] I think that Eisenkott doesn't care [17:03] if his coalition lasts more than a day [17:09] as long as it gets voted in. [17:12] Meaning if he puts together a minority [17:14] coalition with the support of the Arab [17:16] parties [17:18] and they vote on it in the Knesset to [17:20] seat the coalition and it's a terrible [17:22] coalition and it doesn't really work and [17:24] it doesn't have 61 but they have 61 [17:26] voting for it. they get UTJ in because [17:28] they promised him something or Liberman [17:30] who whatever it is if they get 61 to [17:32] vote for some very fragile coalition and [17:35] he become he becomes sw he's sworn in as [17:38] prime minister and it collapses the next [17:40] day and we have to go to new elections [17:42] he's now the prime minister that whole [17:43] time until that next election gets [17:46] sorted out all those months of the [17:48] campaign and the election and the [17:50] coalition building that follows BB is [17:52] finally no longer prime minister [17:55] I think that's what he's And that's why [17:57] I don't I think he once you realize if [18:00] you get into his head where the number [18:02] one priority is getting rid of Netanyahu [18:04] that's his number one priority on the on [18:07] the website of the Ashar party in their [18:10] list of issues that the number one issue [18:13] was Netanyahu. They didn't say it in [18:14] those words. They said it that an [18:16] investigation into October 7th which is [18:18] code on the left for going after [18:20] Netanyahu. [18:21] Okay. But their whole campaign was about [18:23] Netanyahu. It's no secret that's his [18:24] number one priority. [18:26] Okay, look, you can see it also in in [18:29] everything that's being said. He's much [18:30] more willing to go in with the Arabs and [18:33] willing to go in with the than to go in [18:35] with Netanyahu. Those are the three [18:36] options he has in front of him. Okay. [18:39] So, I think that that's what he's doing [18:41] here. I think I agree with everything [18:42] you said about the legislation and the [18:44] fact that there's a taboo in Israeli [18:46] history of making of the prime minister [18:48] making any big decisions during a [18:51] transition. The same should be true of [18:52] the Knesset. There's never in the past [18:54] you don't have major legislation passing [18:57] during a transition period, [19:00] excuse me. So [19:05] anyway, that's where we are. We'll see. [19:07] We'll obviously have more updates on [19:08] this as we go. Let's change subjects and [19:11] uh and talk about uh and talk about the [19:14] main topic we wanted to discuss today. [19:15] Marco Rubio, Secretary of State, gave a [19:18] speech to the Federalist Society [19:20] National Lawyers Convention in [19:21] Washington DC. said a lot of very [19:23] interesting things in there and we're [19:25] going to play a couple clips and comment [19:26] on them. So, let's just get right to it. [19:28] Here is the first clip that uh wanted to [19:31] play here. Here we go. [19:34] But today, we are told by some that the [19:38] age of great nations pursuing great [19:40] destinies is over. That we cannot act. [19:44] We cannot impose ourselves upon the [19:46] world. that we must surrender our dreams [19:48] to the consensus of distant tribunals [19:51] and submit to our place as merely one [19:53] nation among the many. That we must [19:56] accustom ourselves [19:58] to the comfortable and to quiet decline. [20:02] We are told that our determination to [20:04] act on our own interests on our own [20:06] terms is an assault on the universal [20:09] quote unquote rules-based order. [20:12] For example, under this theory, the [20:14] president himself cannot execute the [20:16] foreign policy of the United States. He [20:18] cannot restrict trade or immigration or [20:20] even examine the way in which we spend [20:22] our citizens tax dollars abroad without [20:25] facing the fury of international lawyers [20:29] and jurists and NOS's and UN bureaucrats [20:32] condemning his threats to glo condemning [20:35] his threats to global values and norms. [20:39] All of this at home and abroad is a [20:43] child of the leveling and pessimistic [20:45] spirit of the age. It entices us to [20:48] relinquish responsibility for our own [20:51] destiny and to relieve ourselves of the [20:53] burdens of greatness and seek refuge in [20:57] these glittering generalities of [20:59] international law. [21:02] Even as we defeated the institution of [21:04] Soviet communism, [21:06] we did not triumph over the spirit of [21:10] Marx. [21:12] That spirit of Marx, it lives. It lives [21:15] on in these new forms and doctrines [21:18] which would subordinate the national [21:20] will to the menial consensus of the [21:23] world. Marxism sought to abolish the [21:27] extin the distinctions between men. The [21:30] radicals of our time seek to abolish the [21:33] distinctions between nations themselves. [21:38] >> There's so much in that. [21:39] >> It's a stunning clip. [21:40] >> It's a stunning clip. There's so much in [21:42] that clip. So, what struck me as I was [21:45] watching the speech when when he got to [21:46] this section. So, this came after [21:48] there's actually like about a a [21:50] 10-minute [21:52] section of the speech. This is the end [21:53] of it. And there's interlude in the [21:56] middle where he sort of sidetracks, but [21:58] there's a 10-minute block of the speech [21:59] where he talks about the globalists, the [22:02] intern the international criminal court [22:05] and the UN and all these apparatuses. [22:07] And this is the this is just a piece of [22:09] it. [22:11] And what struck me as so powerful is how [22:13] he called it Marxist. Because when [22:16] people think about Marxism, they tend to [22:17] think about uh economics or they think [22:19] about the cultural Marxism, the [22:21] wokeness, [22:23] but they don't necessarily connect that [22:25] to things like the United Nations [22:26] itself. [22:29] And that he talks