Transcript [00:01] Good afternoon and welcome to the Middle [00:03] East Forums weekly podcast. My name is [00:05] Lauri Regan and on behalf of MEF, I [00:07] thank you all for joining today and for [00:08] your continued support of the critically [00:10] important work that we do. This [00:12] afternoon, I'm very excited to be joined [00:13] by the brilliant Gods, an evolutionary [00:16] behavioral scientist, author, and a [00:18] leading public intellectual who often [00:20] writes and speaks about ideal pathogens [00:22] that are destroying logic, science, [00:24] reason, and common sense. He hosts the [00:26] Sad Truth podcast and is currently a [00:28] visiting professor at the University of [00:30] Mississippi, having spent much of his [00:32] career as a professor at Concordia [00:34] University in Montreal. God is the [00:36] author of numerous books, including The [00:37] Parasitic Mind: How Infectious Ideas Are [00:40] Killing Common Sense, and his new book, [00:42] which he'll be discussing this [00:43] afternoon, Suicidal Empathy: Dying to Be [00:46] Kind Copy is Here, particularly in the [00:49] context of current events surrounding [00:51] Israel, anti-semitism, Islamism, and the [00:53] Decline of the West. I'm going to spend [00:56] the first part of the podcast discussing [00:57] these important issues with God and then [00:59] we'll open the discussion to audience [01:01] questions. So, if you have a question, [01:02] please use the Q&A function at the [01:04] bottom of your screens. And please do [01:06] limit your questions to questions only. [01:09] Um, I'll do my best to get as many of [01:11] your submissions as possible in the [01:13] brief time that we have together. [01:14] Today's podcast is being recorded and [01:16] will be available for future viewing. [01:18] So, please do share this link with those [01:19] in your networks who you think would be [01:21] interested in learning more on this [01:22] important and timely topic. Um, Gad's [01:24] insights are important and should be [01:26] heard far and wide. And in that context, [01:28] I highly recommend that you follow his [01:29] work, which um you can do on X. Thank [01:32] you, Gad. And, uh, appreciate you [01:34] joining us this afternoon. [01:36] >> It's so good to be with you, Lori. Uh, [01:37] just a quick question before we even [01:39] begin. Are you by any chance related to [01:42] a professor of psychology at Cornell [01:44] named Dennis Rean? [01:47] >> I am not. I usually get, am I related to [01:49] Ronald Reagan, but no, I am not. Okay. [01:52] Okay. Fair enough. [01:54] >> Um, so Gad, I wanted to start by asking [01:56] you to share with our audience the [01:57] premise of your book and what you mean [01:59] by suicidal empathy. I know that the [02:01] book begins with the following quote. [02:03] Um, suicidal empathy is a tragic [02:06] manifestation at the civilizational [02:08] level of the well-known proverb, the [02:10] road to hell is paved with good [02:11] intentions. So, what exactly, God, is [02:13] suicidal empathy? And could one make the [02:15] argument that many of the people [02:17] suffering from it have actually become [02:19] evil given their lack of a moral [02:20] compass? Right. So to your second part, [02:23] absolutely emphatically yes. But let me [02:26] explain what uh empathy is versus [02:28] suicidal empathy. And I'll begin with an [02:31] analogy. Cancer cells divide and healthy [02:35] cells divide. The only difference [02:38] between the two is that the former have [02:41] unchecked cell division. They don't have [02:43] a stopping mechanism for the division to [02:46] stop. Now why is that related to the [02:48] distinction between empathy and suicidal [02:50] empathy? Well modulated empathy is a [02:54] perfectly rational virtue for humans to [02:57] possess. We are a social species. [02:59] Therefore we interact with each other [03:01] for you and I Lori to have a meaningful [03:03] conversation. I need to put myself in [03:05] your mind and vice versa. That's called [03:07] cognitive empathy or theory of mind. So [03:11] there's nothing wrong with [03:12] well-calibrated empathy. Suicidal [03:15] empathy though does something akin to [03:18] what cancer cells do. It hyperfires [03:22] in the wrong situations towards the [03:25] wrong targets. Once that [03:28] rational empathetic module is gamed, it [03:33] becomes suicidally [03:35] uh you know faulty. Now and let me draw [03:39] another very quick reference. Aristotle [03:41] several thousand years ago explained [03:43] through his golden mean the idea that [03:46] too little of something is not good. Too [03:48] much of something is not good. And much [03:50] of life is about finding that sweet [03:52] spot, that golden mean. That exact [03:55] principle applies to empathy versus [03:57] suicidal empathy. No empathy renders me [04:00] a psychopath. Too much empathy towards [04:03] the wrong targets makes me suicidally [04:06] empathetic. [04:08] >> Thank you. It's such an interesting [04:10] premise and and we're going to get into [04:11] it in a lot of different contexts. But [04:13] um you know many of us in this space for [04:16] a very long time have been speaking and [04:17] writing about the decline of the west [04:19] where arguably many Western European [04:20] countries may be past the point of no [04:22] return and the US