Transcript [00:00] So recently during one of our private [00:02] JTV Plus community Zoom calls, a member [00:05] from Canada called Brian asked me a [00:08] question that really got me thinking. [00:10] He'd come across a story involving the [00:12] Jewish Theological Seminary in America, [00:15] one of the most prominent institutions [00:17] for training conservative rabbis. And [00:20] just to clarify for those unfamiliar [00:22] with Jewish denominations, conservative [00:24] Judaism is a nonorthodox religious [00:26] movement. The name doesn't refer to [00:29] political conservatism, just to be [00:31] clear. And a group of six graduating [00:34] undergraduate students, Brian told me, [00:37] had circulated a letter calling for [00:40] Israel's president, Isaac Herzog, to be [00:43] disinvited from speaking at their [00:45] graduation ceremony. They accused [00:48] Herzog, of inciting violence against [00:50] Palestinian civilians. And among those [00:53] who supported the letter were four [00:55] students training to become rabbis. Now [00:58] bear in mind we're talking about Isaac [01:01] Herzog, not Itar Bengir, not but [01:05] Salmotric. [01:07] Isaac Herzog, a former leader of [01:09] Israel's center-left Labor Party and a [01:13] man who has spent much of his presidency [01:15] trying to bring together different parts [01:17] of Israeli society. And yet apparently [01:21] even he was too controversial. [01:24] Now I looked a bit more into what [01:26] happened and it became clear that the [01:29] seminar's leadership itself firmly [01:32] defended Herzog's invitation and other [01:35] students wrote a letter supporting him. [01:37] But in the end Herzog didn't appear in [01:40] person. He delivered his address [01:42] virtually instead. Not quite clear uh [01:46] you know all the reasons. looked like it [01:47] just was a scheduling issue. But at the [01:50] end of the day, there was this uh [01:52] rupture that emerged among the student [01:54] body. And Brian was genuinely [01:58] bewildered. He asked in essence, how [02:01] could future rabbis, future leaders of [02:03] the Jewish community be taking positions [02:06] like this? What's going wrong? And he [02:09] was getting at a much bigger question. [02:12] Why is it that we seem to encounter many [02:15] more reform and conservative rabbis [02:18] publicly condemning Israel, sometimes in [02:21] extraordinarily harsh terms, than we do [02:24] with Orthodox rabbis. [02:26] Now, obviously, there will be some [02:28] exceptions, but the overall difference [02:31] is quite striking. And he was asking me, [02:34] what's going on? [02:36] And I know some of you will be thinking, [02:37] hang on a moment. Aren't there [02:39] ultraorththodox Jews who are fiercely [02:41] opposed to Israel as well? Well, I'll be [02:45] addressing that too in this video [02:46] because I think there's also an [02:48] important distinction to understand. [02:51] But first, why is this happening? How is [02:55] it that religious leaders, people whose [02:57] very job is to transmit Judaism to the [02:59] next generation, can end up embracing [03:02] narratives about the Jewish homeland, [03:04] the Jewish state, that seem almost [03:07] indistinguishable from those of Israel's [03:09] fiercest ideological opponents. [03:13] And I've been thinking about this [03:14] question ever since because I think the [03:17] answer takes us to something much deeper [03:19] than Israeli politics. It takes us to a [03:22] fundamental question. about the nature [03:25] of Judaism itself. [03:27] And I want to begin by making something [03:30] very very clear. JTV is a home for Jews [03:34] of all backgrounds. Orthodox, [03:37] conservative, reformed, secular, [03:38] religious, observant, non-observant, [03:41] right-wing, leftwing, and indeed for the [03:44] many non-Jews who watch our content. [03:46] It's also a home for you. We're catering [03:49] to anyone that wants to watch our [03:51] content. [03:53] and I welcome all. And I know that many [03:56] of you watching come from different [03:58] Jewish denominations. [03:59] Some of you will disagree profoundly [04:01] with what I'm about to say, and that's [04:04] absolutely fine. I have tremendous love [04:06] and respect for my fellow Jews, [04:09] irrespective of their level of religious [04:11] observance or their denomination. [04:14] But that doesn't mean I believe all [04:17] approaches to Judaism are equally [04:19] correct. I don't. I believe in the [04:22] divine origin of the Torah. I believe in [04:25] the authority of Jewish law as it has [04:27] been for thousands of years. [04:30] And I believe that these are fundamental [04:32] to understanding what Judaism actually [04:35] is. And equally, I don't believe that [04:38] simply wearing a certain type of kipah [04:40] makes someone automatically right about [04:42] everything. So this is not about judging [04:46] the worth of different Jews. It's about [04:48] examining different philosophies of [04:50] Judaism and asking what happens when [04:54] those philosophies encounter the [04:56] ideological pressures of the modern [04:58] world. And it begins with a very simple [05:01] question. Does Judaism teach us what to [05:05] believe or do we decide what we believe [05:08] and then reshape Judaism to accommodate [05:11] it? Because those are two very different [05:14] approaches to religion. [05:17] Traditional Judaism begins with an [05:20] extraordinary proposition that the Torah [05:22] is not simply a collection of inspiring [05:24] stories, ancient wisdom or cultural trai [05:27] traditions passed down through the [05:29] generations. It's a revelation from God. [05:33] That at Mount Si, the Jewish people [05:35] entered into a covenant with the creator [05:37] of the universe. and that this covenant [05:40] carries obligations, values, and truths [05:44] that are not simply ours to rewrite [05:47] whenever the prevailing culture changes. [05:49] Now, let's also be clear, Judaism has [05:52] always involved interpretation, debate, [05:55] and disagreement [05:58] and also social uh adaptation. [06:04] Open a page of the Talmud and you'll [06:06] encounter extraordinary arguments. [06:08] sometimes over the most meticulous [06:10] details of Jewish law. But these debates [06:13] overwhelmingly take place within a [06:15] shared framework. The rabbis are [06:17] debating how to understand and apply [06:20] God's commandments. They're not [06:22] generally debating whether these [06:23] commandments should remain binding in [06:25] the first place. That is a fundamentally [06:28] different question. And for the [06:30] overwhelming majority of Jewish history, [06:32] despite enormous differences in customs, [06:34] traditions, and levels of uh or ways of [06:37] practicing, that basic framework of [06:41] Torah authority remains central to [06:44] normative Jewish religious life. In [06:47] fact, something that I think many Jews [06:49] today don't fully appreciate is just how [06:51] recent our modern denominational [06:53] divisions actually are. [06:56] Go back two or 30 hundred years and you [06:59] don't find reform, conservative, and [07:01] Orthodox Judaism existing as the [07:04] separate religious movements that we [07:05] recognize today. Those categories [07:08] emerged in response to the extraordinary [07:11] upheavalss of modern European Jewish [07:13] life. As Jews gain greater opportunities [07:16] to participate in wider European [07:18] society, new questions emerged about [07:21] Jewish identity, religious practice, and [07:24] the relationship between Judaism and [07:26] modernity. [07:28] And in 19th century Germany, the reform [07:30] movement began to develop. Its leaders [07:33] believed that Judaism needed to change [07:36] in order to remain relevant in the [07:38] modern world. [07:39] They challenged traditional [07:40] understandings of the binding authority [07:43] of Jewish law. They introduced [07:45] significant changes to religious [07:46] practice and worship. And many of the [07:49] movement's early thinkers argued that [07:51] Judaism's universal ethical teachings [07:54] should take precedence over aspects of [07:56] its particular national and ritual [07:59] identity. [08:00] Some early reformed thinkers even [08:02] rejected the traditional aspiration for [08:04] a Jewish national restoration in the [08:07] land of Israel. [08:08] Think about that. The return of the [08:11] Jewish people to Zion, something woven [08:13] into our prayers and religious [08:14] consciousness for thousands of years was [08:17] no longer necessarily seen as a central [08:20] religious aspiration. [08:22] Now, reformed Judaism has changed [08:24] considerably since then, and many [08:26] reformed Jews today are deeply attached [08:28] to Israel. [08:30] But the underlying philosophical shift [08:32] is important to note because the [08:35] question was no longer simply how to [08:37] apply an inherited binding Torah [08:40] tradition to changing circumstances. [08:42] Increasingly it became which part of [08:45] that tradition should continue to be [08:47] regarded as authoritative in light of [08:50] modern values. [08:52] Conservative Judaism emerged somewhat [08:54] differently. It sought to preserve a [08:56] greater degree of continuity with [08:58] traditional Jewish