Transcript [00:01] Rabbi Yacov Klein, it's such a privilege [00:03] and pleasure to be sitting here with you [00:04] in Jerusalem. Only a few months ago we [00:06] actually met together in London, the [00:08] founding director of Aish Lecha in [00:10] London, really spreading such incredible [00:12] thoughts across the world. And it's [00:14] remarkable that at such a young age, [00:16] you've become such a prolific writer and [00:18] speaker. And thank you so much for all [00:20] you're doing for the world. [00:21] >> My privilege. Thank you for having me. [00:23] >> So, you're a Jewish mystic. And you're [00:25] part of an interesting genre. And that [00:27] word even makes us feel a little bit [00:29] uncomfortable sometimes. What is [00:31] mysticism? [00:32] >> Well, it's an excellent question. [00:33] Personally, I wouldn't classify myself [00:34] as a Jewish mystic. I would say that's a [00:36] bit of a mistake. Mystic, mistake. [00:39] Um don't know. Not a Jewish mystic. [00:41] Th- th- th- In order to understand what [00:43] mysticism is, we have to go back to the [00:45] root of the English word, [00:47] um which is mystery. [00:50] And the word mystery really comes from [00:51] the Hebrew word mistar. [00:54] Right, mistar is that which is hidden. [00:59] Jewish mysticism is a science [01:02] of how to engage with life [01:04] in such a way that we're able to look [01:05] beyond the surface of things and to be [01:08] able to intuit and to connect to and to [01:10] channel [01:11] something deeper, something beyond the [01:13] surface. In that sense, I'm a I'm a [01:15] mystic cuz I hope to be plugged into the [01:17] mystery of life. I'm not in any way an [01:19] expert in in in Kabbalah. I'm not a [01:21] Kabbalist. I'm not a I'm just a Jew. In [01:24] that sense, I think every Jew is a [01:25] mystic because the essence of what it [01:27] means to be a Jew [01:28] is [01:30] to learn, [01:31] guided by the principles of the Torah, [01:34] how to live life [01:36] in an immersive framework of [01:37] consciousness that we call Jewish law, [01:39] Jewish commandments, Jewish culture, [01:41] Jewish thought [01:44] in all areas of the Torah. So, in that [01:45] sense, [01:47] you cannot be a Jew and not be a a [01:49] mystic from that sense because it means [01:51] you're plugged in that place of the of [01:53] the mystery of the mistar of the hester [01:56] of that layer of reality that's beyond [01:57] what the eyes can see where all you see [01:59] everywhere you turn is an opportunity to [02:01] connect to the creator of the world. [02:03] >> So, if a mystic is the person that can [02:05] plug into the mystery and the nistar and [02:07] the hiddenness, [02:09] um [02:09] from my understanding, you weren't [02:10] always like this. When did the journey [02:12] begin? How did it begin? What brought [02:14] you into this type of Torah, this type [02:16] of framework? [02:17] >> Excellent question. I appreciate also, [02:19] thank you for having me. It's a [02:20] privilege to be here. [02:21] Um [02:24] a part of the fundamental [02:27] sort of framework of of of mysticism [02:30] understood in this way of of nistar, [02:31] being able to look at at that which is [02:33] deeper, precludes the [02:37] relevance really of the word potential [02:39] um in any context. [02:42] Because potential means that something [02:43] is a certain way that it how it is now, [02:46] and that maybe sometime in the future it [02:47] will become something else. [02:50] People describe, let's say, teachers or [02:52] parents describe like a child, you know, [02:53] has a lot of potential. What does that [02:55] mean? Means that right now [02:57] nothing. Maybe one day, if he gets [02:59] lucky, somehow something will will come [03:01] from him. [03:02] And and and that means that a person is [03:04] looking at the world or that child not [03:06] with the eyes of a of a mystic, cuz [03:08] you're only seeing the outside. [03:10] The way that a mystic would look at it [03:12] is to recognize, no, no, he has [03:14] greatness in him now. Like he's great. [03:17] He's fundamentally great. And the [03:18] question is only a question of revealing [03:21] that. So, it's not transforming into [03:23] something else, just revealing it. You [03:25] know, so from that standpoint, I was I [03:26] was always this way. You know, [03:28] I always I always had this inside of me. [03:30] I was searching for God, really [03:32] searching for an intimate connection [03:34] with God, [03:35] my whole life. [03:36] And part of the frustration was that [03:38] just like every human being has a body [03:40] and a soul, the whole world has a has [03:42] has like a body, has the physical [03:44] element, and then there's the spiritual [03:45] energy behind it, beyond that. [03:48] Torah has a body and a soul. [03:51] And sometimes, because we seek to [03:53] preserve the tradition of what it means [03:56] to be a halachic um [03:58] Torah-oriented Jew, who's really living [04:01] in accordance with what's revealed in [04:02] both the written Torah and the oral [04:04] Torah and codified in Halakha. [04:07] Sometimes what can happen [04:08] is that we attach ourselves to the body [04:11] of Torah, which is essentially the what [04:12] to do, where to do it, when to do it, [04:15] how to do it. [04:16] And sometimes what can get lost in the [04:19] process is the why. [04:21] The why is the soul. [04:24] Because why animates the what, where, [04:27] how, and when to the extent that a [04:28] person has a strong why, which is a [04:30] fundamental principle of Kabbalah, that [04:32] the whole system of the way that God [04:34] reveals himself in the world called the [04:36] 10 Sefirot, 10 Sefirot, begins with [04:39] Keter, which correlates to will, [04:41] correlates to why. It means crown, but [04:43] it's connected to the concept of God's [04:45] motivation to create the world. If we [04:46] don't have a why, it can't begin. [04:49] But sometimes [04:50] what can happen is that sort of the body [04:52] takes over. [04:53] And so what I felt growing up in a in a [04:55] in a very religious community [04:58] was that institutionally there was a [05:01] a bit of an imbalance toward the side of [05:03] what's called in Kabbalah and Jewish [05:05] mysticism the the vessels or the or the [05:08] body, which are the receptacles for [05:10] what's supposed to then be saturated [05:13] with an experience of godliness and an [05:15] encounter with the divine. But sometimes [05:17] because we're so careful that we should [05:18] protect and preserve that sort of [05:21] traditional body of Judaism [05:24] sometimes the soul can get lost. And so [05:26] what I was searching for from a young [05:28] age is is the why. It's the big picture. [05:32] Judaism is a puzzle. There are so many [05:33] different pieces, but if we never look [05:35] at the puzzle box and see what the [05:37] picture is supposed to be, you have no [05:39] idea how like what like what's what's [05:41] this whole for? [05:42] Why am I here? Don't tell me that now [05:44] Okay, now you're in the world, so here's [05:46] what to do. I want to know why I came in [05:48] the world in the first place. And so I [05:50] was searching and searching and [05:51] searching. It's a whole long story. I'm [05:53] not going to go into every single [05:54] detail. Um but from a very alienated [05:56] place [05:58] having really disregarded this whole [06:00] experience as [06:02] shallow [06:03] and and and surface level and just not [06:06] relatable, not relevant. [06:08] I had the great privilege of a really [06:10] stumbling upon uh the world of Hasidus, [06:13] the world of [06:14] more broadly Jewish mysticism, and [06:16] specifically through the path of Hasidic [06:18] masters, [06:20] who were intent on bringing the soul [06:23] back into Judaism. [06:25] They didn't intend to do away with any [06:27] of the uh halakhic vessels, but they [06:29] sought to reveal to us how those vessels [06:32] were intended to be an immersive um [06:34] program [06:36] of consciousness. [06:37] >> Was there a person? Was there a moment? [06:39] Was there something that brought you [06:41] through that, or did you just come to it [06:42] on your own? [06:43] >> It's a It's a little bit of a longer [06:44] story. [06:46] The entry for me [06:47] was walking into [06:50] a lecture that was being given in [06:51] Yiddish, which also happens to be. So, [06:53] interestingly enough, I don't speak a [06:55] word of Yiddish, but I could understand [06:56] it. Uh because I went to a uh Hasidic [06:59] Hasidic um [07:01] cheder, [07:02] day school, when I was very young. [07:04] >> [snorts] [07:04] >> And tells you a little bit about the [07:05] nature of the day school that I I I only [07:07] understand it, but I can't speak a word [07:08] cuz we weren't [07:10] We weren't allowed to speak. We were [07:11] allowed to listen. So, I can't speak a [07:13] word of Yiddish, but I understand it, [07:14] and [07:15] I walked in, and [07:17] and the person was speaking about Purim, [07:19] about the Megillah. [07:21] And the whole story of Purim, many of us [07:23] are familiar with Haman and and and and [07:25] and threatening the whole Jewish people [07:27] and and and Esther and Mordecai and the [07:28] whole thing. [07:29] So, I know the story. It's part of my [07:31] whole life, reading the Megillah. [07:34] But the way that he was speaking [07:37] about the Megillah, [07:39] through the prism of the of the [07:40] teachings of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, a [07:42] great grandson of the Baal Shem Tov, the [07:43] founder of Hasidus, [07:45] who himself remains one of the most [07:47] original and impactful um Hasidic [07:49] masters in in the whole corpus of of the [07:51] Hasidic tradition, [07:54] I I had never heard anybody speak about [07:56] the Megillah in this way. [07:58] The relevance, the depth, [08:01] the way that it's not a commemoration of [08:02] a story that happened thousands of years [08:04] ago, but that each year anew those [08:06] lights that were revealed to that [08:07] original Purim are available to each and [08:09] every Jewish soul in and of our own [08:11] lives. So, what Mordecai means to me, [08:13] and what Esther means to me, and who [08:15] Haman is inside of me. [08:17] And what it means to to to find, [08:19] [snorts] like the sages say, a person [08:21] should drink until they get to a point [08:23] where they can actually say baruch [08:24] Haman, they can say that Haman should be [08:26] blessed. It's a