may be on its way to [04:24] joining them. You're the first person to [04:26] recognize the role that hypermpathy can [04:29] act as a deadly contagion is is the term [04:32] that you used in your book and that if [04:33] not properly contained it it can destroy [04:35] the west. How is suicidal empathy [04:38] destroying the west and is it too late [04:40] to stop it? Perhaps also god when you [04:42] answer the question can you tie in the [04:44] James Bham observation that you quote in [04:45] your book liberalism is the ideology of [04:48] western suicide [04:49] >> right uh if thank you for mentioning his [04:51] work it actually I think his book came [04:53] out in 1964 which happens to be the date [04:55] of my uh birth. So there you go. Uh look [04:59] there are many many ways by which [05:01] suicidal empathy manifests itself. Uh [05:03] and of course in the book I go through [05:05] an endless number of cases whether it be [05:07] in criminal justice whether it be with [05:09] climate alarmism right let's stop [05:11] producing children because otherwise we [05:13] are raping mother earth. Well for a [05:15] sexually reproducing species where there [05:18] are two functions that you have to [05:20] achieve. First survive and then [05:22] reproduce. If you if suicidal empathy [05:25] erases your survival instinct and if [05:27] suicidal empathy tells you don't [05:29] reproduce because you need to be [05:30] empathetic to mother earth, that's [05:32] probably not a good civilizational [05:34] outcome. But let's discuss a few [05:36] specific ones. By far the one that is [05:40] most existentially dangerous to the west [05:43] is the open border immigration policies [05:47] of the west. And now let me here link [05:49] because you so kindly mentioned one of [05:51] my other books parasitic mind with [05:53] suicidal empathy. Those books are [05:55] actually in a very meaningful way [05:58] related to one another. It's a it's a [06:00] suicidal empathy is in a sense a sequel [06:03] to parasitic mind. In the parasitic mind [06:07] I was looking at what happens when [06:09] parasitic ideas [06:12] hijack your cognitive system your [06:14] thought processes. But we are both a [06:16] thinking and a feeling animal. So in [06:18] order for me to completely hijack your [06:20] ability to navigate the world, I also [06:23] have to hijack your affective system, [06:25] your emotional system. And that's where [06:28] suicidal empathy comes in. And let me [06:29] show you specifically how one leads to [06:32] the other as related to open border [06:34] policies. Cultural relativism is an idea [06:37] pathogen that I discuss in parasitic [06:39] mind. So cultural relativism regrettably [06:43] was originally espoused by a Jewish [06:46] anthropologist by the name of France [06:48] Boaz about 100 years ago basically [06:51] argues that you are in no position to [06:53] ever make moral, ethical, legal, [06:57] societal, cultural judgments about how [07:00] an other society adopts its own values, [07:04] its own behaviors. So if another culture [07:06] wishes to cut off the clitorises of [07:08] 5-year-old girls, shut up racist. If [07:10] they wish to have honor killings, shut [07:12] up racist. If they wish to have child [07:14] brides, shut up racist. Well, if I [07:16] internalize that parasitic idea called [07:19] cultural relativism, it then renders me [07:22] impotent to be able to make judgments in [07:26] my immigration policy because it's wrong [07:28] for me to then argue that people in [07:31] Waziran and Afghanistan [07:33] are less likely to assimilate than [07:36] native Swedes or Danish people into the [07:38] United States. That feels wrong. That [07:40] feels go. So there is a direct line [07:43] between adopting these parasitic ideas [07:46] and then becoming susceptible to [07:48] succumbing to suicidal empathy. To your [07:50] question as to whether it's feasible for [07:52] us to get out of this or not, but well [07:54] your point about the the the 1964 book [07:57] is liberalism by virtue of it. I mean, [08:01] to put it in in my framework, by by [08:03] virtue of the Democrats, the leftists, [08:06] the hyper liberal folks, the [08:08] progressives being the party of empathy, [08:12] then by definition, that's going to [08:14] render them more likely to be [08:15] susceptible to to suicidal empathy. [08:19] >> Thank you, God. Um, I I I also serve as [08:23] the vice president treasurer of Scholars [08:24] for Peace in the Middle East, and I've [08:26] been writing and speaking about the [08:27] problems on our college campuses for [08:28] decades. So I'd love to hear your take [08:30] on the role that academia plays in the [08:32] spread of this disease. And it's clear [08:34] that many of our young minds have been [08:36] indoctrinated to hate America, Israel, [08:38] and the West more more broadly. But [08:40] where does suicidal empathy come into [08:42] the brainwashing? And is there a way to [08:44] deprogram these kids, right? [08:46] >> Um you know, I'm sure your experiences [08:47] at Concordia played a role in your [08:49] understanding of the problems at Western [08:51] University. So we'd love to hear maybe [08:53] some personal examples that you have as [08:54] well and perhaps explain what you mean [08:56] when you discuss the feminization of [08:58] academia. [08:59] >> Right. So