about the the the [22:33] leveling [22:36] as a you know, as as a a feature of [22:39] Marxism that Marxism seeks to abolish [22:41] the distinctions between nations. [22:44] And I I don't think that people [22:47] understand enough [22:49] how dangerous [22:52] these these global institutions are. [22:54] When the United Nations was founded, it [22:56] was founded as a forum for dialogue. [22:59] That's it. Like literally nothing more. [23:03] It was a dialogue so that we can resolve [23:05] disputes and have greater peace in the [23:07] world. It which worked out absolutely [23:11] terribly. Okay? like it didn't I cannot [23:13] think of a conflict that [23:17] was prevented by the existence of the [23:19] United Nations. [23:21] Okay, I can think of many conflicts that [23:22] have been prolonged by the existence of [23:24] the United Nations, [23:25] >> resolutions to conflicts that have been [23:27] prevented by them. But but but casting [23:30] it as Marxism, I thought was very [23:32] powerful. U you know, I I just completed [23:36] the manuscript of a book that's going to [23:37] be coming out in a couple months. [23:39] >> Congrats. [23:40] >> Oh, thank you. Thank you very much. It's [23:41] about the It's about the red green [23:44] alliance about the alliance between [23:46] Marxism and u and Islam, but it takes a [23:51] completely different approach than you [23:53] generally hear out there. And that's the [23:54] reason I wrote the book because [23:56] generally people think of that alliance [23:58] as a pragmatic alliance, an alliance of [24:00] of convenience, that they share enemies, [24:02] right? Or that the socialists are just [24:05] complete morons and they're the useful [24:07] idiots of the of the Muslims. And [24:08] there's some truth to that. [24:12] But that doesn't explain why Abdul sayed [24:14] and Zoran Mani and these other Muslims [24:18] who were elected to the Congress are [24:20] also Marxists. [24:22] That's not an alliance between two [24:24] different groups. These are the same [24:26] people. There's no contradiction for [24:28] them. For Abdul Ali and Zoran Mandani, [24:30] there's no contradiction between [24:34] socialism, between Marxism and Islam. [24:37] They fit. You're never going to find an [24:39] Orthodox Jew [24:42] running as a Marxist [24:45] or an evangelical Christian running as a [24:47] Marxist. [24:50] But every Muslim candidate runs as a [24:51] Marxist, right? Meaning there's [24:53] something much deeper there. And I wrote [24:55] about the philosophical [24:58] um overlap, the theological overlap, if [25:02] you will, between these two movements [25:04] goes much, much deeper than what people [25:06] realize. There's a reason this alliance [25:07] has gone on for a century. Alliance [25:09] between between communists or Marxists [25:11] and and and Muslims. This is an decades [25:15] old institutional [25:17] u connections, [25:20] right? And the a lot of the the Islamic [25:22] terrorist groups are also Marxist. Like [25:23] it's it's a very in so that's what the [25:25] book is about. It really explores the [25:27] depth of this and you start to [25:29] understand what Marxism really is and [25:31] how it's it's an affront to the image of [25:34] God and man and where does sovereignty [25:37] come from, right? Where does sovereignty [25:39] come from? Why does anyone have the [25:40] right to rule over me? You know, if you [25:42] look in the Bible [25:44] when it comes to the appointment of the [25:46] king, [25:49] it's a unique introduction of a law. It [25:52] doesn't say, "Thou shalt appoint a [25:53] king." [25:55] It says, "When you come to the land that [25:57] the Lord your God gives you and you [25:59] say,"I [26:01] want to have a king, then you shall [26:04] place a king upon yourselves." [26:06] And but once you do that, understand [26:09] that the king is subject to the same [26:10] laws as everybody else. He can't have [26:13] too many wives. He can't have too much [26:14] money. Um can't have too many horses, [26:17] meaning he can't build up too much of a [26:18] military to go off on military [26:20] adventures. And what what he the only [26:24] thing he has to do is he has to study [26:26] the Torah every single day so that he [26:28] doesn't think of himself as better than [26:29] everyone else. [26:31] He's the king. [26:33] If you lived in the ancient near east [26:36] and you heard that, which the people who [26:38] received the Torah did, [26:42] you're like, "That's a joke. That's not [26:44] a king." The king is subject to the same [26:46] laws as everyone else. is supposed to be [26:48] is supposed to be humble and is is not [26:51] supposed to have too many m too much [26:53] money and too many wives and everything [26:54] else. Limitations on his power, but also [26:57] the the prerequisite for even having a [27:00] king is that the people have consent. [27:04] And when and when Moses is at the [27:07] beginning of Deuteronomy is retelling [27:09] the people some of the stories that took [27:10] place earlier and he's talking about the [27:12] appointment of judges, he said, "So I [27:14] came to you and I said, [27:20] What does he say to the people? You go [27:22] pick people. He says to the he went to [27:25] the tribes and he said you bring forward [27:27] people. In other words, he told them to [27:30] have some sort of democratic process [27:33] that they're supposed to choose the [27:34] people who will judge them. Sovereignty [27:37] comes from the bottom up [27:40] in the Bible. It's from the bottom up. [27:43] The only authority that is absolutely [27:46] mandated without consent is parent [27:48] child. It's the only one. Even the [27:51] authority of the Torah, God seeks the [27:53] consent of the nation of Israel. [27:56] Right? The So the idea is that authority [27:59] for who governs you comes from the [28:01] people. Now once it comes from the [28:03] people [28:06] and then that means that who who's [28:08] making decisions over me? Who's my court [28:09] system? These