Transcript [00:00] Hello everyone. Things are heating up [00:02] again in the streets of Iran. We've been [00:04] waiting a long time to see some movement [00:07] on the streets. We know that back in [00:08] January there were tens of thousands of [00:11] Iranians who were protesting the regime [00:13] who were gun down in cold blood, [00:15] murdered. Many and many have been [00:18] murdered since by the Iranian regime for [00:20] those protests. [00:21] And the people of Iran have been waiting [00:23] for a reason to come back out. They've [00:25] been waiting to know that they're going [00:27] to be protected. There's a lot to talk [00:28] about on this topic, but let's get to [00:30] the headline first of all. They're out [00:32] in the western province of Ilam. [00:36] Ilam is again that is the western part [00:39] of the of of Iran in the city of [00:42] Abdanan. Protests draw solidarity and [00:46] fears of renewed crackdown. What [00:47] happened was there were 13 employees of [00:50] a petrol refinery complex that were [00:52] killed when their bus overturned. And [00:55] that was the spark that led to people [00:58] coming out into the streets and [01:00] demonstrating. But just in case you [01:02] think that that's all it's about, I'm [01:03] going to play you this short video [01:06] that I found online of these are the [01:08] protesters in Abdanan. Take a look at [01:10] this. [01:13] Down with the Islamic Republic. [01:19] The Islamic Republic must be destroyed. [01:47] Now they're chanting for Reza Pahlavi, [01:49] the crown prince, the son of the former [01:51] Shah. [01:53] From Abdanan to Iran, rise up, rise up. [01:56] That's what we're seeing now. So we [01:58] don't know where this is going certainly [02:00] the regime has it within its power, [02:03] [snorts] within its ability to [02:06] you know, to suppress these protests. [02:07] But to help us understand everything [02:09] that's going on, I want to welcome in to [02:11] join us right now, Ali Siadatian. Ali [02:15] Siadatian is is an Iranian, a former [02:18] Muslim who again grew up in Iran and is [02:21] now a commentator. He writes for JNS. [02:24] He's a fellow of the Ideological Defense [02:26] Institute, IDI, and he's involved in [02:29] many other very important projects. [02:31] Ali, you're from Iran. You still have [02:33] contacts there. [02:35] What are we seeing? What does this mean? [02:37] Is it Are we just hoping it gets bigger? [02:40] What are the chances this spreads? What [02:41] do we know at this point? [02:43] >> Well, [02:44] you know, you you told this you read the [02:46] story. There was a [02:48] workers that were killed, and people [02:50] felt that it was government neglect. The [02:52] roads were not kept properly. There were [02:53] some guardrails that were not put it [02:55] there. [02:56] There was mechanical issues, and people [02:58] came out, and the first [03:00] thing they said was a resignation [03:02] resignation, asking for the resignation [03:04] of some government official. But very [03:05] quickly, [snorts] the grievances that [03:08] are deep in the hearts of people [03:10] that see the government and the regime [03:13] as dysfunctional, unable to run the [03:15] country properly. [03:16] And and that ideological divide that [03:18] separates the nation from from this very [03:21] revolutionary and religious government [03:23] came out. Death to the dictator. Where [03:26] is your cardboard leader? The regime the [03:29] Islamic Republic must end. [03:32] These were now what people were were [03:34] yelling out and even calling for the [03:35] Crown Prince. Now, [03:37] is this going to spread? What's [03:38] interesting about these protests is that [03:40] they're spontaneous. [03:42] Now, the advantage of that is that the [03:44] government can't crack down. There's no [03:45] leadership, no a group of people that [03:48] are behind this organizing it for the [03:50] government to go ahead beforehand and [03:53] take those people down. They're coming [03:55] out of the entrails of people, [03:57] spontaneously combusting, and that's [04:00] what makes it difficult for the security [04:02] forces to actually uh uh hamper down on [04:05] it and and and and prevent it from [04:07] happening. So it's impossible to tell [04:10] when they kind of naturally you know [04:12] spark what will be the spark, how [04:15] widespread will it be. [04:17] These [clears throat] are not easy [04:18] things to predict by any means. [04:21] What's interesting