look, [09:02] every single parasitic idea that I [09:05] discuss in the parasitic mind which [09:07] eventually leads to suicidal empathy. [09:09] Every single one stems from university [09:12] campuses because it as I to sort of [09:16] channel my inner well who mentioned this [09:19] many decades ago. It uniquely takes [09:22] intellectuals to come up with some of [09:24] the most devastatingly imbecillic ideas. [09:27] Now why is that? Is it because [09:29] intellectuals are dumb? No. It's because [09:31] many intellectuals operate in an [09:33] ecosystem that is perfectly decoupled [09:36] from the autocorrective slap of reality. [09:39] Right? So, I can sit up as a humanities [09:41] professor in my tweet jacket and say [09:43] that up is down, left is right, men are [09:45] women, and then I'm hailed as a great [09:48] thinker of lesbian dance theory and I [09:50] get promoted to becoming a tenure [09:52] professor. I don't get punished for [09:54] espousing nonsense. I go upward the more [09:57] insane my ideas are. Right? And so, to [10:01] your first question, every single bad [10:04] idea that leads to suicidal empathy [10:06] comes from academia. Now, in terms of [10:09] personal anecdotes, well, in a sense, I [10:12] started writing the parasitic mind the [10:15] day that I became a professor. Although [10:17] not not literally writing it, but [10:19] writing it in my head because my [10:22] scientific work [10:24] outside of my public commentary is in [10:26] applying evolutionary psychology to [10:29] study human behavior in general and [10:31] consumer behavior and economic behavior [10:33] in particular. So, I've historically [10:35] been housed in a business school. Well, [10:37] to me it it can't make sense that you [10:40] could study employer behavior, employee [10:43] behavior, investor behavior, consumer [10:45] behavior without ever invoking the [10:48] biological heritage of those creatures. [10:51] You would never study any other species [10:55] without invoking its biological [10:57] heritage. But there's only one species [10:59] that exists outside of the realm of [11:02] biology and they're called human beings. [11:04] And so that was the my first exposure to [11:07] to uh oh Houston, we seem to have a [11:10] problem because how could all of these [11:11] colleagues of mine that are supposed to [11:13] have many titles before their names and [11:14] after their names be such walking [11:16] imbeiles? Like there's nothing [11:18] particularly incendiary about arguing [11:20] that hormones affect our economic [11:23] behavior. How else could it be [11:25] otherwise? But to them who were [11:27] inculcated and trained within the social [11:29] sciences, that's completely heretical to [11:32] say something like that. So that would [11:34] be the first sort of grand personal [11:36] experience of how I discovered that [11:37] there was a problem. But then in being a [11:39] professor for 33 years, I started seeing [11:42] stuff that is espoused on university [11:44] campuses that simply is insane. So for [11:47] example, many universities in Canada, [11:50] including the one that I was at [11:51] formerly, now engage in a systematic [11:55] decolonization [11:57] and indigenization of the entire curses [12:00] of the curricula across the entire [12:03] university. Meaning for those of you who [12:05] don't know those those idiotic terms [12:06] like decolonization and indigenization [12:09] that means you can't truly study [12:12] neuroscience or Shakespeare or consumer [12:15] psychology or engineering without you [12:18] incorporating the guiding light of our [12:21] indigenous forefathers. No, science is [12:26] specifically liberating because it frees [12:30] us from the shackles of our personal [12:32] identities. I don't do Lebanese Jewish [12:35] evolutionary psychology. I just do [12:38] evolutionary psychology. That's what [12:40] makes the scientific method so great. So [12:43] it's rife with this nonsense in [12:45] academia. For example, we don't give [12:47] professorships [12:48] to the most worthy and meritocratically [12:53] relevant people. We give them based on [12:56] diversity, inclusion, equity. I'll give [12:57] you one specific personal example since [12:59] you asked for that. University of [13:01] Waterlue is akin to MIT or Caltech. It's [13:05] one of our top one of our meaning in [13:08] Canada. I'm now in the US. Uh one of the [13:10] top Canadian engineering and computer [13:12] science schools. Well, a couple of years [13:13] ago, they put out a call for Canada [13:17] research chaired professorships, meaning [13:19] these are chaired professorships that [13:20] are endowed by the Canadian government. [13:22] So, it's a very prestigious [13:24] professorship. They were looking to [13:26] attract the top talent in artificial [13:29] intelligence and computer science. [13:32] Both open positions [13:35] required that only people who are [13:38] twospirit [13:39] gender non-binary and whatever all the [13:42] other terms of gender whatever uh only [13:46] those people could apply. This is coming [13:50] from the endowed chair of the Canadian [13:52] government at one of the leading [13:54] institutions. So if I am a twospirit [13:57] non-binary person, I could get that [13:59] professorship. If I am the smartest [14:03] artificial intelligence researcher who [14:05] happens