Transcript [00:00] the Myanmar government were trying to [00:01] drive every last Rohingya out of Myanmar [00:05] by murdering them if they didn't go. [00:07] We don't see that parallel in Gaza. So, [00:09] there's really important differences. [00:11] So, they will say that the Palestinians [00:12] have been suppressed for years. They've [00:14] been denied statehood. [00:15] There was a terrorist attack that [00:17] sparked all of this, and then Israel, as [00:19] Myanmar did, went well over the top and [00:20] actively targeted civilians. That's the [00:22] case in Israel's enemies would make, and [00:24] that's where the danger lies for Israel. [00:26] That would be a really seminal moment [00:28] that that causes Israel real harm, you [00:29] know, sanctions, economic damage, [00:31] diplomatic isolation. I mean, in the [00:33] most extreme circumstances, you could [00:35] even get states trying to make the case [00:37] for military action. And then I think [00:38] the really important thing to do at the [00:40] military level is to reintroduce Hamas [00:43] into the conversation. [00:57] >> Ever listen to Call Me Back and think to [00:58] yourself, this would be so much better [01:00] if Amit went on a rant about the latest [01:02] celebrity who said something stupid [01:03] about Israel or if Nadav ranked every [01:06] member of Knesset by how hot they are? [01:08] Tune into our show, Chosen People [01:10] Problems, for the real news. [01:11] >> Yeah, because that's what the world [01:13] needs, more Jews in media. [01:15] >> Yeah, like more Jews with strong [01:16] opinions about things. [01:18] >> I think we should do it one more time. I [01:19] don't want to do yeah. I can't You could [01:21] say it. I just don't want to say it. [01:23] >> What did I say? [01:24] >> We both did yeah. Like we're not Why are [01:26] we doing that? It sounds so [01:28] Sorry for those listening and editing [01:30] this. [01:30] >> It's going to get worse from here, by [01:32] the way. [01:32] >> Listen to our [01:34] show, Chosen People Problems. [01:36] This should actually be the intro. Okay. [01:39] Chosen People Problems. We're like Amit [01:41] and Nadav, but more so. Please tune in [01:44] or Dan Senor will be mad at us. [01:46] You can find Chosen People Problems [01:48] wherever you get your podcasts. You can [01:50] also listen ad-free and get access to [01:52] our weekly exclusive bonus episode by [01:54] joining Ark Plus at arkmedia.org. [01:59] >> You know that feeling when an episode [02:01] but you're far from done thinking about [02:02] it? For many of us, the instinct is to [02:05] go to social media and see what people [02:07] are staring. But let's be honest, [02:09] [music] opening up about Israel and [02:10] Jewish life on these platforms usually [02:12] means bracing for a fight. [02:15] The algorithm rewards outrage over [02:17] understanding and everyone ends up [02:18] shouting past each other instead of [02:20] listening. [02:21] So we at Arc Media built something [02:23] different. [02:24] The Fold is a private, [music] [02:26] thoughtfully moderated community for [02:28] listeners of Call Me Back and the rest [02:30] of the Arc Media family. It's a place to [02:32] keep the conversation going and to get [02:34] to know people who care about the same [02:36] issues you do. [02:38] We know not everyone is going to agree, [02:39] but that's kind of the point. We want [02:42] the Fold to be a place where you can ask [02:44] questions, learn from one another [02:45] without worrying about how [music] our [02:47] adversaries will respond. [02:49] Inside the Fold, you'll find [02:51] conversations about Israel, Zionism, [02:53] Jewish history, society and culture, and [02:56] more. [02:57] Join us at arcmedia.org. That's [02:59] arcmedia.org. [03:02] We hope to see you there. [03:03] Andrew, welcome to Call Me Back. [03:05] >> Hey, thank you for having me on. [03:07] >> Thank you for being here. So I just want [03:08] to start [03:10] establishing the basis because I think a [03:11] lot of this is probably new to our [03:14] audience. Even though they're following [03:15] events closely in Israel and the Middle [03:17] East, they have not been following [03:19] what's been happening in Myanmar, which [03:21] I understand. So tell us what actually [03:23] happened in Myanmar. [03:25] >> Uh yeah, so your your listeners might [03:26] understand Myanmar [03:28] by its old name of Burma. So that's [03:30] where we are. We're over we're over in [03:31] in Asia. And the Rohingya are [03:34] a Muslim minority within Myanmar itself. [03:37] They're associated with Rakhine state, [03:39] which is in the west of Myanmar. [03:42] Um and they've essentially faced decades [03:44] of exclusion, crackdowns on their [03:46] nationality, uh restrictions on what [03:48] they can and can't do with the country. [03:50] They were often portrayed as Bangladeshi [03:52] immigrants. They've uh you know, they've [03:54] had things like their citizenship [03:56] revoked. They've been subjected to [03:58] restrictions on movement, family life, [04:00] those sorts of things. But what we're [04:02] really focusing on is the events of [04:04] 2017. [04:05] Uh and it started with a terrorist [04:07] attack by the Rohingya themselves. So [04:09] they had a group called uh the Arakan [04:11] Rohingya Salvation Army, the ARSA. [04:14] [snorts] [04:15] Uh they attacked Myanmar security posts, [04:17] but then the military's response went [04:20] wildly over the top in terms of for who [04:22] who they attacked. They were attacking [04:23] Rohingya communities across the board, [04:25] not just the terrorist group. [04:27] Um and we've had the UN investigators [04:29] documenting killings, widespread sexual [04:31] violence, the burning down of whole [04:33] villages. [04:34] Um we I think we can make a fairly clear [04:36] case that the operations there targeted [04:38] the civilian population rather than the [04:41] terrorist group themselves. We're [04:43] talking thousands of deaths. 