about Abdanan in Ilam [04:24] and and incidentally of course Ilam is [04:26] the son of Shem and that's you know [04:27] where the name comes from. They settled [04:29] there a long time ago [04:31] is that that was one of the first places [04:34] that sparked the January 8th and 9th [04:36] protests. It began in [04:37] >> to ask you about that cuz I remembered I [04:39] pay close attention to these things and [04:41] I remember that Ilam was one of the main [04:43] centers of protesting back in January [04:46] and I wanted to understand. I know [04:47] different regions in Iran have different [04:51] different sectarian makeups and I wanted [04:53] to know what was [04:54] what was it about Ilam that makes it a [04:56] focus for protests? [04:58] >> I think that Abdanan [05:00] that that was that specific town it has [05:02] 24,000 people living in it. [05:05] And in January 8th and 9th 20,000 of [05:08] them came in the street and suddenly [05:10] there was this footage [05:11] of 20,000 people which is nearly [05:13] everybody in town walking down the [05:16] street hanging in hand [05:18] and I think that was inspiring. That was [05:20] inspiring to the people. [05:23] There is a deep sense of national um [05:26] identity like when Mahsa Amini was [05:27] killed in 2022 she was Kurdish but no [05:30] one thought of her in that light. [05:32] Everyone saw her as Iranian and so the [05:34] nation rallied behind her. That's how [05:36] Iranians internally understand [05:38] themselves at large. There's there's [05:39] small groups that have [05:41] different points of view so it's [05:43] regions like that have less security [05:45] presence. You look at Tehran it's [05:47] basically a military fort. [05:49] So pe villages or towns like that are [05:52] more easily combustible because the [05:54] number of security agents are less. They [05:57] usually belong to families that live [05:59] around there. In fact in in in January [06:01] when 20,000 people everybody in that [06:03] town came out The security forces [06:05] escaped their posts. [06:07] And so that's what makes these smaller [06:09] places [06:11] you know more easy to to rise. Now who [06:13] lives there? The Lur live there and a [06:15] large amount of Kurds live there. [06:17] And you know they've been living there [06:18] for thousands of years and have been [06:20] part of you know [06:22] the history of of Iran. [06:25] They don't associate so much with the [06:27] religious ruling class where Iranians [06:29] increasingly see the clerics as an [06:31] extension of the caliphate of Muhammad. [06:34] And they see it as a very non-Iranian [06:36] element. And so these are the heart [06:38] heartlands of what is Iran. These [06:41] places, the Lur, the Kurds, these this [06:42] is the heartland of of Iran. [06:45] And so they rise in that. [06:47] >> So Ali, I have I have I have some more [06:49] to ask you about. Before just before we [06:50] go on, a word from one of our one of our [06:53] very important sponsors. [06:55] Planting 700,000 fruit trees across [06:57] Israel, renovating the strategic Mitzpe [06:59] Yosef, overlooking Shechem and keeping [07:02] the Jewish presence there, building a [07:04] trauma center in Immanuel in Samaria, [07:07] supporting Jewish farming communities [07:09] throughout Judea and Samaria and that is [07:12] just the beginning. From Israel's [07:14] life-saving dog unit to supporting [07:16] struggling soldiers, widows, orphans, [07:19] and at-risk youth, the Am Yisrael Chai [07:22] fund is making an incredible difference [07:24] in so many projects across Israel. And [07:27] now for the ninth year in a row, they [07:30] hosting their dream raffle and they are [07:32] giving you the chance to support all of [07:35] these amazing causes while entering to [07:37] win, get this, a brand new $1.3 million [07:42] luxury apartment in Jerusalem. That's [07:45] right. That's what they're raffling off, [07:47] a a luxury apartment in the heart of [07:49] Jerusalem. Every raffle entry makes a [07:52] difference. Support Israel, enter to [07:54] win, make Jerusalem part of your [07:56] family's future. [07:58] Visit thedreamraffle.com/news [08:02] today or click on the link below. Now [08:05] Ali, [08:06] you mentioned before that it makes it [08:08] harder to crack down on the protests [08:09] because their spontaneous, because [08:12] they're not organized by any central [08:14] group that can be, you know, sought out [08:16] through intelligence and crack down on [08:18] and