law while also [09:01] embracing historical scholarship and the [09:03] idea that Jewish law and practice could [09:05] develop over time. And there are [09:07] significant differences between [09:09] conservative and reformed Judaism which [09:10] I do not want to gloss over. But from an [09:13] orthodox perspective, both movements [09:16] represented departures in different ways [09:18] and to different degrees from the [09:20] traditional understanding of the [09:22] authority of Torah and Haka. [09:25] And this is precisely why the Orthodox [09:27] world resisted these developments. It [09:30] wasn't simply because Orthodox rabbis [09:31] disliked change. Jewish law has always [09:34] had to address new technologies, new [09:37] social circumstances, and new questions. [09:40] The issue is much more fundamental. [09:42] Who has the final authority? [09:45] Is it the Torah which we believe [09:47] represents the eternal wisdom of God? Or [09:50] is it the moral and intellectual [09:51] consensus of the society in which we [09:54] happen to live? Because if the latter [09:57] becomes the ultimate authority, then [09:59] something very significant has happened. [10:02] Rather than Judaism shaping our [10:04] understanding of morality, the [10:07] prevailing culture begins to shape our [10:10] understanding of Judaism. Do you see [10:12] where I'm going with this? [10:15] And I think that helps explain a great [10:17] deal about what we're witnessing today. [10:21] Consider the ideological environment [10:23] that has developed in much of the modern [10:25] west, particularly within universities [10:27] and other influential cultural [10:29] institutions. [10:31] One of the most powerful frameworks [10:32] through which people are increasingly [10:34] taught to understand the world is the [10:37] division between oppressors and [10:39] oppressed, colonizers and colonized, [10:42] powerful and powerless, privileged and [10:45] marginalized. [10:46] And within that framework, Israel is [10:49] very often placed firmly in the category [10:52] of the oppressor, much as that label is [10:56] absurd, but that's a video for another [10:59] time. The Jewish state has become a [11:02] colonial project to the intellectual [11:04] class of the West. The Palestinians [11:07] become the indigenous victims and the [11:10] extraordinary history of the Jewish [11:11] people, our exile, our persecution, our [11:13] unbroken connection to our ancestral [11:15] homeland and our return to that homeland [11:18] is pushed to the margins. Now, imagine [11:21] that you're a young Jewish student [11:23] immersed in that intellectual [11:25] environment. [11:27] You want to be a good person. You want [11:29] to stand for justice. You want to be [11:31] accepted by your peers. And everyone [11:35] around you is telling you that [11:37] supporting Israel is morally [11:39] reprehensible. [11:41] What happens when the values of your [11:43] social environment come into conflict [11:46] with the historical consciousness and [11:48] particular obligations of your own [11:50] people? Well, one option is to challenge [11:55] the prevailing narrative to say, "Hang [11:56] on a second. Perhaps the world is more [11:59] complicated than these simplistic [12:01] categories. Perhaps the Jewish people [12:03] are not foreign colonizers in the land [12:05] at all. It's a place from which their [12:07] civilization emerged. Perhaps the [12:09] establishment of Israel was not another [12:12] example of European European [12:14] colonialism. [12:15] But the greatest human rights moment of [12:18] the last century, the extraordinary [12:20] restoration of an indigenous people to [12:23] their ancestral homeland after nearly [12:24] 2,000 years of exile. Perhaps Israel's [12:28] enemies have agency and responsibility, [12:30] too. [12:32] But saying that takes some courage [12:34] today, because it means risking [12:36] disapproval, exclusion, [12:39] even hostility. [12:42] And there's another option. You can [12:45] begin to reinterpret your Jewish [12:46] identity so that it aligns more [12:49] comfortably with the dominant worldview. [12:52] And suddenly, opposing Israel isn't a [12:54] departure from your Judaism. It becomes [12:57] an expression of your Judaism. [13:00] You can even present yourself as the [13:02] more authentically Jewish voice [13:05] precisely because you're opposing the [13:07] Jewish state. [13:10] And this is where the philosophical [13:11] distinction we discussed earlier becomes [13:14] so consequential. [13:16] Because if your religious framework [13:18] allows contemporary moral assumptions to [13:21] become the ultimate judge of