are people that we've [28:11] chosen that represent that they come [28:13] from us. The whole idea of global global [28:16] institutions [28:18] that govern everyone [28:20] that have a say in what nations do right [28:24] the again the sovereignty of a nation [28:26] flows upward from the people. [28:29] There's no room for global governance. [28:30] There's no room for an international [28:32] criminal court. It doesn't [28:34] philosophically it's it's blasphemous to [28:37] the concept of liberty to the concept of [28:39] of where power derives from. When God [28:42] enters into a covenant with us, he [28:44] introduces himself by saying, "I am the [28:46] Lord your God who brought you out of the [28:48] land of Egypt from the house of [28:49] bondage." Notice the Ten Commandments [28:52] don't begin, "I am the Lord your God, [28:54] creator of heaven and earth." Or, "I am [28:56] the Lord your God, God of your [28:57] forefathers, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob." [28:59] No, no, no. I'm the Lord your God who [29:01] granted you liberty. Now, let's enter a [29:03] covenant, right? Meaning, there's an [29:05] empowering of the individual, of the [29:07] people that happens. That's it runs [29:09] through every fiber of what's in the [29:10] Torah when it comes to authority. [29:14] And Marxism [29:16] is the opposite of that. [29:19] Marxism, the vanguard knows what's best. [29:21] Like all the Marxist revolutionaries, [29:22] they weren't the workers. They were like [29:24] the educated, you know, but they know [29:27] what's best for the workers, right? It's [29:30] a totally different view of power. [29:31] Anyway, this is what I was thinking as I [29:32] as I listened to to Secretary of State [29:34] Rubio. [29:35] >> That's 100% correct and and I actually [29:39] want to try and bring it to the level of [29:43] the individual. The the line that really [29:46] struck me um from Secretary Rubio was [29:51] to relieve the responsibilities of [29:54] greatness. M [29:57] >> and that's exactly what Marxism is [29:59] because what creates the distinctions [30:02] between peoples in a free society. [30:06] It is the choices that they make. One [30:09] person decides that they are going to [30:11] spend their time studying. The other [30:13] person decides they're going to play [30:14] spend their time playing basketball. One [30:17] person decides that they are going to [30:19] hustle and work harder. And the other [30:21] person decides that they are going to [30:22] watch television. One person decides [30:24] that they are going to exercise. The [30:26] other person decides that they're going [30:27] to get drunk or do drugs. And [30:32] what happens is that you have people who [30:37] become real go-getters. They aren't [30:40] necessarily born as go-getters, but you [30:42] can make yourself into a go-getter. And [30:44] a fundamental message of the Torah, [30:46] right? We see this both in the story in [30:48] the Garden of Eden and the story of Cain [30:50] and Abel is that you have free choice [30:55] and your choices matter. They will [30:58] impact your life. And so if you believe [31:01] that you have the ability to make these [31:03] great choices, then there's going to be [31:06] a significant group of people who do [31:08] make those great choices. They say, "I [31:11] want to improve life. I want to make [31:13] life better. I want to discover new [31:15] things, to build new things, to you know [31:19] just to to to learn new things [31:23] and you have an when you have an entire [31:25] society like that they become explorers [31:28] and you know engineers and inventors and [31:32] all sorts of things get made that you [31:34] can't predict. [31:36] >> This you've just hit on something really [31:37] important. [31:37] >> What happens but here's what happens. [31:39] >> Go ahead. Good. You then have a society [31:41] that has achieved greatness because they [31:44] chose to achieve greatness. And [31:46] everybody else, the ones who are doing [31:48] drugs and watching television and and [31:50] and and wasting their time with with [31:52] with idiocy, they don't understand [31:56] the amount of time and investment and [32:01] intentional creativity. Yes, there are [32:03] some people who are born creative, but [32:05] there are other people, they're not born [32:07] creative, but as they learn how things [32:10] work, right? They are able to understand [32:14] where there's opportunity to grow and [32:16] create. That's what the Bible calls [32:18] wisdom. Wisdom is you understand how [32:20] things work and therefore how to [32:22] maximize your ability to live with that [32:25] thing. Okay? So [32:28] the people who haven't gone through this [32:30] process, [32:32] they number one don't understand how [32:35] where it comes from or how to achieve it [32:37] and therefore they become jealous of the [32:41] the success of other people and [32:43] therefore their only response is to aim [32:46] for equality of outcome. But equality of [32:49] outcome can't be engineered because it's [32:52] dependent on free choice. It's [32:54] >> dependent upon the actions and choices [32:58] of men and by men I mean human beings. [33:00] Yes. [33:00] >> Okay. And therefore the only response is [33:03] we need a leveling. [33:05] >> We need a leveling at the national [33:06] level. We need a leveling at the [33:07] individual level. We need a leveling at [33:09] the the the family level. We need a [33:12] leveling at the economic level. Right? [33:14] So [33:16] that's that's what h right families some [33:20] families choose to have more children. [33:22] Some families choose to have fewer [33:23] children. Okay. But that's [33:25] >> exact consequence 10, 20, 30 years down [33:28] the road. [33:28] >> Choice and responsibility. [33:30] >> Yes. [33:31] >> Choice and responsibility is one of the [33:34] central themes of the biblical [33:37] worldview. [33:39] And and it was revolutionary at the [33:41] time. I just said what I said about