arrested, but it's just everyone [08:20] coming out of their home spontaneously. [08:22] Now, while that's a very that's a nice [08:24] thing to hear that you have people [08:25] coming out into the streets. On the [08:26] other hand, [08:28] you're also pointing out that there's [08:30] not that much organization. And one of [08:32] the, you know, one of the knocks on the [08:35] on the Iranian uprisings that have taken [08:37] place is that there doesn't really seem [08:39] to be any leadership in any coordination [08:41] and maybe there'd be a better chance for [08:43] the Iranian people if they were somewhat [08:45] organized, unless I'm reading the [08:46] situation wrong and there is [08:48] organization below the surface that we [08:50] don't know about. [08:52] Can you comment on that? Like is there [08:54] actually an emerging leadership among [08:56] the Iranian people that could lead a [08:58] protest movement when the time is right? [09:01] >> Yeah, that's the disadvantage of [09:02] spontaneous combustion is that on one [09:05] hand, it's hard for them to crack down [09:06] and know where the next one is going to [09:08] come from. On the other hand, it's it's [09:10] it kind of wears off. It's like blowing [09:12] steam and that's why they let it happen. [09:14] You know, people come, they protest, [09:16] they get tired, they got to go back to [09:17] work, they got two, three jobs, or they [09:19] get killed, shot, arrested, and the [09:21] whole thing dies down and life goes on [09:23] for them. So that's the disadvantage. [09:26] And so since um [09:28] the victory of uh of Israel by killing [09:31] the supreme leader, killing the heads of [09:33] the IRGC, [09:35] the the generation that was heading [09:37] towards a secular government now is is [09:40] is encouraged in order to organize [09:43] better. And for the first time, it [09:46] actually feels that there is a point to [09:48] organize. So there is definitely now [09:51] organizing underneath all of this groups [09:55] that are bringing in um guns, flags, um [09:59] you know, trying to see if they can use [10:02] Elon Musk's satellite system to [10:04] communicate during protest so they can [10:06] organize better. We haven't yet seen, [10:09] you know, the fruits of completely. The [10:11] January 8th and 9th [10:13] protests definitely, they say, you know, [10:15] there was some organization behind that [10:17] from maybe the Crown Prince Network. [10:20] It's hard to tell because, you know, [10:21] there's so much censorship and secret [10:23] and hidden around that that we can't [10:25] analyze it properly. But I would say [10:27] that the organization part of this [10:29] revolution is now being put into place [10:32] because there was a point. You have to [10:34] understand that after the reform [10:37] period, the protest that of 2009 where [10:40] people came after Ahmadinejad and said, [10:42] where is my vote? The IRGC created a [10:45] unit that whose job is to find colonels [10:49] of revolutionary movement when they are [10:51] small and destroy them before they can [10:54] get anywhere. [10:55] Opposition leaders were either put in [10:57] jail or had to escape the country. They [10:59] put very [11:00] you know, Islamic requirements to become [11:02] a member of Parliament so the Parliament [11:03] could not change laws from inside. [11:06] They've been very good at dismantling [11:08] any opposition as well as [11:12] doing psychological programming. It's [11:14] there's a whole department IRGC that [11:16] destroys the concept of nationhood. [11:19] They they they wanted people to come [11:22] together around Islam rather than the [11:24] Iranian nation. So they tried to [11:25] dismantle people's identity [11:28] and kill opposition groups when they [11:30] were small and destroy opposition [11:32] leaders [11:33] in order to make sure that no one could [11:35] come to power. And the irony is this is [11:37] that [11:38] the Crown Prince, he had maybe 25 30% [11:41] support and they and they let him be [11:44] because he was useful. He divided the [11:46] opposition without ever having enough [11:48] people to do anything. And suddenly in [11:50] January 8th and 9th when Israel and [11:52] America had come into place, people [11:54] calculated that unless they can actually [11:57] put an alternative on the stage of [11:59] history and say, look, instead of [12:01] dealing with Khamenei, deal with this [12:03] guy. He now represents us. So there was [12:05] a strategic move