to be Christian white male and [14:08] I'm attracted to women, we're not [14:10] interested in you. [14:12] >> Amazing. It's really amazing. Um, [14:16] I'm going to turn to our people, Jews. [14:20] Um, one problem of concern for me is the [14:22] fact that many Jews both in Israel and [14:24] the diaspora suffer from suicidal [14:26] empathy. And um, in fact, I I actually [14:29] wrote a column a few years ago entitled [14:30] God is Testing American Jews. They're [14:32] failing. from the producers of this [14:34] Israeli movie Naza and you know most of [14:36] the opinion writers at Harets to Brad [14:39] Lander and the 30% of New York City's [14:41] Jewish population who voted for Amdani [14:43] in you know in Congress we've got Bernie [14:45] Sanders Adam Schiff Jamie Rascin in [14:47] Hollywood we've got Hannah Einbinder and [14:50] you know all the other anti-Israel folks [14:52] there and and then we've got our Jewish [14:53] NOS's from J Street and Ben the Arc if [14:56] not now and I could go on and on. I [14:58] mean, there's a lot of j dangerous Jews [14:59] who hide behind there as a Jew high road [15:02] on all things Israel. Um, so as an [15:05] evolutionary behavioral scientist, [15:06] Scott, are you able to explain what's [15:09] wrong with so many Jewish people and why [15:11] after close to 4,000 years of [15:12] persecution, we have yet to build up [15:14] immunity to the suicidal empathy [15:16] disease, which is presumably what makes [15:18] us disregard our own survival instinct? [15:21] >> Yeah, fantastic question. Thank you for [15:22] that. Uh, are you familiar? I you said [15:24] earlier that you you follow me on social [15:26] media and I actually also mentioned the [15:28] term in the book. Are you familiar with [15:29] my term of wood cricket juice? Do you [15:31] know what that is? I [15:32] >> I have heard you discuss it. Yeah. [15:33] >> Okay. But maybe it's worth mentioning it [15:35] to to your audience because it actually [15:37] does apply an an evolutionary/biological [15:40] framework to explain this. The the [15:42] reason why I use the neuroparacy [15:45] framework and I know it's a mouthful so [15:47] let me explain it. Parasettology is [15:49] simply the study of parasite host [15:52] interaction. So, a tapeworm is a [15:54] parasite, but it parasitizes my [15:56] intestinal tract. A neuroparasite is a [15:59] parasite that gets to your nervous [16:01] system, to your, in this case, your [16:03] brain, altering your behavior in order [16:07] to suit its reproductive interest, [16:09] meaning it has literally hijacked you. [16:12] Now, a wood cricket is an is insect that [16:16] abhores water. It wants nothing to do [16:18] with water. But when it is paracetized [16:20] by a brainworm called the hairworm, the [16:23] hairworm needs the wood cricket to [16:26] happily and merrily jump into water, [16:29] commit suicide, hence suicidal empathy [16:32] in order to adhere to the reproductive [16:36] interests of the hairworm at the cost of [16:39] its survival. So now you see why that [16:42] neuroparistical framework is not only a [16:45] powerful metaphor, but it is a literal [16:48] functional explanation for why I'm [16:51] willing to give up my own survival [16:53] imperative in order to adhere to a [16:56] grander ideological commitment. In this [16:59] case, I am infinitely tolerant and kind. [17:01] So what all of those Jews that you [17:03] mentioned and many others, none perhaps [17:06] greater than the completely degenerate [17:08] lobotomized Gabbor Mate, who is a trauma [17:11] expert, who is, you know, a not only is [17:13] he Jewish, but he is a Holocaust [17:15] survivor. Now, let me just break this [17:17] down a bit for you. At at the age of 6 [17:20] months old, he was passed off to a [17:22] family to be protected. 6 months old [17:25] infants cannot build memories. [17:28] Therefore, they're not cognizant of [17:30] anything that they experienced when they [17:32] were 6 months old. But yet, he uses the [17:35] impremature of being a I am Jewish. I [17:38] gabbor mate and I am a Holocaust [17:40] survivor. And I'm telling you that there [17:43] is nothing worse than Israel. Not only [17:46] are they the new Nazis, they actually [17:48] outrank the Nazis that I myself am aware [17:51] of. Well, if he is a Holocaust survivor, [17:54] then I too am a Holocaust survivor [17:56] because as I remind people, I was once [18:00] in my dad's testicles in the 1940s. [18:03] Therefore, I too was technically [18:05] existentially a Holocaust survivor. Now, [18:07] it sounds I'm being spicy and [18:09] provocative, but it's because it [18:11] demonstrates [18:13] what happens to the minds of a [18:15] parasetized Jew, right? But it takes [18:17] Jews like myself who had to wear running [18:20] shoes, good running shoes, and really [18:22] run fast to outrank outrun the ones who [18:25] were going to behead us to then come to [18:27] the west and say maybe you need to be a [18:29] bit less tolerant from your beautiful [18:32] campus at Oberlin College where you [18:34] learned about near east studies and [18:36] leave it for those who sampled from the [18:38] buffets of society to tell you what the [18:40] real deal is. So yes, there are [18:42] explanations that I offer for these [18:44] people. And I should mention to your [18:46] audience, there is no one I despise