counterintuitive thing. [08:29] But that means that we can get to a [08:31] level of faith that's beyond the [08:33] intellect, beyond our rational mind, [08:35] where a person's able to come to the [08:36] realization retroactively that all the [08:38] Hamans in my life, all the difficulties, [08:40] all the troubles, I can I can turn to [08:42] them and I can bless them. And I can say [08:44] that I can't imagine me getting where I [08:46] am now if I hadn't gone through it. And [08:48] so on and so forth. This was a whole [08:49] different megillah. [08:51] And so from there, my eyes really became [08:53] open. There's a lot of other details [08:54] along the way, which I'm leaving out. Um [08:57] but that that began my love affair, my [08:58] lifelong love affair, until now at [09:00] least, and I hope that it will continue [09:02] with this Rabbi Nachman of Breslov and [09:04] his primary disciple, Rabbi Nosson of [09:06] Nemirov. [09:06] >> So, should all Jews be mystics? Should [09:08] they all be exposed to connected to and [09:10] tapped into this type of Torah? [09:12] >> I believe that all Jews are mystics [09:13] already. If we're defining it as people [09:15] who are plugged into nistar, right, into [09:17] Esther, into the mystery, right? [09:20] So, I think I think that's what it means [09:22] to be a Jew in the first place. [09:24] But, from the standpoint of mysticism, I [09:27] believe that some people have that [09:28] element more revealed. [09:30] And some people, that [09:32] concealment-seeking [09:34] element within their Jewishness is [09:37] itself concealed. [09:38] >> But they should or try to reveal it [09:39] more, they should tap into it more? [09:41] >> Absolutely. Absolutely. [09:42] Across the board. Who doesn't need this? [09:45] Everybody's looking for more meaning. [09:46] Everybody's wandering the world. We have [09:48] access to every kind of of of [09:50] entertainment and and and every kind of [09:53] of of information. So, we have it all on [09:55] our fingertips, we can do everything. [09:57] And people are looking for a why. They [09:59] want to be a part of a cosmic story. [10:02] They want to know that they matter. The [10:03] one thing that our generation I find is [10:05] struggling with more than anything is [10:07] self-worth. [10:08] Our teenagers are walking around, [10:10] they're insecure. I just mentioned that [10:12] on a podcast earlier today somewhere [10:13] somewhere else. [10:15] And the whole thing is crazy because I [10:16] see I am and I teach in high schools, I [10:18] see that [10:19] this one is trying to get validation [10:21] from from the other person and their [10:23] whole self-worth is contingent upon the [10:25] validation that that person's giving. [10:26] What they don't realize is that person [10:28] is getting their whole self-worth and [10:30] validation from this other person. And [10:32] so you have is two insecure people that [10:35] you understand it's it's crazy. Where [10:37] should self-worth come from? [10:39] Mystic, mystery, mister hester, the [10:41] greatness that's inside. [10:44] The greatness that's inside comes from [10:45] the collective soul of the Jewish [10:47] nation. [10:48] Judaism is not a culture, it's not an [10:49] ethnicity, it's not a religion. [10:52] It's a collective spirit that has come [10:54] down consistently into various bodies [10:56] all throughout the world throughout [10:57] 2,000 years of exile to move the world [11:00] forward to a state of redemption. [11:02] That's our greatness. It's innate. [11:04] And so if every Jew was plugged into [11:06] that greatness, [11:08] they wouldn't struggle with self-worth. [11:09] God is breathing a soul into you every [11:11] minute. He expects you to do your part [11:14] in bringing the world toward the [11:15] redemption. [11:16] >> So you talk about this God that's [11:18] breathing into us this greatness that we [11:20] can tap into. What is God? How would you [11:22] describe this phenomenon, this entity? [11:24] What what is it? [11:27] >> The truth is we can't say anything about [11:28] it [11:30] because like the Zohar, primary textbook [11:32] of Kabbalah, [11:34] teaches us la smakhshavah t'fisa [11:36] b'khlal. [11:37] That is there is no thought that can [11:39] grasp the divine. Now the water that's [11:41] in the cup can't grasp the outside of [11:43] the cup. It's it's it's something that's [11:45] other than than than our experience. But [11:47] our sages do try to communicate to us in [11:49] various parables in different ways of [11:51] understanding what God is. Many many [11:52] times it's by understanding what God [11:54] isn't. You know, he's not limited and [11:56] he's not he's not uh needy and needy and [11:58] and so on and so forth. And God is just [12:01] But to me the most relatable um [12:03] definition for what this being is [12:06] is brought in the Talmud in the tractate [12:08] of Berakhot which is all about [12:09] blessings. [12:11] Now what are blessings? Just [12:12] parenthetically for a second, a lot of [12:13] people, especially those who grew up in [12:15] a [12:16] observant home, a blessing is some [12:17] liturgy that you murmur and as quickly [12:19] as you possibly can before putting [12:20] something in your mouth. There was a [12:21] rabbi who once said that the speed of [12:23] the blessing is commensurate to how far [12:25] the food is from your mouth. [12:27] So, if you're picking something up from [12:28] the table, you have a little more time. [12:29] If it happens to be up here, you just [12:31] and put it in your mouth. [12:32] >> Very sad. [12:32] >> That's not what it's supposed to be. [12:34] A blessing is a station of [12:36] consciousness. [12:37] It's an opportunity to plug yourself in [12:39] before you engage with the physical [12:41] world to remember this is an opportunity [12:43] to connect to the divine. [12:45] So, in that tractate that's all about [12:47] the blessings, [12:49] our sages teach [12:51] that the same way that our body [12:54] functions in what appears to be a [12:56] fragmented sort of space where this is a [12:58] hand and this is a nose and these are [13:01] ears and and and those are toes and [13:03] and they're all in different places and [13:05] doing different things, but there's a [13:06] soul, [13:08] a singular entity that infuses the whole [13:11] structure and brings it to life and [13:13] animates every single aspect thereby [13:15] uniting all the different facets and [13:17] features. [13:19] What is God? [13:21] God is to the world what our soul is to [13:24] our body. [13:27] >> It animates everything. [13:28] >> It animates [13:30] and it unifies [13:33] all of what appears on the surface to be [13:36] relegated to the realm of duality, [13:38] multiplicity, fragmentation. [13:41] To me, God is the unity. [13:44] The creator, the motivator, [13:47] the the loving being that brought this [13:50] into the world to pursue a relationship [13:52] with every single human or created in in [13:55] his image. [13:57] So, from this standpoint, being a [13:59] mystic, being a Jew, [14:02] a real really to be a Jew, you know, in [14:04] terms of how we're supposed to be, [14:06] how Abraham was and Isaac, Jacob, and so [14:08] on, [14:11] is to develop our [14:13] our sense of perception so that when we [14:16] look at a circumstance or an experience [14:18] or any facet of our journey here in in [14:21] life, [14:22] you don't just see the body. [14:25] You find [14:27] God, which is the soul of that [14:29] experience. [14:30] God [14:31] meaning [14:32] God is love. [14:34] God is our teacher. God is our king. God [14:37] is our father. God is our best friend. [14:41] This is what it means in my humble [14:42] opinion to be a mystic, but it really [14:44] This is what Judaism is. People think [14:45] that mysticism is something divorced [14:48] from the from the Halakha, cuz they [14:50] appear on the surface appears to be no [14:52] two things that are more different, [14:54] right? One is Talmudic dialectics and [14:55] working out the parameters of how many [14:57] hours do I have to wait between eating [14:58] meat and milk and and and and out of [15:01] time I choose and so on. And the other [15:02] thing is mysticism, and I say they're [15:04] literally the same thing. [15:06] Because they're two sides of one coin. [15:08] Because Halakha, [15:10] Jewish law, is nothing other than the [15:14] implementation [15:16] of mystical consciousness. [15:18] So that's filling, [15:20] right? Wrapping wrapping on those those [15:22] boxes of phylacteries every morning on [15:24] my on my arm and on my head is an [15:26] opportunity to bind myself with the [15:28] divine. [15:30] And shaking a lulav on on Sukkot, [15:33] you know how many pages in the in the in [15:35] the [15:35] in the works of the Kabbalist Kabbalah, [15:37] Kabbalah, and that is not doesn't exist [15:39] divorced from the [15:40] Otherwise, it's a flame without a wick. [15:43] Now maybe even more tragic is if you [15:45] have a wick without a flame. [15:47] The key point is [15:50] integration. [15:51] How do I bring together the soul of [15:52] Torah [15:53] with the body of Torah? How do I bring [15:55] together the soul of the world, God, [15:57] with our lived experience of being [16:00] human? This is what the whole purpose of [16:02] Judaism is. [16:03] >> So So then, you know, is that really [16:05] what the purpose of the Jewish people [16:06] are as an embodiment of that? Meaning if [16:08] God is what you described, what's the [16:11] purpose of the Jewish people? To to be [16:12] integrators? Is that our job? [16:14] >> First of all, to be integrators, keep in [16:16] mind that the other two primary [16:19] religions come [16:20] also from the Abrahamic tradition, [16:23] but they come from Abraham and Isaac [16:25] respectively through the son of Abraham, [16:28] is it Ishmael? Ismael? So, that's Islam. [16:32] And the son of [16:33] Isaac is Esau Esau, and from that [16:37] more generally is is Rome Christianity [16:39] and so on. [16:42] And in Jewish mysticism, [16:43] Abraham is the trait of loving kindness [16:46] cuz you see that embodied in it's it's [16:47] all in the Bible, by the way. This is [16:49] all in the text. You see that Abraham is [16:51] a person who's just full of a loving [16:52] kindness. He has a tent that is, you [16:54] know, open is on all four sides that he [16:56] shouldn't have the trouble anybody to [16:57] walk out of the way to get in. Abraham [16:59] is a love. Isaac is severity. [17:02] Isaac allows himself