where large portions of [12:08] the population said, okay, we're not [12:09] monarchists, but at least he has been [12:12] consistent. He has some organization. He [12:14] has some international renown. Let's put [12:17] him and as our guy and hope the world [12:19] says, okay, they they finally have an [12:21] opposition figure that we can deal with. [12:24] The world didn't quite see it that way [12:26] and it was more of a strategic move by [12:29] by Iranians at large to push through [12:32] this regime and actually have a focusing [12:35] figure. Um we'll see where that goes. [12:37] Now there are many other opposition [12:39] groups as well. [12:40] Some are Islamic Marxists still. There [12:44] is the MEK which is small in in numbers [12:47] but has found a way to have a large [12:50] influence in in the in the left of the [12:52] opposition and there's a few other group [12:54] as well. [12:55] And and they have a different vision of [12:57] Iran but they don't have the same level [12:58] of organization and when they call [13:00] nobody comes to the street. Um so we'll [13:03] we'll have to see how all of these [13:04] different opposition groups begin to um [13:07] work together to organize crowds and so [13:10] that the spontaneous frustration of [13:11] individuals which has reached a [13:13] revolutionary stage now can get funneled [13:16] into an organized effective movement [13:20] that can push through the regime. [13:21] There's also movements within the system [13:23] that are trying to change rapidly. [13:26] Since Khomeini has been killed this has [13:28] opened their hands to actually change. [13:31] Um and [13:32] >> by within the system? [13:34] >> So Khomeini had become like this holy [13:37] figure head where his word was law. So [13:40] even though within the Islamic Republic [13:42] there was an understanding that the [13:43] economy is dying, that um relationships [13:47] with the West can't be so ideological [13:51] and that this idea of the Mahdi coming [13:53] can't define the entire foreign policy [13:56] of Iran vis-a-vis Israel that that maybe [13:58] the Turkish model is better where you [14:00] put a suit and a tie and [snorts] you [14:03] inward inwardly you're you're Islamic [14:05] political but outwardly you know you [14:07] belong to NATO. So that model it has [14:10] more resilience and so there's there's [14:13] but all of this was held back by the [14:14] cult of the supreme leader. Now that [14:16] he's dead, all those internal forces [14:19] that want to maintain this regime, [14:22] but [14:23] as the Iranians say, change the [14:24] showcase. You know, it's like a store. [14:26] You you remove a man can put another [14:28] one. You just want to change the [14:29] showcase that people see outwardly. So [14:32] one thing is that they've launched [14:34] massive social media [14:36] efforts, huge huge social media effort [14:38] where they are rebranding themselves as [14:40] Iranian since the Islamic call has no [14:43] more pull on the people. They're they're [14:45] going back to ancient Iran and they're [14:47] putting up stuff from before the Islamic [14:49] period. They're they're saying [14:51] is our heritage. [14:52] They're letting women to walk around [14:54] without the head scarf and internally [14:57] they're trying to pull back from this, [14:59] you know, apocalyptic vision of the IRGC [15:02] and see if they can start to move [15:04] towards the Turkish, you know, way of [15:07] doing things and hoping that they'll [15:09] bring down the revolutionary cry by, you [15:12] know, making better governance. [15:15] So there's there's lots of change [15:17] happening internally in the opposition, [15:19] the people. 100% the country is set on [15:23] political change and between now and [15:25] 2029 we'll see a different government. [15:27] The one million dollar question that [15:29] everyone has to look for is will the [15:31] constitution change? Right now the base [15:33] of the constitution is the Quran [15:35] and people's number one demand is the [15:39] downfall of theocracy. [15:41] [snorts] There's lots of political [15:42] variance, what people want after [15:44] theocracy, but one thing everybody [15:46] agrees on, [15:48] the Quran cannot be the basis of a [15:50] modern state and theocracy has to go. If [15:52] that changes, that's regime change. [15:55] That's the only thing that qualifies as [15:56] regime change. Anything other than that [15:58] is just variations of the same thing. [16:00] >> Sure. So