700,000 [04:45] Rohingya fled to Bangladesh. [04:48] Uh and the Gambia brought a case against [04:51] Myanmar to the ICJ in 2019. [04:54] And they've been uh [04:56] deliberating on that uh you know since [04:58] 2019 and the uh the verdict [05:01] will come down on Thursday this week. [05:04] >> And they brought a case accusing Myanmar [05:07] of genocide. [05:09] >> Yeah, that's right. And so it was uh one [05:11] of the first law changes actually was to [05:13] allow [05:14] uh the Gambia, of course on a totally [05:16] different continent, uh to allow them to [05:18] bring a genocide case on behalf of [05:20] another group against another UN member [05:23] state. So that in itself was the thing [05:25] that opened the door for South Africa to [05:27] take their case to the ICJ against [05:29] Israel. [05:30] >> Okay, so then now let's talk about how [05:32] this case differs from the case against [05:38] Israel and the and and the Israel's [05:40] conduct during the Gaza War. [05:42] >> I think it might be interesting to start [05:43] by saying how Israel's enemies would [05:45] portray this. [05:46] So they will say that the Palestinians [05:48] have been suppressed for years. They've [05:49] been denied statehood. [05:51] There was a terrorist attack that [05:52] sparked all of this. And then Israel as [05:55] uh as Myanmar did went well over the top [05:57] and actively targeted civilians. That's [05:59] the case and Israel's enemies would [06:00] make. [06:02] And I think we can make a very clear [06:04] difference between the two. There's no [06:06] record of the Myanmar military issuing [06:08] evacuation orders. [06:10] There's no record of the Palestinians [06:11] fleeing beyond the borders of Gaza, [06:13] mainly because Egypt wouldn't allow them [06:15] to. [06:16] There's no record of targeting civilians [06:19] in the in the scale that we're talking [06:21] about here. Now, that of course, Israel [06:22] is not perfect. They've made some [06:24] mistakes and some of those mistakes will [06:26] cross the criminal threshold when it [06:27] comes to behavior in Gaza, but have they [06:30] been systematically targeting civilians? [06:32] Well, I think we can very clearly say [06:34] that's not the case. [06:35] We need to really focus on what genocide [06:37] actually means. It's the annihilation of [06:39] a people. [06:40] So, you know, genocide is to a people [06:42] what murder is to an individual. You [06:44] know, you are trying to wipe out [06:46] everyone. [06:48] And I think we've seen a real dilution [06:50] of that term over the last three years. [06:53] The Myanmar government were trying to [06:54] drive every last Rohingya out of Myanmar [06:58] by murdering them if they didn't go. [07:00] We don't see that parallel in Gaza. So, [07:02] there's some really important [07:03] differences. The point I'm making is [07:05] genocide is the crime of annihilation, [07:07] and you have to want to annihilate and [07:09] try to annihilate. Now, you might not [07:10] succeed. [07:12] Um even in the Holocaust, every Jew in [07:14] Europe wasn't wasn't wiped out, and of [07:16] course, that was still the foundational [07:17] genocide. But people get very often [07:20] confused about the bits in the genocide [07:22] convention that says in part. You have [07:24] to try and do it in part. What that [07:26] means is make a substantial enough dent [07:28] in the population that it actually has a [07:31] a threat to the whole. And if we look at [07:33] Srebrenica and Bosnia, we look at the [07:34] thousands of Muslim men that were killed [07:36] in that massacre that was ruled a [07:38] genocide, [07:39] they killed enough of the Muslim men in [07:42] Srebrenica that it damaged the viability [07:44] of that community. It could be [07:46] relatively low in numbers, but the the [07:48] the key point to remember here is you [07:49] have to have the intent, I you want to [07:51] annihilate them, [07:52] and then you have to have the action, [07:54] which means you had a go at it. You did [07:56] your best to try and wipe them out. [07:58] Um and that's where people get confused [08:00] over the phraseology in part in the [08:02] genocide convention. [08:03] >> Okay, so just just to um establish some [08:06] some basic numbers here. It uh [08:09] from public reports, there's somewhere [08:11] between 10 to 20,000 of the Rohingya [08:15] community that were murdered, over [08:17] 700,000 [08:19] displaced, [08:21] and we're talking out of a population of [08:23] about 2 million people of of that [08:27] community in Myanmar. So that's just so [08:29] just so listeners have a sense for the [08:31] for the scale we're talking about. Now [08:33] historically, Andrew, proving genocide [08:35] has required demonstrating not just mass [08:37] killing, but a specific intent to [08:39] destroy a people. [08:41] So how does the ICJ plan to change the [08:43] definition of genocide in the Myanmar [08:46] case? [08:47] >> Well, the argument here is that it's [08:48] simply too difficult to prove genocide. [08:51] So it's the crime of crimes [08:54] uh [08:55] and the inferences that dolus specialis, [08:57] which is the intent part of this, [08:59] makes the bar too constrictive and too [09:01] high. And we've seen that argument made [09:03] time and time again