more [18:49] than the wood cricut Jew because at [18:51] least the ones who want to kill the Jews [18:53] are committed to their cause. But when I [18:56] say, "Oh, please take me." And, "Oh, by [18:59] the way, my children are upstairs, so [19:01] please go rape them. Look how tolerant I [19:03] am." I really despise you. [19:07] >> Great examples. Thank you, God. Um I I [19:09] want to tie Islamism into the [19:11] conversation also because I think it [19:12] serves as one if not the most dangerous [19:14] enemy of Western civilization. Um we've [19:17] established that suicidal empathy leads [19:19] to people doing things and taking [19:20] positions that are anathema to their own [19:22] survival as you just pointed out and um [19:24] I would suggest that in inviting [19:26] unvetted and untold numbers of Muslim [19:27] immigrants into Western civilizations um [19:30] as to which they have no interest in [19:31] assimilating is expediting the decline [19:33] of the West. Um you pointed out I'm [19:35] going to quote you from your book. The [19:36] West suicidal empathy is an aphrodisiac [19:39] to those stemming from to those stemming [19:41] from cultures with a supremacist and [19:43] doineering ethos. My first memory of [19:46] Western suicidal empathy was when um [19:48] George W. Bush stated almost immediately [19:50] after 911 that Islam is peace. And [19:52] you've pointed out that Canadian Prime [19:54] Minister Mark Carney recently proclaimed [19:56] that Islamic and Canadian values are the [19:58] same. Today, anyone who presents an [20:01] honest critique of Islam's connections [20:03] to terrorism is labeled an Islamophobe [20:05] and forced to apologize or cancelled. [20:08] So, chapter 3 of your book, I I think [20:10] you do a phenomenal job of discussing [20:11] all of this, and I'm sure the audience [20:13] would love to hear your thoughts on [20:15] this, including your discussion of of [20:17] what I call stealth jihad, in which [20:18] Islamists recognize that they don't need [20:20] weapons to conquer the West. [20:22] >> Yes. Another great question. Uh, one, [20:25] forgive me, you're the host. One small [20:27] correction if I may. You use the word [20:29] only once. I've never heard of that [20:31] word. I don't know what it is. You use [20:33] the word Islamism. I don't know where [20:35] where are the cannons of Islamism that [20:37] are distinct from Islam. And I'm being [20:39] facicious because I the point that I'm [20:41] making is there is no such thing as [20:43] Islamism. There is no such thing as [20:45] radical Islamism. There is no such thing [20:48] as self-radicalized militant jihadi [20:51] Islamism. Because if I put a bunch of [20:53] qualifiers before the word Islam and [20:56] then I add the magical suffix ism, then [20:59] somehow I'm saying something that is [21:01] different from Islam. There is no such [21:03] thing. The quicker people stop using [21:07] that very kind and empathetic reflex, [21:10] the better that we will be. Now, that [21:12] doesn't mean that every Muslim wishes to [21:15] implement the doctrinal canonical [21:19] imperatives of Islam. That's clear. I [21:22] know more nice Muslims than most people [21:23] in your audience will ever meet. But [21:25] those two statements are perfectly [21:27] consistent with each other. There are [21:29] nice people that are Muslim or Jews and [21:31] mean people that are Muslim or Jews. But [21:34] Islam is a very specific set of codified [21:37] ideas as enshrined in the Quran, the [21:41] hadith, the the sayings and the deeds of [21:43] Muhammad and the S, the biography of [21:46] Muhammad. that content is very clear [21:49] about whether Islam is congruent in its [21:52] foundational tenants with Western values [21:56] or or not. And let me get to the punch [21:59] line. You couldn't have come up with a [22:03] set of doctrines that are any more [22:07] inongruent with Western values. Like in [22:09] other words, if I told you, here's your [22:11] homework assignment. come up with a set [22:13] of beliefs that are maximally in [22:16] congruent with Western values, it would [22:19] be called Islam. So, it's a terrible [22:23] tragedy because the Muslims are [22:26] incredibly smart in their ability to [22:29] understand what the weakness of the West [22:31] is. That's why they have told us [22:33] repeatedly to your point about what [22:34] you're calling stealth jihad is that [22:36] we're going to conquer the West through [22:38] three means. We're gonna conquer the [22:40] West through the womb of our women, [22:43] right? We breed 7.2. You're too lazy to [22:47] even have enough sex to reproduce beyond [22:51] the replacement rate. It's just a matter [22:54] of time, inshallah, when we will [22:56] outgreed you. Number two, we will [22:59] conquer the West through Hijra. Hijra is [23:01] the Arabic word. Arabic is my mother [23:03] tongue. So, it's kind of tough for [23:06] people say, "But he doesn't understand. [23:07] He doesn't know. His name is Joe Smith [23:09] and so on, right? Hijra is the term for [23:13] migration. Well, how great is it that [23:16] when the West faces 9/11 and all the [23:19] other terrorist attacks attacks and [23:21] George Bush then says, "I will not [23:23] tolerate any attacks on Islam. And I'm [23:26] going to show you that I won't tolerate [23:27] it by letting in 5 million