the [33:43] king, the biblical view of a king being [33:46] absolutely revolutionary, even [33:47] blasphemous to people in the ancient [33:49] near east where kings were viewed as [33:51] embodiment of God on earth and were not [33:53] subject to the same laws. But at the [33:55] same time, choice and responsibility. [33:57] ancient Neareastern religions would that [33:59] the Bible came into smash [34:02] were very similar to well both Marxism [34:05] and Islam [34:07] in the belief that your position in life [34:12] is kind of faded. Now uh Marxists who [34:16] are atheists wouldn't say faded. They [34:18] would say it's been forced on you by the [34:21] powers that be. But it's not your fault. [34:24] >> Right? Meaning [34:26] putting responsibility on on some other [34:29] power for my position in life [34:33] is number one a core idea in anc in in [34:37] ancient Mesopotamian paganism where I [34:39] have to try to appease the gods so that [34:41] they so that they don't destroy my crops [34:44] and and make and and so that my wife, [34:46] you know, gives birth, you know, and but [34:49] I'm at their whim. [34:50] >> Right. [34:51] >> Right. And in Islam, it's totally [34:54] submission. And you know the [34:57] >> you need no free choice. [34:58] >> There's no free choice. There's no free [35:00] will. [35:02] There's an interesting passage in the [35:03] Quran where in the Quran where there uh [35:07] there's there's rewrites of a number of [35:09] biblical stories. So the famous one is [35:11] that like it says that Abraham brought [35:13] Ishmael as as an offering. But there's [35:15] one that's very interesting, very [35:16] subtle. It has the story of Abraham [35:20] arguing with God over Sodom and [35:23] Gomorrah, over the destruction of Sodom [35:24] and Gomorrah. [35:27] In the biblical account, Abraham argues [35:29] with God over the moral issue, the [35:33] ethical issue, and God accepts Abraham's [35:35] ethical argument, right? He accepts it. [35:38] It just turns out that there aren't [35:40] enough righteous people. But God accepts [35:42] in principle Abraham's argument. The [35:44] human being can argue from ethics and [35:46] morality. And this is before the Torah [35:47] is given. [35:49] He's he's a he's an agent who can argue [35:52] that story in what happens in the Quran [35:54] is Abraham starts to argue and God [35:57] basically tells him to shut up. Allah [35:58] basically tells him you don't [36:00] understand. You don't know. Keep quiet. [36:02] Wow. Which is actually the opposite [36:05] message. [36:06] Meaning it takes the story and actually [36:08] inverts it. [36:08] >> Right? [36:09] >> The human being has no agency, no [36:11] ability to understand. So what's [36:13] demanded is total submission. Right? [36:16] Marxism demands total submission from [36:18] everyone. And that's why you get shouted [36:19] down. That's why they don't care about [36:20] free speech, right? Think about cultural [36:21] Marxists. It's a mindset. They don't [36:24] It's subconscious [36:26] because it demands total submission. The [36:28] Bible empowers [36:30] Islam and Marxism both call for [36:32] submission. They're actually moving in [36:33] opposite directions in the human [36:35] condition. [36:36] >> Right. [36:36] >> Right. See, now you're already getting [36:38] these are some of the these are some of [36:39] the ideas in my book. [36:40] >> I I want to go one step further. [36:42] >> Sure. [36:43] Um, one of the probably the most famous [36:46] Islamic philosopher is a person named Al [36:49] Gazali and he promoted the idea of [36:51] occasionalism. Occasionalism, it's a big [36:54] fancy word. What it basically means is [36:56] that anytime something happens, it's [37:00] because God willed it to happen. So, if [37:01] I take a bite of an apple, it tastes [37:03] like an apple because at that moment, [37:06] God wills it to taste like an apple. and [37:08] my next bite also tastes like an apple [37:10] because God wills it at that moment to [37:12] taste like an apple. But here's why. [37:14] It's not merely about the theory of [37:18] occasionalism. [37:20] All of science and technology is based [37:23] on my ability to recognize patterns of [37:26] cause and effect. And therefore, once I [37:29] recognize a pattern of cause and effect, [37:31] I can then tap into and say, "Oh, this [37:34] is what happened. I let go of my phone [37:35] and it drops." because that is a rule [37:39] and then I can tap into it and then I [37:40] can build technologies that harness it [37:42] that overcome it right but something is [37:45] predictable but occasionalism is [37:47] fundamentally unpredictable [37:49] >> this this is why so this is the point [37:51] now I'm remembering the original point I [37:52] wanted to make in response to you and [37:53] then we'll go to the next clip which is [37:56] that when what you said about science [37:59] and about innovation that comes from a [38:02] certain these ideas these basically [38:05] biblical mindset said, "Call him [38:08] Judeo-Christian." I don't like that [38:09] term. I prefer biblical because that's [38:10] really that's just that's the shared [38:12] book and that's where this all comes [38:13] from. Um [38:17] there's a reason why science [38:20] flourished in the Christian world, [38:23] >> right? [38:23] >> Why technology developed there, why [38:26] innovation and [38:28] that's why these things happen there. [38:30] Because if you live in under in a [38:31] society that believes you're sort of [38:33] faded to be whoever you are, [38:36] you're faded to be in whatever position [38:38] you're in. [38:41] That actually suppresses progress. [38:43] Anyway, let's move on to the next clip. [38:45] There's so many we can go on. We could [38:46] do a whole we could we could do a whole [38:47] hour on each of these clips. So, here's [38:49] the second clip. This one uh this clip [38:52] that we're going to look at is well, [38:54] we'll just play it and we'll talk. Here [38:56] we go. [38:58] Yeah. So [38:59] >> I think your faith [39:01] attorney is what you do. Your faith is [39:03] who you are. And so I I think that [39:07] [applause] [39:12] and if you speak specifically about [39:13] Christianity as your faith, then I would [39:15] say this is a faith that teaches that [39:17] your job is to care for the less [39:19] fortunate, to feed the hungry and clothe [39:21] the naked and visit the prisoner, which [39:23] you'll do often if you're a defense [39:24] attorney. And uh and but I and I also [39:28] think embedded in our system of [39:29] government in our system of laws is very [39:31] powerful Judeo-Christian principles [39:33] about the dignity of the human being and [39:35] of the individual which our legal system [39:37] ultimately recognizes. Because if you [39:38] think about our criminal justice system [39:39] for a moment, it's built on the notion [39:41] that no matter how guilty someone may [39:43] be, they are entitled to the most [39:44] vigorous defense and that it is the [39:46] state's job to prove the case against [39:49] this person. Because a human life and [39:50] human freedom is so valuable that you [39:53] must overcome extraordinary obstacles in [39:55] order to ensure that if you're going to [39:57] put someone in jail, you the evidence [39:59] and the burden is on your side to prove [40:00] it. In essence, not the other way [40:01] around. We take that for granted. But in [40:03] many parts of the world, you're presumed [40:04] guilty. And your job is to go in there [40:06] and convince them that you're not [40:07] guilty. In our country, in our system of [40:10] law, you're presumed innocent, even [40:11] though everybody knows you did it [40:15] right. But that isn't because we're nice [40:17] people. It's because that embedded in [40:19] our Judeo-Christian values is the belief [40:21] that the individual and the freedom of [40:23] that individual is san is something [40:26] that's sacred because it's given to us [40:28] by our creator. Our very founding [40:30] documents speak to the fact that our [40:31] rights don't come from government. Our [40:33] rights don't come from the law. Our [40:34] rights are not determined by whoever [40:36] happens to be leading us every two, four [40:38] or six years. Our law, our rights come [40:40] from our creator. They are they are [40:42] inherent in us as a person. So I think [40:44] you bring that into the legal [40:45] profession. Now I don't know how it [40:46] applies to a real estate contract, but I [40:48] can tell you how it applies to a [40:49] criminal justice system and to our [40:51] broader system. So I would just say that [40:52] your faith should inform you in what you [40:54] do. And I think ultimately it's a faith. [40:56] You spoke again that you're a Christian. [40:58] Christianity teaches us, as you said, [41:00] not just to care for the less fortunate, [41:01] but also to value human dignity and the [41:04] dignity of all people uh irrespective of [41:06] the circumstances they come from. And I [41:07] think these are things we want to [41:09] encourage in the legal profession, not [41:10] discourage. [41:13] [applause] [41:16] Let me just point out that this was not [41:18] part of his speech. This is in the [41:19] question and answer session, right? [41:21] >> So something so eloquent and so deep was [41:24] not part of his prepared remarks. just [41:26] saying your thoughts. [41:29] >> There are really two parts of his [41:30] answer. The first is where he talks [41:33] about that our rights come from God uh [41:35] and not from man and then is able to [41:38] explain because if they came from man [41:39] that means they would constantly change [41:41] every time there's a new election or a [41:42] new desperate um you know and we should [41:45] contrast this with Senator Tim Kaine who [41:48] recently said that no our rights come [41:50] from the agreement of men in the [41:53] constitution and not from God because he [41:55] does not want God being part of [41:57] >> that's rouso [41:58] >> right um so So, [42:02] Secretary Rubio um you know goes from [42:06] and I'm going to do this in reverse [42:07] order [42:09] because [42:11] that's how deep he's he's thinking. [42:14] Okay. He starts off with our rights come [42:17] from God. And when you have a society [42:21] that believes that your rights come from [42:23] God, that means [42:26] that number one, those rights can't just [42:28] willy-nilly be changed based on who's in [42:31] power. But more importantly, your entire [42:33] criminal justice system is aligned to [42:37] making sure that the person accused [42:41] um you have to prove that he is the one [42:43] who is guilty. He does not have to prove [42:45] his innocence, but you have to prove he [42:46] is guilty. And we we should recognize [42:49] not only how novel this idea is when you [42:51] go back to like you know the history of [42:53] humanity and how trials were conducted [42:55] and you know all the all the the sham [42:57] trials that existed but Secretary [42:59] Rubio's to ability to articulate all [43:03] this going from like the most basic [43:06] foundation [43:07] of our rights come from God to therefore [43:12] if you're a criminal defense attorney [43:14] make sure you do your best job. um you [43:17] know, defending defending your client. [43:19] His ability to go from the the big [43:21] picture ding to the the the details [43:26] five steps later is really incredible. [43:27] But there's a second point here and that [43:30] is he's basically saying this idea of [43:34] separation and church and state that [43:36] doesn't exist. There is no such thing as [43:39] a separation of church and state because [43:42] our fundamental values have left and [43:46] will continue to leave an imprint on how [43:48] we operate. And if we try to remove [43:50] religion, church from [snorts] the [43:52] state, then you're going to have [43:54] something like Tim Kaine, Senator Tim [43:56] Kaine saying that like, oh, our rights [43:58] come from man or