inherited [13:23] Jewish beliefs, then why shouldn't the [13:26] dominant political ideology of your [13:28] generation influence how you understand [13:31] Judaism? [13:33] If your understanding of Jewish morality [13:35] is primarily shaped by the prevailing [13:37] definitions of oppression, justice, and [13:40] liberation, then when those definitions [13:42] turn against Israel, what is there [13:45] within your religious framework that [13:47] necessarily prevents you from following [13:49] them? And I think this is the question [13:52] that we need to confront. [13:54] Not whether every reform or conservative [13:56] Jew thinks this way. Of course they [13:58] don't. Not whether every Orthodox Jew [14:01] has a perfectly developed understanding [14:03] of Israel. Of course they don't. But [14:06] whether certain approaches to Jewish [14:08] religious authority leave communities [14:10] more vulnerable to absorbing the [14:12] ideological assumptions of the [14:14] surrounding culture even when those [14:16] assumptions conflict with central [14:19] elements of Jewish history, tradition [14:21] and belief. [14:23] And I believe the answer is yes. [14:27] Now, I want to be very careful here. I'm [14:30] not suggesting that everyone who [14:31] criticizes Israel is motivated by a [14:34] desire for social acceptance. [14:37] People can have sincere disagreements [14:39] and criticisms of particular decisions. [14:41] And that doesn't automatically amount [14:43] to, you know, outright hostility to [14:46] Israel's very existence. But I do [14:49] believe that much of the criticism [14:50] directed at Israel today is profoundly [14:52] unfair. It applies standards to Israel [14:55] that are rarely applied to other [14:57] countries. It frequently ignores the [14:59] intentions and actions of Israel's [15:01] enemies. And it often treats the Jewish [15:03] state's efforts to protect its [15:04] population as though they were uniquely [15:07] illegitimate. [15:09] And when Jewish religious leaders [15:11] embrace these narratives, I think we [15:13] have to ask some very serious questions [15:16] because a rabbi is not simply another [15:18] political commentator. A rabbi is [15:21] someone entrusted with teaching Judaism [15:23] to the next generation. [15:25] And when a rabbi presents hostility [15:27] towards the Jewish state as a religious [15:30] imperative, that carries enormous [15:32] consequences. [15:34] Because they're not simply expressing an [15:36] opinion, they're helping shape what the [15:38] next generation understands Judaism to [15:41] mean. [15:43] And this brings us to something I find [15:45] particularly revealing. Even within the [15:47] reform and conservative worlds, there [15:49] are rabbis who have publicly expressed [15:52] serious concerns about the growing [15:54] alienation of younger Jews from Israel, [15:57] younger Jews in their communities. [16:00] Religious leaders who themselves support [16:02] Israel are looking at younger members of [16:05] their communities and asking how their [16:07] attachment to the Jewish state has [16:09] become so fragile. [16:12] I think this is enormously significant [16:15] because while there are certainly [16:16] disagreements about Israel within the [16:18] Orthodox world, we simply do not appear [16:21] to be witnessing the same scale of [16:24] ideological alienation from the Jewish [16:26] state. And I do not think that that is a [16:30] coincidence. I think it reflects [16:32] something about the foundations upon [16:35] which Jewish identity is being built. [16:39] If Jewish identity is rooted primarily [16:42] in universal ethical values, cultural [16:45] belonging, or contemporary [16:46] understandings of social justice, [16:49] first of all, what unique message does [16:52] Judaism have to offer the world if it's [16:53] just mirroring the society it's in? [16:55] That's number one. But also, what [16:58] happens when the surrounding society [17:01] begins to define those values in ways [17:04] that conflict with Jewish national [17:06] identity? [17:08] But if your Jewish identity is rooted in [17:11] an eternal covenant with God, in a Torah [17:14] that has bound the Jewish people [17:15] together for thousands of years and in [17:17] an understanding of Jewish history that [17:20] places the land of Israel at its very [17:21] center, you have a very different [17:24] foundation from which to approach these [17:26] questions. [17:28] You might disagree with particular [17:29] Israeli policies or have very different [17:31] views about the nature of the Israeli [17:33] state, but you're far less likely to [17:36] conclude that the Jewish