to be tied down on [17:04] the altar. [17:07] Judaism comes neither from Abraham alone [17:11] nor from Isaac alone, [17:13] but from Jacob. [17:16] In Kabbalah, [17:18] J- Jacob is seen as the midah, the trait [17:22] of tiferet, which means harmony. [17:26] It's the sum that's greater than the [17:28] than the than the total of the parts. [17:31] It's something new that's created when [17:33] we integrate. Abraham in this context [17:35] would be soul, Isaac would be body, [17:38] and and we come from Jacob. Which means [17:41] that our whole task in this world is to [17:44] reveal the light of integration. Lights [17:47] and vessels. [17:48] Souls and bodies, flames and wicks. [17:52] And then, [17:53] to do our job as the priesthood sect, [17:56] hopefully animated with the [17:58] consciousness that's gifted to us [17:59] through a consistent experience with [18:01] Jewish Halakha that's infused with [18:04] spirit, [18:05] to then from that place [18:07] shine the light to the nations of the [18:09] world who have themselves the seven [18:11] Noahide laws. Because Judaism is not for [18:13] Jews. Our God is not the Jewish God. [18:15] He's the creator of heaven and earth. [18:17] He's the God of every human being who's [18:18] created in his in his likeness. [18:21] And the prophets describe that the [18:22] coming of Messiah means [18:24] that the whole world is going to get [18:25] together. [18:26] We're all one family. [18:29] Now, if our 613 straights for the [18:32] our 613 commandments rather that are [18:35] special for the priesthood sect, which [18:37] is the Jewish nation with humanity has a [18:39] body and a soul, you don't think the [18:40] seven Noahide laws have a soul? [18:43] You know how much mystic mysticism there [18:45] is underlying each of those seven [18:47] Noahide laws that we're supposed to [18:48] teach the world. [18:50] The only way that we can do that is if [18:52] we're activated first. [18:54] And today there are Jews [18:57] who have the [18:58] body, but they don't have the soul. [19:00] There are also Jews who have the soul, [19:02] they don't have the body. [19:04] And then there are Jews who just all [19:05] together think that Judaism is some [19:06] culture, and maybe they support the [19:08] state of Israel, and maybe you know, [19:10] that's their Jewish identity. What we [19:11] don't understand is that God is [19:13] literally waiting for us [19:15] to stand up and to reclaim our mission. [19:17] It's not an ethnic identity, it's not a [19:20] culture, it's not even a religion. [19:22] It's the redemption of humanity, and [19:24] it's in our hands. [19:25] >> So, part of that reclaiming the mission [19:28] and part of the mission and one of those [19:29] commandments in and of itself, some say [19:32] rabbinic, some some say based on the [19:33] Torah, some say depends on the [19:35] circumstances to pray. [19:36] >> Oh, sure. [19:38] >> Prayer is a very deep thing. We prayed [19:40] together, [19:41] um you know, this past Shabbat, we [19:43] invited you to lead the congregation we [19:45] had of incredible people. [19:48] And it was clear that you were in a [19:49] state, you were in a mind frame, you [19:52] were connected in something deep. So, [19:53] how does prayer work? [19:58] >> Prayer is incredibly deep. [20:01] Prayer also has a body and a soul. [20:04] The body of prayer is I want something [20:07] and God is some kind of vending machine. [20:09] If I push the right buttons, I say the [20:10] right words, I'll get what I want and [20:12] I'll carry on. [20:15] I'll tell you a short teaching from the [20:16] Kotsker Rebbe. [20:17] Kotsker Rebbe, [20:19] even the word Kotsk is like very sharp, [20:20] it's curt. [20:22] The Kotsker was very biting. He was very [20:24] sharp. [20:25] >> Well, Kotsk actually means something. [20:26] >> Kotsk is exactly Kotsk. It's not Kotsk. [20:30] >> [laughter] [20:30] >> But Kotsk means a thorn. [20:31] >> Exactly right. [20:33] Interesting. [20:35] So, the Kotsk the Kotsker said a very [20:36] sharp thing. [20:39] He said in the book of Genesis, right in [20:41] the beginning of the Torah, [20:44] the serpent, the snake, [20:46] that seduces [20:47] Adam and Eve to eat from the the tree of [20:50] knowledge of good and evil, which is [20:51] incredibly deep. Many, many, many, many, [20:53] many layers of meaning. [20:56] That that snake gets cursed. [20:58] And the curse [21:00] is that [21:01] you're going to have to eat dust. Dust [21:03] will be your food. [21:05] Says the Kotsker Rebbe, [21:07] why is that a curse? [21:09] Imagine if wherever you went, you had [21:11] what you needed. [21:12] You have to You have to like eating is [21:14] not specific food. It's arbitrary. You [21:16] just eat whatever you see around you. [21:18] Beautiful. Never need to work to make a [21:19] living. You don't put food on the table. [21:20] You don't put food on the table. The [21:21] food is everywhere. [21:23] So, the Kotsker says, you're right. [21:27] The curse wasn't that you're going to [21:29] have to eat dust, because that's a [21:31] blessing. The curse was that because [21:33] you'll always have what you need [21:35] wherever you go, you'll never need to [21:37] pray. [21:40] That's a curse. [21:42] Now, that turns prayer on its head. [21:44] Because on the contrary, I thought that [21:46] all the while that things are good in my [21:48] life, then I don't need to pray. [21:51] Says the Kotsker, don't you understand [21:52] that praying itself is the blessing? [21:56] There was a great master of Jewish [21:58] thought called Rabbi Hutner. [21:59] He was a [22:01] Rosh Yeshiva, head of a very, very large [22:02] Talmudic academy. [22:05] And he said the most wonderful thing. [22:07] He says, most of us think [22:10] that prayer is to get us out of trouble. [22:14] He said, the truth is that trouble is to [22:17] get us into prayer. [22:19] >> Beautiful. [22:20] >> We have it all backwards. [22:22] We have the whole thing backwards. [22:25] We don't understand why we're here in [22:26] this world. So, we identify with a body. [22:28] The body needs something. Okay, it might [22:30] as well chuck up a couple of, you know, [22:32] liturgical [22:34] lines from a book. I don't know what it [22:35] means, you know? [22:37] That's not prayer. [22:39] A person who knows what prayer is never [22:41] asks, [22:42] I wonder, you know, when is my prayer [22:44] going to be answered? Cuz your prayer [22:45] was already answered. [22:46] >> That that [22:47] is fascinating because there's a famous [22:49] debate between the Rambam Maimonides and [22:52] the Ramban Nachmanides about whether [22:54] it's, you know, biblical or rabbinic. [22:56] And Rabbi Soloveitchik basically [22:58] harmonizes these two opinions saying, [23:00] you know, at the end of the day, even if [23:01] you're going to say it's rabbinic, it's [23:03] actually biblical because the rabbinic [23:04] opinion is to say it's only a time of [23:06] need. And we're in a state of perpetual [23:08] need. [23:08] >> Yes. Uh it's amazing that [23:10] >> But that really relates to Rabbi Hutner. [23:12] >> Exactly. [23:12] >> Because we always need that. [23:14] >> And we always need prayer. [23:16] First of all, we always need something. [23:17] >> needs us. It's It's us that need prayer. [23:19] >> Us that needs prayer. [23:21] Exactly right. [23:22] Exactly right. And that's the soul [23:24] That's really the soul of prayer. [23:27] And so, prayer is an answer in and of [23:29] itself. It's a gift. [23:30] It's an opportunity to to take time out [23:33] from our otherwise very mundane [23:36] this-worldly experience. [23:39] And to take some time to stop being a [23:40] body and to show up as a soul. [23:43] >> So, we show up as the soul. [23:45] But there's a limit to how much prayer [23:46] can be. [23:47] Um we also need to learn. [23:49] And that learning, limud Torah, it's [23:51] called Torah study, it's k'neged kulam, [23:54] it's one of the greatest, highest things [23:56] we can possibly do. [23:57] But what would you distill, according to [23:59] this mystical approach, as the purpose [24:02] of Torah? Why is it there? [24:04] >> Torah Torah study is absolutely [24:07] it's the essence of everything. [24:09] But it's interesting that when the [24:11] Talmud says that Torah study is the is [24:13] the most important thing, right, which [24:15] is he quoted the Talmud Torah k'neged [24:16] kulam, [24:18] remember that there's another [24:20] part of of our of our tradition [24:23] from those very same teachers who teach [24:26] that gadol of all [24:27] the reason why Torah study is so [24:29] important is shamayim l'dei ma'aseh. [24:32] It's because very practically it teaches [24:34] us what to do. [24:38] So a lot of times we get so caught up in [24:40] in in the in the study of it that [24:42] sometimes we forget that or the whole [24:43] point is like is the actual like how do [24:46] you treat your wife and [24:47] how do you treat your kids, you know? Um [24:49] um [24:50] how do you how do you deal with [24:51] frustration and how do you deal with [24:53] challenge at the workplace and and just [24:55] in life more generally? [24:59] But that's also the still the body of [25:00] Torah. That's why Torah is important on [25:02] the level of the body. [25:05] The Baal Tanya, [25:06] the [25:08] founder of the of the Chabad Hasidic [25:11] movement, very famous all around the [25:13] world. [25:15] So he was the first in that dynasty [25:16] which had seven great great luminaries. [25:21] The Baal Tanya explains [25:24] that the Torah is more than a text. [25:27] The Torah is the transmitted will of the [25:29] divine. [25:32] It's the it's the wisdom of God which [25:35] according to the mystics is one with [25:36] God. [25:37] It's God literally communicating himself [25:40] in a certain sense in a text that is [25:42] echoed in a teaching from our sages in [25:44] the Talmud which sees the word Anochi, [25:46] right? That first word with which God [25:48] introduces himself to the to the to the [25:50] to the world really to the Jewish nation [25:52] which means I am Anochi Hashem Elokecha. [25:54] I am [25:55] this these four letters yud and hey and [25:57] vav and hey Hashem just means the name, [26:00] you know, but that's very deep. I am the [26:02] the oneness, your God. [26:05] They see that as an acronym for four [26:06] words. [26:08] Ana, I [26:09] nafshi, my soul [26:12] ksavis, I wrote down [26:14] yahavis, and I gave it to you. [26:17] The Torah is the soul it's a wild thing [26:19] and that's