over Gaza over the [09:05] last three years. Certainly Amnesty [09:07] International made that case, HRW made [09:09] that case, [09:10] uh B'Tselem made that case. So when they [09:12] released their papers saying that Israel [09:14] was guilty of genocide, they all changed [09:17] the threshold because under the law as [09:19] it stands, uh you can't you can't make [09:22] that case for Israel. And to go into [09:24] dolus specialis, so if you or I went to [09:26] court to say we committed a crime beyond [09:28] reasonable doubt [09:29] would be the intent threshold. It would [09:32] be the threshold they had to prove [09:34] uh in order to convict us. It's even [09:36] higher than that for genocide. So dolus [09:37] specialis up to now has essentially [09:40] meant that the only reasonable inference [09:42] from your actions and pattern of [09:44] behavior is that you wanted to commit a [09:46] genocide. So it cannot be anything else. [09:48] So if you can make a a good case that [09:50] it's actually just a war where a lot of [09:52] bad things happened alongside the war [09:54] and of course war is itself inherently [09:57] fairly immoral act anyway, involves [09:59] killing, that's a bar that armies and [10:01] soldiers have tried to put a frame [10:03] around using just war theory. But [10:06] you could also say that [10:08] that those actions do comprise a [10:09] genocide. And so the the critical thing [10:11] here is the intent. [10:13] >> How does one establish intent? Because [10:16] that really [10:17] the crux of so much of at the heart of [10:19] so much of this debate is how one [10:20] establishes intent. [10:22] >> Yeah, so you can take somebody saying [10:25] we're going to kill everyone. You know, [10:26] the great example there is the Wannsee [10:28] conference in in Germany where they [10:29] literally wrote down their plan for the [10:31] Holocaust. You know, it's there in black [10:33] and white. We're going to wipe out all [10:35] the Jews through this mechanical [10:36] slaughter in concentration camps. So [10:39] that's one way you could do it. [10:40] The other way that's been done [10:42] uh certainly in Croatia versus Serbia, [10:44] this is the this was the big precedent [10:46] case, um they're inferring intent from a [10:50] pattern of conduct. [10:52] And the ruling in Croatia versus Serbia [10:54] was that genocidal intent can be the [10:56] only reasonable inference from that [10:58] pattern of conduct. [10:59] So it can't be a war, it can't be a a [11:02] campaign of ethnic cleansing, which is [11:03] something completely different. [11:05] Um [11:06] to help people understand the difference [11:07] between the two, genocide is the attempt [11:09] to target the people. Ethnic cleansing [11:11] is is more the attempt to target the [11:13] land. You're trying to just clear the [11:15] land and claim it for yourself. [11:16] So there's a nuanced difference there. [11:18] So ethnic cleansing and genocide are two [11:20] different things. So what Ireland are [11:22] now arguing is that the intent can be [11:24] inferred much more broadly. [11:26] So rather than just from a pattern of [11:28] conduct where it's the only possible [11:30] explanation, [snorts] the argument [11:31] they're putting forward is that intent [11:33] can be inferred where there's [11:34] destruction is uh a natural and probable [11:37] consequence that you should foresee. So [11:39] they've taken away intent and turned it [11:41] to foreseeing damage [snorts] um and a [11:44] degree of recklessness in that. But also [11:47] they want to look at this. There's an [11:48] argument in front of the court that they [11:50] should be looking at this far more in [11:51] the round where you look at the damage [11:53] caused, you look at the destruction, you [11:54] look at comments that have been made [11:57] uh by politicians or military leaders. [11:59] And [12:00] you look at that far more broadly um as [12:03] a cumulative assessment, as another [12:05] route to inferring intent rather than [12:07] just it being the only possible [12:09] explanation. [12:10] >> So [12:11] intent can be established [12:14] by [12:15] the conduct, [12:17] like they look at what you did, and they [12:19] say clearly this is what they intended [12:21] to do, or intent can be what's [12:23] articulated, your one C conference [12:25] example. And you're saying they even [12:27] want to loosen the definition even [12:29] further to say they may not have said [12:32] this, [12:33] uh their their actual conduct in the war [12:36] may not have been that, but but the [12:39] damage done [12:42] in the conduct of war, the actual damage [12:44] we have means this they must have wanted [12:48] to commit genocide. [12:49] >> Yeah. That's pretty much it. So [12:51] inferring it where [12:52] contributing to that destruction is the [12:54] natural and probable consequence that [12:57] you should have foreseen, [12:59] but yet you [13:00] you carried on recklessly, caused all [13:01] that damage, and that is is therefore [13:03] part of uh [13:05] awarding state responsibility [13:08] for a genocidal campaign. So hence it's [13:10] very much a significant loosening. And [13:12] what it does is it puts the burden of [13:14] proof onto the accused rather than the [13:16] accuser. So if we think of a criminal [13:18] court, [13:19] a prosecutor would have to prove that [13:21] you or I committed a crime, [13:23] and we can defend ourselves. [13:25] This now turns that on its head where it [13:27] says, okay, now you have to show that [13:28] it's not genocide, [13:30] um or we can infer that it is um through [13:33] through what we are seeing