something like that. [44:00] And then we'll see just people being [44:02] persecuted and prosecuted [44:04] because the state thinks that they are [44:06] guilty, right? Which is actually [44:08] sometimes happens with certain [44:09] government agencies. They have the [44:10] ability to find you without ever having [44:12] gone to to trial. And that's one of the [44:14] um issues that's being, you know, um [44:17] litigated right now. But [44:20] we should recognize that, you know, [44:24] number one, the the the first amendment [44:26] of the constitution has what's called [44:27] the non-establishment clause. It's not a [44:30] separation of church and state. That's a [44:31] later addition. It's really the [44:32] non-establishment clause that no that [44:34] that the government will not have an [44:36] established church. States at that point [44:39] had established churches. Um but [44:43] Secretary Rubio's ability and this is [44:45] what I think all Americans need to be [44:47] able to do is they need to say we are a [44:52] biblical nation and that means our [44:54] rights come from God and therefore that [44:56] leads to the following consequences in [44:58] terms of our criminal justice system. [45:01] And when Americans have that deeper [45:03] understanding, [45:05] then what you have is a society where [45:07] people are united around not just [45:09] certain values, but a certain way of [45:11] things operating. And much of the [45:13] discord that we've seen in the last few [45:15] decades has become is because that has [45:18] been broken. [45:20] I I love that. you know, and the when [45:23] you get down to the legal system, [45:26] he's talking about like he's talking to [45:27] a bunch of young uh law students and [45:29] young lawyers [45:31] and about bringing their faith into into [45:33] their practice. [45:35] Part of what he's saying is that you are [45:38] not when you go into a courtroom to [45:40] defend someone, let's say, or just or [45:42] even to defend your side in a in a [45:45] contract dispute, [45:48] who are you appealing to? [45:52] Are you appealing to the will of the [45:54] sovereign [45:56] or are you appealing to a just a concept [46:00] of truth and justice? And where does a [46:03] concept of truth and justice come from? [46:05] Right? Meaning there's a higher set of [46:07] ideals and that's why it's so important [46:09] that the sovereign [46:11] is [46:13] no individual human being. There's a [46:15] quote I want to share with you. Um, [46:18] another shameless plug from my book. [46:20] This is this this conversation obviously [46:22] everyone's now interested in my book [46:23] hopefully. Um, it's going to come out in [46:26] a few months. It's not even available [46:27] for pre-order yet. We just finished the [46:29] manuscript. It's getting getting [46:30] prepared. [46:31] >> The title is already said that the title [46:33] is a match made in hell, [46:35] >> the political theology of the Red Green [46:37] Alliance. But uh and I and I do quote [46:39] this also in my book [46:42] in Little House on the Prairie in the [46:44] set of books by Laura Ingles Wilder. [46:46] There's a scene where they're at a you [46:49] know it's children's books but they're [46:50] they're at a Fourth of July celebration [46:54] and this is like in the 1880s right in [46:56] the Dakota Prairie but later became [46:58] South Dakota. [47:01] >> And Laura is like a young girl. She's [47:02] like 14 years old. [47:05] And at the Fourth of July celebration, [47:08] they read the Declaration of [47:09] Independence publicly, which was [47:11] commonly done on Fourth of July in [47:13] America. That should be brought back. [47:16] >> But they would have public readings of [47:17] the Declaration of Independence. And [47:18] they would sing songs. And then so at [47:21] this scene, they they read the [47:22] declaration and then they sang the song, [47:24] My Country Tis of Thee. There was no [47:26] national anthem yet. Star Spangle Banner [47:27] was not the national anthem yet. That's [47:29] a much later uh development. It was one [47:32] of many patriotic songs that people [47:33] would sing. But the song My Country T of [47:36] Thee, My My Country T of Thee, Sweet [47:39] Land of Liberty, right? Which a lot of [47:41] people don't under even understand the [47:42] the uh the rebelliousness of the fact [47:45] that it's sung to the tune of God Save [47:47] the King. And it's all about and it's [47:49] all about throwing off the King. the [47:51] final stanza. So in the book in Little [47:53] House on the Prairie in actually the [47:54] book called Little Town on the Prairie. [47:57] That's the volume in the set. [47:59] There's a passage where it describes [48:02] Laura at this event and she hears the [48:05] declaration being read which of course [48:08] you know the uh you know talks about you [48:11] know the where our rights come from and [48:13] then it says it quotes the last stanza. [48:17] Our father's God, to thee, author of [48:22] liberty, to thee we sing, long may our [48:26] land be bright with freedom's holy [48:28] light. Protect us by thy might, great [48:32] God, our king. And here's what Laura [48:35] Ingles Wilder wrote. [48:40] She wrote, [48:42] "The crowd began to scatter, but Laura [48:44] stood stock still. Suddenly she had a [48:47] completely new thought. The declaration [48:49] and the song came together in her mind [48:51] and she thought God is America's king. [48:54] She thought Americans won't obey any [48:56] king on earth. Americans are free. That [48:58] means they have to obey their own [49:00] consciences. No king bosses pa. He has [49:03] to boss himself. Why? She thought when [49:06] I'm a little older, Pa and Ma will stop [49:08] telling me what to do. And there isn't [49:10] anyone else who has the right to give me [49:11] orders. I will have to make myself be [49:14] good. Her whole mind seemed to be [49:17] lighted up by that thought. This is what [49:19] it means to be free. It means you have [49:22] to be good. [49:24] Our father's God, author of liberty. The [49:28] laws of nature and nature's God endow [49:32] you with a right to life and liberty. [49:34] Then you have to keep the laws of God. [49:37] For God's law is the only thing that [49:40] gives you a right to be free. [49:43] >> Wow. [49:43] >> Isn't it a wow? This is I read this many [49:46] years ago. I was reading a bedtime story [49:48] to one of my to my daughters. We used to [49:49] read like a chapter a night of that [49:51] series to to my youngest daughter before [49:53] we went to bed. And it was my turn to [49:55] put her to bed. And I read this chapter [49:57] and it's a deep piece of theology. I [50:00] mean it's like a very sophisticated [50:02] piece of theology about how if you don't [50:06] if you throw off the yoke of human [50:08] sovereignty and God is your sovereign. [50:13] Yeah, you have a government but that [50:14] flows upward from the people. If God is [50:16] your sovereign, [50:20] that's the only thing that allows you to [50:22] be free. [50:24] That's the relationship with God. That's [50:26] that first line of the ten commandments. [50:27] I'm the Lord your God who grants you [50:29] liberty. Right? And then and now then [50:32] now what does that mean? That means that [50:33] you now have responsibility. You're [50:35] sovereign, right? Because otherwise you [50:37] end up giving into your vices and [50:39] passion and chaos ensues and there's an [50:43] anarchy and all people want is some [50:46] outsider to come in and reestablish [50:49] order. [50:50] >> Exactly. [50:51] >> Isn't that stunning? [50:52] >> Stunning quote. Yeah. It's amazing [50:54] quote. [50:54] >> So I turned that into a whole chapter in [50:56] the book. I I unpacked that quote. I [50:58] connect it to the Bible. [51:00] >> You're going to love this book. You're [51:01] going to love it. Sure. Yeah. [51:02] >> All right. Last uh last clip. Let's play [51:04] one more. [51:06] >> And this one follows right after that [51:08] one. Okay. This is all this is like [51:09] literally this is the next uh minute. [51:12] It's the next minute of the of the uh of [51:16] what he said. [51:18] >> The second on the on the point of [51:19] economics and this is just my personal [51:21] point of view. Look, I believe in the [51:23] free market, but I don't worship the [51:24] free market. I think the market exists [51:27] to serve people, not people to serve the [51:28] market. The market is a tool to achieve [51:31] to to provide for human achievement and [51:33] prosperity. [51:35] But there's also a national interest. It [51:37] has to be balanced. I think the market [51:39] works when it does two things. It [51:40] provides wealth and prosperity, but it [51:42] also provides opportunity for people to [51:44] find dignified work. So, we have to do a [51:46] better job of understanding that there's [51:48] no absolutes here. And ultimately, the [51:49] market is an example is a tool. I think [51:51] we have to recognize that people are [51:52] struggling. There's no doubt about it. [51:54] There's no doubt, and I think the [51:55] numbers are clear, that younger people [51:58] today are further behind than their [52:00] peers were 20, 30, 40 years ago. And to [52:02] ignore that would be to close our eyes. [52:03] I think we sometimes forget that yes, [52:06] I'm not saying the stock market is [52:07] irrelevant and unimportant. But for most [52:09] people, the health of our economy has [52:11] nothing to do with the stock market. The [52:12] health of their economy is whether they [52:14] have enough money to be able to afford [52:15] the things they need and want. That's [52:17] how they judge the health of our [52:19] economy. So, we do have a lot of work to [52:21] make these arguments. People call it [52:22] populism. I just call it common sense. I [52:24] think it's important though. [52:27] >> Your thoughts? [52:29] >> He's getting at the major dividing point [52:32] within the conservative movement. There [52:34] is, you know, for the last 30 years, we [52:37] have seen people who call themselves [52:39] conservative, but all they actually [52:41] cared about was free markets. And those [52:45] free markets led them to outsource [52:49] production and manufacturing from the [52:51] United States to other places in the [52:53] world. And that right and obviously [52:56] things made in China are going to be [52:58] cheaper. Why? China doesn't pay their [53:00] workers anything. Obviously things made [53:02] in Mexico are going to be cheaper. Why? [53:05] Because people there make destitute [53:08] wages. Okay? They they don't they don't [53:11] have minimum wage laws. They don't have [53:12] like work safety, you know, the [53:15] factories don't have to like install [53:17] certain kinds of like fireproof [53:19] materials like, oh, they used asbestos [53:21] in in in the building 50 years ago. [53:23] Okay, great. Go to work anyway. Right. [53:25] That's what [53:26] >> and they can and and we can pay them [53:28] bare sub subsistence wages for sure. So, [53:31] so there are all these costs. Making [53:34] things in America costs more. [53:37] >> That's 100% true. But making things in [53:39] America, having an in a a domestic [53:44] industry means that you are having a [53:47] healthy economy. Let me say it a little [53:48] differently. [53:50] The people who said all that matters is [53:52] the free market, they basically said the [53:55] companies are going to get rich while [53:58] the workers become not just poor but [54:01] jobless. They took all the poor [54:03] people's, the lower classes jobs and [54:06] they shipped them off to foreign [54:08] countries. And so the people who ran the [54:11] companies can make greater profits [54:13] because there were more things to sell, [54:16] but it actually harmed America. And what [54:21] se Secretary Rubio was saying is yes, [54:24] we're not going back to a merkantile [54:27] economy where we're just protecting our [54:29] own industry for the sake of