not like in the mystical [26:21] text, that's in the Talmud. [26:22] The Torah is the soul of God, says the [26:24] Baal Tanya. [26:25] >> Well, now it's It sounds like it's not [26:27] not the physical expression but it is [26:29] God itself. The Torah. [26:30] >> sense in a certain sense, hard for us to [26:32] understand that it's one [26:33] >> God's packaging himself and giving him [26:35] over. [26:35] >> Correct. [26:36] So, says the Ba'al Tanya, [26:38] what's the highest part of the human [26:41] um um sort of structure? [26:44] Is the head. You know, and and and the [26:46] head houses the the skull houses the [26:49] brain. [26:50] The mind is the seat of consciousness. [26:52] That's who we are. [26:55] You know, it's an interesting exercise. [26:56] If you take away different body parts, [26:57] are you still that person? You know, [26:59] aside from the like the physical, yeah, [27:01] there there obviously limbs that the you [27:02] know, the body depends on. [27:04] But we are our brains. [27:08] Says the Ba'al Tanya, [27:10] when the essence of you, which is your [27:12] brain, [27:13] is grasping and contemplating [27:16] the the the essence of God, which is [27:18] communicated in the Torah, [27:21] he said there is no greater intimacy [27:23] with the divine than that experience. [27:26] And it's counterintuitive. [27:28] Because on the surface, it looks like [27:30] the most technical thing, like literally [27:31] a person studying information. [27:34] But the question is how we study that [27:37] information, with what [27:39] a priori sort of first principle [27:41] perspectives. [27:43] To a person that Torah study [27:46] is you know, that the Torah is the soul [27:49] of God, [27:50] there's no greater mystical encounter [27:52] with the driest Talmudic passage because [27:56] it's saturated with God's will. If I [27:58] love someone, I love what he loves. [28:02] I want what he wants. That's the [28:04] ultimate ultimate ultimate unity. [28:06] Ratzonenu, our will, lasos is to do, [28:10] right? Is to actualize ratzoncha, your [28:13] will. [28:14] That's that's Torah study, I think, from [28:16] a mystical point. [28:16] >> So, so really the purpose is therefore [28:18] to be connected to God's will. What's [28:19] really interesting there is if God, [28:21] according to Talmud, packaged a part of [28:23] himself through the Torah, the deepest [28:25] part, to go into our brain, which is the [28:27] essence of us, essentially we're [28:29] ingesting God. Essentially, this This [28:32] is God in us and us in God, and it's one [28:34] in the same. [28:34] >> That's exactly right. [28:35] >> And so therefore the purpose of Torah [28:36] study is actually [28:38] to become godly so to speak. It's it's [28:40] it's it's for us to be given over to God [28:42] and God to be given over to us in this [28:44] computational formula that allows us to [28:46] become one. [28:47] >> That's right. And that's Torah study in [28:49] and of itself. [28:50] When you hold the Torah together with [28:53] t'filah, right? Torah study together [28:55] with prayer, which are the two basic [28:57] pillars of the whole Jewish tradition [28:58] relies on, these two fundamental ways of [29:01] interacting with God. So then in a more [29:03] abstract formulation, the Torah is God [29:06] speaking to us [29:08] and prayer is us speaking to God. So [29:09] it's like a certain interesting thing to [29:11] say, well, [29:13] our prayer is is like God's Torah. [29:16] Because Torah, we learn what God wants. [29:18] Prayer, God learns what we want. [29:22] And this is this symbiotic relationship [29:24] between Torah and and and prayer. Prayer [29:28] is when we allow our souls [29:30] to just rise out of the body and up and [29:32] up and up into the into the embrace of [29:34] the divine. [29:37] And that's the concept of prayer. [29:40] T'filah is a Hebrew word that means [29:42] prayer, but it also means like to bind. [29:45] Like like t'fillin. It's the same word. [29:47] Means to bind. So to be bound with God. [29:49] And then in Torah, God descends, right? [29:52] On on Har Sinai, on that mountain is God [29:55] coming down to us. Where's the mountain [29:57] of prayer? [29:58] Har HaBayit. [30:00] Ki v'veiti beit t'filah yikarei l'chol [30:02] ha'amim. It's a verse. Says my house [30:04] will be a house of prayer for all the [30:06] nations. How do you get [clears throat] [30:08] to the Har HaBayit? You ascend the [30:09] mountain. [30:11] And so so prayer means going up to God. [30:14] Torah means means allowing God to come [30:17] down into our lives. [30:18] >> Interesting. You basically connected our [30:19] last two questions. [30:21] Praying is us speaking to God. Torah is [30:23] God speaking to us. When I sat with [30:25] Rabbi Sacks in his home in in London, [30:27] where you're from, he described it to me [30:30] as a conversation. [30:31] >> Yes. [30:32] >> Prayer study and Torah is the [30:33] conversation between humanity and God. [30:35] It's that dialogue. So, I guess the [30:37] question is, you know, there's so many [30:39] different people in this world um [30:42] and there's many different ways of [30:43] subdividing them. And now, [30:45] traditionally, sociologically, we have [30:47] something called gender. We have men and [30:49] we have women. [30:50] What do the mystics think of this? Are [30:52] we one and the same? Are we different? [30:54] How do men and women feature in this [30:56] type of literature? [30:57] >> Unbelievable. [31:00] You know, there's a verse that says "Ki [31:01] Kel Deos Hashem." [31:03] God is the God of of of Deos, right? [31:06] Which means [31:07] knowledge, but it's plural. [31:11] And a very great mystic, let's call him [31:12] Rav Hillel Zeitlin, right? Had a [31:15] tremendous impact and he continues to [31:17] have a tremendous impact. I mean, he's a [31:18] prolific author, writer. It's a [31:20] fantastic book that I highly recommend. [31:22] It's called the [31:23] um it's called [31:24] Hasidic Spirituality for a New Era. [31:27] Can't recommend that book highly enough. [31:28] He He knew. He really knew. He was a [31:30] real mystic. And he was he was amazing [31:33] soul. [31:35] So, he writes, "You know what it means [31:37] Ki Kel Deos Hashem? God is a God of like [31:40] plural consciousnesses." [31:43] He says there are two ways of [31:44] approaching this world. [31:46] There's something called [31:48] Das Tachton, [31:50] which means a lower perception. [31:54] And he says from that perspective, this [31:56] world is real [31:58] and spirituality is like it's just [32:00] either it's an imagination or it's some [32:02] fluffy, you know, abstract realm and [32:05] spirit. [32:07] Das Elyon, a person who has upgraded, [32:11] risen into a higher, more mature [32:14] consciousness, [32:15] to him, the real reality is is the [32:18] spiritual realm. [32:20] This world is just an extension, like we [32:22] have today we have good parables to use [32:25] because we have this evolved tech. So, [32:27] you have the ability to talk about code [32:30] and then the app. [32:31] But, the app You don't speak about the [32:32] app and then from there extrapolate the [32:34] code. That's not how it works. The app [32:36] on the front end is literally just the [32:37] front end manifestation of the code [32:39] that's in the back end. [32:41] So, for the Kabbalists who are operating [32:43] on a level of Das Elyon, [32:45] right? Of that of that more evolved [32:47] higher consciousness, [32:49] that's the real reality. So, I don't [32:51] look at men and women and then say, "I [32:52] wonder what this means." [32:54] I go back to the code and I say, "Oh, [32:56] well, that's why there are men and [32:58] women." It's a whole different thing. [33:00] Why are there men and women? [33:05] Because the way that God [33:07] expresses I would I would say himself, [33:10] but really it's itself cuz it's not a [33:12] him or her. [33:14] The way that God reveals himself is is [33:16] through a transcendent element [33:18] that's aloof, that's removed, that's [33:21] more abstract, [33:23] as well as an immanent element [33:26] that we refer to as the Shekhinah, [33:28] the divine presence. [33:31] That's the latent potential spirituality [33:33] that can be discovered everywhere in [33:35] this world without appealing to higher [33:38] realms. It's here. [33:40] And it's in exile cuz it's waiting for [33:42] you and me to redeem it using our [33:44] consciousness. [33:46] There's the transcendent and immanent. [33:48] Now, because those two elements exist in [33:51] the higher realm in the code, [33:53] so as God, who is really unified, comes [33:56] down into the human race, that produces [33:58] males and females. [34:00] Where the male aspect is the more big [34:02] picture abstract visionary, you know, uh [34:06] and again, we're speaking in [34:07] abstractions here. Every male contains [34:08] the female energy and every female [34:10] contains the male energy. We can never [34:11] speak about that. [34:12] >> you clarify that because [34:13] >> For sure. We can never [34:15] >> are so confusing for people. [34:17] >> We we we're we're just [34:18] >> Kabbalistic language of male and female [34:19] is not per se how we perceive and see. [34:21] >> not men and women. [34:23] >> And by the way, also on a biological [34:25] level, you know, there's different [34:26] hormones, there's different elements. [34:27] >> an X and a Y chromosome. They they both [34:29] contain both. No question. [34:32] But generally, to use a generalization, [34:34] at least historically, traditionally, [34:36] the man was going out to the world, the [34:38] hunter-gatherer, [34:40] but but the the animal that he brought [34:41] home, and it couldn't be eaten. [34:43] It needed to be prepared. It needed to [34:45] be developed. And that was the role of [34:48] the female more traditionally [34:49] classically. And this is true on varying [34:52] layers of functionality in modern day [34:54] relationships where it might not be that [34:55] way. In fact, the roles could be [34:57] reversed. That's not the point. The [34:59] point is is that there's a general [35:00] nature and a tendency that's a masculine [35:03] energy that again might exist within the [35:05] the woman. That's not the point. But the [35:07] masculine energy is this transcendent [35:10] bigger picture [35:12] visionary [35:13] energy. [35:15] And the feminine energy is much more [35:17] pragmatic. It's detail oriented. [35:20] It's like how do we take that and turn [35:23] it into something practical without [35:25] being crude, you know, it's a mature [35:26] audience. [35:27] This is what happens between a man and a [35:29] woman in the process of reproduction. [35:32] And this has remained true. [35:34] What the man contributes can't do [35:36] anything with. It's nothing. [35:38] The female doesn't have anything other [35:40] than what the man is contributing. [35:43] From the the the the integration of the [35:45] two, which is that and we call it a [35:47] seminal drop right for that reason. [35:50] Right, a seminal concept. It contains [35:52] the whole. [35:53] Then it's taken and it's developed. And [35:56] the female has the womb that's capable [35:58] of taking this visionary energy, [36:01] developing it, and then between the two [36:03] can produce a child. [36:05] This is this is to me male and female. [36:07] >> What is the biggest obstacles to a [36:09] spiritual life? You know, you spend your [36:11] time day in day out with people of all [36:13] ages, but primarily [36:15] teens, which I think is really the place [36:18] where this expresses itself most. And [36:20] you mentioned one idea before, but even [36:22] more broadly beyond the specific core [36:24] audience you do. What's the biggest [36:25] obstacle? What's stopping us from all [36:27] living a more spiritual life? [36:28] >> It's an excellent question. To me it [36:30] comes down to identity. [36:32] How do you view yourself? [36:35] How you view yourself [36:37] will transform how you view the world. [36:39] If you identify as a body and maybe a [36:42] soul is in there somewhere, But you'll [36:44] see in the world is a is the physical [36:46] world. And maybe there's some spiritual [36:48] realm somewhere. [36:49] If we can train our children and we can [36:52] educate [36:53] and we can teach people how to identify [36:56] as a soul primarily that has a body. [37:01] There's something in me in this. Like [37:03] this is just this is a a garment. I'll [37:05] take this off after I'm 20 and I'll [37:07] happily discard of it and it's not me. [37:10] If I identify as a soul [37:12] then I'm much more likely to be able to [37:13] discover the the soul with a capital S [37:17] in in in the in the body of of of the [37:19] universe and history which is God. [37:22] And so we need to be speaking about [37:24] Jewish identity. What's our mission? Why [37:27] are we in this world? What do we hope [37:30] for the world? [37:31] What do our prophets tell us about where [37:32] this whole thing is going? What do our [37:34] sages tell us about where this whole [37:36] thing began? [37:37] What's the point? [37:39] If we can root our Jewish identity not [37:42] in anything having to do with this [37:44] worldliness, but in the collective soul [37:47] of the Jewish spirit in Abraham and his [37:49] vision and in the prophets which teach [37:51] us about what that vision's going to [37:52] look like actualized and to realize that [37:54] I have a part in it [37:56] everything changes. My engagement with [37:58] Judaism changes. And I know that there's [38:00] a wick and there's a flame and I have to [38:01] integrate and I know that it's not just [38:03] for me with 613 particularized [38:05] commandments. It's particularism for the [38:07] purpose of universalism. I'm a priest. [38:10] I'm a cohen. I have something to say to [38:12] the world. So say it. [38:14] And then a person begins to live a truly [38:16] spiritual life. [38:17] >> So this is so complex, this world we [38:19] live in. Why did God create it? Why did [38:21] God create the world? [38:23] >> I don't know. [38:26] I don't know. [38:29] I can give some reasons that are [38:31] expressed by the mystics but the [38:33] ultimate answer is [38:36] it's just a mystery. [38:37] >> Would you say that [38:38] >> Mystic. Mister. It's a mystery. [38:42] God doesn't need this world because like [38:44] Maimonides teaches God is perfect, [38:46] doesn't need anything. [38:48] But God [38:49] desired [38:51] to show up vulnerably [38:53] to pursue a relationship with sparks of [38:55] his consciousness that would perceive [38:57] themselves as being separate from God [38:59] for the purpose of an even greater [39:01] revelation of God's unity through [39:03] integration. [39:04] We're specifically [39:07] in a fragmented world [39:09] fragmented sparks of godliness could [39:12] seek the unity that's so unified that it [39:15] could be revealed even here, which is [39:18] the greatest manifestation of God's [39:19] oneness. Why did he create it that it [39:22] should be necessary like that? I prefer [39:24] not to know. Even if I could know, I [39:25] wouldn't want to because it takes away [39:27] all the fun. It's a mystery. I have no [39:29] idea. [39:29] >> But it's interesting cuz it's very hard [39:31] to be able to say I don't know. It's [39:33] very hard to live in the I don't know. [39:34] And it's very hard to live in the [39:36] mystery because at the end of the day, [39:38] um you talked about ego earlier and at [39:40] the end of the day, I want to know. I [39:42] want I I remember in my own personal [39:43] growth into becoming someone that is [39:46] more practicing. Obviously, I'm [39:47] completely growing always. [39:49] Um for me that was one of the biggest [39:51] challenges. I like to know the answer. I [39:52] like to know why. [39:53] >> Sure. [39:54] >> And it's hard to live in that mystery. [39:55] >> What has caused more pain to humans? [39:59] Our knowing [40:00] or our not knowing? [40:03] Ego is the source of all issues. It's [40:06] the source of our own pain. It's the [40:08] source of the pain that people cause to [40:09] other people. It's the desire to control [40:11] and it's the it's the it's the it's the [40:15] illusion [40:16] that we could actually control. [40:20] Part of the healing that Judaism seeks [40:22] to bring to the world is this humility. [40:26] Prayer equals humility. Stand vulnerably [40:28] in front of God. I say, I'm not the [40:30] be-all end-all. There are certain things [40:31] in life that I cannot do. [40:33] And I rely on you. I need you. [40:35] That fosters within the individual a [40:37] spirit of humility, which makes them [40:39] less likely to trample on somebody else [40:42] less likely to cause themselves pain [40:44] because they don't have that ego that's [40:45] constantly being wounded and protected [40:47] because they're not living for them, [40:48] they're living for for something higher. [40:51] When each individual Jew can onboard [40:53] that consciousness and collectively the [40:56] Jewish nation is activated with that [40:58] energy of prayer and humility and depth [41:01] and sweetness and and innocence and [41:06] we can project it to humanity. [41:09] And then there will not be wars cuz no [41:11] one will feel the need. [41:13] And nobody will lift a a sword against [41:16] against their neighbor. [41:18] Cuz there won't be a need. [41:20] Because instead of pointing fingers at [41:21] each other, we'll be able to link arms [41:23] and look up. [41:26] >> And where does free will fit in with all [41:28] of this? [41:29] Is it something real? Is it an illusion? [41:34] >> Yes. [41:38] Both. [41:41] From our perspective, it's absolutely [41:43] real because that's our experience. And [41:46] no matter how much I can tell you free [41:47] will doesn't exist, it will not take [41:49] away the fact that you'll still probably [41:50] have to make a decision on what what [41:52] what dinner you have to eat. So okay, [41:54] it's not ultimately real, nothing's [41:56] ultimately real, but we experience it as [41:57] real from that standpoint, it's [41:58] fundamentally real. [42:00] If a person sits in bed and says, I [42:02] expect that, you know, I'll just make a [42:04] living because it will I come through my [42:06] mail slot like it won't. [42:09] People who train and study and work hard [42:11] will get ahead. You know, there are [42:12] certain things that are predictable [42:14] based on our illusory experience of free [42:16] choice, but for us is fundamentally real [42:18] and God wants us to live within that [42:20] reality. [42:21] In the ultimate ultimate ultimate sense, [42:24] Ain Od Milvado, these three words that [42:27] we find in Deuteronomy don't just say [42:30] there is no God other than him. [42:33] >> There's nothing. [42:34] >> say there is nothing other than him. [42:38] This conversation [42:40] >> is him. [42:40] >> Pretty much. This conversation that [42:42] we're having here in this physical [42:44] beautiful space, [42:46] the the the tech that's allowing anybody [42:48] who's going to be watching this, right, [42:50] to watch this [42:51] and the room that they're sitting in [42:54] is just part of of an expression of [42:58] godliness. It's a ray of the sun [43:02] that exists if you see it from the ray's [43:05] perspective, [43:07] but if you see it from the sun's [43:08] perspective, it's just [43:11] it's wrapped up into that. [43:14] And so the story's already been told, [43:17] but you and I are expected to make [43:19] conscious decisions to enable our part [43:21] of the story to be manifest through the [43:23] role that God needs us to play. [43:25] >> The role that God needs us to play. You [43:27] talked before about sort of bringing [43:29] this incredible world together where we [43:31] don't need to pick up swords or we don't [43:32] need to have wars. I I assume you're [43:34] alluding to this messianic era to [43:36] Messiah. So what is Messiah? [43:38] >> Yeah. [43:40] Classically, Messiah is an event. [43:43] It's exile exile exile exile and then [43:46] one day someone flicks on the light [43:47] switch, oh, the Messiah is here. [43:50] Jewish mysticism sees [43:52] the coming of the Messiah, Messiah, [43:56] not as an event, but as a process. [44:00] And it's based on a story in the Talmud, [44:02] Yerushalmi, also in the Midrashic [44:04] literature and Tehillim, Psalms, [44:08] that describes two Talmudic sages who [44:12] were walking, probably not far from [44:13] here, on one of the one of the hills, [44:16] mountains, [44:17] and they saw the sunrise. [44:19] And one of them said to the other, [44:21] "Kach ge'ulah tanchil Yisrael." This is [44:24] going to be [44:26] what the redemption of the whole Jewish [44:28] nation and the whole world is going to [44:30] look like. The sunrise. "Batkhilah kim'a [44:33] kim'a." In the beginning, [44:35] a little little just little by little. [44:38] "U'kholsheyolah chet." The more that it [44:40] it develops and and it and