Transcript [00:00] There could have been [music] a European [00:02] Islam. Islam is walking backwards with [00:06] such movements as the Muslim [00:09] Brotherhood. [00:10] >> Are people correct to feel that there is [00:12] some form of domination being attempted [00:14] by Islam all of [music] these [00:16] demonstrations, be they in France or [00:18] England or Italy? We see the waving of [00:22] the Palestinian flag. All of this is [00:25] engineered [music] behind the scenes by [00:27] the Muslim Brotherhood who have paired [00:30] up with [music] [00:31] the Iranian Shiite anti-Zionism. There's [00:35] no real engagement with human rights [00:38] with within Islam [00:40] which gives expression to some of the [00:44] most horrendous forms of brutality. Jews [00:47] were burned alive, [00:50] burned alive. They were completely [00:51] dehumanized. They had to pay a tax of [00:55] jizya. [music] [00:55] He was given a receipt in the form of a [00:58] lead seal which he had to wear on his [01:01] neck, a symbol [music] of his [01:03] subservience to Islam. There was no time [01:06] that Jews lived in perfect harmony and [01:09] fraternity with their Muslim neighbors. [01:12] Both Jews and non-Jews have missed the [01:15] boat. [01:16] >> I'm Jonathan Sackur-Dutton. Before we go [01:18] on, please remember to like and [01:19] subscribe to the channel and that way [01:21] you'll help it grow and you'll hear [01:22] about these interviews as they go on. [01:24] Professor Paul B. Fenton, welcome. So [01:27] good to see you here in Tel Aviv. You [01:28] are uniquely positioned, I think, to [01:30] talk about the interrelationship between [01:33] Islam and Judaism or even more broadly [01:36] Islam in the West. [01:38] Firstly, tell me about your background. [01:40] You're a professor that's spent decades [01:42] looking at how the two faiths have [01:44] interacted. [01:45] >> I have a traditional Jewish background. [01:48] I went to [01:50] the cheder and even a yeshiva, that's a [01:52] Talmudical college, so I had a [01:55] a sound grounding in Jewish studies. And [01:58] when I got to university, [02:00] um, I decided to take up Semitic [02:02] languages, [02:03] and I majored in Judaism. So early on, [02:07] um, it was obvious for me that my choice [02:10] would be a combination of the two [02:12] disciplines, and this has now been a [02:15] lifelong a quest as it were, um, in in [02:21] so far as I'm interested in the [02:23] language, the civilization, and the and [02:27] the encounter between these two [02:29] civilizations, Jewish and Islamic. [02:32] >> So when people today talk about Judaism [02:35] and Islam having previously existed in [02:39] harmony, perhaps before the era of [02:41] Zionism and having been a golden age, [02:45] what are they most misunderstanding in [02:48] in that description? [02:49] >> I think we can say positive things about [02:52] the relationship between Islam and [02:55] Judaism, but um, from the outset, and [02:59] I'm talking about Islam and Judaism, not [03:02] about [03:03] the Arabic civilization, which of course [03:05] is pre-Islamic, but from the outset, [03:07] unfortunately, [03:09] there was a conflict [03:11] uh, due to the fact that Muhammad [03:14] wanted to be acclaimed by the Jews as a [03:18] prophet, [03:19] and obviously he hadn't done his [03:22] homework, otherwise he would have known [03:25] that in the Jewish tradition, in [03:30] you can only be a prophet [03:32] in [03:33] the land of Israel or in connection with [03:35] the land of Israel. So there was no way [03:37] that he was going to be acclaimed as a [03:41] prophet. [03:42] Uh, but in the first two years of his [03:45] career, [03:46] he multiplied these attention to the [03:50] Jewish way of life and integrated Jewish [03:53] elements [03:54] into [03:55] the nascent Islam. [03:57] But and it took him two years to realize [04:00] that he wouldn't be accepted [04:03] the Jews. [04:04] And whereas in the first part of his [04:06] career as reflected indeed in the Quran [04:09] itself, he had some very favorable and [04:12] positive things to say about the Jews. [04:14] For example, that they were a kingdom of [04:17] priests and and kings, [04:20] um a chosen nation. Moses being the [04:23] prophet who is the most mentioned in in [04:26] the Quran. After two years, he turned [04:29] his back on Jerusalem literally [04:32] because hitherto it had been the [04:36] uh the orientation of of Islamic prayer, [04:40] turned his back on Jerusalem [04:42] 180 degrees and turned his attention to [04:47] Mecca and turned his back on Judaism and [04:50] then [04:51] uh said some of the most um [04:54] negative and even violent things about [04:57] Judaism which have marked the Islamic [05:01] attitude to Jews ever since. [05:04] Um heightened in that in that direction [05:07] by what is known as the the hadith, the [05:11] oral tradition in Islam. So very early [05:14] on [05:15] that that that sort of fashioned the way [05:19] that Islam would traditionally look at [05:21] Judaism. [05:23] And were it not for the fact that [05:26] um [05:28] uh Muhammad reserved a special treatment [05:32] to the [05:34] uh to the Jews and Christians within the [05:36] framework of his general attitude to [05:39] non-Muslims, i.e. [05:41] either convert or be put to the sword. [05:44] The Jews and Christians having received [05:48] a divine revelation [05:50] were allowed to keep their [05:52] religion, retain their original creed [05:57] um providing that they became the [06:02] and I'd like to uh dwell on on this term [06:05] for a moment or two, which is one of the [06:08] terms like the Golden Age, which is [06:11] very generally misunderstood. That there [06:15] are two words for protected in Arabic. [06:19] One is [06:21] like for example, the French [06:23] protectorate [06:25] in Morocco was [06:27] and [06:28] which is a term which is [06:31] misunderstood because it's [06:33] translated as protected people was the [06:37] status that [06:41] that the Muhammad [06:45] gave to Jews and Christians, which is [06:47] not protected. If protected, then [06:50] protected against whom? The Marcians or [06:55] people coming in from outer space, from [06:56] the Muslims themselves. That is that [06:59] they are [07:01] not protected in a paternal way, but [07:04] they are not to be killed, not to be [07:07] converted forcefully [07:10] forcibly converted to Islam because they [07:13] enjoyed the divine favor in in [07:17] a four times and this is why they were [07:20] allowed to keep their religion [07:22] if they accepted, if they accepted the [07:26] conditions which then were developed [07:28] later on in Islamic [07:31] theology as the conditions of Omar [07:36] supposedly [07:38] the first caliph of the Islamic [07:44] reign [07:46] which were a certain number of [07:48] conditions that Jews and Christians had [07:51] to [07:52] had to accept some sometimes 20 30 in [07:55] number such as for example, they're not [07:59] allowed to carry arms, they were not [08:01] allowed to ride on horses by which their [08:05] their heads would be higher than the [08:06] Muslims. They were not allowed to pass a [08:09] Muslim on his right hand side. [08:12] They were not allowed to make a public [08:15] representations of their religion like [08:17] reading the the Bible or the New [08:20] Testament loudly and were not allowed to [08:22] sound the bells of the church or sound [08:25] the shofar in public Muslim public [08:29] spaces etc etc. If they [08:32] accepted their condition, then they were [08:34] tolerated. So I would say dhimma [08:38] is better translated as tolerated rather [08:42] than protected. [08:43] And but if [08:46] they [08:47] happen to [08:48] um [08:50] to uh [08:52] to to go against the laws of the dhimma, [08:56] then this alliance, this of [09:00] toleration was broken and it they were [09:03] their their [09:05] blood then became licit to be spelt by [09:10] uh by the Muslims. And uh [09:13] on on on on such occasions [09:17] uh [09:17] death could come [09:19] even without a trial rather brutally. [09:22] For example, if uh [09:25] a Jew or a Christian was [09:27] um accused of having insulted the [09:29] prophet, then death would follow without [09:31] a trial immediately. This was a breaking [09:34] of the dhimma, of the pact of [09:37] toleration. [09:38] >> And this is original Islam that you're [09:40] describing. [09:41] >> Uh the attitude, the