people's return [17:38] to their ancestral homeland is itself [17:40] some kind of historical injustice. [17:44] Nor will you look at Israel's conduct of [17:47] fighting its enemies viewed through the [17:49] Torah view of morality and self-defense [17:53] and look at that in a negative or [17:55] hostile way. [17:58] And that's not because Orthodox Jews are [18:00] necessarily smarter, kinder, or more [18:02] morally courageous. It's because the [18:04] starting point is different. One [18:07] approach risks allowing the values of [18:09] the age to become the judge of Judaism. [18:12] The other insists that Judaism must also [18:14] be allowed to judge the values of the [18:16] age. And I think that's an absolutely [18:20] crucial distinction. [18:22] But now there will be an obvious [18:24] objection to everything I've just said. [18:27] Because aren't some of the most fiercely [18:28] anti-ionist Jews in the world also [18:31] ultraorththodox? [18:33] And what about the Haredim in Israel? [18:37] And this was actually another point that [18:38] Brian raised during our Zoom discussion. [18:41] And it's a fair question because if [18:42] traditional Judaism provides such a [18:44] strong foundation for Jewish identity [18:46] and archadec connection to Israel, how [18:48] do we explain the existence of some [18:50] ultraorthodox Jews who reject Zionism? [18:53] Well, first of all, we need to [18:55] understand that the Haredi world itself [18:57] is not a single uniform movement. And [19:01] interestingly, the distinct Haredi [19:03] identity we recognize today also took [19:05] shape during the modern period largely [19:08] in response to secularization, [19:10] emancipation, and religious reform. But [19:13] unlike the reform movement, the Haradi [19:15] response to modernity was fundamentally [19:17] about preserving the authority of [19:20] traditional Torah and haka. Now, [19:23] historically, there have been some [19:24] Orthodox rabbis that opposed uh [19:27] political Zionism. Some believe that the [19:30] Jewish people shouldn't attempt to [19:31] establish a sovereign state before the [19:34] Messianic era. Others were deeply [19:36] troubled by the secular ideology of the [19:38] early Zionist movement, fearing that it [19:40] would replace Torah with nationalism as [19:42] the central organizing principle of [19:44] Jewish life. And they were serious [19:46] theological disagreements. But here's [19:48] the absolutely crucial distinction. [19:52] Opposing Zionism as a secular political [19:54] ideology is not the same thing as [19:57] opposing the existence, security, or [19:59] survival of the Jewish state. Many [20:02] Haredi Jews who don't identify as [20:04] Zionists nevertheless live in Israel, [20:06] love the land of Israel, pray for the [20:07] safety of its inhabitants, and strongly [20:09] support the need to defend Jewish lives [20:12] against terrorism and aggression. They [20:14] may have profound disagreements with the [20:18] secular foundations of the Israeli [20:20] state, but that does not mean that they [20:21] sympathize with Hamas or regard the [20:23] IDF's efforts to protect Israel as some [20:26] kind of colonial injustice. Quite the [20:28] opposite. In fact, many of the Haredi [20:30] Jews that I speak to in Israel, [20:31] including personal friends of mine, are [20:34] profoundly supportive of Israel's [20:36] military campaigns. When I ask them [20:38] about Israel, they speak with enormous [20:41] pride about its military achievements [20:43] and marvel at the extraordinary success [20:45] of the IDF and share profoundly in the [20:48] pain of Israel and the Jewish people [20:51] through all the uh terrible experiences [20:54] that we've uh had in the last few years [20:57] especially. So, while they may not, some [21:00] of them may not identify with the label [21:02] of being a Zionist, in fact, even though [21:05] some probably do as well, but [21:08] regardless, it certainly doesn't mean [21:09] that they're hostile to Israel or its [21:11] efforts to defend the Jewish people. [21:13] They just have it's just a nuanced [21:15] matter where they have specific views [21:17] about uh how the state was originally [21:20] formed. And I I've I've addressed all of [21:22] this in um a video, a documentary we [21:26] made, which I'll mention more about at [21:27] the end, called Zionism and Judaism, the [21:29] false separation. And I explain why many [21:31] in the even in the uh ultraorth orthodox [21:34] world now look at those arguments uh [21:37] differently and uh people that I've [21:40] learned from even in the kabad world and [21:42] not just the religious Zionist world [21:44] look at uh these lines in that they use [21:47] to justify opposition to reestablishing [21:50] sovereignty in the land of Israel. Um [21:52] and they look at them very differently [21:54] today. So I explain all of that in our [21:56] documentary uh which you can find on JTV [21:58] Plus but I'll mention more of that more [22:00] about that later. And we should be very [22:02] careful to distinguish the mainstream [22:04] Karedi world today from the tiny fringe [22:08] groups such as Nuri Carter whose [22:10] representatives have appeared alongside [22:12] some of Israel's most vicious enemies. [22:15] That's utterly indefensible. [22:17] But these groups represent a tiny [22:19] fraction of the Haredi community and [22:21] treating them as representative of [22:23] religious Jews would be profoundly [22:25] misleading. And I also want to add that [22:28] the Haredi world's relationship with [22:31] Israel has been an evolving one. And I [22:34] think we're slowly seeing signs of [22:37] gradual integration, acceptance, and all [22:40] of that because there perhaps is a bit [22:43] of an awakening that's happening that's [22:45] realizing that perhaps the um zealous [22:49] secularism of Israel's, you know, early [22:53] politicians and founding uh is changing. [22:57] The people of Israel are changing. [22:59] they're reconnecting with uh their [23:01] Jewish roots and perhaps their car [23:03] characterization of the state is uh [23:06] they're having a a rethink about that. [23:08] Maybe that's a little bit of a [23:12] an aspiration rather than a reality. But [23:14] I feel like I am seeing some signs of [23:15] that. But now, of course, people will [23:18] say, "But what about military service?" [23:20] Because here I I do have and I've made a [23:23] video about this. You can check it out. [23:24] I do have a disagreement with uh the [23:28] current state of affairs in Israel. I [23:31] believe the current situation in Israel [23:33] where large numbers of the Haredi [23:35] community are exempt from military [23:36] service or any form of national service [23:39] while other Israelis carry an [23:41] extraordinary burden is simply [23:42] unsustainable. [23:44] When young Israelis are risking their [23:46] lives, when families are losing sons and [23:48] fathers, when reservists are being [23:50] called up again and again and again, [23:52] there does have to be a serious [23:53] conversation about shared [23:54] responsibility. [23:56] And I don't think that can simply be [23:58] dismissed. But at the same time, I [24:00] understand that many genuinely believe [24:03] uh in what they're doing, full-time [24:05] Torah study and the spiritual protection [24:07] that offers to the Jewish people. I I [24:10] don't uh demean any of that. [24:13] I just think this question needs to be [24:15] looked at from both sides. Again, [24:17] religious accommodation so that they can [24:19] join the army and also maintaining Torah [24:22] learning for uh those who really can uh [24:26] excel in it. Uh and that perhaps being a [24:28] form of national service. And I made as [24:31] as I say, I made a whole video about [24:32] this that goes into my uh feelings on [24:36] the matter. Um, but as I say, cherishing [24:40] Torah study absolutely I believe should [24:43] it's the last thing that should be [24:45] dismissed. But at the same time, it [24:47] doesn't mean we can't question whether [24:49] the present arrangements are conducive [24:52] to Jewish life and unity. And we can [24:57] have disagreements about that without [24:59] accusing uh any community of being [25:01] disloyal to Israel because the Haredi [25:04] debate is fundamentally about the [25:06] relationship between Torah study, [25:08] military service and collective [25:10] responsibility. But that's a very very [25:12] different debate from whether Israel has [25:15] the right to defend itself against [25:17] enemies seeking its destruction. And I [25:20] think making these distinctions is [25:21] essential if we're going to have an [25:23] honest conversation [25:25] because the problem isn't disagreement. [25:28] Judaism has always been full of [25:30] disagreement. The problem arises when [25:33] our disagreements become so detached [25:35] from our shared foundations that we lose [25:38] sight of what binds us together. And [25:41] perhaps that is the deeper lesson here. [25:44] The Jewish people have survived empires, [25:46] expulsions, persecution, force [25:48] conversions, and attempts at [25:50] extermination. [25:52] We've lived under Greek rule, Roman [25:54] rule, Christian rule, Islamic rule, and [25:57] through the extraordinary upheavalss