Transcript [00:00] We lost our country to Islamists. My dad [00:03] was a commander [music] in the last army [00:06] that fought Hezbollah. Anyone who tried [00:08] to even speak against Hezbollah [music] [00:11] was blown up. Either we stay and be [00:14] slaughtered in our beds or we leave the [00:17] country forever and never come back. [00:19] >> So you came to be a Lebanese Christian [00:22] Israeli. Do do you identify as Israeli? [00:24] >> I [music] am with Israel finishing the [00:27] job. People are going on live television [00:29] [music] in Lebanon saying I want to [00:32] drink whiskey in Tel Aviv. I integrated [00:35] and I felt part actually of the Israeli [00:38] population, the Jewish [music] [00:40] population. We are a civilization that [00:43] was in the Middle East before Arabs [00:45] conquered [music] the land and kind of [00:47] imposed the language and imposed this [00:50] identity on us. You need to understand [00:52] that in the Arab world, we never had any [00:55] [music] content about Israel that wasn't [00:58] negative or only about the war. I [01:02] understand what does it mean to be a [01:04] refugee. It terrifies me when [music] I [01:06] see what young people think and say. It [01:09] terrifies me. If you don't fight [01:12] terrorism and extremism in your country, [01:16] you will pay the price at some point. [01:18] >> I'm Jonathan Sachadotti. If you like [01:21] these interviews, please subscribe to [01:22] the channel and like this video and that [01:24] way you'll keep up to date with any new [01:26] ones that we publish. Mariam Eunice, [01:28] thanks very much for joining me here in [01:30] Tarvid. Great to see you. You're well [01:31] known on the internet for speaking in [01:34] Arabic about your very unique position [01:37] as a Christian Lebanese woman living in [01:41] Israel. So, first off, can you explain [01:43] to me and everyone watching how did that [01:45] happen? Yeah. So my dad was a commander [01:48] in the last army that fought Hezbollah [01:51] on the Lebanese soil in the southern [01:53] Lebanese army. So after the civil war [01:55] was ended in Lebanon, the southern part [01:58] of Lebanon was still a buffer zone where [02:01] the IDF um uh occupied and the southern [02:05] Lebanese people um had this army called [02:09] the southern Lebanese army uh funded and [02:13] obviously supported by Israel to fight [02:16] against terrorist organizations that [02:19] operated in the south and fought against [02:22] us as well as Lebanese. So at first it [02:24] was the PLO and through the '90s it was [02:26] Hezbollah which is an Iranian proxy for [02:29] us and um in 2000 when the IDF withdraw [02:33] uh suddenly we were given two options by [02:36] Nasalah [02:38] uh either we stay and be slaughtered in [02:40] our beds or we leave the country forever [02:43] and never come back. So, we had to flee [02:46] from Lebanon to Israel thinking it's [02:49] going to be for a week or two, you know, [02:50] until the Lebanese army take over the [02:53] south, which never happened. And then [02:55] the government will settle um an [02:57] agreement regarding us as, you know, [03:00] Lebanese citizens, which never happened [03:02] as well. So, I was 5 years old back then [03:05] um uh when we fled. And in 2004, the [03:09] Israeli Kesset passed a law where uh [03:12] Lebanese uh people can have the [03:14] citizenship. [03:16] >> So you came to be a Lebanese Christian [03:19] Israeli. Do do you identify as Israeli? [03:21] >> Yeah, of course. I grew up, you know, in [03:24] uh I went to a Jewish school. I grew up [03:26] in a Jewish town in northern Israel. My [03:29] friends are Jewish. I'm very Israeli, [03:31] you know. I grew up in the Israeli [03:33] mentality, but at the same time at home, [03:37] we were very Lebanese, you know, food, [03:40] uh, the accent, we were very Christian, [03:42] celebrating, you know, Christmas and [03:45] Easter and so on, going to church. So, I [03:48] grew up literally in both identities and [03:51] in both worlds. So, it's it's beautiful [03:54] to me. It's it's really it's also very [03:56] rare in in the Middle East. [03:58] >> Yeah. I mean listen it to people like me [04:01] it's not that weird from my perspective. [04:03] I grew up as a Jew in a Christian [04:05] country and so I celebrated Jewish [04:07] festivals in a place which around me [04:09] celebrated Christmas and I was educated [04:11] among Christians but as you say here in [04:13] this part of the world it's quite [04:14] different. [04:15] >> Yeah. You also you know you grow up here [04:17] watching for example Al Jazzer and you [04:21] just see on TV just the opposite of what [04:26] you're actually living on the ground. [04:28] And so for me it's like I'm living with [04:31] Israelis. I'm I'm a minority here. I'm a [04:34] minority within a minority. Within a [04:37] minority because the Christians in [04:38] Israel are only 2% of the 20% of Arabic [04:42] speakers population. So and we didn't [04:46] integrate in the Arabs of Israel because [04:48] they didn't accept us. For them we were [04:50] traitors. So I integrated and I felt [04:55] part actually of the Israeli population, [04:58] the Jewish population. So it's very [05:00] unique to grow up in this and and just [05:04] live in Israel and on the other hand you [05:07] just watch on TV constantly only [05:09] negative news and you know it's just a [05:13] dissonance that from a very young age I [05:16] couldn't grasp. and and you said to me [05:19] before we started recording actually [05:20] that that you don't identify as a [05:23] Christian Arab in Israel. Um explain [05:26] about that how the identity specifically [05:29] isn't Arab. [05:31] >> Yeah, for for many Lebanese it's also a [05:34] debate within the Lebanese um you know [05:36] population. But for us as Maronites [05:39] especially, we don't identify as Arabs [05:42] because we believe we are Phoenicians. [05:44] We are a civilization that was in the [05:47] Middle East before Arabs conquered the [05:49] land and kind of imposed the language [05:52] and imposed this identity on us. Uh so [05:55] we want to preserve this identity. You [05:58] know some people might call themselves [05:59] even Arameans and some might call [06:02] themselves kalanite. However, it's to [06:06] the point of it is to, you know, keep [06:09] and preserve again this identity that [06:12] has nothing to do with Arabism. And of [06:14] course, we are part of the Middle East. [06:16] We speak Arabic and we gained a lot of [06:19] cultural influence from Arabs. It's we [06:22] don't deny it. And and it's not like us [06:25] wanting to preserve our identity as [06:27] non-Arabs. It's not to be against Arabs [06:31] at all. is just to preserve our identity [06:34] that was way before Arabs conquered us. [06:37] So [06:38] >> and and you mentioned seeing Alazera [06:41] whilst living here and it gave a very [06:43] different perception of your actual [06:44] exper than your experience. Um and [06:47] similarly it sounds like you've lived as [06:48] a minority then in two different [06:50] countries uh really in a sense you when [06:54] there was a a conquest or a takeover in [06:57] Lebanon you became persecuted for your [06:59] Christian identity and in Israel it [07:02] sounds like you mentioned that the [07:04] Muslim Arab community didn't accept you [07:06] but the Jewish Israeli one did as a [07:09] Christian minority. Is that is that [07:11] accurate? [07:12] >> Yeah. Look, Lebanon was funded um for [07:16] the Christians. It was supposed to be a [07:18] Christian country in the Middle East. [07:20] And actually, fun fact, the Marinite [07:23] patriarchy supported the creation of a [07:27] Jewish state because they understand [07:30] back then that we don't want to be the [07:32] only minority in the Middle East. We [07:34] don't want to be the only um um [07:37] religious minority here. So actually [07:40] back then there it was kind of it made [07:43] sense that minorities will have their [07:45] own countries. why not you know and then [07:47] through the years actually and for many [07:49] in my opinion and for the opinion of [07:53] many you know scholars um when the [07:56] Muslims were added especially the [07:58] southern part of Lebanon which was [08:00] majority Shia it kind of through the [08:03] years changed the the demography of [08:06] Lebanon and later on obviously the civil [08:08] war um um crushed Christianity in [08:12] Lebanon. people fled like Lebanon in [08:15] huge numbers and obviously with the [08:18] years more and more Christians left [08:20] because for us Christians we don't stay [08:23] we don't die we don't want wars we [08:27] prefer to run away and live better [08:29] elsewhere than fight for our land or for [08:33] you know a country so unfortunately [08:36] right now the Lebanon is um Muslim [08:40] majority but for us It's it's supposed [08:43] to be a Christian state. [08:44] >> And you said you were five when you [08:46] left. What memories do you actually have [08:48] from those years in Lebanon? [08:51] >> I have a lot of memories, you know, of [08:53] my village, my family, my grandma. Uh I [08:56] was very close to her. Unfortunately, [08:58] she passed away a couple months ago and [09:00] I was very hopeful that I'm going to be [09:03] able to see her cuz I'm very hopeful [09:06] that we will have a peace agreement soon [09:09] uh with Lebanon. So I remember my [09:11] school. I remember bits and pieces of my [09:14] daily life, you know, in southern [09:15] Lebanon. So I remember a lot of things. [09:17] >> And would you I mean, you said that at [09:19] the time of fleeing, there wasn't the [09:21] idea that it would be permanent. At what [09:24] point do you think your family realized [09:27] that you weren't going back? [09:29] >> Great question. I I feel that it was in [09:32] 2006 after the second uh Hezbollah [09:36] Israel war. I feel like Lebanese people [09:39] in Israel understand that the Israelis [09:44] and maybe also the world is not going to [09:46] destroy Hezbollah. [09:48] And the war, the narrative after the war [09:52] of Hezbollah being stronger and the one [09:56] who, you know, um won over Israel and um [10:01] managed to um kick the Israelis in 2000 [10:05] and so on. We knew that this is going to [10:08] be the shift in Lebanon as well in [10:11] powers and it actually was like this and [10:14] Hezbollah started taking control over [10:17] the south and over Lebanon in general. [10:19] So I think this point was the point [10:21] where Lebanese people understand that [10:24] Hezbollah is not going to disappear. [10:26] It's not going to be you know um [10:28] eliminated. And this was the point for [10:30] us that was like, okay, so [10:34] >> but you [10:34] >> we're staying here [10:35] >> still had family there. You mentioned [10:38] your grandmother and I'm sure others and [10:40] and in fact your father when he passed [10:41] away was buried in Lebanon, right? [10:43] >> He is buried in Lebanon. [10:44] >> So there's a deep connection. [10:46] >> Of course, [10:47] >> very deep. H [10:48] >> how how does that feel? Do you still [10:51] today keep very much in touch with [10:53] people there, with family there, with [10:55] culture there? [10:56] >> We can be in touch with our families. [10:58] There is a law in Lebanon that um [11:03] doesn't allow to Lebanese people to [11:06] speak with Israelis. There is [11:11] this law is literally the the the [11:14] craziest law ever. Like imagine Lebanese [11:17] people are not allowed to speak to [11:19] Israelis. And now there is a very strong [11:22] movement, political movement and social [11:24] movement to actually um abolish this law [11:28] and change it or you know cancel it uh [11:31] so we can be in touch with our families. [11:33] Of course it's very dangerous for them [11:34] and um we don't want to put them in [11:36] danger. [11:38] >> So I'm I'm very sorry to hear about your [11:40] your grandmother. You mentioned that you [11:42] know you had hoped that there would be [11:44] peace in time for you to go back and and [11:46] be with her and see her. Um, obviously [11:48] things have changed a great deal in the [11:50] last three years and there has been some [11:53] sense of hope for change. How does that [11:56] feel for you and and do you think it's a [11:58] realistic prospect now within let's say [12:01] your lifetime? [12:02] >> Yes, there is not only hope. I think [12:05] that we have never been closer to peace [12:08] than these days. Literally like we never [12:12] imagined that Hezbollah will be [12:14] literally at its weakest point in [12:17] Lebanon and in the region. We never [12:19] imagined that the you know the Syrian [12:22] regime the Assad's regime will fall in [12:24] Syria which had a huge impact on the [12:27] power of Hezbollah in Lebanon. We never [12:29] imagined that a Lebanese ambassador and [12:33] an Israeli ambassador will actually have [12:36] direct talks in Washington. these things [12:39] we never imagined will happen before, [12:42] you know. So, of course, people are very [12:44] hopeful, but I I feel like we still need [12:48] strong leadership on both sides, of [12:50] course, not only to continue the work [12:52] and eliminate Hezbollah forever or at [12:55] least its arms. Uh, but we need strong [12:58] leadership that is able to take, you [13:00] know, the complexity that is Lebanon and [13:02] take it toward a prosper future and a [13:05] peaceful future with Israel. So, But [13:08] given that that has happened as a result [13:10] of Israeli renewed Israeli military [13:12] action in southern Lebanon and [13:14] specifically where where your family is [13:16] from. [13:17] >> Yeah. [13:17] >> How did it feel for you and other [13:19] Lebanese people like you or Lebanese [13:22] origin to see Israel uh and the military [13:25] action that took place there? I mean [13:26] were you entirely supportive? Was there [13:28] a feeling of uh division within you and [13:31] and your family? Was it difficult to [13:34] watch? So I would like to say first uh [13:38] that the Christian villages of southern [13:41] Lebanon and one of them is my village. [13:43] They are still there and the people are [13:45] still there resisting. [13:48] Um [13:50] because the Christian villages are free [13:52] of Hezbollah. There are no arms [13:54] obviously. Um I'm not obviously in any [13:59] war and I grew up in wars from a very [14:01] young age. I don't wish war on anyone, [14:04] but to me as a Middle Eastern and as a [14:07] Lebanese that my father fought Hezbollah [14:11] and on the 8th of October, this [14:13] terrorist organization decided to take a [14:16] whole country to a war regardless the [14:20] refusal of the Lebanese government and [14:22] the Lebanese people