negative attitude [09:44] to to Jews and Christians much more to [09:47] Jews because Muhammad was very eager [09:52] to be accepted as a prophet by the Jews [09:54] and therefore his [09:56] disappointment was all the greater when [09:59] he realised that this was not to be. So [10:02] his resentment [10:04] towards the Jews was was much more [10:06] aggressive than it was towards the [10:08] Christians. This is in the [10:10] and as I say uh [10:12] was augmented and amplified by [10:17] the hadith that is a collection of the [10:20] sayings of Muhammad in in all sorts of [10:23] attitudes and and encounters. And indeed [10:27] Muhammad was not brought up in a [10:33] religious vacuum. He was [10:37] surrounded by by by Christians and [10:42] much more by Jews, especially when he [10:46] fled from Mecca in 622 which marks the [10:51] beginning of the Islamic era, the Hijra. [10:54] When the Hijra, when he fled from [10:57] Mecca to Medina. [11:00] And just a little remark on the word [11:02] Medina, that's a Hebrew word. It does [11:05] not exist in the Arabic language. Like [11:08] we have Medinat Yisrael, state of [11:11] Israel. Medina was the name, a Hebrew [11:13] name given to the second [11:16] most holy [11:17] city in Islam is a Hebrew word [11:20] because it was [11:22] inhabited by a majority of Jews. And if [11:27] Muhammad fled there, it was because he [11:29] was convinced that he would be welcomed [11:32] by the Jews and recognized by them as a [11:36] prophet. [11:37] >> So among the conditions that you [11:39] mentioned, um there was also the tax, [11:41] right, that they had to pay, the jizya. [11:44] Can you explain that? [11:45] >> I like to translate it not as a tax but [11:49] as a capitation. And in the word [11:52] capitation you have the old Latin word [11:55] caput which means the head. [11:57] And this is really bringing home the [12:00] meaning of this term jizya which which [12:04] signifies that these people should have [12:06] been beheaded like the infidels, but [12:10] because they [12:12] had this privilege of being the people [12:15] favored by God with a divine revelation, [12:19] then as I said earlier, they were [12:21] allowed to keep their religion [12:23] and that in lieu of their being beheaded [12:28] capitation they had to pay a tax a jizya [12:31] an annual tax [12:33] which with the evolution of Islam became [12:37] a very burdensome tax and I think that [12:41] one of the great orientalists of former [12:44] generation Goitein [12:47] calculated that it could represent like [12:50] 30% of a Jew or a Christian's income [12:54] which annual annual income. So it was a [12:57] very heavy tax [12:59] and [13:00] when it [13:02] when a Jew or a Christian dhimmi was [13:04] unable to pay the tax he was when he did [13:07] pay the tax by the way he was given a [13:09] receipt in the form of a lead [13:13] seal which he had to wear on his neck [13:16] and wherever wherever he went so that he [13:19] could be recognized as a dhimmi [13:22] and that he paid his tax which was [13:26] a symbol of his subservience to Islam, [13:30] but if he was unable to pay the tax he [13:32] was imprisoned and tortured and [13:36] very often Jews and Christians [13:39] eventually converted to Islam in order [13:42] to escape the burden of taxation [13:46] and this was one of actually one of the [13:48] objectives of the the jizya was to [13:53] encourage Jews and Christians to see the [13:55] light in inverted commas and convert to [13:59] Islam. [13:59] >> So when you talk about protection it's a [14:01] bit like when the mafia talks about [14:03] protection. There's protection money and [14:06] it's your insurance to be protected from [14:08] the people you're actually paying. [14:10] >> Who actually threatening you with death? [14:13] >> In real terms then in Morocco Algeria, [14:16] you've written extensively and spent [14:18] decades studying really thousands of [14:20] years of history. What would life as a [14:23] dhimmi have been like? Not not in a [14:27] legal sense, but in actual practical [14:29] day-to-day life. [14:30] >> Well, as you say, I have studied this [14:32] and I have written a book called um the [14:35] exile in the Maghreb, a thousand years [14:38] of Jewish experience under Islam. [14:42] And um [14:44] uh [14:45] uh not in any desire to um [14:49] undermine uh [14:51] some very appreciable efforts which are [14:53] made especially in Morocco [14:55] at the present time to acknowledge the [14:59] Jewish contribution to Islamic [15:02] civilization, especially in North [15:04] Africa. [15:05] I think that [15:07] no reconciliation is possible without [15:11] taking into account what was the reality [15:16] of the dhimmi situation [15:19] uh in the historical perspective. [15:21] Much in the same way as Vatican II [15:24] recognized um the uh [15:28] uh [15:29] the crimes of the church against [15:33] in against the Jews and in Jews in terms [15:36] of investiga- in terms of persecution [15:40] and in the Inquisition. [15:42] Um and um perhaps we can come back to [15:45] this Inquisition when when we talk about [15:47] the Golden Age of Islam [15:49] uh in in Al-Andalus. But um uh [15:53] again, in in the same spirit of the [15:57] imposition of the capitation, [16:01] and everything was put uh [16:04] into pressure on the Jews and [16:06] Christians, but [16:08] especially in North Africa, [16:11] uh where Christian presence had uh had [16:14] died out very very soon. [16:17] Uh [16:19] recall in passing that [16:21] that North Africa had been the seat of [16:24] some of the Christian fathers of the [16:26] church. There was a very strong [16:28] Christian presence in North Africa which [16:31] petered out under the weight of the [16:33] dhimma and persecution. They could not [16:37] withstand the the brunt of of of [16:42] Islamic [16:43] persecution. As it was a persecution, [16:45] everything was brought [16:48] in [16:49] upon the [16:51] to weigh down on the [16:53] convince him to [16:55] to to convert to Islam. He was [16:58] considered as a citizen of second degree [17:02] and [17:04] was confined to special quarters [17:07] which were overpopulated [17:09] and could not benefit from [17:14] the hygienic conditions that [17:17] the improved hygienic conditions that [17:19] you could find in the Medina [17:22] that he had to wear a special garb which [17:25] would distinguish him from the Muslim [17:29] citizens. Those one of the reasons being [17:32] that he would shouldn't be [17:34] hailed as a Muslim with the traditional [17:39] salutation [17:41] which was reserved only for for Muslims [17:45] and [17:46] therefore his movements were hindered [17:50] that it was it was dangerous for a Jew [17:54] to [17:55] to adventure beyond the [17:57] which was the reserved quarter or if you [17:59] like the ghetto. [18:02] The Jewish ghetto in Hara was also [18:04] called Hara in other parts of North [18:06] Africa [18:07] and the Jews did venture beyond the [18:11] protection of the because they were [18:15] petty [18:17] merchants in in in the villages and very [18:21] they were they were murdered or robbed [18:23] because they were immediately recognized [18:26] as Jews because of their distinctive [18:29] garb. [18:30] So all in all it was rather a miserable [18:34] existence [18:35] for the Jews who were it not [18:38] for their [18:41] special abilities in in the realm of [18:47] reading and writing mathematics were [18:49] able to [18:52] to rise beyond the condition which would [18:56] otherwise have been theirs as an utter [18:59] misery. [19:01] They would not have survived as as as [19:04] Jews. [19:05] >> So you mentioned there the the Golden [19:06] Age, the Al Andalus, the the Spanish [19:08] Golden Age. So you've emphasized some of [19:11] the negatives, let's say, but there [19:14] a lot of people point towards that as a [19:16] flourishing of Jewish thought and [19:18] particularly in interchange of mysticism [19:21] and Jewish mysticism and Sufism. So what [19:24] is the the lesser known good side or is [19:27] there one? [19:28] >> First of all, [19:30] there's a great misunderstanding about [19:32] this concept of the [19:34] Golden Age of Al Andalus, so much so [19:37] that people are pointing this so you see [19:40] it is possible [19:43] to come to an understanding and serenity [19:48] with Islamic [19:49] the civilization and the proof is that [19:53] in the Middle Ages [19:55] Jews, if we're