that you've [13:34] done. So that's a really dangerous [13:36] inversion of of of of law and justice. [13:39] >> Okay, and then based on that new [13:40] definition, Andrew, what would the [13:41] prosecutors argue against against Israel [13:44] to meet that bar? [13:45] >> So they would say [13:46] um that Israel can already [13:50] be credibly accused of killing, of [13:52] serious harm. [13:54] Um people are deprived in Gaza, people [13:56] are displaced in Gaza. [13:58] Um and I would imagine they would try [14:00] and claim that actually it's so bad in [14:02] there that the conditions necessary [14:03] survive for survival [14:05] um are being threatened. Now I would I [14:07] think disagree with that, and we can see [14:09] from the death rates that that it's [14:11] perfectly possible to survive in Gaza [14:13] right now. But combine that with of [14:15] Israel's incredibly reckless and [14:17] arguably genocidal political statements [14:20] that some politicians have made. [14:22] When you take this new lower level of [14:24] intent, bundle it all together, [14:26] then you're putting that onus on Israel [14:28] to disprove genocide, which is which is [14:30] really challenging. [14:32] Then you could make the case that [14:34] Israel's policies threaten the physical [14:36] survival of a number of people in Gaza. [14:38] Said it was the in part bit of the [14:40] genocide convention that Israel had [14:42] violated cuz clearly they haven't wiped [14:44] out all 2.1 million Gazans. [14:47] Um so in that case, Israel would have to [14:49] look at um the actual risk that existed, [14:52] what officials knew, um causation [14:55] between what Israel did militarily and [14:57] and what happened to people uh in terms [14:59] of suffering, what effective steps [15:01] Israel took to prevent this. [15:03] >> And then the damage to Gaza. And then [15:05] they would say and and and now let's [15:06] look at what what what Gaza looks like [15:09] today relative to how it looked say on [15:12] you know before the ground operation [15:13] began. And they would say they would [15:16] argue this clearly meets the definition [15:18] of [15:19] uh in you know in part like the in part [15:23] part of intent. [15:24] >> Yeah, and there's also other aspects [15:26] like um did Israel receive credible [15:28] warnings about things like hunger, um [15:31] disease, um unsafe displacement and [15:34] failed to do anything about it. That [15:36] that would also fall under one of these [15:37] new proposed definitions. So there's [15:39] there's a lot going on here [15:41] um that has very serious repercussions [15:42] not only for Israel but for any Western [15:44] state that that goes to war. [15:46] >> Yeah. [15:47] >> Um because all of these things happen in [15:48] in war zones. Um and to say things like [15:50] the Racket campaign or the Idlib [15:52] campaign against ISIS were genocidal is [15:54] plainly ridiculous. And yet it's in [15:56] danger of dropping now into this [15:58] category. [15:59] >> So you're basically saying the the this [16:00] this new definition would apply to these [16:02] US-led campaigns against ISIS in the [16:05] Middle East, the ones you're citing from [16:07] from many years ago. [16:08] >> Yeah. [16:09] >> Andrew, now is this new threshold [16:12] necessary [16:14] to establish Myanmar actions as genocide [16:17] because [16:18] based [16:19] on what were everything you're saying [16:21] here, it's not clear to me that you that [16:24] this new definition is necessary in the [16:27] Myanmar case. [16:28] >> I I think the way the question [16:31] presents it is that, you know, we want [16:33] this to be a genocide, so we need to [16:34] have something in place so that the [16:36] court can rule that it is. [16:38] Can the prosecutors prove that it's a [16:40] genocide? [16:41] From what I have seen, [16:43] I think it's very clear that it was a [16:44] genocidal attempt from the rhetoric, [16:46] from the actions, from the burning of [16:48] villages, from the indiscriminate murder [16:50] of civilians, from the [16:52] sexual violence that took place. Like [16:54] all of those things [16:55] for me fall under genocide, and for [16:57] everything I've seen I would say it's a [16:58] genocide. [17:00] But I haven't seen the case that Gambia [17:01] put forward, and nobody has cuz these [17:03] things go in closed chambers. [17:04] >> So Andrew, doesn't Hamas's October 7th [17:07] attack meet the criteria for genocide? [17:10] >> I I think there's a really credible case [17:12] for that. I mean, they were deliberately [17:13] attacking civilian communities. They [17:15] they killed civilians. They used sexual [17:17] violence as a as a weapon of conflict. [17:20] And you know, Hamas has a very strong [17:21] track record of explicitly anti-Jewish [17:24] exterminatory language. You know, that's [17:26] even in their founding charter. And [17:28] people will say, ah, but they've edited [17:29] it. But yes, I think [17:31] that they've changed the language [17:32] slightly. [17:33] But I think their founding principle of [17:36] of wanting to exterminate Jews is is a [17:38] pretty important part of this of this [17:40] conversation. In order to bring a case, [17:42] again, it would be the same threshold [17:44] for Hamas as anyone else. So you'd have [17:45] to connect their ideology, you'd have to [17:48] connect their planning, their conduct, [17:49] the orders to conduct that intent. [17:52] [snorts] [17:53] So you've got to be able to to reach [17:55] that threshold and say that it wasn't [17:56] anything else. Very possible. [17:59] I think that is something that could be [18:00] provable. But