evolves, [44:43] "holechet v'rabbah." It's going to get [44:46] brighter and brighter and brighter, [44:48] mamash like the sun. [44:51] So from my perspective, do I believe [44:53] that there's going to be a messianic [44:54] figure that brings this thing to the [44:55] finish line? Sure. [44:57] But that will not be the beginning of [44:59] the process. [45:00] That will be the final hammer blow, you [45:01] know, that will be the mark of a patish [45:03] that that that last [45:05] closing that you know, that last brick. [45:08] That'll be the end of the process. You [45:10] and I are the process. [45:12] You and I and everybody listening to [45:14] this and really every human being has a [45:16] spark of the Messiah inside of them. [45:19] It doesn't look like that on the [45:20] outside. I don't look like, you know, a [45:21] messianic figure. [45:24] Look deeper. [45:26] With Jewish eyes of faith. [45:28] And you'll find that you have a a spark [45:30] of of redemptive energy inside of you. [45:32] When you can redeem yourself and [45:34] graduate from the das tahton we spoke [45:36] about to start to see the world from a [45:38] das elyon perspective, [45:42] where the first thing you see like the [45:43] Baal Shem Tov taught his students, when [45:44] you look at a table you see God and then [45:46] you see the table, [45:47] you see the code, you learn the code, [45:51] so then [45:52] you brought another [45:55] spark of messianic energy to the world. [45:59] The Baal Shem Tov taught that when every [46:00] Jew redeems their spark of Messiah, [46:05] and we're so busy waiting for Messiah to [46:06] come, we don't think when are we when [46:07] are we arriving? [46:09] When are we going to going to arrive? [46:10] And Messiah is waiting for us to come. [46:13] Hayom im kol tishma'u, Messiah says I'm [46:15] coming today. It's different measures. [46:18] But you got we're wait I'm waiting for [46:19] you and we're waiting for God and God is [46:21] waiting for us. [46:23] The Baal Shem Tov said that when each [46:25] and every one of us can redeem our spark [46:27] of Messiah, [46:29] that's it. [46:31] So the more that this Torah spreads, [46:34] the more that these perspectives begin [46:35] to become [46:37] mainstream, regular, [46:40] that these are the ways that our [46:41] children are being educated in school by [46:43] people who know how to give over this [46:45] kind of education, not just from the [46:46] standpoint of the material, but from the [46:48] lives that they live, the energy that [46:50] they exude. [46:52] And what we said just now in this [46:53] conversation is that is a drop in the [46:55] ocean [46:58] of Jewish [47:00] depth, [47:02] guidance, teachings, paradigm shifts. [47:06] The more that this spreads, [47:09] the dawn is breaking. [47:11] Dawn is breaking. [47:12] >> So as dawn is breaking, you know, you [47:14] described just on these hills, the fact [47:16] that we can even sit in this place, [47:18] you know, is the state of Israel part of [47:20] the unfolding of the redemption? [47:22] >> This is a very complicated issue. [47:24] Anybody who studied this topic a little [47:26] bit knows that there are tremendously [47:29] fierce voices on on either side [47:31] trying to decipher what exactly this is [47:34] because it's not exactly the way that we [47:36] would have assumed our return to this [47:39] land would look through a largely [47:42] secular, you know, political national [47:44] movement that was that was really [47:46] antithetical in many ways to a lot of [47:49] what we spoke about now. So it's not the [47:52] it's not the way that we always imagined [47:53] it would look, and therefore there's [47:55] reason for for skepticism and and and [47:59] even some go so far as to say that on [48:01] the contrary that this is withholding [48:02] the unfolding of the redemption. [48:05] Generally speaking, [48:07] for a person that looks through [48:10] a simpler lens [48:11] and looks at the metzius, just looks at [48:13] the reality, irrespective of how this [48:16] came about, the bottom line is [48:18] we're back. [48:20] We're back in tremendous numbers. [48:23] All around the world there are Jews that [48:24] are flooding this place. [48:26] And by all appearances on a simple [48:29] level, the prophecies have been [48:30] fulfilled and we're literally living [48:32] through that time. Because irrespective [48:34] again of how it looked or how we assumed [48:36] it would look or how it ended up [48:37] looking, it makes no difference. Right [48:38] now, this is the reality. Are there [48:40] hurdles? Tremendous hurdles. From [48:43] without and from within. [48:46] My belief is that the more that we can [48:48] resolve our internal hurdles, which [48:51] would require the body people, right, [48:55] the wick people, the Allahic Jews [48:57] discovering their soul, and the soul [49:00] people, right? And I'm using it as a [49:02] broader term, you know, even those [49:04] people who aren't necessarily super [49:05] spiritual, but those people [49:07] rediscovering tradition, and [49:09] rediscovering what it can look like to [49:11] wed [49:12] all of our various [49:14] incredible strengths [49:16] that each of us bring as part of this [49:18] prism of the Jewish people into one [49:21] collective multifaceted diamond [49:23] of an integrated whole that's healthy [49:26] and that's balanced. [49:29] I think that our external issues would [49:32] be resolved in a much easier way. [49:35] I believe that we would be better [49:36] positioned to be able to communicate [49:39] with the other. [49:41] I think that we would be better [49:42] positioned to figure out how to live [49:45] with the other. [49:46] And then I think that if we can return [49:48] to our roots [49:51] to our religious roots [49:53] I think it would be so much easier for [49:55] us to iron out our difficulties. [49:57] Cuz we would approach it with humility, [49:59] and they would approach it with [50:00] humility. [50:01] And I think that will be the the [50:02] greatest fixing, the greatest greatest [50:05] fixing [50:06] for us and for all of humanity. [50:08] >> So, you've gone, like we asked about the [50:10] unfolding of the state of Israel, you [50:12] said that on a soul level it's [50:13] impossible to ignore what's going on. [50:15] You've talked about potential solutions, [50:16] but you brought into to humanity. So, if [50:19] we go broader than that, all of [50:20] humanity, what do you think is the [50:22] single greatest challenge that [50:24] humanity's facing today? [50:26] >> I think again it goes back to the [50:28] concept of identity. [50:31] Who are we as humans and why are we [50:32] here? [50:34] If we're here to have as much dopamine [50:36] flooding into our brain as we possibly [50:38] can, so if that if that's what it's all [50:40] about, so of course everybody's at [50:42] everybody's else's throat. [50:44] Because if somebody else has [50:46] that naturally means that I have less. [50:50] But if we can begin to see ourselves [50:53] as created in the image of God [50:56] for the purpose [50:57] of transforming this otherwise hell into [51:01] paradise, [51:04] then we can find a way [51:07] to see our differences as just the [51:10] different puzzle pieces that all connect [51:12] to create that beautiful image, [51:16] which is exactly what the prophets are [51:17] describing. When all nations get [51:19] together, you know, Judaism is unique [51:21] among the other two religions, [51:23] the major world religions, [51:26] because [51:27] number one, we don't seek to convert [51:29] anybody. [51:32] And [51:34] number two, not only don't we seek to [51:36] convert anybody, [51:39] the world converting is not even one of [51:41] our ideals, our values. We don't see [51:43] humanity that way. [51:45] We are perfectly happy to allow the [51:47] Indians to remain Indian. In fact, it [51:49] would be a it would be a detriment to [51:52] all of humanity if the Indians suddenly [51:54] felt an awakening and they felt that [51:56] they have to be something other than [51:57] than what they are. You don't think [51:59] Indian culture is a revelation from the [52:01] code that we spoke about? [52:03] Indian culture is is a revelation of [52:05] God. [52:06] Chinese culture is a revelation of God. [52:12] Islamic culture is a revelation of God. [52:16] All we ask is that this diversity [52:20] should begin to think more broadly [52:24] than themselves as individual cultures [52:26] and begin to see a patchwork quilt, a [52:28] tapestry of humanity. [52:30] >> Also included. [52:31] >> Where does that begin? That begins with [52:34] each individual looking at their very [52:36] own what looks like a fragmented body [52:38] and see it as just [52:39] >> part of a bigger world. [52:41] >> explicitly one individual soul. [52:43] Then we start to look at other Jews and [52:46] we say, "Hey, you're separate from me, [52:48] wears different clothing, he affiliates [52:50] differently, we're one soul." And then [52:51] we could have unity. And then we can in [52:54] that unity, which is all built on the [52:56] consciousness of synthesis, like we [52:58] spoke about it earlier, which is the [52:59] integration of the spiritual and the [53:01] physical, which is the integration of [53:02] the body and the soul and the flame and [53:04] the wick and the external and the [53:06] internal. [53:08] So then we can do our mission [53:10] to be a light unto the nations of the [53:12] world where we teach them how to [53:14] maintain their diversity [53:16] but to join together [53:18] in in a in a universal project [53:22] to allow our individual and certainly [53:25] collective image of God [53:27] to become a channel through which God [53:31] reveals himself [53:32] in all of existence. [53:34] >> Beautiful. So in the process of time, [53:36] how has modernity changed Jewish [53:38] mysticism or has it at all? What does [53:40] modernity mean? [53:41] >> Sure. [53:45] You know [53:48] there's a great sage called the Hafetz [53:49] Chaim [53:50] which means the one who desires life. It [53:53] comes from a verse that a person desires [53:54] life should be careful how they speak. [53:58] Only say good things about people. So he [53:59] wrote a book [54:00] all about that. [54:02] It's called Hafetz Chaim [54:04] about how to make sure that we're only [54:05] saying good things and the laws of of of [54:07] of evil speech gossip. [54:10] He said a fascinating thing. [54:12] He lived in [54:14] early 1900s. [54:18] And he said [54:19] that