of [25:59] the modern age. Every generation has [26:02] encountered powerful ideologies that [26:04] claim to possess the ultimate answer to [26:06] how human beings should live. And yet, [26:08] those ideologies have come and gone. the [26:11] Jewish people are still here and the [26:13] Torah is still here. That's an [26:16] astonishing fact and I would suggest [26:18] that one of the reasons for that [26:19] survival is that Judaism has never [26:22] simply been whatever the surrounding [26:24] civilization wanted it to be. We have [26:28] learned from the cultures around us for [26:29] sure. We have contributed enormously to [26:32] them. We have engaged grappled with [26:34] philosophy, science, literature and [26:36] every great intellectual movement. But [26:39] we have also maintained something [26:41] distinct, something that transcends the [26:43] fashions and political movements of any [26:45] polit particular age. And I worry that [26:49] when we lose confidence in that [26:50] distinctiveness, when we become [26:52] embarrassed by the particular story and [26:54] destiny of the Jewish people, we begin [26:57] we begin to lose something essential. [27:01] Because Judaism absolutely teaches us to [27:03] care about humanity. It teaches us that [27:06] every human being is created in the [27:08] image of God. It commands us to pursue [27:12] justice, to protect the vulnerable, and [27:14] to treat the stranger with dignity. [27:17] But Judaism also teaches us the Jewish [27:20] people have a particular covenant, a [27:23] particular history, a particular land, [27:26] and a particular responsibility. [27:29] Those two things are not contradictions. [27:31] Our universal mission emerges from our [27:34] particular identity. And if we erase [27:36] that particular identity in the name of [27:38] universal values, we risk undermining [27:41] the very foundation from which those [27:43] values emerge. [27:46] Now, I want to finish with something [27:47] important. I don't want anyone watching [27:50] this to come away thinking that the [27:51] solution is for Jews to turn against one [27:54] another. Quite the opposite. We need [27:57] more Jewish unity, not less. And unity [28:00] doesn't mean pretending that our [28:02] disagreements don't exist. It means [28:04] recognizing that we can disagree [28:06] passionately, even about fundamental [28:08] religious questions, while continuing to [28:11] see one another as members of the same [28:13] people. [28:14] I don't believe that a reformed Jew is [28:16] any less deserving of my love or concern [28:20] than an Orthodox Jew. And I certainly [28:23] don't believe that the Jewish people can [28:25] afford to write off entire communities [28:27] because we disagree with their religious [28:30] orientation. [28:32] But unity also cannot require us to [28:35] abandon our convictions. If I believe [28:38] that the Torah is divine, that the [28:40] Jewish people have an eternal covenant [28:41] with God, and that our connection to the [28:43] land of Israel is an inseparable part of [28:45] that covenant, then I have to be willing [28:48] to say so respectfully, thoughtfully, [28:52] but clearly. And I want to say something [28:54] else, too. When I look at the young [28:56] Israeli soldiers risking their lives to [28:58] defend the Jewish people, many of whom [29:01] are not religiously observant, I see [29:04] some of the greatest heroes and sadikim [29:06] of our times. People fulfilling one of [29:08] the highest obligations in Judaism, [29:11] saving human life, saving Jewish life, [29:14] protecting their fellow Jews at [29:16] extraordinary personal cost. The [29:19] spiritual greatness of a person cannot [29:20] simply be measured by the clothes they [29:23] wear, the community they belong to, or [29:25] the label they use to describe [29:26] themselves. And perhaps the most [29:29] important thing that we can do is ensure [29:31] that the next generation of Jews grow up [29:33] with a deep understanding of who they [29:36] are. Not simply that they should support [29:38] Israel because Israel is under attack. [29:41] Not simply that they should be proud to [29:42] be Jewish because anti-semitism is [29:44] rising. but that there is something [29:47] extraordinary about being Jewish in the [29:49] first place. That they are heirs to one [29:51] of the most remarkable stories in human [29:53] history. That Judaism has a profound [29:56] vision for humanity, for morality, for [29:59] justice, and for the ultimate purpose of [30:01] existence. And that they have inherited [30:04] a responsibility to carry that vision [30:06] forward. Because if young people