the reason Hamas isn't an [18:02] ICJ defendant [18:04] is cuz Hamas is an armed organization, [18:07] whereas the ICJ is designed to settle [18:09] cases between states. [18:12] So [18:13] the ICC, when they put their their [18:15] warrants in, of course for this, just to [18:17] remind you, that is the the [18:18] International Criminal Court, not the [18:20] Court of Justice. [18:22] Um, the ICC deals with individuals. The [18:24] ICJ deals with state on state [18:26] disagreement. Um, when they issued their [18:29] warrants for Mohammad Deif, they did [18:31] include war crimes, crimes against [18:33] humanity, extermination, [18:35] uh, and murder. So, [18:37] the ICC didn't quite reach the genocide [18:39] threshold, but the fact that they had [18:40] extermination in there is pretty [18:42] telling. So, [18:43] you know, should should there be cases [18:44] against Hamas's leadership such as they [18:46] remain alive, um, there's a very strong [18:48] case in the ICC to take them, uh, to [18:51] court for those crimes, but the ICJ [18:53] Hamas would not fall in scope for that. [18:56] So, you'd have to set up some sort of [18:58] separate tribunal like like Yugoslavia [19:01] um, to do that. But the question was [19:02] about the ICJ, and the ICJ is for state [19:04] on state disagreement, so you couldn't [19:06] take Hamas to the ICJ. So, if we if we [19:08] look at the cases we're talking about [19:09] today, Gambia versus Myanmar, South [19:11] Africa versus Israel, um, the ICJ is a [19:14] mechanism to settle disagreements [19:16] between UN member states. And of course, [19:18] Hamas is an armed insurgent group, not a [19:20] member state. So, to prosecute Hamas [19:23] through the international courts, you'd [19:25] either have to set up an international [19:26] tribunal similar to what was done in [19:28] Yugoslavia, um, or you could look at [19:30] individuals in Hamas who committed [19:32] specific crimes. So, it's it's a much [19:34] much harder to do, uh, [19:36] to do this when the genocide is carried [19:38] out by by a non-state actor. [19:40] >> Okay. How are Israel's legal and [19:43] security establishments assessing this [19:45] threat? [19:45] >> So, from the conversations I've had, [19:47] it's it's it's it's [19:49] broad and varied, uh, as you would [19:51] expect from Israel. So, some people are [19:53] still quite positive about it, some [19:54] people are very negative. [snorts] [19:56] Um, of course, Israel has defended [19:58] itself. Um, their next filing will be in [20:00] 2029 where they get to see South [20:02] Africa's [20:03] latest pack of evidence and respond to [20:05] it. So, we're not looking at a verdict [20:07] for for the Israel case well into the [20:08] 2030s, so time is to some extent on [20:12] their side. [20:13] Um, Israel has [20:15] I know for a fact the IDF are taking [20:17] this incredibly seriously in terms of [20:18] compiling, uh, evidence of military [20:21] objectives, evidence of civilian harm [20:23] precautions, [20:25] uh the aid measures in terms of the [20:27] amount of aid that went in. And I think [20:29] their their case is also focused on the [20:31] fact that actually a lot of the really [20:33] appalling comments that Israeli made [20:35] Israelis made were by people who weren't [20:36] in the command chain. [20:38] So [snorts] it's all very well to say we [20:40] should, you know, we should drive all of [20:41] the Gazans out of Gaza, but if you don't [20:43] have any say in the decision making [20:45] process, I think their argument would be [20:47] that actually that's [20:48] just somebody essentially is [20:50] essentially exercising their right to [20:52] free speech, which is I think, [20:54] you know, to be to be condemned when [20:56] they say these things, but if you're not [20:57] in the military or political decision [20:59] making chain, how much influence or [21:00] impact do you actually have on what [21:02] happens on the ground in Gaza? So that's [21:04] really tricky. So there are two camps, [21:06] one one a positive and [21:08] one a negative. And the uh the positive [21:12] camp think that actually it's going to [21:13] be very hard for them to change the [21:15] threshold of intent, and even if they [21:16] do, Israel's got enough evidence in its [21:18] back pocket to to to rebut that. There [21:21] is the other camp who believe that the [21:23] court is a kangaroo court that's stacked [21:24] against them. They've appointed judges [21:26] who have already declared it to be a [21:28] genocide, and so they take a much more [21:30] pessimistic view um of how things will [21:33] unfold. And and the challenge that [21:34] second camp has is is how to respond if [21:36] it does go as badly as they fear it [21:38] will. So that's the real challenge here [21:40] for the Israelis is is working out if if [21:42] everything goes against them, what their [21:44] appropriate response should be. And [21:46] that's far more tricky than than [21:49] you know, the situation that the first [21:50] camp face who who believe that they have [21:52] all the evidence they need uh to [21:54] exonerate Israel. [21:55] >> We'll be right back after this short [21:56] message. [22:00] How people come to understand Israel and [22:02] Jewish life right now depends on who is [22:04] telling our story. Today, that work [22:07] requires more care and integrity than [22:09] ever before, and that doesn't come [22:11] cheap. [22:12] Our Arc Plus members are the ones who [22:15] fund it. They support our mission and [22:17] get early access to our second weekly [22:19] episode, ad-free listening, and our [22:22] weekly members-only ask