people into [23:29] my country, many of whom celebrated [23:31] 9/11." That's probably not a good idea. [23:33] And the third way we're going to conquer [23:36] the West is by using your miserable [23:39] freedoms against you. So, but this is [23:42] not I did some deep dive sad [23:46] investigative journalism to arrive at [23:48] that. They have been standing on top of [23:51] the mountain and screaming their plan [23:53] for all of us to hear for decades. And [23:56] we go la, I don't want to hear it. Your [23:59] grandchildren are going to pay a deep [24:00] price for that. [24:02] Thank you, God. Um, there's a number of [24:05] questions and we're going to uh get to [24:06] as many as we can. Um, somebody asked, [24:08] "Is secular humanism particularly [24:10] vulnerable to unmmerited guilt?" [24:14] >> Unmmerited guilt of of which type? [24:16] Existentially guilt guilt like [24:19] >> I think in the context of suicidal [24:20] empathy he's asking. [24:22] >> I mean, I don't I don't think there is [24:24] necessarily a uniquely direct link from [24:27] secular humanism to feeling guilty or [24:30] not, right? I mean Catholicism is is [24:33] rooted in guilt, right? We are born [24:36] sinners and therefore we you know we [24:37] have to go to confession. So so the the [24:40] road of experiencing existential guilt [24:42] doesn't have to come with whether I am [24:44] religious or not. Both groups of people [24:47] can succumb to existential guilt. I [24:49] think the main reason for our [24:50] existential guilt is because we have uh [24:53] promulgated the idea that not only is [24:56] the west not a great civilization, it's [24:59] actually the most evil of all [25:00] civilizations because we are [25:02] transphobic, we are Islamophobic, we sit [25:04] on stolen land, we are misogynistic. So [25:08] how else can I solve that problem but [25:11] then to commit civilizational sepuku as [25:14] I introduced the term sepuku is a term [25:17] that captures how the Japanese used to [25:19] engage in self-d disembowelment when the [25:22] samurai class would engage in a behavior [25:24] that was shameful while civilizational [25:26] sepuku I argue you're using the blade of [25:29] suicidal empathy to engage in the [25:31] existential self-d disemboundment of [25:33] your society but no it is not unique to [25:35] secular humanists [25:37] So, um, I'm going to turn back to [25:39] audience questions in a second, but I [25:40] realized I I I also wanted you to talk [25:42] about postmodernism because the [25:44] sufferers, excuse me, of suicidal [25:46] empathy seem to make up their own truths [25:48] and facts and reality. And you there was [25:51] an Albert Einstein quote in your book [25:52] that um you included that uh quote, "Two [25:55] things are infinite, the universe and [25:57] human stupidity, and I'm not yet [25:59] completely sure about the universe." I [26:00] love that quote. [26:02] >> Yes. Uh [26:03] >> does does Yeah. Go ahead. Yeah, forgive [26:06] me for interrupting. Uh, postmodernism [26:08] of all of the parasitic ideas that I [26:10] cataloged in the parasitic mind, I argue [26:13] is the granddaddy of all parasitic [26:16] ideas. Meaning that it is the the apex [26:19] parasitic idea. Why? [26:22] Because it rejects the notion that there [26:25] could be universal truths. It even [26:28] rejects the notion that there is an [26:30] epistemology of truth. Like for example, [26:32] the scientific method is the [26:35] epistemological tool that we use to [26:37] adjudicate between competing scientific [26:40] hypotheses. Well, we've replaced that [26:43] now in in academia through feminization [26:47] with an epistemology of care. In other [26:50] words, the the central premise of a [26:53] university is not to create new human [26:56] knowledge and distribute that new human [26:59] knowledge and intellectually enrich our [27:01] students and so on. It is to be [27:04] maximally caring. So for example, if I'm [27:07] going to do a research program that does [27:10] advance scientific and you know human [27:13] knowledge, but in doing so I end up [27:16] hurting someone's feelings, then I [27:19] should refrain from engaging in that [27:21] research and therefore it becomes a type [27:23] of forbidden knowledge as I discussed in [27:24] suicide empathy. So postmodernism is the [27:27] worst of all parasitic ideas because [27:30] everything is up for grabs. up is down, [27:32] men are women, slavery is freedom, war [27:34] is peace. Who are you to tell me what [27:36] truth is? [27:38] >> So, following with that, somebody asked, [27:40] "How can we use the progressives own [27:41] vocabulary to defeat them?" Um, if we [27:44] don't use their language, they don't [27:45] listen to us. Do you have any thoughts [27:46] on that? [27:48] >> I mean, I don't necessarily have a top [27:51] of mind strategy of how to use language. [27:53] I mean, the the best language I have is [27:55] this thing called truth. This is why I [27:58] speak. [28:00] I could be as professorial, if not a lot [28:03] more professorial than most other [28:05] professors, maybe all of them, but I can [28:08] also be very spicy and direct and [28:10] frontal because I'm so exasperated by [28:15] all of the untruths and the lies that [28:18] there is no better way than to speak [28:20] plainly and truthfully. And this is why, [28:22] by