this that technology was evolving [54:22] which was like basic rudimentary [54:23] technology like the camera, you know, an [54:25] an an early you know, version of the of [54:27] the phone and things like that [54:30] is because God is giving us [54:32] the capacity to understand spiritual [54:34] concepts as they reveal themselves in [54:36] our lived experience of reality. So for [54:37] example, there's a Mishna, it's a [54:39] Talmudic teaching, Tanakh teaching [54:42] which says a person should always be [54:43] aware that there's an eye watching you. [54:47] There's an ear that listens even in [54:49] private. Your actions are not private [54:50] because you're not private because the [54:52] whole world relies on you and everything [54:53] you do brings energy to the world and so [54:55] on. A person should be conscious of [54:56] that, says the Hafetz Chaim. Before the [54:58] before the camera and the phone, nobody [55:00] could like understand like what does [55:02] that mean? I'm here. There's no one [55:04] here. There's someone else somewhere [55:06] else who hears what I'm saying. There's [55:08] someone else who can see what I'm doing. [55:11] So the kind of said that modernity [55:13] technology is evolving in such a way to [55:15] allow us to really make these concepts [55:17] real. As we get to [55:20] post-modernity [55:21] and the technological explosion [55:23] especially as it relates to AI and what [55:25] we're experiencing currently [55:30] is that whereas early tech [55:32] was giving us parables to be able to [55:34] understand the revealed aspect of the [55:37] Torah. [55:40] The technological innovations that we're [55:41] currently experiencing whether it's in [55:44] science, quantum physics, quantum [55:45] mechanics, or whether it's in just pure [55:48] tech [55:50] artificial intelligence [55:52] is giving us the tools to be able to [55:54] understand the esoteric aspect of Torah. [55:58] To be able to really understand [56:01] how it is [56:03] that that godliness quite literally [56:05] infuses everything cuz everything is [56:06] energy in a string theory. Everything is [56:09] energy. Everything is vibrations. [56:12] Everything is unified, right? Science is [56:14] beginning to discover this. [56:16] And so the technological revolution is [56:18] perfectly aligned [56:20] with the spiritual emergence of a higher [56:23] consciousness. These are two sides of [56:25] the same coin again. Body and soul, male [56:28] and female, light and vessel. And the [56:31] key is to integrate. [56:32] >> So modernity has given us almost a new [56:34] language, new parables to access the [56:35] >> new language. [56:36] >> To to access the old. That's the irony [56:38] here. The modernity allows us to [56:39] understand the [56:40] >> Precisely. [56:41] >> So what about um you know, you talked [56:43] about the dynamics and you universality [56:45] and there's different traditions and [56:46] they all emanate from God. But in terms [56:48] of specificity is there a difference [56:50] between Jewish mysticism and other [56:52] mysticisms, other schools of thought [56:54] traditions in that sense? [56:56] >> So let's take I mean I can't I can't [56:57] claim to be I'm not an expert at By the [56:59] way, let's just make this clear. [57:00] Everything that I say is my personal [57:01] opinion and based on my personal [57:03] experiences my thinking. I'm not an [57:04] expert in anything. I'm not a mystic. [57:06] I'm just a a Jew who cares about life [57:09] and and wants to live for real and I [57:10] spent the last 15 years, you know, [57:12] essentially searching and digging and [57:14] learning and and and then sharing and [57:16] teaching what I found to be helpful to [57:18] me with others. I'm not an expert at [57:20] all. I'm not authoritative. I'm just [57:22] sharing opinions. [57:24] Now, the real secret is that even the [57:25] experts are only sharing opinions, but [57:27] okay. But let's but even me, it's just [57:28] an opinion. Certainly not in other [57:30] traditions. I don't know anything. [57:32] From the little bit that I know, [57:35] Buddhism [57:37] actually contains [57:39] a tremendous amount of [57:42] similarity [57:44] and [57:46] reflection [57:47] of certain core principles of the way [57:49] that Judaism perceives the world. [57:53] It's interesting in the 1960s, almost [57:55] everybody who was who was going to India [57:57] were were all Jews. They called them [57:58] JewBus. Now, Jewish Buddhists. [58:01] Even today, Jews are very drawn to [58:03] Buddhism. [58:05] The fundamental difference, though, [58:07] is again, to my understanding, where the [58:10] Buddhist deity [58:11] is is is not relational or covenantal. [58:15] It's just the ground of being. Just is. [58:19] Judas Judaism believes that that ground [58:22] of being, the essence of all of reality, [58:25] it's called in the Ikra v'Ikar of the [58:27] Kol Ha'Olam, the the root and the [58:29] essence of of all the spiritual worlds [58:31] and and all of existence, [58:34] actually reaches out to us covenantally. [58:37] And and sticks out his hand, as it were, [58:40] and says, "Please take it. [58:42] Let me into your life. Build a [58:44] relationship with me in the same way [58:46] that you'd build it with another human [58:47] being, which is just a reflection. I [58:49] mean, speak to me." Buddhism is not not [58:51] prayer. It's meditation. Prayer is is is [58:53] a Jewish thing. It's a biblical thing. [58:55] >> So, it's the idea of covenant. It's a [58:56] it's a a different expression of a [58:58] relationship theologically that's [59:01] happening. [59:02] >> That's right. And [59:03] that's right. And and even though [59:04] ordinarily we seem to separate the two [59:06] where on the revealed level of Torah, [59:08] it's a covenant and God is up there and [59:10] we're down here and God gave us a Torah [59:12] and he's going to punish us if we don't [59:13] and he's going to reward us if we do. [59:16] Jewish mysticism understands that all of [59:18] that [59:21] is absolutely one [59:24] with [59:25] the more, so to speak, esoteric or or [59:28] almost Buddhist-oriented [59:29] experience of what's called in in [59:33] more modern terms, panentheism. [59:35] Right? Which is basically pantheism. [59:37] Spinoza was basically the the position [59:40] that like the world is God. Like the [59:42] world itself is God. [59:44] Panentheism means that God suffuses [59:47] every particle of of of this world [59:50] but still is separate from it. [59:52] That's called makom shel olam. God is [59:55] the place of the world, v'lo olam [59:56] makomah, right? The world is not God's [59:58] place, that's called pantheism. [60:00] Panentheism is God is the place of the [60:03] world and God is suffusing everything as [60:05] it's all within him, but God is other [60:07] than the world. It's that God [60:11] that through the system of the Torah in [60:13] its written form, in its oral [60:16] clarification, in its halakhic [60:18] codification, [60:20] gives us an opportunity [60:22] to turn all of life into an immersive [60:25] experience [60:27] of a direct [60:28] relational, dialogic encounter with that [60:32] energy [60:33] that pervades all. [60:34] It's a It's a marriage between those [60:36] two. [60:37] >> So that that's a certain plane, it's a [60:39] certain [60:40] uh for lack of a better term, [60:41] religiosity to be able to tap into. [60:44] Does one need to be religious in the [60:46] typical way of observance to be able to [60:48] study mysticism? [60:50] >> I believe [60:51] they stand a teaching from the Talmud [60:53] that says that each and every person [60:54] needs to say, "This should be li never [60:56] olam, the whole world was created from [60:58] for me." [61:00] I believe that there is no such thing as [61:02] relative spirituality. [61:04] Meaning, as far as your spirituality and [61:06] religious observance is concerned, there [61:08] is no other standard. It's just you. [61:11] Given your background, given your [61:13] traumas, given your your your [61:15] experiences, your hopes for the future, [61:17] disappointments, your talents, [61:18] ambitions, abilities, [61:20] your [61:21] affiliations, associations, [61:24] the blockages, the walls, and so on and [61:25] so forth. For every person, it's [61:27] different. [61:28] However, [61:30] for each and every person, there's [61:32] always a next right step. [61:34] And I believe that for people who are [61:37] like I think it's called [61:38] S [61:39] B N R, right? Spiritual but not [61:42] religious. [61:43] It's beautiful. [61:45] Flame without a wick. [61:48] Soul without a body. S- Amazing, but [61:50] it's a ghost. [61:52] God has angels. He wanted the humans. [61:55] The whole point is integration. [61:58] And so, from my perspective, it depends [62:02] where you're at. [62:03] If you're in a place of halakhic [62:05] observance, where that's your whole [62:06] life, and you're really studying it to [62:09] keep it, and you know, and you're [62:10] really, you know, to the letter of the [62:12] law, [62:13] your next right step is is probably [62:15] in [62:17] it's probably to discover the more [62:19] spiritual, meditative aspects that will [62:21] enable you to infuse your halakhic [62:22] observance with vitality and vibrancy [62:25] and meaning and God. [62:28] But if you find yourself in the other [62:29] place, [62:32] then it's probably true [62:34] that a deeper dive into the traditional [62:37] um way that [62:39] probably if you're listening to this, [62:40] your your grandmother or [62:41] great-grandmother certainly lived, cuz [62:43] there was no there was no such thing as [62:45] as irreligious Jews before about 300 [62:48] years ago or so. 280 or so years ago, [62:51] didn't exist. [62:53] That there was no such conception of [62:55] like spiritual but not reli- What does [62:57] that mean? Based on everything that we [62:58] said, that you cannot have Jewish [63:00] mysticism without halakha, in the same [63:02] way that you cannot have halakha without [63:04] Jewish mysticism. It's it's a it's a [63:05] farce. [63:07] They're one thing. [63:10] So, when a person understands it, [63:12] halakha is it's not What it is not [63:14] optional. It's the whole reason that [63:16] we're here. God gave us commandments [63:19] with very clear parameters. [63:21] He gave us what to do. Not to be robots, [63:24] a body without a soul is a corpse. God [63:26] doesn't need, you know, idiots walking [63:27] around with plants and waving them for [63:28] no