me anything [22:24] episode. [22:25] Join Ark Plus at arcmedia.org. [22:29] And to our members, thank you. [22:34] >> Hi, I'm Daniel Hartman, president [22:35] [music] of the Shalom Hartman Institute [22:37] in Jerusalem. [22:38] >> And I'm Yossi Klein Halevi, senior [22:40] fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute. [22:42] >> What's more important, to be feared by [22:44] your enemies or morally [music] true to [22:46] yourself? [22:47] >> Should Israel strive to be a nation [22:49] among nations or should it accept the [22:51] [music] fact that it is now a fortress [22:53] apart? [22:54] >> What do Israelis and Diasporic Jews owe [22:56] each other? [22:57] >> If you're Jewish, [22:58] >> or a friend and ally, [22:59] >> these questions have been gnawing at you [23:01] these past few years. [23:03] >> For some of you, like for us, [music] [23:05] these questions have been keeping you up [23:07] at night. And for some, they've been [23:09] simmering in the background, waiting for [23:11] answers. [23:12] >> But dilemmas don't always have clear [23:14] answers. What they do deserve are honest [23:18] and respectful debates. [music] [23:20] >> And as it happens, Yossi and I love to [23:22] challenge each other to get to the [23:24] bottom of things. [music] [23:25] >> We look at current events through the [23:27] lens that speaks to us most deeply, the [23:29] Jewish lens. [23:30] >> So if today's Jewish dilemmas are on [23:32] your mind, tune into our conversation [23:34] [music] [23:35] on For Heaven's Sake, a partnership [23:37] between Ark Media and the Shalom Hartman [23:39] Institute. [23:40] >> You can find For Heaven's Sake on Apple, [23:42] Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get [23:45] your podcasts. [23:46] >> See you there. [23:50] >> Andrew, so when you when you think about [23:52] these different camps that you're [23:53] describing in the Israeli system, what [23:54] defense strategies could each camp [23:57] develop or shape to challenge South [24:00] Africa's allegations? [24:02] >> Yeah, so broadly, we can break this down [24:03] into sort of the legal side of things [24:05] and then the military side of things. So [24:07] for the legal team, um they can develop [24:10] their understanding of the specific [24:12] intent requirement. [24:14] Um [24:16] bearing in mind this is a state-on-state [24:17] allegation, so the allegation is that [24:19] the state of Israel as a stated policy [24:22] wanted to commit genocide. So you can [24:24] distinguish state responsibility from [24:26] individual criminal liability. You know, [24:29] of course, there are war crimes in Gaza [24:30] to investigate, and I think if you can [24:33] break the link between state direction [24:36] and individual criminality, that's [24:37] really, really important. [24:39] Um, [24:40] you know, context is vital. Um, and if [24:42] we look at some of the statements [24:43] they've used to accuse, for example, [24:45] President Herzog, [24:47] [snorts] um, you know, they've clipped [24:48] sentences that he said where in the very [24:50] same sentence he goes on to clarify that [24:53] he was talking about Hamas rather than [24:54] all of Gaza. [24:56] So, you know, there's a lot of context [24:57] that Israel will be able to supply [24:58] there. [25:00] And I think breaking the link between [25:01] hey, civilian casualties and genocide is [25:04] really important because civilian [25:06] casualties do happen in warfare. [25:08] Um, there is provision in the law of [25:10] armed conflict to allow civilian [25:11] casualties to occur legally. [25:13] Uh, and Israel, I think at the legal [25:15] level will have to show that they took [25:17] the necessary precautions, that they did [25:18] apply the principles of proportionality. [25:21] Um, and if they've kept their records [25:22] properly, that should be relatively [25:24] straightforward. So that's the legal [25:25] level. [25:26] Um, at the military level, [25:28] um, it's about preservation of targeting [25:31] decisions. It's about proportionality [25:33] assessments. It's about [25:35] uh, evidence of the warnings they gave [25:37] um, to Palestinians to to get out of the [25:39] area before they struck. Um, and then I [25:41] think the really important thing to do [25:43] at the military level is to reintroduce [25:45] Hamas into the conversation [25:47] because they spent three years deleting [25:49] themselves from public conversation to [25:52] speak to online discourse. You'd think [25:54] there wasn't even a war in Gaza. You [25:56] think it was just Israel bombing away [25:57] merrily, um, hitting whatever they [26:00] could. You know, Israel suffered 500 [26:02] killed in action, 3,000 wounded in Gaza. [26:04] Uh, most of the damage and destruction [26:06] we see on those those awful photos is [26:08] through ground maneuver, [26:10] not through um, air strikes. You know, [26:12] it's the way that Hamas put an IED every [26:15] 50 yards or even more dense [26:17] into [snorts] the Gazan areas they were [26:20] fighting through. You know, all of this [26:21] is completely omitted from public [26:23] discourse. And that's the sort of thing [26:25] that Israel need to put into [26:27] their case from a military perspective [26:28] to prove that they were actually [26:29] fighting a very determined and vicious [26:32] enemy who who inflicted actually some [26:33] quite significant blows on them as they [26:35] fought their way through those areas in [26:37] Gaza. [26:38] So that's that's what you really need to [26:40] do I think if you're Israel is is stop [26:42] start breaking that intent chain between [26:44] state and