going to talk about Jews [19:57] in particular, were able to [20:01] attain a very [20:03] high level of [20:05] culture and science and philosophy under [20:09] the reign of Islam, whereas they [20:14] lived at the same time and in [20:16] Christendom in the state of utter misery [20:19] and persecution. [20:21] The misunderstanding is that [20:24] this was a Jewish golden age, that [20:28] it was entirely internal. The Jews were [20:32] able through an understanding, through [20:35] input of Islamic [20:37] civilization, not [20:40] um not society but civilization, they [20:43] were able to learn philosophy and poetry [20:47] and science, medicine, and they were [20:50] able to rise [20:52] to a cultural level which was unequaled [20:55] until modern times. But in the societal [21:00] level [21:01] the this the pressure [21:03] of the outside Islamic world was still [21:07] um disastrous. [21:09] And the proof is that [21:11] who is [21:13] do we not have a greater model of the [21:16] ideal of the golden age than Maimonides, [21:20] Moses Maimonides, who lived from 1135 [21:24] till 1204? [21:26] And who was obliged to [21:30] flee his Spanish [21:34] Islamic Spain because of the [21:37] persecution, Al Muḥad, the reign of Al [21:39] Muḥad, which was one of the most [21:42] catastrophic [21:44] um [21:45] environments [21:48] in terms of persecution [21:50] and [21:53] annoyance of Jews that in the whole of [21:55] Islamic history. [21:57] Jews were, and I have proof of this, [22:00] that Maimonides himself was obliged to [22:03] to convert to Islam and acted outwardly [22:06] as a Muslim [22:08] and inwardly behind shutters as a Jew. [22:11] And eventually fled Islamic Spain for [22:15] more tolerant climates. [22:17] >> So when people say that [22:19] there was collaboration, cooperation, a [22:22] golden age um previous to Zionism, you [22:26] know, let's say the last 100 odd years, [22:29] what's true and what's historically [22:31] false? [22:32] >> The uh anti-Judaism, [22:35] anti-semitism is something else, but [22:37] anti-Judaism, as I say, was there from a [22:40] from the start as a leitmotif, [22:43] a constant leitmotif throughout the [22:46] history of Islamic Judeo [22:49] Muslim relations. And so there was no [22:51] time [22:53] that that Jews lived in perfect harmony [22:56] and fraternity with their Muslim [22:58] neighbors. However, it is true that when [23:03] Muslims became [23:05] more humanistic than Islamic, [23:08] when they were interested in philosophy [23:11] and theology as such, [23:14] we do have phenomena such as the Bait [23:17] al-Hikma in Baghdad where [23:20] there were discussion groups amongst [23:23] Jews, Christians, and Muslims [23:25] who talked about their different [23:27] conceptions of God and divine [23:30] attributes, aspects of theology. And [23:32] there were again in Andalusia at the [23:34] court of Granada [23:37] someone like [23:40] uh who was at the same time uh [23:43] politician and um a Sufi a mystic. There [23:47] were [23:48] exchanges between Jewish diplomats, [23:52] Jewish doctors, physicians and people of [23:55] that rank. [23:56] Um insofar as [23:59] uh a Sufi who had uh let's say a [24:02] metaphysical conception of religion [24:06] rather than a [24:07] a down-to-earth [24:09] legalistic approach [24:12] um were able to rise above the [24:14] differences between Jews and and Muslims [24:17] and [24:18] uh and and and come to a a situation [24:21] exchange [24:23] uh and um mutual appreciation. [24:27] >> One of the challenges [24:28] >> today for us non-Muslims who are [24:31] interested in the topic is to separate [24:33] this idea of a personal spiritual faith [24:37] from an origin story which seems to [24:40] encompass quite a lot of persecution, [24:43] domination, [24:44] um and war, brutalism in fact. [24:48] To what extent [24:49] I guess what I'm I'm getting at in all [24:51] these questions is to what extent is it [24:53] separate from Islam? To what extent is [24:55] this idea of Islamism, the political and [24:58] sometimes even warlike elements of Islam [25:02] separable from the origins of Islam, [25:06] Muhammad's story, the early foundations, [25:08] and the early texts? [25:09] >> Well, I think that the the most [25:12] outspoken [25:14] reply to that is the [25:17] sort of safe [25:19] that um [25:21] in the Quran there are a number of [25:23] internal contradictions without speaking [25:26] about contradictions in relation to the [25:28] Bible or Christian tradition. And there [25:32] are a number of internal contradictions. [25:35] And [25:36] this is explained by Islamic theology by [25:39] a theory of abrogation that what [25:42] Muhammad said [25:45] later on, which is in [25:48] contradiction to what he said earlier, [25:50] is what is to be taken into account and [25:53] abrogates what he said earlier. [25:55] >> So the later verses, if there's a [25:56] contradiction, you go by what he said [25:58] later on in life? [25:59] >> Yeah, I can give you a concrete example [26:01] that that [26:03] initially Muhammad said that the [26:05] drinking of wine is something which is [26:08] not nice, okay? [26:10] And later on there's a verse that says [26:12] that it's completely prohibited. So [26:15] something which is allowable but [26:17] unpalatable and something which is [26:20] forbidden at quite a distance. But he [26:22] later on abrogated [26:25] this later verse abrogated the first and [26:28] this is explained away by [26:30] by the Muslim [26:32] exegesis that had he if he had [26:34] prohibited outright from the beginning [26:36] alcohol, then he would never have had [26:40] the followers that accepted Islam. But [26:43] once that they had accepted Islam and [26:46] were inured or used to Islam, then he [26:49] came clobbered them as it were, so to [26:51] say, with the the absolute prohibition. [26:54] >> The alcohol example is a useful one [26:55] because today mainstream Islam does not [26:58] accept any consumption of alcohol. So [27:01] the abrogation is in practice. [27:03] >> What is interesting is that the last [27:06] verse in Surah at-Tawbah, the Surah of [27:09] repentance, which is the ninth Surah, [27:13] these are the [27:14] the chapters which comprise the Quran, [27:17] the fifth verse is known as also as the [27:21] verse of the sword, [27:24] Ayat as-Sayf, and which says [27:26] once the sacred months have passed, that [27:29] is Muharram, when you are not allowed to [27:31] commit murder, [27:33] kill the polytheist, the mushrikin, [27:37] wherever you find them, capture them, [27:39] besiege them, and lie in wait for them [27:42] on every way. [27:43] But if they repent, perform prayers, [27:46] repent means that if they convert to [27:48] Islam, then [27:50] and they pay the jizya, then set them [27:53] free because Allah is [27:57] is merciful. Allah is merciful. [28:03] And [28:04] on this point very interestingly, [28:07] in a discussion, someone once told me, [28:10] yes, Allah is merciful, but men are not [28:13] merciful. Whereas in Jewish [28:15] theology, it says [28:21] just as God is merciful, be thou [28:24] merciful. [28:26] Is that good if you catch the the nuance [28:29] is very important. So here this is the [28:31] last verse that Muhammad's mentions [28:34] uh that he he reveals, and this is the [28:37] absolute abrogation of everything that [28:40] went before that polytheists if they do [28:43] not accept accept Islam, they are to be [28:45] killed. So here you have inherent in the [28:48] other the [28:50] Islam in the Quran itself, which is the [28:54] book uh the the Bible, sacred word of [28:57] Islam. I repeat ninth surah verse five, [29:01] everyone can look it up and this this is [29:03] the message. [29:04] >> And Jews are classed as polytheists? [29:06] >> Now there is a big discussion in Islam. [29:09] This comes up [29:11] many a time. Are Jews [29:13] uh monotheists? Are they or are they [29:16] not? [29:17] The general consensus [29:19] in [29:20] Sunnah in the Sunnah form of Islam is [29:23] that they are not, but sometimes they [29:26] are considered as [29:28] uh because they are [29:31] accused of worshipping in in in in [29:35] in in the same time as God some [29:38] mysterious character that was not really [29:41] being identified called [29:44] that they are worshipping [29:46] and that is an accusation that is often [29:50] pointed out pointed against the Jews and [29:52] therefore they are [29:55] and