that were already [14:25] crushed after Corona and you know [14:27] economical instability and political [14:29] instability. They decided to start a war [14:32] on Israel. [14:35] I [14:37] am with them taking the responsibility [14:40] of this war and I am with Israel [14:43] finishing the job. Like I don't want [14:46] wars but if we are at a war because this [14:50] terrorist organization that is also [14:51] refusing to disarm [14:54] then finish them. We want this to be the [14:56] last war. I don't want other people to [14:59] you know uh suffer again because of the [15:03] same people and the same reason. [15:06] So it's very hard but we are fighting [15:09] terrorism and this is unfortunately the [15:11] only way to fight terrorist organization [15:14] that hijacked the whole country and [15:16] doesn't even want to disarm. How does it [15:19] feel when you see people in the UK or in [15:22] the US or other European nations out on [15:26] the streets protesting then against the [15:29] IDF against Israel uh and specifically [15:33] referencing southern Lebanon and [15:35] military action there, painting Israel [15:37] as the belligerent partner in this [15:40] murder as they say of children and [15:42] families when you know so differently [15:45] from they what is going on? Look, the [15:48] ignorant of [15:52] Americans and Europeans, and I'm not [15:55] saying this to, you know, to [15:59] degrade them. I'm just saying it because [16:02] when you don't know the geopolitics of [16:06] this region, when you are unfamiliar [16:09] with what does it mean to be under a [16:12] terrorist organization that controls [16:15] your daily life, when you don't [16:17] understand what it means for a country [16:21] to fight a terrorist organization that [16:24] operates from, you know, populated [16:28] areas. is when you just want to, you [16:32] know, just take part with underdogs that [16:34] you don't even understand what their [16:36] ideology is, you are an ignorant. And it [16:40] makes me so mad to see this masses of [16:43] people going out to protest something [16:46] they don't understand just because they [16:48] hate Israel. I mean, you can protest [16:51] against a policy. You can obviously [16:54] criticize government. We do criticize [16:56] our government every day. But this [17:00] massive movements supporting Hezbollah, [17:03] supporting Hamas, supporting inif [17:05] without even understanding the meaning [17:07] of this, without even understanding how [17:09] people on the ground are affected by [17:11] this. This to me is [17:17] terrifying. Terrifying. These people are [17:20] liberals. They so they supposed you know [17:22] to be the leaders of the future and [17:24] probably their decisions will affect me [17:27] as a Middle Eastern and instead of [17:30] supporting us fighting terrorism they [17:33] are supporting terrorism. It's [17:35] terrifying [17:36] >> and you just said earlier that you know [17:38] you want Israel to finish this to end it [17:40] to endbollah at least in its armed form. [17:44] Uh whereas many of them, even [17:47] those who would say, "Well, we were [17:48] supportive of Israel's reaction or [17:51] defense, but it's gone too far." You're [17:53] saying it hasn't gone far enough, right? [17:56] >> Collateral damage is is disgusting and I [17:59] went through war and I don't want other [18:01] people to like I'm a refugee. I [18:04] understand what does it mean to be a [18:06] refugee. So, of course, I'm not here [18:08] saying, "Oh, let's have war, you know, [18:11] but I want to fight terrorism and I want [18:16] to eliminate terrorism." And if they, [18:19] the leaders of their own people, they [18:21] don't care about their people. They [18:23] don't have empathy toward their people. [18:26] What am I supposed to do? What am I [18:28] supposed to do to pay price for another [18:31] war? for my kids to grow up and be [18:34] kidnapped and slaughtered in a Hamas [18:37] tunnel? No. No. [18:41] >> Would you one day want to live back in [18:44] Lebanon if you could? [18:45] >> Of course. Of course. I want to go back [18:47] to my country, my people. I want to go [18:51] to party in Beirut. You know, it's it's [18:54] still the [18:55] >> Me too, by the way. [18:57] >> It's great. you know, like you you see [18:59] the the videos and how people party and [19:02] the Lebanese spirit is very we we really [19:05] love life just like Israelis, by the [19:07] way. And this is something similar [19:08] between the two uh uh people, we love [19:12] life, even though we grew up in [19:15] literally war zone, but people always [19:17] find reasons to party and and have fun [19:21] and go out and and dance and music and [19:24] good food, you know. Of course, I dream [19:26] to live with my people and to have, you [19:29] know, them visit Israel and see Israel [19:31] from my point of view and Israelis [19:34] visiting Lebanon. This is the dream. [19:36] >> And I mean, you mentioned this, you [19:37] know, amazement that actually things [19:40] have happened as they have over the last [19:41] few years whereby you've had Lebanese [19:44] and Israeli diplomats meeting in the US [19:47] in DC and and trying to get to that. Do [19:52] you really think that's a possibility? [19:54] not just in terms of diplomacy, but also [19:56] in terms of population, or has Lebanon [19:59] changed drastically since the one you [20:02] left and and do you think that it would [20:04] work out that Israelis could come and [20:06] party in Beirut with you for example? [20:09] >> Yes. Yes. And we see it actually on the [20:12] ground. [20:14] And this was one of the changes that [20:16] happened since 8th of October that [20:18] people are no longer afraid. The people [20:21] are no longer afraid to say we want [20:23] peace. People are going on live [20:26] television in Lebanon saying, "I want to [20:29] drink whiskey in Tel Aviv. I want to [20:31] visit Jerusalem. I want a peace. I want [20:34] a good neighboring. I want to prosper. I [20:37] want the countries to finally have peace [20:39] together. Like people are not afraid [20:41] anymore. And this was a taboo before. A [20:44] taboo. Anyone who tried to even speak [20:47] against Hezbollah was blown up. [20:51] Literally politicians, journalists, [20:54] social or peace activist. And now people [20:58] are not afraid anymore. And we are [21:00] seeing this movement actually starting [21:02] from the people up. And it's beautiful [21:05] to see more and more voices. by the way, [21:07] not only in Lebanon, across the Middle [21:09] East, more and more people my age and um [21:13] even older that are not afraid to say [21:16] anymore, we are sick of terrorism. We [21:18] are sick of extremism in our region. We [21:21] deserve better. We deserve better. [21:23] >> And and why do you think it is that now [21:25] they're able to speak about peace? Is it [21:26] because of the pages? because of the [21:28] IDF, because of what happened to [21:31] >> in Lebanon is 100% because of um the the [21:37] fight against Hezbollah and and you know [21:40] the fact that Nasra was eliminated uh he [21:43] was the strongest figure in Lebanon and [21:49] um and obviously Kamina as well that was [21:52] eliminated. So of course the fact that [21:54] Hezbollah is weak has a huge impact on [21:58] why people are not afraid anymore [22:00] because Hezbollah was the reason why [22:02] people