individual criminality [26:46] and then prove that you are fighting a [26:48] war rather than just trying to [26:50] exterminate the Palestinian population [26:52] in whole or in part. [26:54] >> Okay, I want to consider two scenarios. [26:56] The first is Israel's found responsible [26:58] for genocide, but the United States [27:00] continues to protect Israel [27:03] at various international fora the most [27:05] obviously critical one is at the UN [27:08] Security Council. [27:09] What would be the practical consequences [27:11] be for Israel's economy, its arms [27:13] supplies, diplomatic relationships and [27:16] standing in the world? [27:18] >> I mean there's a lot of moving parts to [27:19] this and a lot of it's going to depend [27:20] on who sits in the White House at the [27:23] time this verdict comes in. [27:25] And it also I think depends on how [27:27] successful or otherwise Israel may have [27:29] been in in fixing its reputational [27:31] issues. You know we've seen if you look [27:32] at the polls in the United States we've [27:34] seen declining support from for Israel [27:36] on both main parties [27:39] especially in the younger generation. So [27:41] if we think you know forward maybe [27:44] maybe five, six, seven years when this [27:46] this [27:47] decision actually gets comes in I think [27:49] a lot will depend on the political [27:51] atmosphere at the time. [27:53] Will Israel still be able to count on [27:54] the United States for its veto in the [27:56] Security Council? I think it's [27:57] incredibly important because the ICJ [28:00] itself [28:01] can't actually hand down a punishment. [28:03] So this isn't like an ordinary court [28:04] where you have a verdict and then the [28:07] punishment comes down. [28:09] The punishment will have to be applied [28:11] to through either the UN General [28:12] Assembly in a non-binding resolution or [28:14] through the [28:15] Security Council with a binding [28:18] resolution. And that's where the danger [28:19] lies for Israel when South Africa [28:21] applies to the UN Security Council for [28:24] sanctions for [28:27] you know diplomatic measures [28:29] and the US declines to veto it that [28:32] would be a really seminal moment that [28:34] that causes Israel real harm. And you're [28:36] looking at, you know, sanctions, [28:37] economic damage, diplomatic isolation. I [28:40] mean, in the most extreme circumstances, [28:42] you could even get states trying to make [28:44] the case for military action. Um, you [28:46] know, that is an extreme scenario, but [28:47] it's not off the table if this verdict [28:50] comes in. And so that's the um that's [28:51] the really challenging thing for thing [28:53] for Israel here. Um, and it shows I [28:55] think I think it shows really clearly [28:56] why Israel's [28:58] standing in America is so important [29:01] um and why the fact they haven't taken [29:03] perhaps the the PR war or the [29:05] information war um as seriously as they [29:08] should have done is going to come back [29:09] and bite them quite severely if the [29:11] other efforts to change the genocide uh [29:15] ruling um are successful and and see [29:18] Israel um see Israel condemned. So it's [29:21] it's a very it's a very broad picture. [29:23] It's a very holistic thing that Israel [29:25] has to consider and we have to um [29:26] understand where the risks and the [29:28] dangers lie here. [29:29] >> So I said I said Andrew, let's consider [29:32] two scenarios. You obviously gave one [29:34] one one very dark scenario. So suppose a [29:37] a future American administration [29:39] withdraws the protection of the UN [29:41] Security Council veto [29:43] and [29:44] international sanctions begin to bite [29:46] and Israel increasingly finds itself [29:49] isolated. That I mean that that is where [29:50] this could go [29:52] in a if we if we really do want to go [29:54] towards a a very it try to evaluate what [29:57] a a very dark scenario looks like. [29:59] >> Yeah, exactly. I mean if if Washington [30:01] permits [30:03] broad measures to be brought against [30:05] Israel in the Security Council and [30:06] doesn't veto it, you know, I think arms [30:09] embargo is the minimum we can expect. [30:11] Uh and of course Israel is still to an [30:13] extent dependent on [30:15] uh American arms. Um I know Bibi, the [30:18] President so promised Netanyahu has [30:20] spoken about the need for Israel to to [30:21] gain a degree of strategic independence [30:23] and I would agree with that assessment [30:25] um especially of course because Israel [30:27] is still and is going to be for the [30:29] foreseeable future still surrounded by [30:30] enemies [30:31] who wish [30:32] the country military harm. Those those [30:35] arms and the ability to defend [30:37] themselves is critical for Israel's [30:39] Israel's future. [30:41] The challenge would come in things like [30:42] spare parts for the F35, replacement [30:45] munitions for to replace bombs that have [30:47] been dropped. [30:48] Um, [30:49] and on top of that, [30:51] if you could coincide that with [30:52] financial measures, with trade measures, [30:54] with with economic sanctions, [30:56] uh, Israel would see slower growth, [30:58] rising cost of defense. [31:00] And you would also have to consider that [31:04] there is a, uh, there'll be individual [31:06] responsibilities on people with to to [31:08] deal with what has been ruled a genocide [31:10] or state would become legally much [31:11] harder. So even in the private sector, [31:13] that will become a challenge as well. So [31:15] it's, you know, this this ruling if it [31:17] comes in in the worst