Transcript [00:00] The payout of 400,000 pounds to Lucy [00:02] Kahn isn't surprising to me at all. I [00:05] mean, the amount might be or or the [00:07] efforts they went to to try and cover [00:09] this up. I mean, they paid that money [00:10] out, but they still haven't admitted [00:11] that they did anything wrong. Um that's [00:13] not a surprise because I think that most [00:16] Jews and quite a lot of other people [00:17] know that the BBC has a massive problem [00:20] with Jews and anti-Semitism and warped [00:22] coverage of Israel and have known that [00:24] for many, many years. Uh we know that [00:26] because they even did their own [00:27] investigation into it years and years [00:28] ago and then covered up up so that [00:31] nobody will be able to see it and spent [00:33] tons of money on hiding that as well [00:35] from freedom of information requests. [00:36] That was the Balen report. Um but since [00:38] then, we've seen so much that it's [00:40] actually unbelievable that they can [00:43] still be denying it even whilst paying [00:44] out these massive sums. Just think back. [00:47] The BBC literally had to get rid of the [00:49] director general and the head of news [00:52] because of their mistakes, errors, [00:54] failures, lies, whatever you want to [00:56] call it when it came to their coverage [00:58] of Israel since October the 7th. Uh [01:00] they've had so many different cases of [01:03] their bias and their lies being shown in [01:06] their coverage that they had to get rid [01:08] of those two senior members of staff. [01:09] Now, this massive payout to somebody who [01:11] had a 22-year career there making [01:13] documentaries for them. Um I think it's [01:16] really hard to understand how they can [01:19] really having the cheek to say that this [01:21] isn't an ongoing problem. And yet, why [01:23] am I not surprised? Because we've known [01:25] about this for so long. Uh the BBC is [01:27] literally, I mean, I think they call it [01:29] these days gaslighting Jews and everyone [01:31] else who points to these problems [01:33] constantly. Even just think back to that [01:35] ridiculous hospital story where Jeremy [01:37] Bowen and others said that Israel had [01:39] flattened a hospital in the Gaza Strip. [01:41] Uh when anybody watching this who had [01:43] any experience of stories from the [01:45] region could see that that was probably [01:47] not what had happened. [01:48] >> And it was pure speculation at the time [01:50] as well for which Jeremy Bowen has not [01:51] apologized. [01:52] >> No, in fact, he said that he didn't [01:54] regret it at all. He had no regret even [01:56] though he admits that he was wrong about [01:58] it. So, the point is that I think the [02:00] BBC has such a shabby record on this, [02:03] but it's pretty consistent that record. [02:05] It's consistently wrong and consistently [02:07] anti-Israel and consistently, I would [02:09] say, increasingly anti-Jewish. So, I [02:12] would say they've had the opportunity to [02:14] sort this out many times, including when [02:15] they got rid of the director general and [02:17] the head of news, and they didn't do it [02:18] then. So, I don't suppose they're going [02:19] to do it now, either. [02:21] >> Let's talk about another organization [02:22] that hates Jews, the Green Party. Their [02:25] uh policy is Zionism is racism. Now, [02:27] they themselves have been branded racist [02:30] by the Jewish Board of Deputies. Tell us [02:33] about this. [02:34] >> Yeah, well, to compare that game, I [02:35] guess, is what the Board of Deputies is [02:37] doing here. The Board of Deputies is [02:38] quite an old institution that was set up [02:41] originally by Sir Moses Montefiore and [02:43] the Spanish and Portuguese Jews [02:45] congregation, which I'm actually a [02:46] member. It's the oldest Jewish community [02:49] in the United Kingdom, and they set up [02:51] when the Jews were readmitted to the UK. [02:54] And [02:55] it was set up really to try to represent [02:57] Jewish positions and Jewish thoughts to [03:00] uh the government and to the monarch. [03:01] And so, what they're doing here is [03:03] trying to, I suppose, explain how Jews [03:05] feel about this racist, anti-Semitic [03:07] policy that the Green Party has adopted. [03:09] Again, the Green Party, like the BBC, [03:11] insists it's not doing anything wrong. [03:13] Insists this isn't anti-Jewish. Insists [03:16] that Jews who say that this is [03:18] outrageous and racist are wrong. Um [03:22] if you go by the Macpherson principle, [03:24] the idea that you could tell a minority [03:26] that it is collectively wrong in its [03:28] majority to say that something is racist [03:30] against it is also quite quite [03:33] problematic. So, I think the Board of [03:34] Deputies has has done pretty much the [03:36] right thing in branding it this way, but [03:38] it's not going to do much good because [03:39] institutions in the United Kingdom [03:41] today, I mean, the Green Party is [03:43] relatively unimportant politically, but [03:46] increasingly alarming, uh they are [03:48] turning against Jewish people in quite [03:50] an alarming way. And when Jews dare to [03:52] speak out about it, [03:54] it just made worse because people say, [03:56] "Well, you would say that, you Jews. [03:58] You're trying to be manipulative. You're [03:59] trying to stop us saying things that we [04:02] think are fair about you." And so it's a [04:04] sort of downward spiral. It's absolutely [04:06] no surprise that more and more Jewish [04:08] people are actually despairing about [04:09] this sort of anti-Jewish rhetoric, [04:11] anti-Jewish actions, anti-Jewish [04:13] sentiment that's being expressed more [04:15] and more openly. [04:16] >> And this has been the tale as old as [04:17] time, but has got so much worse in the [04:18] last three years since the 7th of [04:21] October attacks by Hamas terrorists. It [04:24] is now the first [04:26] election in Israel since that time. It's [04:30] really hard to know what the result will [04:33] be. In theory, Benjamin Netanyahu could [04:35] continue. In theory, Isaac Herzog could [04:37] become the prime minister, former [04:39] cabinet member of his. In theory, [04:41] Naftali Bennett could come back. I just [04:43] wonder what your instinct is, how you [04:45] think things will go, and what sort of [04:47] coalition will be built in Israel, and [04:49] what that will mean for us here. [04:51] >> Yeah, well, I'm out in Israel at the [04:53] moment, here to observe and report on [04:55] what's going on with the election as [04:56] well. So I can tell you that there's a [04:58] lot of debate and discussion here in [05:00] Israel. I can't second-guess what's [05:02] going to happen. The polls all go in [05:04] different ways, as as is often the case [05:05] with polls. And also the system here is [05:08] so varied. There are so many parties. [05:10] They all depend on coalition forming as [05:12] well as the vote. So I think there's all [05:14] to play for. And Benjamin Netanyahu [05:16] could indeed stay in power, conceivably, [05:18] because despite the massive failings of [05:20] October the 7th, biggest failings in in [05:23] this country's history, he has since [05:26] then, in many people's eyes in the [05:28] electorate, redeemed himself. Of course, [05:29] there are those who will never forgive [05:31] him for what happened on that day. And I [05:32] would say that both positions are [05:34] understandable if you're just assessing [05:36] what's going on. But what I will say is [05:38] this, that I think all the reports and [05:40] all the scare stories and all the horror [05:42] stories that you read in a lot of the [05:43] international media, and even in quite a [05:45] bit of the media here in Israel, about [05:47] the death of democracy and that this is [05:49] the last chance for the country and all [05:51] those sorts of things, to my mind seem [05:54] massively wrong and ill-judged. Because [05:56] actually, most of the horrors that this [05:58] country undergoes or has has experienced [06:01] internally, the arguments, the debate, [06:03] the ripping society apart are actually, [06:06] I would say, the result of democracy, of [06:08] quite a healthy democracy that is alive [06:11] and kicking. There are so many parties, [06:13] so many opinions, so many passionate [06:15] beliefs that people are actually [06:16] debating this constantly. And many [06:18] Israelis I'd spoken to, even out and [06:20] about today and this evening, have said [06:22] that they still don't know who they're [06:24] going to vote for tomorrow when they go [06:26] into the polling booths. And that is not [06:28] an unusual position in this country [06:30] where things can change your mind even [06:32] up to the last minute. [06:34] >> Thank you very much, Jonathan. Perhaps [06:35] we'll talk more about the results of [06:36] that election and whether there is a [06:38] coalition built or whether there's [06:39] another election and another one, as [06:41] well as is sometimes the case in Israel. [06:43] Certainly has been in the last few [06:45] years. Thank you, Jonathan Sacerdoti [06:47] there. What do you make of what he said?