were terrified to speak up. [22:05] People were you know people had um uh in [22:09] Lebanon if you spoke against Hezbollah [22:12] for example someone would come over to [22:14] your place and they would hurt you. So [22:18] it's a you know it's a psychological [22:20] terrorism. you can't you can't say your [22:23] opinion even. [22:24] >> And before Hezbollah, you mentioned the [22:26] PLO were the terrorist enemy in uh [22:28] southern Lebanon. Uh how does that feel [22:31] then as an Israeli Lebanese? Um the the [22:34] PLO is now I mean again as many people [22:37] in the West, they're the good guys of [22:39] the Palestinian movement. Uh Israel has [22:41] been at war, not just in Lebanon, but [22:43] also in the Gaza Strip after the [22:45] Palestinian invasion there. Uh, is it [22:48] difficult for you as somebody from a [22:50] non-Jewish, non-originally Israeli [22:52] background to even take a position say [22:55] when it comes to Palestinians? [22:58] >> Of course. Of course, we had um we as [23:01] Lebanese people and many people don't [23:04] even understand this that the Lebanese [23:06] people and especially the Christians and [23:09] also the Shia of southern Lebanon, [23:12] we had very brutal [23:17] brutal history with Palestinians in [23:19] Lebanon. Brutal history. The civil war [23:22] started because of the Palestinians who [23:25] was armed in Lebanon and again acted as [23:28] a country within a country fighting not [23:31] only Israel, they fought Lebanese as [23:33] well. Back then, Arafat he said very [23:37] clearly the way to Jerusalem pass [23:40] through Jun which was a Christian t. [23:44] What does it mean? What does it mean? [23:47] And again in southern Lebanon, the PLO [23:50] kidnapped, raped, killed people from my [23:54] village. I have people telling me [23:56] stories from the 70s and 80s where [23:59] people went to, you know, their land and [24:02] never came back to the village where the [24:04] PLO came to our village to [24:08] hid into a church in order to be able to [24:11] fight Israel from our churches. [24:14] You know, people don't know this. So, of [24:16] course, it's very hard. It's the trauma. [24:18] It's the um it's the relations that, you [24:21] know, no one ever uh say, "I'm sorry." [24:24] No one ever from the Palestinians say, [24:26] "I take responsibility for what happened [24:28] in Lebanon." Just like everything [24:30] happens in the Middle East. We just put [24:32] everything under a rug. we sign an [24:34] agreement and you know [24:38] >> so for you it you live in this very [24:41] small community in Israel but obviously [24:43] fiercely supportive I would say of the [24:46] actions of the IDF and and the state in [24:49] these battles that you share which is [24:51] against terrorism against specifically [24:55] different forms of Islamic terrorism um [24:57] and you're not from a Muslim background [25:00] uh does it make it difficult for you in [25:02] terms of relations with Islam, with [25:04] Muslims. Um, you've said that you got on [25:06] very well with Jews. How has it been [25:08] with Islam? [25:09] >> I have a lot of Muslim friends. I don't [25:12] think that the problem is religion. I [25:15] think the problem is extremists in a [25:18] religion. So, I I'm not against Islam. [25:22] I'm not against Muslim people. I'm [25:23] against Islamists and people that have a [25:26] very clear ideology that it's either [25:30] them [25:31] or we all are going to die. This is my [25:35] point of view and I'm very clear about [25:37] it and I'm not afraid to say it out [25:38] loud. If I am choosing my friends, I [25:41] want my friends and I want my allies to [25:43] have the same values. we can speak in [25:46] different values and then you know and [25:49] this is what happens in many cases here [25:51] between Israel and Palestinians that [25:54] there is an agreement that is signed but [25:56] then one part with a specific ideology [26:01] it's like oh we signed this agreement [26:04] but no for us the ideology is above [26:07] everything this is this is us we can [26:10] have a terrorist organization killing [26:12] civilians even though we had an [26:14] agreement [26:15] with a certain state you know so you [26:18] can't have relations here without having [26:21] the same values and without having basic [26:24] understandings and this is something we [26:26] are struggling with here so this is a [26:29] struggle I'm having with um Islamists [26:33] let's say not Muslims [26:35] >> where do you feel other than Israel [26:37] where Muslims and Christians and Jews [26:40] can live together effectively where do [26:42] you think um that's worked out for [26:44] Christians like yourself and [26:46] non-Islamist Muslims, which other [26:48] countries has it worked in? [26:49] >> Okay, so fun fact, I grew up obviously [26:51] in Israel with this very complex [26:53] background. Um, of course, you grow up, [26:56] you have a lot of um, you know, [26:58] stereotypes about Muslims even though I [27:02] have Muslim neighbors, you know, uh, but [27:05] however, you just grow surrounded by [27:08] many narratives that is very hard to [27:10] break uh, in many cases. And then the [27:14] Abraham Accords happened which opened [27:18] our world in Israel to a a completely [27:22] new region which is the Middle East but [27:24] it's the other side of the Middle East. [27:26] So the Emirates and Bahrain and I was [27:30] very honored to meet Bahraini people [27:32] first uh when the peace agreement uh [27:36] were signed and I discovered [27:41] kind of like I was like oh my god this [27:44] is moderate Islam that we don't have in [27:47] in in our region because we only hear [27:49] the extremist Islam here and these [27:52] people we have the same values. my best [27:54] friend Fatimal Harbish is an incredible [27:57] peace activist that we have almost [28:01] identical background and values even [28:04] though she's very Bahraini Arab Muslim [28:07] woman and I'm very Christian Lebanese [28:10] Israeli you know Middle Eastern woman [28:13] it's you can never you know you can [28:16] never see this so yeah when I went to [28:18] the Emirates and to Bahrain I saw a [28:21] beautiful leadership of moderate [28:24] um Islam that not only celebrate their [28:27] tradition but they have values of [28:30] respecting other. I saw churches in [28:33] Bahrain and I was shocked. I saw a [28:35] synagogue in the main uh market of [28:39] Bahrain. Again, never imagined this. Abu [28:42] Dhabi, the people there are incredible [28:45] and they actually managed to, you know, [28:47] have both tradition and their religion, [28:51] but also they are very modern. They are [28:53] very open. It's beautiful. So, it can [28:57] happen. It can happen. And in a way [29:00] that's what the Abraham Accords um [29:03] really brought about or or recognized [29:05] which is a new Middle East. A Middle [29:07] East where um Muslim Arab countries can [29:12] imagine [29:14] the existence of a Jewish state can [29:16] imagine the presence of Jews in the [29:18] Middle East and that has changed [29:19] everything not just for Israel and for [29:21] Jews but also for you as a Christian. [29:23] >> Exactly. And also for the I feel like [29:25] also for the Sunni world, you know, I [29:28] feel like Muslims in Lebanon, like [29:30] especially Sunni, they are like, [29:33] "Wait a minute." Like they