therefore you're not allowed to to [29:57] to marry Jewish women according to some [30:00] some opinions. On the other hand, in [30:03] Shiite Islam [30:05] which has always had the the most [30:08] negative attitude traditionally from the [30:11] very beginning towards Jews [30:14] they are like in the Jewish tradition [30:19] they are five cardinal principles [30:22] of [30:24] of uncleanliness [30:29] uh for example blood and [30:34] and [30:35] menstruation [30:37] the pigs and Jews are one of the [30:40] cardinal sources of of uncleanness, and [30:43] therefore the Jews are considered in [30:46] Shiite Islam as being essentially [30:51] um unclean, najasat in in in Persian, [30:54] najat najas, that they are essentially [30:58] unclean, and therefore it was forbidden [31:00] in traditional Persia for a Jew to to go [31:05] out in the marketplace, to pass through [31:07] the marketplace if it was raining, [31:09] lest a drop of rain could have fallen on [31:13] him, then sprinkle on the fruit which [31:16] was exhibited in the market, which then [31:18] became unclean. [31:19] >> So the actual filth of Jewishness can [31:21] can be washed onto other physical [31:24] things. [31:25] >> This is anti-Jewish, anti-Judaism. [31:27] >> right. And I suppose the the question I [31:29] have on that is that there are those who [31:30] say that it is the modern concept of [31:33] Zionism and the modern state of Israel [31:36] that have kind of brought out an [31:37] animosity towards the Jew and towards [31:40] Israel, and that, you know, these [31:43] centuries of harmony previous to that or [31:46] something that that is more inherent to [31:48] Islam than the [31:50] bloodshed and the violence. And And it [31:52] sounds to me like you're not a believer [31:55] in that that thesis. [31:56] >> We've discussed earlier the fact that [31:59] the Jews are tolerated, [32:01] just about tolerated in Sunni Islam, [32:05] that they're less tolerated in Shiite [32:07] Islam traditionally over the ages, [32:10] and um that we have [32:14] like in like in the case of North [32:16] Africa, we have [32:18] outbreaks of of pogroms and and [32:23] and [32:25] and forced conversion in Islam. [32:28] We are sitting in in Neve Tzedek, [32:31] and [32:33] something like 200 yards away we have a [32:36] The synagogue here. unfortunately, it's [32:39] it's in [32:41] it's in [32:43] disrepair and is not used anymore, but [32:45] it was founded [32:47] by Jews from Mashhad. There's a street [32:49] here that is [32:51] has information about Jews of Mashhad [32:54] who fled from Mashhad in eastern Persia [32:59] after the forced conversion, I think it [33:01] was some of like 1830, 1840 [33:05] and disguised as Muslims who were on [33:09] their way to the Hajj. They then left [33:12] the caravan and made their way to [33:16] the land of Israel where they returned [33:18] to Judaism and settled in in Tel Aviv [33:21] and and [33:23] first of all in Jerusalem and then Tel [33:24] Aviv. So here is an example of a whole [33:27] community of Jews who were forcibly [33:31] converted to Islam in the 19th century, [33:34] but this is only one of many of a series [33:37] of of of persecutions and and forced [33:40] conversion. Now I'd like to say [33:42] something about anti-Zionism [33:44] which [33:46] supposedly is something which was only [33:49] developed after the creation of State of [33:51] Israel in 1948. [33:54] First of all, as an introduction to [33:57] this, I would like to say [33:59] that [34:00] the Jerusalem [34:02] in traditional Shiite Islam not only has [34:06] no significance at all, but is even [34:11] rebuffed and marginalized in Shiite [34:15] tradition. There's a question asked in [34:19] the [34:22] Bihar al-Anwar, which is the 16 volume [34:27] some of [34:29] Shiite theology by Muhammad al-Baqir. [34:34] That was a very [34:36] common name in in [34:38] in in in Iran today, Baqir, [34:41] who is asked the question [34:43] um should we prefer [34:45] uh should we turn towards Jerusalem in [34:47] prayer? Should what significance is [34:49] Jerusalem? He says there's no [34:51] significance at all. We should prefer [34:54] Najaf or Kufa than than Jerusalem. The [34:57] proof being that there's no monument in [35:01] the whole land of Israel that was built [35:04] by a Shiite Islam. No significance at [35:07] all, no institution, no edifice of [35:10] Shiite Islam, nothing to it. Not only [35:12] that, [35:13] but even though on the the banknotes [35:16] from the time of Khomeini you have the [35:19] Dome of the Rock [35:20] >> Mhm. [35:21] >> that until the time of Khomeini [35:24] uh [35:25] Jerusalem was looked down upon, spat [35:28] upon [35:29] and the effigy of Omar who who built the [35:34] the uh [35:36] the the Dome of the Rock [35:39] was [35:41] very much in the spirit of Guy Fawkes in [35:44] in in England and effigy of Omar was [35:47] burnt every year. Eid Qushani Amra was [35:51] burnt and and [35:53] it was his destruction, his [35:55] assassination by by um by a Shiite by um [35:59] an Iranian under the name of um [36:04] uh Fairuz. [36:06] Uh [36:07] his assassination was celebrated for 18 [36:10] days with bonfires and celebrations. [36:12] >> What changed because it's the current [36:14] Islamic Republic regime under Khomeini [36:16] that instigated Al-Quds Day and [36:18] basically championed Jerusalem as the [36:21] focus of their anti-Israel fervor, [36:23] right? [36:23] >> So here is an essential [36:27] and a key to the understanding of the 50 [36:31] years of uh [36:34] the Shiite clerical reign in Islam in in [36:38] Iran today [36:41] is that in the Hauza, which means the [36:45] uh the college or the university, [36:47] Islamic University of Qom, [36:49] the founding fathers of this [36:54] institution, which is like excuse the [36:57] term but for my Jewish listeners is like [36:59] a yeshiva, [37:00] founded by [37:07] was that it it was originally an [37:10] anti-colonial [37:12] movement against the British and their [37:15] the British petroleum in Iran [37:17] was [37:20] a reaction against the West. [37:23] Later on this [37:25] resentment and hate towards the British [37:29] was transferred to the to the Americans [37:32] which became known as [37:37] the great Satan [37:39] and the its follow-up Satan [37:45] with Satan which was Israel. They came [37:48] together. This was then developed into [37:51] theology [37:53] taken further by [37:56] Khomeini who on the 1st of February 1979 [37:59] as soon he as soon as he arrived in Iran [38:03] declared [38:05] the Jerusalem Day [38:07] and in his book [38:10] about [38:11] the relationship [38:13] relationship between [38:16] the [38:17] clerical conception of Islam which [38:20] hitherto in Shiite [38:23] environment had been something [38:25] quietistic. The [38:27] had no political role [38:29] in in public life. He was only consulted [38:32] on religious matters. [38:34] That that Khomeini trans [38:37] transformed [38:39] the cleric into a political leader [38:42] and he proclaimed that [38:45] that the [38:46] the clerics, the mullah, [38:49] the Ayatollah, [38:50] would then play an active role in [38:53] reviving, in bringing the bringing of [38:56] salvation through the return of the [38:59] awaited Mahdi, the Messiah, the Islamic [39:03] the Shiite Messiah, which would [39:06] necessarily pass through the destruction [39:10] of Jerusalem and the state of Israel. [39:13] So here is the the key that [39:15] that everything is geared to. Their [39:18] nuclear [39:19] um [39:21] power, the construction of nuclear power [39:23] is only to destroy Israel and beyond [39:28] American influence in in the Middle East [39:30] as as a path towards [39:34] uh the liberation of the Islamic [39:37] territories and the and the return of [39:41] the Imam al-Muntazar, the awaited Imam. [39:44] >> In that respect then, it it is something [39:47] what you're saying of a perversion of [39:49] even Shiite Islam [39:51] >> Absolutely. [39:51] >> as a response to British colonial power [39:53] and then ultimately Jewish presence back [39:56] in the modern state of Israel, that this [39:58] is not inherently [40:00] Islamic. It's actually a modern [40:01] political distortion. [40:03] >> First of all, historians call this [40:05] neo-Shiite [40:07] theology. [40:08] It in that it is [40:10] um [40:11] a diversion from traditional Shiite [40:14] Islam. I just explained that in terms of [40:16] fiqh, in