the way, I use things like satire, [28:25] why I use sarcasm, why I use humor. It [28:28] may or may not surprise you, Lori, to [28:30] know that of all the people that, you [28:32] know, approach me in the streets, [28:33] probably the number one thing I often [28:35] get is I was watching one of your videos [28:38] and I couldn't stop laughing for 10 [28:40] minutes now. Is it because I I didn't [28:43] really want to become a professor and I [28:45] wanted to be a stand-up comic and that's [28:47] why I use humor? No. It's because I will [28:49] use all communication modalities that I [28:53] consider to be relevant to get my [28:56] message across. So in that sense, I'm [28:58] answering the question which is use all [29:00] possible tools to to defend and protect [29:03] the truth from all the nonsense. [29:07] >> And in a sort of similar vein, somebody [29:09] asked, can the word Islamophobia be [29:10] linked to suicidal empathy because it [29:13] propagandizes the fear of Islam as [29:15] illogical? [29:16] >> Exactly. And that that's why those the [29:18] the Muslim uh you know activists were [29:22] brilliant in understanding the [29:24] weaknesses the Achilles heel of the west [29:26] right by by the way that reflex of you [29:29] know using language to you know uh [29:32] advance your cause [29:34] comes from postmodernism. It actually [29:37] comes from a variant of postmodernism [29:40] called deconstructionism. [29:42] Jacqu Deerida would be the sort of the [29:44] the pioneer of that that quote field. It [29:47] basically says that language creates [29:49] reality, right? There is no objective [29:52] reality out there that is outside that [29:55] which we name. And that's why it becomes [29:58] very important for the progressives to [30:00] play all those linguistic games because [30:02] then I can shift your understanding of [30:05] the world based on what I label the [30:06] world. [30:09] Um, do do you know if there are any [30:11] examples of suicidal empathy in the laws [30:13] of the Torah? [30:16] >> I don't. That's what a great question. [30:18] >> I I mean uh [30:21] I I'm thinking of sort of the opposite [30:23] of suicidal empathy. Take your insulent [30:26] children to the gates of the city and [30:28] stone them to death. That seems to be [30:30] maybe on the other side of suicidal [30:33] empathy. Your child is insolent, they [30:35] die. Um, I mean, I can think of things [30:39] that relate to suicidal empathy, not so [30:42] much in the Torah, but in the New [30:44] Testament, right? Because, and I guess [30:46] you might, right, turn the other cheek, [30:48] love your enemy, and so on. And I I [30:50] referenced that very briefly in suicidal [30:53] empathy. Do you have any readily [30:55] available examples that you might want [30:56] to share with me? [30:58] >> It was a question from one of our [31:00] listeners. I see. I Yeah. No, I'm sorry. [31:02] I I personally do not have that [31:04] familiarity and I wasn't you don't [31:06] either. [31:07] >> Yeah. I can't think of a readily example [31:10] in the Torah of suicidal empathy. Maybe [31:12] that's a good thing. [31:13] >> Yeah. Um so there's there's somebody [31:16] that is coming back to Islam Islamism [31:19] Islam um and asking you know whether [31:22] questioning whether there are nice [31:23] Muslims because aren't they sort of the [31:26] Trojan horse of global jihad? you know, [31:28] claiming to be moderates and reformers [31:29] and um not actually being so and and [31:32] that real moderate Muslims are are [31:34] probably more like Ayan Herciel who has [31:38] converted. Thoughts on those on that? [31:40] >> Right. Look, uh [31:43] I don't necessarily pay attention to [31:47] needing to light the Shabbat candle at [31:51] 4:21 because Kabad has said that it's [31:54] 421. based on that metric, then I'm not [31:57] a very practicing Jew. Uh I don't [32:00] necessarily not eat shrimp soup because [32:03] there is a kosher law against shrimps. [32:06] Then by that measure, I'm not practicing [32:08] Judaism. But you'd be hardressed to find [32:10] someone who lives their Jewish heritage [32:13] and has many death threats for being [32:15] Jewish. Right? So why am I saying this [32:17] example? because you could be wedded to [32:20] your Jewish heritage or your Islamic [32:23] heritage or your Christian heritage [32:24] without necessarily adhering to all of [32:28] the cannons of that faith. Correct? So, [32:30] I don't practice a gentle form of [32:33] Judaism where we do eat shrimps. I just [32:37] ignore the parts that I don't wish to [32:40] pay attention to. And that in no way [32:43] negates the fact that I belong to a [32:46] nearly 6,000-year heritage of a peoples. [32:49] And in that sense, I'm very much wedded [32:51] to my Jewish heritage. So I think the [32:54] exact same thing could apply to someone [32:56] who comes from an Islamic background. [32:58] They grew up in a culture. They were [33:00] born in Bahrain or they were born in [33:02] Morocco. They don't know what's in the [33:04] Quran. They don't care what what are the [33:07] in you know the imperatives that say [33:09] that the entire world has to be [33:11] Islamized under the flag of Allah. They [33:13] just want to live their lives and they [33:14] happen to be born into a Muslim. So in [33:16] that sense they're good people, lovely [33:19] people who don't wish anybody harm. And [33:21] so it's in that sense that I say we have [33:23] to grant some sort of uh place for those [33:27] people to be able to exist, right? [33:29] They're just good people who would [33:31] invite me over for a humos sandwich and [33:35] they would not be decapitating me. But [33:37] to your [33:39] the person who asked that question, [33:42] there is the issue of why so many [33:46] nonmilitus [33:48] are not [33:50] actively fighting against the stuff in [33:53] their religion that is problematic. [33:56] Right? So you may have 2 billion Muslims [33:58] of which only 10% are insanely violent. [34:03] That makes 200 million people. We're [34:05] left with 1.8 billion people. How many [34:08] of those are being complicit in the goal [34:10] of the 200 million? Regrettably, the [34:13] number is quite high. So I think we need [34:15] to offer some sort of goodness to many [34:19] people who just wish to live their [34:20] lives. That's why I always try to remind [34:22] people that of course there are nice [34:23] Muslim neighbors who don't wish you ill. [34:26] But again, I focus on Islam. If I am a [34:30] fully practicing Muslim, could I truly [34:33] coexist within Western values? And the [34:35] answer is an emphatic no. [34:37] >> So the the last question um somebody [34:40] asked, "What do you suggest we do to [34:42] fight the suicidal empathy?" So I think [34:43] this is a good opening maybe for you to [34:45] touch on your your final chapter to the [34:47] book on inoculation. [34:48] >> Yes. So exactly to to to what you just [34:51] said in the last chapter in chapter 8 I [34:53] offer a an I mean a vaccine against [34:57] suicidal empathy and I offer you know [35:00] very very specific prescriptions. So let [35:02] me give you one or two of these but then [35:04] I'll give a a broader sort of 30,000 [35:06] foot uh answer. So for example, many [35:09] people are intoxicated by the prospect [35:13] of the immediate effect of the dopamine, [35:17] the empathy based dopamine hit. So the [35:20] illegal refugee knocks on the door and I [35:23] can do two things at that point. I could [35:25] let in 6 million of them and I will [35:29] immediately be drowning in the dopamine [35:32] because I am stroking my luxurian hair [35:34] in the mirror of moral preining and [35:36] going look what a good person I am. I [35:39] just let in 400,000 Ahmeds into my [35:41] society. I'm better than those people [35:43] who would have judged them. So I got [35:45] that dopamine hit but in doing so I'm [35:48] stuck in what's what I call the myopia [35:51] of first order effects. Meaning there is [35:54] a second order effect and a third order [35:56] effect. If your society becomes majority [36:00] Islamic, then we will have a different [36:02] reality than the one that your children [36:04] grew up in. So don't succumb to the [36:07] empathy based dopamine hit. Recognize [36:10] that life is not a first order world but [36:14] has a domino effect. So that would be [36:16] and I I list many others. For example, I [36:18] talk about the false equality bias. Men [36:21] and women are equal under the law. [36:23] They're not equal in their proclivities. [36:26] Religions might be equally protected by [36:29] the first amendment, although I think [36:30] they shouldn't be. That doesn't mean [36:32] that they are equally likely to [36:34] assimilate within the western tradition. [36:36] So don't confuse equality under the law [36:39] as being indistinguishable. Right? Men [36:41] and women are distinguishable from each [36:43] other, but they should be treated [36:45] equally under the law. But again, the [36:47] suicidally empathetic make that [36:49] categorization error. But the bigger [36:51] picture is [36:54] even something as wonderful and virtuous [36:57] as empathy could become cancerous. The [37:01] the cell division that causes your deep [37:05] scab to get healed, right? Cell division [37:08] is good. It's only good as long as there [37:12] is a stopping point to that goodness. [37:15] Melanoma since we're talking about skin [37:19] results in the bad version of cell skin [37:24] cell division. So we didn't say cell [37:27] division is good ad infinitum. We said [37:31] cell division up to a point. Empathy is [37:34] great up to a point and and it has to be [37:39] strategically medded out in a way that [37:42] is consistent with evolutionary rational [37:45] calculus. It makes perfect evolutionary [37:48] sense for every single person who will [37:51] ever listen to this chat to be more [37:54] willing to jump in front of a bus to [37:57] save their biological children than [37:59] random children in Rwanda. That doesn't [38:02] make you callous or sinister or evil. It [38:06] makes you a creature that is endowed [38:08] with an evolutionary calculus. So [38:10] empathy, good suicidal empathy will [38:13] bring the end of us. [38:16] >> Brad, I wish we could keep you for [38:17] longer, but um unfortunately we we do [38:20] have to end this, but u we'll bring you [38:22] back some time with your next book. [38:25] >> Um I wish you all the best with this [38:26] book and your new position at at at Miss [38:28] at Old Miss. And uh again, thank you to [38:32] everybody joining and thank you God [38:33] wishing everybody a wonderful afternoon. [38:35] >> Thank you so much, Lori.