are having an [29:38] agreement with Israel, we want an [29:40] agreement as well. like why Lebanon [29:42] should be in a war zone while other [29:45] countries have an agreement with Israel [29:48] which was a taboo before as we spoke and [29:52] and I want the same. I want what I care [29:56] about now and and I think this is anyone [29:59] in the Middle East. This is the the [30:01] thought. We want prosperity. We want [30:04] stability. We've been through so many [30:06] wars. We are really tired. And then we [30:09] see the agreements and their really [30:12] positive impact and effect on the [30:15] region. And we want this. So yeah, we [30:20] need leaders that are, you know, able to [30:22] take us there toward sustainable [30:25] agreements, peace agreements and [30:26] solutions on the ground. [30:28] >> You became very well known on the [30:30] internet for expressing these sorts of [30:33] views in Arabic. Um, who's your main [30:35] audience and how did you really start [30:37] doing that? How did it come about that [30:38] you became this powerful voice? [30:42] >> So I'm a Middle Eastern. I'm an Arabic [30:44] speaker. So obviously my audience are [30:46] Arabs around me, Middle Easterns, um, [30:50] Lebanese people, my people. Uh, from a [30:53] very young age, I had this literally [30:56] fire inside of me to get out everything [30:59] I said now. Like I wanted to be part of [31:02] the Middle East. I want Christianity to [31:05] be part of the Middle East. I want my [31:06] story and my father's story and my [31:08] community story to be part of history. [31:12] And I wanted justice for us that we [31:15] fought for our land against terrorism [31:18] and all of this. You know, when you grow [31:21] grow up in an era of social media, the [31:24] the very natural way was to go to social [31:29] media uh of course to content creation. [31:32] And the first video I posted online was [31:36] Roshan Nikra from the Israeli side using [31:39] Israel in Arabic saying from the Israeli [31:42] side. And I think for the Arab world, a [31:45] Lebanese girl, that's saying very [31:48] proudly, I'm a Lebanese in Israel. It [31:52] was not only shocking, but it was also [31:54] very intriguing and it created all kind [31:58] of, you know, emotions and I found my [32:00] niche because this is exactly what I [32:02] wanted to do and this is exactly what I [32:04] share. very authentic, very me uh [32:07] cultural content, religious content, [32:09] stories that we don't hear in the Middle [32:12] East because the extremist voices are [32:15] taking our voices and and it's important [32:18] for me to reinforce the moderate voices, [32:22] the stories that no one heard about, [32:24] just like my story. [32:25] >> And what was the reaction then from from [32:27] the Arabic speaking world? Was it all [32:28] positive? [32:29] >> Wow. Like the first couple years, it was [32:32] before even the war. Imagine like it was [32:34] 6 years ago. Um I think at first most of [32:39] the comments were so negative that [32:42] people were worried about me. They were [32:43] like you don't care about what they are [32:45] writing you like they are writing really [32:47] horrible things [32:49] and and even my family which always [32:52] supported me obviously but they were [32:53] like but but you know like [32:57] you know you hear all these really bad [32:59] words and and our community even they [33:02] were calling my my mom they were like [33:04] please tell her to stop because people [33:06] are cursing us [33:09] and I didn't stop because I was like I'm [33:11] not doing anything bad this This is this [33:13] is me. We we need people [33:17] that are able to change the narrative. [33:20] And I wanted to be this person so badly. [33:23] And I'm happy to say that now what I [33:26] hear are people saying to me, thank you [33:29] for your courage. We need that. We need [33:31] this courage and we need this hope. And [33:34] it just like this one person allow other [33:37] persons other people to have the courage [33:40] and to know that they are not alone in [33:43] their thoughts. [33:44] >> Arabic speakers in in the Middle East [33:47] but also elsewhere in the world are [33:48] watching. [33:49] >> Of course diaspora I mean there are more [33:51] Lebanese diaspora in outside of Lebanon [33:55] than in Lebanon itself. And of course, [33:58] you know, um when you speak in Arabic, [34:01] every Arab person can understand your [34:03] video. So, I'm happy to say that I'm [34:06] very viral across the Middle East. And [34:09] again, not only my voice, but other very [34:11] courageous people that since the 7th of [34:13] October are not afraid to speak up in [34:16] Arabic to change the narrative we were [34:18] stuck into for many long. [34:20] >> So, it's great. It's not just private [34:21] messages to you. There are actually [34:23] other people speaking out as well. [34:24] >> Yes, the comments. You can see the [34:26] comments. people, Lebanese people like [34:28] expressing their um you know their their [34:31] desire to peace and you know asking [34:34] questions about Israel. You need to [34:36] understand that in the Arab world we [34:38] never had any content about Israel that [34:42] wasn't negative or only about the war. [34:46] So for a person to watch a video, an [34:49] Arab person to see me, a Christian [34:53] Lebanese woman going to work in Tel [34:56] Aviv, this is mindblowing. People were [34:58] like, "What do you do?" Like like, "Do [35:00] you have Jewish friends? Like, do they [35:03] do you can you speak Arabic in Israel?" [35:05] If people don't don't really know [35:07] anything. So it's it's great. It's [35:09] amazing to be this voice and to show a [35:12] different point of view and to show [35:14] other people that it's actually possible [35:16] that we're all the same at the end of [35:19] the day. [35:20] >> And does it work the other way around? I [35:22] mean, are Israelis generally speaking uh [35:25] able to see Lebanon and Lebanese is [35:28] anything other than [35:29] >> Look, it depends. Obviously the younger [35:32] generation that consume [35:34] um [35:37] the press here and also social media is [35:39] very negative and after the 7th of [35:41] October I feel like Israelis really lost [35:44] faith in peace or in Arabs. Uh they [35:49] obviously we are all post-traumatic. We [35:52] went through one of the most horrible [35:54] events and what comes after obviously [35:57] with the no support at all from anyone. [36:02] It I think it shattered the the the [36:05] Israelis. So we are still handling this [36:08] event. So I feel like it's very hard for [36:11] them still to see the the light at the [36:15] end of the tunnel. But this is why my [36:17] work is also speaking to Israelis and [36:21] exposing the voice the voices on the [36:23] other side, the moderate voices, the [36:25] voices that actually want peace and to [36:27] say that the majority of Lebanese are [36:30] not Hezbollah. Hezbollah are the extreme [36:32] actually and they don't represent the [36:35] majority. So it's important for me. I'm [36:38] I'm kind of the bridge between these two [36:40] sides. So it works both ways, [36:43] >> right? So it's not just like being an [36:44] ambassador for Israel uh and and Jews [36:47] towards Arabic speaking people in [36:50] Lebanon and elsewhere. It's actually the [36:52] other way around as