terms of um legalism, [40:21] um [40:22] and [40:24] uh [40:24] the the Ayatollah, the marja, the [40:27] references, the clerical references were [40:30] something that were were to be, you [40:32] know, consulted only on religious [40:34] matters and not to to [40:37] um [40:37] perform a political role. And so this is [40:41] a first perversion. The second [40:43] perversion is that that from there we [40:46] have this development of very negative [40:50] attitudes Judaism, which is based on [40:54] what already exists, but then develops [40:57] as a deviation from [41:00] anti-colonialism into into an [41:03] anti-Americanism, anti-Zionism of a very [41:07] virulent and violent form, which is not [41:10] arrested by the most brutal forms of [41:14] violence. [41:15] >> You mentioned earlier the the Persian [41:17] Jews and some who had escaped here to [41:19] Israel. Um there was of course [41:21] quite an interesting [41:24] program that CNN of all channels [41:27] recently about the Jews of Iran with the [41:30] suggestion from many of them themselves [41:32] being filmed, obviously not living in [41:34] freedom, that they had a dissociation [41:37] themselves from Israel, that they felt [41:39] safer, more Persian, more Iranian let's [41:41] say than they felt Jewish. Can you speak [41:43] a bit to that very contemporary idea [41:46] that there is a thriving Jewish [41:48] community in Iran who themselves are [41:51] against the colonial influence and power [41:54] of the state of Israel? [41:55] >> During the [41:56] Pahlavi reign during the reign of the [41:58] Shah, [41:59] who in his white revolution [42:02] um tried to modernize Persia, modernize [42:07] Iran and indeed hark back to pre-Islamic [42:11] times and and um [42:13] emphasized the old Sassanid and Persian [42:18] civilization, pre-Islamic civilization. [42:21] And at that time many of the old in many [42:24] of the former [42:26] um [42:28] statutes of [42:29] of persecution of Jews fell away. And [42:32] for example, [42:34] um [42:35] uh discussing once with a Muslim Shiite, [42:39] uh he said yes, where Jews were [42:41] integrated into Persian society, they [42:44] knew their place, they knew that when [42:47] they were invited to my parents' house [42:49] and they finished drinking coffee, they [42:51] would turn their coffee pot, their [42:53] coffee to cups upside down so that their [42:57] Muslim Shiite hosts would know that the [43:00] Jews had [43:01] drunk in those cups which would then be [43:04] needed to be purified before they could [43:06] be reused by a Muslim. [43:09] And there's a special word for this. [43:10] They took them to they were to be [43:12] immersed in water very much like a [43:15] ritual bath, like a mikvah before they [43:17] could be used by a Muslim. [43:18] >> Like like some religious Jews who will [43:21] you know cutlery and crockery in order [43:23] to purify it for kashrut. [43:24] >> Yeah, but this was every time that that [43:26] this would be used by a non Shiite Jew [43:30] a Jew or a Christian they had to be [43:32] purified. So this this went into [43:35] abeyance [43:36] and don't forget that that the Jews and [43:40] who are [43:41] living in contemporary Iran have to be [43:44] very careful about what they say and and [43:47] about their loyalties [43:50] to anything outside of Iran. They have [43:53] to be very discreet and so whenever they [43:57] whatever they say in in in interviews [44:00] must [44:01] must be taken with a grain of of salt [44:04] and you I mean you can see on [44:06] internet you can see the chief rabbi [44:09] rabbi so-called rabbis demonstrate [44:12] taking part in in pro-government [44:15] demonstrations. [44:17] This is not of their personal accord, [44:20] but this is something they have to do. [44:23] >> And it's obviously not just um Shiite [44:25] Islam, there's also Sunni Islam which [44:27] has and you know we've described quite [44:29] in some detail the the background of [44:32] previous to all of this of [44:35] more fundamental Islamic animosity [44:37] towards Jews. You mentioned earlier [44:38] Vatican II and and I think that's [44:40] something you've stressed in your work [44:42] that I'm aware of which is that there [44:44] needs to be if if we're to envisage a [44:47] future where we can coexist um Jews and [44:51] Muslims, non Muslims and Muslims we need [44:54] to acknowledge the [44:57] what happened in the past. It can't be [44:58] done through a sort of process of [44:59] denial. It has to be acknowledgement and [45:01] then moving on and some form of [45:05] apology or or [45:07] redemption from it. But there is no [45:09] magisterium for Islam as far as I [45:11] understand it. So Vatican II isn't [45:13] really possible within Islam, is it? [45:15] >> Well, one of the ways of approaching [45:19] this [45:20] and which has been emphasized by [45:25] such visionaries [45:27] as [45:28] [clears throat] there's another [45:29] political [45:31] proclamation as Netanyahu and and Trump [45:35] in in the conception of the Abraham [45:38] Accords [45:40] is that we have a common basis [45:45] and and which was expressed in [45:49] a [45:51] the second Vatican by the fact that [45:54] the synagogue is the mother of the [45:55] church, that we have common roots [45:59] and that [46:00] if Islam recognizes [46:03] the Jewish input into [46:08] into an initial initial stages of Islam, [46:12] how much [46:13] Islam owes to Judaism and how much we [46:16] have in common, [46:17] then these could be building bricks to [46:20] to some bringing together and [46:22] understanding in the name of Abraham. [46:25] Unfortunately, unfortunately, this is [46:28] not the case [46:30] in in universal Islam insofar as [46:36] the the official dogma in in Islam is [46:39] that the Quran is uncreated. It it [46:44] preceded the creation of the world and [46:46] therefore it is impossible that there be [46:49] a Jewish input into the Quran and [46:53] nascent Islam insofar as this is [46:57] preceded the creation of the world. [47:00] The [47:01] that the [47:03] Quran was created was once an official [47:07] creed was a part of the official Muslim [47:10] creed at the time of the Mu'tazilites [47:12] and and which it was then evacuated by [47:16] by Islam. So that is a very [47:20] for the moment I would say [47:25] very [47:26] strong [47:28] impediment and and [47:31] obstacle to to [47:34] to the conception of the Abraham accords [47:37] and and and showing what we have in [47:39] common, what we have shared in in in our [47:43] history. I can give you another example [47:46] from music, but before that I'd like to [47:48] say that [47:51] I came [47:53] very recently I came to the [47:55] understanding that [47:56] even though [47:58] Iran is [48:00] came out of the non-Semitic world and [48:02] therefore they are not the descendants, [48:04] the physical descendants of Abraham as [48:07] much as the Ishmaelites or the Arabs. [48:11] What is interesting is that according to [48:16] Muslim tradition Abraham was born in [48:19] Susa [48:20] which is Shushan in in Iran. So we can [48:24] include [48:25] by that token we can include the Iranian [48:28] peoples in in the concept of the Abraham [48:32] accords. [48:34] I would like to use perhaps this with [48:37] our final word. [48:39] I'm also musicologist and very [48:41] interested in Jewish music [48:43] and [48:46] the Jews played an a considerable role [48:50] in Islamic society as musicians both in [48:53] Iran and the Persian Persianate world [48:57] and the [48:58] Arab world, in particular [49:02] in North North Africa, even Baghdad, [49:04] the greatest musicians [49:08] were were Jews, very often Jews, [49:11] and [49:12] some of them were even the [49:16] conservationists of the [49:21] the repertoire of Arabic music, [49:23] which included very often Sufi poems, [49:27] mystical poems that were in this [49:29] repertoire in Arabic and in Persian. [49:33] And [49:34] I see in this [49:36] also an expression of [49:38] participation [49:41] in the artistic world, in the aesthetic [49:43] world, as well as in the intellectual [49:45] world [49:47] of Jews in on a par in a with Muslims in [49:53] the in the [49:54] civilizational context. [49:56] >> You mentioned there the Abrahamic [49:57] Accords and the kind of modern attempts [50:00] to [50:01] focus on on the foundations that the the [50:03] religions share in common, the Abrahamic [50:05] faiths. [50:06] So