reason. [63:30] God envisioned [63:32] vibrant vibrant Jewish experience with a [63:36] body and a soul, a flame and a wick, [63:39] male and female, imminent transcendent. [63:42] This is what it means, in my opinion, to [63:44] be a Jew. [63:45] >> It's going to be dangerous studying this [63:46] mysticism? [63:48] >> Sure. [63:50] It absolutely can be. [63:53] I believe it's far more dangerous not [63:55] to. [63:57] There's a risk to everything in life. [64:00] I believe that we cannot afford to [64:02] withhold from our souls at this moment [64:04] in history when it's clearly exploding [64:07] and the and the you know, I was watching [64:08] a podcast [64:10] recently. [64:12] Apologies for my voice. He made a [64:13] reference to, you know, to the shabbos [64:15] we had together. [64:16] I wasn't screaming the whole shabbos. I [64:17] was crying the whole shabbos. [64:19] Apparently, crying does this to you. I [64:20] didn't know. [64:22] I was watching a podcast. [64:24] >> Crying from joy for those that are not. [64:26] >> Crying for many reasons. [64:27] >> with us for that shabbos? [64:28] >> Crying crying yes [64:30] crying for many reasons. Go into why I [64:31] was crying. [64:35] >> So, you're watching a podcast. [64:37] >> It was mostly joy. [64:38] I was watching the podcast [64:41] and he he said something that blew my [64:42] mind. [64:43] He said he grew up quote totally [64:44] unaffiliated Jew. You know, the type bar [64:46] mitzvah is the last Jewish thing you do. [64:48] And and and he was he was he was looking [64:50] for spiritual connection and he heard [64:54] somewhere this is in the 70s, not so [64:55] long ago, right? [64:57] He heard that, you know, in in Kabbalah, [65:00] that's where you find, you know, God. [65:03] So, he showed up in a uh [65:06] in a Yeshiva [65:08] and he asked them, you know, where can I [65:09] learn Kabbalah? Like he showed up in [65:10] some Talmudic academy like [65:14] and then he just threw out a sentence [65:15] that it blew me away. He said at that [65:17] time, there was a nothing available in [65:21] English on Kabbalah. [65:25] >> [snorts] [65:26] >> There was nothing available in English. [65:27] This is in the '70s. [65:29] You know where we're holding today? [65:31] Thousands and thousands of books, [65:33] academic, religious, spiritual, [65:35] meditative, experiential. [65:38] How many You know how many the [65:39] literature on Jewish mysticism is [65:42] exploding. [65:45] Exploding. [65:46] So, anybody with eyes can see this is [65:49] what God's bringing about in the world. [65:51] But, it's got to be done in a healthy, [65:52] balanced way. [65:54] Lights and vessels. [65:56] >> And how's this impacted your own [65:58] relationships? [65:59] With your wife, with your kids, with [66:01] yourself. Like, practically, does this [66:03] come into who you are as a person? And [66:05] if so, what's an example? How do we see [66:07] this practically? [66:08] >> It's my whole life. [66:10] This is my whole life. [66:13] My relationship with my wife, [66:16] I love her very much, and she's [66:18] everything that I do is her. [66:22] Is it an encounter with the divine? [66:25] Because godliness can be revealed [66:27] in the space between husband and wife. [66:28] The Talmud says isha vi'isha, husband [66:31] and wife zachav, they merit. [66:33] In other words, zachav could be merit, [66:34] it could also mean refined. [66:37] If they're refined, [66:38] we work on ourselves, [66:41] shchina shribenaia. [66:43] The divine presence is in that place. [66:46] There's a There's a beit hamikdash, [66:48] there's a holy temple between husband [66:49] and wife. [66:52] You can either have [66:53] a temple between husband and wife, it's [66:55] it's miracles and God's presence, or you [66:58] can destroy that temple. [67:00] There's a temple between parents and [67:01] children. [67:04] That temple could be bursting with with [67:06] with God, [67:07] or it could be in shambles. [67:10] So, for me, my relationships are They're [67:13] the lived application of hopefully [67:15] everything that I learn. Am I perfect? [67:17] Very far from it. [67:20] But, this is This is my whole life is to [67:22] work on this. I want to be a Jew. I want [67:24] to really be a Jew. I don't want to be a [67:26] card-carrying some member of some, [67:28] you know, [67:34] I want to feel the spirit of Abraham, [67:36] Isaac, and Jacob [67:38] pulsating in my being. [67:40] I want to help others rediscover that [67:42] because there's a world out there, and [67:44] it's in pain, [67:45] and it's waiting for us. [67:48] So, that spirit pervades all of life. Of [67:50] course, it enhances the relationship. [67:52] All relationships we have are [67:55] really expressions of our fundamental [67:57] relationship, of the fundamental [67:59] relationship, which is between us and [68:00] our creator. And it's all there to teach [68:02] you a little bit. I have my books, you [68:04] know, the [68:05] put out a book recently called From My [68:07] Heart to Yours. It's a collection of [68:08] writings, musings, reflections. [68:10] There's a whole section in the book of [68:12] lessons that I learned from my son, [68:13] Shmuel Schmucker. [68:15] 6 years old now. The best. [68:19] Because being a father [68:23] has taught me so much [68:25] about the way in which God relates to us [68:28] as our father. [68:30] You don't know what it means. There's [68:32] that God loves us like a fa You know, [68:34] that God is our father, but Israel, you [68:36] know, we're the firstborn child of God, [68:38] which by the way connotes that there are [68:40] other children, which is which is all of [68:42] humanity. We have a a special job. [68:47] You can't really understand that. [68:50] And the implication of the love, [68:53] the implication of what that means, [68:55] until you have children of your own. [68:58] >> So, those relationships are the [68:59] expression of all this. We've looked [69:01] through the teachings at these different [69:03] questions in life. I'd like to end this [69:06] with one teaching. [69:08] Not from the teachings into life, but [69:11] actual teaching itself that animates [69:13] your existence. And we talked about [69:14] Torah study. I know there's a lot of [69:16] teachings in your mind. You put out all [69:17] these different books, these thoughts [69:18] you're sharing. Can you share just one [69:20] profound teaching to conclude this [69:22] incredible conversation? [69:23] >> Sure. There's one teaching that's just [69:24] coming into my head. I don't it's the [69:25] most essential teaching. [69:27] It's I don't know for some reason this [69:28] came into my head, so I'm going to share [69:29] it. [69:30] It comes from a great Hasidic master [69:32] called Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berdichev. [69:34] My first book that I wrote was called [69:36] Sparks from Berdichev. It was basically [69:38] expression into hopefully clear plain [69:41] English [69:42] of the the tzaddik's you know, this [69:44] righteous person's teachings on a weekly [69:45] Torah portion. [69:48] So, what I'm going to what I'm going to [69:49] share with you now is is a good example [69:51] of the way that Jewish mysticism and our [69:53] Hasidic teachings enable you to look at [69:55] the very same words [69:57] but it means something completely [69:58] different. [70:00] And the words are we say it in the [70:01] Aleinu prayer that we recite after the [70:04] three standardized prayers each day. [70:08] We say God, you are you are [70:11] the divine. [70:12] Ba shamayim mimmal, in the heavens [70:15] above, [70:16] v'al ha'aretz mitachas, and on the earth [70:18] below, einai. [70:21] It's all you. [70:22] And of course that means in the [70:23] spiritual, in the physical, like the [70:25] whole conversation, einai. At the end of [70:28] the day, [70:29] it's just you. [70:31] It's really just you. [70:33] Says the Berdichever, he turns it into a [70:35] much deeper I don't know much deeper but [70:37] but a but a [70:39] guidance for life in a way that it [70:41] becomes really relevant. [70:44] He says, "You know what shamayim means? [70:47] This word shamayim which is translated [70:48] in the heavens is a reference [70:50] to our spiritual pursuits. [70:54] So, he [snorts] says, "Ba shamayim [70:55] mimmal doesn't mean that in the heavens [70:58] above, [70:59] he says ba shamayim, when it comes to [71:01] our heavenly pursuits, mimmal, look at [71:04] those who are higher than you. [71:07] Those who are more advanced, [71:10] strive to be like them. [71:13] Strive to be ever growing. [71:16] Take your like I said before, your next [71:18] right step. [71:21] V'al ha'aretz, [71:23] Berdichever says when it comes to [71:24] physical things, sides of your house, [71:27] you know, the make model of year of [71:29] decade, century of your car [71:32] how much money in the bank and so on. [71:34] Well, the all right [71:36] bitachas. [71:37] When it comes to physical things [71:40] look at the people have less than you [71:42] be grateful. [71:44] Just came into my heart to say this [71:46] teaching. Maybe that's helpful for [71:47] somebody. [71:49] Um but it's again it's a good ex- [71:51] expression of the way that [71:53] this lens of the interior spirit of [71:56] Torah takes the same Torah, same verses, [71:59] the same episodes, the same stories [72:02] and the same commandments, the same [72:04] details [72:05] and it and it and it it changes [72:07] everything. It changes nothing. [72:09] It changes everything. It's the same [72:11] body [72:12] but it's expressing a soul. [72:15] >> Well, it's truly beautiful and your soul [72:16] has truly come through and I can tell [72:19] you on a personal level and I'm sure [72:20] many of our listeners [72:22] that while you may be younger than me [72:24] Maal [72:25] you know, looking up to the journey that [72:27] you've taken and how many people you [72:28] inspire has been phenomenal. And my only [72:31] blessing to you is that number one you [72:33] can carry on looking up to others me [72:34] Maal and you carry on that journey and [72:37] you know [72:37] >> Benji. [72:38] We look at each other. That's also part [72:40] of it. [72:40] >> Look at one another and the other thing [72:41] is that you constantly become that me [72:43] Maal for others that you just grow, go [72:46] deeper and deeper and deeper and inspire [72:48] the world around. [72:49] >> Thank you. [72:50] >> Thank you so much. [72:50] >> so much. Thank you for having me. [72:51] >> Thank you.