case scenario [31:19] could be really damaging. [31:20] >> Okay. I want to close [31:23] by asking you, I mean, you're a military [31:24] expert, you're also an international law [31:27] expert. By your lights, [31:30] has Israel been preparing at least, [31:33] you know, I mean, there's the immediate [31:34] aftermath of October 7th. There's the [31:36] multiple fronts Israel had to fight [31:38] kinetically. But more recently, do you [31:40] think Israel has been preparing for the [31:42] wrong kind of war? [31:43] >> Yeah, I mean, I think [31:45] in many ways the over focus on the [31:47] physical fight has been [31:49] essential. You know, I can understand [31:51] completely [31:52] why defending Israel's borders, allowing [31:54] people to move back to the Galilee and [31:56] the Gaza periphery and securing the [31:58] state of Israel physically has been the [32:01] priority. It makes a lot of sense, but [32:03] I think [32:04] the theme here is that Israel has failed [32:07] to integrate battlefield success with a [32:09] sustainable political outcome. [32:11] And that's always been the real [32:12] challenge for Israel because it sits [32:13] slightly outside their gift to achieve. [32:16] But just killing the enemy and [32:17] destroying [32:19] uh, their capabilities doesn't [32:20] necessarily establish what happens when [32:22] the fighting stops. [32:24] And that's been the real challenge for [32:26] Israel. And I think in many ways they've [32:27] also considered [32:29] things like humanitarian policy, things [32:31] like legal scrutiny as problems to worry [32:33] about after the fighting is done. You [32:35] can follow all the policies that you you [32:37] you should legally. you can follow [32:39] international law. [32:41] Um, but I think unless you look at [32:44] how else your enemy is attacking you, [32:46] you kind of miss a really important part [32:47] of the picture. And what I think uh [32:50] quite a lot of people I've spoken to in [32:52] Israel, certainly at the level of [32:53] general or politi- a political [32:56] uh echelons, [32:57] um they've kind of tried to defer this [32:59] problem to later on where actually it [33:00] should have been an integral part of [33:02] what they were doing [33:03] um right from the start in order to to [33:05] foresee these potential negative [33:07] ramifications and mitigate them early [33:10] because what th- what's happening now is [33:11] because they didn't do that, they're now [33:13] on the back foot defending themselves. [33:15] So I think that there's a lesson there, [33:16] but I think those mistakes are [33:18] understandable. General hindsight has [33:20] never lost a war and we can all be back [33:22] room lawyers. So um in the context of [33:25] 7th of October and the shock that [33:26] happened to Israel and the needs to to [33:28] rescue those 251 people dragged into the [33:31] tunnels, [33:32] um you can forgive the Israelis for not [33:34] worrying about legal ramifications in [33:35] international courts in 10 years time [33:37] after the event. [33:38] >> So I take your I take your point that [33:40] you can't retroactively [33:43] you know repair the situation, but what [33:44] could Israel do today [33:46] if anything [33:48] to prevent the outcome [33:50] you're you're most concerned about? [33:52] What could Israel do? [33:54] >> Well, I think it's all going to live and [33:55] die on the uh on the ICJ case and how [33:58] Israel prepares its case and and make [33:59] the case that this is a war that they [34:02] were fighting a determined and capable [34:04] enemy, which they were. [34:06] Um, and I think if you can show that [34:08] conclusively, I think that makes it very [34:10] hard to say it's a genocide. [34:12] Now if the case is stacked against them, [34:14] then I guess the answer here then then [34:16] sits at the political level on the [34:17] American side. [34:19] Um, you know you need to focus on on [34:21] winning back [34:22] those voters that you've lost and that [34:24] needs uh you know a state PR campaign to [34:26] put it very bluntly. [34:28] Um, it needs Israel to do much better at [34:31] selling itself to the world in terms of [34:32] how it conducted its uh its conflict. [34:35] It probably needs a degree of [34:36] accountability for people like Ben-Gvir [34:38] and Smotrich and and all the other [34:40] politicians who [34:42] uh he he said such [34:43] dreadful and damaging things. I I think [34:45] Israel could potentially be a little bit [34:47] more open about how it prosecutes war [34:49] crimes as well and maybe be a little bit [34:51] more explicit as as to how many people [34:53] have been convicted of those because [34:54] that will break the link between state [34:58] instruction and individual criminal [35:00] action on the ground. [35:01] Um [35:02] but of course it's all going to start [35:03] with a new government and until Israel [35:06] gets that in place uh I don't think [35:08] we're going to see much movement on that [35:09] side of things. [35:10] >> Okay Andrew, we will leave it there. Um [35:12] thank you for this sobering [35:14] but illuminating conversation and we [35:16] will be tracking [35:18] the developments at the ICJ uh over the [35:20] next few days uh and until then I look [35:22] forward to having you back on. [35:24] >> Thanks Dan, it's been a real pleasure. [35:26] >> [music] [35:30] >> If Call Me Back is where you come for [35:32] honest conversations about Israel and [35:34] the Jewish world, please hit subscribe [35:37] and also share it with a friend. [35:38] And if you missed our last episode, it's [35:40] worth going back for. See you next time.