okay, last question before I [16:03] let you go. [16:06] This [16:06] what we're seeing in Abdanan is nice, [16:08] it's welcome and we hope and we wish the [16:10] protesters all the success in the world. [16:13] Are we seeing or have you heard because [16:15] you have more contacts? [16:17] Are there any indications of anything [16:19] else [16:21] throughout the country? Are there any [16:22] more street protests that we've heard [16:24] of? Meaning, has it been totally quiet [16:26] everywhere else? [16:27] What's the lay of the land? [16:29] >> There was a few more towns in the west. [16:32] Ahvaz, they blocked the highway. [16:36] There was an oil [16:38] There was a There was a car carrying gas [16:41] like a truck. People started to take [16:43] that and started to to steal gas from [16:45] it. [16:46] There was a little little bit of It [16:47] sparked a little bit of protest in that [16:49] neck of the woods [16:51] in the west, [16:52] but it didn't turn into something [16:55] national because it wasn't a national [16:57] crisis. [16:58] It was a group of people who died [17:00] unfortunately in that in that in that [17:02] part infected that town. They came and [17:04] arrested two people that they said they [17:06] were the leaders of this and they always [17:08] will try to intimidate people. So it's [17:10] hard to tell what will be the national [17:12] crisis that will spark, you know, a [17:14] spontaneous national [17:16] movement, but I do suspect we're headed [17:17] to cycles of protests like birth pangs [17:21] and contractions that will get closer [17:23] and larger. [17:24] What sparks it, we'll have to see, but [17:26] what I do know for sure [17:28] is that the Iranian people are [17:30] politically savvy and they will not rise [17:32] until they see the light at the end of [17:34] the tunnel, that there's a path to [17:35] victory. [17:36] And everyone's waiting to see, will the [17:38] United States launch another wave of [17:40] attacks? [17:42] This meeting between Putin, Xi, and [17:44] Donald Trump will will decide the fate [17:47] of the Islamic Republic. So everyone [17:48] want People are waiting to see what will [17:50] be the decision that the big powers will [17:52] make between themselves about this [17:53] jurisdiction. And finally, will the [17:56] economic pressure break their back to [17:58] the point where there'll be defections [18:00] from within because people aren't [18:01] getting paid? [18:03] These are things people are waiting for [18:05] to see the cracks and then to see a path [18:07] forward. [18:08] But as you said, without political [18:10] organization, [18:11] without defections from within, all [18:14] we'll see is just chaos, chaos. [18:18] So that has to fall into place. The [18:20] frustration of people is now evident [18:22] that something small, I mean, not small, [18:23] but 13 people died, but I mean, it [18:26] immediately turned into political [18:27] protests of revolutionary magnitude. [18:30] That's where the nation is. But for that [18:32] energy to be harnessed, we need to see [18:34] that organization [18:37] or an a coup. If we don't see [18:38] organization and we don't see a coup, [18:41] then these they will try to manage the [18:43] country through the guns, try to make [18:45] some sort of a deal to get money back [18:47] into their pockets and make changes from [18:50] within, hoping that they will be able to [18:53] alleviate some of the revolutionary cry. [19:02] >> So you feel it's inevitable that at some [19:04] point the regime will be falling or do [19:06] you think we haven't crossed that point [19:07] yet? [19:08] >> I think that [19:09] change has 100% already political change [19:12] has already begun in Iran. The magnitude [19:14] of the change [19:15] and the speed of it is what we're now [19:17] going to find out over the next two [19:18] years. [19:20] >> Alisia Adatan, thank you so much for [19:22] joining us here on Israel 365 News and [19:24] all of you. If you also want to better [19:26] equip yourself with the facts to defend [19:28] Israel, check out the Pro Israel [19:30] handbook. [19:32] Viewers to this channel get 15% off. The [19:34] details are in the description of the [19:35] video. Alisia, we're going to have you [19:37] back on as this situation continues to [19:39] develop. Thank you so much for doing [19:41] this. [19:42] >> Follow me on Instagram at Alispeaksx. [19:45] >> Absolutely. [19:46] All right, Alisia Adatan, thank you very [19:48] much.