well. You're kind of [36:53] helping Israelis to understand that [36:56] there is, you know, even beyond their [36:58] this generation's memory. There is [37:00] something there. [37:01] >> Of course, we all need hope like both [37:03] sides, the the Lebanese or Arabs and the [37:07] Arabs of the Middle East and also [37:09] Israelis. Of course there are we we went [37:12] through years of you know no one knows [37:14] anything about the other. So people like [37:17] me and others we are doing this. We are [37:20] the bridges between these two people. [37:22] And and yet it must be quite frustrating [37:25] that outside of the Middle East there is [37:28] I think a growing perception certainly [37:31] on the street in some places and and [37:33] even at government level that Israel is [37:35] kind of a a deliberate warloving [37:37] belligerent state when in actual fact [37:39] from what you're telling me and what I [37:41] know peace in the Middle East has [37:43] actually been made more viable [37:46] especially with Lebanon between Lebanon [37:47] and Israel because of Israel's [37:50] willingness to fight against these [37:52] terrorist forces. And similarly, that's [37:55] what happened with the Abraham Accords. [37:56] It's the strength of Israel that has [37:58] enabled it to make peace and to [38:00] demonstrate its commitment to peace. But [38:03] that is not the perception outside of [38:05] the Middle East, is it? [38:07] >> Exactly what I said before. You know, [38:08] when you grow up and I I understand it, [38:11] you know, when you grow up in Europe or [38:13] in the USA, you don't really understand [38:16] the nuances and the complexity of Israel [38:20] or the Middle East. So of course you [38:22] don't understand this like I I grew up [38:24] in Israel and and from a very young age [38:26] I remember and I'm sure you know this as [38:28] well that every mother say to its son [38:32] that when you grow up there will be no [38:34] army you don't need to go to the IDF [38:38] and people don't understand that this is [38:40] the mentality of Israelis this is the [38:42] the mentality of the Jewish people they [38:44] are you know even though they are very [38:48] hated in the Middle East and [38:51] people think it's legitimate to fight [38:53] them, to kill them, um um to call for [38:58] the elimination of their state. They are [39:01] still here fighting, but also they are [39:04] able to say, I am I want peace and they [39:08] are able to actually make peace and sign [39:12] peace agreements. So I don't think [39:15] people outside of Israel or the region [39:19] can actually understand this. [39:21] >> And that's fair. I think you know if if [39:22] one believed the perception and the the [39:26] interpretation that's pushed so often [39:28] like for example in the UK then you [39:30] would have a similarly terrible or [39:32] negative opinion of Israel and its [39:33] actions. But why what is the reason? I [39:36] mean they it's not like it's too complex [39:38] for people to understand. There are [39:39] people on the streets of London every [39:41] few weeks in their many thousands who [39:43] seem to believe they understand the [39:45] micro details of Palestinian leadership [39:48] or life in in the Gaza Strip. They they [39:50] have the capacity to try and understand [39:52] what's what's caused this [39:54] misapprehension, misunderstanding, this [39:57] sort of tissue of lies really that's [39:59] allowed so much of the West to have been [40:01] told something you know personally to be [40:04] the opposite of the truth. I feel like a [40:07] big part of of why um Europeans or the [40:11] West perceive Israel as they do is [40:13] because of social media. I mean I feel [40:15] like um the more you are hateful toward [40:19] the stronger part, [40:22] the more heroic you are because you are [40:25] standing with the weak people even if [40:28] you don't understand really what's going [40:31] on between these two people. So I feel [40:33] like social media for sure and [40:37] unfortunately again the press the press [40:40] that is you know pushing the negative [40:42] stories all the time. It pushes the um [40:46] the narrative of [40:49] Israel as a state that wants war. And I [40:52] didn't read almost about the suffer of [40:54] the Israeli people that I'm one of them [40:58] that went through trauma and I could be [41:02] one who, you know, was kidnapped from a [41:04] Nova festival. I wasn't at the festival, [41:06] but this was this is something that I [41:09] would totally be at, you know. So this [41:11] lack of empathy toward Israel and maybe [41:14] even the Jewish people, I think it's [41:16] something that unfortunately very rooted [41:18] also in the mentality of people uh to [41:22] just be anti-Jews [41:24] for a reason. This is the the you know [41:26] the roots of anti-semitism. It's very [41:29] sad. It's very sad that we don't hear [41:31] more voices of young people saying you [41:34] can criticize a country but hating on a [41:37] religion or hating on people [41:39] especially if they are not part of this [41:42] country it's just wrong and we are [41:46] losing this all around the world in my [41:48] opinion this this you know ability of um [41:52] healthy criticism [41:54] >> on the other hand is there any hard [41:56] feeling or disappointment on your part [41:59] or or your community's part towards [42:01] Israel for its actions in southern [42:03] Lebanon for example with the withdrawal [42:05] as you said suddenly or any other [42:07] actions that have actually you know not [42:10] to be too harsh but to say actually this [42:12] hasn't helped [42:13] >> look yes of course like I can you know I [42:17] can argue a lot of the uh decisions that [42:20] are um that the government is taking and [42:23] I don't agree on everything and I have a [42:25] lot of things to say but I'm also [42:28] realistic like I'm not a um army person [42:33] so I don't know what's going on military [42:35] wise and I'm not a politician. I don't [42:38] know what's going on political political [42:41] wise you know and I understand that a [42:43] lot of information I don't even get it. [42:46] So realistically I disagree on many [42:49] things and I can share my thoughts as [42:51] well but I don't really know what's [42:54] going on on the ground. I just hope and [42:59] I know that Israel's first goal is to [43:03] eliminate Hezbollah and I'm sure that [43:06] after this the benefit of everyone and [43:10] the the second goal would be to go into [43:12] a peace agreement. So this is what I'm [43:14] pushing from my point as a social [43:16] activist. You know hopefully one day [43:18] I'll be a politician and then maybe I [43:21] can have more, you know, power. But I [43:24] mean, you strongly believe that that the [43:26] for example that the anti-resbollah [43:28] feeling in Lebanon would translate into [43:32] pro peace or pro- Israel. [43:34] >> 100%. Yes. Yes. We we are seeing this on [43:38] the ground like the press in Lebanon, [43:40] the the public opinion. Um again, not [43:45] everyone loves Israel and it's totally [43:47] fine. You know you can't eliminate an [43:49] ideology of years in two three years but [43:54] the majority have a strong feeling that [43:57] is anti-hebah [43:59] and that is like I want peace just for [44:02] stability. I want stability. So, you [44:05] know, there are many