do you think that it is possible in [50:09] in today's age and moving into the [50:11] future that there could be a [50:12] reconciliation, that could be peace [50:15] geopolitically, but also more broadly, [50:17] spiritually, religiously between Islam [50:20] and non-Islam, Islam and Judaism [50:22] specifically, but more broadly? [50:24] Is it possible [50:26] or or is it inherent within Islam that [50:28] there will always be a tendency, whether [50:30] it's neo-Shia [50:33] belief or or Islamism or the kind of [50:37] persecution you described much earlier [50:39] on in North Africa? Is that just an [50:41] inherent part of Islam and its attitude [50:43] towards Jews, whom ultimately it came to [50:45] replace? [50:46] >> I can give you an answer in one word, [50:48] which is an enormous concept. [50:51] It's modernity. [50:53] As long as [snorts] Islam hasn't entered [50:56] the world of modernity, we cannot hope [51:00] for [51:01] the realization of this [51:03] abramic accords in the terms I mentioned [51:07] earlier, that is the realization of our [51:10] common roots. [51:11] That when Christianity in the 18th [51:14] century, 19th century and following them [51:18] Judaism, especially Europe and Central [51:21] European Judaism [51:23] came to terms with a more moderate [51:26] attitude to our holy scriptures in terms [51:29] of archaeology and philology and history [51:33] in an academic approach to to their [51:37] religions and their religious [51:38] scriptures, something which went hand in [51:41] hand with modernity and resulted in a [51:45] much more mature attitude and [51:47] intellectual attitude to religion as [51:49] long as this is not the case in [51:52] with Islam [51:54] and that that they [51:58] relate to their sacred book in terms of [52:02] of history and philology and and they [52:04] see the influence of of Judaism and to a [52:08] second degree Christianity and then come [52:11] and then come to the realization of how [52:14] much we hold in common [52:16] not how much separates us. As long as [52:19] this is not overcome then there is [52:22] little hope. [52:23] >> I guess the obvious question is do you [52:24] see seeds of that? Is there modernity [52:26] within Islam gain? You see states like [52:30] the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the UAE, [52:33] they are making efforts towards [52:35] modernity and yet the religion, the [52:38] religious part of it seems to pull back. [52:42] >> Well, I I put this question to a [52:44] Pakistani [52:49] cleric who was recently in Israel [52:53] and who was [52:55] an advocate of interreligious dialogue. [52:58] He was on a visit to Jerusalem [53:01] and I said, you know, is there hope that [53:03] in Pakistan, for example, [53:06] there could be a current of people who [53:08] would be willing to [53:11] to participate in religious dialogue [53:14] with this concept in mind, this [53:18] modernistic approach to Islam. And he [53:21] said to me in one sentence, not in our [53:24] lifetime. [53:25] But [53:27] because [53:29] Islam is walking backwards [53:32] with such movements as the Muslim [53:36] Brotherhood founded by Sayyid [53:40] [snorts] [53:41] who, by the way, [53:43] also [53:45] entered [53:47] into this college in [53:50] and became part of [53:53] the discourse of these fanatical [54:00] neo-Shiite theologians. Indeed, [54:06] translated the works of [54:09] the [54:11] the theoretician of [54:14] of the Muslim Brotherhood. He translated [54:17] it into Persian. So them very much [54:20] influenced by this current, which is [54:22] walking backwards into the prehistory [54:26] instead of going forward. [54:27] >> And many people today are looking at [54:29] Europe. And you know, you you grew up in [54:32] Great Britain, [54:34] but you had much of your professional [54:35] life in in France [54:37] at the Sorbonne. And And you [54:41] must look to what happens recently in [54:44] France and has been happening for some [54:46] time and to what is starting to happen [54:48] in the UK and elsewhere around Europe. [54:50] And [54:51] do you recognize that there is an [54:53] Islamic influence in this draw to [54:57] violence, in the unrest? Is it Are [55:00] people correct to feel that there is [55:02] some form of hijra into Europe, that [55:05] there is some form of [55:07] being attempted by Islam, is it indirect [55:11] connection to what you've studied and [55:12] documented in all of your academic work? [55:15] >> Well, if you notice that [55:18] in [55:19] all of these manifestations, [55:22] all of these demonstrations, be they in [55:24] in France or England or Italy, we see [55:28] the the waving of the Palestinian flag [55:31] and and um [55:34] slogans in support of Gaza. [55:37] So much so that this is these are not [55:39] demonstrations [55:41] that spill over into um [55:47] into stealing and and uh [55:50] uh [55:51] and [55:53] breaking into shops and such like. These [55:55] these these are not demonstrations, [55:57] these are razzias [56:00] as practiced by the the Bedouin, as [56:02] practiced by Muhammad in his early [56:06] period. [56:07] When he attacked, interestingly, he [56:09] attacked caravans between Arabia and [56:13] Gaza. [56:14] He would attack them and use the money [56:16] to further the interests of Islam as, by [56:20] the way, [56:21] what's his name? Nawab [56:23] uh [56:24] Safavi, Nawab Safavi, who carried out a [56:26] number of political [56:29] assassinations. He is one of the [56:31] thinkers that influenced [56:33] um [56:35] Khomeini [56:36] that and he said and he robbed the [56:39] Muslims and [56:41] made up the excuse that as this money [56:44] would be used to further the aims of [56:48] of Shiite Islam, that this was licit, [56:51] this was legal. [56:52] >> You said razzia. [56:53] >> Razzia. [56:53] >> What does that mean? [56:55] >> Um these are the attacks that the [56:57] Bedouin would would use from time [57:00] immemorial, attacking the commercial [57:03] caravans and using the booty from the [57:07] caravans for their own use. [57:09] And by the way, let us mention because [57:13] he was talking about Razia and [57:15] Gaza, Gaza, it's from the same Semitic [57:18] root. [57:19] Razia and Raza in Arabic are from the [57:23] same root. [57:24] >> And it's a route that eludes to [57:25] attacking and raiding. [57:27] >> Exactly. [57:28] >> So you do see really what we're seeing [57:30] unfolding around us in Europe. You see [57:32] it as a direct manifestation of the same [57:36] non-modern, [57:37] same brutal Islamic tradition that was [57:41] present from the time of Muhammad and [57:43] that you've documented so um you know so [57:46] extensively in your in your written work [57:48] in in North Africa. You see them as [57:51] the same thing. [57:52] >> Because all of this is engineered behind [57:55] the scenes by the Muslim Brotherhood [57:58] who are paired up with [58:01] is Iranian [58:03] Shiite [58:05] uh anti-Zionism [58:07] and uh and is financed that that that [58:12] unbe [58:13] unseen or not wanting to be seen by the [58:18] uh [58:20] by the public by the European public. [58:23] This is it this is where it's coming [58:26] from. [58:26] >> And when you see reports, I don't know [58:28] if you saw it recently, there was a [58:29] report in the Telegraph in the UK that [58:32] among babies born now, the surname, not [58:37] the first name one, that's quite well [58:38] known, is is commonly Muhammad, but but [58:41] the surname is Khan is is is soon to [58:44] overtake Smith [58:46] >> Right. [58:46] >> as the most popular surname for babies, [58:49] which seems to me [58:51] much more significant than the idea of [58:53] Muhammad. [58:54] Most Muslims will call their child [58:56] Muhammad, so it skews the results. But [58:58] the family name Khan on the cusp of [59:01] overtaking the family name Smith seems [59:03] far more [59:05] um important. [59:07] >> Yeah. [59:08] >> What do you you know you've left Europe, [59:10] you're living here now in Israel [59:13] and many Jews are doing the same. [59:16] What do you think is going to happen to [59:17] Europe, and and what do you think [59:19] the Islamic influence and intention is [59:23] there? [59:25] >> I remember that a quarter of a century [59:27] ago I used to listen into the [59:32] Saudi Arabian radio, and they were [59:35] priding themselves in the fact that [59:39] European intellectuals [59:42] so they