today [30:10] understand the depth, beauty, and truth [30:11] of their Jewish identity, they will be [30:13] far better equipped to confront a world [30:16] that increasingly challenges it. And [30:19] they won't need to choose between being [30:21] proudly Jewish and being good human [30:23] beings. They'll understand that properly [30:26] understood, the two go hand in hand. So [30:29] when Brian asked me, "What's wrong with [30:31] us Jews? How can our future rabbis be [30:34] taking these positions?" I think the [30:36] most important question isn't simply [30:38] what's wrong with those particular [30:39] rabbis. It's whether we're giving the [30:41] next generation a Jewish identity strong [30:43] enough to withstand the pressures of the [30:46] world around them. Because ultimately, [30:49] the future of the Jewish people will not [30:51] be secured by making Judaism more [30:53] fashionable. It will be secured by [30:56] making Judaism more deeply understood. [30:59] And that's precisely why I started JTV. [31:03] And before we finish, if you'd like to [31:04] join me for those private community Zoom [31:07] calls where we discuss these issues and [31:08] much more and ask questions and [31:11] community can uh talk to me and one [31:13] another, then just head over to www.j-tv [31:18] plus. And it's also where you can access [31:20] all of our premium documentaries, [31:23] including one that I hope will address [31:26] some of the uh issues that I've [31:28] mentioned in this film and that I think [31:30] lead to part of the problem that we see [31:33] where you can even have some Jewish [31:35] people trying to make a distinction and [31:37] push a distinction between Zionism and [31:39] Judaism because actually so many people [31:42] including Israel's enemies utilize that [31:45] uh argument, but it's actually complete [31:48] nonsense. So, I felt we had to [31:49] thoroughly and comprehensively debunk [31:52] this myth head on, and we made a film [31:54] called Zionism and Judaism: The False [31:56] Separation. Have a watch of the trailer [31:58] for it. And to watch this really [31:59] important film in full, just click on [32:01] the link below in the video description. [32:03] I'm not against Judaism. I'm just [32:05] against Zionism. [32:06] >> It's not Jewish, it's Zionism. [32:07] >> Judaism and Zionism are completely [32:09] separate. [32:10] >> You know, Judaism is a faith. [music] [32:12] Israel is a state. [32:14] >> You can be Jewish without being a [32:15] Zionist. [32:17] and Judaism is totally [music] [32:18] diametrically opposed. I'm sure you've [32:20] heard this before from protesters, from [32:23] politicians, from even well-meaning [32:24] people trying to navigate the Israel [32:26] Palestine debate. But I'm here to tell [32:28] you that this separation is complete [32:31] nonsense. It's a comfortable lie. The [32:34] kind of lie that sounds intelligent but [32:36] collapses the moment you actually open [32:38] this book, the Torah, [music] the Bible, [32:40] and study Judaism on its own terms. In [32:44] this JTV Plus documentary, we're going [32:46] to tackle this myth head on. We'll [32:48] actually look inside the Torah and see [32:51] how in the very first book, Genesis, [32:53] there's no mention of law or religion. [32:56] It's all centered on the promise of a [32:58] specific land to a specific nation. [33:00] [music] We'll trace how Judaism, not [33:02] modern politics, but Judaism itself, is [33:05] structured around one obsessive, [33:08] relentless, undeniable claim, the land [33:10] of Israel belongs to the Jews. will [33:12] reveal why the building of a nation in [33:14] the land [music] of Israel is an [33:16] indispensable part of the project of [33:18] Judaism. Why Judaism is not a religion, [33:21] it's the divine project of a nation in a [33:23] land. We'll discover how the Torah [33:25] [music] preemptively answered the [33:27] colonization accusation that wouldn't [33:29] fully materialize for another 3,000 [33:31] years. We'll explore why if the land is [33:34] so central, Jews had to spend thousands [33:36] of years in global [music] exile. We'll [33:38] unpack what Zionism actually means and [33:41] how anti-ionism doesn't just contradict [33:43] Israeli policy, it contradicts the [33:45] fundamental architecture of Judaism [33:47] itself. For some people, this is going [33:49] to be uncomfortable viewing, but by the [33:52] end, we'll prove beyond any reasonable [33:54] doubt that Judaism and Zionism are [33:56] inseparable. To watch this JTV Plus [33:59] documentary and access much more premium [34:02] content, click on the link in the video [34:04] description.