reasons for people [44:07] to want peace and to be anti-war. And of [44:11] course, again, realistically, of course, [44:13] Lebanese people are very angry at the [44:16] war and very angry at many of Israel's [44:18] decisions to attack some places. And, [44:22] you know, it's a mess. War is a mess. [44:26] But how again, how can you fight a [44:28] terrorist organization that doesn't want [44:30] to disarm? [44:32] So and at the end of the day I feel the [44:36] the hope and wish of everyone is not to [44:39] go through another war because we are [44:42] already suffering. So at least [44:45] we all hope it's the last time we will [44:47] suffer this. And when it comes to [44:49] Christian life in Israel, again, I think [44:51] that there's a a widespread [44:53] misconception in parts of Europe and the [44:56] West that Christians are massively [44:59] persecuted by Israel, that Christian [45:01] life is not respected, Christian [45:03] worship. Well, you I mean, that's it. [45:04] you you laugh at it, but it's it's we [45:08] had we've had the Archbishop of [45:10] Canterbury visit uh in the last few [45:13] months and pose with people who had [45:15] connections to Palestinian terrorism and [45:18] talk about the persecution of Christians [45:20] in the Holy Land by Israel and the Jews. [45:24] Does that you know, you're shaking your [45:25] head. Tell me what [45:26] >> persecution. Seriously, like of course [45:29] there are problems, there are issues. [45:31] The biggest one to me is the fact that [45:35] there are Jewish extremists that spit on [45:39] Christians in Jerusalem even though they [45:42] are you know the law is very um um [45:46] strong against them and the police and [45:49] the you know the the um security forces [45:53] are doing everything to fight this. [45:56] But to say there is a persecution here [46:00] is just to literally be blind to what is [46:03] actually going on in Israel. Like people [46:06] can go and pray. I go and pray. I walk [46:08] around with my cross very proudly. Not [46:11] only in Tel Aviv, in every part of this [46:14] country. We have churches. We have [46:16] communities that are actually [46:18] prospering. you know Christians in [46:20] Israel although we are 2% of the [46:23] population but economical wise [46:26] economically wise social wise education [46:29] wise we are the highest [46:32] in all categories you know where can you [46:36] find another places where minority can [46:39] actually prosper and have you know go to [46:43] university and have businesses and be a [46:47] very high quality equality minority in a [46:51] country especially in the Middle East [46:53] like the Christians in Israel. So I'm [46:55] sorry saying they are persecuted. Okay, [46:58] show us where like literally show us [47:01] where so we can speak against it and we [47:04] can you know work to change it. But [47:08] saying this is just it's it's nonsense [47:11] and and [47:13] it's disappointing to me as Christian. [47:15] And when you've seen images like that [47:17] one that went around the world, you [47:18] know, of the Israeli troops who who [47:20] desecrated the statue of Mary in [47:22] southern Lebanon, for example, [47:23] >> it was in my village. [47:24] >> Yeah, [47:25] >> it was in my village. Again, there is [47:30] racism in every country and in every [47:33] population. And there is one soldier [47:37] that thought that it's fine to do this. [47:40] And guess what? He was punished. And [47:44] even the prime minister Benjamin [47:46] Netanyahu went on and apologized and [47:50] other people other Jewish people that [47:53] actually spoke up against it. And as a [47:55] person as Christian who grew up within [47:58] the Jewish not only community but [48:00] literally having Jewish friends, I know [48:03] that this does not represent Judaism in [48:05] any way. So yes, it's sad that there are [48:10] people that think it's okay to do this, [48:13] but I don't think it represent the [48:16] majority. And I think it's [48:18] individualistic [48:20] uh behavior that again does not [48:22] represent any values of Jewish people or [48:25] Judaism or any Israeli. [48:27] >> It's not something that you've [48:28] experienced personally in your [48:30] day-to-day life. [48:31] >> No, I never experienced this. No, no, [48:34] no, no, no. And again, because you're, [48:36] you know, part of what you do publicly [48:38] is is to shatter these myths around the [48:40] world. As somebody with proper direct [48:43] experience of it yourself, [48:45] sort of what do you say to these other [48:48] allegations that are so popular of of [48:51] apartheid or of inequality on a massive [48:55] institutionalized scale in Israel? Are [48:59] they all wrong? [49:00] Look, there is a very easy usage of very [49:04] complex um words like calling Israel an [49:08] apartheid is not only a mistake, it's [49:12] just not correct on any [49:16] anyway. I just went two days ago and I [49:20] voted in the elections and I can run to [49:24] elections. Actually, I ran for my [49:26] municipality elections couple years ago. [49:30] So, [49:32] having the rights of any Israeli here, [49:36] we all have it. I live it in my daily [49:38] life. I live in a democra democratic [49:40] country. I have rights. So, saying that [49:43] it's an apartheid is really it's not [49:46] only far from reality. It has nothing to [49:48] do with reality. If people want to [49:51] criticize something specifically, then I [49:53] can maybe answer that. But I never [49:55] answered to this apartheid [49:58] allegations because it really doesn't [49:59] make sense to me. [50:00] >> In actual fact, Israel probably maybe I [50:04] would be right to say the best state in [50:07] the Middle East for let's say an Arab [50:10] Muslim woman in terms of her education [50:12] and freedoms and rights. [50:13] >> Yeah. Yeah. It look it goes back to [50:16] culture. Like there are many places here [50:17] that the man doesn't allow their wives [50:20] to go and study. But of course we have a [50:23] very open societies here. People can go [50:26] and study. You know there are a lot of [50:28] specific programs that are personalized [50:31] to different communities here with the [50:34] thought of the needs of each community [50:37] uh religion wise, social wise, you know. [50:40] So I think this is something very [50:41] beautiful here in Israel. And fun fact [50:44] also I worked at Babilan University as a [50:46] spokesperson and you know being [50:49] Christian I wasn't um um so it wasn't [50:55] compulsory for me to do the um um [51:00] religion studies so I could choose other [51:04] courses because I'm Christian. So you [51:07] know I I again I people don't understand [51:11] how this country is very very respectful [51:14] toward others and people here from all [51:17] backgrounds have the right and and have [51:21] rights that actually are for their good [51:24] sake. Again racism there is racism [51:27] everywhere. You know, of course, [51:30] last news here that people are afraid to [51:33] hear Arabic in the streets and some [51:34] people were attacked because they speak [51:36] Arabic. So, of course, we have racism [51:38] and we have a lot of issues we need to [51:40] take care as a state, but again, there [51:43] is a far distance between saying [51:46] apartheid to what's actually going on on [51:49] the ground. [51:51] So, I think it