protecting [54:31] our own industry. But if America is [54:34] going to decide that there are minimum [54:36] wage laws and there are work safety [54:38] standards, then it has to own the [54:40] responsibility for that and make sure [54:42] that at least any other place that is [54:45] being produced abide by those laws. [54:47] >> But they're not. They're they're [54:49] circumventing the whole thing. The the [54:50] whole thing's ridiculous. They created [54:51] laws to help workers, but the laws ended [54:54] up harming the workers as all these [54:56] companies shipped everything out and the [54:58] stock market not which not all Americans [55:01] are invested in. Like your main income [55:04] should not be from the stock market. It [55:06] should be from the work of your hands. [55:08] >> Yeah. The moral point you're making is [55:09] so powerful that if we believe that it [55:12] is immoral for workers to not be paid a [55:15] living wage and taken care of with [55:17] safety standards, etc., then [55:21] how can we allow an American company to [55:24] ship its jobs overseas [55:28] to use basically slave labor, [55:31] >> right? [55:31] >> Why is that legal? Right? In other [55:34] words, why [55:36] any that that's a great point, but you [55:39] also raised a very important point. You [55:40] know what what he said here about how [55:42] listen, we're into the free market, but [55:44] it's supposed to make people's lives [55:45] better and [55:48] we need some sort of balance. Like you [55:50] said, that people consider themselves [55:51] conservative when all they care about is [55:52] the free market. [55:54] Look at the Bible again. [55:57] In the Bible, we have something that [55:59] looks on the surface like some sort of [56:01] redistribution. We have in the jubilee [56:03] year where everyone's land all the land [56:06] goes back to its original owners. People [56:08] who ended up in indentured servitude [56:10] because because of whatever happened in [56:13] their lives, they lost everything. They [56:14] went bankrupt. They committed crimes. [56:16] They then get a fresh start. They get [56:18] their land back. It looks like [56:20] redistribution. But you know there was a [56:21] French economist in the middle of the [56:23] 20th century named Bertrand Deuvenel who [56:25] gave a series of lectures that was [56:27] published as a little book called the [56:28] ethics of redistribution. [56:30] really he was an anti-redistributionist. [56:32] He was a but he makes a really powerful [56:35] point in in this book in this these [56:38] lectures where he says [56:40] he he mentions the biblical jubilee and [56:42] he says it looks like redistribution but [56:45] it's not because in Marxist [56:48] redistribution it's a redistribution of [56:50] outcome and that's what makes it [56:51] immoral. [56:54] This is a redistribution of resources [56:57] which is is not just a a minor [57:00] difference. It's everything because [57:02] what's immoral about Marxist [57:03] redistribution is that I don't get the [57:05] fruit of my labors are not mine. [57:07] >> Right? But here we're redistributing the [57:10] the raw material. And what does that do? [57:12] It prevents long entrenched oligarchies [57:15] from forming [57:17] because people can't just accumulate [57:19] more and more and more and more land [57:21] which ultimately is what gives people [57:22] the most power. They can't because every [57:25] every Jubilee it's all going to get [57:26] redistributed and go back to whoever the [57:28] original owners were. Everyone gets a [57:29] fresh start with their new resources. [57:31] So we actually have in the Bible a free [57:34] market, a very very free market with all [57:37] kinds of incentives built in to keep it [57:40] free, but at the same time built into it [57:43] are correctives, [57:44] >> right, [57:45] >> to make sure that that everyone is [57:48] everyone is given an opportunity. It's [57:50] really it's really the ideal there. And [57:52] you know, again, we could have, you [57:54] know, we could have made three episodes [57:55] about this Rubio speech and um why don't [57:58] you tell everyone what you're going to [57:59] be doing with the speech in your own [58:01] material you're putting out. [58:02] >> Sure. So, in in a a video earlier this [58:05] week, I spoke about how Secretary Rubio [58:09] um you know, the main idea was that we [58:12] have to impact the culture. We have to [58:15] make sure and the American culture has [58:17] to stem from our understanding of [58:20] American history. Our understanding of [58:23] American history is forms our American [58:25] identity. It gives us the fuel to power [58:29] through the difficult times. That was [58:31] what I spoke about in in the main, you [58:33] know, in a video uh a few days ago [58:36] >> on this channel. [58:37] >> On this channel, uh the name of the the [58:39] name of the podcast is called Culture [58:42] Matters. Um the tagline being if [58:44] politics is downstream from culture then [58:46] culture matters. Um and yes matters is [58:50] both the noun and the verb. Um the the [58:53] and what I'm going to be talking about [58:54] is he he had a great uh analysis of why [58:58] we need to be involved in Iran. Uh, so [59:01] I'm going to be talking about that part [59:03] of his speech and I'm going to try and [59:04] delve a little bit deeper into uh the [59:07] contrast between um him and uh Senator [59:10] Kaine about where our rights come from [59:13] and what that means and what Senator [59:15] Kaine is trying to do. [59:16] >> All right, great. We'll leave it there. [59:18] >> Rafie, thanks again for doing this. [59:20] Always a pleasure every week. Yes. [59:22] >> And uh please drop a comment, make [59:23] suggestions to us, things that you like [59:25] or or think we can improve about this [59:27] podcast. And uh please uh share this. [59:29] Make sure you subscribe to the channel [59:30] and that you're catching everything [59:32] we're putting out every day. God bless.