ProIsrael

There was never a golden age – Prof of Islamic history reveals the truth about Islam and Jews

Jonathan Sacerdoti
Jonathan Sacerdoti39.7K views • 763 likes • 281 comments1 week ago • 1 hour and 19 min

Transcript

Description (by owner on YouTube)

For a thousand years Jews lived under Islamic rule. Professor Paul B. Fenton has spent his career reading what the documents from those centuries actually say. Was there ever a golden age in which Jews and Muslims lived as equals? Professor Fenton argues that the flowering of Jewish philosophy, poetry and science under Islam was real — but that it was a Jewish achievement rather than a shared society, and that it happened in spite of the conditions Jews lived under, not because of them. Fenton, a scholar of Hebrew and Arabic who spent much of his career at the Sorbonne and wrote 'Exile in the Maghreb: A Thousand Years of Jewish Experience Under Islam', joins Jonathan Sacerdoti in Tel Aviv to discuss the status of the dhimmi, the jizya and the lead seal a Jew had to wear at his neck as a receipt, the forced conversions of Mashhad, and why he believes the Islamic cruelty the world saw on October 7 has roots far older than Zionism. He also explains the debt he believes Judaism owes to Islamic civilisation — and why he thinks Europe has already missed its chance. Subscribe for more interviews: https://www.youtube.com/@MrJonsac?sub_confirmation=1 If you value my work, please donate: https://jonathansacerdoti.com/support/ 👁‍🗨 Watch if you want to understand what a thousand years of documents say about Jewish life under Islam — and why a scholar of both traditions believes no reconciliation is possible until that history is acknowledged. 💬 We Discuss: 📜 Why Muhammad courted the Jews of Medina — and what happened when they refused him 🕌 The verse of the sword – what does the Quran really say about Jews and Christians? 🛡️ Dhimmi: why “protected people” is a mistranslation, and protected from whom 📋 The conditions of Umar — Jews deprived of weapons, horses, even blowing the shofar in public 💰 The jizya, the lead seal worn at the neck as a receipt, and what befell those who could not pay 🏘️ Life in the mellah: separate quarters, distinctive dress, danger beyond the walls ✨ Al-Andalus reconsidered — a Jewish golden age inside a society that was not golden 📚 Why Maimonides outwardly converted to Islam and fled Spain ☪️ Sunni and Shia attitudes to Jews, and the doctrine of ritual uncleanness 🇮🇷 Why Jerusalem had almost no standing in traditional Shia Islam before Khomeini 🔥 How an anti-colonial movement in Qom became the theology of the Iranian regime 🎥 What Jews still living in Iran can and cannot say on camera ⚔️ Razzia and Gaza: how Europe's riots are linked to Palestinians and Islam 🙏 Why Islam can have no Vatican II, and what blocks the Abraham Accords 🎼 The debt Judaism owes Islamic civilisation — Saadia Gaon, Baghdad and Jewish music 🇪🇺 “There could have been a European Islam” — what, how and i it too late? 🔔 Subscribe for more serious and unflinching conversations about Britain, Israel, antisemitism, politics, terrorism and the defence of Western democratic values. 📲 Follow Jonathan On X: https://x.com/jonsac On Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/jonathansacerdoti/ On Substack: https://jonsac.substack.com 👇 Comment below — can Jews and Muslims build a future together without first agreeing on the past? #JonathanSacerdoti #PaulFenton #Islam #Judaism #JewishHistory #Antisemitism #AlAndalus #Dhimmi #MuslimBrotherhood #Iran #Israel #Maimonides #Europe

Subscribe to the newsletter

A regular email of new videos and articles from across the site. To hear about this channel on its own, use Follow above.

Get the pro-Israel voices the algorithms bury, right in your inbox.

Your email stays private.