claimed of themselves were [59:45] converting to Islam, [59:47] not the most recommendable by the way, [59:50] and they saw this as a stepping stone to [59:55] what they [59:56] saw as the return of Muslim Spain to the [60:01] bosom [60:02] of Spain to the bosom of Islam, and that [60:05] eventually beyond the borders of of [60:08] Andalusia to Europe itself, that they [60:12] that they were [60:14] in terms of the Muslim conquest, [60:17] and that there was an understanding [60:20] between Shiite Islam and Muslim and [60:25] Sunni Islam which had been traditional [60:27] enemies from from the practically [60:32] the inception of Islam were now [60:36] pairing up [60:38] of a common accord and that even [60:42] you know meted out [60:45] let's say grosso modo [60:48] Africa, Central Africa to Sunni would be [60:51] the hunting ground of of Sunni Islam, [60:56] and Europe and America would be financed [60:59] by Iranian money for for the conquest of [61:04] of [61:05] Islam in general but more particularly [61:07] Islamic Shiite Islam. [61:09] >> In your work, you deliberately didn't [61:12] make it a a narrative history, it was a [61:14] documentary, [61:15] Um and and many of those documents are [61:17] quite terrifying to read. They were [61:19] about [61:20] severe brutality, beheadings, fire, [61:23] branding, salting of of beheaded people [61:26] that Jews were required to do. [61:28] And many of us are looking at today's [61:31] world, at some of the brutality that is [61:33] proudly used to dominate or terrify, [61:36] whether it's October the 7th and the [61:38] videos that Hamas and the other [61:40] Palestinian invaders of of Southern [61:42] Israel deliberately put out uh of [61:44] torture, [61:46] um [61:47] brutality. [61:49] Or we look at the ISIS beheading videos [61:51] which were proudly filmed and sent out [61:54] for the world to see. Or we look at [61:55] videos of ISIS putting prisoners in [61:58] cages and lowering them into [62:01] pools of water to drown people. The [62:03] brutality feels the same to many people. [62:06] And what you seem to have been telling [62:09] me is that it is intrinsically linked in [62:11] some way [62:12] to the basics and oldest parts of Islam. [62:16] Is that the case and are they trying to [62:18] tell us something with with these images [62:20] today? [62:21] >> Okay. Without [62:23] entering into gory details, I will just [62:25] give you [62:26] um [62:27] two elements [62:30] of [62:31] which will contribute to your reflection [62:33] to our reflection on the subject. The [62:36] first is [62:37] that one of the basic elements in Jewish [62:40] theology [62:41] uh which was [62:43] was probably at the origin of the [62:46] concept of human rights [62:48] to which people like Henri Cassin, [62:51] Jewish uh personality contributed, is [62:54] that [62:55] man was created in the image of God. [62:58] That [62:59] someone who saves a human being, since [63:03] Adam was created as a single [63:06] human being, it is as if he has saved [63:09] the whole of humanity. [63:11] This is outlined in in Muslim theology, [63:15] outlined [63:17] outlined [63:18] refused [63:19] that one cannot say that man was created [63:22] in the image of God. This is [63:24] anthropomorphic [63:26] declaration which is prohibited by [63:28] Islam. [63:30] So it means [63:32] that man was created in the image that [63:35] God wanted him to be created in. [63:38] Here it's [63:39] >> Mhm. [63:39] >> This is their interpretation of [63:46] God was created in the image that God [63:49] wanted. [63:50] So that is fundamental [63:54] element [63:56] that there's no real engagement with [63:59] human rights with within Islam [64:03] which gives expression to some of the [64:07] most horrendous forms of brutality. [64:11] Second element that I would like to [64:13] bring up [64:15] is that [64:17] what is the punishment reserved for a [64:20] Jew in in Islamic tradition, in Islamic [64:24] lands, be it in we have examples [64:27] examples from the Middle East [64:30] examples from North Africa right up to [64:33] the 20th century, the beginning of the [64:35] 20th century and these are documented in [64:38] in my book the in in the Maghreb, 100 a [64:42] thousand years of Jewish experience [64:44] under Islam [64:46] is that [64:47] Jews were burned alive [64:50] burned alive which that means that not [64:53] only were they not created in the image [64:56] of God [64:57] but they were completely dehumanized [65:00] that you could burn [65:02] a Jew like you could burn an animal [65:04] whereas this is [65:06] completely prohibited in Islam itself [65:09] that in Islamic sources [65:12] it is forbidden for man to use fire to [65:16] punish [65:17] another human being because this is a [65:21] divine punishment. This is a form of [65:23] anthropomorphism [65:25] that you are imitating [65:27] the infernal [65:29] punishment which is reserved for God [65:32] alone. And yet [65:34] the punishment for a Jew is is being to [65:36] be burnt alive and there are multiple [65:38] examples [65:40] in in my book [65:42] a thousand years of exile in the [65:44] Maghreb. [65:45] >> And there were multiple examples on [65:46] October the 7th. [65:48] >> Example exactly. [65:49] >> So the implication is that Jews are not [65:51] human? [65:52] >> Exactly. They're not human. [65:54] >> And non-Jewish non [65:56] Muslims? [65:58] >> All more so. All more so because if [66:02] they're polytheists like Hindus or [66:05] or Buddhists all more so. [66:07] >> And what's the attitude towards the [66:08] Trinity in Christianity? Is that seen as [66:10] a form of polytheism? [66:12] >> Absolutely. But [66:14] given that Jews and Christians as [66:16] mentioned earlier [66:17] had the privilege of being [66:22] people of the [66:25] people of the book that they had [66:26] received a divine revelation [66:30] they were to be preserved. They were to [66:32] be tolerated. [66:34] But other than that if they [66:37] if they [66:38] override [66:40] the conditions of the [66:44] covenant of the so-called covenant of [66:48] then they are liable to the death [66:50] penalty and in the form of burning. Many [66:53] Jews who were accused [66:55] of having insulted the Islam or insulted [66:58] the prophet [67:00] whereby going against the covenant of [67:04] they were burnt on the spot. [67:07] Examples in my book. [67:08] >> Given [67:09] all of this that we've discussed today [67:12] is there grounds for any optimism [67:16] about the future both in Europe or here [67:19] in Israel where Islam is playing an [67:21] increasingly important part and where I [67:23] would say attitudes vary drastically as [67:25] to how non-Muslims should react [67:29] towards um Islam um in its best and [67:33] worst examples. What gives you hope if [67:37] anything and what do you think is the [67:38] right strategy for interaction [67:41] um between Muslims and non-Muslims, [67:44] Islam and non-Islam? [67:45] >> A Jew has no problem with declaring we [67:49] have a debt we have a debt towards [67:51] Islam. I'll explain this in in in an in [67:54] a few minutes. [67:56] And [67:57] Islam also has a debt towards Judaism in [68:03] its in from its inception as I explained [68:06] earlier. [68:07] Until [68:10] the Muslims I'm saying the Jews are [68:12] prepared to accept this until the [68:14] Muslims are prepared to accept this [68:17] and the key to this is modernity [68:20] entering into [68:23] modernity and and a more balanced and [68:27] serene attitude to their sacred [68:30] scriptures and the roots of their [68:33] religion which will then bring them to a [68:35] realization of how much we hold in [68:39] common rather than how much we are [68:42] separated from the religious other [68:46] then there is little hope. [68:48] But [68:49] if we do and and this involves [68:54] an enormous effort on on the part of [68:58] of the people who hold the keys to our [69:01] educational system our [69:04] social systems what have you. [69:07] But but in in in in [69:10] above all [69:12] education this can be achieved [69:14] through through [69:17] education and dialogue until we come to [69:19] this realization then [69:22] then there's little hope on the Muslim [69:24] side. [69:25] >> What is the [69:25] >> Jewish debt to Islam that you're [69:27] referring to? [69:28] >> So, Maimonides said of Saadia Gaon, [69:31] Maimonides is the greatest Jewish [69:33] theologian and philosophy of [69:36] I would say the whole Jewish tradition, [69:38] but especially of the medieval period, [69:41] which was very formative [69:43] in terms of [69:45] Jewish tradition. [69:47] Harked back to Saadia Gaon, who died in [69:51] 940 [69:53] the height of the Geonic period, which [69:57] flourished under Islam. He said, were it [70:00] not for Saadia, then Judaism would have [70:03] disappeared. Were it not for Saadia, [70:07] who translated into Arabic [70:11] the Jewish Bible, commented [70:13] in Arabic the Jewish Bible, [70:16] formulated the first Hebrew dictionary, [70:20] bilingual dictionary, Arabic and Hebrew, [70:23] who [70:25] laid the foundation of Jewish liturgy [70:28] inspired by Muslim models, who [70:33] elaborated Arabic [70:35] Hebrew grammar from the model of Arabic [70:39] grammar, [70:41] who [70:42] what else can we add? The theology, who [70:44] wrote the first book of Jewish [70:46] philosophy and theology [70:50] in Arabic [70:53] the translation of [70:56] in Provence [70:58] that he gave the framework for [71:03] much of what Judaism has become [71:07] in the pre-modern period and now in the [71:09] modern period [71:10] in [71:12] the Geonic period, which flourished [71:15] under the Islamic Islamic [71:20] civilization [71:21] at a time when Baghdad [71:24] was the center of the world as much as [71:30] New York can be considered the center of [71:34] modern civilization, [71:36] as the language of international [71:40] exchange. [71:42] So [71:43] and it was the capital of an empire [71:46] which [71:48] which whose confines started in India [71:52] and ended [71:54] the frontier to to France [71:57] in the in the West and [72:01] allowed through [72:03] the roots of communication between [72:07] Baghdad and Cairo, Cairo and Fes, Fes [72:11] and Cordoba in Al Andalus. [72:14] The [72:16] dissemination [72:17] of this learning [72:20] elaborated by Saadia and his peers. [72:23] >> they're still dimmis. [72:25] >> They're still dimmis. No, I'm talking [72:26] about the Jewish Golden Age in terms of [72:30] philosophy, theology. [72:32] >> Is the idea then that the cause of the [72:34] Islamic conquest being so widespread [72:37] that network was used by Jews to [72:40] communicate Jewish thought and thinking [72:43] in a in a wider way and that is the debt [72:46] that you're saying that Judaism owes to [72:47] Islam. It's that given that Islam [72:50] conquered and was dominant within it, [72:54] Judaism at least managed [72:56] to kind of piggyback and and and spread [72:58] its beliefs to Jews. [73:00] And were it not for the Islamic [73:03] conquest, it wouldn't have been able to [73:04] do that. [73:05] >> Exactly. [73:06] >> Okay. It's a strange sort of debt [73:07] though, isn't it? [73:09] >> No. But I mean it's a very deep debt [73:11] which we are [73:13] benefiting from even today. There is [73:17] a a downside to some of that. For [73:19] example, the opposition of women in [73:21] Judaism. But in in all in all, this is [73:26] what saved Judaism. [73:28] >> So we have we have a debt [73:30] in of which Islam is unconscious. [73:33] But it's it's a very great debt. [73:36] >> I think many Jews are quite unconscious [73:38] of this debt as well. So so you're [73:39] saying that given if both sides could [73:42] acknowledge this debt, really [73:43] internalize it as well, then that gives [73:46] you some hope. But do you see that [73:47] happening? [73:48] >> And I think that that [73:50] that it's there, that from 19th century [73:53] people have spoken about the [73:57] golden age of Spain, which is also [74:00] largely due to Arabic influence. The [74:03] other side has totally been ignored by [74:06] Islamic society. How much they are [74:10] indebted to Jewish civilization. [74:13] >> I guess to kind of try and bring things [74:15] full circle to today, what where is it [74:18] being done right? Where is the hope for [74:20] that being prioritized both in in the [74:24] Islamic world and outside? And and do [74:26] we, I suppose as Jews and more broadly [74:29] as other non-Muslims, have a part to [74:32] play in that? Or is that a is that [74:33] really a task for an internal battle [74:35] within Islam? [74:36] >> Unfortunately, both Jews and non-Jews [74:40] have missed the boat, missed the [74:42] opportunity. There was a golden [74:43] opportunity when we had this inflow of [74:48] Muslim Muslims into Europe, [74:51] be it into Germany or or Belgium or [74:55] or England and France on the one hand. [74:58] The Jewish coexistence [75:01] that we have, a Judeo-Arabic coexistence [75:04] in in Israel, [75:06] in the educational system. I spoke [75:09] earlier about the importance of [75:12] the educational [75:14] factor in in this. There was so much [75:18] that we could have done in terms of [75:20] education, of broadening the [75:23] intellectual horizons [75:26] of the the love for democracy, [75:30] the [75:32] the [75:33] highlighting [75:34] what we have in common that could have [75:36] been done in in the educational systems [75:40] in France and and in Israel in in the [75:43] Arabic schools. Why don't they teach why [75:47] isn't why isn't why for example in in [75:50] the Christian schools in the Galilee why [75:52] don't they pray in Hebrew? Why do they [75:54] continue to pray in in Arabic? They [75:57] recite Psalms. Christian worship is 80% [76:00] made up of Psalms. Why do they recite [76:02] them in Arabic and not in Hebrew to to [76:06] emphasize the the Jewish element in in [76:09] Arabic civilization be it Muslim or [76:12] Christian. Nothing is done. [76:13] >> So in a way on the one hand the [76:15] depressing part is maybe we've missed [76:16] the opportunity you're saying. [76:18] >> We're missing we're missing [76:19] >> We are missing but secondly the [76:21] opportunity seems to be if I'm reading [76:23] everything you said in the first part of [76:24] the interview with everything you're [76:25] saying now seems to be that we should [76:28] have used the opportunity to educate [76:29] towards modernity to educate towards [76:31] democracy to educate towards human [76:33] rights and yet you earlier described how [76:35] those things are [76:37] counter to Islamic philosophy and [76:40] belief. So what you're effectively [76:42] arguing for is a is educating Islamic [76:45] immigrants um or diaspora Muslims [76:50] away from [76:51] Islam. [76:52] >> No, but they could have been a European [76:54] Islam. They could have been an Israeli [76:59] in verty commas Israeli Islam. But no [77:02] the opportunity was totally ignored and [77:05] missed and I think it's [77:08] more or less irreversible. For example [77:10] in French schools in the baccalauréat [77:14] program they used to teach authors like [77:16] Primo Levi [77:20] who has very little Jewish ca [77:23] characteristics in his [77:25] novels [77:26] but only because he was [77:28] Jewish when they started to teach this [77:32] in in terminal in in the [77:35] in pre uh graduation classes, there was [77:39] such a hullabaloo on the part of Muslim [77:42] as [77:43] as [77:44] students that the subject was dropped. [77:47] was [77:48] left out of uh baccalaureate. [77:51] >> Hm. [77:51] >> So the the influence is in is in the the [77:54] other direction. Instead of educational [77:57] authorities [77:59] putting their foot down and saying this [78:00] is this is education, this is what it [78:03] is, and this is what you'll have to [78:05] learn. If you're not happy, then then [78:07] return to where you came from. [78:10] No, they're tripping [78:13] trod trodden upon by [78:16] uh by [78:18] adverse currents in in in that society. [78:23] >> Well, Paul, thank you so much for [78:24] spending the time with me today. Your [78:25] your uh knowledge and and extensive [78:29] study in this area is is, you know, it's [78:31] apparent throughout and it's [78:32] exceptionally helpful, I think, to hear [78:35] hear everything you've had to say. I [78:36] really appreciate it and um let's hope [78:39] that it isn't too late. Let's hope that [78:40] perhaps there is still the opportunity [78:42] to be grasped as as we try to grapple [78:45] with these problems moving into the [78:46] future. Thank you. [78:47] >> I hope that um some of what we've [78:50] discussed today will be food for thought [78:53] for our listeners and that they will [78:55] take it to heart [78:57] and act upon it. [78:58] >> Thank you so much. [78:59] >> Thank you.