would be fair to say that [51:52] you're quite optimistic about the future [51:54] of Israel and and for example with peace [51:57] with Lebanon and and the expansion of [52:01] Arab and Israeli cooperation and [52:04] collaboration. Would that be fair to [52:05] say? [52:05] >> I'm very I'm very optimistic. Yes, I'm [52:08] very optimistic and I'm really hopeful [52:12] that we will see leaders that are able [52:15] to take us there 100%. And how [52:18] optimistic are you when you look outside [52:20] the region to Europe or to America? [52:25] >> Wow. To be honest, [52:27] from what I'm seeing on the news and and [52:30] when I visit there, I feel like [52:35] I feel like there is very deep [52:37] misunderstanding of, you know, what's [52:40] going on there. And [52:43] it terrifies me again. It terrifies me [52:45] when I see what young people think and [52:48] say. It terrifies me. [52:50] >> But do you, as somebody that lived [52:51] through it in Lebanon, look at uh [52:54] demographics or the influence of [52:58] extremist Islam in say the UK or in [53:02] France or in America even? Does it worry [53:04] you because you personally know what [53:07] that can lead to? [53:08] >> Yeah, we lived through it. We lived [53:11] through it in Lebanon. We were Christian [53:13] majority. [53:15] And again, I'm not blaming Islam. I'm [53:18] just, you know, Islamist and wars and [53:22] ideologies in this region are a serious [53:25] thing and you shouldn't be um lightaded [53:29] when you handle these type of issues. [53:32] And when I see a lot of similar things [53:35] that are happening currently in Europe, [53:37] this is something that is very [53:38] concerning to me. And I really hope that [53:42] the leadership in Europe will wake up [53:45] and understand where is the limit [53:49] between not only democracy but freedom [53:52] of speech to ideology and Islamism [53:56] again. But when I think about it, you [53:58] know, I I did a debate in Oxford uh not [54:01] that long ago and on the other side was [54:03] Sir Jacob Reese Moog who's a veteran [54:06] politician uh very Catholic and he uh we [54:09] were debating suspicion of Islam and his [54:12] argument to paraphrase it was that [54:14] Britain doesn't need to be suspicious of [54:16] Islam even extremism it seemed because [54:19] of its strong democratic and Christian [54:21] grounding. uh now you come from [54:23] somewhere where you've seen that a [54:25] strong Christian grounding doesn't in [54:27] and of itself defend but British people [54:29] especially establishment ones like him [54:31] often feel this could not happen here to [54:34] us uh this we are stronger our faith is [54:38] stronger our religion is stronger our [54:40] democracy is stronger what do you say to [54:43] those people who look at Lebanon and and [54:45] Iran as a basket case [54:46] >> you know Lebanese people are the most [54:50] religious people in the world and I'm [54:52] not even exaggerating. And we lost our [54:55] country to Islamists. [54:58] This is this is a fact. It doesn't [55:00] matter how strong your faith is. If you [55:04] don't fight terrorism and extremism in [55:09] your country, you will pay the price at [55:11] some point. And [55:14] we saw it again in the Middle East, but [55:16] I'm sure we will see it in Europe as [55:18] well. And hopefully politicians will [55:21] wake up and [55:24] they will put limits and put laws that [55:28] actually fight again the Islamists or [55:33] the the ideologies that are um happening [55:38] right now or going on right now. I'm not [55:40] I don't want people to think that I'm [55:42] against Muslim people because I'm not [55:44] saying right now that the UK should uh [55:47] you know limit Muslims or whatever. No, [55:50] I'm with freedom of religion and and I [55:53] do believe that Islam in general [55:57] has beautiful values. I'm saying that [56:00] people and politicians should understand [56:03] where is the line between a religion to [56:06] an ideology that is not a religion [56:08] anymore but it's something that actually [56:11] hurt the majority and impose a danger on [56:16] a society. And in a sense, maybe it's [56:18] that democracies often concentrate on on [56:21] the idea of protecting minorities from [56:24] the majority, but they sometimes forget [56:26] that there's a need to protect the [56:27] majority from some minorities. [56:30] >> Yeah. I think that also they like [56:34] these democracies should also notice [56:36] what's going on in Muslim countries that [56:39] are actually prospering. In a Muslim [56:42] country, you can't say whatever you want [56:45] in the mosque. [56:47] there is a very strong [56:50] um uh control over what is said and in [56:54] countries like if I say the Emirates [56:57] they are fighting very fiercely the [57:00] Islamic Brotherhood and any type of [57:02] extremism if they are doing it there [57:06] this should be done in Europe as well [57:08] and in any democracy [57:10] >> what sorts of things do you think we're [57:12] getting wrong say in Britain or in [57:14] Europe in terms of fighting that that [57:16] form of extremism. What? Because of [57:18] course the debate is over freedom, over [57:20] freedom of speech, freedom of religion. [57:22] And so the the obviously terrorism and [57:25] violence, there's a clear line, but when [57:26] you come to like extremism and [57:29] fanaticism, um it's much harder for [57:32] societies like ours to decide where to [57:34] draw that line. Right. [57:35] >> Of course, I feel like again, especially [57:38] maybe in Europe and the USA, that they [57:40] never had a religion or religious wars. [57:44] I feel like they need experts maybe [57:46] from, [57:48] you know, from the the the Muslim world, [57:50] people that actually understand and can [57:52] say, "Okay, this is a religion. This is [57:56] not religion. This is extremism. This is [57:58] an ideology." You know, we should have [58:01] more people that are experts on these [58:03] matters because Europe never faced this [58:06] problem before and now it is and there [58:08] are many people that are able to be [58:10] experts on the matter and actually you [58:13] know help politicians to make better [58:16] decisions to help not only the minority [58:19] but also the majority of the people. So [58:22] we need this we need we need people to [58:25] that understand and are able to say [58:27] where is this line pass. So it's it's [58:32] and to me it's kind of easy you know [58:34] like you need an expert and get help get [58:39] help. [laughter] [58:42] Well, thanks for all you're doing in in [58:43] spreading the word and for for telling [58:45] it as as you've lived it and as you see [58:47] it. I think it's so important and it's [58:49] voices like yours that give us hope that [58:51] we can find ways through it and that we [58:52] can not just coexist or or tolerate but [58:55] actually thrive together and and you [58:57] know build these important important [58:58] relationships and really much respect to [59:01] your bravery for starting to do it and [59:03] and for your determination in continuing [59:05] to. [59:06] >> Thank you so much. Thank you for the [59:08] platform and uh I'm very hopeful and I [59:11] think we all should be hopeful and more [59:13] courageous to say I wouldn't say the [59:16] right things but to educate ourselves [59:19] and to speak rightfully.